Тёмный

Economy of Russia - Data vs Reality 

Econ Lessons
Подписаться 14 тыс.
Просмотров 59 тыс.
50% 1

Russia has great potential, but it can not be realized because the people are not truly free. The world's greatest resource is free minds. Russian despotism does not allow self-actualization and people to live to their fullest potential and dreams. Therefore, the economy lags and will continue to do so. I want a better world, but this begins with real human liberation.

Опубликовано:

 

27 мар 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 2,2 тыс.   
@crand20033
@crand20033 2 месяца назад
Russian worker's motto: they pretend to pay us and we pretend to work.
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 2 месяца назад
Its a good strategy in life, but if you do that I recommend you work on your own venture simultaneously.
@Vlad_a450
@Vlad_a450 2 месяца назад
@@EconLessons This is the USSR heritage.
@5ufo
@5ufo 29 дней назад
​@Vlad_a450 and USSR is russian empire/golden horde heritage. Nothing is changing in Russia for centuries
@joeschembrie9450
@joeschembrie9450 3 месяца назад
Maybe the data coming out of Russia isn't real, but the artillery shells seem real enough.
@TeaParty1776
@TeaParty1776 3 месяца назад
Russia buys weapons from Iran,a fundamentalist religious nation.
@joanofarc6402
@joanofarc6402 3 месяца назад
The North Koreans are making their artillery now. lol.
@castlerock58
@castlerock58 3 месяца назад
@@joanofarc6402 I have never seen one intelligent comment that ends with lol.
@Kingcarparpeggio
@Kingcarparpeggio 3 месяца назад
@@castlerock58 : But he/she is right. Buy 100 shells 50% don’t work.
@YellowGun114
@YellowGun114 3 месяца назад
Unfortunately, that's all Russia is known for. Such a militaristic society.
@Kingcarparpeggio
@Kingcarparpeggio 3 месяца назад
He said ask yourself what you own that’s made in Russia. I did and the answer was nothing to my knowledge. I also asked myself what I own that’s made in the USA and the answer was also nothing to my knowledge. I live in the UK. It’s all made in China.🇨🇳
@olmostgudinaf8100
@olmostgudinaf8100 3 месяца назад
A fair answer. I had a bottle of Pepsi last week, but it's gone. But feel free to expand the question. What do you own that was invented in Russia or is made *anywhere in the world* on behalf of a Russian company or under a Russian licence?
@billyungen
@billyungen 3 месяца назад
@@olmostgudinaf8100 Yes, precisely: Invented, created, originated, or produced anywhere in the world on behalf of a Russian company or under a Russian license. I watch a lot of interview videos -- Europeans being asked things like which country they hate or would never visit. The USA tops that list (not North Korea, not Iran, not Russia, but USA). It is a great irony how many of these people are wearing jeans, baseball caps, and such. Then think about how dependent those people have become on the internet and related technologies! I realise only too well that there are a lot of very, very stupid Americans. But the world is dependent upon products and technology that comes out of the USA. You cannot say the same for Russia!!! I don't drink Coca Cola, but I know that it is the most recognized brand in the world. I can think of several American brands that would be readily recognised in most countries of the world. I know no Russian brands.
@Kingcarparpeggio
@Kingcarparpeggio 3 месяца назад
@@Adi-bo5do : I wasn’t suggesting that the US didn’t make anything, I just said I’m not aware of anything made there that I own and I’m still not. I often want to buy stuff on eBay from the US but the postage costs makes that impossible.
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 3 месяца назад
Google made in USA, RU-vid, made in USA.
@jaymorgan8017
@jaymorgan8017 3 месяца назад
​@@EconLessonsby cia to spy on us
@joblo341
@joblo341 3 месяца назад
That hundred year old sickle would probably be better than a new one you buy today ...
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
He is cherry picking. I have old pocket watch from Soviet Union which lasted longer than new from Switzerland. Conclusion? Swiss makes bad watches.
@ktrimbach5771
@ktrimbach5771 3 месяца назад
@@BojanPeric-kq9et In reality, modern capitalist societies make crap meant to fall apart.
@yagsipcc287
@yagsipcc287 3 месяца назад
@@BojanPeric-kq9et Yup I am in Ireland and my dad who is 75 has tools his dad used they are used to this day for projects he does (he is a retired plumber and loves hunting) those tools are better than the same ones you get today, things chip or bend.
@Kenneth_James
@Kenneth_James 3 месяца назад
Cant believe they still needed sickles. And some still do?
@Philip-hv2kc
@Philip-hv2kc 3 месяца назад
That shape of sickle still occurs today. It's not a good shape and curvature. Thus it likely got stored away and never used which I suggest is the reason it's survived till today.
@petermaunsell4575
@petermaunsell4575 3 месяца назад
I'm not gonna argue with a guy waving a sickle around
@crand20033
@crand20033 2 месяца назад
My wife had ten long, sharp fingernails. Wouldn't argue with her either.
@vibrolax
@vibrolax 3 месяца назад
I worked at a US precision optical technology company with a core scientific/engineering staff who had emigrated from the former USSR in the early 90's. They were top-notch in both theory and practice, became Americans, and lived the dream. Unfortunately, the USA is becoming more like the USSR every day. My ex-USSR colleagues and I discussed it often.
@izzytoons
@izzytoons 3 месяца назад
RFLMAO.
@carlroberson972
@carlroberson972 3 месяца назад
You are right, our formerly great 4th Estate is now a government echo chamber, our aviation is starting to resemble Russian aviation, and we're even trying to run our elections like Russia, eliminating candidates before they get on the ballot.
@disco1974ever
@disco1974ever 3 месяца назад
To this day Russia produces more Engineers each yr than any other country. They produce the most Physics graduates and produce more STEM grads than the EU.
@RealKull
@RealKull 3 месяца назад
They were top notch since they were a product of Socialist School System
@rockfella1377
@rockfella1377 3 месяца назад
@@disco1974ever 2 million russians fled over the last 2 years. There's a huge braindrain in russia. There's no denying that obvious fact.
@smk4902
@smk4902 3 месяца назад
Russia doesn't make consumer goods. How would they sell them? Sanctions won't allow it. Russia makes strategic things. Like nuclear reactors, nuclear icebreakers, nuclear submarines. Airplanes, helicopters both military and civilian. Trucks and all kind of vehicles, military and civilian. Space ships etc.
@robertstennett7566
@robertstennett7566 2 месяца назад
How stupid can you get, they have 140 million consumers in Russia to buy their consumer goods.
@t.fidler5895
@t.fidler5895 Месяц назад
Russian car and truck industry was destroyed by china.
@deewells1965
@deewells1965 3 месяца назад
6:18: Given there is a war, everyone should be checking where any product they buy is made. Here in EU, we have a big problem with many businesses no longer stating country of origin or "Made in X". IKEA has gone the route of printing with microscopic fonts. We need to adopt a philosophy that if a business is too ashamed to state where their product is made, then the consumer is too ashamed to buy it. Please spread the word!
@majvorandersson4641
@majvorandersson4641 3 месяца назад
I'm in! I bought pumkin seeds yesterday in EU with origin stated as: China, Europe or S. Am. .. Really annoying.
@deewells1965
@deewells1965 3 месяца назад
@@majvorandersson4641 The most important is that you tell people and set demands. Agriculture in general has in general been a problem. I just posted in here about stolen Ukrainian grain sold as Barilla pasta noodles at ICA in Sweden. Seeing as this was stored in a Russian military base for months, there is a very real national security issue about this being used as a vector to spread biological warfare agents
@sham27007
@sham27007 3 месяца назад
Good idea as I don't buy american or german made stuff.
@rodpanhard
@rodpanhard 3 месяца назад
Everything in the EU now has microscopic fonts given all the assorted languages they need to cover, you need a magnifying glass to read what should be prominent. This suits the manufacturers as they can hide their shennanigans easier from public awareness.
@olmostgudinaf8100
@olmostgudinaf8100 3 месяца назад
​@@rodpanhard That's just capitalism. It's cheaper to print a single label with 6 languages than 6 different labels for your different markets.
