ChatGPT-4o Tries to Convert Me

Подписаться 24 тыс.

Просмотров 11 тыс.

50% 1

Joe Heschmeyer goes toe to toe with Chat-GPT, rebutting the internet's best large language model's arguments against Catholicism.
Get more Shameless Popery on Patreon!
/ shamelesspopery
Listen to Shameless Popery on Catholic.com:
www.catholic.com/audio/sp

Опубликовано:

29 май 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 145

@catholiccom 27 дней назад

Joe please stay Catholic

@HellenicCatholic 27 дней назад

He’s a gift to the Church.

@user-jm4kz5bg9f 27 дней назад

Right, but ChatGPT is working on him to convert!

@shamelesspopery 27 дней назад

Catholic Answers needs a powerful AI to battle the bad one.

@justinking3558 26 дней назад

@@shamelesspoperyisnt that what Jimmy Akin is?

@chasnikisher7006 26 дней назад

@@shamelesspopery No it doesn't,it has actual apologists. I don't look forward to Thursday to hear from a computer. Please take this topic to its end.

@josh39684 27 дней назад

AI actually showed me the weaknesses in Protestantism arguments

@brodelicious 26 дней назад

That’s literally an artificial argument

@josh39684 26 дней назад

😂@@brodelicious

@john-paulgies4313 21 день назад

I would not rely on a simulation of intelligence to give intelligent arguments one way or another.

@user-mt9hv8sf9f 16 дней назад

How? What did you ask?

@timrichardson4018 26 дней назад

I was in the midst of assessing all the Catholic doctrines, feeling drawn to the Church, when i read your book Pope Peter. You pointing out the central question, is the church what it claims to be, and then supporting the answer in the affirmative as you did, is what got me over the hump and convinced me to become Catholic. Here i am, over a year later, and I am so happy I'm in the Church.

@shamelesspopery 26 дней назад

Praise God and welcome home!

@pmlm1571 26 дней назад

lovely, Timrichardson, welcome home!

@InMyAffliction 27 дней назад

If Joe's not gonna hawk his patreon at the start of every episode then im gonna do it for him. He's such a gift to the church, theres fun stuff in the patreon and he absolutely deserves our support. Editing to add I just watched the first Q&A livestream and it was excellent. You still have 7 hours to join and be part of this week's!!

@InMyAffliction 27 дней назад

(It's linked in the video description)

@shamelesspopery 26 дней назад

You're wonderful, thank you so much! I've been so thrilled with the growing Patreon community. Unsurprisingly, you guys are the best!

@InMyAffliction 26 дней назад

You've been so incredibly helpful in my return to the church. I'm so glad I finally have a way to properly thank you. I'm always praying for you and your family

@halleylujah247 27 дней назад

Who has more misconceptions about Catholicism ChatGpt or James White? 😁

@josh39684 27 дней назад

Haha right 😂

@xxrandmlinksxxbruh2419 27 дней назад

James white knows about the Catholic Church and the teachings smh

@chaoscontrol2400 27 дней назад

😂

@tomgjokaj 27 дней назад

Jamal Mohammed White 🤣

@undyne4032 27 дней назад

@@xxrandmlinksxxbruh2419 After last debate with Jimmy Akin, don't think so, Jamal Mohammed White is ignorant, uses manipulitive tactics to present his arguments as more appealing not because of logic, but by emotional manipulation

@HumanDignity10 25 дней назад

The point you made about trusting the authority of the Church resonates with my experience. I had fallen away for a long time, and I had a lot of questions as I came back to the Church. As I researched all of my questions, I found that the Church had very good, strong answers that made sense. Sometimes I would go for days or weeks of struggling to find the answers but I kept going because I knew they were there and I needed to trust the process of finding them. The Catholic Church goes very deep when addressing ideas, social issues, scripture, history, and doctrine.

@polaramas.867 27 дней назад

Always excellent work Joe- you are a gift to the Church. Thank you and be blessed in Christ.

@pmlm1571 26 дней назад

Very interesting, yes, please do the rest of ChatGPT's pro's and con's. You did a heroic roundup so far!

