Corgeut V Pagani Design MOONWATCH Homage BATTLE 

Hi guys, hope you're having a great weekend and thanks for watching! If you want to vote for your favourite watch of the two, here's a link to my community page ru-vid.comcommunity Cheers!

Nice comparison. But I want to add something to this- The Corgeut case resembles the case of the first Omega Speedmasters (i.e 105.012) that did not have the push buttons and crown protection, hence, it was a Symmetrical case, but after NASA told Omega they would like to have protections, Omega agreed and that is reflected in the actual Omega models and in the Pagani. Another thing is the Chronograph Seconds hand. The Corgeut is using the hand that Omega used from 1972 to 2009, while the Pagani is using the hand that is in actual use by the 3861 model. Then third, the sub-dials of the Pagani are more accurate that the Corgeut in the markings. But both have the minute subdivisions in the minute track that are actually used by the new 3861. Just a personal comment- With all the advanced technology, I wonder why Seiko (the maker of the VK63 movement), Citizen, ETA, Ronda, and others, have not make a Quartz-MecaQuartz movement that truly imitates the original the mechanical three sub-dial movements of past times, like the 1863, the Valjoux 7736, etc. Instead, they make add a 26-hr dial, when none of these classic models had- (except for some late automatic movements like the Lemania 5100 and 1341). I would really like to have one homage watch with those dials and functions.........

In my perception the Corgeut doesn't have a chance. Main reasons are the mineral crystal and even worse the bracelet with fully polished middle links. Excellent idea to include the community vote Al! 👍

Pagani have knocked it out of the park with their V3 designs and the quality is excellent lately, giving them the best value for money out there imho.

I have the Corgeut and absolutely love it! FANTASTIC value and looks great, wears even better. I bought mine in May 2021 for $53 USD.

Having watched it, on balance the PD looks better, I was hoping it would be the Corgeut, but the mineral glass vs the sapphire is a big factor. And the slightly better lume on the PD too.

I love these head to head battles. Another great vid! 😎

A pal of mine has a real Speedy, i have the pagani featured, my friend was impressed how closely it looked and felt to his Omega.

The Corguet speedy was my first purchase, I believe v2 with the more accurate bezel thickness, I really enjoy it on a tan leather strap, i thought it had a saphire crystal but I managed to scrstch it, so maybe it is hard mineral like the v1. I really like how thin it is, wears very comfortably, and being quartz is accurate and doesn't require any effort, just set and forget. Great watch and a great value foe the price point. My only real gripe is the symmetric case, the pushers appear accurate, but look odd hanging out in space, where the asymmetric case of the omega should be acting like a crown guard changing the proportion and look of the pushers and crown. Minor gripes include minimal tick marks on subdials making accrate timed measurement a little iffy; also the dial coloration and texture, I like it but compared to the PD v3 its a little low contrast and less legible. I purchased a Pegani Design speedy to compare when the white hand version 3 came out. It quickly became my everday watch. The dial is a deep black providing striking contrast and legibility, the asymmetric case provides correct case proportions, the subdials are deep with concentric circle texture providing a slight sunburst reflection, I wear it on a dark deep red leather strap and it looks amazing, the lume is ok, but exceeded expectation for a speedy homage, and while dim, does last a long time providing viable time reading in total darkness. The dial proportion in relation to the bezel is key to matching the beauty of the Omega Speedmaster, the Corguet comes closer but unfortunately has the unguarded spindly pushers sticking out of the symmetrical case like antennae. The Pagani's asymmetrical case and thinner case side are much more accurate, but something about the way the light reflects off the sidewall/rim of the slightly domed saphire crystal causes the dial too look slightly smaller than it is, and the bezel to look slighlty wider, which in my opinion changes the visual proportions enough that it looses that unique speedmaster look. Its still beautiful and very similar to a speedmaster, but without that key proportion being accurate it looks like something new and unique but not exactly a speedmaster, despite the presence of so many identical elements. I still love it though, and find it superior to the Corguet, though I love that one too. They both have thier own pluses and minusee. If one could combine the elements that each offering gets right, it would be the perfect homage.

Before I watch this, I want to say thanks. I've really been wondering about which one of these to go for! Now to watch the show.

Not sure exactly why but the Corgeot just looks like a classic while the PG doesn't quite capture the vibe of the Moon watch. It could be that crystal. That being said my PG Daytona homage is my grab and go watch when I don't have time to set the day date on the Ray2. It seldom happens as that Orion has been getting around 80% of the available wrist time since I replaced the lightly scratched miniral with Sapphire and turned it into a almost Kamasu almost a year ago.