@KuopassaTv
@KuopassaTv 3 месяца назад
Made in Russia: timber, coal, gas, oil. But then, they're not made but collected from the ground.
@pccougar895
@pccougar895 3 месяца назад
He mentioned Russia exploiting their natural resources.
@igorinaKC
@igorinaKC 3 месяца назад
Right, there is one big lake of oil in Siberia and Russians picking it with USSR made buckets. They use buckets from USSR because they don't know how to produce modern bucket like Americans.
@Nitroat-xo4tj
@Nitroat-xo4tj 3 месяца назад
they make shitty ladas.. dont say they do nothing! Also some grain, fertilizers and weapons. (most collapsed, but they do something, i guess)
@-NEH-
@-NEH- 3 месяца назад
They are at hunter gatherer level.
@m.g.debruin8294
@m.g.debruin8294 3 месяца назад
Since 2 years ago one type of a Lada had only one a Airbag inside the car.@@Nitroat-xo4tj
@LambofSuffering
@LambofSuffering 3 месяца назад
And this is how you end up with Russia is running out of missiles in 2 weeks and washing machines.......
@yagsipcc287
@yagsipcc287 3 месяца назад
Lol yup this guy is coping hard for some reason. Its not like Russia is the number one exporter of food, its not like they make massive amounts of raw and refined materials from metals, woods, gas, oil, weapons, food.
@SkyDiver-wd5oj
@SkyDiver-wd5oj 3 месяца назад
@danielhalachev4714 he was being sarcastic.
@multipl3
@multipl3 2 месяца назад
Yet you trolls feel the need to type 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
@tommygun5038
@tommygun5038 2 месяца назад
Whenever we see washing machines, shovels and coping in comments. We know what Russia is producing. Gulag propaganda like Baghdad Bob did for Saddam.
@nicke0b
@nicke0b 2 месяца назад
They did run out .... missile attacks got really weak for a long time....
@lc3853
@lc3853 3 месяца назад
My experience tells me that Russians and Chinese study deep math, but Americans think they understand statistics after watching Moneyball.
@smk4902
@smk4902 3 месяца назад
Something interesting I saw on RU-vid. The Russians have resumed the production of big bodied civilian airliners. Currently undergoing testing.
@SkyDiver-wd5oj
@SkyDiver-wd5oj 3 месяца назад
@smk4902 yes, I noticed this too. I guess, Boeing no longer exports to Russia and they resumed their tried and true Tu (Tupolev), IL (Ilyushin), and Yak (Yakovlev). I remember hearing on NPR decades ago that Russian civilian planes had a much steeper accent because they were, essentially, modified military planes.
@zulubeatz1
@zulubeatz1 2 месяца назад
Meanwhile, they fall out off the sky because they are running out of parts. Get real
@smk4902
@smk4902 2 месяца назад
@@zulubeatz1 How would they run out of parts if they make every part for these aeroplanes. The Soviet planes had pretty good record. The Russians know how to make planes of all kind.
@StepDub
@StepDub 3 месяца назад
Seems appropriate to be holding a sickle while talking about Russia.
@aleksis-kivi
@aleksis-kivi 3 месяца назад
I used an American sickle just last week. It looks about a hundred years old. Got it from someone in Pennsylvania.
@creativecatalyst777
@creativecatalyst777 3 месяца назад
Most won't ever get your joke. Those days are over, sorry, try X😂😂❤
@StepDub
@StepDub 3 месяца назад
@@creativecatalyst777 I’ll try not to hammer the point.
@johnhume4346
@johnhume4346 3 месяца назад
Yeah that cold war mindset is really digging us out of a hole 🙄
@johnhume4346
@johnhume4346 3 месяца назад
They make pretty fucking good missiles and rockets and space stations 🤡
@midlander8186
@midlander8186 3 месяца назад
To be honest, you'd need to go back a century or at least decades to find a scythe made in the US. This American has some old American made hand tools, but all the tools I buy now are made in China, whether they are hand tools or power tools.
@dave20thmay
@dave20thmay 3 месяца назад
I'm in the UK and I know that the USA still make excellent machine tools.
@midlander8186
@midlander8186 3 месяца назад
@@dave20thmay Do you mean industrial lathes and milling machines? There are plenty of older US made lathes and milling machines around. Many of the lathe and milling bits come from overseas, though, and the newest mills I've worked on in a factory come from Korea. Edit: incidentally, all the steel I used when I worked a lathe in a factory about two and a half years ago came from China.
@dave20thmay
@dave20thmay 3 месяца назад
@@midlander8186 The Hardinge I used at work till I retired and the Bridgeport Mill I can still get to use were American. I hope that it is not true that US stuff has gone. Best Dave
@brentsrx7
@brentsrx7 3 месяца назад
China actually promotes and deregulates its private sector, allowing market forces to dictate prices. The U.S. has been going down the road of creeping socialism for some time. State-sponsored workers unions, welfare, and the Military Industrial complex is bankrupting society and destroying the real economy. It's living off echos of greatness.
@RRaucina
@RRaucina 2 месяца назад
Don't forget Estwing, Channellock, Klein and Vaughn for world class USA made tools. And Council for axes and sledge hammers.
@Brave2standalone
@Brave2standalone 3 месяца назад
Everything I bought here in the US was "MADE IN CHINA" - we don't produce much either and that's why the inflation is so high! Russian military equipment seems to be doing fine; they are #2 right after the US in military exports!
@roelkomduur8073
@roelkomduur8073 3 месяца назад
what exports? NO ONE is buying.. Even India stopped buying Russian arms...
@user-zv4jf8ag8p
@user-zv4jf8ag8p 3 месяца назад
Their military equipment is nothing but scrap metal easily obliterated by Ukrainian farmers lol
@isoldam
@isoldam 3 месяца назад
Garbage. The US is the second largest manufacturer in the world, behind China. The US has 16.6% of the world's manufacturing output. China has 28.4%. There has been a huge amount of investment in US manufacturing due to the Inflation Reduction Act and reshoring because of global tensions. US manufacturing output is expected to grow 1.5% in 2024 and 3% in 2025
@_alienblood
@_alienblood 3 месяца назад
It's a myth that china builds everything there not producing semi conductor's to western standards there only new to construction of cars they don't produce pharmaceutical products the west still leads in alot of industries
@polarvortex3294
@polarvortex3294 3 месяца назад
A few years ago I bought some berry juice at the Dollar Tree. It tasted pretty good, and it turns out, to my surprise, it came from Russia. Next time I was there I bought a few more bottles, but after that I couldn't find the stuff anymore. I guess sanctions or changing times killed the brand off at that store. That's about it for my Russian purchases so far!
@user-kb2ww8mk8o
@user-kb2ww8mk8o 2 месяца назад
Samsung use Russia chips in their phone, for gps or something, many car parts are made in russia, nuclear fuel is made in russia, plenty or weapons, some technology but it's operate through central/eastern europe because in north america the market is already taken or is getting taken before russian could reach the country
@playboyr5393
@playboyr5393 3 месяца назад
Holy shit, this is some serious coping skills!!!
@annalehman93941
@annalehman93941 Месяц назад
Good for Russia isn't? It be worse if the West has smart "experts"
@smk4902
@smk4902 3 месяца назад
Interested fact NASA has been using only Russian space rocket engines and space ships. since they scraped the space shuttle.
@_alienblood
@_alienblood 3 месяца назад
Not anymore russia scraped it's space program it was funded the the west anyway
@annalehman93941
@annalehman93941 Месяц назад
Few days ago Roscosmos send on orbit modern rocket Angara-a5 from new cosmodrome built from scratch in the last ten years. I think Russia is one of few countries whith capability to build new cosmodrome and new rocket
@MarcPagan
@MarcPagan 3 месяца назад
Damn (in a good way). Thank you for a clear and on point video. Getting to the point, using raw data to "trust, but verify", and being direct, are amongst the reasons I've appreciated Econ professors, and especially Milton Friedman, since my first Econ 101 class decades ago.
