Everything Wrong With Snowpiercer In 14 Minutes Or Less 

the more you know. so how does fish blood clot when a fish is cut?

I thought it was to provoke infection, but this makes sense too

Very neat fact, thank you. +Josue Roberto Infection is most likely a bonus: Hit with an Axe and you survive? Well you will bleed out. Manage to prevent bleeding out? Well now you have an infection.

i thought the fish was poison.

Kyra Davis how the fuck do you know that?

You sir win the internet.

Thank you.

I didn't understand the joke.

they are in a train...their entire life...so they been...

Bravo, sir. Take a bow.

“Yo Madam Supervisor, are you sure you don’t want us to have ANY ammo at all? Not even Rubber ? Alright, you better give my family a life insurance policy.”

Lol I was stoked when I heard that, cause now them guards are *_fucked_* .

Why the acting wasn’t good enough for chills. The movie didn’t look horrible in the beginning, but Overall the movie made no sense and shouldn’t have been made. Utter trash

@@troythemighty3683 I mean, I don't disagree, but there are probably savvy art critics out there praising this movie.

DOGE™ they should fire themselves and try something else

Aw, sh*t

Well basically everyone was

That must’ve been a sick ass kill streak

good.

@@j_rivera2007 that's like... 50 uav's

I know what video you just watched. ;)

Ah, I've found the fellow intellectuals in the comment section.

I just know saw that video too!!

Me two

I saw that video

***** lol. I actually really love this movie.

+Alex Rus It would make a lot more sense if he was more angry then disgusted. That would have been a more understandable scene.

+AmyD You're assuming he was in any fashion proud of eating people, even when he was doing it. He more than likely had a moral problem, and physical problem, eating people in the beginning but found a way to reason beyond it. But I'd imagine it's also because he knows other people eat it, and since he thinks of himself as their protector and helper as he is trying to forge ahead to a better tomorrow, it was a moral repulsion that everyone was being forced to eat the bugs. TL;DR: When was the last time you heard a cannibal say: "We're having bugs for lunch? Yay! I'd totally not rather eat my mother-in-law!"

+AmyD That bothered me too!!!

It's made of bugs... And shit. Human shit.

JayRyan I’ve seen this exact comment on 9 of their videos and I still find it funny

CinemaSins: Chris Evans came out in another movie. Ding. CSins contradicts himself every second and the sins are mostly a total stretch.

@@elderberryva9282 I don't, at least not in that format.

@@Wulfpack1 I love that some people still don't get that most sins that Cinemasins point out is just for comedic relief. It's completely obvious that this is just an act and not real movie sins. He just said "I don't know why but I'm sinning it"

@@servant691 I like Csins. Its funny. What upsets me us when in the comments people treat it like an actual review and dont see the actual good movie.

And boots

its nams jacket

I remember thinking the same thing.

They where passed down from other tailes

@@ElloImNoodle exactly, so why does it fit so well. Do they have sowing equipment or is he just lucky? But I guess it's a jacket, so probably pretty forgiving regarding stature, unlike a t-shirt or something.

I see what you did there :)

It makes sense if you hear the whole speech, he just uses extinct again to make a point

Look at the video connecting those films

@Wary of Extremes link to the video? Thats really interesting

@@aboodyboi Just search Snowpiercer Willy Wonka on RU-vid.

+Jack Duripper That was the only thing I could think when I saw it. Also I think polar bears actively hunt humans, not just have no fear.

+DeepCFisherman Polar bears hunt humans because they have no fear of them as there are no humans in their natural environment. Like nowadays wolfs are the descendants of wolfs which learned that human flash is really dangerous in a long term xD

+Carolus Rex lol

+DeepCFisherman Nothing actively hunts humans, every animal on the planet gives zero fucks humans exist unless they look more like a tasty snack.

***** I'm not saying they brake down doors and hunt people, obviously. But if you're in their neck of the woods, then yeah there are things that hunt humans. Wolves, tigers, crocs.

Well she was in the tail section but not in the complete back of the train, where Gilliam lived. Curtis hung out with Gilliam there and also walked the entire length of the train so he technically walked farther than she did.

