Hogwarts Legacy | Ray Tracing ON Vs OFF Graphics Comparison | RTX 4080 Ultra Ray Tracing

Подписаться 455 тыс.

Просмотров 38 тыс.

50% 1

Today we are Compare the RTX Ray Tracing Graphics Comparison of Hogwarts Legacy on RTX 4080 with Max Setting and Ultra Ray tracing on and no upscale like DLSS or FSR 2.0. Just Pure original Raw 4K Footage. Share your thoughts, leave a comment also Subscribe. #HogwartsLegacy #rtx4080 #GraphicsComparison
------------------------------------------
PS5 | PS4 PRO
Xbox Series X|S
Capture Card: elgato 4k60 S+ | Live Gamer 4K - GC573
PC Specs:
CPU: Intel 13900KS
Motherboard: Asus Tuf Gaming X570-Pro (Wifi)
Cooler: DeepCool Liquid Cooler LT720 360mm 4th Gen Dual-Chamber Pump
Memory: Corsair Vengeance LPX Black 32GB DDR4
SSD: Samsung SSD 980 EVO NVMe M.2 (2TB)
Graphics card: Zotac GeForce RTX 4080 16GB AMP Extreme AIRO
Operating System: Windows 10
Monitor: LG 4K 32Inch
------------------------------------------
Channel description / Info:
All videos on my channel are my Own original content which I Played & create myself or Capture & record myself. After that then edit them in a way to enhance the viewers experience and provide best Ever quality content. I also do Lot of Tech unboxing videos and Games Graphics Comparison.
Do not allow for my content to be uploaded or used without my permission

Игры

Опубликовано:

14 фев 2023

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 166

@star_man Год назад

I actually prefer it with the raytracing off. I think it's like a lot of games that are using new effects they tend to overdo it to try and "showcase" it, but it can just end up looking awful. I remember when bloom was first introduced suddenly every game had eye-wateringly overdone bloom on every surface, and it looks like the same thing is happening at the moment to raytracing as it's the new cool thing to sell graphics cards.

@muresanandrei7565 Год назад

You are mad because you can't afford ray tracing shut up

@dembipor Год назад

Absolutely. In this video you can see a place where old wooden floor behaves like a mirror, which is completely unnatural.

@TheCgOrion Год назад

I was thinking the exact same thing about it. I definitely prefer it off in this title. Plus, I can downsample 4k to my 1440p screen, which looks better yet.

@ripto93 5 месяцев назад

Perfect comparison, i still remember oblivion and that blinding bloom...

@bonbontheway9458 Месяц назад

yes but the out side looks alot more natural

@bananaman4894 Год назад

The Ray Tracing seems to make surfaces more reflective than they should be, almost making the floors look wet

@ImProbablyFine. Год назад

it's mostly marble, it should be reflective

@monkeyswift100 Год назад

I agree 👍 Without raytracing it looks absolutely fine... If the ray tracing was 60fps it would be a 10/10 game for art and beauty

@KCTheArtender Год назад

I have a 4080 and 100% agree... It makes even marble look like a wet surface and the reflections often move unnaturally. I turned it off to play. I think until it becomes standard in the industry, artists will spend more time creating without it. Playing HL with it seemed like an afterthought to the creators.

@raukoring Год назад

@@KCTheArtender scamtracing

@Lovistarful Год назад

looks good bro... ur attempt to dissaprove just cause u cant afford it doesnt fit well

@HeisenbergProd Год назад

Personally I go with ray tracing but it's true to say that they made alot of surfaces way too reflective, making it look almost less realistic than without RT on. Also it's abit sad that there is so much noise in the RT reflexions

@trevorward4762 Год назад

You would think raytraced shadows would be amazing in this game, but they seem a bit lackluster

@kaiqueloureiro1827 Год назад

06:02 why the RTX looks so blurry?