@tyrentyren
@tyrentyren 3 месяца назад
As person living in Russia I would like to make just one observation. I am glad that USA have such experts on Russia as yourself. Keep up good work. We as Russia wouldn't be in a place we are now without such experts on Russia. 😂
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 3 месяца назад
Explain in detail based on Stats what your counter argument is.
@markb3786
@markb3786 3 месяца назад
@@EconLessons He can't. Unless you want to talk about mining nickel
@futsk01
@futsk01 3 месяца назад
@@EconLessonsHe provided as much stats as you did in this video. Relax.
@Peter.F.C
@Peter.F.C 3 месяца назад
​@@EconLessons Western stats are made up. But the artillery shells raining down on the Ukrainians speak volumes. Stop embarrassing yourself.
@indieanna4764
@indieanna4764 3 месяца назад
Russia needs all the help it can get, shame pride and stupidity stands in the way.
@RZakelis
@RZakelis 3 месяца назад
I was born in Soviet Union and I live close to Russia now (Lithuania).I haven't seen or know any good reliable products made in Russia.
@marioceva7163
@marioceva7163 3 месяца назад
Sarmat.
@RZakelis
@RZakelis 3 месяца назад
@@marioceva7163 haven't seen this sarmat, have no idea how reliable it is, and in general complete useless thing in ordinary life
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
I still have grandpa's pocket watch. I don't know when he bought it, but he died in car crash over 50 years ago.
@RZakelis
@RZakelis 3 месяца назад
@BojanPeric-kq9et I guess you're talking about "Vostok".Yea, not too bad wristwatch.
@marioceva7163
@marioceva7163 3 месяца назад
@@RZakelis give security .
@cuffzter
@cuffzter 3 месяца назад
Not defending Russia, but about a 100 years ago companies deliberately started making things to break or having a shorter life cycle, starting with lightbulbs. The sickle was made during a time when people made things supposed to last, but the scythe was made during a time where it was supposed to be replaced so that companies could manufacture and sell new. And thats not just in Russia, but something that came from us in the west.
@daniellarson3068
@daniellarson3068 3 месяца назад
Market forces are fixing a problem. Unfortunately, the problem was the factories wanted more cash flow.
@smb-zf9bd
@smb-zf9bd 3 месяца назад
That is an old wive's tales. 99.9% of companies did not do this for precisely one reason - people buy quality goods. I am a cook and spend extra for quality utensils and appliances. Same with my computer... could have gotten a super-cheap desktop that lasted a couple of years or a cheap tablet but instead I made an investment in a 2016 MAC and the latest IPAD/ You really do get what you pay for and I'd hazard, most of those that buy cheap products then bitch because they don't last didn't read that sentence before buying. Put another way, I worked with material scientists for a good 8 years (material development) and the focus was on longevity and quality - not planned failure.
@daniellarson3068
@daniellarson3068 3 месяца назад
@@smb-zf9bdNot an old wives tale. Companies have "Planned Obsolescence." Here is the definition: "a policy of producing consumer goods that rapidly become obsolete and so require replacing, achieved by frequent changes in design, termination of the supply of spare parts, and the use of nondurable materials." Look up the Phoebus Cartel. They ensured incandescent light bulbs had limited life. If you read about cars in the 1960s prior to market share being swallowed by the Japanese (and others), you will see that the big 3 automakers at that time designed vehicles for a 3 year life. Be careful buying appliances such as refrigerators and washing machines these days. Just go to an appliance parts store and ask them. I make it sound bad, however, I guess Capitalism certainly did a better job of producing consumer products than the boys of the USSR.
@TeaParty1776
@TeaParty1776 3 месяца назад
> companies deliberately started making things to break or having a shorter life cycle commie propaganda! Competitors will make better quality.
@wildbillbegleyjr.3523
@wildbillbegleyjr.3523 3 месяца назад
Mr Larsen I have to break it to you He's right. Planned obsolescence is a fact esp. look at cars. Also it's money ruling the world and consolidating. You will eat bugs soon they're Fixing the whole world now. If they don't have nuclear war first if that happens food will only be one of Many issues. We don't have long don't be programmed cover your backside.
@jamesewanchook2276
@jamesewanchook2276 2 месяца назад
Good Channel, Cheers from Vancouver!
@yarkorab
@yarkorab 2 месяца назад
Some American actor once said he wished he could boycott something Russian, but he didn't come across anything made in Russia...
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 2 месяца назад
Excellent I love this.
@davidstrojan904
@davidstrojan904 3 месяца назад
Your analogy of sickle VS scythe is totaly wrong. These tools are used for different things. We use scythe for cutting grass on difficult, ususaly mountainous terrain. It doesn't need to be hard and if you hit a rock, it doesn't break. Sickle is usually used in the woods, for cutting branches, undergrowth, herbs, etc. If you use sickle to cut a meddow, it will break your back and if you use a scythe to peel bark from a spruce tree, you'll be in the woods forever. FYI: scythes have two handles, so you can swing them in a circular motion, yours doesn't: you have no clue how to use it, do you...
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 3 месяца назад
I do have a clue as I collect such thing. The metal based on the blade is poor in the Russian made one.
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
He is an economist, he has no clue about such things. Just look at his writing about "chemicals in agriculture".
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
@@EconLessons you think there is no poor quality built in US? That is called cherry picking.
@dmitryletov8138
@dmitryletov8138 3 месяца назад
He is US "scientist", you know what I mean, right?
@Philip-hv2kc
@Philip-hv2kc 3 месяца назад
There's good scythes and maybe there are bad sythes too . I've only encountered top quality ones , they definitely shouldn't chip or require frequent sharpening.. I tried slightly altering the shape at pointy end of one and it was as difficult as trying to pound stainless steel to shape . There's also another type of scythe that requires more of a golf type swing for the more bendy fresher long growth. The stiffer older long growth like for harvest time is tackled by the scythe he displayed equipped with those two branch out handles mentioned.
@fredyyfredfreddy
@fredyyfredfreddy 3 месяца назад
As a Swedish economist who have been interested in the Russian economy for the past 12-15 years, I couldn't agree more. The miracle behind the Russian economy surviving sanctions is that they write on a piece of paper that they are producing a bunch of stuff for their military and then they put a price on these war materials, that they are probably not even making and that no one in a free market would be willing to pay anyway, multiply the two and claim that their economy is growing. Also private consumption is ''holding up well' despite the uncertainty and the 16% interest.. hmhmhm. And then a few western institutions repeat these figures because they have no other figures to go on and the Russian propaganda uses that as evidence that their economy is doing well.
@TheDog_Chef
@TheDog_Chef 3 месяца назад
They will be out of money soon.
@Pifagorass
@Pifagorass 3 месяца назад
Reserves are not limitless 😅
@user-ng9tm6nx1b
@user-ng9tm6nx1b 3 месяца назад
I don’t know where your economics degree you got from. It seems you wasted the Swedish government money and your time. You are a big Joke 😂
@user-ng9tm6nx1b
@user-ng9tm6nx1b 3 месяца назад
@@TheDog_ChefYou are crying coz your time is UP. The new Global powers are CHINA Russia and India
@D.von.N
@D.von.N 3 месяца назад
It is an artificial bubble. About 70% of the workforce is on the govt payroll and many had their salarias rised due to shortages of workforce. Also some were lucky to get a payout for their men on the front. Poor folks suddenly got their hands on more money and they spend, spend, spend. But it is just the country's financial black hole. Nothing much to show for it with a vacuum building inside. Banks were throwing money on the nation in unsecured loans and they have nothing to pay it back. And Kremlin won't have enough resources to bail banks. They either will go down or Kremlin will have to start printing money, which comes with other issues. And now the previously allies are pulling out under the threat of the secondary sanctions, China and Turkey alike, also Kazachstan. Tha recent attack in the concert hall sent further waves to the surrounding countries and the level of racism spiked, going after the immigrants on which the RuSSian economy stood.
@Atiliusmagnus
@Atiliusmagnus 3 месяца назад
First video from you and impressed. Liked it and subscribed.
@martindansky6202
@martindansky6202 3 месяца назад
I would have clicked on this but Russia does produce equipment that is more than just extract, like binoculars and cameras. There is the large Kazan optical company in Russia. Zenit near Moscow has been making cameras for decades. So to say it produces nothing because he held up an inferior quality scythe is an exaggeration.
