Irish People Try Thanksgiving Pies For The First Time

Подписаться 1,3 млн

Просмотров 2,5 млн

50% 1

Irish People Try Thanksgiving Pies - for the first time! MERCH MADNESS: TRY.media/Merch
Subscribe: TRY.media/Subscribe | Instagram: TRY.media/Instagram
Get exclusive content and more: TRY.media/Patreon
More Information:
We love a good pie here at the TRY HQ, however our Irish pies tend to be more the apple or strawberry & rhubarb variety. After getting our hands on a lovely selection of Thanksgiving Pies, we knew we had to sit our Irish People down and see what they thought right away - pumpkin pie? Sweet potato pie? Who knows!
Thanks to Take the Cake for delivering on our very niche order: takethecake.ie/
The Tryers featured in this video:
Laura Gough: TRY.Media/Laura
Lena Klein: TRY.Media/Lena
Callyann Brennan: TRY.Media/Callyann
Seán MacGabhann: TRY.Media/Sean-MacG
Colin Regan: TRY.Media/Colin
Seán Connolly: TRY.Media/Sean
Follow The TRY Channel:
Twitter: TRY.Media/Twitter
Facebook: TRY.Media/Facebook
Instagram: TRY.Media/Instagram
Subreddit: TRY.media/Reddit
Watch more from The TRY Channel:
Latest Uploads: TRY.Media/LatestUploads
Popular Uploads Playlist: TRY.Media/PopularUploads
Trying Alcohol Videos: TRY.Media/Alcohol
Trying American Things: TRY.Media/American
_________________________________________
If you like to send us a package with items to try, please send to the address closest to you:
(General notes: *Max limit: 10kg. If you're sending food/drink for a video, please send at least 4 variants with enough to share between six people. Food/Drink items ONLY. No alcohol packages and no cooked/baked homemade goods. These addresses are for items to try in videos. Any gift packages for individual TRYers can be sent to their own PO Boxes, which can be found via their own social media.)
US Address:
TRY Channel
APW 4119337
5 South Main Street
Englishtown
NJ 07726
USA
UK Address:
TRY Channel
APW 4119337
AddressPal
The Beacon
Mosquito Way
Hatfield
AL10 9WN
Credits :
Content produced by The TRY Channel.
Music courtesy of Epidemic Sound.
Thank you to our Patreon Producers: Robert Grant, Jake Larkin, Fernando Sotelo, Joe Lyden and Carlos Magana and Hoffafiles.
TRY is your new home on RU-vid. A place where people try things for the first time. Similar to popular RU-vid channels such as BuzzFeed, WatchCut, GMM & TheFineBros' React, our goal is to create content to entertain you and to bring a positive light to the start or end of your day.

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

21 ноя 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 14 тыс.

@shelbyseelbach9568 Год назад

When you realize these pies are store bought instead of made by someone's grandma, you realize they were severely shortchanged in this experience.

@daledavies2334 10 месяцев назад

Must agree. After being divorced, friends would invite me to a pot bless dinner and ask me to bring a dessert, thinking I would buy a pie or cake. NOT! Brought sweet potatoe pie with whip cream and lime pie with warm cherries. The other wives were asking the hostess if I really made the pies.

@alanphinney 10 месяцев назад

I'm 71yrs old American and I don't think I've ever eaten vanilla ice cream with any pie except with hot apple pie or apple crisp (a kind of cobbler). Whoever suggested ice-cream with sounds as if they are not that familiar with American pies 1st hand. Ice-cream is just a delicious way to eat very hot party. Of course there is no accounting for taste. Keep trying them all. 6:09

@shelbyseelbach9568 10 месяцев назад

@@alanphinney I don't want ice cream on any pie.

@alanphinney 10 месяцев назад

I highly recommend rhubarb-strawberry pie! Try to learn to make them yourselves, (remember it's easy as pie!)

@5Gburn 10 месяцев назад

@@shelbyseelbach9568Apple pie is the only possible pie that will pair with ice cream, but definitely stands on its own and I respect your Originalist stance, sir.

@samechick 2 года назад

As a proud pie eating American, I must say, that cherry pie looked sus.

@johnmccomber8371 2 года назад

For Uncle Sam's sake its blue

@angelad8339 2 года назад

They used real cherries. You’re used to that processed goop from a can or jar.

@johnc.hammersticks 2 года назад

That apple pie was atrocious, that is not hand made.

@cnoyes72 2 года назад

@@johnc.hammersticks I'm sure all the pies in this vid were store bought.

@CPny65 2 года назад

Cherry Pie is Red not Purple or Blue. I think they are right that it's a mixed berry.

@brettsteele7027 6 месяцев назад

Really Irish friends, the difference between store bought and homemade is enormous

@Arcturus545 7 месяцев назад

I'm from the Caribbean when I came to America & had an apple pie I was like WHAT HEAVEN IS THIS?!!!!

@remyllebeau77 5 месяцев назад

Welcome to sugar and diabetes heaven.

@Christobanistan 4 месяца назад

@@remyllebeau77Where the people die early, and happy.

@Roamr1720 3 месяца назад

ya but yall got some good bbq.

@jameslalley3787 3 месяца назад

Adding whip cream and ice cream is really overkill lol ! But it’s tasty !

@RMBittner 2 года назад

I think it’s safe to say that most Americans would use/expect tart red cherries, which are bright red, in a cherry pie. There’s no confusing a cherry pie with blackberry, blueberry, or mixed berry.

@courtneywallace871 2 года назад

My sentiments exactly

@TheNeonParadox 2 года назад

Truth. And honestly the cherry pie should have been earlier in the order. You can't have cherry after the wonderment of pecan and pumpkin.

@Phyde4ux 2 года назад

The last time the Try channel did American pies (back when they were Facts), they were given the saddest, most miserable excuse for a pumpkin pie known to human creation and, of course, it was received with universal distain. All the Americans in the comment section were rightfully livid. So while it appears their cherry pie has missed the mark, they are showing improvement.

@brianwoods9552 2 года назад

Dunno what that was. Certainly not cherry.

@roboslug7582 2 года назад

In the US we use Montmorency cherries. Those are the bright red ones Americans are familiar with. In Europe, they mostly use Morello cherries, which are very dark, about the color of a typical blackberry when they're cooked. But they taste just like a regular tart cherry. So in Europe, it would be pretty easy to confuse a cherry and blackberry pie by appearance. That said, their reaction kinda indicates that they probably used a sweet cherry or black cherry, which are the same color as Morello cherries, but don't have anywhere near as much flavor, and they lose what little flavor they have when they're cooked.

@24k_puregold47 2 года назад

I’m getting the impression that if an American went to Ireland and opened a pie shop, it would be awesome!

@tehmedulla 2 года назад

Yes! Especially my Grandmas pies she would be at home! 😂

@brendaryan306 2 года назад

Especially if you made a pie using Guinness

@angrypop2594 2 года назад

Yeah I was thinking the same thing.

@katieegge699 2 года назад

It would definitely depend on if they can bake or not. I feel like they did those people dirty with some of those pies.

@angrypop2594 2 года назад

@@katieegge699 I totally agree with you. Especially the cherry and sweet potato pies.

@spuriouseffect 8 месяцев назад

Sweet potato pies don't taste like sweet potatoes, they taste more like pumpkin pie. And cherry pies have a strong cherry flavor. Whoever made those two pies didn't know what they were doing. Edit: If these are all store bought pies, then you have no idea how much better homemade pies taste. Night and day difference.

