Everything Wrong With Dumbo 1941 

Umm... Dopey anyone?

@@Jellied_Slime_Games we said major the dwarves while still iconic are still secondary characters.

@@CloudyNight2156 oh... Ok.

Holy- you're right!

Duh, elephants can't speak

Natasha Hart might be because it was actually done well the first time and not in an “edgy” sense

I'm pretty sure the new Dumbo will be 500000% less racist as well.

I don't know about anyone else, but I literally blanked out all but the last 20 minutes from my memory. I *know* I watched this movie as a kid tons of times, but I genuinely didn't recognize ANYTHING prior to Dumbo's mom being taken away. I could have sworn the "see an elephant fly" song happened in the midsection, not right at the end.

The original was made back in a time where people weren't offended by everything so...

@@Rockhound6165 lol how the hell do you know that? Did you try asking black people back then? Plus, white people lose their fucking shit when a colored person drank from the whites only water fountain. So yeah, they were major snowflakes back then. Stop being a brain dead parrot.

Even The Lion King somehow got inadvertently cursed. XD Sure, Sarabi gets to see her baby boy fulfill his destiny... But then the voice actor died before the sequel and everyone forgets she ever existed for some reason. XD

@@Guilmon470 Considering that TLK2 continued Disney's grand tradition of exceptionally sh*tty sequels, she should be glad to have not been apart of that movie- aside from the whole, y'know, being dead part.

@@Guilmon470 I always assumed she either just got too old for the pack-activities after Simba took over the Pridelands and retired to chill in a cave somewhere, or was somewhere among the rest of lionesses of their pack and just wasn't given special focus during the events of Lion King 2.

Sharikacat Out of most of the direct to DVD sequels, TLK2 was one of, if not the best sequel.

HONESTLY

Hard these days to defend the crows in Dumbo, what with the internet not doing nuance and all, but it's worth noting the crows are the smartest characters in the film and apart from the mouse the only ones who befriend and help Dumbo. Deserves a minus on a few of those racist sins for that.

Realist shit I've heard

James Owen a stereotype is still a stereotype. Just because an offensive caricature of a group of people turns out to be a good person, doesn’t make it any better.

I hope he never stops sinning Disney racism. I watched these movies when I was not even 6 and damn wtf where my parents thinking making me look at this stuff just because it is drawn.

@@nyx0s389 Go on, say why not, prove it, because it kind of does make it better. Since it was made in a period when segregation was still very alive in the US, I rather like the idea of Dumbo being given identifitably black friends. If you can forgive the 'caricatures', it's quite a nice thing! And really what are we objecting to here, they call each other brother, joke around a bit and sing well in a musical film? Oh and by the way the name Jim Crow does not actually feature in it. What you're seeing is not really caricature, they're characters, black characters for sure, and smart ones informed by their own culture - black culture - most obviously jazz culture. What's most charming and believable about the sequence is it's the black characters who despite the jokes are the most sympathetic to the little outcast - and did you ever stop to consider why? It's because they know what it's like to not be accepted by certain parts of society, that's why the scene works so well. It's maybe not the most subtle treatment of black-ness, but it is certainly not one that er... dehumanises the crows. Would it really be better if such black characters were indistinguishable from white ones? There, nuance.

Ding

That avatar is worth two Sims. *DING DING*

right add 1000 sins

@@nspcrazy1122 'Sins' misspelled as "Sims" Ding

@@mr.boomer8794 r/wooooooosh **ding**

FishyEat Butter LOL

it took me literally one second of seeing the image of dumbo crying and hugging his mother's trunk to begin tearing up myself. works every fucking time. god dammit. fucking hell.

😭

100% me

Don’t you judge me!!!

And he was named using the same logic if a woman named Michelle named HER son, Michelle Jr. This has always bugged me...

Isn't that what we did with Cinderella?

@@rheyapigors5511 ohhhhh

@@rheyapigors5511 yeah

​@Michael Valensi I think you missed his point. He isn't saying things were better then at all, I think he's amazed how something that long ago can have that effect on him and I completely agree. If you don't get effected by Baby Mine you have a heart of stone sir.

I never even felt any emotion watching this movie

@@coquimapping8680 okay edgelord

@@dr.redacted_ I’m not, I just don’t get emotional. I rarely ever do watching movies.