@tonyl3762 27 дней назад

Man vs Machine. Always a winning theme. Go Joe!

@ToddJambon 26 дней назад

I feel like, if the Papacy is incorrect, there would have to have been some point when someone in the lineage of St. Peter suddenly said, "I am officially creating a position in the Church to be Vicar of Christ on Earth. I have the authority to do this because I'm suddenly interpreting the Bible to say that Peter was the first Vicar of Christ, and that anyone who is Bishop of Rome suddenly has special authority. You will now call me Pope and kiss my rings." If there was never the concept of Pope before that (I'm not saying they used the title Pope from the beginning), then such a statement would be ludicrous and the guy would have been hanged for blasphemy. While we have evidence of people challenging the Pope on different subjects over the years, we don't have anyone challenging the existence of the office of the Pope for a long time in Church history.

@john-paulgies4313 21 день назад

"And behold Core the son of Isaar, the son of Caath, the son of Levi, and Dathan and Abiron the sons of Eliab, and Hon the son of Pheleth of the children of Ruben, Rose up against Moses, and with them two hundred and fifty others of the children of Israel, leading men of the synagogue, and who in the time of assembly were called by name. And when they had stood up against Moses and Aaron, they said: Let it be enough for you, that all the multitude consisteth of holy ones, and the Lord is among them: Why lift you up yourselves above the people of the Lord?" (Num. 16:1-3)

@TheMoreYouSew 27 дней назад

This was awesome! Your response on the Papacy alone was gold but this was all great!

@apathetiquette 27 дней назад

I wouldn't mind 2-3 hour episodes. I vote for at least more videos in this series. I'm grateful for everything you do. Keep up the good work!

@JudgedInvisible 26 дней назад

Excellent work. More in the series? Yes, please! 😊

@the3rdchief 26 дней назад

Mr. Joe I love you so much! I literally did this yesterday with Chatgpt😭😂

@DAWanamaker 26 дней назад

Joe, I really enjoyed this video. As a marketing professional, I use ChatGPT almost every day. So interesting to see it in this way.

@jimherlihy 26 дней назад

I’m going to listen again Joe, and would be grateful for another 2 plus videos in this series. Thanks for the systematic layout of the information, it’s so helpful to my understanding.

@corygarfield 27 дней назад

i think this is a great idea; would love a pt. 2 to finish off the remaining objections. cheers.

@begelston 26 дней назад

Just a historical note, oral traditions played a significant role in ancient Israel around 30 A.D. functioning as a primary means of transmitting knowledge, cultural values, and religious teachings. Books were scarce and literacy was not as widespread. So it makes perfect sense when Paul states " hold on to the traditions which you were taught, whether by word of mouth or by letter from us", since that is how teachings were commonly conveyed. Eventually, doctrine was codified. Codification of the Biblical canon was instrumental in preserving and formalizing teachings that had been transmitted orally. It also allowed for clearly establishing doctrine so that there is no wiggle room to alter foundational truths and introduce heresy.

@MyVidsJG 26 дней назад

This was a great concept for a video. Creative. By way of suggestion, go the other way. Ask ChatGPT to make arguments for the conversion of a person to Catholicism. AI has known biases (reporting, selection, group attribution, and implicit) because it draws from certain sets of information to respond to questions. What conversion arguments would it draw from to convert, say a Muslim, Protestant, or Buddhist, to Catholicism?

@paulaofchrist 26 дней назад

I absolutely want another video, you just looked SO excited at the beginning of the video, and you should definitely do stuff that you like. I think this Rapid fire style video is great for when I'm washing dishes/cleaning [when I usually listen to apologetics].

@Cato229 27 дней назад

This was fun. It's a good tool to see what arguments have the most currency and a good opportunity to respond.

@OrangeXenon54 27 дней назад

I'd love more videos like this. You so thoroughly break down arguments in easy to understand ways, it all just makes sense.

@sodetsurikomigoshi2454 27 дней назад

also, Scripture isn't the only entity that is "God-breathed". Jesus breathed on the Apostles in the Upper Room before He sent them on the Great Commission. ...without telling anyone to write anything or bring anything written down.