@philipkelly7369 8 месяцев назад

Eh, I'm going to be honest, to me store-bought pumpkin pies are usually just as good or better as homemade. Other varieties though, your dear aunties homemade pie recipe is always going to be superior.

@spuriouseffect 8 месяцев назад

@@philipkelly7369 Mom made her pumpkin pies out of squash. So much more flavor.

@RH-cv1rg 7 месяцев назад

@@philipkelly7369 Store pies are as good as home made? You need to get yourself a new Grandma.

@ohger1 7 месяцев назад

Depends on the store or bakery, but generally you're correct, yes. But there are exceptions..

@bcase5328 7 месяцев назад

Pumpkin Pie or Sweet Potato Pie, the way to have your vegetable and desert

@ricknichol3688 8 месяцев назад

I live in Canada I've avoided pumpkin pies for 30 years and I was at my new in-laws and they have pumpkin pie so I tried some and I wondered why I was not eating them my whole life they are so good

@betterlatethannever4529 7 месяцев назад

Just the act of avoiding it is a sin against food. Your penance for such an act is to spend the next 30 years spreading the good news of the pumpkin pie

@ohger1 7 месяцев назад

I love pumpkin pie and make it from real pumpkins (not canned), but I know that pumpkin pie is a bit of an acquired taste - I understand why some people don't care for it even though it's my favorite. But anybody who doesn't like a fruit pie (apple, cherry, blueberry) needs to have their heads examined!!

@Christobanistan 4 месяца назад

@@ohger1It takes about 30 seconds to acquire the taste! 🤤

@protorhinocerator142 2 дня назад

I'm glad that Canada also celebrates Thanksgiving. You plan it around the harvest. It's not that hard. Such a shame other countries seldom join in the fun. There's no reason Ireland can't have pumpkin pie, roast turkey, etc.

@KA10012010 2 года назад

So sad about the sweet potato pie. 😢 They need someone’s southern grandma to make this for them. I DEMAND A REDO!!!!

@anndeecosita3586 2 года назад

My Southern granddaddy made better sweet potato pies than my Southern grandma. Don’t count the men out. 😂

@d.martinez-rodriguez333 2 года назад

I agree totally.

@NoThankUBeQuiet 2 года назад

Meh. It's a ever so slightly different pumpkin pie and pumpkin is so much easier to find.

@reuben854 2 года назад

@@NoThankUBeQuiet Sweet potato pie is so much better!

@FourSeasons04 2 года назад

Yep, I can guarantee that sweet potato pie wasn't prepared properly. Sweet potato is miles ahead of pumpkin pie, IMHO. 😋

@baconbill8148 2 года назад

I worked for a fruit distributer for two years, and I can confirm, the cherries used in that pie look to be blackjack cherries. What we Americans are used to are tart cherries that have the traditional red color. Blackjack cherries are juicey but have very little flavor so yeah the pie probably was bland.

@ForbiddenFish 2 года назад

Oooh, that's why I thought that pie looked weird lol

@Joelyototw 2 года назад

Okay that makes sense I was skeptical about it being cherry pie lol

@S-Lewis 2 года назад

Yes, sour Evans cherry pie is next level flavor.

@vonKobra 2 года назад

Black cherries are nice fresh for snacking, but would make a flavorless, generically sugary pie

@JustInOutDoors78 2 года назад

Always tart cherries for the pie unless you want to add 3x the sugar and pray you taste something other than the crust

@rexoates4484 8 месяцев назад

The pecan tree is the state tree here in Texas. We consume tons of pecan pie during the holidays. Served warm with some Blue Bell vanilla ice cream and YUMMY!!

@curtish2541 7 месяцев назад

Now you know in Texas that our pecan pies aren’t always JUST pecan pies. We take a page out of our Cajun brothers and make Col. Beauregard’s Pie, a pecan pie with dark chocolate chips at the crust, with bourbon pie filling. Served hot with that Blue Bell Homemade Vanilla, oh my Lord!

@Darth_Conans 7 месяцев назад

And if anybody asks for "pee can", we show them the toilet.

@kimchi2780 7 месяцев назад

Blue Bell Ice and Mrs Bards bread.

@gaiustacitus4242 5 месяцев назад

@@Darth_Conans Only a Yankee says "pee-can pie."

@jakerazmataz852 5 месяцев назад

Yea, I don't know if these were warm. They all could be IMO.

@emiliedeangelis6268 7 месяцев назад

Awww, pie diplomacy. Americans are like “come over for pie anytime, guys!”

@FLORIDA_MAN_813 Год назад

Colin just earned himself American citizenship for that rendition of Warrants Cherry Pie

@kriscoumbe8577 Год назад

Totally 👍 agree.

@faithalexander9128 Год назад

YES!! Colin, you must work a song into each episode!

@kyrvhy 2 года назад

The cherries you have in Ireland and the UK are not the ones that we use in North America for "Cherry" Pie. Our filling is made with sharp bright red cherries; a totally different variety. Some people call them "Pin Cherries" but most are a "sour" cherry or Amarelle and particularly the Montmorency variety of Amarelle which is bright red. Cheers from Canada.

@RustyDockLight 2 года назад

Omg sour cherry pie is SO good! We used to pick them off our own tree but then bugs ate it and we had to cut it down

@TheRisskee 2 года назад

You know, I noticed their standard cherries are different in Ireland when I watch one of their cocktail videos and the recipe called for a maraschino cherry and when they gave the the cocktail, the cherry was almost black. This video just confirms they've got a different regular cherry. It's not ideal but it would make sense to send them a can or two of Comstock cherry pie filling.

@Vortex1988 2 года назад

@@TheRisskee That's not accurate. There are maraschino cherries which are bright red, and there are Luxardo Maraschino Cherries which are the black ones. They do taste different, but both are available at most liquor/cocktail stores. A lot of bartenders will use the Luxardo Maraschino Cherries to elevate their cocktails a bit more, since not everyone is as familiar with them and because they have a much richer flavor. I agree that the cherries used in the video weren't the right kind, but the Luxardo Maraschino Cherries can be found just about anywhere....or at least in the US anyway.

@atakeuchi_ 2 года назад

That is key…SOUR cherries…tart and sweet…and 🤤 I’ll be baking one today. 😬

@TruthTroubadour-xi9cc 2 года назад

We have those sweet dark cherries, but dont put them in pie. We use the red tart variety. SO good!

@nancybrewer8494 7 месяцев назад

Pumpkin and mincemeat makes me think of Thanksgiving, but chocolate pie with meringue and coconut cream with meringue, oh, and lemon meringue! My husband used to say he only liked two kinds of pie: hot and cold!

@dennisswaim8210 6 месяцев назад

Canadians celebrate Thanksgiving on a different date so it's not just an American thing. Of course you Irish can start your own Thanksgiving tradition. We all have things to be thankful for. Pick a day invite all your family and friends over and feast watch the game and be thankful.

@Christobanistan 4 месяца назад

Is Canadian Thanksgiving inspired by a historical event? Ours was a celebration of a military alliance between a local tribe where they agreed to stop massacring the Pilgrims and help them survive in exchange for guns to use against other tribes. Although, that's gotten dumbed down over the centuries.

@jameswilson7790 3 месяца назад

The Canadian Thanksgiving holiday is the same day as the holiday formerly as Columbus Day. It's the second Monday in October.

@davidaugustine3686 Год назад

I'm genuinely just relieved they loved pumpkin pie.

