Thank you very much for sharing this concert , i am iranian but here and now first as human, and then as middle eastern say thank you for sharing this music , because all human being can hear music , can help others, and yes all human can kill each other...what is the matter with simple fact ...we see it agian and agian in human history... why some of us are under control of politicians, cult maker and thier media ? The truth in music, poetry, philosophy and science...hear to this music ...with hope of peace and love and reason ❤❤❤
I don't know how thank and send my deep love for all who read my comment and send me what i feel best thier best affliction thank you all , with love and hope for peace not only in outer world but for all of you and at all humans inner peace and freedom ❤
I always admire Aynur, she is ageless and a devoted fighter for her traditions. A true rite performance!!! Thank you for offering here this concert to us!
This is an extraordinary encounter that unites two unique Kurdish talents. Through sheer individual efforts, they have not only managed to convey the voice of the Kurdish people across the globe but also showcased the people's exceptional ability to innovate, even under the most challenging circumstances. Hun her bijîn! Serkeftin!
My friend, are you here to enjoy music or deal with ethnic identity crisis? One is Iranian, and the other is Turkish Kurd, and they're making great music. Let's not spoil that with ethnic identity issues!
Ji bo pesindayînê li peyvekê digerim lê peyvê nabînim. Berhemê dest û tiliyên te yên zêrîn li gerdûna me û li tevaya xweristê her zindî bimîne, Keyhan Kelhorî. Her bijî Kurd, her hebî Kurdistan..
Thank you so much for this concert! My Kurdish husband was completely carried away by this wonderful, unique east-western cooperation and all the lovely artists.🤗
I was so happy to see the concert had been recorded. Congratulations to everyone. Even through a screen and hours away from the live concert, it gives you chills and a state of awe.
On Saturday the 20th of July 2024 at Alexander theatre in Monash University Melbourne. I had the great privilege of witnessing the performance of Kayhan Kalhor and the renowned Turkish musician Erdal Erzincan, this experience was truly a once in a lifetime opportunity. This performance demonstrated virtuosity at a level I have never seen before, the level of mastery by Kayhan Kalhor and Erdal Erzincan of both their respective instruments and understanding of harmony to improvise with another musician for more than 90 minutes is magnolias. From the way they utilised every component of their instrument to the emotional complexity of the music, I still sit here in awe of that performance; I truly believe that Kayhan Kalhor and Erdal Erzincan serve as a powerful motivation to aspiring musicians and are one of the greatest musicians to ever grace planet earth.
Aynur bu konseri sanırım kendisi işin vermiş. Uyumamak için kendimi zor tuttum. Kürtlerin yalın klamlarını/ türkülerini böyle tanıtamazsın. Dinleyiciye kafanı kaldırarak söylersin türkülerini, Tara Mamadova, Rewşan, Petra Nachtmanova gibi. Tüm gece dinleyiciden kopuk bir konser olmaz.
Gran versatilidad del grupo. El color de la voz de la cantante concuerda perfectamente con los instrumentos logrando una verdadera armonía. ¡FELICIDADES A TODO EL CONJUNTO!
Eine Starke und Hoffnungsvolle Simme! Aynur beschreibt mit ihrer wundervollen Art das Leid und die Seele Kurdistans! Eine starke Leistung und ein starkes Talent.Eines der schönsten und seltensten Klänge, die die Welt für kurze Zeit schön machen. Ich bin froh dass es Musiker wie Sie gibt, die dass Kurdische am Leben hält.
Ich war früher der größte Aynur Fan, aber mittlerweile kann ich sie nicht mehr hören. Es ist traurig, wie sich ein Künstler derart deformieren kann, schade…
@@carekwere Es geht mir nicht um die Deformierung, Sie ist eine Künstlerin einer der wenigen die uns Kurden eine Stimmt gibt, und das hat sie auch schon vor vielen Jahren bewiesen. Deswegen sollte man solche Stimmen wie Sie nicht ins Negative kommentieren meiner Meinung nach.