@pmlm1571 26 дней назад

good point!

@douglasdde376 27 дней назад

What a fantastic way to use our gift of the brain, profound, humble, presented with love reinforcing my faith and calling Christ to be his workmanship ! Doug /Ottawa

@TheHumbleConvert 27 дней назад

This was fantastic Joe! You should start a segment called AI Mondays… or Tuesdays lol or a play on TGI Friday… TGIAI 😅 jk but this was unexpectedly very informative and interesting 👏🏽

@rickfilmmaker3934 27 дней назад

Great stuff Joe!! Please do 2 podcasts a week! Thank you!

@JohnThomas-xl2ro 27 дней назад

Love SP

@javierdvm 25 дней назад

You should do one where you push back on it and give it your answers just so it continually tells you “you’re right…”

@deepusnttf432 26 дней назад

Well summarized Joe. Looking for next part. No worries with 1 or 2 hour video.

@powerlessburger 27 дней назад

Joe only loves us as far as $20 confirmed

@danielvidal-garate3554 27 дней назад

😂lol

@clgmafnas 27 дней назад

Lol...Joe is awesome! 👍🏼

@StringofPearls55 27 дней назад

🤭

@jendoe9436 27 дней назад

With inflation on the rise, I feel honored that Joe spent actual money on us 😂

@shamelesspopery 26 дней назад

AT LEAST $20. Some of you even more.

@Gio-ce8ob 26 дней назад

This was a fantastic video! I had low expectations bc I don’t care much for AI. I’d love to see more in this vein.

@samuelnicacio4621 22 дня назад

Joe please know I snorted internally when you said Paul had a road to Demascus moment 😂😂

@BlessedMrs.777 5 дней назад

Thank you for spending so much time on the papacy

@marjoriemiranda-diaz1484 5 дней назад

Yes! Please do the second part of this! You have an interesting way of approaching the topics you choose. I evangelize, and you provide great insight (and sources) for teaching and defending the faith.

@Ladya12345 27 дней назад

Totally worth the wait Joe!

@08frank12 26 дней назад

Yes, please continue with the rest of the content!

@BensWorkshop 27 дней назад

Very interesting. Always useful.

@musicarroll 16 дней назад

Galileo produced some of 😊 his best work while under house arrest.

@fioparkhurst3539 22 дня назад

I enjoyed this video, especially as a refresher.

@BryceCarmony 27 дней назад

Great show thanks Joe

@janeallen9543 26 дней назад

Brilliant thank you and God bless

@charlespagano9636 24 дня назад

Great job, Joe!!

@haydongonzalez-dyer2727 27 дней назад

great video idea

@timboslice980 26 дней назад

It’s not iron clad proof but concerning the greek word “petros” translated as small stone…. Earlier in Matthew during the temptation of christ, satan tells Jesus to transform stones into bread. The greek word used there is Lithoi or Lithos (plural) if Jesus wanted to call simon a small stone, why didn’t he call him Lithoi? Imagine how devastating that would be to the catholic position if the gospel author used Lithoi instead of Petros? The fact that he uses Petros in perspective of Petra, should increase and flip the weight of the argument towards the catholic position. Protestants cannot answer it except to fall back on semantic range and theological predetermination.

@vicenteroque8108 24 дня назад

Good thing it was Cephas and not Petros

@JuanGonzalez-kb3gm 24 дня назад

Sounds good, i was just listening to Jimmy Akin, he was also saying even if Peter was a small stone it means nothing. 1 Corinthians 1:28-30 And God chose the small things, things that people despise. Yes, he chose even the things which seem to be nothing. He did this to destroy the big things. It’s so amazing that after 2000 years the church is still there in Rome, while Caesar is gone. We know nothing of his lineage, yet we still have Peters successors. Peace be with you

@timboslice980 24 дня назад

@@vicenteroque8108 Right well I have to tell you, ive had more than 1 Protestant refuse to consider his Aramaic name. Even though it’s given in scripture! I mean at that point you have to throw up your hands…. No amount of evidence will convince someone like that…..