@oreosessions3288 Год назад

agreed its my favorite.

@lisahirschlozano823 Год назад

same!!!

@donkink3114 Год назад

I absolutely hate pumpkin and sweet potato pies, they are related species and taste nasty to me

@elizabethanne8729 Год назад

@@donkink3114 CONGRATULATIONS 🥳 More for me 🥰🤤

@flackenstien Год назад

Seriously. It's the most Thanksgiving pie here. Only pecan rivals pumpkin as an Autumn pie, though I much prefer pumpkin myself. Apple and cherry are just pies. I've never heard of sweet potato pie. Yams and fries, sure, but not pie.

@misinformedmarti 2 года назад

Best thing about the pecan pie is how healthy it is. All 15,000 calories of it.

@rickwoodford4039 2 года назад

I see you like the lighter version.

@brendanobrien4095 2 года назад

That's per slice, of course!

@savvylovexx 2 года назад

Calories don’t count on thanksgiving everyone knows that 😂

@Joe_Parmesan 2 года назад

Too bad they didn't try some peach cobbler

@walterkavanagh9337 2 года назад

But..but... Mom said the calories were removed!

@abertasso1298 7 месяцев назад

I could listen to the whole group describe literally almost anything. They are so much fun.

@user-fz9kh1bl8e 8 месяцев назад

God bless the irish. Peace from California.

@TheHighSorcerer 2 года назад

New life plan: Move to Ireland, open pie shop. My parents owned a bakery in my youth, my mom's pie recipes won an award from the city. I feel like I'd do well there with how excited everybody got over those pies, and I know how to make all of them.

@MrBottlecapBill 2 года назад

The problem is you won't find the ingredients you need to make these pies in Ireland lol. You could truck it in but that will cost you a LOT. Which is why most of these people have never eaten these pies before.

@Pixieshade 2 года назад

@Bottlecapbill you don't have pumpkins or apples trees or cherries in Ireland? I imagine pecans would be expensive just like here. But surprised you're cant buy Sugar, flour, eggs, butter, cinnamon? That would all have to shipped in? Pie are very simple with few ingredients.

@TonsMoreCowbell 2 года назад

Free name idea: American Pie

@johnisaacdavey 2 года назад

Do iiiiit

@seeking.harmony 2 года назад

You should watch the movie Waitress. She invents different pies. A lot of them sound scrumptious.

@qwazse4 2 года назад

Let’s be clear: not all thanksgiving pies are dessert pies. There’s also the pie you’ll have for breakfast, the one you’ll have for lunch, and the one for halftime during the football game.

@lth5015 2 года назад

Lol, what? That's got to be a your family only thing or possibly a regional thing. Pie for breakfast? Pie for lunch? But "lunch" is dinner on thanksgiving. Also pie for halftime has to be a joke right?

@richardgilson3512 2 года назад

@@lth5015 agreed. Halftime is for wings, possibly nachos depending on preference

@joelw2012 2 года назад

@@lth5015 Yeah I've never had Thanksgiving pie for anything but dessert.

@blaz3r77 2 года назад

I get what you're talking about, Thanksgiving is an all day thing that everyone gathers together for. you have your first big plate full of everything and then everyone grazes as the day goes by, getting your favorites as you get hungry again

@Darth.Fluffy 2 года назад

Hell yeah...pumpkin pie is awesome for breakfast. It's because it's better chilled.. For desert? Apple pie (hot) with FROZEN ice cream.

@Weebwithpurplehair 5 месяцев назад

I've got a friend in Scotland who told me they don't have pecan pie in Scotland and I was shocked. So it made me so happy to see people from Ireland eating and loving pecan pie.

@TheAncientOneYT 7 месяцев назад

I love the fact that he knows the lyrics to the She's My Cherry Pie song. Considering he looks pretty young, it makes me as an American feel proud. By the way, I have always wanted to visit, if not live in Ireland - the country looks beautiful. I wish I could afford a visit, my years are slowly getting me numbered :(

@MarrionThompson Год назад

If that's a cherry pie, I'm stunned. Cherry pie is traditionally made from tart Queen Anne cherries creating a pleasant sweet-tart combination. The filling is red.

@spirt010701 8 месяцев назад

Pair cherry pie with butter pecan ice cream or pecan praline.

@sandhermit3665 8 месяцев назад

To me, it looked like blueberry pie, that might account for the lack of taste. Don't get me wrong, I like blueberries but they don't have a strong flavor. Cherries on the other hand are really flavorful.

@sscot720 8 месяцев назад

It looked like blueberry, which i Love

@stevenmassel259 8 месяцев назад

It's a black cherry pie. It's not a red cherry pie, which is more tart.

@amysmith6783 7 месяцев назад

First off, cherry pie does not look like that (at least none that I've ever had) it should have a beautiful sweet/tart mix of a taste. Secondly, I think the pecan and the sweet potato pie should have been made by a true southern. I am from Pennsylvania and can honestly say so far the best tasting is from the south. I've tasted them, I know. Northern states, I am truly sorry your's just don't cut it.

@Opry99er Год назад

Glad you liked the pumpkin and pecan! That cherry pie you guys ate did not look like an American cherry pie at all. 😂

@fluffydog9356 Год назад

I agree! Almost looked like blackberry pie.

@02ujtb00626 Год назад

I thought it was blueberry.

@sarahglaser1252 Год назад

Those were bitter cherries

@TigerRose246 Год назад

The purple-ish color and small fruits of that pie looked more like blueberry, to me. Was expecting the red color of the classic cherry. No photos of cherry pie look like that, at all!

@crystaldushkin8909 Год назад

Exactly! Needs to be made with canned cherry pie filling, not with real, actual cherries!! 😏 guess you wouldn't know that in Ireland though haha!

@faithismespeaks6848 8 месяцев назад

There are many versions of pumpkin pie, the homemade deluxe versions of pumpkin pie are to die for, especially if the person baking it knows how to make the perfect crust.

@kevinroberts9580 6 месяцев назад

My mom made the greatest Pecan pies, she baked 10 for Thanksgiving and Christmas, and people begged for more. My aunt tried to make pecan pies like my mother's using my mother's recipe and they didn't turn out as good. She told her it was because she wasn't holding her mouth right when she made it😂 my favorite pie is Blueberry

@SunshineCatwoman 2 года назад

I have to say that the "cherry" pie you sampled looked and sounded nothing like our cherry pie. Our cherry pie is bright red and bursting with cherry flavor.

@snowflakehunter 2 года назад

Not all are bright red. That is artificial coloring in canned cherry mix.

@carolells8240 2 года назад

@@snowflakehunter But cherries aren't black, at least not cherries I put in a pie.

@whosweptmymines3956 2 года назад

@@snowflakehunter Yep, the cherry pies I grew up with are red, but not crazy bright artificial red. Seriously though, cherry pies are top-notch.

@Skitdora2010 2 года назад

@@snowflakehunter If you cook pies with real fresh red sweet cherries, the pies are red like a strawberry pie is. The darker cherries I think are the tart sour cherries grown by Michigan. When you cook your pies, don't use purchased fruit mix. Slice and dice your fruit and sprinkle a 1/4 cup of sugar over it and let it sit in the sugar to pull out the juices for an hour or more. Then dump it in your pie shell and bake. Edit- If you want a non juicy pie add a little flour or cornstarch to thicken and gel up the juices some.