@Fred-ck1gh
@Fred-ck1gh 2 месяца назад
They produce crap for the domestic market as nobody outside Russia want to buy crap!
@KiraNt4
@KiraNt4 3 месяца назад
It's wierd that an economist forgot to mention such a high-tech company as Rosatom. "Today Russian nuclear industry constitutes a powerful complex of over 400 enterprises and organizations employing over 250 thousand people. Industry structure includes four large-scale research and production complexes: enterprises of nuclear fuel cycle, nuclear power engineering, nuclear weapons application, and research institutes." Rosatom has dozens of international projects as well. You can check wiki and see for yourself.
@annalehman93941
@annalehman93941 Месяц назад
He's indoctrinated with traditional polish propaganda ) i think it's good western economists thing the same way where they design "sunctions from hell" (c) Today i buy a box of fresh strawberries from Krasnodar and some very good cherry tomatoes from Tiumen. I live in Novosibirsk and ten years ago it was absolutely impossible. Since then government gove huge amount of money to agricultural firms and it works perfectly
@riptoff433
@riptoff433 3 месяца назад
So the old Soviet flag has a picture of a sickle MADE IN THE U.S.A. instead of the Soviet made type. LOL Now that is funny.
@FabiusPolis
@FabiusPolis 3 месяца назад
umm...no..Russia made sickles before the USA was even founded, one is a hand sickle and the other is a scythe and he compares them with each other as if its the same.
@SMGJohn
@SMGJohn 3 месяца назад
Did your parents drop your during birth?
@BOGSAVAGE
@BOGSAVAGE 3 месяца назад
The only thing I ever had made in Russia were glasses brought from IKEA.
@mynameisnobody3931
@mynameisnobody3931 3 месяца назад
And i bet it was Ikea that made sure that it happened. It was not Russia itself that made that deal
@renatorodriguez5086
@renatorodriguez5086 3 месяца назад
So had I. And did not last for long, cracked spontaneously....
@arminiuschatti2287
@arminiuschatti2287 3 месяца назад
Same here.
@patverum9051
@patverum9051 3 месяца назад
I had a very nice Zenith SR camera, heavy but nicely made, in USSR.
@harleyquinn8202
@harleyquinn8202 3 месяца назад
I buy ammunition made in Russia, works good in American made rifles.
@pychoupchhoeuy2008
@pychoupchhoeuy2008 3 месяца назад
Where do they get fertilizer from ? Just one thing and how they build their one spaceship ?
@user-ym9qw3gg3j
@user-ym9qw3gg3j 2 месяца назад
Do they really work
@izraphailzero5610
@izraphailzero5610 Месяц назад
space ships?) lmao. Do you mean those RD engines that were designed/built and FUNDED by NASA (USA)? Or you're about the Progress ship which uses tech from 1970x? They're literally using old soviet tech. Even their new "hyper-sonic" rocket "Kinjal" (Кинжал) - is a slight modification of Iskander and the concept was created in 1980x. And fertilizer. These are made from nature gas... guess from where they got it so much?
@schurlbirkenbach1995
@schurlbirkenbach1995 3 месяца назад
If that's true, then why Russia does not collapse after the embargo, imposed by the west. The western Europeans suffer much more from the embargo than Russia. If Russia does not produce anything, how can that be possible ?
@chhoukdying
@chhoukdying 2 месяца назад
😂 buy from China… why don’t you think?
@chatnoir1224
@chatnoir1224 2 месяца назад
Google "german export to kyrgyzstan" and check image section.
@annalehman93941
@annalehman93941 Месяц назад
​@@chhoukdyingand pay by what exactly?
@hrisoflinoski4803
@hrisoflinoski4803 2 месяца назад
For a country that makes shovels they're doing pretty good. 😂
@robertstennett7566
@robertstennett7566 3 месяца назад
World bank, Russia is one of the world's largest economies and is currently at rank 8.
@MrKakibuy
@MrKakibuy 2 месяца назад
so why do they need a 16% interest rate?
@StelzCat
@StelzCat 3 месяца назад
Some people just crawled under the rock about 30 years ago and never made it out of there.
@donjoaoresort8565
@donjoaoresort8565 3 месяца назад
Mister if US had lost 20 million dead it would be devastated. You don’t know nor understand the horrible history of Russia from 1917 to 2000.
@andysteward8617
@andysteward8617 3 месяца назад
Dude had me til he started bragging about how California is some sort of bastion for farmers
@ktrimbach5771
@ktrimbach5771 3 месяца назад
Typical clueless academic
@markb3786
@markb3786 3 месяца назад
What exactly is the central valley then?
@andysteward8617
@andysteward8617 3 месяца назад
@@markb3786 that’s where the socialists will set their water restriction sights next
@RRaucina
@RRaucina 2 месяца назад
California feeds the USA and a lot of the rest of the world. I can drive for 40 minutes down a backroad and the vineyards never end all the way to the horizon. And california has like 4X the economy of russia.
@linkly9272
@linkly9272 2 месяца назад
@@markb3786Apparently it's not real, haha.
@ericdaniels4650
@ericdaniels4650 3 месяца назад
People will always think themselves better than others. Their ideas of life are superior to every other idea. Freedom is choosing how you live your life. Nowhere on planet earth can you go and live life as you want. There will be rules, regulations, zoning, environmental concerns, property taxes. The moral is you can't claim to be free while living under someone else's rules. You can't even claim to own anything because governments around the world can take anything you have and there isn't much you can do about it. I know this my grandfather lost 30 feet of his property for an additional lane of traffic. He was forced to sell at the offered price by the state and there was nothing he could do to stop it. There are strengths and weaknesses in every form of government but they all aim for control of the population. Russia isn't perfect but neither are other countries. America for instance has abused it's position in the world by printing so much money it's currency is worthless. We should spend less time worrying what others are doing and more on what we are doing because I don't think we are better today than 100 years ago. In my opinion we are worse off as a society and our children are simply out of control with near zero parental discipline..
@KulibinX
@KulibinX 2 месяца назад
As many Russian economy observes mentioned, it is virtually impossible to run any production businesses in Russian Federation, because of very restricted regulations, fees, charges and taxes, and on top that beurocracy and corruption. As one of analytics said in gas prices there no gas. Oil cost in the current gasoline pipe price only 20, 25 percent. And it is pretty much for all goods and services. Russian government behave like occupants or colonial regime.
@Cocoluna66
@Cocoluna66 3 месяца назад
They only live and survive with shovels !!
@samdl1436
@samdl1436 3 месяца назад
I used to travel to Russia on business frequently and can’t agree with what you say. The Russian economy is highly dynamic and regulation light. The only large and successful consumer tech company in Europe is Yandex. Yet you’re showing an antiquated sickle and make this bogus claim that Russia produces nothing. This is not serious.
@clancywiggam
@clancywiggam 2 месяца назад
Yandex, you mean the russian version of Google. Never heard of it. I am European. I had to Google it. I have never Yandexed anything. I would never use the russian version of anything. The only thing russia does better than any other country in alcoholism.
@user-do4by5ox8z
@user-do4by5ox8z 2 месяца назад
Спасибо за правду! Но этот человек говорит не для реалии, а для хайпа Сплошная ложь и снос мозга🤷
@samdl1436
@samdl1436 2 месяца назад
@@clancywiggam The whole point is that Russia has its own version of Google whereas all other European countries do not. You could make the case that the rest of Europe is technologically behind on Russia whereas Russia is only behind on the US. My point though is that these are silly discussions. The author of the video is not objective, is lead by his emotions and doesn't think rationally/objectively. He is therefore not a reliable economist you should listen too. But I'm afraid you are lead by your emotions too.
@clancywiggam
@clancywiggam 2 месяца назад
@@samdl1436 I am not. I have numerous accounts from people working in russia, all talked about alcoholism, a poor work ethic and a total lack of initiative amongst russian people. I don't need an Irish version of Google, or a French version of Yahoo, or a Greek version of Bing, and I am sure any tech savvy russian would be using the established search engines rather than some digital version of a Lada.
