Dumbledore Is Socrates | Harry Potter Theory

Подписаться 2,2 млн

Просмотров 240 тыс.

50% 1

Head on over to hellotushy.com/SUPER to get 10% off!
Today J dives into the Wizarding World of Harry Potter to discuss Dumbledores unusual teaching methods and how he utilizes the Socratic Method and the Socratic Paradox
#HarryPotter #SCBSpiritWeek
Carlin Brothers Coffee ►► www.CarlinBrothersCoffee.com
Super Carlin Brothers Merch ►► www.SuperCarlinBrothers.Store
J vs Ben ►► bit.ly/2I5xHee
Harry Potter Theories ►► bit.ly/2K2Rtru
Super Carlin Gaming ►► bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
BECOME A SUPER CARLIN FRIEND➜ / supercarlinbrothers
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
FOLLOW US:
P A T R E O N ➜ / supercarlinbrothers
J's V L O G➜ / jonathancarlin
T W I T T E R➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
I N S T A G R A M➜ / jonkerlin & / scb_ben
F A C E B O O K➜ / supercarlinbrothers
G A M I N G ➜ bit.ly/1CRM5Bq
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Want to send us something?
Super Carlin Brothers
PO Box 4339
Roanoke, Virginia 24015
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Business Inquiries Only: carlinbrosrtp@gmail.com
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Intro Music Created by RKVC
/ @rkvc
Intro Animation Created by J. Cutt Productions
/ @j.cuttproductions
Every time you give us a thumbs up a Narwhal gets its horn! (maybe..)

Кино

Опубликовано:

17 май 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 799

@SuperCarlinBrothers 3 года назад

Just wanted to post a big THANK YOU to everyone who is participating in SCB Spirit Week, it has been honestly so heartwarming seeing your posts everyday - You guys are seriously awesome and the best audience in the world!

@DoctorSprout 3 года назад

The best audience for the best content creators

@slevinchannel7589 3 года назад

Not enough Theorys.

@GRC_grayson 3 года назад

Thanks, trust me I’ll participate I’m just waiting till Star Wars day and Disney/Pixar day and formal Friday 🖖😃😂❤️

@gellertgrindelwald2921 3 года назад

But why ?

@GRC_grayson 3 года назад

@@gellertgrindelwald2921 me? I don’t understand

@Avenger19111 3 года назад

"Did you put your name into the Goblet of Fire? " - Socrates

@meaganbailey5672 3 года назад

"DIDJA PUT YOUR NAME IN THE GOBLET OF FIYAHHH?" Socrates asked calmly

@arieldanielle7858 3 года назад

Really it would be "Why did you put your name in the Goblet of Fire" because the socratic method

@AmaraJordanMusic 3 года назад

He asked ~CALMLY~

@tuddthetotodile5448 3 года назад

Slamscharry into a wall

@flumpyofdoom 3 года назад

@@meaganbailey5672 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

@everettburdett1702 3 года назад

"give a man a plane ticket and he flies for a night. throw a man off a plane, and he flies for the rest of his life."

@NobodyWhatsoever 3 года назад

I like this one, too: Build a man a fire, and he's warm for the night. Set the man on fire, and he's warm for the rest of his life.

@balrighty3523 3 года назад

Ah, you beat me to it. Very well then; I shall share the wisdom of Belkar Bitterleaf instead: Solve a man's problems with violence and you help him today. Teach a man to solve his own problems with violence and you help him for the rest of his life.

@riduanaqil1452 3 года назад

Omg lol

@OriginalPiMan 3 года назад

@@NobodyWhatsoever I usually hear that one phrased as "give a man a match and he is warm for a moment".

@meaganbailey5672 3 года назад

@@OriginalPiMan The "light a man a fire/on fire" one is a quote from a Terry Pratchett book, pretty sure it was from Night Watch

@Windja69 3 года назад

“Ooooo and the ball has a riddle on it? And the answer: die. cool” is probably the best line in the video

@graylewis7551 3 года назад

ETERNALLY dying over this quote

@sludgy5134 3 года назад

If Dumbledore = Death and Dumbledore = Socrates , Socrates = death

@SuperCarlinBrothers 3 года назад

You may be on to something...

