Тёмный

'Boots on the ground should not be be off the table' Ben Hodges interview | DW News 

DW News
Подписаться 5 млн
Просмотров 248 тыс.
50% 1

In this exclusive interview with DW's Ines Pohl, retired US Army officer Ben Hodges discusses German Chancellor Olaf Scholz's announcement that there are British troops in Ukraine before the UK has announced it, and why it seems inadvisable for Scholz to rule out Germany sending its own troops to Ukraine. Hodges also touches on the oft-mentioned subject of what the chances really are that Putin would deploy his nuclear arsenal.
Subscribe: ru-vid.com...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
#russia #ukraine #putin

Опубликовано:

 

28 фев 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,3 тыс.   
@JuliaPrazsmary
@JuliaPrazsmary Месяц назад
12:17 "...Not one American soldier or German Bundeswehr soldier has even broken a fingernail...So, I mean, what are we tired of?" I love this man.
@robertmiskey5502
@robertmiskey5502 Месяц назад
Hodges is brilliant Why can’t political leaders listen to his advice?
@junk4dimeji
@junk4dimeji Месяц назад
Yes. Only the Ukrainians who you claim to care about about.
@virtual2152
@virtual2152 Месяц назад
I hope you caught his fluent German at the end, too. lol
@JuliaPrazsmary
@JuliaPrazsmary Месяц назад
@@virtual2152 That, and the fact that he is able to clearly pronounce nuclear, instead of "nucular" :D
@theroldan8013
@theroldan8013 Месяц назад
ben hodges trying to send europeans to die for uk and usa... and eurosavages cheer him lol
@erichert1001
@erichert1001 Месяц назад
Macron didn't say we should send troops to Ukraine, he said he couldn't rule out the possibility.
@csat1078
@csat1078 Месяц назад
And Scholz said british and french soliders are already in ukraine on the ground...
@derloopkat
@derloopkat Месяц назад
This scandal was fabricated by the media. It's absurd to ask every President or PM in Europe if they agree something Macron didn't say. These journalists just want to produce the headlines.
@Writeous0ne
@Writeous0ne Месяц назад
And Putin didn't say he will nuke anyone but it's certainly a possibility.
@amc3463
@amc3463 Месяц назад
Yup why do you think so many Russian jets have been shot down lately
@josephsullinger6529
@josephsullinger6529 Месяц назад
The nato countries also said they wouldn't send M1 Abrams or F-16s in either yet look at them now. It's only a matter of time
@Clavers1369
@Clavers1369 Месяц назад
Eisenhower said a commander should never tell the enemy what he isnt going to do. Let him waste his time guessing.
@jakub.kubicek
@jakub.kubicek Месяц назад
Unless it's information warfare and that is EXACTLY what he's going to do.
@JuliaPrazsmary
@JuliaPrazsmary Месяц назад
1. politicians don't grasp that this isn't cold war any more. This one is hot, people die, children die. Or are displaced, or swim an icy river to escape the draft. I've seen plenty in my time at the Ukraine border. Declarations just won't do. 2. they don't care any more. I'm afraid that the time of the democratically elected statespeople who put the benefit of their electorate, or their country before their own is long gone and lamented.
@user-mv6he6gl8m
@user-mv6he6gl8m Месяц назад
I guess Biden and Scholtz are speaking to another audience - their presumed voters...
@TheBlackIdentety
@TheBlackIdentety Месяц назад
Eisenhower was a military General. We would need people like him in power not these civilian clowns.
@teresitaepanto
@teresitaepanto Месяц назад
how can the russian defeated if they dont make and action
@billyblackie9417
@billyblackie9417 Месяц назад
The French never said they would send troops on the ground in Ukraine he only said the possibility is not off the table just like anything is open for consideration this is being blown out of proportion. All options are open for discussion not decisions made to put troops on the ground. All countries have the right to think about what can be considered
@eddastrohmayer251
@eddastrohmayer251 Месяц назад
It was rather crazy of Macron to celebrate the ununity of NATO- memberstates in public. Even Stoltenberg refused. Putin will laugh quite a lot..
@hansmemling2311
@hansmemling2311 Месяц назад
It was still meant as a provocation to satisfy macron’s desperate need to stay relevant in all global politics. Macron is trying for France to stay relevant and regain the relevancy it once has on the world stage.
@DarkSkay
@DarkSkay Месяц назад
Yes, this video begins with a misquote of what Emmanuel Macron said about a week ago.
@axelscharf2415
@axelscharf2415 Месяц назад
But why would Macron who has so far delivered almost no military aid suddenly talk about boots on the ground ? Macron is just a attention seeker and like many others is using this conflict for his political games. While Ukrainians are dying.
@kennychad2821
@kennychad2821 Месяц назад
I think Germany has been trained to be timid since WW2. They're not used to being boisterous and militant and for good reason. The reality is, today NATO needs Germany and their military prowess of engineering. An organized and galvanized NATO is a beast of an adversary and every time Putin opens his mouth, NATO gets stronger. Europe just has to see that themselves.