Lol cmon dude you know what he meant. First dude who actually FOUGHT his way to the top. Everyone else was handed a free trip.

Plus all the children as well!

Claude isn’t a person

You mean transgender Augustus Gloop

The fire scene was quite good too, and the convo near the end between Namgoong and Curtis

It was acually unexpected and cool I couldn't stop thinking about it for months Now I can't stop thinking about Parasite Director Bong is freacking amazing

Leo Saucedo i thought that was gunna be in the end!

Leo Saucedo yessss lmao he's my favorite character in the movie everything he did was selfless and badass

Oooh. You should write a script about that. Clever idea!

Yup, they've actually been going around in circles for years in a ski resort. It was all part of some nefarious plot to lure all the world's idiots onto this train.

so something like matrix

I suspect the second and third of the Matrix movies were made to keep viewers on the train just to fuck with them, so to speak, but the original Matrix movie was rather insightful. I think DavesWorld's idea could stand apart as original.

Then why would that punished guy's arm freeze early in the movie?

That was the moment I realized I just wasted so much time on this movie lmao so dumb

That's not the point. The bear symbolises freedom and unadulterated nature; a new beginning.

@@geokim8590 Not a very good point at all. Do you know how violent polar bears are?

@@Heisenberg21420 yeah dont they seek you out if they see you?

@@jeremybetz16 Yes polar bears are the most dangerous out of all bears. Famous saying for bear attacks. Brown lie down Black fight back White say goodnight

Aren't accents genetic? His parents are probably Irish.

@@Kevin-fp3vw Not even a little bit. Adults who've lived in one place all their life can move somewhere with the same language and pick up parts of the regional accent. Absolutely nothing on that train should have produced an accent that strong.

@@walonsubilol I was joking get jebaited

@@Kevin-fp3vw pretty bad joke

Kevin damn bro, you got the whole squad laughing

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-jEX52h1TvuA.html

Yeah and the old bad guy at the end is theorized to be Charlie

LSSJ JOHNNY Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory*

Meh, this movie was severely overrated.

@@ilovebeingprecious that still confuses me. The book is called _Charlie and the Chocolate Factory_ , but the first films is called _Willy Wonka..._ even though it's more about Charlie while the other filmed called _Charlie..._ is more about Willy Wonka... Edited for italics fix

rick 123 ikr

Actually it's the original, not the Johnny deep as Wonka version, Willy Wonka and the chocolate factory

rick 123 that's just a theory.

Paul Moitoso a film theory

@@paulmoitoso9658 no it's pretty legit watch the video it's pretty much not a theory

sin 104: Polar bears in the Himalayas? They are sea creatures.

sin 105: What the actual fu*k was this film about?

I know it is a joke but> "Polar bear attacks on humans are extremely rare, and according to records by James Wilder, out of 73 fatal bear attacks between 1870 and 2014, only 20 have been the result of polar bears. "

@@jannespor8922 Willy Wanker, obviously :p

@@Osama-KIN_TMZ01 yes it's rare, because who goes to the arctic to become polar bear snack?

I mean it's been 17 years and I can imagine that most polar bears wouldn't really remember humans so this means that they are neutral until hungry.

Yeah, I saw it as an awesome ending because it leaves so many possibilities. It can be anything from incredibly hopeful to incredibly depressing, whatever your understanding of the movie requires. Though apparently the director just wanted to show life and it was supposed to be a hopeful ending. But who cares about his intent :)

but the left wingers who wrote this, polar bears represent hope and humanity being they are the poster children for global warming, or no, cooling now...

@@cultfilmfreakreviews more importantly, the creators aren't Americans. Climate change denial is a pretty unique American delusion, just like prosperity gospel healers and scientology

Yeah, that was pretty much the extinction of the species. That bear is going to be hungry. If not now, soon. And they're slow moving meat.

If the train crashed by a big city, that'd open up more possibilities.

The polar bear was supposed to signify there are living things surviving outside.

Purvdragon-sensei - A polar bear isn't a human though. It's one thing for a sparse population of cold-adapted creatures to survive the harsh environment, but I would think many of the humans that survived to the end of the movie will manage to survive the harsh outside world. Not unless the train's infrastructure is more intact that it looks at the end of the movie.

