Imperial Star Destroyer VS the Enterprise E PART 1 

"Mr. Data, beam a quantum torpedo onto their bridge."

come to think of Kirk's Enterprise tanked several shots from a weapon known as The Doomsday machine that destroyed planets and the Enterprise E shields would be far stronger than the old constitution class

"But lasers wouldn't even penetrate our navigational shields, don't they know that?" -Jean Luc Picard

7:55 LOOOOOOOOL Vader hails and for some reason thinks its a good idea to have his lightsaber out while bouncing back and fourth. hahaha

if I remember correctly, couldn't the Enterprise simply remodulate its shields to break the tractor beams lock?

thrawn should have been in charge becuase his job was to scout and control the unknown regons of the galaxy and beyond

LOL annoyed by the interruption he kills the ships captain... WELP that escalated quickly

"Lasers? Those can't even penetrate our navigational shields." - Captain Picard

Lost me at Data being on the ship. He's dead :(

Editing software from a Sith lord.... Brilliant

Vader's like, "Square up punk!!"

I'm just listening to somebody's fan fic, why am I enjoying this

Given that you only had 3 movies to choose your Trek clips from, this is a very well put together story. All power to clever editing! And hurry up with part 2 please ;-)

Old Spock's ship from the kelvin timeline vs the death star

This is great, liked and subscribed

Very well done. Very entertaining. Great job

Warf - "Captain, we're being hailed." Picard - "On screen." Vader - "If you knew the power of the Darkside!" I'm sorry, that was stupid AF but funny AF. AND very nicely edited!!

Commander Data was destroyed. It would have to be "Before".

I think you did an amazing job here, I am Star Trek and Star Wars fan since ages, thank you very much for your nice work:) Thumbs up, May the Force be with you, live long and prosper.

Awesome job guys! Very creative story so far.. I am looking forward to the conclusion. :)

I'm sorry but the idea Troi's parlor trick of empathy would even slow down Vader's command of the force is downright silly. Her mother or a more powerful psychic MAYBE but yeah I don't think she'd have the juice.

Apparently this guy never watched TNG Lasers couldn't penetrate the Enterprise-D's shields and the E without any doubt has better shields. The Star Destroyer was never a threat to the Enterprise. One Photon Torpedo and it would be gone. End of story

What a neat idea, this was really fun.

Entertaining, fun and a little cheeky. That's a very fine needle you successfully threaded.

I would like to point out that the physics that are seen in the Star Wars Universe a turbolaser does about 450 terawatts of damage and the large 8 turbolasers seen on Star Destroyers would do 3000 terawatts of damage. and in Star Trek universe the enterprise-d Type X phaser does 100000 terawatts of damage. the enterprise-d has seven of these. also the next thing I would point out is the shields in Star Wars are very different than the shields from Star Trek. the Star Destroyers energy Shield would stop phaser but would not stop torpedoes. it does have a ray shield but the ray shield is very weak this is why Fighters are able to damage Star Destroyers with torpedo or missiles. so a Quantum torpedo from the Enterprise would hit with ....250 megatons of damage. one torpedo should just about put the Star Destroyer out of commission. if you use the physics from the actual TV show and the movies. and do not use the manuals which Through Math make no sense versing the shows make no sense. for an example if you look at the manuals Enterprise does 1.3TJ percent damage and Bubba Fett's fighter does 63,000TJ of damage using the same formula. Also it say something like a mine in star wars is like 2000 megatons but the explosion is only showing kilotons!..... thank you for the video. very cool

NERD ALERT !! The upgraded Photon torpedos are tens if not hundreds of times more destructive than the Tsar Bomba detonated on Earth. If the Super Star Destroyer can go down thanks to one X-Wing, then i am certain a Star Destroyer would crumble like the face of Sheev Palpetine.

I know this is an older video...but it was alot of fun...Hoping their are more of these coming in 2020😍👍💓

Bit late to this. What a great idea for a story! As I’m more of a Trek fan over Star Wars, you’ll get a good idea where I hope this is going to go. Looking forward to part 2 immediately. Let’s “make it so”!

"To hell with our orders." Gosh i love this scene

Yes, 9 planets!!!

This was great!!!

This is brilliant !

Vader makes a spectacular commander, so long as you can fulfill his orders. Even if it was for the sake of the audience, he would always make the reasons behind his actions very clear to the admirals.

I think the Empire would have to deal with the Voth as well. Not just the Enterprise E.

Definitely subscribing for your versus videos.

Thank you for the silliness of fun!