@LegaliseFinland
@LegaliseFinland Месяц назад
Mr. Hodges never ceases to speak straight facts.
@DjokovicTheGoat
@DjokovicTheGoat Месяц назад
Hahaha he predicted Ukraine would capture Crimea by August 2022, then said spring 2023, then said summer 2023. Total clown always wrong
@brandonlance3601
@brandonlance3601 Месяц назад
​@@DjokovicTheGoatiterally always
@theant9821
@theant9821 Месяц назад
​@@DjokovicTheGoathe said if they were given the equipment necessary, which they weren't and still haven't. We've provided the bare minimum from day one, should have given them everything they needed straight away and the war would likely have been over 12 months now.
@MattRios-jn1qx
@MattRios-jn1qx Месяц назад
Just love to listen to Ben Hodges. He's a breathe of goodness and clarity, common sense
@rmdomainer9042
@rmdomainer9042 Месяц назад
Military men are sometimes quite fascinating to listen to. Like frontline buddhas.
@isaacmoore3639
@isaacmoore3639 Месяц назад
I hate the fact that Gen. has been preaching this strategic objective requirement and nobody in the us government has been listening!
@thomasjgallagher924
@thomasjgallagher924 Месяц назад
Tell me about it. What in the world is Lloyd Austin saying to Biden? "Yes sir, withholding key capabilities while overstating the price tag of our contributions to Ukraine will send a clear message." I can't believe Mark Milley and CQ Brown have been willful participants in this cluster puck. I wish more people in the US had the insights and integrity to see that Biden has mismanaged this from before "go" and that one of the few worse possible people for the job would be Trump. Why do people get behind "their guy" rather than behind a policy?
@Sheddweller419
@Sheddweller419 Месяц назад
I absolutely agree , but I do think that Ukraine listens to him, not to mention every present and retired NATO serviceman , me included.
@alanshackelford6450
@alanshackelford6450 Месяц назад
Nobody? I'm sure there are some really good people in the defense and intelligence communities who agree completely. It's a handful of loathsome political creatures, mostly in the House of Representatives, who put their petty agendas ahead of both the political will of the majority of Americans as well as the well-being of the American republic.
@jordanferguson7425
@jordanferguson7425 Месяц назад
The GOP hasn't been listening
@thomasjgallagher924
@thomasjgallagher924 Месяц назад
@@alanshackelford6450 I'll preface what I'll say with me being a Democrat in Ukraine, so as to alleviate concerns about this being party preference. I don't disagree that there's a special place in heck warming up for Speaker Johnson's arrival, but the Biden administration made multiple errors in judgement that has denied key capabilities when they were needed (before the Russians fortified). Biden way over-stated the fear of escalation when no one in eastern Europe was saying that concern was justified. He blew the opportunity to make real progress when the political will was global and throughout Congress. He still denies capabilities even if the funding is there and he said strategically short-sighted things like no NATO boots on the ground. (BTW Kyiv is more full of American accents than I ever recall kt being.)
@charlieterzano4833
@charlieterzano4833 Месяц назад
He's so consistent on his points, I hope at some point western leaders put his advice in action
@vlhc4642
@vlhc4642 Месяц назад
At some point you might realize he's the reason you lost and he might actually be working for Russia.
@C05597641
@C05597641 Месяц назад
I hope not. I dont want to die in a nuclear war over Ukraine.
@stephenadenu-mensah6538
@stephenadenu-mensah6538 Месяц назад
He should send his children to the front line and stop sitting there talking
@austinp5244
@austinp5244 Месяц назад
Ben gave us as an straight answer. Great man.
@dgib1694
@dgib1694 Месяц назад
Macron specifically said there was no consensus in Europe about the possibility of sending troops, but that he thinks we should keep this open. This journalist keeps misrepresenting what was said.
@skywillfindyou
@skywillfindyou Месяц назад
Macron said one thing, got backlash and hasted to correct it, with other offcials rushing to put in in their interpretations to keep thing calm. Face it, it's a mess.
@tetianavarvynska2125
@tetianavarvynska2125 Месяц назад
ALL OF THEM DO! This is just so crazy.
@theroldan8013
@theroldan8013 Месяц назад
ok vic nuland we believe you..... plop
@adrien5834
@adrien5834 Месяц назад
@@theroldan8013 His speech is online, dude. Just go watch it.
@mr.priman
@mr.priman Месяц назад
I mean, Germans somehow thinks, that they still owe anything to ruzzia
@patricerobert4191
@patricerobert4191 Месяц назад
Just to be clear, macro did not say we should send troops, he said « there is no consensus about sending troops, but we cannot completely take this of the table » the journalist work is getting more and more poor.
@theroldan8013
@theroldan8013 Месяц назад
lol you seems desperate. macron said what said we all hear
@adrien5834
@adrien5834 Месяц назад
@@theroldan8013 What he said is online. clearly you didn't watch it.
@effexon
@effexon Месяц назад
thats good wording, keeping it vague and on the table of possibilities is smart.