@paytonschopf5622 27 дней назад

What’s up with the “8 myths about Martin Luther and the reformation” video getting removed because of nikitaventures claiming copyright?

@shamelesspopery 26 дней назад

It's in RU-vid Purgatory. We're hoping that they'll indulge us, because it's quite clearly fair use and not an actual copyright violation. Time will tell.

@MihovilPletikos 26 дней назад

another great show Joe! I have a question for you. I have been working on an approach for defense of perpetual virginity based on biology/medicine. Biology/medicine part is airtight since this is where I am expert in, but I would like to have someone who can take a peek at my theological part. If you could do it, I would be extremely appreciative of that!

@johnmackall8243 26 дней назад

Glad you spent so much time on the papal arguments. This is the entire case for the Catholic church imo. Once you accept the role of the papacy, all other issues will fall into place.

@aaronsmith5904 24 дня назад

This was nice, to try and go through random arguments. A variety, just bringing up the main points. I also like your in depth videos aswell though, they are all thorough and really good. Some have even convinced me of things I knew we had to believe, but I wasn’t too convinced with reasons given. Highlights being your one on how Christ’s death on the cross saves us (talking about Calvinism too). Also your one on Mary’s perpetual virginity. I was completely convinced by that, not only does the bible not contradict the perpetual virginity of Mary, but the most reasonable conclusion from the bible is that Mary WAS a perpetual virgin, by your arguments.

@TheMoreYouSew 27 дней назад

Oooh!

@Quekksilber 27 дней назад

First. :) This comment was AI-generated. Edit: Turns out I was second. What a bummer. This edit was not AI-generated.

@andrewscotteames4718 27 дней назад

You were second 😅😂

@Quekksilber 27 дней назад

@@andrewscotteames4718 The refresh-button made it painfully aware to myself... I corrected the original comment!

@user-jm4kz5bg9f 27 дней назад

The Church came before the New Testament and codified the canon of Old Testament as we know it. The Church Fathers, specifically the Apostolic ones, continued their tradition. To look at them and the New and Old Testaments through Catholic eyes, it all makes logical congruent sense. Through protestant or even Orthodox lens, they seem schizophrenic.

@nicbentulan 22 дня назад

Israel IS Jesus. Why turn off comments in Israel vs Palestine video? Im appalled how Christians like Joe Biden & Pope Francis (jesuits & democrats are liberals right?) don't fully support Israel's completely justified war.. Why? What do you think of this? Are they like Peter, JVP like Judas, Israel like Jesus & Hamas like Romans/some Jewish leaders? Why are regions w/ more Jews better than countries w/ less? Eg Russia vs Ukraine. Eg Gaza vs West Bank. Eg Taiwan vs china. Eg Hong Kong vs Macau. Eg US UK Australia Japan vs Norway Iran Iraq North Korea. Parallel : Jesus = Israel (magnanimous Jew) - Judas = Jewish anti-Zionists (big traitor) - Peter = democrats, liberals, Catholic church (little traitor) - (??) = republicans, conservatives - Romans & some Jewish leaders = Hamas (enemy of magnanimous Jew) - Humanity = Palestinians & free world (recipient of salvation of magnanimous Jew) - Grace = Leaflets, aid, corridors, field hospitals (the salvation offered by the Jew) - Matthew 5:11 = idk what's the analogue in the old testament / tanakh ? Why do 20yo conscripted Jewish soldiers die while hundreds of thousands of Palestinians live from Israel's leaflets? Joe said it's coherent to say Israel is defending itself. So I suppose Jesus' crucifixion was defending Himself? Zionists are fooled by Hamas propaganda! Quote 1- Gazan 🇵🇸 to IDF 🇮🇱: 'We must take down the heads of Hamas. Don't leave this place! People are stupid and do not understand anything. What are we to do with all of this? This is all because of Sinwar and Haniyeh. Haniyeh eats at restaurants in Turkey. And Sinwar eats hidden underground. They eat meat while we eat bullets.' - Source : kfsPPvA8nLE Quote 2- "HAMAS is killing my people. (...) Most Gazans are against Hamas."-Jordanian -Palestinian Mudar Zahran. - Source : O7Go9af9koY Why don't we just show this to every university? Gazans don't want ceasefire! Israeli PR shot itself in the foot in my opinion by insisting 'most Palestinians support Hamas.' Don't interrupt your opponent when they're making a mistake. - If the pro-Palestine/anti-Israel say most hate Hamas, then Israel won't murder civilians since the civilians are allies of Israel.

