Thanks for your guide. I'm right at the start of Chapter 2 (did -nothing-) and this worked for me. However, the Lilly May whiner encounter kept spawning so I just ignored the person until they left the area, slept, then the fisherman was near where I woke up. Since I didn't talk to the Lilly May person, hopefully it will still spawn later as I'm trying to keep this save game as fresh as possible.