@delta_glider4362
@delta_glider4362 Месяц назад
@@adrien5834 >clearly you didn't watch it. All NATO's tops who speeded to disregard Macron's words didn't watch him too? 😆 You are patetic
@The_Stef
@The_Stef Месяц назад
@@theroldan8013 Macron said exactly what the OP is claiming, Macron never got more specific or committed to sending troops.
@johncarr2333
@johncarr2333 Месяц назад
This is what we need to hear. I have a lot of respect for this man.
@a.r.stellmacher8709
@a.r.stellmacher8709 Месяц назад
Do you want WW3?
@johncarr2333
@johncarr2333 Месяц назад
@@a.r.stellmacher8709 it's already here. Most either can not see or refuse to recognize the obvious. We continue to do so at our own peril. Our own people have been compromised. This is period is about a global power grab.
@chris24j48
@chris24j48 Месяц назад
As Churchill said our policy is “ Victory”in winning WW2 . Should be same in Ukraine
@eddastrohmayer251
@eddastrohmayer251 Месяц назад
Nobody needs Churchill-sayings in times of nuclear weapons!
@miroslavdusin4325
@miroslavdusin4325 Месяц назад
@@eddastrohmayer251 Ok so as Russia has nuclear weapons we need to give up immediately and hand over to them everything they want. I am sure this will work and ensure peace for our time.
@russ_6214
@russ_6214 Месяц назад
Newsflash you brainiac - neither the U.S. nor the west is at war with Russia. Russia did NOT attack the west or the U.S. no matter how much war mongers like old men with “rank” who never fought in a real war themselves will have you believe.
@WingkKong
@WingkKong Месяц назад
The British depended on the soviet Union to defeat the German
@WingkKong
@WingkKong Месяц назад
​@@miroslavdusin4325you need to respect Russian interest They are not small country In The Middle East Which is attacked at will by the America
@natalieturko4808
@natalieturko4808 Месяц назад
You would think that Macron had said something outrageous. The West has sent troops to countries with far LESS reason for doing so (Afghanistan, Iraq). Ukraine has already proven its commitment to achieving freedom, democracy, and peace within its own, sovereign borders. Russia has a population of 140 million to Ukraine's 40 million. In what way is this a "fair" fight?
@dwl3006
@dwl3006 Месяц назад
Ukraine has proven its commitment to embezzling E.U. and U.S. tax dollars.
@thedustyhead
@thedustyhead Месяц назад
Besides Russia being a military arms manufacturer , and Ukraine being an agricultural country ! The Ukrainians are fighting a brave fight and deserve all the help In both military and humanitarian aid In order to remain a free sovereign democratic country , maintaining their freedom their flag their language and their culture . To live in peace governed by their own elected leaders In Kyiv .
@dwl3006
@dwl3006 Месяц назад
@@thedustyhead Or they could agree to not join NATO and end the war that way.
@eepberlin7970
@eepberlin7970 Месяц назад
Maybe because it’s much easier to send troops to far off countries and mostly attack from the air than to go and fight on the ground against an actual enemy on Europe’s borders
@natalieturko4808
@natalieturko4808 Месяц назад
@@dwl3006 Wrong. NATO is a DEFENSIVE alliance. It exists to protect vulnerable, sovereign countries from Russian aggression. Ukraine MUST, and WILL join NATO as this will be the only way to protect itself. This was NEVER about NATO. This was about taking over Ukraine and the destroying Ukrainian identity.
@SergioLopez-hw6pk
@SergioLopez-hw6pk Месяц назад
Amazing interview, Ben Hodges is a great military analyst. I don't miss any interview with him. He always brings some news points of view very interesting.
@TheTororist
@TheTororist Месяц назад
he's been consistently wrong for over a year on his analysis
@majortom8047
@majortom8047 Месяц назад
The Toroist - Nope. It's you who has been wrong every time.
@inzhener2007
@inzhener2007 Месяц назад
Not only general is well connected, he is also well grounded in facts and logic.
@markuscev4581
@markuscev4581 Месяц назад
Lmfao he said the counteroffensive was going to take Crimea back. It didn’t even make the first line of dense they made 500 meters for 60 billion dollars
@tayler2396
@tayler2396 Месяц назад
@@markuscev4581 He also qualified with "IF" the West adequately supports Ukraine, which it did not do and still is not doing.
@dangal9366
@dangal9366 Месяц назад
Nothing should be off limits...behind close doors.
@Stargate101
@Stargate101 Месяц назад
His last statement was on the nose. Russia wanted to make sure Ukraine never got the iron dome. Oct 7th was Iran's gift to Russia.
@andyjones1982
@andyjones1982 Месяц назад
Iron dome is far too expensive to protect Ukraine from so many missiles and drones. And I think long term we will see it is too expensive for Israel to maintain as well.
@patlecat
@patlecat Месяц назад
Hodges is right. Sadly Scholz is not fit for times of crisis like this and he can't detach himself enough from Russia.