This "mecquartz" from Seiko is know for the accuracy and reliability. I´ve seen owners given testemonies of its accuracy. Something 15 seconds a month. One specific user, after 1 year of ownership, said that accuracy is

I hesitated between the Corgeut, PD and the Phylida. The latter was automatic I think but I wanted it with the ST19 manual wind movement. I rejected it because of the higher price range. Finally I decided to buy the PD, but it was the V2 and when it arrived I almost instantly regretted my choice. It had black date wheel but the indicies were silver. It looked good but I wanted the white hands. When V3 came out I bought one and it looked way better! I could easily sell the PD V2 because it's a nice looking watch, just isn't a true homage. I vote for the PD. Imho it's a more complete package.

I have the Pagani. I just wish they applied an AR coating. The sapphire crystal is so reflective it makes the whole thing look kinda cheap. Yeah I know it's so low-priced already but I'm sure most people would gladly pay a bit more for AR coating.

These sort of comparisons are flawed.. it assumes each category has equal weighting. Some aspects are more important than others, I’d rather a better rating for movement and crystal than brand or bracelet

PD-1701 looks great Moonwatch.

Awesome comparison Al definitely both have pros and cons just like every other watches in game

I have both, the Pagani for me is better but not vastly I swapped the bracelet on the Corgeut as it's not great but the price of the Corgeut is fantastic value always interesting content

I think the Corgeut is more of an homage to the FOIS whereas the PD looks more like the Professional. All in all the PD is the better watch but I like the retro look of the Corgeut more.

My Corgeut has a thinner bezel, much like the PD. I ordered it with a NATO, and I love it. The hands line up almost perfectly, much better than a Seiko I purchased...

I had Pagani Design by 11 points myself

I purchased the corguet, with the blue face. The legibility of the face versus the speedy black and white hands; latter wins. No issue to speak of with movement +, where the difference between wearing frequently, and not.

Good review, ordered the PD......

Loving my PD Speedy! 100m WR and date makes this a fantastic grab n go daily banger!

Why no get both? Haha 😄 Both seem to offer a good value for what you're getting. Each one is different enough from the other that getting both wouldn't be buying the same watch twice. My two cents. Great comparison. Cheers!

Great evaluation

If you want the Speedy Pro look, I think PD is the better watch.

I just got this PD Speedy and the PD Daytona yesterday... very nice pieces. I couldn't decide, so I just got them both. Still saved something like 15 grand. 😂

I would like to add an accuracy test segment. How did they keep track of time after a day or two or a week?

Hi I have both plus a white one and also a nother one by ormish all work well I have two many watches but it's great fun.

Hello and great content, one question though, can you swap the bracelets?

I vote for Pagani, this watch is worth every penny.

i think pagani looks better its a larger watch and the Corgeot looks much bulkier. Imo the bracelet of the Pagani is unwearable out of the box i would give it lower points. You need to polish it on your own with sandpaper or get a 3rd party bracelt. It's simply too uncomfortable to wear if you're used to other metal bracelets that have been polished.

corgeut looks odd as the bezel it completely wrong. in my opinion the best speedy homage is the phylida st1901, the build quality and finish on mine is outstanding for the price. spend the extra and get something much better is my advise.

What is the difference between the pagani pd-1664 and 1701

If either one uses acrylic instead of mineral/sapphire and goes 38mm in diameter, thats already a clear winner..

So I watched this very interesting video through and followed the link to vote only to be told that the voting facility isn’t.available on my device - an ipad. Really? Come on youtube, get real and support these contributors that do all the work and you just feed off!

PD for the win 🏆

Corgeut is better, the whole point is the dome glas.

Corgeut looks like a toy watch, bezel looks to big...

Pagani wins hands down for me

Both watches are 40mm aka not usable for me. I would take them for a test if they were 38mm.

The Corguet case is better proportioned.

The Corgeut seems like it is an homage to the Pagani. Way more value for money in the Pagani.

I own both and I prefer the my Corgeut . I own 7 Pagani's inc a black and grey dial PD-1701 and have had really major QC issues with 4 of them. Pagani's ability to deal with QC issues really suck and they are abysmal. They try to ignore you in the hope that you will go away and I've had to resort to involving Aliexpress to mediate, who have found in my favour every time and have issued me with a refund (usually 50% of the cost) .....If you buy Pagani then 'Caveat Emptor'

At first glance the Corgeut looks cheap and not accurate in comparison to the real Omega. The Pagani Design comes much closer in accuracy and proportions to the original. And the bracelet is just not the correct one on the Corgeut. Huge fail. So PD wins.

Corgeut should also lose points from having a brand that sounds French. But seriously, it looks and reads like garbage next to that Pagani Design. The viewer who said it's still better is on crack.

Pagani looks better