+That Sodding Gamer you forget that a dudes arm got frostbitten soo badly it fell off in seven minutes, and they can just walk out there in a parka and not die? I dont see any dead Tauntauns around to snuggle in its guts... unless they brought one of those new-fangled bullets around and a knife to rip open polar bear.

+Spastlcatedtoad Can't help you there.

You don't know what exposition is then

because its colder on the top

Different areas Different heights. Those 7 were on mountain.

I only ever saw 5

@@bait5257 yeah it was the revolt of the 5

Or end up like her mother, as a frozen popsicle.

lol

+Voracious T I like this movie and of cours it's not realistic and I am ok with that because it's not the point but the ending is just bad in my opinion not just the icebear from the moment they reach the front of the train it turns into a WTF marathon

+Voracious T But did you eat baby?

If you think it's only ok, how come you got a poster of it in your room?

Jess when I watched I counted her speech is legit in the movie is dam near close to 6 mins she dose legit talk for the amount of 7 min in the movie .

LMAO

+J158n LMMFAO That got me too! >in tears!

That's racist

lol

Officially using that now

The sins are useless. They've got no sins. They used up all their sins 4 years ago in the les mes revolt.

+Raz Edits Haha good one

Infernape he just adds a "sin" every time he says something

Raz Edits you deserve a 🏅 for that wordplay

The director's name is "JoonHo" not "Bong" btw, Korean names have first/last names switched places.

The arm can't survive 7 minutes without turning into a popsicle but surprise its livable outside.... Even this youtuber missed that one and it was the most frustrating thing for me at the end.

😂

@@Morristown337 A train going at high speed is different than standing outside with little to no wind. Also, in order for ice to form on the track, it has to turn into water and refreeze, which mean it is warm enough to melt the snow at least at some point on a regular basis to have that much ice.

@@6thgraderfriends the windchill wouldn't make that much of a difference.

Breaking the fourth wall... is still a sin. hehe

Heh?

Agreed

I think letting Edgar die was a great scriptwriting move. It showed how focused and determined he was, whilst he loved his friend he didnt place his life above all the others fighting and dying. Traits of a real leader, not allowing his personal feelings to get in the way of objectives and minimising loses to his side rather than himself.

Tentons O'fun i agree with you. and i think it’s unfair to suddenly view a selfish, dictating asshole as a defenceless victim when it’s convenient; personally i thought was fair of him to kill her, she certainly didn’t have any sympathy as she watched a guy’s arm freeze over and shatter and ultimately all the other times she mandated the same thing.

@@barrylyndon5552 thanks to people like you I can get glimpses into the thought processes of regular people who supported Hitler till the end.

3 he said he will never hate a person named bong. And he sinned it anyway.

Aerys Gaming Because sinning the movie isn’t the same as hating it.

omnicowdemon But...he sinned it because the korean director has a “funny” name?

I don't like playing the card, but how is that not racist?

yeah, he sins a lot of things he actually likes, bacause haha so quirky and funny

OuR vIdEoS aRe SaTiRe

There's no indication Gilliam raised him. If anything, his Irish accent indicates he was raised by Irish folk on the train.

He got it from Liam nesson in unknown 😂

That would make sense - I remember thinking, "after everything you've apparently been through, why is ground-up bug so bad?" Hell, people in modern society eat bugs in some cultures.

I thought all the outside shots of the train was pretty crap

In Le Transperceneige they ate "Mama" a bizarre protein which regenerates itself and is housed in it's own car but which they are perpetually afraid won't regenerate, Rats, Rabbits, and the first class ate produce that they grew. I'm not sure where you are getting that they literally drank and ate shit from the upper class.

Ocular Bleach hell I've eaten bugs and they don't taste bad. They taste more like puffed rice.

They left some great stuff out. Like the whole religion based around The Engine? So much good stuff. Still, the film was amazing.

Thank you for the 2+ minutes of unrestrained giggling,

Best comment so far 😂

He was bold as hell

I think it works the same way as their paint manufacturing for the 17 years of school, and all those carriages that need touched up.

