Тёмный

Filters for Deep Sky Astrophotography 

Nebula Photos
Подписаться 200 тыс.
Просмотров 90 тыс.
50% 1

Learn about using filters with your DSLR for deep sky astrophotography. Summary and glossary at: nebulaphotos.com/resources/fi...
--
Support this channel on Patreon: / nebulaphotos
or by using my affiliate link when shopping for astrophotography gear at:
OPT - bit.ly/31XDk9d
or High Point Scientific - tinyurl.com/highpoint-nebula
--
Twitter: @nebulaphotos
Instagram: @nebulaphotosdotcom
--
MUSIC:
Moon Shadow by Little Glass Men is licensed under a Attribution License.
freemusicarchive.org/music/Li...
--
Table of Contents:
00:00 Intro
02:07 Do I need a filter?
08:07 Where does the filter go?
13:21 What filter should I get?
15:18 I'm in Bortle X, should I get a LP filter?
16:57 Technical underpinnings and further thoughts

Опубликовано:

 

2 июл 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 217   
@bkm83442
@bkm83442 3 года назад
I really like that your channel doesn't ignore the beginners with a DSLR. So many astrophotography channels focus on high end specialized astro cameras that are out of reach for many people.
@6Eternal9
@6Eternal9 3 года назад
I don't understand why would someone dislike this amazing video which is absolutely free , I watched both ads in starting of video till end , I subscribed your channel because you explain each and every part in so detail it helps so much , thank you for sharing Love from India :)
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Glad you liked it! Clear skies, Nico
@caviestcaveman8691
@caviestcaveman8691 2 года назад
Yay now in 2021 everything is happy no more dislikes on RU-vid videos the world doesn't like negativity so now its taking the first steps to get rid of it!
@NotnaRed
@NotnaRed 3 года назад
That was so thorough and organized you could be a librarian. Thanks for the input, much appreciated!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
🤓📚 Glad you liked it! Clear skies, Nico
@ssbhide123
@ssbhide123 2 года назад
Isn't he already a librarian at the Wolbach Library of the Center for Astrophysics?
@aarijkhan8093
@aarijkhan8093 2 года назад
Nico really deserves more attention. He is always delivering top quality master class type content with glossaries etc... for absolutely free! Massive respect
@kevinashley478
@kevinashley478 2 года назад
I have to say....you are to astrophotography what Bob Ross was to painting. So many owe you thanks!
@NatarajanGanesan
@NatarajanGanesan 3 года назад
One of the best videos so far. The latter half was particularly very useful. A refreshing revisit to some basics.
@TermoneenyCC
@TermoneenyCC 3 года назад
Thankyou for taking the time to make videos like this to help others.
@johnseniura8026
@johnseniura8026 Год назад
Super informative. This one video answered so many of the questions I have had about filters and astronomy cameras in general!
@Rajesh-cg5pz
@Rajesh-cg5pz 4 года назад
Wow!! Exactly what I've been waiting for!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Awesome, hope it helped
@sofamiller7133
@sofamiller7133 Год назад
I’ve mentioned some of this on other videos of yours, but I live in a small town with a Dark Skies organization that lobbies our local government, so there’s an outdoor lighting ordinance and the new traffic lights are Dark Skies compliant. We get tourism for agriculture, wine and cider, and our dark skies. A friend’s mom asked us if that blotchiness in the night sky was clouds, this woman in her 50s seeing the true vastness of our Milky Way for the first time! You can likely imagine her shock on hearing what it actually was
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos Год назад
It truly is amazing to see it for the first time. That is great to hear about the success in your town!
@ryanmichaelhaley
@ryanmichaelhaley 4 года назад
Finally! I've been looking for a video like this ♥
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Great!
@kenkoskela3357
@kenkoskela3357 3 года назад
Excellent job on these videos! Very clear teaching and helpful to those of us trying to learn astrophotography. Thanks!!
@egarcia0033
@egarcia0033 3 года назад
Thanks for cover in depth filters for DSLRs for all of us newbies!
@warrenhill8022
@warrenhill8022 3 года назад
Great info, thanks Nico
@sc4r3crow1976
@sc4r3crow1976 3 года назад
Great video once again. Very instructive and clear for everyone I think. Keep it up
@mm_137
@mm_137 Год назад
Thanks a lot! This was really helpful ♥️
@deancamp4914
@deancamp4914 3 года назад
Very useful - thanks Nico.