@snowflakehunter 2 года назад

@@Skitdora2010 In all likelihood, these cherries came from the cherry capital of the world...Croatia. I say that given the proximity of it to Ireland where this video was shot. To narrow it down further I suspect the cherries came from the Luxardo Family Farms in Italy which grows a proprietary cherry that is a type of Morello cherry and is super dark red.

@JayBendt 2 года назад

"we have a fuckload of pumpkins here - wake up Ireland" this made me laugh. seeing their joy eating pies was delightful.

@meganroberts8721 Год назад

Wonder if the pumpkins they have are carving or pie pumpkins

@loganshaw4527 Год назад

Lol the love of pumpkin pie and the hate for sweet potato pie. Lol I think I am part Irish some where.

@loganshaw4527 Год назад

I would rather have a baked golden potato then a sweet potato.

@valeriedemello1794 Год назад

First you have to get someone to process them and put the puree in a can. Making pies from actual pie pumpkins is a real bitch!

@LaurieSwenson 10 месяцев назад

@@valeriedemello1794 I made pumpkin pie from huge jack-o-lantern pumpkins for years. I didn't realize the small pumpkins were the pie pumpkins. But they all taste good to me!

@yardsale49 7 месяцев назад

When I was in the Army and deployed to Operation Desert Storm our Mess Sargent made a sweet potato pie type desert. He used surplus sweet potatoes and what he had in hand. I dont think he had ingredients for crust but it was absolutely fantastic.

@rayeckert242 9 месяцев назад

Greetings from the good old USA. Pecan, blueberry, peach, apple… Hard to go wrong with American pie! And as far as the whole “pumpkin spice” thing goes… Just make the freakin’ pie!

@pamelabasilone5173 2 года назад

I've never seen cherry pie that looks like that! You've been duped! Cherry pie is made with sour red cherries, they're very specific and they're even called "pie cherries". They're EVERYTHING! Tart and sweet. Demand the real thing! Also, sweet potato pie is more of a southern or cultural preference. Pumpkin is the choice of the vast majority for Thanksgiving. Pecan, speaks for itself, it's amazing!

@ditzydoo4378 2 года назад

Agreed!!! That was the Saddest excuse for a cherry-pie I do believe I've ever seen...

@Apcideful 2 года назад

Looking at how the color it left on the crust and ice cream was blue I'd say they had a blackberry or blueberry pie, not a cherry pie.

@ailish086 2 года назад

I’ve never seen red cherries for sale in Ireland. Just the black ones.

@jchacon9362 2 года назад

100 % agree. I make pies all the time and I have never made a cherry pie that is that dark. It looks more like blackberry and I bet it is blackberry.

@edwardmclaughlin8851 2 года назад

shush

@lemuryellowtail4819 Год назад

pecan pie really doesn't need any added caramel it is so sweet

@Yukikazehalo Год назад

Makes me wonder if the pecan pie was made correctly because even by American standards its a very sweet pie, a caramel drizzle should be completely unnecessary.

@lnsflare1 Год назад

I think that the salt in the salted caramel is what gives it the extra oomph.

@Yukikazehalo Год назад

@Starkey Morgan that was my thought, a proper Pecan Pie would be absurdly sweet by European standards.

@Roonasaur Год назад

It is mostly sugar in the first place, lol

@incudust953 Год назад

@@Yukikazehalo if the caramel is just as sweet as the pecan pie then it wouldnt make a difference. It doesnt make it sweeter than it already is if both the pie and drizzle are of equal sweetness. it just adds another flavor profile.

@Seofthwa 9 месяцев назад

The blond lady's enthusiasm towards everything always brings a smile to my face.

@joyal77 7 месяцев назад

American pies are THE BEST! Love Thanksgiving! As a Brazilian living in America it’s my favorite holiday, best pies, love all American pies 😋😋😋😋😋😋😋❤️👍🏼

@hisbigal 2 года назад

I remember when I first moved to Scotland 16 years ago, I wondered how I would ever make a pumpkin pie. Since I couldn’t get any canned puree, I bought an actual pumpkin and made it from scratch. It was far more labour intensive than I ever imagined, but it turned out really good. I made a Thanksgiving dinner for my Scottish friends who had never had an American Thanksgiving experience. They approved.

@DaemaroBloodmoon 2 года назад

Fun fact the stuff in the can isn't a actually a pumpkin. At least not the kind you'd use for decoration or a jack-o'-lantern. The canned stuff is A Dickinson squash. Pumpkin is a broad term so they can label it as that still.

@katmandudawn8417 2 года назад

My sister lives in Australia and would take canned pumpkin back when she came home to visit. She once made a couple of pumpkin pies for a gathering at work. They were a huge hit to the point that 2 guys almost had a fight over the last piece. America is a huge pie loving place. We have tons of types. I always add a splash of bourbon in my pecan pie. And from scratch banana cream or baked coconut pies are wonderful. I love lemon chess, blueberry and peach pies too. I like homemade pie better than cake but most store bought pies are gross. Terrible bland or overly sweet filling with disgusting crust. My kids cried when given store bought pie for the first time. They wanted to know what was “wrong” with it.

@nooneyouknowhere6148 2 года назад

@@DaemaroBloodmoon or hubbard squash. Some actually have real pumpkin.

@edmartin875 2 года назад

@@katmandudawn8417 Agree about store bought pies.

@MP_heehee 2 года назад

@@katmandudawn8417 yesss you have to add the bourbon, it's the magic ingredient!

@neome776 2 года назад

Aww…nobody’s old enough to give props to that young man’s rendition of Warrant’s “Cherry Pie!” 🤘🏼

@traviswells9586 2 года назад

I am old enough…just was not a fan of the song.

@Todd.T 2 года назад

I am old enough. I'm still upset about the dollar store cherry pie that none of us eat that was chosen to represent.

@kaldo_kaldo 2 года назад

I think old music still exists. I was a kid when it came out. He did a good job, but I don't like the song.

@centuryrox 2 года назад

@@traviswells9586 I liked the chick in the music video much more than the song!

@tidefanyankee2428 2 года назад

@@centuryrox Bobbie Brown is her name. She ended up marrying the lead singer.

@momishka7 5 месяцев назад

"we know what to do with potatoes and we know NOT to do this" fkn beautiful i laughed so hard, thank you. love love

@RandE89 7 месяцев назад

"Fack-loads" Hahaha, love it! I think about 30% of the reason I watch these videos is the adorable accents and differences in annunciation.

@ediisasi9270 10 дней назад

Feck-loads. Feck is kinda like F*** lite for the Irish I would say.

@Withidread 2 года назад

Whatever else you have, a proper Thanksgiving generally includes having multiple pies that you and your guests have no hope of finishing until at least 2-3 days later. So the answer to the question "Pumpkin or Pecan?" is "Yes."

@charlesbauer6075 2 года назад

So True!

@LoideainTheScribe 2 года назад

AND you get a slice of pie with a cup of coffee for breakfast the next day. Yummmmm

@emilywilliams2970 2 года назад

Fully intend to make seven types in the next few days

@chris...9497 2 года назад

Several pies is absolutely the tradition.

@maryjokelleher6396 2 года назад

In my family it's "I'll have a little of each".

@brt5273 2 года назад

That cherry pie was made with those dark canned cherries that are used for some purpose that I've never been able to figure out...not what we typically use in the States. Should have been tart/sour cherries that have a wonderful complex flavor with the sugar and pastry. Also "Dutch Apple Pie" is the best version of apple pie, which has a pastry shell filled with apples and topped with a crisp and highly spiced cinnamon and ginger crumb.

