Celebrating Birthday is Permissible in Islam? Dr Zakir Naik, Bilal Philips, Mufti Menk, Shabir Aly 

Please if you watched the video with all respect don't deny the truth when it doesn't suit you

جزاک اللہ خیرا . Those who have superficial understanding they think it's incorrect saying birthday is not allowed in Islam. I wish you may be blessed with real understanding of Deen e Islam, Ameen!

Subhan'Allah Alhumdulilah Wa li ilahaillilah Wa Allah O Akbar peace and blessings of Allah Swt be upon all the prophets messengers and the companions RA and the Muslim Ummah Ameen yah rabbil Aalameen ♥️☝️

It went from "it's haram" to "it's ok". 😂😂😂😂😂 Listen, to be on the safe side: don't imitate the kuffar.

Regarding the last scholars explanation, well it is forbidden to celebrate anything annually except for 2 eids. A new house ceremony or graduation, or any form of happiness expressed in celebration is acceptable. But it shouldn't be done yearly like we do in birthday celebration and it also has origin from pagans.

As a Muslim we celebrate our birthdays 5 salah a day and Friday we celebrate our great grandparents Adam and Hawa birthday by coming together to listen to the message.

The main thing we Muslim do follow lunar calendar... So celebrating birthday according to christian calendar doesn't make sense at all 🤷

please explain "And the same peace on me the day I was born and the day I will die and the day I would be raised alive." (Kanzul Iman the translation of Holy Quran, Sura Al Maryam, Verse 33) I think this is very clear to me, Happiness and Joy on day he born (ESA AS) and it does not negate it in the quran.

It is ok to have mix understanding of birthday celebrations. We are hung up on small issues. People are not praying and fasting that’s a bigger issue.

Agreed

People think they are right because it’s personal celebration but just they want to make haram to halal because they do . When i see this type of comment and discussion that this is not haram I remembe’‘ there will be time people make haram thing to halal ‘’

Dr Yasir qadhi makes good points . May Allah bless you abundantly Aameen

Dr Yasir Qadhi almost made it Sunnah , Astaghfirullah. See this is exactly what is wrong about injecting other culture in the Islamic Tradition. Soon it'll be part of religion to celebrate anniversaries to win your wife's heart. Let's see what our Prophet ﷺ did and stay close to Allah's message. May Allah Protect and Guide us all. Ameen

Last one seems controversial and unclear...

Even jesus or isa alay salam.. Never celebrate his birthday.. If I'm not mistaken..

I agree with Dr Shabbir ally

From my own level of Islamic knowledge, if the Prophet pbuh recommend fasting on the day one was born then that is enough.

After watching this video. i am confused,,, someone plz clearify whether to celebrate or not?

There are only 2 eids (celebrations) in Islam as per Prophet Muhammad (s.a.w) ! Dont listen to Dr. Yasir Qadhi on this matter!

Prophet actually fasted in memory of his birthday, u celebrate by fasting

I agree with Yasir Al Yadi, the most sensible argument here

then is easter egg and such festivals halal according to this logic?

Sheikhul Islam Yasir Qadhi 💯

According to "Satanic Bible" birthday is most important festivals of the stanic worshipers

Ahmed deedath celebrating birthday of prophet (s)

3 candles?

Dr. Yasir Qadi, Men Wearing pant and shirt is different topic than celebrating pegan celebration annually. To you Then celebrating Christmas is also ok?!?

Simple cutting of cake ?

Yasir qadhi you are genius ignorant non Islamic scholars

BIRTHDAYS ARE SHIRK. ABSOLUTELY NO OTHER WAY TO LOOK AT IT.

If a celebration is going to encourage festivities that are against Islam, like gender mixing, music, dancing or is part of another religious ritual, then it doesn't need to be in Quran to become Haram. Do what you think is right brothers but I agree it's makrooh at very best. May Allah Guide and Protect us all. Ameen.

So who follow mr yasir kadi.... celebrate bday and according to him its halal....hmmm may Allah give him andnus all hidayat.

Is Birthday wishes Haram?

🕋🕌

Dr. Zakir seems to be more christian than Muslim. So celebrating Birthday of Prophet Mohammed is against Islam as per Dr. Zakir. It's just Hypocrisy.

Please tell this to Indian Actors Salman Khan Fardeen Khan Aamir Khan Saif Ali Khan So many are there , dance on the floor with underwear and bikinis They celebrate birthday and they were bokinis etc

Vahabisam

Yasir Qadhi wants to win his wife luv by doung anually anniversary 😢cant u give her other surprises now and then..why wait for the anniversary invented by the mushrik?if Rasulu LLAH was here with us now would he have allowed such celebration?!!! So now it will become a must to all wives bcose Yasir said..and it will go on and on and Subhana ALLAH eventually fitna will occur..definitely..

But our niyyat is not like moon worship.

Who is the your leader? Yes ibnu abdul vahab...

so independence day celabration is haram?

Dr. Yasir Qazi is absulutely right.

U cannot adopt the culture and practice of other religions.

Birthday is 100% a pagan festival so don't know what you talking about Yasir & again anniversaries is also another western thing so are mothers, father's day, for us Muslims everyday is a blessing & if 1 by 1 will copy the non Muslims especially in rituals as birthday then in future we will accept anything so you are definitely WRONG because the Hadith of don't copy the non Muslims does apply to birthdays

Yasir kadi you are out of control we don't believe you you are not a scholar

The 2 Eids and Jummah are general celebrations, I personally think we should be thanking and praising Allah every 2nd for keeping us alive, however for some people that's the only time they say Alhamdulillah, Dr. Yasir Qadhi's argument makes a lot of sense to me, we should not make everything in Islam haram especially when hadiths and Quran did not say anything about it. Let Personal happiness be the halal way. Salam

Dr. Yasir Qadhi is a fitnah in our religion of this time in doing this. It is scary to listen to this guy and he has more philosophical approach. 😮

Zakir Naik and all those who call a birthday celebration 'Haram' should have their heads examined. Firstly, Both of the Eids and Friday are celebrations of the Religion as in whole, while a birthday of an individual is a personal celebration wherein well wishes from his well wishers and families are blessed and bestowed upon him. They are two very different type of celebrations and a birthday celebration can also be looked upon as a celebration of the day when Allah gifted this individual a life. Secondly, Islam is a free flowing religion, free flowing of thoughts and ideas, free flowing of exchange of blessings, free flowing of compassion, free flowing of goodness, free flowing of happiness and it should be kept that way and not get constricted which these dumb minded preachers intend on doing. All I have to say is Celebrate every breath you take and offer your deepest gratitude to Allah for it. Islam does not constrict goodness and happiness. Celebrate your Birthdays and always dedicate a moment on your birthday to express your gratitude to Allah for gifting you this life this day. Amen.

Birthdays are not public they’re private events and have NOTHING to do with religion in our times please don’t make everything haraam.

Mombatti nikaalo

Dr yassir qadhi check your words u ar misleading ummah

DR Shabeer Ali needs to look more deeper. This was pagant ritual and pharaoh practiced it.

Why would you stick the last video to waste the whole argument of kuffar celebration ? The last guy is untrustworthy

Crap logic

He is wrong

Do not speak like a enemy of the prophet

YASIR QADHI WRONG NUMBER 👎

Yasir is gone, his brain is in a state of hibernation. This man is realy fitnah

I dont agree with Yasir Qadhi. I will not learn from him at all.

There is another reason why birthdays are Haraam. chocolate cakes were not eaten during the time of our prophet. All cool cakes are new inventions. They are Bidah and that's why haraam. Because Bidah is haraam.