The problem I have with many of these match ups is that they all seem to happen at point blanc range, which is ok for the star destroyer. However in the original star trek many of the battles happened without visual and used instruments to locate and fire on an enemy. In many ways it was like submarine warfare, as shown when the enterprise first encountered the romulans. So given the speed and maneuverability of federation ships, why not just bombard the bad guys from standoff range. Also, light speed limitations was a weakness exploited by the Picard manoeuvre. So you should be able to do slash and run tactics with an enemy who literally would not be able to see you coming. In fact they would only see the enterprise as it is back in its its start position and you are putting out fires. So how about a match up that utilises these aspects of a match up.

lasers won't get thru federation navigational shields.

HAY TECHIE LOVE YOUR VIDEOS WICKED COOL... I THINK ALL THE SIZE COMPARISONS, AN WEAPONS DIFFERENCES ARE KILLER. STAY COOL AN KEEP PUSHIN ON MY FELLOW OUT WORLDER... PEACE...

This is such an underrated video :D needs more views :D

I am really sure sustained ion cannon fire would disable the magnetic containment field on the antimatter containment units aboard the enterprise

"Lasers can't even penetrate our navigation shields." - Picard Lasers have no power limit. The Death Star for example uses a laser to destroy planets. The Borg Cube's cutting beam was also a laser. It's possible that the Empire developed laser weaponry past the point where the Federation abandoned the technology in favor of other energy weapons. But we don't know.

You had me at "To hell with our orders"

You guys are so ahead of the curve. These two stories will converge eventually, as long as people will pay to see it. $ means everything In Hollywood, and every where where else on the face of the planet. I can't wait!

Was it the E version that can split into saucer's battle station? Also they've only been using phasers upto now? I think if the ship splits into it two battle vessels, with it's accurate phasers, and full compliment of torpedoes, they tear apart the Star Destroyer!!

... please, please PLEAS have Q appear and start screwing with Vader!

very very nice Dude!

EckhartsLadder referred this video and asked we mention it: love your take and understand why he recommended watching it. Look forward to looking over your catalog.

Okay my ass the star destroyed would have any impact on the enterprise But Vader killing everyone on board is plausible

I keep saying this: Star Wars weapons, be it turbo laser or ion cannons would bounce off any Star Trek universe shields. The only era of Star Trek ships that would be vulnerable to Star Wars tech is the Kirk era. Anything after that, well, it would be hilariously one sided. Ion cannons are energy based, basically like an EMP, which is designed to drain the electrical systems of a ship. Problem with it against ST shields is that they are designed to absorb and reflect any energy based attack. This is why phasers and disrupters are the only weapons in ST that is designed to take down shields. The Empire does not know this, and would not be able to react in time. Phasers of the enterprise E would eat the Star destroyer's shields for breakfast as that's what they are designed to do. A quick,scan of the ship would reveal the weakness of the star destroyer, which is the exposed shield generators, target them, and destroy them with a well placed full spread torpedo launch, which would rip through any armor. Again, photon torpedoes were designed for hull penetration, and quantum torpedos, which is what the E is carrying, are more powerful. The star destroyer, in the meantime, would realize the futility of taking on a much more well equipped and manuravoable ship. Let's just say that the turbo lasers do do the damage you state in this video (which I doubt, considering lasers do nothing to shields in the ST universe) probably would land a few hits, while the targeting computer would make short work of any tie fighter, bomber, or interceptor the Empire launches against it. Now Vader would be plotting an escape from the E, hoping to buy some time, he hails the E. Picard, forever the diplomat, opens a channel, only to be choked immediately. Word, seeing his captain under attack, cuts communication with this unknown ship, and launches a full volley of quantum torpedos at the ship. The explosion breaks Vader's hold on Picard, while his captain reports a hyperspace jump has been calculated. The E comes around to finish off the SD, launching a full barrage of phasers and torpedos, just as the SD jumps into hyperspace. The E finishes off the remaining interceptors, capturing a few to learn more about this foe. As Picard gives the order to return to their time, engineering reports no major damage, and is ready to return.

Much as I love star wars, this wouldn't even be a contest. A full spread of quantum torpedoes and bye-bye Impstar Deuce.

Superb video.

I know he's not as well known, but Thrawn would have been a better opponent to command the SD for this match. ST captains often win by out thinking their opponents and that's how Thrawn preferred to operate as well. Vader usually opted for overwhelming force over clever tactics. I think the Enterprise might win not because of their tech, but because it has the better crew.

A barrage of quantum torpedos ends Vader and the Star Destroyer. The End.

Dude - Did you write this yourself??? THIS IS AWSOME STUFF!!!!

this is great!

for those that are saying that a SD Shields are weak need to remember that in the ESB, we see an SD get destroyed when an asteriod crashes into the bridge but that SD had been in the field for days getting hit by many asteriods. in return of the Jedi Admiral ackbar even said focus all firepower on the super star destroyer, you also see in the movie that the engines have already been damaged and because of that it crashed into the Death Star which destroyed it. i believe if it didn't crash it could have survived. the weapons shields in Star wars can also disrupt transporter technology just because of the way they work, which we all know transporter technology is highly interfered with.