@sorbicsagor5080 2 года назад

My only guess for why some stores use/sell those dark cherry pies is because said cherry tree produces well and is easy to cultivate. A proper red cherry pie, while not my favorite, has tones of flavor.

@janiceconnolly8740 2 года назад

Yes!!! That’s the good stuff! @Billy Todd

@RedRoseSeptember22 2 года назад

Absolutely with the Dutch apple pie, so delicious.

@PapaBushka 2 года назад

I'm in the States, and everyone I know who bakes cherry pies uses those gaodaweful canned cherries.

@ford4life069 2 года назад

Crumbs that fall off and make a mess. No thanks. Give me a lattice double crust, still warm with the ice cream on top. Wafer thin is also a crime. Nice thick chunks that give you a real bite of fruit. Mix of apple varieties too. They just need to come to Texas and have someone cook for them because most of their pies looked bad.

@seandunne6714 7 месяцев назад

The thing about pumpkin pie and sweet potato pie is if like one you hate the other. 🥧🥧🥧

@lisageoffrion7826 7 месяцев назад

Glad you like our pies!!!

@eddiewakesmusic3137 2 года назад

😲..If anybody describes their Sweet Potato Pie experience as tasting merely like “mashed Sweet Potatoes”, they have most certainly NOT had Sweet Potato Pie!!! The implications of what’s missing is stark! 😉

@marlonsmalls6820 2 года назад

I am borderline offended at their reaction to Sweet Potato Pie

@marytramp5678 2 года назад

why does everyone have to like sweet potato pie? i love sweet potatoes, but HATE sweet potato pie. i happen to agree with the Irish on this one. somethings shouldn't be made into piies, and sweet potatoes are one of them. it ranks up there with Pickled hogs feet on the disgusting ranking chart for me.

@jendubay3782 2 года назад

@@marytramp5678 you don’t have to agree with it, but saying that implies that perhaps it was made incorrectly, as the cherry pie was (by using the wrong type of cherries.) If that’s the case, it’s not really a fair trial.

@marytramp5678 2 года назад

@@jendubay3782 so if i don't like something it's simply bc it was made incorrectly? that's complete and utter bs. and point in fact sweet potato pie is mashed sweet potatoes! and baked very similiarly to pumpkin pie. i say similiarly bc there are different spices. thank GOD bc i love pumpkin pie. People like different things, not everyone's pallette is the same. it's part of what makes us all unique. it doesn't always come down to how it was prepared. i try not to judge things on how i like it the first time, i will give things a 2nd and often times a 3rd chance before i say i definitely don't like it. i can honestly say i HATE sweet potato pie. it is a pumpkin pie wanna be. and ranks right up there with pickled pigs feet. another southern delicacy i can't stand.

@marytramp5678 2 года назад

@@mattbrew11 wth is a "dark American"?

@feldweible 2 года назад

I have NEVER seen a "Cherry" pie that was that color.

@777SilverPhoenix777 2 года назад

i think someone used black cherries to make that. explains why that was a horrible pie.

@JJ-uq7te 2 года назад

Those pies looked awful. Thin sliced apples.?? Black cherries??? No lemon merang or chocolate merang ??? Those were lame pies. I know. I'm the son of an expert baker.

@snowflakehunter 2 года назад

It is a Luxardo cherry pie. The original maraschino cherry. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-ZB7U3nqoWX4.html

@iamnotamused317 2 года назад

Yeah, looks a bit suspicious to me.

@snowflakehunter 2 года назад

@@iamnotamused317 It is a Luxardo Cherry pie. Luxardo Cherries (also known as Luxardo Maraschi9no Cherries) are grown by the Luxardo Family on there farm in Italy. They have a deep dark red/purple color and are both naturally sweet and tart. Regular Maraschi9no cherries pales in comparison. You should be suspicious of the cherries commonly used in the U.S., They are bleached with added sugar to make them sweet. Luxardo cherries are much more common in European countries due to logistics. The closest thing we have in the U.S. are Bing cherries, yet we insist on using inferior cherries with Morello and Amarelle cherries making up 95% of all cherries used in the in U.S. for its pies. Luxardo cherries are so much better.

@ptorq 8 месяцев назад

Sweet potato pie and pumpkin pie are very similar things to me; they're not identical, but it's still kind of surprising to me that everybody LOVED the pumpkin and HATED the sweet potato. Also, cherry pie is not supposed to be that color. What you had looked like somebody tried to make cherry pie with (fairly sweet) bing cherries instead of (very tart) sour cherries or something. Which might be pretty good, but it wouldn't be at all the same, and you'd probably need to cut way back on the sugar. I personally like pineapple pie, and the last few times I've gone to the trouble to make a pie myself, it's been pineapple.

@user-tq1ni3bw3l 6 месяцев назад

Sweet potato pie made right is more savory....

@dalegreer3095 5 месяцев назад

True, good cherry pie is very red.

@33brookerray 8 месяцев назад

They need to try boysenberry pie from Knott’s Berry Farm. Now that is wonderful pie. 😊

@karenjurado8489 7 месяцев назад

Knotts pies are amazing!

@markroeder2491 7 месяцев назад

My favorite fruit pie!

@sjean2166 2 года назад

I'm pretty sure "I'm not sure if I like it, I need to try another bite" is the standard response to pumpkin pie (for a first timer)

@loganshaw4527 Год назад

That Irish response is classic for sweet potato pie.

@occheermommy Год назад

No I still feel that way until my piece is gone. Then I try another piece. I’m still not sure. Get back to me after thanksgiving

@SquireWhipple 2 года назад

As an American who absolutely loves pumpkin pie, it was fun watching everyone come around on it. They were all looking at it with fear in their eyes at first, but the fear quickly turned to disbelief at what their taste buds were telling them.

@augustbrown9711 2 года назад

Pumpkin pie looks gross, but tastes amazing.

@dirac_dydx1830 2 года назад

It warms my heart to see people discovering new foods that they like.

@frederickvondinkerberg7721 2 года назад

Nothing on earth would make me eat that shit

@jreyman 2 года назад

Yep, Pumpkin pie is very good. It's evil twin, sweet potato pie, is the exact opposite of good.

@rebeccaobrien2642 2 года назад

They should try it again served appropriately as a pumpkin-y vessel for whipped cream. The topping on the side borders on barbaric.

@mellokeith 8 месяцев назад

If you use the same seasonings as the pumpkin pie, the sweet potato pie will taste the same. When I lived in the UK and had trouble finding canned pumpkin, I used sweet potatoes… almost no noticeable difference. Enjoy!

@lharrill7229 6 месяцев назад

You should try making a pumpkin pie from a fresh pumpkin. My mother used to make them. Once in a while she'd try to slip thru a pumpkin pie made with canned pumpkin and we always knew. And no one like it. So much better made from fresh pumpkin. My mom would cut up and cook the pumpkin and divide it into single pie servings in freezer bags and freeze it. To use later.

@chrisstevens410 2 месяца назад

@@lharrill7229what kind of pumpkin did shee use? I am told that tha jack-o-lantern pumpkins are watery and flavorless.

@lharrill7229 2 месяца назад

@chrisstevens410 Just regular Halloween pumpkins. As kids we realized carving pumpkins didn't get us pumpkin pies. So I began painting them instead so my mom could make pies out of them. One time they came home with a pumpkin they bought that was so big they had to park the truck right up to the back of the house and roll the pumpkin off the truck and into the porch. It was an old sleeping porch. So it sat at the same elevation as the house and was fairly big. She got enough pumpkin to make over 70 pies from that one pumpkin. Cooked it down and froze it in freezer bags. I wish I had learned exactly how to cook them down. Poor woman couldn't fool us with canned pumpkin. Big difference.