@charlymop Год назад

There is subtle things that the raytracing is adding, a little bit of bounce and some ambient and in some cases the reflections looks ok. BUT it's mostly broken and quite useless, so that's good news for people who were scared of missing something. The RTX AO is really messing with some objects such as leaves and hanging towel and other stuff. Control was doing better 4 years ago...

@thegreatfulgamer5749 Год назад

The game with RTX off doesn't look bad at all

@RemizZ Год назад

Most traditional lighting, if done well, doesn't, but it takes the devs a lot longer to make it look that good without ray tracing. That's one of the selling points: Just create the surfaces with the correct reflection properties and place a real light and the rest is automatic.

@randomcheese1719 Год назад

@@RemizZ this game doesn't use ray traced lighting, just ao, shadow and reflection

@mandrews6282 Год назад

Honestly it almost looks better with RT off. Many of the reflections are too reflective and sharp for the materials, and the softer ssr makes more sense in a lot of scenes, even if it doesn’t jump out at the player as much. Also the image seems to be noticably clearer without RT. Would have preferred heavier RT shadow implementation, or GI and AO, over reflections. Still nice to have as an option though and they did seem to prioritize current gen consoles and higher end hardware as the primary rather than just a last gen title with higher res and performance and calling it a day. As evidenced even more by last gen versions now being delayed to presumedly get them to run properly. Since the game has been in dev for something like 6 years, that means it started out as a last gen title and they made the effort to prioritize newer gen once it became available. Def looking forward to the inevitable sequel in UE5.

@a2raya772 Год назад

Set the Effects Quality to high instead of ultra, it gives you better reflections. similar to RT on.

@Bunta1987qwerty Год назад

It’s honestly pretty dumb they didn’t migrate it to ue5. Lumen ray tracing is less expensive, and looks just as good. The ray tracing looks bad in this game, in my opinion. Even ssr can create those reflections. The mirrors can be made using planar reflections too. No ray tracing needed. Additionally, the lack of nanite means these high geometry assets get overdrawn, causing significant performance loss while looking worse. I was hyped for this game until I heard they produced it from ue4 instead of ue5. A lot of the stutters in this game are probably due to world partition, which means the world is made of tiles. Travel in any direction, and it has to load all the shaders from the tile you’ve gotten within range of. It does this while dumping shaders from the ones that just went out of range. Ue5 is much better for many reasons.

@jankratochvil9779 Год назад

Lumen + Nanite is yumy yumy compare to this and its only 10 fps drop compare to 40+ fps by rtx, with my amd gpu :D.

@mandrews6282 Год назад

Game’s been in dev for like 6 years. Migrating to UE5 is considerably more work than people assume it might be, and it’s a cross gen game so they’d also have to scrap the planned last gen console versions. I agree it would look amazing in UE5, likely where the inevitable sequel would be, but from a technical and financial standpoint it wouldn’t have made any sense for them.

@Bunta1987qwerty Год назад

@@mandrews6282 I’ve migrated a few projects, and apart from displacement being different, sky and atmosphere, and world partition, I haven’t really seen anything that’s difficult to fix. Of course this game is much larger than any of my projects, but they also have a whole dev team. They could have even just set aside a small team to work on migration, in case it didn’t work out. Even if they chose to delay it until Halloween, it would’ve been worth it, and ue5 has been around long enough that they could’ve made that decision long before they even announced a release date. All of the assets that don’t use displacement would work as is, and can be converted to nanite with a few clicks. The landscape could be exported without tiling, and then reimported, and displacement can still be done, it’s just a different process. Nearly everything is automated in migration, and you get specified errors and changes for the things that are broken. I think the benefits would’ve been worth it. Consider all of the games in recent history that sell poorly because of early reviews, and how much avoiding ue4 could have prevented that possibility.