@@goldentony111 i cannot stay dry during that scene. Its still my all-time favorite Disney song.

Correction: "I'm not crying about a non-existent baby elephant, you're crying about a non-existent baby elephant."

You're*

*ding* *ding*

When cinemasins shows they have a heart *ding*

I don't have a crying

Wlaker Boop llama face!!!

But there is nothing wrong with it 😂

He didn't do that movie yet, did he???

@@loganentertainment1814 "They". This channel is more than just Jeremy

Yes

When I was a kid watching it on tape, I always found a way to look at anything but the TV so I wouldn't cry as much. Today, almost 2 decades later, I got choked up and came to the comment section. Guess the feels won't go away

I never cried or felt any emotion during that scene

OH MY GOSH I DIDN'T REMEMBER THAT

I never cried during this movie

Well they did remove the sin for the beginning part of “Baby Mine”, so maybe the trunk cradling was part of that.

I still cry during Baby Mine. But what kind of circus animal handlers would take a baby elephant away from his mother when there is obviously no other elephant who will care for it.

@@karenhall4645 “1941 circus handlers” should probably answer that

I remember being fascinated by the nightmarish sequence back when I was a kid. Suffice to say, I always did find Dumbo to be boring to watch as a whole, but the Pink Elephants on Parade is easily the most memorable and redeeming part of the Disney cartoon.

I was terrified of it as a kid but now it's one of my favorites

I was weirded out by it

That sequence alone is probably why Tim Burton was chosen to direct the live-action remake, lol.

Too bad the rest of the movie is cruel racist garbage.

You were sweating thru your eyes. It happens.

*ding*

Every time I saw that scene, someone was cutting up some nonexistent onions. "I'm not crying about a nonexistent baby elephant, YOU'RE crying about a nonexistent baby elephant!"

You're not crying, it's raining on your face.

I DIDN'T CRY EITHER. But some car drove by and there was a puddle in the street, and it must have splashed some water up on this here face...

Gosh I love that movie. (And it’s actually not too far off from history, save the magic and city of gold and stuff)

Omfg yesssss

Right! Still to this day it's one of my favorites. IDC how old I get (25) i always enjoy it!!

@@hidden_animator522 one of my favorite

Yes!!!!

They did wizard of oz

Wait til Cinemasins does Disney’s Snow White And The Seven Dwarfs.

Cringeworthy comment lol. You kids try very hard to gain subs and it always fail lol

The 30s and 40s worth the golden Era of Hollywood films

I hope this becomes a thing in the future Sins videos.

I’m upset there wasn’t a “ Roll Credits “. 😠

I never watched the English version so I had no idea he said climax this much xD And I don't recall the portuguese version having this word, they must have translated to something similar

@@randalgraves6979 Sometimes when the title is someone's name, there isn't a "Roll Credits" sin with the sheer amount of times people say it.

lol

😂

But *I THINK NOT!!*

@Dandy Crow HAHA, TELL THAT TO LEVI AND NOT FEEL LIKE LEVI'S EMBARRASED

Yep. Right before the bombing of Pearl Harbor

I remember those days, it was like it was yesterday.

I knowww, I could swear it was from the 80's or smth

Communism O'Clock sure

Communism O'Clock you be at least 80 if you were born that year but if you were old enought to watch you’d be at minimum 90 and that’s bullshit

"Pink Elephants on Parade" gave me nightmares for a week after I saw the movie as a kid.

They fixed that in the new movie. I love how he begins to fly and he flies often.

Yep, as a child I was unaware of just HOW RACIST dumbo really was. Holy FUCK that tent building song...

@@bagelbytes6543 same, I felt crushed realising that when it was pointed out. The psychedelic scene is still as disturbing as I remember though

Despite it's obvious flaws (being racist mainly) it's still a good movie.

Isaiah Albers In my opinion, it’s an annoying, racist movie whose animation and humor has not aged well, and which has a few good moments.

@@bagelbytes6543 There were alot of racists, back then it's just one of those things

Because they were drunk at the time too.

With style*

@@kateworkman921 -Per the Hitchhikers' Guide, all you need to do to fly is to throw yourself at the ground and miss.

@@laurahubbard6906 I was literally quoting that whilst watching Shazam this past Friday

Did you look this scene ?