@user-pu7ds6pm1k
@user-pu7ds6pm1k Месяц назад
Thank you DW this interview with such a thoughtful, knowledgeable person.
@GregMoylan-pn6sr
@GregMoylan-pn6sr Месяц назад
I feel sorry for Scholz... definitely a softy for the good times, but way out of his depth when times get tough.
@eddastrohmayer251
@eddastrohmayer251 Месяц назад
I feel sorry for little Napoleons and war- cheerleaders. Only diplomacy will make a solution to this senseless war ! And just to add: Macron is isolated in Europe with his big mouth and already wents back ...
@gyorgygajdos1657
@gyorgygajdos1657 Месяц назад
He is a small town mayor.
@eddastrohmayer251
@eddastrohmayer251 Месяц назад
@@gyorgygajdos1657 And you a great war-hero ? Suppose only a war-cheerleader...
@roylidstone3678
@roylidstone3678 Месяц назад
Agreed but don’t feel sorry for him, while he constantly procrastinates, Ukrainians die
@harmless6813
@harmless6813 Месяц назад
I don't feel sorry for him. If he has no clue he at least should listen to others.
@mikeb5664
@mikeb5664 Месяц назад
All options must remain on the table.
@andyjones1982
@andyjones1982 Месяц назад
Including peace negotiations I hope.
@tayler2396
@tayler2396 Месяц назад
@@andyjones1982 Those should be on the table after Russia is out of Ukrainian territory.
@olafvonbraun7300
@olafvonbraun7300 Месяц назад
Ben is one of the most clear-eyed people out there. Rational, calm, calculating. These politicians are like little girls running around and flopping mouths, unfortunately with consequences.
@Wargasm54
@Wargasm54 Месяц назад
😂
@AK-ej5ml
@AK-ej5ml Месяц назад
Unusually Macron is right on this one: Sending troops shouldn't be excluded as a possibility - though of course it should be an absolute last resort, the first step should be a significant step up in material and economical support for Ukraine.
@zhufortheimpaler4041
@zhufortheimpaler4041 Месяц назад
in that cas, france should increase its aid to ukraine by about 10x, then it would be an equal GDP share to germany.
@eddastrohmayer251
@eddastrohmayer251 Месяц назад
The only thing Macron did is celebrating the disunity of NATOmember states ! Even Stoltenberg refused. It's absolute nonsense to go to public without seeking consensus before. Putin will laugh quite a lot ...
@inotoni6148
@inotoni6148 Месяц назад
Then why isn’t France moving forward? It was Macron's idea. In addition, France hardly helps Ukraine at all, compared to Germany
@eddastrohmayer251
@eddastrohmayer251 Месяц назад
If right or wrong, he made a fool of European countries by celebrating their un-unity in public. Putin will have laughed a lot !
@olivierbeltrami
@olivierbeltrami Месяц назад
Ben Hodges is so fantastic; detailed, cogent, big-picturesque.
@operator9858
@operator9858 Месяц назад
epic sarcasm man. lol
@freedomlover20740
@freedomlover20740 Месяц назад
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@AstroGremlinAmerican
@AstroGremlinAmerican Месяц назад
@@operator9858 Totally beet-worthy. Congrats!
@altodata2617
@altodata2617 Месяц назад
😂😁😂😁😁😂😂
@omgsolikevalleygirl
@omgsolikevalleygirl Месяц назад
are you part of the organisation that runs the American government per chance?
@reinormand
@reinormand Месяц назад
excellent interview. Ben Hodges has the conviction and mental clarity of a winner
@peetky8645
@peetky8645 Месяц назад
Iraq - lost, afghanistan - lost, vietnam - lost. Not a winner.
@MunterPunter
@MunterPunter Месяц назад
For two years Mr. Hodges has given it to us straight. Are any of our European politicians ever going to listen? Sphincter Boy Scholz has shat himself over putin again.
@braxxian
@braxxian Месяц назад
Has has also been 100% wrong with every prediction he has made regarding this war. He is a Ukrainian cheerleader, not a impartial analyst.
@hecmen7298
@hecmen7298 Месяц назад
@@braxxianI agree he’s been very wrong. Would love to see his investments. I support Ukrain but things looking not too good
@paddy6358
@paddy6358 Месяц назад
@@braxxianCheerleader?? Unless you like the idea of WWIII, Russia must lose.
@Wargasm54
@Wargasm54 Месяц назад
Giving it to us straight? 😂. He’s a clown and he’s been completely wrong every step of the way. Ukraine is getting their teeth kicked in.
@sandybrown4957
@sandybrown4957 Месяц назад
@@paddy6358 anyone stopping you?
@paulstafford2747
@paulstafford2747 Месяц назад
Thank you General Hodges. If only our foolish leaders (our politicians) would follow your advice.
@jeremygibbs7342
@jeremygibbs7342 Месяц назад
Well said general Hodges. Its not about ignoring Russias nuclear threats. Its about reaffirming our convictions. Are individual roghts worth fighting and possibly dying for? Is freedom of press and speech more important than self preservation? The threat of nuclear war exists whether we would meet an aggressor on the field battle or not.