@mandrews6282 Год назад

@@Bunta1987qwerty yah but you have to figure this has been a 6 year project, and this studio has never made a triple A game at this level before. The game had already had delays in UE4 alone so undertaking a complete migration would have been ill advised, even if they maybe could have pulled it off. The financial aspect may have been the bigger issue as well as UE5 means they have to cancel the previously advertised PS4 and One versions. That’s probably an even higher risk since they were already releasing one of the most controversial titles in recent years. An unnecessary migration is a serious risk for little gain really and overall a net loss.

@mandrews6282 Год назад

@@Bunta1987qwerty I was really just saying that it’s not a simple conversion. There is a decent amount of work migrating a game this size even from UE4 to 5, and would require redoing QA as well as other aspects. You’re right that it is easier than moving to a whole new engine or starting from scratch, for sure. But they wouldn’t have just been able to throw it in UE5, turn on Lumen and Nanite, and call it a day. Prob looking at at least 6 months to a year delay on top of the other delays they’ve already had. More if they wanted to get into meta human or the other features UE5 offers. I bet we will see a UE5 sequel though and I am impressed with Legacy as is as UE4 is nototiously finicky for open world projects.

@Aleksandar6ix 5 месяцев назад

The sunlight on the walls through windows is neat, and it brightens some dark areas up.....but overall the traditional method for this game is already so beautiful, it doesn't need ray tracing! I would have loved to see if it does anything in combat scenarios though. The floors for one are far more real looking in material and reflection without RT on.

@CazTanto 3 месяца назад

Not sure if it's cos I'm using Ultra Plus mod, but I've just tried turning RT off and am still getting the light from windows on floors and walls. It really surprised me as I assumed this was RT too 🤷🏼‍♀️ Hence how I ended up here; needed a side-by-side to see if RT is actually anything more than just mirror polish on everything stone 😅

@sstier48 Год назад

There are some really bad graphical errors when turning on rt still, and yes my system can handle it running at 60+ fps, but certain objects get completely fkd

@JakkoTB Год назад

Off looks better. Look at the shiny wet mess the floor becames with RT on. As if all the roofs are broken and there has been a hurricane.

@nateTrh Год назад

Shadows are pretty soft and jagged with rtx on my pc. It also destroys hair but it could just be the way it's modeled as well. I would probably skip it unless you want to cut your framerste by more than half.

@blckmlr7573 Год назад

Hogwartz Legacy seems to focus with Reflections and Lighting more I think they should've focused more so on Reflections and Shadows when it comes to ray tracing much like Shadow of the Tomb Raider did. Hogwartz itself needs to look darker and not cast light everywhere. Looked good with RTX off but some of characters of course looked a bit dull but with it on they looked really good, I'd prefer the characters look with ray tracing on but they need to tone down on ray tracing and pick which ones they want Shadow, Lighting, or Reflections as the game looks its faaar to refelctive with RTX on and looked better awith it off like I said. The Stone/Marbel flooring ya to reflective witht he lights.

@davesway1170 Год назад

I've always felt raytracing is too aggressively implemented and it's less lifelike

@L3nny666 Год назад

To me it looks like the gamma setting of the texture’s roughness / glossiness mapping gets scrambled up when rtx is on. Looks like a bug to me

@The_Gent Год назад

Ive played games with reflections like this 15 years ago now all a sudden Ray Tracing comes along and to get those same reflections you need a 2000$ Gracphics Card.

@StrangeHairJoe Год назад

I bet you're thinking of the splinter the series (like one to three) :D

@UrbenLegend Год назад

I am a big fan of raytracing, but Hogwarts Legacy does not do a good job of showing it off. I agree with the other comments saying that the reflections are dialed up way too high. Take a look at the marble flooring in the first scene. Without RTX, you see that it consists of different tile patterns with varying degrees of roughness and therefore varying degrees of reflectiveness. With RTX on, it just looks like one uniform mirror like surface. I can hardly tell any difference between RT shadows and AO on vs off as well. Considering how much RT takes performance in this game, I'd recommend playing with it off.

@cubrman 9 месяцев назад

Yeah, reflections aren't actually the best part of GI. Shadows and AO are. Sadly this one does not seem to feature them.