Assuming that we didn't watch the video how dare you!

I almost cried about a nonexistent baby elephant

I don't get it

Jeremy must be psychic...

me too!

"My 6-8 year old mind was so innocent" yeah thats because we're taught racism😭😭😭😭😭

@@tateyannaw.6063 Um no, that's not true, at least not for me, and not for all people

@@samgomez9942 we are taught racism, either directly or through omission, or microaggressions we see from the people around us, and propaganda like the stuff in this movie. let's not pretend or try to whitewash history or reality here

@@twoscoop4932 Dude, I'm not. But we don't teach racism. Just because there are stereotypes that exist in media (like games, movies, etc.) doesn't mean that we are being taught that those stereotypes are an accurate depiction of reality. They've done studies on this stuff, and the studies have shown that people (whether they're black, white, or whatever) have a natural preference for people who look similar to them. I'm not trying to say there aren't horrible racists out there, but I'm saying that most of the time, its just natural to be more comfortable around those who you share more similarities with and can relate to more easily.

@@tateyannaw.6063 correction. “We have to be taught both racism and that racism exists in order to understand when something is racist.” There. Now the poor fella ain’t a racist just for understanding what racism is.

It's so childish but very on brand for CinemaSins.

He also added 20 sins for a random "racist" line in the movie, so...

Should of been more 3 maybe even 5 sins off

@@dannyjorde2677 He added 20 sins for the slavery of only black men and the black men singing about the reasons they "deserved" to be slaves. 20 sins was NOT enough.

@@carmillawoo6505 He added another 10 sins for the scene with the crows

@@carmillawoo6505 Reparations now

13BubblesPlays I teared up so fast

I sing "Baby Mine" to my baby all the time and don't really connect it to this movie, but hearing it made me want to cry.

@@sunflowermouse307 That's really cute actually. And it's such a pretty song too. I bet your kid loves it.

Dead Knows Best you are correct

This is a channel about OBNOXIOUS NITPICKING! Not unbiased overthinking!

@@Sir_Uncle_Ned There is no such thing as "unbiased".

That's merely the people being paid to do their job doing their job.

@@ShroudedWolf51 Disney paying in-betweeners something like 2 cents a frame while collecting that sweet, sweet WPA subsidy money.

R-R-R-R-R-REALLY!!!!!!

You shall not escape my reallys.

This guy again

AND he took modern equipment with him!

It's actually to take advantage of RU-vid searches regarding the remake and generate views.

I’m from Puerto Rico, but I could tell you geography from all over the world.

Nah, fam. I'm here because there isn't an Honest Trailer yet

tee-hee

I fucking died 😂

@@valiang8867 I know, right‽😂

You were alive then or like watched it more recently

Been scrolling through the comments to see if anyone else noticed. Cracked me up. High five!

Only thing I can think of off the top of my head is how they blatantly made it obvious even for those who haven't really read about Miles Morales in the comics that his uncle was going to be one of the villains.

jigglyturd He reviewed that movie on CinemaWins, didn’t he? You check it it out if you haven’t watched it yet

@@PuppetOnions About 200% they're different people

Pinocchio is also a good movie, but isn't it also a little racist?

Isaiah Albers yeah probably but not nearly as much

@wulfgar3000 Idk about racist, but the Kid Island scene doesn't have a lot of good messages lmao

Sad to see it didn't turn out well and Disney went out of business all those years ago. We could have got some more interesting animated movies from them. Oh well.

it's crazy how much on the verge of crisis disney was. like up until as early as the 90s disney was having a lot of trouble and then finally they boomed. amazing rags to riches story with walt disney lol

Eh, it was the 40s shit was rough back then.

Kinda makes you wonder how some people grew up to be so easily offended.

This cruelty exists in real life animal circuses. This is why Ringling ran out of business. You know, Dumbo actually was the start of Ringlings long decline because it shed some light on real life circus cruelty. Interestingly enough, Inactually saw a petition to have the ending of the remake changed so that he would not stay in the circus. And considering how less and less popular animal circuses have become, I actually think this is a good idea.

I hadn't forgotten. I can't watch it because it just reminds me of the real life cruelty, in circuses back then all the way to animals being used for entertainment today. Won't be watching the new film.

What if it ends with the circus shut down and all the animals going to a sanctuary?