I don't get why he had to point it to his head tho. Would have worked if he pointed it above his head as well.

It was a direct reference to the scene where the man refuses to kneel before Loki in the Avengers.

that makes alot more sense thanks

Yes that’s what I said but to me that was only explained in the series and not the movie so I think that’s why he gave it a sin since the series hadn’t e out yet.

socalspirit805 it’s kind of explained in the move in Mason’s Speech “In the beginning the social order was determined by one’s ticket, First class, economy, and Free-loathers like you” so it’s implied they didn’t contribute and I inferred they boarded without permission.

I think its better not to know where they are from because the movie tells you that they are a part of the system and since the movie is a movie about capitalism its more fitting. The poor are a part of the system as well and no intruder.

+Katja Yount Plus it wasn't a Catfish.

+Katja Yount In the director's interview, he said the scene was inspired by the movie "Godfather" where they send dead fish.

+Katja Yount That's what I thought too.

I'll be honest my husband was the one who told me the thing about the fouled blood.

+Katja Yount You're right. I'm pretty sure I remember the director saying it was because the fish's blood was poisonous.

why every one else is living in luxury while the owner living in engine room lol

I think that just shows that he doesn't have any understanding of what those poor folk need to deal with

Plus, there was that moment when Harris said, "she's waking up," It got noisy then, but yeah... I could sleep through that...

clearly its noisy sometimes. otherwise he wouldnt have said it. most likely the engines or the kids running the engine screaming or smething. I dont think he says it randomly

Clearly naming the train "snowpiercer" embues it with the ability to survive those conditions. How could the critics have been so blind?

If you had a perpetual motion engine could you not have an underground bunker that is heated and supplied with electric for perpetuity?

@@OptimusJel its not really possible on earth to have a perpetual motion machine because energy will always be lost to the environment through heat or light.

One of the rails or about 6 to 8 inches wide

I think it became against the geneva convention with the three-sided knife and the musket. Flintlocks leave a gash that /will/ infect

Fish blood acts like an anti-cougulant i think, if one of those axes glanced off you and just cut you the bleeding wouldn't stop for awhile, to use it as a bio weapon the fish would have to be rotting or have some sort of disease/infection already in its blood or guts to pass on.

+Micah “Organ Donor” I';ve been requesting this for like over a year. Probably closer to two. Please people of cinemasins, do this movie, not because I hate it, but because I loved it.

+savcam500 Definatly Battlefield earth.

+Micah “Organ Donor” Which one?

omfg...no! *Judge Dredd* hell yea. The new one is just not worth it unless they do it in 2 mins or less😤

+Micah “Organ Donor” NOTHING is wrong with Dredd.

+KeithWithoutACrew It's worth noting that this was based on a French graphic novel "Le Transperceneige" and in that version the train was 1001 cars long. So yeah, they probably skipped through a lot

It's been too long since I saw the movie, but when that assassin guy shoots through the window at Chris Evans, how many train cars does it show between them? I think I remember it being more cars than they possibly could have walked through on screen.

charles jones and the train in the movie was 60 cars long

SenorPredo - Realistic Minecraft Roller Coasters unless the track was banked inward like at least 30°, it wouldn't have

They most likely transverse through because this is a two hour movie and it would be kind of boring if they just showed every single car which according to the comic were like more than 1000

Yeah that always kind of annoyed me and the same goes for Kim Jong Un too because everyone calls him Kim but that's his last name really

@@brandonlo5162 Well, it's common to use last names when talking about politicians.

Most just call people by what they're most commenly referred to as. If someone comes up and says "My name's John Smith, call me Smith", you call them Smith, instead of John.

it's funny that its the same thing the segurity guy points :D.. and call cap america "fucker"

Mr. Cardboard it’s more the logistics of this whole thing. How many cars are on this thing and how many people do people have to go through everyday. How many times has class been interrupted by someone heading to the club or going through the restaurant because they’re ODing. Idk it just makes for some awkward but comical situations in my opinion.

The very next car was a residential car so that is probably where the families lived.

​@@mr.cardboard3723 Feel bad for wilford though. Poor guy can't even get to the sushi bar without going through the club filled with drugged people. The way he organized the train just completely fucked himself up.