@DeadNoob451
@DeadNoob451 Месяц назад
lmao "freedom of press".
@skinnyTheCat
@skinnyTheCat Месяц назад
Ben should run for president. This man has lots of valuable experience, and imo has shown clear thinking, Logic and sense through out the world mess we are in since russia started its agression on the world.
@kirilld6206
@kirilld6206 Месяц назад
Will be the last president for USA it seems.
@user-cs5bn6tu1f
@user-cs5bn6tu1f Месяц назад
Aggression on the world ? Mmmm... Maybe aggression to US egemony...? World is big. You consider only British or US or English speakers. If it is that you are thinking of remembering, this is a small part will help you before making such a statement. His only logic are the money 💰 he get from lobbying the defence industrial complex.
@ElnursStory
@ElnursStory Месяц назад
100% agree with you, men like him should run for president not a businessman who cares only about money especially in short term
@reginasemenenko148
@reginasemenenko148 Месяц назад
Exactly!
@akvilebalta2275
@akvilebalta2275 Месяц назад
Yes!
@bloggalot4718
@bloggalot4718 Месяц назад
All options should be left open.
@andyjones1982
@andyjones1982 Месяц назад
Including peace and compromise, based on a realistic view of Putin, Ukraine, and Russia, not on this baseless and insane idea that Russia wants to conquer the rest of europe. Ukraine is one of the Rus-sian countries, like Belarus, with a large Russian population, many of whom welcomed Russian forces. that is the truth, easy to find and evaluate, but suspiciously few people on here seem to have done that.
@majortom8047
@majortom8047 Месяц назад
General Hodges is the one to listen to, since he is 100% correct.
@silafaupaulmeredith7251
@silafaupaulmeredith7251 Месяц назад
He has been consistently wrong. Just to refresh your short memory He has been saying Russia ran out of ammunition last year, poorly trained, low morale. Do you want me to go on?
@LuV2SPDup
@LuV2SPDup Месяц назад
​@@silafaupaulmeredith7251, please, don't. You're severally misinformed.
@silafaupaulmeredith7251
@silafaupaulmeredith7251 Месяц назад
​@@LuV2SPDupDo you want a link from last year
@LuV2SPDup
@LuV2SPDup Месяц назад
@@silafaupaulmeredith7251, I don't want a link, Iván.......
@LuV2SPDup
@LuV2SPDup Месяц назад
@@silafaupaulmeredith7251 , what part of "I don't want your misinformed links" you don't understand?
@jeanredman-roberts5604
@jeanredman-roberts5604 Месяц назад
Allowing foreign technical experts into Ukraine. to help build desperately needed fortifications is a no-brainer, along with the related equipment. This is defensive, after all.
@pcopeland15
@pcopeland15 Месяц назад
Ben is one of the few strategic thinkers at the moment, who is clear and not stalling or reactive.
@ItsMe_Hello_People
@ItsMe_Hello_People Месяц назад
Great interview with Ben Hodges. Thank you!
@KimJungGooner
@KimJungGooner Месяц назад
Never tell the enemy what you won't do.
@pastorDbow
@pastorDbow Месяц назад
Ben and David Pedreaus are one on their views and they are best we have in the U.S. They say support Ukraine to win!
@janewilkin1984
@janewilkin1984 Месяц назад
Like victory in Afghanistan 😮😮
@ww5302
@ww5302 Месяц назад
It was just a few years ago when Germany was the best friend of Russia.... Germany ignored many worning and pleading from one Eastern European country specifically , And called them Russophobe
@marko1263
@marko1263 Месяц назад
Wtf are you smoking? They weren't friends, just business partners.
@zhufortheimpaler4041
@zhufortheimpaler4041 Месяц назад
and still germany is the largest european supporter of ukraine by a long shot. you could combine most of europe (including UK and France) and wouldnt get equal amounts of aid to what germany delivers constantly.
@Micha-qv5uf
@Micha-qv5uf Месяц назад
​@@zhufortheimpaler4041it's annoying isn't it? Nobody looks at the bigger picture people just act reactionary and emotional to little pieces of information without any context. People are literally animals.
@willw8011
@willw8011 Месяц назад
I still remember French cursing the USA and saying the USA forced the French government to stop the sale of French built warships to Russia. European people and countries are similar to a pit of snakes always wanting to bite anyone at any available opportunity. The USA needs to get away from these countries and people.
@OliverNorth9729
@OliverNorth9729 Месяц назад
I guess the germs forgot about the east german thing quickly.
@user-qt1eo7dq8v
@user-qt1eo7dq8v Месяц назад
Where is Taurus?
@MetalheadAndNerd
@MetalheadAndNerd Месяц назад
Where are Germany's nuclear weapons?
@zhufortheimpaler4041
@zhufortheimpaler4041 Месяц назад
where is the french aid? 635 million $ in delivered military aid is quit a limited amount comparing it to 18 billion $ from germany.