This is the only time i n star trek history that Deanna Troi was actually useful

Meanwhile a very confused and flabbergasted Voth goes running back to their people telling them they have to leave the planet asap.

this was good dude. coming from a trekkie this was good

I'm hungry give me food

4:19 scene from Empire strikes back

Exciting stuff

Do you think for the next series you could do a battle between the malevolence from the clone wars and the uss vengance from into darkness?

There's a couple things that need to be added to this. First off, Deanna isn't going to do jack squat against the Force. Her abilities are for the most part sensing other's feelings and with a great deal of effort she can put some direction to it. These abilities cannot do anything against a telekinetic attack from a being with powers on par with the Platonians (look it up). There is a question as to whether the Force would work in our galaxy since there seems to be nothing in the way of midichlorians, but if Vader was choking Picard in this then in this circumstance we can assume it does. The only thing that saves Picard is technobabble like beaming him off the bridge and out of Vader's grasp. Secondly, the Enterprise has a lot more sublight power to it than anything that Star Wars has shown us. Star Trek:TMP showed the refurbished original Enterprise clearing Jupiter in a handful of seconds. That means Kirk's Enterprise was going an appreciable percentage of the speed of light on sublight engines alone. This makes sense when you figure that Kirk was able to hoof it into the interior of the Mutara Nebula when it wasn't even visible from the Regula 1 space station. The Enterprise E is larger, but is also a much more futuristic craft. It will undoubtedly maintain at least some percentage of the original's speed. The increased mass certainly wouldn't reduce its velocity down to a Star Destroyer or TIE Fighter's, who can't even clear the radius of Tatooine in an appreciable amount of time. Of course Picard can't just jet out of the system on sublight or even warp. If Vader intends to build a superweapon, that will likely involve stripping the Earth practically bare of natural resources. The chances of humanity developing in that situation is next to nil. Picard has pretty much gotten himself involved in a predestination paradox. The result of that paradox demands that Picard drive Vader back to his own galaxy and destroy the wormhole. Ignoring that however, it brings us to the interesting situation of comparing Star Trek's weaponry with that of Star Wars. When Curtis Saxton's works were in vogue, it was no contest. A light laser from a Star Destroyer put out 5 gajillion million billion zillion zettajoules of energy and could vaporize a black hole in a single hit (an overexaggeration sure, but not as much as it should be). Now that Saxton's claims are in the realm of Legends, we see from the new canon that Star Destroyers, far from being able to turn the surface of a planet into molten slag, can place bombardment shots within a quarter mile of a Jedi on a speeder without causing considerable harm. Compare this to the ships of TNG era, where a fleet of Romulan and Cardassian ships did indeed wipe the surface of what they thought was the Dominion homeworld from existence. Doesn't matter if it was a ruse, it was a close enough ruse to fool the starship captains so the results of the bombardment were pretty spot on to reality. Long story short, Disney may have taken this from a shoe in for Vader and handed victory squarely to Picard.

turbo lasers would pose no threat to the E and ion canons? uhmm you do know in trek ships regularly pass through massive ion storms in space far more powerful than anything a canon would produce. and one volley of quantum torpedoes and bye bye star destroyer

Captain Picard - "Mr. Worf, beam a photon torpedo onto their bridge."

How would the UN space battleship Yamato fared against an empire's Star destroyer ? Could you do a comparison .

just teleport couple of torpedos on destroyer and watch fireworks from 70s.

the star destroyed has no chance once the enterprise begins to target it. the enterprise is equipped with phaser banks and quantum torpedoes with were show to be able to destroy a borg sphere with ease.

Thanks for the great story!

LMAO. I love the way you describe how they could have plausibly met for this battle, and how each side would react. You could have just played it out on the merits of each ship's tech, but instead you gave us a entertaining story to justify it.

Data is dead at the end of Nemeses. B4 has Data's memories but it is a different robot.

sorry, I cant see the lady overcoming darth vader with what little she has.

So GREAT!

Best episode yet!

stat destroyer

Omg I was literally thinking about this last night

love it!!

How do we know SW ion weapons will have any effect at all on ST shield or power tech? ST ships have been shown to weather ion storms without ill effect as well as take multiple hits from ground based ion cannons (Voyager).

The Scientology bit cracked me up. Thank Gort I wasn't sipping covfefe!