How long does it take to build an interstate?

@@NameEntry I75 took 31 years to build from the georgia/florida boarder to miami.

Are you sure that says 75? It definitely ends in 5, but I’m not sold it’s a 7.

Vamos no prekupeychon ok are

*ROLL CREDITS*

Could have made a bonus round for every "Dumbo"

Because its a name

I don't get it. A name must get a "roll credits"? How so? @@afif5496

Time Travel MM No, it’s just usually when they say the movie’s name in the movie they say “Roll credits!”

The media attacks people for that even though it happened years ago but not Disney, because they own the media.

@@skootergirl22 not Disney...uh...I think you haven't been paying attention. Disney has been catching shit for this, Song of the South, and tons of its shorts for longer than most people have been alive. The fact that they literally have a "not to be rereleased" list sort of says anything and everything.

Warner Bros at this time period had released, far FAR worse then this in there cartoons.

Ironically, I think Song of the South is less racist, than Dumbo. Song of the South is naive.

Mad respect for jeremy for adding 20 sins to that tbh

me

Scared the crap out of me as a kid.

Wait, you didn’t understand? He was drunk.

IKR?! Began to reach a level of serious uncomfortableness. LOL!

StoP Pl3as3

Something the creator of this video has never experienced

@@sethhartman7432 HA!!!!!!!!

@@Sinstar33Cause you can't go a single second without taking one word meaning a dirty word? Really? -_-

Disney

@Angel Starwind Okay, I'll buy that. But still, what's the likelihood of, say, two or more people dropping acid simultaneously and going on an identical trip? (Not sure if the LSD-scene from Easy Rider counts, lol!)

@@looneywoman shared 'hallucinations' can be achieved with DMT

@@looneywoman very since they will be talking to each other

welcome to Disney where have you been for over 100 years?

what swamp did this opinion spew out of?

@@brandonalmendares1642 The paved over swamp that is Florida.

Thank you!!! Finally someone agrees with me! I’ve lived here for 11 years and I WANT SEASON GODDAMMIT!!!!!

@@brandonalmendares1642 Even when I ignore the politics of Miami, I actually went there at the end of February because NCL docks there for their Caribbean cruises and learned it's a shithole in politics and traffic management. I am in the Tampa bay area and not even Tampa and Ybor can make up for how crappy this state is.

@@sarahniazi6332 I lived here all my life but just recently picked up a cigar habit after my recent cruise. Florida does have one thing going for it. As long as you keep the indoor temp in the 60-70s, humidors love this state.

i think that's a 100% yes

Benjamin Abramowitz wait... That’s a thing?! I only know about Captain America 1990

Benjamin Abramowitz that’s genius

1998 avengers starring Ralph Fiennes and Uma Thurman

Yudha Bagaskara I need to see that

also how strong were those stork beaks?!?

@@amzz019 probably as strong as ninja who's been weightlifting for his entire life and is on steroids

*their

Unpopular opinion: they are all as completely sad as each other. On its own, the *Baby Mine* scene in Dumbo is as sad as fuck thanks to the fact that Mrs. Jumbo was caged. But death is an extra sad, VERY serious thing, ESPECIALLY the death if a loved one.

You know what always filled me with sadness and dread?There is a scend where bambi heres his dead mothers calling him into an open feild. Only to get chaced by group of hounds

Poor Simba And Bambi And *[(ĐŲMBŒ)]* Jumbo Junior

From driving through the state several times, I gathered that Florida is comprised primarily of sinkholes and swamps with some nice coastal areas tacked on for contrast. It's beautiful, but it's pretty flat.

They got all the crazy right though.

What part of Florida. I lived in Brandon Tampa for 18 years I miss it there.

i didnt visit the states but i think florida is flat and sunny like most of the time

No, but it is very hillBILLY.

Nigahiga

Time stamp please?

04:50

I'm a Marine and I approve this message.

Walt Disney goal was to not make them laugh but to make them cry. He was one of the first to get people to cry over a drawn character.

And they take a giant shit all over the enemy!

He was the only white guy to play one of the crows. The rest of the guys were voiced by African-Americans.

@@franks8010 and he was the leader of the crows. Oh boy.

Probably in May when that movie comes out.

At least 3 sins off for Robin Williams' funnyness in that movie

Aurora’s mother is still alive and well in sleeping beauty.