@VilkatisJanis
@VilkatisJanis 2 месяца назад
@@samdl1436 Point is, that Google is US, that would be western, other stuff, like BMW is German, therefore European, still west. But we can find thngs in our ordinary lifes that come from Europe, US, China and other bigger powers.. what is that you can find in your everyday life that comes from russia.. if it is Yandex, i have bad news, almost no one uses it.
@dmitryletov8138
@dmitryletov8138 3 месяца назад
Poor American scientist doesn't know that most of the International Space Station was built by Russia.
@indieanna4764
@indieanna4764 3 месяца назад
And how does that help the russian people, just the govts ego.
@user-ex1db5dz5t
@user-ex1db5dz5t 3 месяца назад
Yep Russian built with stolen western technology 😮
@wirrwarr8834
@wirrwarr8834 3 месяца назад
Of the well over 50 main modules, 5 were contributed by Roskosmos. Do you still want to know about the level of technology of these modules compared to the Japanese, European and American modules? I'll say this: Back then, Russia wasn't even able to build the pipelines for oil and gas transport and export itself, let alone the mechanical infrastructure.
@redneckster6639
@redneckster6639 3 месяца назад
What about first man in space?
@RZakelis
@RZakelis 3 месяца назад
@@redneckster6639 Soviet Union
@ananominity
@ananominity 3 месяца назад
Yes, Russia's primary exports are from its' natural resources, but they are a sizable percentage of the worlds' demand. They produce about 20% of the worlds' oil, 25% of the worlds' natural gas, and coal is a big industry too. They have more forestland than any other country and paper products are a large export. They also export every mineral used in manufacturing and 1/3 of the worlds' iron ore, but their #1 export is fish. They produce 1/3 of all canned fish and 25% of all fresh and frozen fish worldwide. Nearly half of the worlds' grain comes from Russia and Ukraine. To say they don't produce anything is ridiculous. Just because they aren't manufactured items does not make them inconsequential. Take Russia out of world markets and it would get painful and expensive.
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
For Europeans and Americans: expensive. For poorer countries word "painful" is severe understatement. But looking at Gaza, starving Muslims, including children, is no problem for "noble and virtuous liberal democracies" so I guess that 50-100 times more people wouldn't be the problem either.
@smb-zf9bd
@smb-zf9bd 3 месяца назад
Global economics is evolving to function without Russian products. Period. Any smart nation is searching for a substitute since the situation is not sustainable. It may take a few months or a couple of years to find a replacement (like the EU and fossil fuel) but believe me, many nations are quite willing manufacture products in need. They simply need a commitment, like Ukraine using old steel plants for neon.
@markb3786
@markb3786 3 месяца назад
Yep. mobsters selling commodities
@edwardhanson3664
@edwardhanson3664 3 месяца назад
Good example of what you're saying: Russian submarines, and I wonder about their nuclear missiles.
@wbiagioni
@wbiagioni 3 месяца назад
yes I read they used superglue on their submarines and the nuke they testfired was a dud.....oh wait that was not Russia
@MrKakibuy
@MrKakibuy 2 месяца назад
probably designed with the help of Germans, and ultimately contribute nothing to current war, end up as Kursk )
@nicolasolton
@nicolasolton 3 месяца назад
Was the video filmed in Russia?
@JBol-gm1mw
@JBol-gm1mw 2 месяца назад
My experience from the Soviet Union: Hundreds of thousands of agricultural tractors were produced every year and delivered to the Kolhos/Sovhos. There these new tractors were used for only one or two years - usually only a few weeks in spring for plowing and sowing - then they were parked for a few years, used as spare parts donors and later finally written off.
@user-nt3gc8wv1m
@user-nt3gc8wv1m 2 месяца назад
Love this video, keep up the good work!
@rrmackay
@rrmackay 3 месяца назад
What does Russia produce ? All of the exotic metals in your cell phone and computer are mined in Russia ! Your titanium golf clubs are manufactured with Russian titanium. Finished goods are one thing, raw materials are necessary for every factory.
@sergey_a
@sergey_a 3 месяца назад
I hope that foreigners will continue to live with this misconception. And the longer this misconception continues, the better for my country.
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 3 месяца назад
Don't you love other nationalities?
@markb3786
@markb3786 3 месяца назад
Come back and say why it's a misconception because the Russian-manufactured products I have seen in Russia are both sad and hilarious
@supaman6713
@supaman6713 3 месяца назад
What's your monthly salary, how has it changed in the last 2 years?
@yelenazayakina1506
@yelenazayakina1506 3 месяца назад
sergey_a 👍😉
@harleyquinn8202
@harleyquinn8202 3 месяца назад
@@supaman6713 "What's your monthly salary, how has it changed in the last 2 years?" - How many years does it take the average American to pay off their mortgage?
@SuperMagnum2011
@SuperMagnum2011 2 месяца назад
Thanks Mark. Very interesting.
@liambyrne591
@liambyrne591 3 месяца назад
Do they make rockets or is it just shovels
@darkslaerdark
@darkslaerdark 2 месяца назад
washing machine chips )
@karlmarka
@karlmarka 2 месяца назад
These are Soviet rockets manufactured using Soviet machines. Just like the guy in the video said.
@user-cb2df9zy6d
@user-cb2df9zy6d Месяц назад
@@darkslaerdark A missile with a chip from a washing machine is capable of hitting an object less than 5 meters in diameter, a tomahawk missile (not just one, a whole salvo) somehow missed the airfield...
@user-cb2df9zy6d
@user-cb2df9zy6d Месяц назад
​@@darkslaerdark Boom... ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5cHLzRQCyR8.html
@user-vu9xl2yz4s
@user-vu9xl2yz4s Месяц назад
The fuel for rokets come from China. Chips from west.
@smk4902
@smk4902 3 месяца назад
Yes Russia never was and is not to this day developed like the west. And yet the west never managed to take over and colonize Russia. I don't know how to explain this. "A riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. " Churchill had the intellectual honesty to say it.
@joanofarc6402
@joanofarc6402 3 месяца назад
Very interesting! Thank you.
@Don.Challenger
@Don.Challenger 3 месяца назад
In 1990 Russia had a hope, but China got there first with the cheapest goods and never lost their grip (until recently).
@harleyquinn8202
@harleyquinn8202 3 месяца назад
Russia barely has 150 million, China has ten times more people. Economy of scale.
@annalehman93941
@annalehman93941 Месяц назад
​@@harleyquinn8202and it was very different by social status. Russia was very urbanized and have many advantanced technology like nuclear power plamts and China was absolutely opposite - not so urbanized etc
@bigolboomerbelly4348
@bigolboomerbelly4348 3 месяца назад
Are you saying the russian economy is crude?
@geoff9759
@geoff9759 3 месяца назад
Oil agree
@rambleon2838
@rambleon2838 3 месяца назад
That was rude
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 3 месяца назад
Unrefined extraction of resources, in a non-regenerative way, disrespecting the environment.
@dainagrn7030
@dainagrn7030 3 месяца назад
​@@EconLessonsthe problem that whole world except the west don't respect environment.
@user-cb2df9zy6d
@user-cb2df9zy6d 3 месяца назад
@@dainagrn7030 Human influence on the planet is greatly exaggerated; on such a scale we are nothing more than cockroaches.
@slavakotelnikov2440
@slavakotelnikov2440 3 месяца назад
How about you analyze modern American consumer goods (produced in China?)
@vindobonaification
@vindobonaification 2 месяца назад
Best way to disqualify yourself from any argument is Whataboutism.
@innercynic2784
@innercynic2784 3 месяца назад
For a country that makes nothing they're doing pretty good.
@goldienorman9402
@goldienorman9402 3 месяца назад
😂😂😂😂😂😂
@_alienblood
@_alienblood 3 месяца назад
You serious outside of Moscow and St petbourgh russia has staggering poverty electricity is on and off no Internet some towns have no santation horse and carts are still used russian economy is in dire straights
@boomer955
@boomer955 2 месяца назад
@@_alienbloodYes, people eat nothing but vodka and have to dodge bears while walking to work.