Well I agree with the fact that Imperial (as well as Rebel) targeting systems seem to be more primitive than the Federations. Normally the Enterprise could not survive many hits from Devastator's Turbolasers assuming the Turbolasers were using full power. (based on tech manuals). Vader might want to incapacitate the ship wanting to learn more about this potential foe, after all if they are going to be an impediment to future Imperial control of the system then he needs to learn about his enemy now. Thus he may have ordered Turbolasers used at half power (I'm assuming they can be used on a variable setting like the Superlaser of the Death Star as revealed in Rogue One). This might be to test Enterprise's defenses without revealing his full strength. I also agree that the Enterprise would make short work of the TIE Wing. After all Tie Fighters (with the exception of Advanced, Defenders and Avengers don't have shields, the only fighter on Devastator that has shields would be Vader's in all likelihood.) I do agree seeing the new technologies of the Federation, Vader would seek to capture the ship. Of Particular interest would be the phaser fire control, after all if the Empire had this technology the Rebellion's fighters would be insignificant. This is actually good for the Enterprise as Vader is unlikely to crush them while he can, using the ion cannons and tractors is a good idea. I don't think Deanna Troi could stop Darth Vader. Her abilities were very limited. Indeed Vader might could even sense Deanna, as well as any other Betazoids or even Vulcans aboard, if their abilities come from the Force even if they don't realize that. However while I don't buy that Troi could stop him, Data might could cut the feed fast enough and the break in viewing might be sufficient to cause the Dark Lord to lose his grip on Capt Picard's throat, allowing him to survive. (Though Capt Riker showed remarkable resources once when Picard was Locutus of Borg). Picard might well ask Riker for some unorthodox suggestions. Data would probably be the one most likely to locate the vulnerable shield towers on top of the bridge structure of the Devastator. Using a spread of torpedoes could destroy the towers giving the Enterprise a chance at escape. The ionization might require them to fire the torpedoes without relying on the ship's normal targeting computers which would be disabled. The ionization might disable Data shortly after he reveals this, Worf taking the shots.

The premise of how this all occurred is quite awesome tbh. Love the idea that star wars was like 70 million years ago!

I like the selection of clips you've chosen to tell the story! 4:44

Turbolasers wouldn't be able even to pen the shield. Seriously, the Shields of the Enterprise can resist phasers capable of taking out the entire surface of a planet, something that would require "thousands of destroyers to do so" (Han Solo dixit).

Ion cannons would NOT interfere with the enterprises systems. The ships shields have a magnetosphere property to them that would draw the energy to hardpoints. Nothing in the starwars universe could touch startrek shields. and phasers would 1shot the tiefighters rapidly. a single volley of quantum torps to the bridge of the star destroyer would destroy it

as far as vss videos with more holes to punch in them than both sifi universes i must admit this one is the best yet!

Several very good points in this part - points that most other vs. comparisons miss. Points such as TL accuracy, and the survivability of TIEs against a phaser armed ship.

Quantum torpedoes...

Nice dub work - they'll never notice!

So this is a Star Wars fan channel. Well, I know the winner - Star Wars 👏👏👏👏👏😂

Wow! You are FAAAR more eloquent than the actual images! You are a true story teller!

Oh, please. One Genesis torpedo and the destroyer, or even the Death Star, would be toast.

Arm Transphasic Torpedos! Fire! -- Star destroyer is destroyed.

very good :)

I have a question. What it the name of the song you use for your outro?

Enterprise always! 🙂 And this coming from a Star Wars fan!

You forgot most of the technology that the Enterprise has at it's disposal: The Enterprise has a massive amount of shielding that it can throw up. It can divert power to the shields to keep them going which can easily repel 100% of the laser fire from the Tie Fighters. I'm sure that the shields could also repel most of the fire from the Turbo Lasers. Also, all the Enterprise has to do is get BEHIND the Star Destroyer and they're safe. Yes... Star Destroyers have a Blind Spot! Why doesn't anyone bring up this point? If the Enterprise gets behind a Star Destroyer and launches a few Photons at its exposed engines, that destroyer is toast. They are that easy to take down. Speaking of which, Photon Torpedoes should strike fear in the hearts of any Star Wars fan because they literally don't have strong enough shielding on the Star Destroyers. "Our cruisers can't repel firepower of that magnitude!" Photon Torpedoes are just too powerful! Hell, a few photons fired at the exposed bridge will take down a Star Destroyer. Remember when a single X-Wing flew into the bridge of one and sent it careening into the side of the Death Star? Phasers! The phaser cannons of the Enterprise are far superior and powerful enough to punch right through the shield grid of a Star Destroyer. A single volley could pierce the shields and destroy the exposed deflector shield generator on the destroyer. Transporters! The Enterprise could beam the entire bridge crew off the destroyer and into its many brigs. Enough said on that topic. You completely ignored all of this tech in this video. The Enterprise would never suffer any damage.

Just not sure about the Gigagwatt or Terrawat range of the Star Wars Turbo-Lasers? Depending on this I am not sure how much energy the Star Trek shields can handle?!

Why would the ion cannon affect the enterprise? weren't all starfleet ships upgraded to protect against those weapons after the breen attacks?