@StarFlare6TL 6 месяцев назад

Oh my god I need more Irish people trying things.

@innocentsweetiepie 2 года назад

You have to have someone who knows how to truly make sweet potato pie to get the full delicious experience of it

@frederickvondinkerberg7721 2 года назад

Vile

@tampazeke4587 2 года назад

Exactly! Sweet potato pie is frickin' amazing when done right. Get one from the American South.

@77Brainfreeze 2 года назад

I've never had a slice of sweet potato pie and not instantly thought "I wish this was pumpkin instead".

@0001captainawesome 2 года назад

I like how the "traditional" pumkin pie slowly grew on all of them. They all had to keep taking more bites lol.

@xzonia1 2 года назад

Oh, to taste pumpkin pie again for the first time. X) I loved the one lady saying she could see why we put it in lattes. Pumpkin pie is wonderful! :)

@jonathanbell8887 2 года назад

It’s the ONLY pie I truly love.

@highpineapple 2 года назад

Exactly! Hahaha

@cc1k435 2 года назад

@@jonathanbell8887 It's not the only pie I truly love, but it is one I specifically look forward to every fall.

@rapodaca3360 2 года назад

@@jonathanbell8887 I kinda agree with you but... Have you ever had sweet potato pie?

@michaelsnyder6922 8 месяцев назад

I’ve eaten an entire pumpkin pie in about 30 minutes before. Best thing on earth

@JasonChannell 7 месяцев назад

Callyann has the best accent. Adorable.

@toriblue Год назад

For any viewer who isn't American, I just wanted to point out that pumpkin pie is usually relegated to Thanksgiving (and sometimes Christmas) but all of the others are served year round. Pumpkin harvests are seasonal (fall) ...which is why we don't tend to serve pumpkin pies during the spring or summer.

@VS-re1sr Год назад

Yep! Plus pumpkins are native to the Americas (Mexico) so they are associated with what the Natives served the European settlers. Same with turkey and potatoes (again, Mexico). The first Thanksgiving included venison, game birds, fish, and corn.

@magpiewench Год назад

I mean, you can get canned pumpkin all year. It's my husband's favorite (after sweet potato), and if I'm rolling pie crust anyway, I'll make a pumpkin or sweet potato pie.

@gaellegoutain1286 Год назад

I did not see any pecan pie other that around Thanksgiving or Xmas.

@peacefullyme848 Год назад

@@gaellegoutain1286 pecan pie is usually found year round in the southern US.

@gaellegoutain1286 Год назад

@@peacefullyme848 Never seen them other than during the holidays :(

@BigLegoBear70 2 года назад

That "cherry" pie looked more like blueberry pie.

@mayhmmaydn 2 года назад

Yah that was gross looking

@annbower6278 2 года назад

Definitely not cherry by a long stetch since the producer screwed on that 1.

@frocat5163 2 года назад

@@annbower6278 I'm pretty sure that cherry pie was made from Bing cherries (or some other sweet cherry) instead of a more traditional sour cherry like a Morello or Amarelle.

@rockinsteady406 7 месяцев назад

I love the "Warrant" references with the cherry pie.

@kyndread71 2 года назад

Every Thanksgiving, my family gives me a whole pumpkin pie, just for me only. And I eat it by myself. PROUDLY.

@davidhall2197 2 года назад

Will your family adopt me? lol

@2Stonefly 2 года назад

Well done sir.

@Jadamhodges 2 года назад

As a North Carolinian growing up on all of these pies homemade, I can attest to that a sweet potato pie is freaking amazing and should be sweet like that pumpkin pie. Both should be delicious, I think that one you had was not correctly made.

@ewitdakey8683 Год назад

That what I was thinking I’m from North Carolina too

@DontUBaDiva Год назад

Yes I don't think they got good sweet potato & cherry pies.

@LuWho21 Год назад

I had the same thoughts. My mom makes a sweet potato custard that’s very similar to the pie without the crust. She makes a nut and brown sugar with butter crumble for the topping, similar to a Dutch apple pie.

@jeffhollers1241 Год назад

Yep. From North Carolina. The sweet potato pie they tasted must not have come from round here.

@skyethebard Год назад

It didn't even look right...it was too light. My family loves pumpkin pie so I mostly make that for holiday dinners but I like sweet potato pie just a bit more.

@keithchandler8316 4 месяца назад

This was the first video I have watched on your channel and being an American and seeing your reactions were priceless! Thank you for laughs.

@momof2momof2 7 месяцев назад

So much fun watching people in other countries enjoy our food.

@ronhall5395 Год назад

Wow, A good cherry pie needs to be made with tart cherries. I have never seen a cherry pie that looked like that one. I think it had some other berries mixed in.

@summerhunnie23 Год назад

I feel like they used black cherries, such a shame.

@gelflingfay Год назад

It is probably what was available at the time to make it with.

@kred792 Год назад

that legit looked like a Marie Callender's blackberry pie

@mrspock2al Год назад

Michigander here. You need red tart cherries from Traverse City, MI for the best cherry pie with a big scoop of vanilla ice cream. Stay away from the canned filling and make sure that all the pits are removed (Guess how I know)

@buddymitchell6216 Год назад

I feel bad they made the cherry pie with the wrong type of cherries I’ve never seen a black cherry pie.

@Joseph-tf4lg 2 года назад

You guys need a cherry pie made from Oregon tart cherries, like montmorency, balanced with sugar, a buttery flakey crust, and whipped cream. It's perfect.

@susanflanagan8010 2 года назад

That sounds amazing!

@TruthTroubadour-xi9cc 2 года назад

@@susanflanagan8010 it is!

@janethobbs1195 7 месяцев назад

So fun to watch people in Ireland eat Thanksgiving food. You make me want to make Thanksgiving dinner in Ireland!

@shapeach 8 месяцев назад

My grandmother was born in 1900 in South Louisiana. She was an incredible baker. Our favorite though was blackberry over homemade dumplings!! Just like Chicken and dumplings but with sugar added. Rolled by hand with rolling pin. Next, fresh blackberries, on top and since the desert is best when eaten warm, its topped with real cream! The blackberries came from my uncle's farm, but any fresh black berries will do. It is probably the best desert I have ever eaten in my LIFE!! try it when the berries are in season!

@Sharay98 2 года назад

The thing about cherry pies is that they’re more of a summer pie than a fall pie, because cherries are in season during the summer.

@michelemaliano7860 2 года назад

Yeah, and they are bright red. You would not confuse it with blueberry.

@NathanCline12-21 2 года назад

I like cherry pie no matter the time or day

@miamorecadenza1226 2 года назад

Agreed. I mean part of the things we eat on Thanksgiving is that its from the Harvest. The apples are perfect at this particular time of year, and so are the pumpkins and sweet potatoes.

@titaneyes1 2 года назад

Being from Iowa, I've had all of these pies, many MANY times. But, I've never seen a cherry pie that looks like that. I wouldn't call that a cherry pie.

@alwaysopen7970 2 года назад

Canned cherry pie goo found in all grocery stores.

@seanmilliken4866 2 года назад

@@alwaysopen7970 EXACTLY!!! The American way!

@myblueskye777 2 года назад

I agree it's a Scary Pie.