@hrisoflinoski4803
@hrisoflinoski4803 2 месяца назад
@@_alienblood Are you on steroids?
@bonnersommer7201
@bonnersommer7201 2 месяца назад
Yes, as mentionend by exploiting the incredible big lands that have been conquered during centuries.
@senttosiberia
@senttosiberia 2 месяца назад
I’ve lived in russia for almost 30 years. I’m a farmer. What he says might be true, but if you accept that ask the same questions about the USA ... not as bad by far ... yet. Do you compare 100yo Pennsylvania Steele with modern scythes or cycles made in the USA Today.
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 2 месяца назад
I would have to test them. What did you grow? I grow mostly potatoes.
@profrog493
@profrog493 3 месяца назад
Professor Beer-Nut Perfect memorable name
@Lukky_Luke
@Lukky_Luke 3 месяца назад
Russia is now importing refined petroleum products... So yeah they are pretty screwed
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
US imports 1/3 or oil despite "we have our own oil and we are the largest producer" mantra.
@user-cb2df9zy6d
@user-cb2df9zy6d 3 месяца назад
In response, Ukraine will soon begin importing electricity in batteries.
@nicolasolton
@nicolasolton 3 месяца назад
​@@BojanPeric-kq9etUS exports oil at this time.
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
@@nicolasolton imports around 1/3 of oil too. Not all crude oils are created equal.
@churblefurbles
@churblefurbles 3 месяца назад
Not tired of making the same bad predictions since the start of all this huh
@johnherrick7486
@johnherrick7486 3 месяца назад
You are a great alternative to other Geopolitical analysts on youtube.
@thealphazoid
@thealphazoid 2 месяца назад
Thank you for mentioning Grammarly. I’ve graduated the same biz school as Grammarly founder
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 2 месяца назад
I love Grammarly and grateful for their unwavering support of Ukraine. Thank you.
@floxy20
@floxy20 3 месяца назад
The Soviet quota mentality had a lot of negative consequences. Factory managers were given quotas of goods to produce, for example 30,000 pairs of shoes per month. The goal was achieved without regard to quality because under socialism what constitutes measurable quality? Under capitalism it is measured by sales (consumer satisfaction),
@johnm7267
@johnm7267 3 месяца назад
The reason Soviet factories were given quotas was because after the devastating war when everything was made over to the war effort the demand for goods was so high. Of course you obviously don’t know anything about what Russia faced while America was making a fortune out of the war Russia faced 14 Panza divisions while America plus allies faced just two. They lost 27 million people mostly men which had a profound effect on the economy where the work was left to the women. You people with your glib answers to everything
@AS-np3yq
@AS-np3yq 3 месяца назад
No the quotas are inherent in socialism and communism. Has nothing to do with war and so on.
@daniellarson3068
@daniellarson3068 3 месяца назад
@@johnm7267 The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact thing kind of leaves one to believe that they brought some of these problems to themselves. When your leaders lack honor, don't expect good things.
@TeaParty1776
@TeaParty1776 3 месяца назад
Quotas are not coordinated by markets w/buyers. There is no way govts can know what people want to buy. Even w/good quality.
@Crunch_dGH
@Crunch_dGH 3 месяца назад
Putin's "Pride."
@skipmcgrath
@skipmcgrath 3 месяца назад
I worked there in the 90s and agree totally. We had to use drywall screws from Europe, because soviet drywall screws had the cross in the middle for the screwdriver punched off center. So when you tried to drive them with a drill, they would just fly off in all directions. And now Russia is reorienting the limited industrial capacity it has to produce heavy equipment, such as tanks, the only purpose of which is to be driven to Ukraine and be blown up in a few days. And because the whole world can watch the tops blowing off these tanks on youtube, no one outside of Russia will ever buy them. So the possibility of subsidizing the arms industry in the future with foreign sales is next to zero.
@rambleon2838
@rambleon2838 3 месяца назад
Russian's survival depended on heavy investments from the West after the Soviet Union collapsed. I do remember seeing on TV the bread lines in Moscow because they were not capable to fee themselves. The West literally rebuild their dilapidated agro and energy sectors throughout the 90s while they were waging two wars against Chechnya and overthrowing Gorbachev and Yeltsin at the same time. Putin turned the privatized economy back into a pseudo state-owned economy owned by him, but managed by his oligarchs who are just one step away from a window.
@cyclewisconsin105
@cyclewisconsin105 3 месяца назад
@@rambleon2838 That pretty much nails it.
@gingernutpreacher
@gingernutpreacher 3 месяца назад
In the early 90's my dad brought a lada car a Russian fridge and a Russian camera. No we have nothing
@rambleon2838
@rambleon2838 3 месяца назад
When Putin left Dresden Germany in 1989, his East German comrades gifted him a washing machine and a TV. The first images of the invasion was Russian solders stealing electronics, washing machines, air conditioners, toilets, and in one instance a small heating boiler.
@mmmikeyyy
@mmmikeyyy 3 месяца назад
It's the same thing with data coming from China. What's frustrating is that often the same people who tell us that Chinese GDP figures are completely made up at other times cite official Chinese growth numbers to explain what's going on there. We see plants closing, idle ports overflowing with empty containers, people unable to find work and are asked to believe that the GDP will just be growing 6% as a result. The fact that only fake data is available is not an acceptable reason to cite it as if it were real.
@tanjazino9981
@tanjazino9981 2 месяца назад
Strongly agree.
@janethompson5153
@janethompson5153 2 месяца назад
Great reporting 👏 just found you 👍❤ 🇬🇧
@ralph3728
@ralph3728 3 месяца назад
I live in the United States made in the United States. When I go to buy things I try to buy things that were made in Japan or Europe, not the United States. Even non-physical things like software is from the US is pretty mediocre, if you don't believe me take a good hard look at Google's success as a software/hardware company or for that matter how unreliable Microsoft is as a product line. I'm not saying we're like Russia but we're far closer to being a Russia than we are to the United States of 120 years ago.
@SkyDiver-wd5oj
@SkyDiver-wd5oj 3 месяца назад
@ralph3728 I only owned a US-made cars when I was young and poor. Now I buy Japanese cars and European appliances.
@tommygun5038
@tommygun5038 2 месяца назад
You can thank the bean counters for most of that.
@mrjuvy49
@mrjuvy49 2 месяца назад
Comparative advantage, no country can make every thing a a consumer wants.
@darbyheavey406
@darbyheavey406 3 месяца назад
Organic farming is a function of wealth.
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
if EU was organic, there would be no trouble about rise of fertilizers' price. Organic farming is shortcut to famine.
@smk4902
@smk4902 3 месяца назад
Trust me economic success will be less and less measured with the production of washing machines, TVs , even cars. A lot of countries can make these things now days. Not just the West anymore. The future is not Mercedes or BMW. China is the largest car exporter now.
@zadadazadada4298
@zadadazadada4298 3 месяца назад
Great video!
@Michael-it6gb
@Michael-it6gb 3 месяца назад
I'm not sure if this video supposed to be a joke, or sarcasm. Russia is able to produce their own tractors, agriculture machines, semi-trucks, paved roads, airplanes, even micro-electronics. And those industries inside of the country have been GROWING in the last couple of years because of the sanctions and lack of western products. The quality is good enough for sustainability. I have relatives living there and they have been doing fine in terms of resources and groceries, living conditions, etc. Just talked to them last week. Before Russia, Iran was the most sanctioned country for decades, and they have survived overall.
@floriangyer5857
@floriangyer5857 3 месяца назад
Yes but extremely low Quality and that is why nobody want to buy them.
@Michael-it6gb
@Michael-it6gb 3 месяца назад
@@floriangyer5857 Russia was about to start selling one of their UAZ budget cars in U.S. but it was banned because of the "invasion" in 2022. Along with all the other products they were already selling all around the world.
@nemesis8131
@nemesis8131 3 месяца назад
The fact is: they will never sell it to the West.
@georgevladimirovich7190
@georgevladimirovich7190 3 месяца назад
@@floriangyer5857 Low quality? You make me laugh as you don't have a clue.