@MagicsJohnson 3 года назад

Ahhh...reminds me of learning about logic in my intro to philosophy class lolol

@lindamazule2289 3 года назад

The philosophical way to think about Socrates and Dumbledore's way they lived their lives is, "yeah, they tought us some lessons even after death"... Wich, I think, is the best feeling ever - to know, that even after you dissapear from this world, your lessons will be usefull after many, many years ...

@krishmajumder1411 3 года назад

@@SuperCarlinBrothers if Harry = death and death = Dumbledore and Dumbledore = Socrates does that mean Harry = Socrates? Or Harry = Dumbledore?

@windhelmguard5295 3 года назад

if dumbledore is socrates, does that make hagrid diogenes?

@shane7778 3 года назад

The real reason Ben hides the honey: So Luke doesn’t put it in his hair. Such a great uncle!

@tega6278 3 года назад

The real unsung hero

@AmaraJordanMusic 3 года назад

I love this. 🤣

@SierraMascara28 3 года назад

Video idea: can you do a character analysis on Barty Crouch Jr the year he was at Hogwarts? For example, why suggest to Harry to become an auror? How did he teach so well? Sometimes it just seemed like he liked Harry. I know it was probably just great acting, but how was he sooo good at it that he fooled even Dumbledore?

@fuzzyapple 3 года назад

I can give some insight into this. The suggestion that harry should become an auror was kind of an ironic joke I guess, since jr didn't expect him to survive that year. He did teach in an unconventional way which was off the books and hands on. This of course connected well with the students, but he taught this way cause that's how he experienced it himself. Effective, but problematic from an educational standpoint. And to fooling dumbledore: most of that is just great skill. Jr couldn't have had a lot of time to adapt the mannerisms of moody, but he did it perfectly. And he was really offensive, which could only work because dumbledore knew something was f'ed up that year and jr smoothly led dumbledores attention everywhere else. You have to keep in mind that moody was one of the most skilled aurors with such an intense paranoia that even dumbledore trusted, that nobody could've replaced a calibre like moody without making a fuss. Put an ex death eater aka karkaroff into the mix and tadaa you have the perfect diversion.

@shane7778 3 года назад

@@fuzzyapple but why

@Evaristo.Fernandes 3 года назад

He taught so well because he kept asking real Moody i think

@simplyskrypt3914 Год назад

@@Evaristo.Fernandes yeah im guessing a mix of torturing him by starvation, veritaserum and the imperius curse forced the real moody to give barty jr whatever info he needed

@tcbrison6592 3 года назад

If someone makes a “Think, Mark” meme with dumbledore and harry, please send it to me. I need it.

@the_jdb3351 3 года назад

DIDJAHPUTYANAMEINTHAGOBLETOFFIAH

@liambecker558 3 года назад

You beat me to this comment

@somenerdpng 3 года назад

Look it up, already exists for sure

@_Harry_Potter 3 года назад

@@the_jdb3351 Dumbledore yelled calmly

@IBeenOnHots 3 года назад

@@_Harry_Potter in the book. Some people only know the fine details of the movies

@THEO00900 3 года назад

Fun fact: Socrates method is also called midwife's method as Socrates mother's job was midwife and as she helped women birth babies, Socrates considered himself help people birth ideas and the Truth.

@aumathewarriormouse2549 3 года назад

All this ancient Greek stuff and we're not gonna talk about how Marvolo's ring is really the mythic ring of Gyges and Dumbledore fails the test of the ring? 🤔

@ovni2295 3 года назад

And yet Galadriel passed the test and will diminish and remain Galadriel and go into the West!

@swayambhupanigrahi296 3 года назад

@@ovni2295 I see you are a person of culture

@sit-insforsithis1568 3 года назад

No “we” aren’t going to talk about that,

@rsb2040 3 года назад

I’m so early that Dudley still 36 presents

@chaddusgeneralpythor8665 3 года назад

well i’m from last year and he has 37

@jasminesolo-granger5940 3 года назад

SOILER ALERT (:

@randoml97 3 года назад

As someone who's taken lot's of classes on teaching and is about to go into my student teaching, I would like it to be known that this is actually a VERY valid teaching method. Like we are very much encouraged to "lead" students to the information instead of just telling them stuff. Dumbledore is a good teacher🤣🤣

@elainegoates9792 3 года назад

Who uses this method with the world and all of his students at risk.