@@theruoc147 there is a tunnel underneath with a kind of train inside and the train is 1001 cars long

There’s a shot where you can see how long the train is, many more carts then we see in the movie

+Jeff Cares Well, it certainly caught my attention!

watch every frame a paintings video on it its great

+Jeff Cares Renegade Cut made a video on it and the director in general who is probably the second most respected director in South Korea right behind the guy who made Oldboy.

+Jeff Cares The train is a metaphor for our society

+Jeff Cares I read somewhere that the reason it never really got looked at in America is because the creators thought that Americans wouldn't get such a complex movie, so they never bothered to release it. But then, Netflix picked it up and people started watching it and it gained a cult following.

Do you use two arms to hold your cell phone? Maybe steve jobs was right about the importance of slimming down consumer tech.

+Herp Derpingson They never found the mythical living quarters.

It was at the tail section

+Herp Derpingson no it wasn't. Except if you mean for the extremely poor people, then yes. For everyone else, no living quarters where ever shown. They didn't even care about the linear construction of a train, that making people walk the entire length of the train to go to school was probably a bad idea. They didn't address that because except for the poor and the conductor, no one lived anywhere. 100s and 100s of people sleeping on the floor. It's symbolism. It's crap.

+Herp Derpingson nothing like the waterchip breaking.

+Herp Derpingson, that became EXTREMELY apparent with the propaganda video bit. Almost made me want to ask, "So, which vault did these people come from? 111? 8? 69?"

This is apparently because in the novel, it's not bugs, but literal waste from the upper class cars. They were literally eating bars of shit. Apparently they filmed that originally, but post-editing decided it was too much for editing, hence the crappy CGI used in that one scene, when the rest has been great.

@@aetherofthenorth9700 that makes so much more sense and I wish they just left it alone lmao. Thanks for this trivia

@@aetherofthenorth9700 they kill each other with axes, talk about eating babies but shit bars were too much...

​@@wiezyczkowatayes , they are too much .

Same

You should watch this movie it's amazing

S7Robin I have, I didn’t really like it though

@@freshpeanut4967 Yeah I didn't like it either, was too 'avante-garde' for me. The scenes were shot in a chaotic manner.

@@s7robin105 no it was a shitty movie. and a very cheap political propaganda

*+George Broughton* lol, add it to the list

+George Broughton It's implied that when the Chinese/Korean/Japanese man looked out the window in the greenhouse car that he saw an animal.

+Billiam Clinton I thought he saw the plane wreck which he used as a guide to show the snow melting away?

+Khaleel Rahman That was a different scene. That was during the tunnel fight scene with the axes and hooded men. The greenhouse seen is later.

Khaleel Rahman how did that dude see that with a his eyes

Pssh. Still legal in most parts of the world. I'd tap that, in Canada, Russia, China, India, Greenland, Iceland, Japan, Australia, New Zealand, anywhere in South America, most of the land area of the US, almost all of continental Europe, and the entire UK and Ireland. ** The chart I'm referencing was last updated 6 years ago, but yeah it's probably about the same

Not to mention almost all of the US.

Yea, but the age of adulthood is 19 in Korea, where this movie was made in.

+internationalpirate0 the age of consent in South Korea is 13

Still technically 18. Possibly 17 depending on when you were born in the year. Koreans are already 1 at birth. Hence why they have a Korean age and a "rest of the world" age.

I'm glad someone else said it. It annoys me how little awareness Americans have about British accents.

I literally paused the video to scroll down the comments hoping someone else pointed this out 👍🏻

James Newcombe not to mention she nailed this I had know clue it was her till about 1 hour in

@@NateApplicable Americans think we're just one big cockney island.

Oh no people can’t distinctly label another country’s many accents! People here in the US can’t even tell you where our own accents come from so how the hell do you expect them to know another country’s accents? 😂😂😂

+Blake J. Stone Wasn't it to foreshadow the need for night vision goggles?

It was a stylistic choice, much the same as the buttons on the front of Vader's costume. How it functions isn't important because it isn't crucial to the plot. If it looks cool and doesn't take the audience out of the film then it's all good.