He blames himself because she perished in a home he purchased for her, via some gas or monoxide leak.

@@brandonlyon730 most...

Yep, in a house HE bought her

Some potent fuckin' Mountain Dew! I've drunk gallons of Mountain Dew and I've never tripped balls like that.

​@@kylebentley7512 the fact that you drank that much Mountain Dew is very very concerning

Aly Cat Plays I didn’t mean all at once🤣🤣

when i was little i literallly didnt understand y the elephant was experience nightmare fuel. I may have been too sheltered at the time

@@kylebentley7512but still

here here!

Senor_Onion THAT MOVIE IS UNSINABLE LMAO

@@LesbiansMarie I'm evil, I know

Senor_Onion don’t worry, I kinda wanna see Cinema Sins sin that movie :P

Senor_Onion it’ll basically be them pretending to be asleep for about 70mins, since The Fox And The Hound is so skippable & boring

They should sin Oliver and Company, Thomas and the Magic Railroad, and Winnie the Pooh (2011 film).

Yeah people say this movie is a masterpiece or something but it’s 90% racism, animal abuse and elephant fever dreams

Back in the days when cinema was not only for snowflakes but actually showed reality and tackled real problems even in a closed society.

People now have the luxury to reject reality completely or project their own little percieved oppressions in their vain pursuit of an individual? group identity? for the sake of any real individual personality or character development.

FlyHigh - Hays Office literally banned adultly, gambling, pregnancy, and anything that “would lower the morals of the viewer”. Yet you call us the snowflakes for noting the factual existence of racism?

@@gzer0xHey guess what? There used to be racism in movies. Hey, guess what... there still is👍 Hey guess what!.... ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rF82lbJM6ik.html

@2manynegativewaves In 1941?

And his film studio would have gone after Disney for tarnishing his brand. MGM was no joke. They would have buried Walt Disney.

@@tigerbread78 He wasn't even born yet. Lizzy would have still been a teen.

@@ObadiahtheSlim 👍

This was probably just Disney not wanting to name drop Mickey Mouse

Except it won't be a drunken scene. No way in a modern kids movie would a baby of any kind be getting drunk AF

The pink elephant on parade was a huge tim burton miss the movie is actually not that bad daddy devito is worth it

I thought so too. The scene wasn't worth buying a ticket.

That movie looks dope .

I watched the trailer to it yesterday, boots wasn’t even wearing boots, that makes me hate dora even more.

cinema sins: An actual Dora the explorer film exists *sin counter immediately goes 130* sentence death

@@calebproductions1264 What irks me is Dora looks too old, and Boots looks cheaply animated.

What pisses me off the most is that they got Scott Lang’s friend from Ant-Man to be in that shit, the poor guy doesn’t deserve that.

Yes!

Scarlet's a thirsty-ass ho for one. Also Ashley, there's only one man named Ashley and that man is Ashley Williams, hail to the king.

@@georgeprchal3924 Hey, I LIKE Ashley McIsaac.

It's a great film, but it's also a very long film. Not complaining, but it would be a very long EWW! I'd have to bring popcorn for the inevitable comment storm after watching the video.

If this video is any indication, he'll only do it if there happens to be a remake of "Gone with the Wind" coming out that exact week.

I dunno. Given that Walt basically had scab artists making this movie because his main animators were on strike (an act that Walt took very personally because he thought he had been wonderful to his employees), I wonder how much of the song is meant to be supportive of grunt workers and how much is meant to be sneering.

@@pompe221 maybe ignorant wishful thinking. The myth of the happy labourer who just loves doing things and is satisfied with peanuts for pay just because they manage to be in a good mood and singing sometimes. People sing and laugh and cheer themselves up sometimes as a coping mechanism, it can be a survival instinct like cats purring when they are badly injured. Sometimes you laugh because crying costs too much. Doesn't mean everything is ok.

@@annana6098 It was a little unclear what I meant, so I edited it a little. I wasn't saying that they actually ARE happy, just that they get told to shut up, get back to work and sing, because they're expected to be Happy Hearted Roustabouts by the very people that are treating them like crap. I wasn't arguing that they're actually happy because they get to work and sing. Bit of lexical ambiguity, my bad.

PLEASE There have been several requests now! It would be fun!