@adityathakur2653
@adityathakur2653 Год назад
Excellent video! Really interesting and so well explained. A big thank you!
@toddnoseworthy1447
@toddnoseworthy1447 3 года назад
A LOT of info. Great video!!
@stewartpope8305
@stewartpope8305 Месяц назад
Thanks for the great video. It really helped me understand the different filters and how they are used.
@TheDicsolovag
@TheDicsolovag 3 года назад
Very good approach to this topic and very informative video!
@igoreq4495
@igoreq4495 4 года назад
I've been looking for such a video about filters! Spot-on Nico, thanks!!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Glad I could be helpful
@miodragpetkovic6142
@miodragpetkovic6142 2 года назад
Vau. Full support. Nice and easy about most important questions about filters.
@l.m2517
@l.m2517 3 года назад
Thank you Nico for this amazing video !
@alexsaptetrei
@alexsaptetrei 3 года назад
Very concise video. Thank you
@jrags35
@jrags35 3 года назад
thank you so much for this !!
@mrkutube
@mrkutube 4 года назад
Excellent educational video. I enjoy your videos Nico. Please keep them coming.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Thanks! I plan to
@southernexposure123
@southernexposure123 2 года назад
Many thanks for this and your other videos. I'm a beginner with just enough experience to begin having filter questions. You answered those questions and saved me significant time and money by making those important explanations. I'm already subbed and appreciate you very much for sharing your experiences,
@raziqkanani7059
@raziqkanani7059 4 года назад
Thanks for making this video Nico it was super helpful!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Thanks Raziq! Clear skies, Nico
@EricTViking
@EricTViking 4 года назад
Another great video Nico, I really appreciate the minimal use of music and that you just get straight into the information. So many channels seem to focus on glitzy productions, arty cut scenes and all sort of other un-necessary garnish, keep up the great work mate. You have another Patreon 👍
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Thanks Richard! I appreciate the support!!
@unrealspetznaz
@unrealspetznaz 3 года назад
Agree 200%
@williamford5270
@williamford5270 3 года назад
Wow, thanks. This helps a lot.
@woody5109
@woody5109 2 года назад
Thank you sir, being new to this you have alleviated some serious stress for me, not to mention cash.
@ponapo9653
@ponapo9653 Год назад
Thanks man!!!
@philippefenain4405
@philippefenain4405 3 года назад
Great deal of useful information ! I am not anymore a beginner but not yet an advanced astrophotographer, and your explanations have clarified a lot of concepts to me !! Thanks 🙏
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Great to hear Philippe! Clear skies, Nico
@danwray5626
@danwray5626 4 года назад
Good explanations, Nico!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Thanks Dan!
@vladimirmachek2524
@vladimirmachek2524 3 года назад
Great work, thank you very much. Very helpful form me.
@user-yd1zl1tv8x
@user-yd1zl1tv8x 9 месяцев назад
Wow, Nico!!! Yours is a monumental introductory exposition of astrophotography and visual filters. Well done. Thanks for the details. I found it useful that you spoke of DSLR and Astro-DSLRs .... (Digital cameras were at their infancies when I studied photography.) Nice job. Thanks for posting!
@aaronramos6056
@aaronramos6056 3 года назад
What a boss, i really like your videos ! The quality of your explanations !!!! You got one more sub :D Clear sky
@OriaXu
@OriaXu 4 года назад
Great video! Just like your image processing videos, it is very well explained!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Thanks, glad it was helpful!
@abood-2639
@abood-2639 4 года назад
Your content has been very helpful as a new astrophotographer beginning in untracked deep sky :) thank you and keep up the good work
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
You're very welcome. I'll have more untracked videos this summer
@pi198273
@pi198273 4 года назад
Great video as always. Keep it up and stay safe.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Thanks!
@JeffClay-clayhausphotography
@JeffClay-clayhausphotography 3 года назад
Great intro to filters. Looking forward to the roundup. As a long time Pentax shooter just want to point out that Astronomik does make clip-ins for the full frame K-1. Unfortunately my two Astro conversions - full spectrum and H-alpha - are on APS-C bodies so will look into 2” filters.
@CoandaImageServices
@CoandaImageServices 2 года назад
I’m really glad I watched this before I bought a filter. I live in a Bortle-8 zone in South Korea and I’m much better served driving to the mountains than I would be spending a lot of money on filters that would ruin any galaxy photos I shot.
