On a serious note the professor is clearly in the right here Listen to the person with the mic when ur the audience ur supposed to shut up and listen cuse the speaker is a big man If bill gates /PMcomes to give you a lecture you don't talk dumbass You don't deserve iiser anyways if u support the girl Enjoy your nibba nibbi life
She was obviously talking and giggling in the front row. After all the disrepect, she had the audacity to ask what happened! What a terrible human being. The guy siding with her should be named and shamed.
@@DeepChauhan93bro what is wrong with you, a teacher will teach what he/she have to teach... And the students that opted or were present have no right to interfere in the teaching if they don't want to study... There's a lot of people who wants to excel in class so its only good to ignore such type of students and focus on your business.
@@DeepChauhan93u may or may not like the speech but giving respect is a different thing.If u really didn't like it u shouldn't be in the first place and this is not some political speech to comment like that.
As someone who's done multiple speeches, I can see why the director lost patience. The most insulting thing a person can do, is not listening to the person who is speaking for you. Judging by the girl's immediate counter-behavior, the director must've warned her multiple times. If you can't sit still without talking to your friend, then you should've sat behind. Talking and disturbing the people listening while sitting in the front is disrespectful. I'm surprised that no one said anything about this.
Its just because you are a pathetic speaker no one listens to you. If you are very good. it will be pin drop scilence and all ears to you. Don't put the blame on the audience. Take the responsibility. show some spine.
Me doing the 500 th like 👍. Also thinking about students on the last bench who were able to hear professor but not the girl its like listening to a partially deaf movie and like listening with a single earphones. Justice for those last bench kids.
1:51 the director had already said Okay and was about to go back to the stage but that another teacher (over smart) had to further escalate the situation.The girl was also seen gossiping in the video on two occasions, she might have thought the teacher didn't notice her as he was facing straight but he had good peripheral vision and instead of owning up her mistake, she was arguing.
@@VishnuP-th5tq Apparently, because this is a classroom and not a playground, and even the pre- school students understand that when a teacher says silence means pin drop silence. A disciplined student today, makes a good, law abiding citizen tomorrow.
@@soumyaroopsarkar1812bhai, discipline name ki cheez hoti hai..Wo student hai aur Jisse argue kar rhi wo professor phd karke baitha hai ..waise aaj kal teacher logon ko respect hi kaun karta hai , liberalism k name par. Ye aaj kal ki society ki harsh truth hai
For the braindead people blaming professor Imagine you are delivering an important speech you have come prepared for and you see people in the front row constantly giggling and talking even after you calmly asked them not to talk initially Then the student shows attitude.Wouldn't you be infuriated
Ikr half the comments dumb💀 they be like respect is earned and bullshit..what has the student earned to be spoken to politely when she was in wrong and then talking back .
Exactly. I haven't been on stage multiple times in my life. But I can relate to the professor. It is so annoying that you are delivering something and someone is constantly talking or laughing.
@@slowkey07😂😂😂 only for illiterates that is cuz the person in front of you is more knowledgeable than has more experience and is giving you some advice so you should listen to it properly 😂
@@NXT_LVL_DVL well i definitely would fucking enraged if i have prepared a speech for hours but my students are there giggling laughing and when are asked to shut up show that arrogant attitude and when you're asked to shut up then it can be asked in apolite way or in a rude 🙄
I'll agree on that fact that it is very annoying when someone does that, but it still isn't the right response to give as a director of ISSER and even as a senior, the best response was to ignore her and focus on the 99.99% of the people who were listening to him with no qualms, which he failed to do
@@batmobikeit's not about willpower, it's very disrespectful and annoying to both the speaker and the audience. If you can't fathom that then that's on you.
She is like born a loudmouth. Normally, people would be taken aback by such outburst by teacher and then respond. This looks like she came prepared to piss him off.
Her parents should have taught her some manners , mother should have punished her for talking like this too elders+ A DIRECTOR OF ONE OF THE TOP INSTITUTES Can't imagine the frustration of the prooffessor
@@acc-gi4nrbro how can you talk when a teacher (teacher meaning a person teaching you to accomplish your goal) is teaching in a class * (college)? Did your parents didn't teach you some manners?
@@acc-gi4nrbruh she was sitting in the first bench. Imagine U are giving a speech and a person right in front of you is giggling and talking with her friend.