@dipayanroy8300
@dipayanroy8300 3 месяца назад
​@@floriangyer5857 how did you come to the conclusion that Russian made products are "low quality" ??? I have many online Russian friends they are all doing well and living comfortably. They are worried more about Ukrainian terrorists. Stop blindly believing the crap from Western media.
@Bruce22027
@Bruce22027 3 месяца назад
Sophisticated fighter aircraft and rocketry come from Russia. We were exclusively using Russian rockets to get to the ISS for a lot of years.
@danielturczan2485
@danielturczan2485 5 дней назад
Only because russia used it's ICBM rockets, and was therefore the lowest cost producer. Those rockets are all gone. Unless russia plans on decommissioning it's strategic nuclear reserve, it's space program is defunct.
@user-tu9wi7zd5r
@user-tu9wi7zd5r 3 месяца назад
I think Kaspersky internet security was quite good. You’d have to be insane to use it now!
@smk4902
@smk4902 3 месяца назад
Hey energy and food are the most important resources. Especially if you are in control of your own.
@TEmery
@TEmery 3 месяца назад
Well somehow a boatload of experts were wrong and now how many nato countries are loosing to this gas station masquerading as a gas station? Apparently Russia’s industrial production has surpassed Germany.
@patverum9051
@patverum9051 3 месяца назад
They buy drones and grenades from Iran and N-Korea, so their production levels are still equal to Italy's,like they've been for years.
@HT-ww3zg
@HT-ww3zg 3 месяца назад
You're spot on, Mark. Good work! You're a professor. I hope you are teaching our kids.
@angelostamboulakis8371
@angelostamboulakis8371 3 месяца назад
All anecdotal talk with no facts or figures. Yeah, great job teaching the next generation of uncritical Americans.
@amirlach
@amirlach 3 месяца назад
Worked in Siberia 1993-4 for Calgary Overseas. Times were tough for the locals. We had modernish trucks and service rigs from Alberta. They were decades ahead of what the Russians had. Their trucks were better suited for working in the sand. Central tire inflation, flotation tires and beefy axels. Our Alberta equipment functioned as good or better in the cold as theirs did. And our trucks got around on the frozen ground without the problems we had in the soft summer sand. We do most of our off road work in winter anyways. Nearly every other oil related modern tech came from the west. Reda Pumps and Fishing tools ect. Their oil and gas pipelines we tied into. Plants and refineries we only saw from a distance. I still have many pictures of our operations.
@cyruslupercal9493
@cyruslupercal9493 3 месяца назад
Thing about extracting is to do it efficently you need good secondary economy to provide the tools. So it's channeling the secondary economy back into the primary one. So even their primary economy is going to become decrepit without foreign imputs.
@pedrozs1
@pedrozs1 2 месяца назад
80% of the fertilizers used here in Brazil come from Russia friend, you are wrong.......
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 2 месяца назад
Fertilizers are a form of mining, not really production, taking NPK from the earth and it is very destructive. I am sorry Brazil is destroying its lands with Russian chemicals.
@petardetar5191
@petardetar5191 2 месяца назад
@@EconLessons Good that only USA chemicals are Eco friendly :) I will tell you just 1 thing - BlackRock (BASF, Monsanto, Cargill) In USA all are Gen.modified raised food product In Russia all is natural grown (read un-modify )
@annalehman93941
@annalehman93941 Месяц назад
​@@EconLessonsin modern world fertilisers are high tech products with an advanced chemistry technology
@sarahgesheft1697
@sarahgesheft1697 2 месяца назад
A clown with hippi habitus in a forest isn't so convincing.
@ericdowney6374
@ericdowney6374 3 месяца назад
I totally agree with this guy that RU doesn't make goods to int'l standards. But don't let that fact overwhelm the war calculation. RU is making 155mm artillery shells at 3X the rate of NATO mfg facilities. And RU makes them for $50 instead of $500 each. War is an inherently industrial activity but UKR will eventually be overwhelmed by RU because UKR is running out of people who can fight. USA & EU have outsourced their mfg capacity and would take years to rebuild. My heart is with UKR people but I don't see a path to stalemate or victory for UKR.
@florabee9283
@florabee9283 3 месяца назад
The one product I know of and have in my household that was manufactured in Russia is vacuum tubes (or thermionic valves depending on where you learned English). The Soviet-era factory (and pretty much the entire town of Saratov) is owned by an American and many of the devices they produce are copies of western designs down to the artwork on the cartons. Besides that, there are some tea cakes made near Moscow that are pretty good. Oh I also have some matches and stacking dolls.
@georgedone7997
@georgedone7997 3 месяца назад
You are 100% correct. If they would be competitive in anything, their consumer products would find their way to the rest of the world the way products from China do. The only product which found an international niche was the antivirus from Kaspersky. If I look good enough I can find in my house products manufactured in Vietnam, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka (clothing, footwear, children toys) but nothing from Russia.
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
Nothing from most other Western countries too. Have you ever bought German tooling machines? Of course not, they are not consumer goods.
@georgedone7997
@georgedone7997 3 месяца назад
​@@BojanPeric-kq9etI bought a lot of german consumer products including several german made cars, a lot of powertools (Festool), Miele washing machine, dryer, vacuum cleaner, etc. The idea is that it just doesn't happen to be very good in an area which is not adressing consumers (for example tanks) and absolutelly zero in consumer area (for example cars), there is certain permeability between the 2, if you have good engineers designing tanks some would eventually resign and work designing cars and the other way around.
@user-cb2df9zy6d
@user-cb2df9zy6d 3 месяца назад
Kaspersky Anti-Virus remembered, but for some reason the Nginx web server did not, although this is a standard for highly loaded resources.
@sergejadam8860
@sergejadam8860 3 месяца назад
@@BojanPeric-kq9et
@dmitryletov8138
@dmitryletov8138 3 месяца назад
How about NGINX that runs 70% of internet webservers???
@keyto5526
@keyto5526 3 месяца назад
this guy is living in stone age? what about the alcohol? ya right, i assume usa can't handle russia concentrated version of alcohol, so they don't import them.
@ApeAlchemist
@ApeAlchemist 3 месяца назад
Helping the algorithm !
@kobemop
@kobemop 2 месяца назад
There was good growth in Russia between 1999 to 2008 (mostly recovering their economy). However, there's no point in comparing countries that are/were sanctioned and closed off from the world as foreign investment is one of the key drivers of economic growth.
@kobemop
@kobemop 2 месяца назад
Russia is rather doing well for themselves despite being under sanctions.
@EconLessons
@EconLessons 2 месяца назад
Russia is not doing well. It is a bad player in the world and 50% of the people in the countryside have outdoor plumbing.
@donjoaoresort8565
@donjoaoresort8565 3 месяца назад
Who is supplying nuclear fuel to the world ? The fertiliser? Wheat highest exporter
@MrKakibuy
@MrKakibuy 2 месяца назад
you prove his point, all of this is primitive resource extraction
@donjoaoresort8565
@donjoaoresort8565 2 месяца назад
@@MrKakibuy Who makes rocket engines for the US? Russia is fighting with its own arms against the combined arms of 21 major countries in the present war. They lack in consumer goods because Russia has always been geared towards war, as it is never given time and space and peace to breathe by the West, starting from 1854 Crimean war, Napoloen before that, Hitler after that, Cold war after that, and Ukraine in 2014.
@MrKakibuy
@MrKakibuy 2 месяца назад
@@donjoaoresort8565 no you are not. The US have no sent an aid package for 6 months. Ukraine is actually fighting now the combined arms of Russia, Iran, North korea and china. And they are doing very well despite not even having an air force. What makes you think russia creates rocket engines for the US lol? The US would never make itself dependent on another country in weapons.