*+Matthew Aubry* Vader's buttons imply some useful functionality. There is nothing useful about those hoods.

goodvibrato​​ Yeah there is. They're ominous as FUCK! I see that in a train car and I'm quitting the rebellion right now. Also the function they obviously served was to keep blood out of their eyes. Not some 'implied' functionality. Don't defend Vader's buttons, it makes you look like a whiny fanboy.

+Matthew Aubry I see guys wearing hoods that cover their eyes and i'm MORE likely to fight them because they're blind.

SarcastiCat But the ending fucks it all up

I think that ending was someone else's idea because they probably had no idea how a movie like this should end.

This is based off a book.

The ending is awesome

The ending is great it makes people think and feel hopeful and hopeless all at the same time

This, I'm not even a particular fan of this movie but this video is just so stupid and doesn't get the point at all. Well, what did I expect coming here from the baby driver analysis.

Taking Cinema Sins seriously and complaining how he doesn't get movies is like assuming that furries in bear costumes are real bears and complaining that they don't maul people in a realistic fashion. And doing this on a Snowpiercer video is some kind of next level of irony lol

@LightNessITA it's just an entertainment video which can have anything and everything. There are serious points, joke points, self aware bad joke points, recurring points, recurring nonsensical points, points making fun at himself, etc. It's just a guy talking about movies in this weird format.

left wing allegory.

@Roseki they should really center on the fact it's about "spreading the wealth around"

The show is really good

Also the show has way more cars than the movie did. 1001 to be exact. It obviously is hard to walk all the distance.

Мармеладов ТВ re phrase that for me please

@Мармеладов ТВ to generate heat and keep them from freezing to death.

Mohammad Zekereya thank you dude

+giantWario I get the feeling that if they hadn't made the "bad guys" of the film so ridiculously hate-able and impossible to relate with, we would have been rooting for the elite the whole time.

+adoredpariah I still was! lol. I was like "Dont stop the train, you'll all die you idiots! Think of the ecosystem!"

+adoredpariah Why?

XyZlll XyZlll Because like Wario's post points out, if you look closely the "heroes" are more like idiot jerks. If they aren't endangering everyone on the train's lives, they are eating babies or running headlong into gun lines. They had to make the "bad guys" so ridiculously over the top to distract from the fact the protagonist and story's heroes aren't very good.

+Pervy Sage why?

+Pervy Sage Weeaboo.

+Steven Wills i'll do the martian!

+Pervy Sage There's hate in that word.

+Steven Wills you should look up "honest trailers the martian" i thought it was funny

Tyler Durden they already did that video twice

Whats the one rule?

He implied maybe The Godfather is one such movie?...

R.I.P we will always miss him

+Trumpepe Oh, shut up. He was an outstanding actor, he deserves some recognition for his services.

+Trumpepe Why are you so negative? It's doesn't suit you, brother.

what the f**k? is Alan Rickman dead? is this a joke? I'm panicking over here? give me answers! I'm about to Google this and if you're lying I'm going to be so disappointed in you.

+Hopeless Enough yeah he is dead. R.I.P.

Such an underrated "4th wall breaking" scene

Torrin Owens eating people wasn’t okay. He was literally breaking down into tears remembering it. And just because one disgusting thing is gross doesn’t mean a less disgusting thing is no longer gross. That’s stupid logic.

@@yeahkeen2905 Hmm calling me stupid does really make me want to listen to you

Torrin Owens I didn’t call you stupid but okay. Either way it doesn’t make me wrong.

MrHeems polar bears don't play 😂😂😂💀💀💀

+Myles “Corey Grinder” Johnston Well this one was on Netflix for a while, if you have that. And You only get a small taste of the WTF present in the film in this sins video.

Mike E Oh yeah, I get that is what these are, for me though it gives me enough of a 'sense' of what the film is, you know? I don't remember it being on Netflix in Australia, maybe I wasn't looking hard enough. All good though.

Myles Johnston Well I'm USA, so maybe that was it. Stupid regionlocking on digital content.

