hornby vs Bachmann 

This unlocked forgotten memory buried in the back of my head.

I remember watching the original vid. Though I didn’t know it was gone/deleted.

I remember watching the original video. I'm amazed you managed to memorise the dialogue word for word.

I can’t decide

Y'know, I remember simierski's Hornby vs. Bachmann videos from way back too! But the fact that you and EngineShedStudios managed to bring back a good majority of the original script back is amazing too.

I thought this was going to be a parody of simierski's HvB videos. I'm astonished that you could memorize the dialog from the original video you based this off of.

I like the Hornby thomas more, but my main issues are with more how both brands manufacture their model trains Hornby uses already available motors along with things like flywheels for a smoother and more powerful experiences that don’t cost much to replace Bachmann chooses to make their own motors, which can cause them to be weaker than the Hornby models. This also results in the motors only being available through their own website, meaning you’ll have to pay a bit more than a hornby motor as bachmanns are made in house. From my own personal experiences, my bachmann thomas has broken down and started having problems after around 3 weeks of operation, while my hornby model is still trucking along just fine.

I prefer Take Along

Bachmann for the shape but hornby for the face

I got dirty minded for a few seconds there

I like bachmann because it’s easier to get in the us but hornby is more accurate

Hornby because it’s max amount of coaches it could pull is 11 coaches, While Bachmann can pull 7.

Well if I'm basing my decision on which one to get on performance it sounds like Hornby is the right call.

I like Hornby ones the most (not all of the produced models). But I would love if Bachmann could make RWS versions of the characters using real engines as an alternate line on their catalgue now that Hornby has left the Thomas marquet.

I actually prefer Bachmann myself. But Hornby is good, too.

You’ve done an amazing job memorising every piece of dialogue seen from the original lost video made by Ricky from ThomasTankMerch. In all seriousness, I’ve always been a Hornby type of person.

Eh? The two are pretty allright

I prefer both because they both look pretty good

I Prefer Both!

I like the model of Hornby as being based on a real engine is cool but the Bachmann colors and paint application is a lot better. It also seems to be made out of better materials but that could just be the lighting making it look like that.

I want to see one of these type of videos for Edward, James, Percy, Toby and Diesel as both have there good and bad models from each company and yes I know it's a remake but there's still potential.

Kinda have to go for the Hornby Thomas. I like how the prototypical appearance with his face looks. Currently looking into getting the 2016 iteration of Thomas that has an updated face and brighter blue paint.

Bachman because you can’t buy a new Hornby anymore and the Hornby one is not that we’ll detailed

Both

It’s sad the original video was gone back then I was into look at Bachman then I thought about hornby based on rws and real e2 when hornby thomas running board was painted white grey based on TVs

the Lego guys say it all

I never got to have either of them

Bachmann is more accurate to the show, but I think Hornby is more charming, at least for me

I generally think they're both alright but I'm going to have to go with Bachman. The only thing it needs is a better face.

HORNBY

both because model and railway series

Surprised no one has told you to swap the faces of the two

I prefer Bachmann when it comes to Thomas and Friends Model trains being more accurate to the original series than Hornby.

I hope the original gets found. Nice remake though!

Was the original one deleted? I remember watching and it was hilarious. Great job with this 😂

Hornby Thomas

I have a hornby thomas

i like hornby bc they make coke thomas

Long boi

Bachman

Is there a reupload of the original video?

Hornby

I loved the bachmanns as a kid but honestly the hornbys have grown on me, even tho they are ass more times then not

Bachmann

Bachmenn because it is more ez too find

i think bauchman sins robot chiken tho

It has to be Bachman

bachmann

Well i prefer both because they have also their weak side like the bachmann Thomas face is not good and the Hornby Thomas doesn't have a White running board so yea

Idk

bachmann w

Hornby. same goes for the majority of the range that they made. The only real stinkers are Emily and Edward, though while the Bachmann Edward looks better it's an awful puller.

I prefer Bockman

I prefer hornby

I prefer Tomy

Hornby better that’s all I’m going to say

Naaaahh custom models are better

Bachmann (hornby Has some garbage models)

tomix n scale is better

HORNBY

Hornby

Bachmann

Hornby

Hornby

Bachmann