@harry_wardd
@harry_wardd 3 года назад
Buckling up to watch these awesome tutorials. Your video the other week on the Great Conjunction was so helpful that I managed to catch a decent image! I then attempted some deep sky photos for the first time untracked- failed miserably but during my stretching noticed deep yellow casts which totally ruined the photo - so looking forward to clueing up in these whilst I wait for my star tracker 🙌
@MountainFisher
@MountainFisher 6 месяцев назад
I found the information very good even though I don't do much photography. I use the Neodymium Baader Moon and Skyglow for visual in different scopes as it's one of those filters that works and works well for visual and photography. Daytime Moon is awesome with it when the Moon is out. It just makes things stand out more as well as working for DSOs with a camera.
@TMG_Dude
@TMG_Dude 3 года назад
Came for 5:57 stayed for the thorough information! THANK YOU IMMENSELY
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Awesome! Clear skies!!
@TMG_Dude
@TMG_Dude 3 года назад
@@NebulaPhotos You as well ! ^-^
@toanthai
@toanthai 2 года назад
Very informative, Nico. I learned so much. I have started this week with my Canon 6D modded, Rokinon 135mm and Star Adventure 2i tracker. I live in bortle 8 so it’s difficult for sky imaging. I ordered an Svbony 70ED and considering of getting L-enhance filter. I am not sure if long exposure might cause trailing since I won’t be using auto guiding. I just want to keep things simple for now but still want the filter to enhance the contrast.
@xaviergonzalez4800
@xaviergonzalez4800 9 месяцев назад
I replaced my ir cutting filter in my canon with a quartz glass lens because it allows a wider range of the light spectrum (from the beginning where ultraviolet begins to where infrared ends) there for the camera can capture more light in less exposure time. On my guiding camera, I was able to see twice as many stars using less exposure than I started with. This is great for polar alignment guiding cameras. My mod is made for infrared photography as well as ultraviolet photography, but I am using it now for astrophotography. Quartz silica glass lenses are made in China for 5 to 10 dollars at that size.
@TheMajestic1971
@TheMajestic1971 4 года назад
Years ago I made the step to go for a BCF mod on my canon 1100D, I was totally blown away by the difference it made and still use it today. (I remember how my jaw dropped when I saw the first images of the Orion nebula.) I can even use it for daylight photography, I only have to adjust the white balance since everything is more red. Good video Nico!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Yes, modded cameras are really fun. And good point, I should have mentioned that modded cameras can be used for daylight photography, either by setting a custom white balance or buying a OWB (original white balance) filter which are sometimes available.
@DLMVegas
@DLMVegas 3 года назад
Thanks for this video Nico. What I have now realized is that I HAVE TO GET my Nikon D810 or Sony A7RIII modified to use the clip in filters from Astronomik. Since there is a problem in modifying the Sony cameras I have, that only leaves my Nikon D810. Heavy and rear screen focusing sucks on the D810. I've tried shooting the Horsehead Nebula and Rosette Nebula with very little success using my stock cameras. On the Sony side I'm using a 100-400mm lens and on the Nikon side I would be using the 150-600mm Sigma lens. Haven't tried the 4-5 minute exposure thing yet either. Keep the videos coming though.
@JustAskThisDad
@JustAskThisDad 2 года назад
IF YOU ARE NEW TO ASTROPHOTOGRAPHY .. SKIP TO 5:57 for Nico's clear advice about filters.. then you can watch rest of the video for information/entertainment purposes... Thanks Nico!!
@unrealspetznaz
@unrealspetznaz 3 года назад
Again, another informative and entertaining video. I hope you could address, in a future video, the question of what to do in cities where the change to LED is rapid (should we throw away our light pollution filters?) Thank you so much!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Thanks! I'm still working on my light pollution filter reviews and will address this a bit in that video I think.
@brendanmanning1959
@brendanmanning1959 Год назад
Thanks
@martynh5410
@martynh5410 2 года назад
This was a lengthy but very informative and useful video Nico. Thank you!