@erikabailey7397 2 года назад

Maybe they used sweet cherries instead?

@rickalexander2801 2 года назад

a Hostess brand cherry pie looks and tastes better than what they were eating

@dawnbullard6068 6 месяцев назад

I agree. My cousin has mastered my grandmother’s sweet potato pie recipe. He made me a pie for Christmas and I ate the whole thing in 1.5 days sooo goood🤤😋😛

@marjoriejohnson6535 7 месяцев назад

Apple pie without the cheese is like a hug without the squeeze...cheddaar wedge served on the side...my grandfather used to say this , i remember 1955

@briansimpson1330 4 месяца назад

OMG. When we were little Dad had apple pie with cheese. We looked at him like WHAT? Tried it and it was game on then Love it

@brianplaysgames7456 2 года назад

Out of all the pies presented, sweet potato pie can vary the most depending on how it is made. Different people use different spices to flavor it, thus the taste can widely vary. When it's made right, sweet potato pie is my favorite Thanksgiving pie.

@Hellboy700 2 года назад

Exactly. Some people don't know how to make a proper sweet potato pie. Especially when you are supposed to press the cooked sweet potato through a sieve to remove the fibrous threads. The spice blend and the sweetener can influence the overall character of the pie and the color. Willing to bet no molasses or brown sugar was used in that pie.

@Cha-Llin 2 года назад

I was looking for this comment. I've come across some people who can't mentally get past a potato dessert. L Which meant more for me.

@ThumbsMcThumb 2 года назад

Sweet potato pie is the imposter of pumpkin pie. Just like oatmeal cookies can be an imposter of chocolate chip.

@Hellboy700 2 года назад

@@ThumbsMcThumb ummm, no. Sweet potato pie is a new world invention and has every reason to be present in Thanksgiving. Your idea of it being an imposter is both historically inaccurate and borderline ignorant. Say you don’t like it, fine. Say it’s an imposter to pumpkin pie, and get called out for not knowing the significance of its existence.

@ThumbsMcThumb 2 года назад

@@Hellboy700 sweet potato pie: looks like pumpkin pie, but is a LIE. That’s an imposter 💯

@Mike-123 2 года назад

As an American, I've never actually had sweet-potato pie, so no worries there. You guys got screwed on the cherry pie though! How is it black and not red? Legit cherry pie is delicious.

@pedantic79 2 года назад

I think they used sweet cherries, like Bings. Instead of tart cherries.

@fr2ncm9 2 года назад

The best cherries for a pie are the sour variety.

@CanyonALynn 2 года назад

Yeah, it looked like blueberries or blackberries.

@notimportant3820 2 года назад

You should definitely try sweet potato pie, it's amazing when it's homemade. ❤️

@susanfabian1521 2 года назад

These days store bought pumpkin pie has more sweet potato than pumpkin in it.

@terrypokorny4755 4 месяца назад

From the usa thank you irish i am native american and irish on my mom side . Food is good so is your

@dougjohnson3990 5 месяцев назад

There are so many things we take for granted. It’s hard to believe that they haven’t eaten fruit/ pumpkin pies. I want to show them the food world of the US!

@KawaTony1964 2 года назад

If the sweet potato pie was made properly, it should taste almost exactly like the pumpkin pie. They both usually use "pumpkin spice", which is cloves, nutmeg, cinnamon, ginger and allspice. The only difference is the fairly bland medium to hold the spice flavor. In a pumpkin pie, the medium is almost tasteless pumpkin. In a sweet potato pie, the medium is slightly more flavorful but denser sweet potato. So, the fact that you hated the sweet potato pie but liked the pumpkin pie tells me there was something wrong with the sweet potato pie.

@SheAThought 2 года назад

Facts sweet potato pie is a denser (and superior) pumpkin pie...

@HermanVonPetri 2 года назад

A sweet potato pie might be ever so slightly more... fibrous? I guess than a pumpkin pie. But yes, a lot of people really can't tell the difference between them.

@joeyrobison6629 2 года назад

I prefer the sweet potato pie over the pumpkin pie. The flavor I get from pumpkin is a sort of musky flavor. (sorry for the redundancy), from the sweet potato the earthy along with the spice.

@damonhowell6292 2 года назад

All of this. I’ve had bad sweet potato pie, and I expect that’s what happened here. When it’s done right, it’s nearly indistinguishable from pumpkin.

@nathanlarge4497 2 года назад

They'd be able to tell the difference with my preferred sweet potato pie recipe... a couple of shots of bourbon go in the filling.

@SamBryans128 11 месяцев назад

Their reaction to pumpkin is spot on. Step 1: What is this? Step 2: Is this gross? Step 3: Do I like this? Step 4: No, I think I might like this. Step 5: Oh wow. This is actually great.

@AndyMatts44 9 месяцев назад

I really don't like clove, so I'd done after step 2.

@DeadCat-42 9 месяцев назад

Use nutmeg and cinnamon instead.@@AndyMatts44

@mcarrusa 8 месяцев назад

The total progression of almost every food of my childhood.

@funnyusername8635 7 месяцев назад

For years I thought I hated pumpkin pie. Turns out I just hated my grandma's pumpkin pie (sorry grandma!).

@FreeJennJenn 7 месяцев назад

😂

@hamblinta 7 месяцев назад

We have all sorts of pies: there is apple, cherry, peach, blackberry, strawberry rhubarb, lemon, key lime, pumpkin, sweet potato, turtle, chocolate, banana cream, lemon cream, coconut cream, French silk, mince meat, chess, buttermilk pie, and the list goes on and on! We love our desserts

@TheHOWLER45 9 месяцев назад

Pecan is my favorite being from south Alabama and having pecan trees everywhere. I love my moms pecan pie. I learned to fix one from her recipe that she got from her mom and so on, and so on.

@SavageGreywolf Год назад

Honestly I think of cherry pie as more of a Christmastime thing. Also that cherry pie looked bizarre, like it was from an alternate dimension's America. Our cherry pie filling is like neon red, like you could flag down a truck with it.

@codymartin3370 Год назад

This is so true, but the way it was stated literally made me bust out laughing 😂 But seriously, that’s not a cherry pie lol

@jojogian2428 Год назад

Cherry pie to me is March/April or late summer 🥧. I love their reactions!

@horsewings3561 Год назад

YES I literally just made home made cherry pie the other day. Seriously what did they DO to that cherry pie.

@CallMeDutch83 Год назад

The Rick of pies.

@leekestner1554 Год назад

To be so dark they had to make that out of Bing sweet cherries in stead of pie cherries that are tart.

@Patrickjohnphotography 2 года назад

As a Northerner, I am so glad that my first sweet potato pie was made by a Southerner. Sweet, flavorful, and perfect. I feel for these Try-ers. :(

@TexasRose50 2 года назад

I always wonder if they were store bought, or did someone actually make them from scratch? Especially the pie crusts.

@Hypegreene05 2 года назад

That's what I said. Someone didn't handle the sweet potato pie the way they were supposed to.

@phazesix 2 года назад

As a Northerner, I've never had sweet potato pie. Pumpkin is my fave...no need to branch out. I've probably only had pecan pie once in my life as well.

@KrisFlicks 2 года назад

@@phazesix oh bro you GOTTA try a good ole southern sweet potato pie, i promise it’ll open your third eye and change ya life

@RhandiChapman 7 месяцев назад

OMG - you guys are hysterical! So fun to hear what ya'll think!