@@kikovelasco2366 no we don't think that world should revolve around us, but if a child is handled with extreme Strictness then the Mental pressure revolves around us
Nibbas in comment section who can't get into ISSER leave not even state college LOL with anime pfps and use Instragram saying "respect should be earned" Like dumass he's a DIRECTOR At IISER imagine it's like bill gates coming to give you a lecture
Imagine if a boy argued with a Lecturer then no one would support him, but in this its a girl so they all trying to save her thinking they are emotionally weak, but if that was boy then they would have thrown him away from hall in few seconds. Sad reality of Society and they need Equal rights ☕
Professors are professors. After years of grind and their phd phase, they have come to teach. If I were at her place, very first reaponse would be to bow head and immediately say 'Im sorry'. If required, I will leave out. Do not argue with people of deep knowledge. Stand there in front a whole crowd and see how it feels to be ignored by turning back, giggling, and chatting left-right. I'm myself a student, 21 years old, in my final year phase. For all those who parrot "studonts rights", I know very well what many of us are. From copying in exams via bits, worst case even via mobile phone in exam halls, using CGPT to finish off assignment in minutes without applying any sort of thought processes. From last day before exam kind of preparations, to severe laziness hooked to phones for the rest of the days. From littering in your own campus to really challenging the B in B.E by always romancing and misusing your campuses. Are you guys really any fit to utter "studont rights". It will be you ferocuously hardworking pupils who protest later that you dont get jobs because govt. did not create for you. Superb! Slow claps.
Mind you this is IISER kolkata, there's no culture of copying with bits and using CGPT like yall do in your low tier engineering colleges, if you can't understand the dynamics of interactions like this, then pls ignore and move on. And if you really had any respect for the profs, you won't say anything like this Heck you can't even relate a bit with how good students study in top colleges, slow claps for you sir, for trying to stereotype college students as losers
@@devd_rx So you assumed I study in a low tier, even my entire schooling I never been to a low tier. My opinions are my opinions. Be it IIT Madras, where they have legal bars for drinks, be it IISER, I know the passion most students have. Without the respect for professors, nothing will fall into place. Especially the way she waved hands towards the professor. I totally have a low opinion on his youth. Anyways sorry to say, it is because 90% of these students were rich already; their parents enrolled them in some FITJEE, they reached IITs, IISCs and IISER. Then.. after graduation from subsidised education, what do they do? Research? YOU TUBE VIDEOS 🎉👏👏👏
Avg bitch. Yall the kinda people who will be a wage slave for their whole life and never amount to anything. Just because u have a phd doesnt mean ur a good person. What a braindead take
The moment he said don't behave like that, she immediately realized he is talking to her and immediately defended herself. That itself gives away that she is not innocent. If a person is really innocent, they will first confirm what happened before defending themselves.
If the student really didn't do anything then what else will the student say. Teachers have a very low mental maturity in general. The professor in this video is 62(or at least he looks like one fucking pussy) anyways the girl is in her 20s. So imagine a person who is 60 years old fighting with a person who is less than half of that motherfucker 's age. So think how low that fucker's mental maturity is. Teachers need a wack. Waise bhi grades and marks really don't matter in life. Even I scored failing grades in school. Now I am studying in one of the best colleges of Mumbai. So in the long run it really doesn't matter. But that fucking teachers will be there only. In that same school where they are fucking teaching. They haven't even experienced the real world and have seen only one town and school for years and they think that they have seen the world. BULLSHIT. And on top of that they judge a student based on a ability that hardly matters in life. I mean studying. So if you this from a broader perspective.. WHAT TEACHERS DO IN SCHOOLS IS HEIGHT OF STUPIDITY. I think students should just move on because FUCKERS WILL BE FUCKERS. I MEAN TEACHERS
para marco Hey, I guess you were so much in frustation when you wrote this comment. Seems like there's been injustice to you at your school or something. Nevermind, it doesn't happen with every student or at every school. By the way , my comment was not related to the video, it was indeed a fun fact which is fucking true. And yes, talking about the video it's not a school but a National Institute where a professor lost his temper to an annoying girl whose fault was actually countable. Where, there was no study system was being displayed as you mentioned in your comment about. Remember one thing, grades at school might not be important for our later graduation but the morals and habits of studying that we build during school will always be there in us. Those habits would help us in our later qualifications and rest of our lives.
Wow! What an amazing reflex response of this girl! If anyone ever shouts at me, it will take me atleast 10 seconds to realize where I am, who am I and then process if he is shouting on me... and then realize that I can breathe as well...