@danjensen9425
@danjensen9425 4 года назад
Yes you made the filter video. I’ve been waiting . I’ve only used an astronomic cls in a none modded t6i and not sure if it helps. Now I no why not much difference if any . I think the mix of led sodium vapor and mercury is the reason But not to worry just a half hour drive to bortle 2 or 4 and will be getting a dedicated Astro camera like an asi for nebula galaxy and Jupiter moon or Saturn, just not sure which one but a cooled one for sure as summer days are often over 100
@creeper360bill
@creeper360bill 4 года назад
Filters don't really work on broadband targets for most people, they can actually hurt the images. On emission nebulae you should see some improvement with a CLS but it may not be that much depending on your LP. www.reddit.com/r/AskAstrophotography/comments/glq0u9/waat_the_weekly_ask_anything_thread_week_of_17/frbeag0/?context=3
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
That's great that you are within a half hour of Bortle 2. I'm envious!
@tomreid7
@tomreid7 2 года назад
Have a stock dslr and new to astrophotography?, no filter needed, thanks Nico, I'll come back to this video when I'm more experienced.
@willdobson79
@willdobson79 Год назад
The Don! 🙏👌👍
@TtoTheOmarse
@TtoTheOmarse 2 года назад
Hi Nico. I'd love to see you test out the Kase light pollution filter at some point to see how it stacks up. It's super cheap but they don't seem to have published any performance data. :)
@PaniczJaszczur
@PaniczJaszczur 2 года назад
Great video, as always, but please show us that furry beast crying behind the closed doors in the next video! :)
@kevinashley478
@kevinashley478 2 года назад
The "informed decision" is very important. I tell my kids to always question everything and everyone, no matter their status, until they clearly understand what they are being told. "You cannot make an informed decision if you don't have the information."
@eacron
@eacron 2 года назад
This was great!!!! so much great information! but I wasn't clear is there an adapter for a 2" filter that would go between a crop sensor camera (Nikon) and a dslr lense or would I have to get something like a redact. I'd really rather use my Nikon lenses if I could for the time being. I live in NYC.
@EricTViking
@EricTViking 4 года назад
BTW could you do a dedicated video on making Bias frames, darks and flats so that we can refer to a single video for the info? I haven't got the process committed to muscle memory and can never remember whether flats are at the same focus and settings as the lights, and which ones have to be done at the same temperature etc... Thanks 😁
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
It's on my list. I'll try to have it done by September
@siegfriednoet
@siegfriednoet 3 года назад
Another very well explained video, you make it all so understandably thank you !So if I get this right, I am now using a mirrorless canon and so I am better of buying 2 inch filters if later I want to use a filterwheel with dedicated astrocamera like a ZWO 2600 or a B&W camera ?
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Correct. 2" filters are the most versatile.
@edwinsanchez1167
@edwinsanchez1167 3 года назад
Hi Nico! Can’t wait for your next video comparing filters, meantime I am not clear on dedicated cameras, do they have the I/R filters built in as the dslr? I was thinking about modifying my dslr but at the same time eventually I want to buy a dedicated cooled camera but I’m a bit confused! If dedicated camera has same issue maybe I just modify my dslr and don’t switch😩 be well, clear skies!!🤝
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Some are full spectrum (need to buy your own uv/ir cut filter) and some have an Astronomical uv/ir cut filter already installed (ha mod). None that I know of have the more extreme ir cutoff of your typical DSLR. So no worries there if you buy a dedicated astro camera. The cooling is also really nice! Hope this clears its up! I'd be happy to answer any questions about specific camera s too!
@edwinsanchez1167
@edwinsanchez1167 3 года назад
Nebula Photos thanks Nico, yes so that makes sense, my savings are still not there to buy a dedicated cooled camera yet but I am sure I will ask your opinion I just would like to get one that its easy to use like the dslr that you just focus and shoot sort of, you know what I mean. Stay safe, keep them coming and clear skies Nico! 🤝
@ronstewtsaw
@ronstewtsaw 3 года назад
I would think the obvious filter size for a lot of setups (mine, anyway) would be T-mount dimensions (42 mm thread, 0.75 mm pitch). (For those who don't know, normal 42 mm photographic filters have 1 mm thread pitch. Don't ask how I know.) Let me know if I am wrong, good people.
@filippobussi8955
@filippobussi8955 3 года назад
Hi Nico!! first of all thanks for your patience to explain everything in great detail. if i didnt get wrong i can use a clip in filter both with telescope and lenses right??
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
That's right!
@NetlistPCB
@NetlistPCB 2 месяца назад
Start with a cheap red #25 filter. The atmosphere is more transparent to red light and tends to reflect blue and green light back into your telescope.
@LXIXXX
@LXIXXX 2 года назад
As far as trackers go, check out the Omegon MiniTrack LX2 or LX3. I think they cost less than the MSM, and no batteries or power required.