@christopherbillington8965 5 месяцев назад

Sweet potato pies are all about the spice mixture. I've never had a good one from a store or bakery, but I've made some that were unbelievably delicious. A good sweet potato pie is everything a Pumpkin pie wishes it was, but more.

@xtapl 2 года назад

I don't know what that "cherry pie" was made out of, but it looks SUPER SUSPECT.

@edgewood99 2 года назад

BLACK CHERRIES...not the red kind.

@dcordin 2 года назад

to me it looks more like blueberries.

@LeesaDeAndrea 2 года назад

Sour cherries make the tastiest pie. I wonder if they used sweet cherries? Because pies made with sour cherries are not bland!

@donavanblue9247 2 года назад

love their faces when they got their 1st taste of Pecan Pie.

@JebHoge 2 года назад

Same here. I knew it was going to be true love but it was so fun to watch.

@Kittycat822 7 месяцев назад

I had a good chuckle! My grandma being an Irish immigrant to America she had a very limited food pallet.

@Happy_H0ur 7 месяцев назад

Ugh now imagine they're getting a nice warm super gourmet version of these! Yum!!!

@tessyredding5422 2 года назад

You’ve misrepresented a cherry pie, we do it better than whatever that was. We love pie here 😊 great shoot

@marinapappas5073 2 года назад

I honestly thought that was a blueberry pie when they brought it out. 😂

@Amy_Dunn 2 года назад

I also thought it was a blueberry pie! They also misrepresented sweet potato pie. It's a southern dish and it's amazing if made right. I have a feeling they just mashed up sweet potatoes and put it in a pie shell by their reactions. 😆

@drj.r.cooper2493 2 года назад

True! I think someone in Ireland made the lies from a recipe & substituted BLACK cherries. A for effort, D- for execution...I've NEVER met anyone who would make that mistake. By the way @TheTryChannel, there are at least 4 DOZEN very different pies y'all could/should try.... and none of those stores bought pies! The pumpkin pie should've been 50% thicker & the apple pie needed big chunks of apples, plus Lemon Meringue, REAL cherry pie, plus 4 different kinds of chocolate pie, etc., etc. Thanksgiving is a flop unless the most, uptight, snooty, self-loving fashionista loosens his/her belt & the top snap/button of their pants, stating, "I'll never eat that much again as long as I live....but I plan to try NEXT Thanksgiving!"

@marinapappas5073 2 года назад

I was thinking the same thing about the sweet potato pie. It has almost the same spices as the pumpkin pie so I was confused by their reaction to it.

@lynnwilhoite6194 2 года назад

@@marinapappas5073 Me too. I make a mean sweet potato pie, and in my opinion, much better than pumpkin pie.

@reed13k73 2 года назад

The pumpkin looked overbaked to the point of being burnt, and the cherry was the darkest cherry pie I've seen in my life. Glad you all liked em - pumpkin is super easy to make by the way.

@sidneyvandykeii3169 2 года назад

Pumpkin is only easy to make if you can find it in a can though. My mom used to make it from scratch with real pumpkins and it is NOT easy to make. They do NOT have canned pumpkin pie filling across the pond though.

@larrytuttle3529 2 года назад

That couldn't have been a cherry pie. It was either blueberry, mixed fruit, or rotten cherry.

@RealRaynedance 2 года назад

@@sidneyvandykeii3169 Likely because canned pumpkin doesn't even use the same thing that everyone pictures when they hear the word "pumpkin".

@sidneyvandykeii3169 2 года назад

@@RealRaynedance canned Pumpkin is mostly canned squash if I remember correctly. With the proper spices in it.

@RealRaynedance 2 года назад

@@sidneyvandykeii3169Usually Dickinson squash, yeah. Which has a LOT less water in it and a lot stronger of a flavor.

@Distress. 6 месяцев назад

I know i shouldn't be shocked considering the Irish accent is the progenitor of many southern accents, but every time they do they accent its so amazingly natural.

@johannesvalterdivizzini1523 7 месяцев назад

I'm from NY, so I didn't typically have pecan pie for dessert, but I've come to really enjoy them as traditionally pleasing Thanksgiving pies. A very good thing. My Austrian grandmother used to make a bang-up apple strudel and her finest pie was lemon merengue.

@ppuckette100 2 года назад

Whoever made those sweet potato pies definitely wasn't from the South (USA) or knows how to cook soul food because real sweet potato pie kicks ass!

@JDotWill 2 года назад

Thank you! Most of them not enjoying it killed me a little on the inside & I immediately had to question where they got it & who made it.

@hathi444 2 года назад

Amen! Proper sweet potato pie is incredible! ❤️

@m.gideonhoyle409 2 года назад

Truth...

@sweetest_weasel8132 2 года назад

They need to hire an American to cook for them 🤣

@lisamelroy2855 2 года назад

I just recently tried it for the first time. It was quite similar to pumpkin pie, so I loved it!

@mskraft 2 года назад

Not everyone knows how to make a sweet potato pie. Sounds like they got a bad one. They need to try one of mine. 😉😂

@marcus812 2 года назад

They sounded like it was regular potatoes with sugar 😂

@lilbutterfly6977 2 года назад

I was gonna say... someone f'd up their sweet potato pie. I like them both but to me sweet potato is milder than pumpkin. I don't celebrate Thanksgiving anyway, I'm ½ Cherokee & ½ Irish. Thanksgiving was taught to be were the pilgrims & native Americans sat down & had a peaceful meal to celebrate their union together but in truth it was the pilgrims celebrating the slaughter of the native Americans so yea.... it's just a day of food....

@joeharrington8962 2 года назад

@@lilbutterfly6977 My wife's family is Native as well. They just get together and eat and watch football. That Thanksgiving story school taught us is nothing but horseshit.

@tawhneebaby 2 года назад

I volunteer as tribute...

@Kaya084 2 года назад

I will only eat a sweet potato pie if my aunt makes it. That was the one request I had every year.

@terrijuanette486 7 месяцев назад

Pecan pie is super easy to make: Make and bake the crust; layer the bottom of the pie with pecans and pour the hot syrup on top and bake it. The pecans rise to the top in baking. It's delicious.

@remyllebeau77 5 месяцев назад

They are spot on. Pecan pie is really the best of those.

@superannieoakley4513 10 месяцев назад

Pretty sure this whole segment would've gone different if someone's southern grandmama made these pies!! lol Especially the sweet potato pie. It's one of my favorites. Oh, can't beat a homemade blackberry cobbler(w vanilla ice-cream)either. The blackberries have to be handpicked though! 😋 Yum

@danielfranklin9062 8 месяцев назад

Yes, they should have brought in a southern chef to make the pies for this video. However, sweet potato pie is to pumpkin pie as oatmeal raisin cookies are to chocolate chip cookies.

@bodyrumuae2914 8 месяцев назад

Does she make sweet potato pie with sweet potatoes or with yams because many people don't know the differences?

@yellowiris123 8 месяцев назад

Yes, my mamaw made the best blackberry cobbler. She didn't use a recipe. It was just in her brain. She was a wonderful southern cook and an awesome grandmother.

@superannieoakley4513 8 месяцев назад

@bodyrumuae2914 Any true southerner knows a sweet potato pie is made w sweet potatoes, not yams!😉 There's not a huge difference in the two, but as far as taste goes, the sweet potato is sweeter than a yam

@racpropst 8 месяцев назад

I think my New England mother (of pilgrim descent) would be say all those pies were inedible. However even a bad cherry pie is better than a kidney pie.