@Pierluigi_Di_Lorenzo
@Pierluigi_Di_Lorenzo Месяц назад
In a country having the aircraft to launch them.
@ronald220964
@ronald220964 Месяц назад
In the Taurus storage
@jaarneal
@jaarneal Месяц назад
@@MetalheadAndNerd That's easy to look up. Just read about NATO nuclear sharing.
@wladekhanczar
@wladekhanczar Месяц назад
I like this Man...Gen.Ben Hodges best military analyst, thank you very much, 100% right.
@yellowscott
@yellowscott Месяц назад
Hodges for president!!! Makes WAY more sense than the 2 galoops that will run?????
@neiltitmus9744
@neiltitmus9744 Месяц назад
In public nothing should be off the table
@vlhc4642
@vlhc4642 Месяц назад
You realize the only thing rest of the world sees is NATO desperation.
@DeadNoob451
@DeadNoob451 Месяц назад
Except for talking badly about climate change or gender or a million other things that do not involve WW3. Okay.
@NickolaiFury
@NickolaiFury Месяц назад
Ben Hodges is a national treasure!
@buravan1512
@buravan1512 Месяц назад
He's there to sell this WAR. SCHOLZ is there to maintain the GERMAN Economy, they have two different tasks.
@benjones4365
@benjones4365 Месяц назад
10:00 Thank you to Ben Hodges for stating what he means by wining.
@jarmosalonen2068
@jarmosalonen2068 Месяц назад
As a Finn it has been difficult during this war time to see Germany lacking the objective of the war support. Ben Hodges is right in his words. Baltic countries and Finland have the goal to defeat Russia in Ukraine. A compromise peace is not lasting. Means to achieve a win will be seen once the objective goal is clear.
@masterchinese28
@masterchinese28 Месяц назад
Gen. Hodges is always a good interview. He sees clearly how the West easily deters itself and the need for clear objectives.
@quarryryde
@quarryryde Месяц назад
That was a very good interview. Agree that Olaf Scholz is out of line. For a leader, he is too emotionally engaged. We need cool heads during a crisis.
@chrissavill8713
@chrissavill8713 Месяц назад
Emotionally engaged?... I'd call it being just plain scared.
@schongeistrebell4739
@schongeistrebell4739 Месяц назад
Thank you for saying what seems totally obvious to me but not for many people including politicians out there. This is a very smart, sensitive interview I wish everyone would see and listen.
@altodata2617
@altodata2617 Месяц назад
Sarcasm?
@berndbrakemeier1418
@berndbrakemeier1418 Месяц назад
Nein, Russe! @@altodata2617
@Sindrijo
@Sindrijo Месяц назад
It's not even totally obvious, it is painfully obvious, and I cannot fathom the level of self-importance of some politicians in the US seem to have, some of them would not hesitate to sacrifice the rest of the world around them if it only meant they get to feel important for another term. I am equally perplexed by the depoliticization of a large percentage of the US via divisive but ultimately distractive partisan issues that are solvable with a little compromise but are not to be solved because they are more useful as political chess pieces.
@larion3296
@larion3296 Месяц назад
Very good analysis from the general, on many different subjects and from different views. Much more political framing and realism than before. He seems very well informed.
@considerthis7712
@considerthis7712 Месяц назад
Agree with Hodges. Germans needs to sack Shultz now. It is SO dumb telling the world and Putin that Germany will not do any military action.. when Putin never restricts his options. Unbelievable. ( Australia)
@franceyneireland1633
@franceyneireland1633 Месяц назад
North Korea is not restrictions their weapons that they are supplying to Russia nor has Iran.
@zhufortheimpaler4041
@zhufortheimpaler4041 Месяц назад
no Scholz only stated the agreed actionplan from February 2022, that there wont be an active NATO involvement in Ukraine. That was never a sectret. That british and french military observers and training missions are in ukraine is also known for 2+ years by now.
@Micha-qv5uf
@Micha-qv5uf Месяц назад
Your comment shows a lack of experience and is just wrong in so many ways. 1. You can't just "sack" a democratically elected leader. On what base would you do that? It would cause severe damage to peoples trust in democracy. 2. I think people from the US or in your case Australia don't have the right to make such bold statements. You're not the ones sitting directly next to Russian nuclear missile silos. It's easy to talk big when its not your citys and your people that are at stake.
@considerthis7712
@considerthis7712 Месяц назад
@@Micha-qv5uf 1. Tell me any democracy, including yours, that does not have a process to sack a Leader outside of elections, especially when the majority of the Parliament including the leaders own party,want him/ her replaced? It happens frequently. 2. The German Chancellor is a disgrace in both Strategic Leadership and drip feeding support always overriding his own earlier “no” to actions and Russian love him for it. 3. In so many ways., you gave two ignorant arguments, “ so many” ?
@DeadNoob451
@DeadNoob451 Месяц назад
@@Micha-qv5uf Lmao no sane person still has "trust" in what they call "democracy". Its not the 60s anymore dude.