@southernexposure123
@southernexposure123 2 года назад
Thank you for your help. I have a cheap telescope with a lot of CA. I'm using a Canon crop sensor DSLR and a Panasonic Micro 4/3 camera for astrophotography. I'm not sure I'll get a full frame camera, so is there a need for me to get a 2 inch filter? I think a Baader Contrast / Fringe filter will eliminate a lot of the CA. Am I limited to using clip in filters? I prefer to use threaded filters because of wanting to use both my cameras to see which one I prefer for the hobby. I've been looking for, but I haven't found tubes threaded for filters other than eyepieces and Barolws. I do have a set of macro photography extension tubes, but I don't think they're threaded for filters. I also have an adapter for eyepiece projection, but I can't tell if that will hold a filter. Can you point me in the right direction for locations of and the names of the products I need? Thank you very much.
@xDNightmarex
@xDNightmarex 4 года назад
nice and informative video, guess for now I'm best off w/o a filter :-) reading some of the other comments and you're looking for topics for new videos, here's an idea to think about: why does stacking actually work? So if I take 400 shots at 2 secs why is it the same as a tracked 800sec shot and how big is the difference between let's say 100 stacked, 300 stacked, 1000 stacked (I tried 100 shots at 2 secs with my crappy gear and only got something that looked like the classic windows starfield screensaver [even with stretching] but with loads of noise , but in contrast a non-tracked 20-30sec exposure looks somehow better)
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Thank you for the idea! I like this idea a lot and it would be good to test and show results. A lot comes down to post processing, but I don't doubt there are differences as you noticed. Clear skies, Nico
@Zane_Alto
@Zane_Alto 3 года назад
Just saw your video on the Orion Nebula and I was going to comment "long hair gang💯" but i decided to come to your newest video so that you will most likely see it, just to see that you cut your hair 😭😂 Do you like it more? I just started wearing man buns all the time. also i am just 16 and cant afford a proper astrophotography setup yet but i still have been enjoying your videos!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Glad you've enjoyed them! I almost always cut my hair in the spring to get it off my neck for the summer months. By the next spring it's long enough to donate it again.
@sammorgen
@sammorgen 3 года назад
This is a nice video. Of course I will buy first a star tracker but I must say I have some entry-level filters for "normal" photography (HD, CPL). should I take those off when photographing the night sky?
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Yes, definitely take them off! Good thing to mention. Clear skies, Nico
@shiniforever
@shiniforever 3 года назад
this is so intrasting i'm soooooooo happy that you went out with so much info as i am unable to find anything worth while online ,thank you !! quick question, ive removed the IR cut filter on my own and didnt replace it with a clear glass how much will that effect the focus and where can i get the Ha filter that you talked about ?? ( Canon 70D )
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Hi Shini, I'm not sure. It would definitely be a minor effect, perhaps not noticeable. Have you noticed any issue with focusing since removing the filter? I know that is why the professional services replace with clear glass (so the backfocus stays the same). Since you didn't install a clear glass, you can achieve the same effect with a 1mm shim between the optics and the camera. May be hard with lenses, but easy enough with a telescope. Astronomik is the biggest source of all kinds of clip-in filters for the Canon DSLRs. Here's an ha clip-in that would fit your 70D: www.highpointscientific.com/astronomik-h-alpha-12-nm-eos-clip-filter-ha12-eos
@shiniforever
@shiniforever 3 года назад
@@NebulaPhotos thanks so much for the info and happy new year, tbh i am not so sure if it is because of that of because of the L enhance filter that i have or if it is because of star trailing as i am using sky guider pro with a sigman 150-600 mil lessen , however if you want i can shear some pf my photos that i took and maybe we can get to the bottom of this ?
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
@@shiniforever sure. Send to nicocarver at Gmail dot com
@xtrithx4389
@xtrithx4389 2 года назад
I use filters to help reduce light pollution because I have sooo much light pollution from where I live. In order to get something barley visible like star clusters,galaxies and nebulae I have to use a filter or the pictures get way to bright and are unuseable or poor quality. Just looking at Saturn and Jupiter I can't see much detail unless I got far away from the city which I can't go out much.