She's a girl, a clever one . She knows he can't do shit to her while she can take advantage of the system to get the director in trouble. Had it been a boy who argued he would be facing disciplinary action for sure.
😅I think we should appreciate that cameraman because of whom we are able to see this masterpiece, Like for his whole life he was waiting for some shit to happen while his camera was on😂😂
Mc iiesr Kolkata m Jane ki aukat h teri , bate phak rahe hai sala lodu k bal 😂😂 bangali nahi hota to kisi engrej se apni ma , behen , biwi chu dwa raha hota 😂😂😂😂 sale kutte ki lumd , kuch knowledge h tere m 🤣🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕🖕💅
Man the cameraman was holding the camera so steady... Instead of him if any of friends were holding that camera they would have started to record the ceiling 😂😂
Lol what kudos? He was probably gunning for his job, and took the opportunity. If not, he would have silently stood there and enjoyed that girl get thrashed with a smile. Indian professors don't cant care less enough for their students, especially fickle things like dignity and respect.
Unpopular opinion- sometimes a teacher who is a senior can lose their cool, it can be underlying health issues, mental issues, etc. Elder people do make mistakes, but its completely irrational and wrong to argue with them and pin them down. Just say sorry and move on. Don't make excuses. PS- she did turn back and was whispering something among her friends. Should have apologised right away instead of being like a toddler who says i didn't do nothing.
love this comment. People praising the girl honestly need help. Even if she didn't do anything wrong (I'm pretty positive she had done something, the prof ain't dumb that he'll start shouting at her for no reason) the least she could've done in the situation was just say a simple "sorry" end of story. The prof is also in the wrong here since he straightaway lost his shit and started shouting at her, he was even using the mic to his benefit and overshadowing the girl. We need to understand that he is aged and older people may react to situations this way. We all probably might have seen our own grandfathers be like this, have a sudden surge of anger at random (at least I have) . I won't say that his age should be the factor that justifies his actions, but this world is about understanding right? Is it not? It was sad to see how no one was in support of the old guy. They all turned against him and even applauded against him. No one showed even an ounce of understanding towards him. He had to face utter humiliation. I am trying my best to write this comment nicely, if I was at that place, I would've done my best to bring that little brat into her place. The audacity to straight up counter argue against an aged prof. It is fine to argue, at least try doing it politely. Plus, this is a situation where one shouldn't decide to argue since it disrupts the whole damn ceremony or whatever event is going on, a simply "sorry" is the way to go. This ain't your regular classroom where the teacher has time to hear your justification. Just shut up and let things flow. Seeing people like this with half knowledge of the context, and the way people at the place handled the situation, I sometimes feel Thanos was right.
Well its old dude problem then, if he is mentally unstable just leave the fucking post why doing all this bs, that's not how one should act as a teacher
In ancient times teachers were above all God But in present time disrespecting and abusing a teacher is fashion and considered as cool If I was there I would definitely take stand for teacher
This generation is too soft I mean I am from this generation too but instead of arguing she could have just said sorry it was clear that she was talking during the speech and when someone is trying to teach something you should just say thank you and listen to them your parents dont pay a fortune for you to go to a lecture and laugh with your friends the proffessor is absolutely correct in this.
@Uchiha itachi I'm glad that she respond back immediately, used her voice against that "autocratic" director !! Why she says sorry when she didn't do anything wrong!!?? It's her right to fight back!! & dear, professors or directors are not above questions.....If they did wrong or mistake than it's student's duty to correct him/her!! I don't know from which college you belong, where it teaches that if teacher did anything though it's wrong, students have to apologize !! My college/university teach me to used my voice against any wrong whatever it's did by anyone, even not spare a professor / director!! Everyone not like you or your friends, others have self respect and they can fight for that!! That girl have the correct attitude to tackle all the bullshits and survive this world without compromise her self-esteem!!
I can see her turning back and talking and I'm sure he night have noticed it so many times , he wouldn't create such a big problem if she did it just once
Bro,he is a dean,you have to listen to him,if you want to prove your point you can prove it later,that will not decrease your good image!!.....he is a dean man he deserves some respect and yes he can shout at her!!!
Jab seat woman reservation se mili hu tab oss seat ese he barbaad hoti hai aur esse bacche sorry bolkar baat ko khatam karne ke jagha baat ko badakar apne teacher ki disrespect karte hai, totally waste of seat thats why indian institutes lacking behind in comparison to Mit, harvard only reason poor quality of students and not any great output in research due to reservations 🤦♂️🤷♂️