@margaritoceja 14 дней назад

Unwritten tradition is written, so I hear

@margaritoceja 14 дней назад

To protestants, Martin Luther was the first Pope then...now James White and for how long.

@ianmiller07 27 дней назад

Joe, Have you ever thought about responding more to Tim Kauffman? PS excited for this video

@shamelesspopery 27 дней назад

It's hard to gauge from the outside how popular or relevant Kauffman is. He certainly makes a lot of questionable (and even outright false) claims, but I'm just not sure how many people are reading him and coming away persuaded by the things he's saying.

@ianmiller07 27 дней назад

@@shamelesspopery Thanks for the reply! That's fair. Personally, I found him on Twitter first (where he has a small but I think growing following) and then visited his blog and read through what he claims, which, I must admit, is very interesting. I think most understand his claims are contrary to nearly every sinlge patristic scholar but don't actively have the knowledge to rebut his arguments and he also willingly admits that he contradicts the scholars. I also haven't seen much efforts to interact with him which could contribute to more questions for people. With that said, I think it may be helpful to engage some of his claims. Although, I understand why you may not want to. Appreciate all the work you do! Blessings

@nicbentulan 22 дня назад

@@shamelesspoperyhow about respond to pope Francis & Joe Biden? Israel IS Jesus. Why turn off comments in Israel vs Palestine video? Im appalled how Christians like Joe Biden & Pope Francis (jesuits & democrats are liberals right?) don't fully support Israel's completely justified war.. Why? What do you think of this? Are they like Peter, JVP like Judas, Israel like Jesus & Hamas like Romans/some Jewish leaders? Why are regions w/ more Jews better than countries w/ less? Eg Russia vs Ukraine. Eg Gaza vs West Bank. Eg Taiwan vs china. Eg Hong Kong vs Macau. Eg US UK Australia Japan vs Norway Iran Iraq North Korea. Parallel : Jesus = Israel (magnanimous Jew) - Judas = Jewish anti-Zionists (big traitor) - Peter = democrats, liberals, Catholic church (little traitor) - (??) = republicans, conservatives - Romans & some Jewish leaders = Hamas (enemy of magnanimous Jew) - Humanity = Palestinians & free world (recipient of salvation of magnanimous Jew) - Grace = Leaflets, aid, corridors, field hospitals (the salvation offered by the Jew) - Matthew 5:11 = idk what's the analogue in the old testament / tanakh ? Why do 20yo conscripted Jewish soldiers die while hundreds of thousands of Palestinians live from Israel's leaflets? Joe said it's coherent to say Israel is defending itself. So I suppose Jesus' crucifixion was defending Himself? Zionists are fooled by Hamas propaganda! Quote 1- Gazan 🇵🇸 to IDF 🇮🇱: 'We must take down the heads of Hamas. Don't leave this place! People are stupid and do not understand anything. What are we to do with all of this? This is all because of Sinwar and Haniyeh. Haniyeh eats at restaurants in Turkey. And Sinwar eats hidden underground. They eat meat while we eat bullets.' - Source : kfsPPvA8nLE Quote 2- "HAMAS is killing my people. (...) Most Gazans are against Hamas."-Jordanian -Palestinian Mudar Zahran. - Source : O7Go9af9koY Why don't we just show this to every university? Gazans don't want ceasefire! Israeli PR shot itself in the foot in my opinion by insisting 'most Palestinians support Hamas.' Don't interrupt your opponent when they're making a mistake. - If the pro-Palestine/anti-Israel say most hate Hamas, then Israel won't murder civilians since the civilians are allies of Israel.