@SmeeUncleJoe
@SmeeUncleJoe 3 месяца назад
"Filter Finder Tool" ... Did you ever get around to that ? That would be awesome. I just bought a ASI533 MM MONO and I want to use it on a Ritchey with FL of 1625 mm. Anyone have any suggestions, for DSO's, without breaking the bank ? Also, since you put out so many great videos, can you suggest a video or more, from your library, that i should watch
@SergeyKravchenya
@SergeyKravchenya 4 года назад
Thanks for the video! Are you planning to make a similar series of videos about software for astrophotography?
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
I'm always looking for new video ideas to add to my list. What kinds of things would you like to know about software for astrophotography?
@SergeyKravchenya
@SergeyKravchenya 4 года назад
​@@NebulaPhotos There is a lot of software for processing photos/stacking and do all those kinds of stuff with astrophotos. So the first struggle I faced with is - can I use just one tool like PixInsight? Or will DSS + photoshop could replace PixInsight (probably not, but why?)? I'm really at the beginning right now. I use DSS + photoshop and just want to know what the options are. Some of the programs are pretty expensive and there are a lot of them. So it is good to know what alternatives you have. I hope it all makes sense. Thanks again for all your videos! I've learned a lot!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
@@SergeyKravchenya got it thanks! I'd probably need to do two series. One for acquisition software (APT, PHD2, SGP, BYEOS, etc), and one for processing software (like the ones you mentioned). Cheers, Nico
@nivedkrishna8212
@nivedkrishna8212 11 месяцев назад
I will mix the infrared data by only focusingon it and combine it with visible light
@josephnaja
@josephnaja Год назад
Nico, do UHC clip in filters really help? I have a Canon EOS M10 Camera that I use with my 8 inch Reflector. Thanks
@PhilipLeichauer
@PhilipLeichauer 3 года назад
AliExpress seems to have clip in filters for Fuji and Sony
@SalarHaghighatafshar
@SalarHaghighatafshar 3 года назад
Thanks for your nice and informative videos. I was thinking that using narrowband filters on the IR side of the spectrum will be a completely waste of money if your camera sensor is not astro-modified (either full-spectrum or without IR-cut filter). Am I right?
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
I'd say that would make your life very difficult, but I have seen some do it. Eventually I hope to run my own tests, as it's not something I've tried (narrowband filters on stock DSLR)
@brendanforward7322
@brendanforward7322 9 месяцев назад
Hey bro, really like your content and how you approach explaining multiple aspects of astrophotography. I have a question for you if you don’t mind: I just got my first CCD camera (ASI 183MC Pro) and I was interested in knowing if I need a UV/IR cut filter? I was looking at a 2” filter with a, filter drawer. Not entirely sure how it fits in the image train, but I was thinking a 2” field flattener, the filter drawer and whatever m42 extenders I need for back focus. So in a nutshell wanted to know do I need a the filter /drawer and if so how would you place it?
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 9 месяцев назад
Yes, the ASI183MC Pro only has an anti-reflective window, not a full-on IR-cut filter internally, so for best results I suggest getting an astronomy-specific 2" IR-cut filter. Most field flatteners have internal threads for this type of filter (2" filter = 48mm threads). If your field flattener has that feature, you would not need a filter drawer.
@anuranjan0101
@anuranjan0101 3 года назад
Great info .. Subscribed...! And dude what happened to longs hairs..i liked them better 😂
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
I cut my hair about once every year or two
@anuranjan0101
@anuranjan0101 3 года назад
Its shame there are no professional to do astro modification for my dslr and i cant risk doing by myself. I dnt know if there is any way out.
@southernexposure123
@southernexposure123 2 года назад
I'm still trying to find the answer to my question from 12 hours ago so I kept scouring the Internet. Here's what I think is at least part of the answer. Please correct me if I'm wrong and please confirm if I'm headed in the right directon. To insert a filter I must remove the t adapter from the t ring, screw in the filter as far as it will go, and then reinsert the threaded t adapter. My scope is the Orion ST-80. I don't think the focuser is made for 2" accessories. If I use 2" filters do I need to upgrade to a focuser manufactured for 2" accessories? Is there an adapter that goes from 1.25" up to 2"? If so would using such an adapter still contribute to the famed vignetting I want to avoid? Thank you.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 2 года назад
I have a Orion ST-80 and by default as you say it doesn't have a 2" focuser, it's t-threaded. Normal T-threads are 42mm, a 2" filter has 48mm threads. What you would need to use a 2" filter is a 2" filter drawer with 42mm t threads on the outside. I think such a product might exist. Check out Agena and other online stores. Other options might be to get a field flattener that has allows for threaded 2" filters or to change out the focuser. Those would probably both be more expensive than a filter drawer. In terms of threaded filters, 1.25" may work for M4/3 if you can get the filter close to the sensor, but for APS-C and full frame DSLRs, you are going to want to use 2" or clip-in.