@Maly715 Год назад

they need to fix the reflection in the water so it doesn't disappear when you look up and down

@Revalopod Год назад

that's because it's using screen space reflections, and not ray tracing. The game doesn't use raytracing for water even if it's turned on which is a bit silly

@naraius7271 Год назад

This is a beautiful game, but the RT is way overdone. The weird twinkly speckling on edges and especially wall surfaces looks really distracting and odd. Too much. isn't this castle like 1000 years old or more? No 1000 year old floors are going to gleam like that. I gave the poor house elves a break and turned the RT off lol

@Limboinpinbo Год назад

Devs are getting closer to nailing RT, but I agree with most it might’ve been cranked up too much here

@Phelaidar Год назад

I honestly think the RT implementation is really poor in this game. Reflection shoudl be different in different materials, and thats what happens without RT. With RT enabled, every reflective surface reacts the same and is very sharply reflective. Other than that, RT doesnt fix my biggest issue with the game which is the ambient occlusion, which is still screen-space even with RT on.

@DylanZ1201 Год назад

Honestly the game looks really good with high/ultra settings, the performance cost is huge with RT settings even on a 4080 and makes the game a stutter fest even with frame generation on.

@seladondm Год назад

Floors are very well waxed, they're perfectly reflective

@Boogs117 Год назад

the backgorund noise @6:12 lol

@lomasharripersad1233 Год назад

RT set to medium looks better compared to it on ultra tbh. I recommend trying it out

@pabmargera Год назад

So... american truck simulator have better mirror reflections without raytracing? This is fucking awesome! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

@pratikdas8765 Год назад

Could you notice at 6:12 , how it sounds?

@clusterphuckedgamers 9 месяцев назад

In this case I'll take the SSR over the RT reflections. RT makes all the floors look entirely too glossy and unrealistic. SSR is looking much more realistic even in the rain. Also turning off RT reflections gives you a very nice boost in performance. If they down-toned the aggressiveness of the gloss with RT on the game could potentially look great with it enabled. But as for now SSR wins all day. ~IMO~

@laurianososa339 Год назад

¿Los juegos de la actual generación están hechos para vender graficas tope de gama? talvez, si pueden jugar el juego sin RTX no se pierden de mucho, muy pocos juegos se ven genial con rtx on. En fin a seguir disfrutando que sin rtx se ve hermoso el juego

@jakubkful Год назад

This game without RT looks exactly like it should look with RT. If you want the best visual effects then turn RT off.

@expecto1982 Год назад

The right side is a good example of how clean and beautiful wax stone looks on Saturn. The environment feels brighter and cleaner.

@expecto1982 Год назад

This is Saturn Metal-Plastic. "Harry Potter" has been played many times in different places.

@expecto1982 Год назад

Even the "Harry Potter" you came to know that took place on Horseshit had Metal-Plastic elements in mind. Otherwise, Horseshit would have been nothing but rot and filth.

@expecto1982 Год назад

"Metal and Plastic" together was a concept in the very early days of "human" existence to help the black reds to maintain shape and feel consistent inside a human-shaped body. Experiencing is believing and it is also a form of "programming". The more someone is programmed to have certain sets of behavior, eventually that set of behavior becomes the person. Think Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady. Social and linguistic programming helped her grow from a monkey to a fair lady.

@expecto1982 Год назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-EAYUuspQ6BY.html&ab_channel=shanmugamlakshmanan

@ansekh7059 Год назад

I was told that ray tracing was only implemented within Hogwarts, but that's not true, is it?