@sebastianfragoso5802 27 дней назад

Hey Joe, I have a question based on the Church’s teach on marriage and the videos you did a couple weeks back. Would it be theologically sound to say that the Women in Revelation 12 has to be Mary because the queen mother came in the role as advocate for the people and Mary being one with the Holy Spirit fulfills the promise of an Advocate in the New Kingdom God? I thought the question would’ve been easier to word

@alonsoACR 27 дней назад

Hello, I'm not Joe. I just want to point out, you did indeed lay out a very simple argument. However, I fear that you're referencing some Scripture verses and prophecies that are not well known outside some Catholic groups. Most Protestants won't know what you're talking about regarding a Queen Mother, being one with the Holy Spirit, or the Advocate to Christ. As a rule of thumb, if you're ever discussing with a Protestant, and you feel a quote of the Old Testament may prove decisive, lay out the verses clearly and explain them. Most Protestants I've met (even the very well read ones) have never truly gone through the Old Testament except MAYBE the Psalms and a bit of Genesis. I've seen some of their pocket edition Bibles only include the New Testament, which is crazy, as Christendom has always held (since the Early Church Fathers) that any deeper view in the New requires an even deeper view in the Old. For reference, see Joe's video on the Three Kings of Bethlehem, and how he had to spend a LOT of time laying out the OT (and the accompanying worldview). If you've never read the Old and all you have is the NT and a rough map of 1st century Middle East, you'll find that calling them Kings is baffling, obviously wrong, and unbiblical. But it isn't. Applied to your comment, you'll find that your argument, applied to the average Christian, will necessitate much more elaboration. God bless you and keep you.

@grond21 26 дней назад

I believe that is a very common understanding

@scrapdog2113 27 дней назад

What happened to the video that yall posted earlier today? Just curious

@shamelesspopery 27 дней назад

It's in RU-vid purgatory, bc it was hit with a couple of automated copyright claims. We're clearly quoting snippets of the videos in order to present and critique them, and so it should be a straightforward case of "fair use," but we've got to go through the official process. In the meantime, this!

@scrapdog2113 27 дней назад

@@shamelesspopery Ah okay, that’s unfortunate. But it’s very good of y’all to still put a video out today!! :) Great work and God bless

@gloriarodriguez3721 27 дней назад

Just saying the $20 a month is super worth to me especially the illustration feature

@shamelesspopery 26 дней назад

I'm totally green. What are some ways that I should be using it to get the most out of it?

@gloriarodriguez3721 26 дней назад

@@shamelesspopery look up "The Prompt engineering" videos by Vanderbilt University free on RU-vid. By learning those specific prompt engineering techniques you can maximize what you can achieve with ChatGTP. Also search Jules White Prompt engineering (He is with Vanderbilt University and my sister's boss she is a Generative AI Engineer) Jules White Champions AI not as a replacement for humans but as an enhancer to allow for more efficient and thought out work and task management. ChatGTP can help with social media posts, excel spreadsheets, ideas, giving feedback on workflows and processes. and more. Also it can now keep a memory of conversations and details contained within different chats.

@sclg560 18 дней назад

I like your shirt

@gamefan8552 27 дней назад

AI is the infallible interpreter of Scripture.

@user-kh9lq4mb9f 27 дней назад

Here is the Historical truth. Not misleading use of the Bible In 313 CE, the emperor Constantine issued the Edict of Milan, which granted Christianity-as well as most other religions-legal status. While this was an important development in the history of Christianity, it was not a total replacement of traditional Roman beliefs with Christianity. In 325, Constantine called the Council of Nicaea, which was a gathering of Christian leaders to determine the formal-or orthodox-beliefs of Christianity. The result of this council was the Nicene Creed, which laid out the agreed upon beliefs of the council. In 380 CE, the emperor Theodosius issued the Edict of Thessalonica, which made Christianity, specifically Nicene Christianity, the official religion of the Roman Empire. Most other Christian sects were deemed heretical, lost their legal status, and had their properties confiscated by the Roman state.