@reinerdesouza9438
@reinerdesouza9438 2 месяца назад
@@MrKakibuy Mr. Educate yourself of some facts - Russia has been supplying rocket engines to US for 3 decades, and also NASA, even Musk said Russian engines are great! Iran supplied only drones - but for a year now the most effective drone is the Russian made 'Lancet' - heard of it? N Korea only old artillery shells. China is not supplying any arms. All this help is limited. The US gave cluster ammo (banned in 120 countries) the UK provided Uranium shells, (bad for environment) the Germans leopard tanks, Poland Jets and the Danes, Czecks - they all thrown the kitchen sink against Russia. US black Hawk patrols the black sea before attack on Crimea, UK personnel have a hand in Crimea attacks, and the US servicemen man the Patriot missiles! The French the Scalp and the UK the storm shadow; NATO officers present on the ground, as Estonia said, and Germany given everything ..............Yet....The Russians learn and adapt quickly and they made great strides in this one year. The Russians work quietly unlike the talk talk talking Ukies forever blabbering and lying lying lying. Ukraine had airforce in 1991 - Russia Ukraine the arms were divided 60:40. The Ukies did nothing, despite having a big advantage, while the Russians updated their weapons systems. After the war, no one will be able to touch Russia, and if the war continues till 2025, then Ukraine will no longer be a viable nation - as it has not been for 450 years! Sorry, you understand nothing! Better keep quiet and don't let others know your surface understanding.
@annalehman93941
@annalehman93941 Месяц назад
Nuclear fuel is primitive resources? Really? 😂 ​@@MrKakibuy
@johnosullivanPSI
@johnosullivanPSI 2 месяца назад
This guy is a comedian!
@brianmurray1395
@brianmurray1395 3 месяца назад
Well I have Russian rifles and shotguns and for 25 years they have never let me down! They say made in Russia not USSR.
@smk4902
@smk4902 3 месяца назад
The two tools you are comparing are apples and oranges. One is made of ticker steel, the other is made of a thin steel sheet, because it cuts in a different way.
@piotrczubryt1111
@piotrczubryt1111 3 месяца назад
100 years old sickle from Pennsylvania, must be good. What about new sickles from Pennsylvania?
@harleyquinn8202
@harleyquinn8202 3 месяца назад
"What about new sickles from Pennsylvania?" - they stop producing them 100 years ago
@hardtackbeans9790
@hardtackbeans9790 3 месяца назад
Why, yes I have been to russia many times. Not fair to say the poor old russians don't make anything . . . They make lots of trouble. Okay, seriously. Ummmmm, they do make high quality Baltic Birch plywood. They are quite prized by woodworkers. It is extracted from the forest, true enough but then they have to fabricate the panels. They were actually better than most anything you could get made here. But of course most of what they make is destined to the scrap heap very soon.
@vesaruntti
@vesaruntti 2 месяца назад
Aral Sea long as we can call it a "sea" anymore, is fine example what Russia does the best.
@deepinthewoods8078
@deepinthewoods8078 3 месяца назад
I don't own anything from Russia, but i do own an iron sewing machine which says 'made in Estonia'. It's 90 years old, i guess...
@TaiganTundra
@TaiganTundra 3 месяца назад
Russia is literally the biggest weapons exporter, they also make a lot of crude and fertilizer.
@MrKakibuy
@MrKakibuy 2 месяца назад
it isn't. also their weapons are crap, India and other countries cancelled many deals
@TaiganTundra
@TaiganTundra 2 месяца назад
@@MrKakibuy Crap? Seems to be holding up just fine against the much more expensive NATO hardware in Ukraine. Mil equipment is made to be destroyed so keeping it cheap is a good idea.
@MrKakibuy
@MrKakibuy 2 месяца назад
@@TaiganTundra what hardware? The west is using the aid to massively rearm while only sending Ukraine expried equipment from the 70's. Most of the 'amazing' russian weapons get destroyed by cheap fpv drones, and if their production is so good, where are the T14 armatas? I only see old soviet tanks.
@TaiganTundra
@TaiganTundra 2 месяца назад
​@@MrKakibuy Patriot, Abrams, Challenger, Bradley, Leopard, Bushmaster, M777, M113, NASAMS, Bofors L70, M109, RHIB, Stryker, International M1224 MaxxPro, Cougars, Oshkosh M-ATVs, Humvee, 18 155mm "Paladin" M109A6s, MIM-23 Hawk, AN/TWQ-1 Avengers, FV107 Scimitar Mk II, FV103 Spartan, FV104 Samaritan, CVR(T), Husky, just a small list, there's a gigantic wikipedia article on this. Furthermore Russia is also destroying western equipment with cheap drones, so what? What works works so both sides do it. Ukraine couldn't regain more than a few small cabbage patch fields with the epic counter-offensive despite even having a cool movie trailer.
@MrKakibuy
@MrKakibuy 2 месяца назад
@@TaiganTundra Yes and? all of these are cold war technology and not wunderwaffen by any measure. You can keep coping about the counteroffensive but the war is not over and Russia couldn't capture more than a few hundred square kilometers in 2 years now, and how many people did they lose? even the avdiivka "victory" did not achieve anything noteworthy. russia is about as close to win in Ukraine as the US was in vietnam. But hey, atleast you produce supersonic missles (Ukraine destroys oil refineries thousands of kilometers in russia with orders of magnitude less costs)
@michaelnold5820
@michaelnold5820 3 месяца назад
I have been saying this for years! They make no decent autos, nor motorcycles nor anything of quality. And now it’s worse. Spread the word!
@arnoldsaunders6073
@arnoldsaunders6073 3 месяца назад
If a zircon comes your way, I think you will change your opinion.
@duhbigcat1848
@duhbigcat1848 3 месяца назад
@@arnoldsaunders6073 even their military equipment is crap. All Russia has are threats and propaganda.
@rambleon2838
@rambleon2838 3 месяца назад
@@arnoldsaunders6073 Almost all components are sourced from the West. Russian navy ships used to be built in Ukraine and Poland. The Shaheed drones are Iranian technology. Let's see how fast they can bring those refineries back on line with NLA spare parts from the West.
@k66a865
@k66a865 3 месяца назад
Yeah what can they line up with russia made brands against: Adidas Nike Mercedes Apple Samsung Sony BMW Ferrari Versace Siemens Bosch Miele … and the list goes on and on Its zero… like Z
@caveman-zd5yv
@caveman-zd5yv 3 месяца назад
It looks like they produce a lot of weapons.
@bobjacobson858
@bobjacobson858 3 месяца назад
About the only manufactured items I have from Russia are coins, stamps and banknotes--and most are from the Soviet days.
@johnheaton5058
@johnheaton5058 3 месяца назад
Thoughtful...
@cheztaylor8
@cheztaylor8 3 месяца назад
Worth remembering America must be happy enough with the quality of nuclear fuel supplied by Russia. I doubt anyone could use that scythe easily because it has no handles. My father used to swing a pretty mean scythe.
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
Not just that, but US can't produce one type of fuel so it must be imported for Russia. Nobody wants to venture to project to build such facility because there are no guarantees that in few years US will not resume import from Russia.
@cheztaylor8
@cheztaylor8 3 месяца назад
@@BojanPeric-kq9et Odd isn't it. I would have thought self sufficiency in nuclear fuel would have been a mandatory requirement. Russia is apparently the dominant player globally in enriched uranium and continues to supply many countries with nuclear fuel . . . and no one talks about sanctioning that. Not much of a market for scythes these days, I guess. ;-)
@BojanPeric-kq9et
@BojanPeric-kq9et 3 месяца назад
@@cheztaylor8 I don't know technical details, but it is specific type of fuel. I know that nuclear fuel is not like coal or gasoline, there are many types for different types of reactors. Not directly related to Russia, but US didn't sanction China for gallium, but China effectively sanction US for it. And nobody in US administration ever thought about importance of gallium, unlike lithium which is very popular in media. Scythes are essential for next Children of the Corn movie!
Далее
PROOF: Russia's Economy is Collapsing
10:26
Просмотров 142 тыс.
The last one surprised me! 👀 🎈
00:30
Просмотров 3,2 млн
Russian Monetary Crisis - Fall of the Bank of Russia
12:46
How the Resource Curse Will End Russia Economically
15:28
Myth: Russian Economic Growth
5:47
Просмотров 18 тыс.
Russian Ruble is Not Money
10:46
Просмотров 56 тыс.
What does America Produce?
7:59
Просмотров 9 тыс.