Close, the onions should be Vidalia not white its missing 1/8 ts chili power a dash of Crystal hot sauce not the flakes and you never mix the ketchup with the water after the onions are soft add the ketchup, chili power, cinnamon and hot sauce all at once and mix then add the water and simmer until the sauce thickens, Bingo...
Thank you. The onions are indeed vidalias as I mention in the description; forgot to state it in the video. I will definitely use your suggestions in my next batch. Thanks again!
Havnt seen jars in years lol?. Uncle had a cart for 30 yrs. His recipe as you said tomato paste and vinegar like ketchup? They all had a special something, his was allspice not cinnimon. But that's why we hit every cart lol. All a bit different.
Never heard of the NY Style Onion Sauce unitl a few years ago. Seemed interestng for a different topping. Looking at other recipes on youtube all use Chili Powder as the seasoning on the onions. Like you, instead of using tomato paste, water, vinegar, brown sugar, I used ketchup. Came out very good. Because of the time it takes, I start with 2 lbs of onions. It makes about 1 qt of onion sauce and keeps for a long time in the fridge. I have no idea if this tastes anything like the NY Onion Sauce, but I like it. It's my new sauce on a rainy day when bored !!!!
Thanks Gail. Quite honestly, Im on a diet and when I cheat I fear my facial expression may convey something other than delicious. Because of this I dont taste on camera at times. It was very tasty tho. Better than the Sabret onion sauce in the jar. Yeah, beard is grown from October thru mid April...my winter coat.lol
john campo ur welcome! I’ll be trying this recipe. Love my onions. I bet it would be great on a cheeseburger too. I’m on a diet myself as well. Good luck on urs!
The first couple times I made it I wasnt crazy about the sweetness. Ive adjusted the amount but maybe it needs more adjusting. Thank you for taking the time to comment.
Also you need,, chili powder, paprika, a little brown sugar... not much don't over sweeten. Onion powder, salt, pepper, a little garlic powder not much. I use in cup water about 1 1/2 - 2 Tbsp tomato paste. This for 1 large onion. About 2 tbsp white or rice vinegar.