@user-kh9lq4mb9f 27 дней назад

Religious historians and scholars often define Nicene Christianity as being the first incarnation of the state church of the Roman Empire that was officially endorsed by the Roman Emperors from 381. In the 900s and early 1000s, the choice was really that of the emperor: He chooses the pope and the clergy does the rubber stamping. The decision was made in 1059 to take the clergy of Rome out of the system and have the chief bishops of Italy do the choosing, primarily as a way of reducing the Holy Roman emperor's influence.

@canibezeroun1988 27 дней назад

I actually have a query saved that I call the Christian Choir to compare the different traditions. "Not necessarily" is sprinkled in everywhere haha.

@Vulkihn 23 дня назад

Hello Joe. Was doing some thinking and I believe you should do a video on why Jesus was NOT Muslim. It’s a pretty heavily debated topic, and Muslims have many ridiculous claims about it. I’m curious to hear what you have to say. God bless you.

@NewNostalgia 26 дней назад

To stupid youtube: I do not use an ad blocker!

@TobiasJoe85 26 дней назад

I was hoping you'd interact with it a little more like Alex OConner did.

@Pablo-gl9dj 5 дней назад

The papacy is a finely spun bit of nonsense.

@RobbsFamily 27 дней назад

Where in the Psalms does it say that God or Christ will ascend into heaven with the Ark? I'd really like to add this to my discussions.

@undyne4032 27 дней назад

Psalm 132, 8 Arise, O Lord, and go to your resting place, you and the ark of your might.

@RobbsFamily 26 дней назад

@@undyne4032 thank you for this. But I can see my friends arguing that this isn't about Jesus' Ascension but just about God and the Ark ar the time it was written. I'll do some more research I'm trying to figure out how to build this into the argument

@JB91484 26 дней назад

@@RobbsFamily Jesus is God. Father, Son, Holy Spirit. Triune God. The Lord God. The apostles called Jesus Lord. Hope that helps.

@alonsovm2880 26 дней назад

@@undyne4032 its a type. Yes the author is talking about his contemporary context, but if someone is minimally christian they would recognize scripture to be inspired and without error. God can use this to prophetically portray future events even in the psalms. Christ himself quoted psalm 22 while crucified. Study types and make a list of their new testament / church equivalents.

@carlosux 20 дней назад

the google one is better at defending Catholicism

@glennlanham6309 26 дней назад

Ain't working

@richardjackson7887 25 дней назад

That's because ChatGPT-4o does not realize that vessels the potter made for wrath cannot help but fulfill their destination just like Pharaoh when God hardened his heart also. Pharaoh was shameless also!! Romans 9:17-23 KJV For the scripture saith unto Pharaoh, Even for this same purpose have I raised thee up, that I might shew my power in thee, and that my name might be declared throughout all the earth. 18. Therefore hath he mercy on whom he will have mercy, and whom he will he hardeneth. 19. Thou wilt say then unto me, Why doth he yet find fault? For who hath resisted his will? 20. Nay but, O man, who art thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, Why hast thou made me thus? 21. Hath not the potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honour, and another unto dishonour? 22. What if God, willing to shew his wrath, and to make his power known, endured with much longsuffering the vessels of wrath fitted to destruction: 23. And that he might make known the riches of his glory on the vessels of mercy, which he had afore prepared unto glory,

@GizmoFromPizmo 27 дней назад

Somewhat off-topic but I'll just give my experience. I was raised Catholic and then in my late teens, I converted to Christianity. I was baptized for the remission of my sins in a swimming pool at around 1:00 in the morning by a guy who knew the bible very well. I lasted maybe 10--years then I backslid. I fell away for about 20-years then, after completely messing up my life, I came begging for my old job back (so to speak). The first time I was saved, the only tools I had were the bible itself, some concordances, a bible dictionary, and some commentaries. I also had tools like a Greek/English interlinear, which is helpful. But that was it. When I got saved again, the internet was a thing. Now I had search engines and my bible proficiency shifted into high gear. I can see A.I. causing another explosion in bible knowledge. Just like the search engine was more useful than all the concordances ever written, A.I. will probably make bad preachers good. I mean, I've heard some pretty lame sermons in my day but if these same guys had a tool like A.I., their sermons might be more consistent with the word of God. A.I. is a tool. As long as it's used in pursuit of God, it will bear fruit but if all you're doing with it is to justify your own lame denomination then it will not serve you well. I mean, "Why should I be a Baptist?" is bad question. Ask a bad question and you'll get a bad answer. But asking, "How does the blood of Jesus Christ cleanse me from my sins?" That might produce some good observations that you'd never considered before.