@babylonfuc 3 года назад

respectfully the information you are leading students to is not as important as the information that harry needs to save the world

@addisonmay23 3 года назад

@@elainegoates9792 🤣 yeah, the science is pretty conclusive that explicit instruction works for most students, whereas this implicit style works for like 30% of students. I know what method I’m using.

@fogell_mclovin8252 2 года назад

@@babylonfuc If he had given all the information to harry, Voldemort would read his mind. The plan would be ruined. If he told harry he would survive the confrontation, harry would die. He needs to believe that he would die in order for him to survive and given everybody else the love protection.

@stormhealer3443 3 года назад

"Because your hair is messy. - Because you put honey in it. - I don´t know why! - You tell me, son!!!" I am dying xD

@MarkBonneaux 3 года назад

Trust me, this comes from experience. Maybe not with honey, but with something

@jeremytung1632 3 года назад

You can tell this happened at least once.

@eleanor_n_ 2 года назад

Maybe this is the reason why Ben hides the honey 🤔

@YingwuUsagiri 3 года назад

It's called self discovery and it's one of the most interesting mental intricacies of the human mind. When someone explains something to you the retention rate is very low, however when you figure it out yourself (or think you did by coaxing) your brain is so pleased with itself that it hardly ever forgets that it did and then it sticks. It's like a positive to the ego of your psyche, remember that thing I thought of myself? Sure do!

@AmaraJordanMusic 3 года назад

I love how the brain learns things in different ways. You retain more writing notes by hand than typing, for example. Or if you learn it in a way that you’ll be able to explain and teach it to someone else, your retention rates go way up. It’s so interesting to me!

@YingwuUsagiri 3 года назад

@@AmaraJordanMusic Yeah it's fascinating. I personally also love the four degrees of knowledge. 4th = No knowledge at all, 3rd = Assisted knowledge (with someone else or a guide), 2nd = Routine knowledge (with the help of having the subject matter in front of you) and 1st degree of knowledge = Blind knowledge, being able to guide someone else through a problem like a helpdesk would without even needing to see the subject matter they are talking about. We were learned that to be able to teach someone else you yourself need at least a 2nd degree of knowledge of what you're making a tutorial/guide or lesson about.

@PibbDFanta 3 года назад

@@YingwuUsagiri then I have first degree knowledge of One Piece lol

@michaelkelleypoetry 3 года назад

“Give a man a fish and you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish… Don’t teach a man to fish. He’s a grown man, fishings not that hard.” -Ron Swanson.

@windhelmguard5295 3 года назад

teach a man to fish, feed him for a lifetime. sell a man your fish, feed yourself for a lifetime.

@noorykorky5056 3 года назад

LOL.... 😂😂😂😂😂

@sand747 3 года назад

@@windhelmguard5295 fantastic

@jots2493 3 года назад

@@windhelmguard5295 dont teach a man to fish. He will destroy the ecosystem

@rfl8359 3 года назад

@@jots2493 teach a man to fish with moderation then we can coexist with nature

@lindamazule2289 3 года назад

Gosh, I just realised that the way my father tought me and the way I teach my siblings and kids is totally Socratus/Dumbledore way...

@tommygately8461 3 года назад

Bruh, same!

@thebluepineapple684 3 года назад

*taught

@reaceainsworth3506 3 года назад

@@thebluepineapple684 should've put 'tought' think Linda, think!

@lindamazule2289 3 года назад

@@reaceainsworth3506 I am from Latvia so sorry if my grammar is sometimes incorrect..

@reaceainsworth3506 3 года назад

@@lindamazule2289 I'm just playing and don't worry, I'm English and still struggle

@casparjackson4075 3 года назад

I love this mix of Greek history and Harry Potter

@torifelten9066 3 года назад

This is paradise for me. I like both.

@ceilingsintheireyes6288 3 года назад

@@torifelten9066 you are my people

@casparjackson4075 3 года назад

@@torifelten9066 you are my kind of person

@casparjackson4075 3 года назад

@@ceilingsintheireyes6288 you too

@nicoski6347 3 года назад

The way you guys draw these connections will never cease to amaze me. This makes perfect sense, and yet I never would've thought of it.