Mike E All good, I had figured that could have been the reason. Yeah, it's a bit of a pain in the arse but, you never know what they might do in the future.

don't watch it's dreadfully boring

Really doesn't mean all his movies are good

so? anyone can be made fun of and it doesn't amount to all their works being good. Enough ass-kissing of the man with the trophy.

@@samchau3476 Sam Chau What do you mean by 'so?'? The narrator is saying as if this director named Bong is a nobody, which actually isn't. I'm merely pointing out FACT, that he won Oscars, not saying that all his works are great, and I don't see how is this even ass-kissing, duhh. 🙄🙄

@@song3035 lol butthurt it's just a tame joke, get over it

@@samchau3476 Me butthurt? By a comment left by a total stranger on the internet? Nahh ain't got time for petty things like this 😂

Bruh

And the guy killing a pregnant lady

@@micahbell9093 she deserved it... Also, double kill... *ding*

@@micahbell9093 or the bodyguard executing a random rich guy and one of his own soldiers for basically no reason

I think they explain general idea in the movie, no? The world was actually frozen but is slowly thawing. Wilford was as clueless as the rest in that regard, otherwise he would've simply stopped the train and used the slaves he had build new authoritarian society.

@@NJ-wb1cz Yes, it's slowly thawing but what the hell would he use to build and sustain a society and a still frozen world. He already has a sustainable ecosystem in the train in which I'm pretty sure would be difficult to sustain outside of the train

@@kevinbanh5421 his train ecosystem is wholly dependent on people not being able to leave the train. Remember those three corpses? If the next bunch of people would survive the escape then they could simply destroy the tracks and ambush Wilford. The moment the world starts being barely habitable his only chance to protect the society he created is to stop the train and c create a settlement around the free energy machine.

God this is an old comment, but I just felt like adding my interpretation of the answer. Curtis makes a pretty blunt point about midway through the movie that he felt regret for still having both arms. This is inferred to be both because he hadn't sacrificed it by standing up in an act of revolt and being forced to lose it, or by voluntarily sacrificing his arm to feed the masses. He held Gilliam in high regard for his sacrifice. So, when he saw Timmy trapped down there, after promising Tanya he'd save him, that was his moment of sacrifice. This was him giving his arm in the same way Gilliam did, and so many others did. It's not so much symbolism as it is the conclusion of his arc. He went from unable to make that sacrifice, and not believing himself to be a leader, to being forced to be a leader, to finally taking on that role and making the needed sacrifice.

+Lullu Edge For real! I was starting to feel like I'm the only god damned sane person because it seems like everyone else in the comment section loved it. What a piece of shit movie. Packed to the brim with cliches (oh mai gawd the main character has to choose between saving his friend and moving forward with his goal in an extremely contrived scene how original), shitty writing ("AND I KNOW THAT BABIES TASTE BEST BOOOHOOOOOOOOOOOOOO"), terrible, and horrible CGI (except for the train crashing scene)

then you haven't seen many movies in your life.

+PARAN0IDxGERBIL completely agree. It was just random violence without a good story.

But Jeremy said he loved it. Maybe it is a good film, but the premise is too stupid for me to care.

I mean if you have ever tried to travel by train in Sweden during the winter you know how laughable this fucking movie is....

Tom Doyle Cause it is still narration, me thinks.

if he had seen it once that would have been enough. He also wasn't locked away the whole time, he had to have had invented the security systems.

Florian Laur they say in the movie he had just been put in prison.

Bruh were you high when watching the movie?

Ok so... in the novel the “food” the tail section eats is literal shit, like in the movie they call it “shit” so it’s likely that the cgi bugs were a quick fix

Which also explains the logic, or lack thereof, of the whole damn movie. I am pretty sure you have to be drunk or on day 5 of insomnia to understand this ...whatever it is.

+Wraith Wrecker Geez I see a lot of love for this movie in the comments (I really have, btw), but no real reasons given. It seems like you're just loving it for the sake of "getting its 'deep and thought-provoking/original plot'" that really isn't any of those things. Come up with something more supportable. Sheesh.

