The executions in this movie are the most realistic Ive ever seen. Thats what actually happens to a human body if its shot in the head. Goes limp instantly. Insane.
She was intelligent. And that doomed her. Lesson: Never demonstrate your intelligence in a way that threatens small minded superiors who have supreme power over you.
@@frootlooper thank you for clearing that up, I was under the impression that most managers I've met are boot licking morons, must've miscalculated on that one.
@@Jhonatan5 I doubt they were any worse than anyone else in war or wielding immense power. History would back me up on that, despite what others who would like to distort reality may say.
Super concerned as to how you are experienced enough in seeing people shot in the back of the head to make the determination that this scene was "realistic"... maybe a different word would have been a better choice?
@@karmasauce6288exactly. The same reason why the Soviets murdered thousands of Polish military officers and intelligentsia POWs and buried them in the Katyn forest. Same cynical barbarity…different uniforms. Apparently the Soviet Union was our ally in the Second World War. It was, and still is, a mad mad world.
Bullshit. Are you a sheep? Never again. If you are going to sign, the manager has to prove it to you that he is correct. Even in the armed forces you have tools to defy an order.
@@murphyhastings1457 My apologies to all the Roman citizens here. Marcus Aurelius Antoninus is the name in latin, Marco Aurelio in my native language Spanish. Obrigado
“A smart person knows what to say, a wise person knows whether to say it or not” I’m guessing she thought she would get brownie points for being a graduate of the university of Milan.
It’s the casual way that guy shrugs that gets me. The terrifying thing about the Holocaust and other atrocities is that the perpetrators were just people. It’s horrifying to think that, in their position, any one of us could be just like them.
@@holidaycat I'm German and both my Grandparents resisted. They were ordinary people. They had no higher education but they knew the difference between right and wrong. They resisted individually, and were dispossessed individually. They met and married after the war.
Not everyone. My Father was in Hungary when the nazis took over. He left school and joined the French Foreign Legion, to fight. Later, he escaped a Nazi POW camp. Yes, a Jew who fought. And because of that, I am here.
Just saw Taken with Liam Neeson yesterday on Hulu. I loved him in this movie and saw it 3 times in the theaters. It is a reminder of the horrors of war and the evils and goodness of man. I remember this scene as one of the most powerful of the movie.
The Russians now like Putin say they hate communism and call Ukraine communists and yet they invented communism, like Karl Marx and Lenin and Trotsky, all Jewish.!
*Schindler’s* *List* ✍🏼 Ralph Fiennes was an absolute phenomenal actor during the movie. Every single seen with Amon Goeth was entertaining and always gave off that unpredictable/uneasy feeling. Of course Oskar Schindler’s character played by Liam Neeson was *just* as amazing. 👏🏼
Right lmfao! Its like the more positive you try to be, the more youtube trys to bring you down by showing you the darkest most depraved clips they have... haha
You know, I'm getting the same vibe. I get the steak videos and the guys playing with guns. The Sopranos stuff and the girls with the dress Hauls. I even enjoy the people with deer videos. How does it add up to Schindler's List all of a sudden?
@@JPKILLER.That was HER* performance, and also that’s entirely realistic, because it would take around 30 seconds for her reflexes to stop, because her musculature would still have enough impulse.
@@withlessAsbestos Te lo digo en español, un tiro en el cerebro anula cualquier reflejo, cae como gelatina, puede haber reflejos postmorten, pero su forma de resorte no es una muerte realista, he visto muchas ejecuciones reales, y así no actúa un cuerpo siendo disparado directo al cerebro.
@@JPKILLER. Lo entiendo esto, pero aun me parece que este reflejo fue realista porque fue demasiado rápido. Entonces me parece que esta fue une reflejo en realidad. Lo siento por mi Español, no es mi idioma primera.
@@mauriceholloway8913 its just a caricature, admit it or not they were innovative, had technology beyond their time, even after the war was over the allied forces wre scrambling to recruit them for their knowledge and expertise.
I got upset that they killed her off. It's just like killing the smart one in the room because she's 10x better than this nazi dude. I bet he got the ultimate punishment in real life for his actions!
I did that at my last job while learning the trade. Even worse? I was just asking logical questions. He told me, "we don't pay you to think." & I quit within a month of that comment. I tried to move past it, but it really sat with me.
@@garrylove8955 That, but she should have followed Rule 46. She was so confident and well-spoken, she demonstrated her educational background and unintentionally made the “Superman” feel inferior.
His portrayal was very convincing. Spielberg himself admitted that he developed feelings of hostility unconsciously towards Fiennes and the actors wearing SS uniforms.
remember they had a ton of input from the actual people who were there. They would have been more than able to describe/show what their loved ones deaths looked like.