@tappajaav 3 года назад

You can't know how many they didn't come up with themselves.

@nicoski6347 3 года назад

@@tappajaav I suppose that's true, but usually they credit whoever gave them the idea if they didn't think of it themselves, and anyway I'm willing to give them the benefit of the doubt.

@tappajaav 3 года назад

@@nicoski6347 That's the magic of them being great entertainers, uploading more content frequently and halo effect. Even if none of the theories they publish were theirs people would still watch and like them.

@maddievstheworld2593 3 года назад

This is why Dumbledore is such a great character. Because he is so smart and logical and yet flawed. His weakness is not caring for people in the way that they need but rather in the way that it benefits him. Dumbledore manipulates everyone he knows by laying out the logic socratically to get the outcome he needs. He is not a bad person, but he also treats people that he loves like they're secondary. He did it with his sister and brother, and Newt, and Harry.

@Mr.Kerr-cade Год назад

All very true. That's why I wrote a song about him

@diyavatsavai5778 3 года назад

I think Socrates's poison more closely resembles the ring, which was slowly killing Dumbledore

@aWildJersh 3 года назад

Saw Socrates and dumbledore and thought SIGN ME UP 😏

@3amDepression 3 года назад

J’s version of Socrates is a lot more entertaining than my history teacher lol

@pederslothzuricho7685 3 года назад

I hope Sokrates is not in your history lessons... sort of the wrong lesson to put it in, he isn't exactly a historically verifyable fact or character we can determine lived, he belongs in ancient world studies, or classical world studies. Maybe that is why your history teacher sounds boring and depressed 😏. History is somewhat linked to ancient greece but is very different in its methodical approach.

@puremath3491 3 года назад

You should read some of Plato's works, I've actually laughed out loud at many of the things Socrates says as he literally just gets people to prove themselves wrong

@SarahCraigGater 3 года назад

@@pederslothzuricho7685 he is in a class called humanities and ethics in the UK

@NotBessem 3 года назад

J would probably be the world’s greatest history teacher

@davecampbell4 3 года назад

I loved his explanation of Socrates' teaching style. It made me laugh so hard.

@CosmicFaust 3 года назад

As a philosophy student this video is going to be very interesting :D

@umbrella0110 3 года назад

Your thoughts? (Now that you've seen it) 🤔

@landlighterfirestar5550 3 года назад

As another philosophy student, this was so fun, and I think funnily enough, I managed to reach a conclusion that was basically the Socrates paradox in one of my essays without even knowing it existed. And the essay wasn’t even on Plato or Socrates

@thedeliverus 3 года назад

Wow! Not only was the video good, I LOVE that you guys add a "timer" to make it very clear what is the ad and what isn't. This is an amazing practice and honestly is one of the best ways to comply with global ad laws (cough cough, UK) while keeping viewer interests at heart

@mattwearden3542 3 года назад

I have no doubt in my mind that you’ll somehow convince me 😂

@ahtnamaSAugust 3 года назад

“Oh and the ball has a riddle on it... And the ans- Die, cool.” ✋”ok bloodthirsty much” 🤚 The two funniest moments in my opinion 😂

@youngkiller3618 3 года назад

Last time I was this early, Harry Potter didn't have a scar.

@AmaraJordanMusic 3 года назад

Nice one, also sad.

@seanmalloy0528 3 года назад

"When you have to shoot, shoot, don't talk"- Tuco from "The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly"

@vultureairsoft2153 3 года назад

Personally my favorite character is fluffy

@SuperCarlinBrothers 3 года назад

Fluffy does not get enough love!

@juliedavis2286 3 года назад

Mine is tonks and hedwig

@coolnerdlll6053 3 года назад

Mine is Fluffy's owner (I shouldn't have said that). 😉

@calredwine7001 3 года назад

@@juliedavis2286 i thought ATLA lol

@vultureairsoft2153 3 года назад

@@SuperCarlinBrothers agreed

@ConConSmith 3 года назад

Ok I just want to say I LOVE THIS VIDEO! I went to a classical education school and we talked about and used the Socratic method all the time. It's really cool to have one of my favorite book series be related to things i've learned in school.