@Kim-J312
@Kim-J312 Месяц назад
Macron is right ! We ( NATO) should not take boots on the ground as an option. He didn't say we (NATO) are sending boots on the ground.
@johnbox271
@johnbox271 Месяц назад
US boots on the ground in Ukraine is an insane proposal.
@pgs1796
@pgs1796 Месяц назад
Always a pleasure to hear the views of Ben Hodges.
@user-ep3ed5jd7q
@user-ep3ed5jd7q Месяц назад
I pray the world is listening to the dignified wisdom of Officer Ben Hodges…..this is a great interview.
@a.r.stellmacher8709
@a.r.stellmacher8709 Месяц назад
Aren’t you promoting WW3 by agreeing with Mr. Hodges?
@krollpeter
@krollpeter Месяц назад
Good interview, good questions. DW at the top!
@kinngrimm
@kinngrimm Месяц назад
7:30 The mentioning of nuclear weapons just makes me angry and more resolved that we have to support Ukrain as i am not to be bullied into fear by some dictator who denies his countrymen rights and sends them blindly into a meatgrinder.
@Angry.Canuck
@Angry.Canuck Месяц назад
Simple, straight to the point. clear. I like this man.
@SveaGra
@SveaGra Месяц назад
Love this gyu, I think he is very much on the spot. He has also expiriance and knowlege of orchs tinking...
@TH-mn6rf
@TH-mn6rf Месяц назад
Can't agree with Ben Hodges more. Why do you want to tell your enemy what you will do and what you will not do?
@DaveDorenbergVeltman
@DaveDorenbergVeltman Месяц назад
🤨 why is that reporter twisting words? It's not what is being said.
@thedubwhisperer2157
@thedubwhisperer2157 Месяц назад
Surely boots on the ground are, by definition, not on a table...
@LV-426...
@LV-426... Месяц назад
The most sensible human alive right now.
@0onpoint
@0onpoint Месяц назад
Sensible to vampire coins
@chrisviking7807
@chrisviking7807 Месяц назад
Lacking a clear stratgey with clear goals is a sure way to lose a war.
@Sokrabiades
@Sokrabiades Месяц назад
Amen. A loss of lives, money, and opportunities.
@nicolaasstempels8207
@nicolaasstempels8207 Месяц назад
Ukraine does have a clear aim and strategy, but the West, and the US in particular, doesn't.
@smftrsddvjiou6443
@smftrsddvjiou6443 Месяц назад
No boots on the ground.
@a.r.stellmacher8709
@a.r.stellmacher8709 Месяц назад
Agreed. We should not agree to what Ben Hodges says. We don’t want WW3.
@AK-ej5ml
@AK-ej5ml Месяц назад
Completely agree that DW should not misrepresent what was actually said - DW can, and used to, do better.
@hiltonsue-wah-sing1239
@hiltonsue-wah-sing1239 Месяц назад
He is absolutely right. You should not telegraph your intentions to your enemy. Keep them guessing.
@humanonearth1
@humanonearth1 Месяц назад
Ahhh, don't tell your adversary your red lines, duh. (Gives history book)
@HatBilly2008
@HatBilly2008 Месяц назад
Ben would be a great president for the United States he should run for office
@Clavers1369
@Clavers1369 Месяц назад
The headline is a classic mixed metaphor. How can the boots be on the ground and on the table at the same time?
@DeadNoob451
@DeadNoob451 Месяц назад
Soldiers are boots on ground and politicians responsible have their feet on table relaxing at home.
@SupGaillac
@SupGaillac Месяц назад
At this point, misrepresenting that much what Macron said can only be done on purpose. He never said "should send", but only that the possibility shouldn't be ruled out.
@theodoroseidler7072
@theodoroseidler7072 Месяц назад
Mr. Ben Hodges is excellent. Why presidents don't listen to such excellent advisors is beyond me. Scholz needs to get his act together.
@TheJohn93226
@TheJohn93226 Месяц назад
Massive respect for General Ben Hodges! 💙💙💙
@miroslavavisinger
@miroslavavisinger Месяц назад
I hope you are now happy being at home with your family. Enjoy. So long, general. Thanks for all lessons you have shared. 👍❤️
@MarcosK
@MarcosK Месяц назад
Hear him, please…
@Goldfinger140
@Goldfinger140 Месяц назад
Competence meets competence. Thank you.
@chuckmartin2220
@chuckmartin2220 Месяц назад
With crazy talk like that, I'm glad he's not in a position to actually do anything.
@a.r.stellmacher8709
@a.r.stellmacher8709 Месяц назад
I see it the same way. He is indirectly promoting WW3, in which Germany would play a leading role. False Flags set by Germany’s so- called allies could easily draw Germany much deeper into this war and putting blame on it for starting WW3. I don’t want to read headlines like ‘Germany starting WW3’.
@andersgrassman6583
@andersgrassman6583 Месяц назад
Crystal clear, and there is absplutely nothing to disagree with.
@primalamusica3
@primalamusica3 Месяц назад
I love listening to Ben Hodges. Much Respect! Thank you for inviting him .