Yeah and it is still happening now a days only that the boss can't shoot employees because the law is different now, abusing them is already the same thing as shooting them
She didn't die because she was right, or educated. She died because he felt she was out of line. She dared to speak to him like that infront of others. I do not think she realized how insecure her position was. She felt as needed or necessary. She thought she had value and that is what he didn't like.
I think you’re overthinking it. He’s a nazi, she’s Jewish. There’s no line to be out of because he doesn’t even see her as a human being. For him to be insulted or have his insecurity called out he’d need to see her not only as an equal but as a person, and that is definitely not happening.
@@heebeejeebee3168 nah it happens. U ever seen a dude get knocked out on a street. Their head bounces off concrete. And if u ever seen execution vids this happens as well. Don’t talk when u don’t know shiet.
For all those dating he killed her because she's educated and he felt inferior to her. No. She was a Jew. He felt nothing but hate. Amon Goethe was a monster. One of many. It's just too bad he killed so many before they stretched his neck
Considering how close in ideals Socialism and Communism are I was always puzzled at their hatred of each other. Both require large, powerful central governments, both see the state taking over large portions of the private sector which usually work better as they were, both pump out endless propaganda and neither can handle any form of criticism.
Correct. It's all marketing to the people, so that they have a populist endorsement to legitimize a single-party ideology ... which becomes a totalitarian state. Dems in the US are halfway there.
The cruelty and disregard for life is what’s so appalling but that’s the banality of evil. He felt she made him feel inferior and that’s a no no. The minute she said she graduated he felt lower as if it was an insult to him personally. She knew more about construction than he ever would. And then when he invokes on my personal authority you know she is doomed. I felt bad for her because she was surrounded by monsters.
@@_9br And you don’t have to speak for the rest of us. I thought it was a very good, step by step psychological analysis of the characters’ thought processes, character development, how that scene unfolded, and why. Very good example of the banality of evil. I generally find that the lowest thinkers limit everyone else involved. I read that Hitler might have won the war if he hadn’t filled his trains with so many people on his kill list that he couldn’t move his troops around fast enough or supply them with enough food and ammunition to do their jobs. What fine and tragic irony, that is.
@@user-vb6gl6nf7c If you read that then you read a bullshit book written by a moron, as that wasn't the reason Hitler lost the war. Germany never stood a chance to begin with. There was never a scenario where they could have won.
This scene gave me chills, he killed her because he wasn’t going to argue with her, even though she was right and after he has her killed, he orders the workers to take it all down anyway
You must react with chilling shivers when you hear a cold blooded monster like Amon saying to the prisoners he considers less than slaves or even humans, to "politely asking" (ordering them) to stay away off him... just to spare them from catching the flu he's bearing. You know he's really not concerned for their health or well-being lives, but maybe to prevent many of them off any contagion spreading, and getting too sick to work for him and Oskar
I've seen real executions on Liveleak and this one looks as real as the those I've seen. No extra special effects, just shown as it is. Brutal and almost surreal. Amazing movie.
I’ve always had so much respect for her strength of character in this scene. Maybe she said a little more than was asked. But how she remained calm and stuck to her principles even after realizing she was about to die is inspiring and encouraging. She seemed young too. I don’t think her reaction was as humble as it could have been in that particular situation speaking with a Nazi officer…but humans aren’t perfect and her going on was probably in an effort to show him that she really knew what she was talking about rather than to show off. When she realized she was about to be shot you can tell she was terrified, and that she felt the injustice of it…yet she didn’t plead for her life. She didn’t scream or get angry or cry. She accepted it with the utmost dignity..yet stood her ground. I just love her character in this scene so much.
This whole scene shows how you cannot reason with hatred. It's a fantastic scene. She was doing exactly what they asked her to do and they still killed her for it. It goes to show that hatred is pure and there was no mercy. Absolutely fantastic scene.
Will never forget seeing this movie at the theatre at 13yrs old with my parents. I felt frozen to my seat for the entire movie. When the credits rolled everyone in there was silent, no one moved until the lights came on. Was a haunting memory of an incredible movie of such a terrible time in history.
what makes me even more sad was that are people got to go home as heros the entire world new who the good and bad guys were now and days in war both sides are bad guys
I have, in fact, seen people shot and killed before, and yes, this is just about as accurate as I've ever seen in a movie. To the point that it's somewhat unnerving, from the way she instantaneously limps over to the actual effects for the bullet wound, it's very real.
These are pretty realistic, so I don't know what your on about. Watched a few "real life" videos myself, and this is like almost 1:1 ratio correct, except I have no idea why her body shot up like that.
@eatyourvegetables1449 I've actually seen that happen to in real situations, I don't know for sure what causes it, but I think it's just something to do with the nervous system sputtering out and springing one last time before death. Again though I really don't know.