@Anonymousduck161 27 дней назад

Catholics are Christians. You can’t “convert to Christianity” away from Catholicism. You can only leave the Church. I hate when prots try to make this false distinction. Also, if you were raised Catholic, you were already baptized and therefore committed a grave sin in getting rebaptized.

@GizmoFromPizmo 24 дня назад

That's bogus, man. You can't say, "My denomination is right and if you think it's wrong (without regard to your reasons) then that just shows how wrong YOU are." That's at LEAST circular reasoning. It's very disingenuous. Catholicism has SERIOUS doctrinal issues that aren't healed by the decree, "I'm right because I say so!" That doesn't make the problems go away except in the minds of the smoothest brained individual. The bible commends folks who "search the scriptures daily" to check on the doctrine of even the apostles themselves (see Acts 17:11). The bible tells us repeatedly that it is the final authority on all matters of the faith. Inserting some other authority contradicts that final authority. I mean, if the apostles and prophets were telling truth in the first century then what makes their doctrine false today?

@nicbentulan 22 дня назад

Never mind that. Pope Francis said Israel committed an act of terrorism. Israel IS Jesus. Why turn off comments in Israel vs Palestine video? Im appalled how Christians like Joe Biden & Pope Francis (jesuits & democrats are liberals right?) don't fully support Israel's completely justified war.. Why? What do you think of this? Are they like Peter, JVP like Judas, Israel like Jesus & Hamas like Romans/some Jewish leaders? Why are regions w/ more Jews better than countries w/ less? Eg Russia vs Ukraine. Eg Gaza vs West Bank. Eg Taiwan vs china. Eg Hong Kong vs Macau. Eg US UK Australia Japan vs Norway Iran Iraq North Korea. Parallel : Jesus = Israel (magnanimous Jew) - Judas = Jewish anti-Zionists (big traitor) - Peter = democrats, liberals, Catholic church (little traitor) - (??) = republicans, conservatives - Romans & some Jewish leaders = Hamas (enemy of magnanimous Jew) - Humanity = Palestinians & free world (recipient of salvation of magnanimous Jew) - Grace = Leaflets, aid, corridors, field hospitals (the salvation offered by the Jew) - Matthew 5:11 = idk what's the analogue in the old testament / tanakh ? Why do 20yo conscripted Jewish soldiers die while hundreds of thousands of Palestinians live from Israel's leaflets? Joe said it's coherent to say Israel is defending itself. So I suppose Jesus' crucifixion was defending Himself? Zionists are fooled by Hamas propaganda! Quote 1- Gazan 🇵🇸 to IDF 🇮🇱: 'We must take down the heads of Hamas. Don't leave this place! People are stupid and do not understand anything. What are we to do with all of this? This is all because of Sinwar and Haniyeh. Haniyeh eats at restaurants in Turkey. And Sinwar eats hidden underground. They eat meat while we eat bullets.' - Source : kfsPPvA8nLE Quote 2- "HAMAS is killing my people. (...) Most Gazans are against Hamas."-Jordanian -Palestinian Mudar Zahran. - Source : O7Go9af9koY Why don't we just show this to every university? Gazans don't want ceasefire! Israeli PR shot itself in the foot in my opinion by insisting 'most Palestinians support Hamas.' Don't interrupt your opponent when they're making a mistake. - If the pro-Palestine/anti-Israel say most hate Hamas, then Israel won't murder civilians since the civilians are allies of Israel.