@chihuahua5039 3 года назад

Scb: posts Me:clicks

@SuperCarlinBrothers 3 года назад

Chihuahua Lover: Comments Me: Hearts

@melanieturner6177 3 года назад

Me found this Chanel:watches it Watching it me : subscribes

@AliAngelpie 3 года назад

Dumbledore is so mysterious and enthralling, you gotta admire his tactics

@Mr.Kerr-cade Год назад

I agree with that. That's why I made a song about him. Come check it out and tell me what you think. I would really appreciate it.

@craigmckendrick4460 3 года назад

Hi there I normally watch them after two days because I am busy

@SuperCarlinBrothers 3 года назад

OH man you are here early today!

@malarkey5323 3 года назад

Same

@craigmckendrick4460 3 года назад

I love your therios they are fantastic

@NobodyWhatsoever 3 года назад

Ironic that people speculate Dumbledore is Socrates, but it's Dobby who is most impressed with socks and tees.

@joaofarias9986 3 года назад

Do we already have the Dumbledore/Omniman meme yet? "Think, Harry!Think!"

@NocandNC 3 года назад

I scrolled down looking for this lol

@herbdandilion3434 3 года назад

I would pay to have you read the books omg plsss let this happen

@poyrazcoskun 3 года назад

Harry: I‘d want him finished. And I‘d want to... Palpatine: Do it!

@darkecofreak23 3 года назад

Yes, Socrates coined the “But Why” style of argument and maybe the For Want of a Nail trope.

@diyavatsavai5778 3 года назад

7:33 Throwing shade at the golden trio I see! 😂

@toriandtilly 3 года назад

Honestly Dumbledore was amazing at a teaching technique called "scaffolding". No sky scraper can be constructed without scaffolding (well maybe they can today but still) the teacher instead of giving the student the answer asks the questions and gives the tools for them to find the answer on their own. The teacher gives them the scaffolding to stand on while the student constructs the skyscraper.

@Matt-vh2ci 3 года назад

Dumbledore said calmly: THINK HARRY THINK

@StarLoyd424 3 года назад

13:40 It's like that old proverb: A bowl is most useful when it's empty

@MessOfAnElisa 3 года назад

Also interesting that Socrates was sentenced to death in part for “corrupting” the youth of Athens by, as the leaders would describe it, putting ideas in their head (obviously not the case) but it also works as an interesting parallel to Umbridge/Fudge’s attitudes to Voldy’s return vs Harry/Dumbledore’s

@kaimichael5855 3 года назад

I love both of these subjects so I love that these topics cross over

@Nothing-gk3ir 3 года назад

been here since 2016, good to see how much you guys have grown. Currently buying Name of the wind. Really hype!

@forestgrump4723 3 года назад

I just got mine in the mail yesterday I'm ten pages in and the prose is so beautiful I could cry. The way he writes is like the definition of show don't tell. I can tell I'm going to love this book.

@Nothing-gk3ir 3 года назад

@@forestgrump4723 Oh cool! I am expecting it soon. will update when i get it

@johnhenson4237 3 года назад

Why do i feel like ur talking about luke with the whole honey in the hair thing?? 😂😂

@klach6215 3 года назад

I know right!!

@ruthdeckman9781 3 года назад

I thought the same thing!

@shane7778 3 года назад

The real reason Ben hides the honey....

@lauraeden6224 3 года назад

My favorite philosophy prof when I was in grad school at UMASS was Gareth Matthews who wrote an essay entitled “ Finding Platform 9 3/4: The Idea of a Different Reality”. It was included in the Popular Culture and Philosophy Series volume entitled “Harry Potter and Philosophy, If Aristotle Ran Hogwarts”. Thematically, there are so many philosophical rabbit holes to explore in the HP series it is hard to know where to begin! Thank you for taking an admirable stab at it✨

@vallentinac9513 3 года назад

I love the message/deeper meaning of this video theory!! Definitely one of my favorites!!!

@danielleprado13 3 года назад

Great video!! Also, so happy to have my Harry Potter Tuesday picture featured in the video 💕

@jessiepapabear4272 3 года назад

Totally loved the deep dive and insight

@chromekatana1124 3 года назад

Hey guys this is the first Time I’m early but I’ve been watching you guys for 4 years and I love all your videos so much there the best, I’ve seen them all but keep up the good videos you guys are my favorite and awesome

@SuperCarlinBrothers 3 года назад

Thanks so much!