@christianabudinen530 Год назад

Quick question… why the reflections on mirrors look so bad… when we had games 20 years back that had mirrors and looked better for example Max Payne… look it up… what was the technique back then…

@Vitaire Год назад

For many games of that era they'd simply put a mirrored copy of the room you're in behind it! Some games would even add a mirror version of the player character that follows your movement

@afonsoalmeida4817 Год назад

rtx added a cat, love it

@nightdark2616 Год назад

For some weird reason I am getting 60 fps with a 6700 XT on 1440p with all 3 raytracing settings to high. All other settings: high. Texture quality: ultra. Without FSR I get 45 fps and with FSR 2.0 I get 60 fps. It's not normal because the 6700 XT is not supposed to be able to get such good performance with those settings. I have no idea why it is happening. It's only on this game I get such good performance.

@randyrrs7028 3 месяца назад

Ray tracing on looks like someone just mopped the floor

@newlife.oldlove Год назад

Honestly not worth it for a few extra reflections on the floor.

@TheBobist Год назад

But mirrors don't reflect.....

@kaiqueloureiro1827 Год назад

04:42 the floor looks wet with RTX...

@applepie8645 Год назад

I have an RTX 4070, 32 GB RAM, 1TB SSD hard drive, and an i9... But this game constantly crashes with ultra settings and any level of ray tracing... So annoying. Is there THAT big if a difference between 4070 and 4080? How are you running this????

@Swat-ev1fk Год назад

I have a 4080 and its the same for me. Crashes every few minutes with RT on, I disabled it and now runs fine.

@slashmckagen 5 месяцев назад

It seems they've fixed this problem. I just got this game and it runs fine on ultra everything with a 4060 laptop

@igordata Год назад

Wet floor vs dry floor

@roberttakacs19 Год назад

😅

@Noface603 Год назад

Call me a boomer but i am not sold on ray tracing in general

@BulekGaming1998 14 дней назад

My 16 gb ram took much usage while all ray tracing on😅

@Jasonlovesmusic559 23 дня назад

honestly looks way better with RT off

@baloghdave123 Год назад

Ray tracing OFF looks more realistic imo.

@CyberJedi1 Год назад

Raytracing is really poorly implemented in this game, to the point I think playing with RT off looks better. All the reflections have a lot of noise and shimmering, it's horrible, very low res, shadows pop in at medium distances, when you are outside you can see shadows popping a lot as you get closer.

@kerkertrandov459 Год назад

Is this still the case after the march 8th update?

@kerkertrandov459 Год назад

I also read u can use engine ini for config to adjust the rt

@WCGwkf 6 месяцев назад

why are all the floors wet lmo. ill stick with keeping rt off

@phrozac Год назад

So just overdone RT reflections and AO? Bit disappointing. Especially after seeing how impressive Cyberpunk 2077’s RT Overdrive mode looks. Full path tracing in a AAA game in 2023!

@xenomorph7299 5 месяцев назад

wow ray on looks so much better

@SNAKEFIRE9183 Год назад

RT Reflection on = Wet floors here :/

@Jajajajaja...1 Год назад

The raytracing in this game is hot garbage. What's funny is.... you can fix it, clean it up, get rid of the shimmer and the overly reflective surfaces with like 6 lines of basic code in the engine.ini file and it makes the game look wildly better, it takes only minutes.... so why didn't the game designers do this when I was able to?

@SAITA-CHRIS Год назад

To be honest, Raytracing makes reflections exagerate. RTX off looks more realistic most of the time. Never been a fan of raytracing. This game doesn't change my mind. Not worth the FPS impact at all.

@cdel4391 6 месяцев назад

so with ray tracing on it just looks like someone mopped the floor.....on 7:03 you will see some loss of detail on the cracks on the floor....hdr wasn't optimized well in this game it seems

@kylerclarke2689 10 месяцев назад

Has anyone ever played the game this way? It crashes if i even look at ultra settings

@swipyduck Год назад

RTAO doesn't seem to work properly it looks like.

@Pierraxl Год назад

Rtx ON is horrible.... i have a 4090 and the hability to run smooth with RTX in ultra settings, and i turned RTX off because it's horrible.