@satanite13
@satanite13 4 года назад
Hey Nico, great explanation on the filters. As a side note I’d like to ask you where can I get my T3i rebel converted to a full spectrum camera here in the states? I know you’re based in MA and I’m okay with sending my camera to the east coast but would be great if knew of a service on the west coast too, thanks.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
Hi Rohan, I believe lifepixel is on the west coast and can do a full spectrum mod for your T3i.
@satanite13
@satanite13 4 года назад
Nebula Photos oh perfect! I’ll check them out thanks a lot!
@cucubits
@cucubits 3 года назад
Sooo, when are you planning to release your light pollution filter shootout video? I've been reading about these things for a while now and I'd really love to get my first one but still can't decide.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
I'm trying to get it done this month. (been saying that for a few months now- I am new to reviews and so it's been a learning curve for me and taking longer than expected). Feel free to email me with your specific info: gear, sky conditions, goals, and I can advise. nicocarver at gmail dot com
@edgarsi
@edgarsi Год назад
Hi Nico! Thank you so much for your great review! May I ask you, what do you think of Universal Astro light-pollution filter? Looks like the new player in the market with a very reasonable price! Have you had a chance to try this one out yet? thank you!
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos Год назад
I haven't. Thanks for the heads up
@SarvanshVisuals
@SarvanshVisuals Год назад
Hey how am I supposed to know how should the histogram on an image look like for untracked astrophotography.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos Год назад
It doesn’t matter for untracked. With untracked we are almost always underexposed so just use the NPF rule, fast aperture, and a high ISO and take as many as possible
@deltacx1059
@deltacx1059 10 месяцев назад
Higher end Fuji cameras have their own matrix patterns.
@mimcan70
@mimcan70 3 года назад
Hi which brand is that cheapest tracker in your video?
@guevura9611
@guevura9611 Год назад
Clip-in filters for Nikon????? Where can I find for apsc?
@astrostar_clearski7041
@astrostar_clearski7041 3 года назад
Hi. Im in Bortle 5. I can not see the milkyway, will a filter help me with that? I have a canon 600D Stock. I just want to see the milky way, so i was thinking that there must me a filter for me to get away from the light in my bortle 5? No led lights here where i Live. Old lights on the country :)
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
The milky way is a broadband target. Filters don't help bring it out in my experience. Even if you cant see it in a single shot, you should still be able to bring it out with hundreds of stacked photos from Bortle 5.
@kisho2679
@kisho2679 3 года назад
One needs a tracker for DSO, right? But for solasystem photography one might need a lightpollution-filter if photographing from city/aglo (independent of tracker)?
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
No. Solar system objects are fairly immune to the effects of light pollution so no LP filter needed. They are very particular about seeing so you need to look up forecasts and ideally be in a good location for that. Deep sky WITH filters requires tracking. You can get started in deep sky without filters and without tracking. See other videos on my channel for guides on that.
@hateswhitewhales
@hateswhitewhales Год назад
great video! ALOHA!
@donr6234
@donr6234 4 года назад
👍
@Sergeant_Nugget
@Sergeant_Nugget 3 года назад
Honestly, I can't find many for Nikon. I only found 1. Ohayo makes LPS filter but for the front of the lens. Just put it on like any other normal filter (I.e. UV). I have a Nikon D5600 and been a pain... feel like astrophotography is really mainly for Canon
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
The hard thing for the clip-in filter manufacturers is that Nikon kept changing the internal structure of their crop-sensor camera bodies, while Canon was very consistent. The D5600 has a great sensor though, so you should still be able to get some cool shots! Clear skies, Nico
@another3275
@another3275 2 года назад
Thanks for your share, I have got canon 6D stock camera, im about to buy h-alpha 12nm filter to be able to take better milky way pictures to reduce light pollutions, any suggestion? please
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 2 года назад
I'm not sure if you are going to be happy with the results of using a H-alpha filter on milky way with a stock camera. Do you have any examples of someone doing this that you think looks good?
@another3275
@another3275 2 года назад
@@NebulaPhotos After watching your video I have decided not to buy h-alpha filter. I have purchased CLS filter and Moveshootmove star tracker. I think best budget choice for me.