@RepairedCandy 3 года назад

"Think harry, think!" Someone's been watching invincible

@tracethibault7402 3 года назад

Thanks for making these videos Carlin Brothers

@israelperets7799 3 года назад

Love you guys Today I binged every video of yours related to Harry Potter

@IronCodyAlan 3 года назад

This one is a gem Jazzy J- one of my favorite SCB Dumbledore videos to date 🤙🏼

@anaikaeledath3658 3 года назад

I loved the theory, and I also loved the little timer for the sponsorship!

@ankedecleer5474 3 года назад

Love the time bar for the sponsership

@saracarrillo3876 3 года назад

I get soooo excited as soon as I see a video from scb posted💕💕

@karramia14 3 года назад

Kudos for that time check line on the sponsor ad! Definitely helped me to not skip to be honest 🤭😁

@jaimelannister1797 3 года назад

You should do ASOIAF theories. I need some content while I dreadfully wait for Winds of Winter

@AmaraJordanMusic 3 года назад

The series is just not so family friendly, you know? It would be risky. I’d love more people to talk about theories. Especially from the books. But I don’t see them hopping on the ASOIAF train. With all due respect, Senator. 😅

@jaimelannister1797 3 года назад

@@AmaraJordanMusic Understandable, but I've heard them discuss (although briefly) Game of Thrones, AKA they discussed their disappointment with season 8, so I thought they might be interested in ASOIAF

@martymcflyy6775 3 года назад

You guys are the masters of creating wacky ideas and then somehow fitting it together

@erenyeager3829 3 года назад

Socrates, huh? I honestly can believe that considering Socrates was quite intelligent and smart and Dumbledore is also the same so...

@duskopal1069 3 года назад

That little timer at the sponsored section was a great idea, please keep doing it

@haydenlow9907 3 года назад

I like what you did with the little sponsor bar at the bottom of the screen.

@aaronbateman3941 3 года назад

I literally wrote an essay on Socrates yesterday and now you post this. What is going on?

@Colaman112 3 года назад

Oh dear J, I think he's onto you.

@amauryrey5009 3 года назад

You're conclusion is very interesting! I liked this reversed Spiderman. Thanks for the lesson 😉

@st11ches 3 года назад

I love the topic and sponsor combo here.

@jenniferwettervik4495 3 года назад

Next year for university I'm planning on writing a big essay about literary intertexts in the HP-books and this would be suuuuch an interesting thing to bring up!

@Daggeira 3 года назад

I would _love_ it if you guys got into some Good Place theories. Seems like it'd be right up your alley.

@danielsimonds9124 3 года назад

This is a phenomenal video. It also makes you actually think about how we’ve actually been taught all through our lives. And if you want to actually critically think. It gives you an insight into how certain organizations try and change your thought process by ignoring the most important part of the method. That there is an actual answer to the questions they are asking. But to warp the method they ask questions and hint at an answer within the question and then agree when the person comes to the conclusion that fits your narrative the most.

@samb4067 3 года назад

This is actually a really good explanation of the Socratic method in general

@Abraxun 3 года назад

Thanks for keeping us all entertained with the content guys :)

@emmalemon1597 3 года назад

Me DEFINIYELY not thinking about my review on Socrates yesterday......😳

@bethanymerchant2378 2 года назад

THANK YOU! This was amazing! I'm getting a BA in Philosophy and this semester is a heavy focus on Socrates! I love Harry Potter and your videos and this comparison between Dumbledore and Socrates was great! In Plato's Republic Socrates also outlines the ideal city and names Philosophers as the rulers because as you said in the video, they would not want to rule, and what makes one best to rule is that it is basically forced upon them not that they desire it. Harry became a great leader for the fight against voldemort because he was thrown into it, and Dumbledore refused the offers to be minister because he knew those with the desire for power are not the ones who should have it. You made so many great comparisons and it had me cracking up! Thanks for making my day, Philosophy and Harry Potter! The perfect combination!

@Sw-nn6le 3 года назад

J, that was quite insightful! Now I need to get some coffee and a pair of amazing socks.