@stephangleiner1333
@stephangleiner1333 Месяц назад
I never undrstood what Olaf Scholz wanted in the chancellors office. Seemingly unsuitable. So I guessed I might maybe miss something in this sober north German. Now I see, that tragically, he simply has an inflated selfconfidence. What makes the tragedy even worse is that he has to deal with a war now. Rather two wars. His failures mean death and suffering, possibly defeat for so many people.
@bellbookcandle3051
@bellbookcandle3051 Месяц назад
I wish he was advising the White House!! 😔
@jonathanwestwood9373
@jonathanwestwood9373 Месяц назад
Ben Hodges is high caliber individual. Well done listening to his views.
@user-kg4fr9jr7v
@user-kg4fr9jr7v Месяц назад
More you appease Putin and looking for negotiations more confident he becomes. All russians attached. Compromise is not what you need in war, compromise leads to more war
@adampapp6623
@adampapp6623 Месяц назад
Eu has to pull out the finger of the butt and start to stand alone and help Ukraine. If UKR fail, what does ppl think, will they stop with a fully mobilized economy and experienced army?
@tayler2396
@tayler2396 Месяц назад
Moldova. Georgia maybe.
@harryhirsch3637
@harryhirsch3637 Месяц назад
So refreshing to hear clear words from someone who has thought things through instead of incoherent word salad from certain politicians.
@benyomovod6904
@benyomovod6904 Месяц назад
Chamberlain, Daladier, and Scholz The list of shame
@Truspio
@Truspio Месяц назад
I mean Germany don't have to provide taurus or in fact any weapons to Ukraine - it is a good will of any country as Ukraine is not in the alliance, but for Olaf Scholz revealing secret/ alliance information to the hands of the enemy is something unimaginable. I don't know how other countries would ever cooperate with German intelligence after this.
@zhufortheimpaler4041
@zhufortheimpaler4041 Месяц назад
its not secret information, there have been tv interviews etc with british and french soldiers in 2022 who had observed the battle of kyiv for example.
@bannol1
@bannol1 Месяц назад
With Olaf Scholz at the helm there is very little prospect of strong, united leadership.
@swapnilmalshe
@swapnilmalshe Месяц назад
Bang on Ben Hodges!!! So clearly analyzed!!!
@cipriandenes6641
@cipriandenes6641 Месяц назад
BRAVO !! In sfarsit un om care stie ce vorbeste !!! Respect pentru argumentele lui !!
@pepperpath
@pepperpath Месяц назад
Great interview 🙏
@larsrons7937
@larsrons7937 Месяц назад
General Ben Hodges is among the most clear sighted military minds we have around. We should listen carefully to what he says.
@TrixiLovesYou
@TrixiLovesYou Месяц назад
Scholz is completely clueless when it comes to strategic foreign policy. The guy has probably never heard of ambiguity.
@TheFANROCKER
@TheFANROCKER Месяц назад
Mr Hodgson, it is a pleasure to listen to you. Really good format, two smart people talking, nice. Thank you for that.
@GaminHasard
@GaminHasard Месяц назад
Slowly slowly walking into disaster. Hubris. Just hubris.
@fritzraake22
@fritzraake22 Месяц назад
Someone explain to me why Biden doesn't give Ben Hodges a prominent decision making role. He knows the situation in Europe/Ukraine like no other American.
@oatztui4183
@oatztui4183 Месяц назад
All the same from Putin that magic word Nuke dose he think he's the only one with Nuke.
@thisismetoday
@thisismetoday Месяц назад
I feel this man should be in charge.
@sxe1nuar
@sxe1nuar Месяц назад
Ben Hodges is free to join Ukranian army any time he wants 🤷
@dereckbrannigan6195
@dereckbrannigan6195 Месяц назад
Thank u Gen Hodges for your clear advice based on your brilliant career.
@eddastrohmayer251
@eddastrohmayer251 Месяц назад
He also advised the Ukraine- counteroffensive ... Not so good, wasn't it ?!
@KaterinaBudyakova-hf7rk
@KaterinaBudyakova-hf7rk Месяц назад
Brilliant Zero advice, unfortunately, from US gentleman. He personally have empty reasons and really helpful motivation to resolve the conflict between Russia and Ukraine. Care Zero about real ppl Ukraine and Russia
@dereckbrannigan6195
@dereckbrannigan6195 Месяц назад
@@KaterinaBudyakova-hf7rk how much does Putin pay you?
@DeadNoob451
@DeadNoob451 Месяц назад
@@dereckbrannigan6195 That lame old ad-hominem is not an argument my dude.
@chrisnorcross6233
@chrisnorcross6233 Месяц назад
Good interview. Excellent clarity.
@ronzagata4021
@ronzagata4021 Месяц назад
Well said!!!
@slavojalois1639
@slavojalois1639 Месяц назад
Why don’t they listen to this guy! Slava Ukraini!
Далее
КТО БОЛЬШЕ ЧУВСТВОВАЛ?
00:12
Просмотров 450 тыс.