@cedriccappelle2036
@cedriccappelle2036 4 года назад
How do I know how aggressive the IR cut filter is on my camera?
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 4 года назад
We can make imperfect comparisons by shooting ha emission nebulae with different cameras and comparing the response. A more technical way would be to shoot a white light source through a diffraction grating and study the spectra. I might have more on this in future videos
@jdawg2771
@jdawg2771 3 года назад
To be honest.. there’s not on star in the sky where i live.. but one big question here.. If you just look through the filter.. no camera.. Will you see a difference? Using any filter?
@petset77
@petset77 Год назад
I came here from another video of yours, suggesting that for live sky viewing, a filter is not needed. ...I haven't gotten to that point yet, but will touch on your first explanation, which is that adding a filter isn't going to add to light bands already removed (filtered out) by another filter (in your example, a DSLR). Another newbie in a forum I belong to asked if it's possible to stack filters. ...being a rational thinking mind (IMO), I suggested that blocking more and more of a very dim deep space object might not improve imaging. As for this presentation, I never did get to what I was looking for. ...perhaps I came to the wrong video, since the "Do I need a filter" segment didn't cover live viewing (I'll back browse to verify the reference). Perhaps the human eye isn't sensitive enough to appreciate what a filter does for night viewing. I get that human eye aperture is very small for space exploration. My consideration is based on partial explanations via other videos, without any reply other than "Start with tracking". I don't want astrophotography at this point. I'm new at astronomy. I want the best views I can get with the 8" dobsonian I have. More than one vid showed initial one second photo made by a digital focuser camera being better than human eye viewing. All went on to take many other pix to stack for amazing photographs. One suggested the obvious: that even a short exposure snapshot from medium aperture telescope mirror is more sensitive than the small human eye. My question is: would a few short exposure snapshots taken with a focuser cam then stacked with one of the computer apps bring detail and color to things like Nebula or galaxies for a live viewing session if a laptop was brought into the fold? Any input will be appreciated. ....While a lot of what you discuss in this video is above my head, it's well presented. Thank you.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos Год назад
Let me know if you can find the reference as I don’t remember it. Filters for visual astronomy through an eyepiece are a whole different subject and basically nothing in this video or on my channel applies to that subject. Sorry! Yes, even relatively short exposures (1/2 sec.) with a modern digital camera will show way more detail than our eyes. Our eyes work like video cameras so each exposure is only 1/30 sec. Which is not much time for the dim detail of a deep space object to develop. And yes to your question about a laptop with small focuser camera. That is a whole growing field of amateur astronomy called ‘electronically assisted astronomy’ EAA. The idea is to do ‘live stacking’ where the image develops right in front of your eyes on the laptop. There is free software like sharpcap, DSS live, and others that work well for this method.
@petset77
@petset77 Год назад
@@NebulaPhotos, thank you for the reply. It was indeed EAA videos that had me asking the question. No one else explained much, other than "get tracking", which I perhaps will do in the future. I'm new to the hobby, so visual is where I am at this point... plus, as an old guy, I want to know how to scan the skies myself before punching in known numbers. Anyway, thanks again. and have a happy Holiday Season.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos Год назад
I think it is definitely admirable and a good idea to learn visual astronomy without tracking or 'Go To' first. Most of the youtube videos I've seen (mine included) only focus on photography, maybe because it lends itself to the visual medium better. If you have a local astronomy club, I think you will find many amateurs are interested in visual / EAA and will be happy to help. Have a wonderful holiday Steve and clear skies! Nico
@constellationshots3893
@constellationshots3893 3 года назад
triad filters are scary expensive but thank god that opt finances. And by focus do you mean auto focus because if so, I don't use auto focus, I only do astrophotography and not day time.
@NebulaPhotos
@NebulaPhotos 3 года назад
Hi Varun, Yes, it would mainly effect autofocus. Another reason to replace with clear glass is to protect the sensor.
Далее
OSC Narrowband Filters - What to buy?? Let's compare!
24:36
The GEAR Behind My Best Astrophotography Images!
14:49
Просмотров 114 тыс.
The right equipment for visual deep sky observations
12:46
What are filters and should you get one?
10:26
Просмотров 26 тыс.
Are Broadband Light Pollution Filters Any Good?
11:23
This weird metal is insanely bouncy
18:03
Просмотров 9 млн
Best Light Pollution Filters for Astrophotography
33:55