+Wraith Wrecker Don't get me wrong, I don't hate it... I simply see through the pandering pseudo-intelligent themes and messages to find that not only does it fail to serve its purpose, it focused to much on its point to properly explain itself. MANY of the comments stating that it was "fantastic", "outstanding", etc. only said that and gave no reason leaving one with the impression they were either joining the bandwagon of love or that they didn't see past its façade into its flaws. And those that argued with those that called it out went with the "you simply failed to capture its deep/insightful/meaning... you are (too young/dumb/etc) to understand" argument.The fairest comments about this movie were middle of the road, they pointed out the enjoyed its visual differences but that the plot was lacking.

jtq1995 The filmmaking(camerawork, lighting, editing) was superb, the acting was wonderful, the action was very well done, the social commentary was powerful(something very rarely seen in Hollywood), the characters were convincing and had motives(more than can be said of most movies). I could go on, but you get the point. People saying this movie is a piece of shit are just wrong. And keep in mind that it's Bong Jun-Ho's english debut. For a debut into Hollywood, I'd say it's a raging success(its marketing was awful though. Barely anyone saw it in theaters). If you don't mind, WHAT exactly do YOU qualify as "pandering"? Most Marvel movies are full of what I'D call pandering, but I don't see ANY of that in Snowpiercer. And what about the plot was lacking? I felt the plot was very compelling and something we've not really seen much of in other movies. Sure, the movie has some flaws, but there's too much excellent filmmaking, performance, etc for me to hate it. And besides, the concept is not cliche and compared to other movies, this one is nearly devoid of cliches in general. The thing I like most about the movie is that it's ambitious. The school scene, the nightvision goggle scene, the new years' egg scene, the scene when they're shooting at each other from different train cars, etc. The ideas behind those scenes would be shot down in a splitsecond by Hollywood producers and I applaud the filmmakers for gambling on them, because they worked. So when you say, "The plot is lacking", what do you mean? What exactly was "lacking"? I don't see it, to be honest.

+Badger0fDeath I felt like the action scene between the guys in leather jackets was pretty epic though. idk if it was just me but you can almost see the rage in the lower class people mixed with the sort of pseudo entertainment that the leather jacket guys had.

+Wraith Wrecker Being a corporation hating liberal even I thought the class warfare theme was extremely heavy handed. Maybe they were trying to make it so ham fisted that even the typical 24 hour news network bred and raised American dumb ass got it. But I think it could have done with some subtlety.

Glad to see you here man, we are always between the first who sees the video

+fabrizzio Aldana always anxious to see things I missed

*+Couch Tomato* lol what? The average length of a Cinema Sins video is about this long.

+goodvibrato a few lately have been like 20 mins lol

+riflemanusa why is that?

they froze his arm within 7 minutes outside but the world is livable outside in the end?!

@@Morristown337 to be fair they were also moving extremely fast, and his arm was bare

@@pinkorange4980 yes

@@Morristown337 and temp different in other areas

Yea probably, but is odd to see that they had no bullets when guarding the people and all of a sudden they do with zero explanation.

+boy638 It was explained, they never actually ran out of bullets. The scheme with Gilliam and Wilford was to trick the underclasses into rebelling so that they could cull the population. To accomplish this, they told the guards in the tail section that they were all out of bullets, and just kept the actual bullet supply near the front of the train. if it hadn't have been for that trick with the torches, the rebels would've all been hacked to pieces in that tunnel, decreasing the surplus population.

+boy638 They always had bullets just not enough for every guard, that's why the ones in the back only had to pretend they did because everyone was afraid and wouldn't fight back, and the ones in the middle actually had weapons. Once they got too close to the front they started using bullets.

+boy638 they were preparing for another rebellion dumbass

+Chinedu Opara That isn't a plot hole, actually.

+Ricardo Savino 2001 makes Interstellar look simple and straightforward, i don't think they can sin it because i don't rhink they can understand it.

***** Yep, Stan Kubrick. Probably...

***** If you read the book, you will see that there´s no mistery in the movie!

+Ricardo Savino But this is Cinemasins, where the books don't matter.

Codysir oh, I know that... that was just a tip for our friend that struggled to understand the movie!! But I´d really love to see CinemaSins and Screen Junkie doing this one!

It's been 16-17 years... 12:34 AM 5/18/2020