@Trinity10725 3 года назад

One of your best theory videos thus far. Well done

@yitziyyb 3 года назад

Great video and theory as always! One thing about Socrates is that since he always questioned everything, if you stopped and asked him his opinion, he didn't have one. Which is interesting considering his student Aristotle. Dumbledore on the other hand is all opinion and moral. So similar but different

@caitlinlach9615 3 года назад

I'm not even 5 min in and am legit wondering if Luke put honey in his hair

@JoshRazauskas 3 года назад

‪All the evidence really is there! How did I never pick up on any of this before? Fantastic job J! I hope my spirit week entry counts. I had some extenuating circumstance stances so all I could really do was show my collection.‬

@elmerzcosta 3 года назад

my philosophy major just started, I feel like this is a sign. Thank you SCB!

@Nanalagoon 3 года назад

Another great video! One of my fave things is to try to see how the HP series was influenced by older stories/myths :D

@WilliamReginaldLucas 3 года назад

Philosophy is a strong force in Harry Potter, love this

@Goodbutevilgenius 3 года назад

Or, as Americans would say, sorcery.

@jameswilson-cj9mh 3 года назад

off topic and was gonna mention in other video but was on things cant leave comment but nice paras bennie. also always like the videos

@judek1166 3 года назад

HEY BROTHER! Absolutely loved this one guys, very interesting (and hilarious)

@clymbr 3 года назад

I'm getting excited for Name of the Windsday!!

@nickcalmes8987 3 года назад

Great video. I thought about how they paralleled each other too.

@michaelkearney6737 3 года назад

In the famous last words of Socrates, "I drank what?"

@jonathanward8967 3 года назад

Jay you are such a fan boy. Your brothers videos are 1000x better and more entertaining

@august1837 3 года назад

Ok, the title has me intrigued. Anything that has to do with Ancient Greece or scb tends to have that effect

@brewski118sempire 3 года назад

As Kvothe said.. "It's the questions we can't answer that teach us the most. They teach us how to think. If you give a man an answer, all he gains is a little fact. But give him a question and he'll look for his own answers."

@AmaraJordanMusic 3 года назад

Love those books. 😩 I got a special edition for my birthday and it’s amazing, but I’m scared to touch it. 🤣

@brewski118sempire 3 года назад

@@AmaraJordanMusic interestingly enough. I have never actually "read" the books. Just listen to the auto books so so many times.

@AmaraJordanMusic 3 года назад

brewski118sempire I prefer the audiobooks too; they’re in my top ten, and I’ve been a fanatic for years. every fantasy lover I know has gotten the audiobook or book for their birthday or Christmas or something, but I especially love sharing the audiobook. It’s just… special. 😊

@THEO00900 3 года назад

14:26 All parents ever: UNLIMITED POWAAAAA !!!!!

@LonKirk 3 года назад

Great video. Brilliant. Thank you.

@RealTimePogo 3 года назад

You should see if you can do an audio version of the books with you reading them.

@VFX_Mage 3 года назад

strong points I like that this also helps Harry learn after Dumbledore dies.

@rillegas08_vods 3 года назад

that quote from deathly hallows is strikingly similar to what dumbledore says about the mirror of erised and the sorcerer's stone

@awaywiththefaeries9464 3 года назад

7:34 I’m so glad you brought that up, it makes no sense that they wouldn’t have thought of that, especially if Hermione is as clever as people say she is.

@jannatulshoilee1443 3 года назад

Here before the author claims this is what she meant all along!

@tappajaav 3 года назад

Ah yes, J.K.Author

@abigailw7146 3 года назад

@@tappajaav ah yes, j.k transphobic

@tappajaav 3 года назад

@@abigailw7146 Just wait until she tweets "oh and by the way, all the characters of Harry Potter books are members OF LGBTQ+- movement and sexually identify as everything"

@maej1260 Год назад

I always liked that he did tell Harry what to but let him come to the realization on his own.

@remnant1018 Год назад

I think Dumbledore was also training Harry in _how_ to solve the rest of mysteries that go on in the book. He didn’t teach Harry about the sword directly, but because of the way their conversation went about it, Harry knew that Ron needed to go use the sword to kill the locket without having to talk to Dumbledore. He also knew that the cup was in the bank vault and where the diadem was. Dumbledore didn’t know those things, but because of how he trained Harry, Harry was able to use his understanding of Voldemort to figure those things out on his own once he had enough clues.