@voluntarism335 Год назад

I have a 4090 as well and I have ray tracing turned on, wouldn't play the game without it

@roberttakacs19 Год назад

I can't believe it! The game looks better without RT! Is this why you charge $1200 for a 4080 Nvidia? So I can play games with inferior graphics?

@f.miller801 9 месяцев назад

This game is absolutelly not worth it with ray tracing on. Playing on a 4070 at 1080p ultra settings it stutters like hell in some areas and the effects do not look great. The reflections are extremelly noisy low res and flickery and the shadows also are not that impressive. Terrible implementation of the feature by the devs.

@irepresentthe312reich8 Год назад

I never be a big fan of ray tracing, my pc can run smooth on ultra setting, and its already enough good for me, rt only makes everything looks unnaturally wet, dont know why people spend thousands of dollars to just to turn on ray tracing.. But again, it’s their money, i am just sharing my opinion..

@voluntarism335 Год назад

You wouldn't say that garbage if you could a gpu that could do ray tracing well

@Bunta1987qwerty Год назад

@@voluntarism335 some games do a decent job of ray tracing, but not this game, and every game loses a lot of performance from it. I only turn it on in games that really gain from it without causing a huge performance hit. Control is a good example. So is Spider-Man remastered. This game? Trash RT. I definitely wouldn't buy a gpu just because of its RT performance though.

@Horned26 Год назад

This Ray tracing is just selling Fog from Nvidia marketing ! Mirror without reflection if you dont use rtx common we are not fools

@Bunta1987qwerty Год назад

Yeah, planar reflections in ue4 look really excellent, but they didn't even bother to use one. It seems like they didn't even bother placing a reflection capture in the room either. Definitely destroys the purpose of the mirror unless RT is on. Lazy, incomplete, unpolished, unoptimized game. 6 years of work and a ton of money. It's honestly kind of depressing.

@SacredShiro 11 месяцев назад

Prefer it with Ray tracing off

@AlexandreHimself Год назад

6:12 what is going on ?

@ZomgZomg007 Год назад

pretty poor implementation of ray tracing on this one. its like there but at like 1/4 pixel

@Gefkin Год назад

LOOKS BETTER AND MORE REAL WHEN ITS OFF

@EddyOver9000 Год назад

Yeah I agree, it’s kinda like if the floors were recently moped

@Gefkin Год назад

@@darkshadow6556 look like the floor is wet .. with it off it looks far more real, ultra setting with it off .. unless the floor is highly polished pro style

@vookicookiegaming Год назад

For me raytracing off looks better, because when it is on I cant see sh** at 7fps

@milenkopizdic9217 8 месяцев назад

Looks like floors are waxed lmao

@arrowdau Год назад

oil effect on everything

@Fantomas24ARM Год назад

I choose RT ON every day of the week, even with stutters.

@yevheniibatiievskyi 22 дня назад

2024 - reflections in the mirrors are just ugly.

@asaneouji15 Год назад

Looks fantastic. Ray tracing really adds to the shadows / reflections / lighting. A lot more depth and I am loving the ray traced look!

@rugdoc97 Год назад

looks like everything has been polished even the wood and walls where it shouldnt reflect its too much

@americanninja9163 Год назад

this game looks like it's for ps2

@heartshaker5088 10 месяцев назад

เปิดเรย์แล้วแบบว่า จากพื้นอิฐด้านๆ กลายเป็นพื้นอิฐขัดเงาวับอย่างกับกลายเป็นพื้นกระเบื้องไปเลยอะ 555555

@hyrberus2882 Год назад

SHOW ME FPS

@Mrmaxsimus86 Год назад

RT ON = FPS OFF - 50😄

@hyrberus2882 Год назад

JUEGA UNA PARTIDA!

@aqfwgerg Год назад

fake video

@slvrog3470 Год назад

And just for the sake of it, you need to buy a video card for 1.5 thousand dollars to play with these rays? A couple of times I turned them on, looked, smiled and turned them OFF😂

@raukoring Год назад

scamtracing €$£¥