@@gurbetkaara Selbstverständlich ist es toll, dass Aynur die Kurden auf der Weltbühne präsentiert und den Kurden eine Stimme gibt, aber gerade deswegen hat sie eine besondere Verantwortung gegenüber ihrem eigenen Volk. Und selbstverständlich sollte man konstruktive Kritik äußern dürfen. Traurig ist, dass sie immer mehr die orientalischen Instrumente aus ihrer Band rausgenommen hat. Zudem kann sie auch mehr als Kulturbotschafterin des kurdischen Volkes auftreten. Warum zeigst sie nichts von kurdischen Tänzen und Kleidung auf ihren Konzerten? Wieso kann sie sich nicht mal von Def spielenden Frauen begleiten lassen? Es ist einfach gecoverte Lieder ohne Vorbereitung runterzujaueln und zwischendurch bisschen Schreien sls wäre sie eine Schamanen, aber wenn sie mehr Beachtung erhalten will, dann muss sie tatsächlich mehr tun.
@@carekwereich mag/ mochte Aynur auch immer sehr. Leider fühle ich die neueren Alben aber auch nicht wirklich. Teilweise ist mir das zu westlich ausgerichtet bzw mir fehlen die kurdischen Instrumente. Ich möchte das jetzt nicht pauschalisieren, da sind auch schöne Sachen dabei, aber generell fehlt mir da was. Ich kann mir vorstellen, dass man sich als Künstlerin weiterentwickeln möchte, Genres verbinden und vielleicht auch mehr westliches Publikum ansprechen möchte, aber leider sind ihre letzten Werke nicht so mein Fall.
What I don’t understand why this is mixed w jazz instruments! Kurdish music is so beautiful when plays w all original instruments,,, I am trying understand the combination, but jazz is jazz not Kurdish. I am glad ppl enjoyed it yet is due not knowing Kurdish music and the very different totally different instruments than JAZZ which is so so western. I understand the creativity of it but Kurdish folk and traditional songs which she sings is better played in its own original art
Hepsinin atası kamanchedir Karadenizde çalınan kemençe ve kabak kemanede dahil kamanchenin türleridir kemençeyi rumlar getirmiştir.zaten Karadeniz çoğu pontus rumu asillidir kemençe ordan geliyor Atina da bile kemençe kültürü var çünkü pontus Rumlardan almışlar kabak kemaneyi kim getirdi bilmiyorum ama onun da atası kamanchedir.bide mardin taraflarinda çalınan kemençeye benzeyen rebab diye Kürtlerin bir enstrümani var onun da atası kamanchedir.
Kurdistan Kurdistan.....why Kurdistan?!! Playing Iranian culture music by an Iranian Kurd. Kurds outside of Iran should leave their crazy chauvinism and learn from these Iranian Kurds.
Love from Iran for Great People of Germany that welcoming and promoting all culture, in particular Iranian Native Music or Persian Folkloric Music 🍀🥊🍀🥊🍀🥊
Her iki kürd sanatçıya hayranım,kürd kültürünün ne denli derin ve köklü olduğunun kanıtları,her şeyde olduğu gibi işgalcilerin bütün saldırılarına karşı dim dik ayakta.
Anadolu Mezopotamya Balkanlar Kafkasya halklarının kardeşliği BERABER mücadele edeceğiz elbette yaşamak için Afrika benzeri halkları! SINIFSAL mücadele ile beraber yaşamak kültürünü oluşturan katkıları beraber Yaşayarak örnek olsun Halklar ve devrimci sınıflar yani İşçi sınıfı ile birlikte Siyasi partiler arasında ortak mücadele Devrim ve Sosyalizm mücadelesinde buluşalım ❤
Üzülerek söylüyorum Kürt dostlar bir devlet olmak istemediler !? Egemenlerle işbirlikçi olmayı tercih ettiler Aşiret feodalizmin gölgesinde kaldılar Bir dostan duydum Kürtler " feodalizmin pençesinde Toprağa bağlı yani tarım toplumu Ağa beyler! Aynı zamanda Bilge felsefe müzik şiir heykel edebiyat beslediler! Adlarını anmayim çoklar! Hepsini sevgi ve saygıyla anıyoruz! Benim adımda Abdullah
