Is success genetic? | Kathryn Paige Harden

Подписаться 7 млн

Просмотров 344 тыс.

50% 1

This interview is an episode from The Well, our new publication about ideas that inspire a life well-lived, created with the John Templeton Foundation.
Subscribe to The Well on RU-vid ► bit.ly/thewell-youtube
Watch Kathryn Paige Harden's next interview ► Schools ignore genetics-and that’s actually a bad thing • Schools ignore genetic...
The relationship between genetics and the environment is incredibly complex.
The term "heritability" refers to the proportion of variation in a population that is due to genetic differences. But people misinterpret the word to mean "genetically determined," "unmodifiable," or "innate" - but it doesn't mean any of these things.
Just because a version of a gene might be linked to a particular outcome in one group of people does not mean it is linked to the same outcome in another group of people.
Read the video transcript ► bigthink.com/the-well/nature-...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About Kathryn Paige Harden:
Dr. Kathryn Paige Harden is a tenured professor in the Department of Psychology at UT, where she leads the Developmental Behavior Genetics lab and co-directs the Texas Twin Project. She is the author of The Genetic Lottery: Why DNA Matters for Social Equality (Princeton). Dr. Harden received her Ph.D. in Clinical Psychology from the University of Virginia and completed her clinical internship at McLean Hospital/Harvard Medical School.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Read more from The Well:
I put a camera on a monkey. Here’s how it shook my understanding of humanity
► bigthink.com/the-well/awe-ani...
Atheism is not as rare or as rational as you think
► bigthink.com/the-well/atheism...
System 1 vs. System 2 thinking: Why it isn’t strategic to always be rational
► bigthink.com/the-well/system-...
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
About The Well
Do we inhabit a multiverse? Do we have free will? What is love? Is evolution directional? There are no simple answers to life’s biggest questions, and that’s why they’re the questions occupying the world’s brightest minds.
So what do they think?
How is the power of science advancing understanding? How are philosophers and theologians tackling these fascinating questions?
Let’s dive into The Well.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join The Well on your favorite platforms:
► Facebook: bit.ly/thewellFB
► Instagram: bit.ly/thewellIG

Опубликовано:

12 июн 2022

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 196

@bigthink 2 года назад

How do you think of the relationship between nature and nurture?

@grimsobad8545 2 года назад

As long as you have no genetic disability, genetics don’t determine your success, what determines your success is determination

@dandylandpuffplaysminecraf8744 Год назад

Opportunity is not hard work. 🙃

@sandeepj1479 Год назад

@@grimsobad8545 hi

@grimsobad8545 Год назад

@@sandeepj1479 huh ?

@grimsobad8545 Год назад

@@sandeepj1479 oh shoot I remember you!!

@WildsDreams45 2 года назад

My dad was one of the first Black aviators to work with the AWACS planes and because of my mother I never got to know him or be in a successful environment. It was so bad that when I met my brother at the age of 18 I was shocked that anyone from my family even had a car! It took some time for me to get going because I grew up in tents and motel rooms so needlessly to say I failed in school and was socially lacking. However, after a lot of struggling I started finding success and now I'm on the verge of being a business owner and currently make over 80k a year at my current job. I've always wondered if it's because of my dad or my will power. I just naturally strive towards bigger. I don't like to go out of my way, but I recognize that it's essential. I have to grow and to stop would mean certain death.

@rb757 2 года назад

It was your will power well done, if you wanted to give up you could have but you didn’t.

@bjrnn.2689 2 года назад

Will is god tool but far from the most important for economical sucsess. Will can even be dangerous if you dont have the right tools to channel it. You probably have an iq of 115 or higher, same goes for your father. If you had 90 you would never reach that far, neither would he.

@davyroger3773 2 года назад

@@rb757 why do some people have more will power than others?

@rb757 2 года назад

@@davyroger3773 in my opinion it’s a factor of many things certain people have mental health issues, certain people don’t but I have noticed those that wallow in their sadness & issues always have less will power whereas those that sit with it accept it move on & keep fighting get better even if they start off with less will power I’m saying this also from my own experience by the way. It’s also depends on who we surround ourselves & our core beliefs there’s so many things. I believe that who we are is left in our hands even if we started off with very unfortunate circumstances but how we end up is left up to us. Everyday we have a choice I also have a similar story to yours & I know many people just like myself who have beat their odds & some people that accept defeat. It could be fate to which is a whole other thing which confuses me.

@roguegenesis7020 Год назад

Proud of you shawn! you give me further motivation to improve myself

@FranBunnyFFXII 2 года назад

There's an anime from the 2000s that explores Nature vs Nurture extensively with a lot of it's characters in both very subtle and obvious ways. It's called Elfen Lied. If you watch it, watch it in English, and pay close attention to many of the characters. A lot of the these tiny little things go a long way into later character behaviors. Its a show heavily focused on Discrimination and Abuse. Absolutely brilliant TV show that explores this concept in a non pretentious way. I highly recommend it if you're curious about Nature Vs Nurture.

@ajgiza9866 2 года назад

such a great show!

@victortalukdar8925 2 года назад

The music of that lillium box is a masterpiece, it tells you the whole story in a subtle way (phases of happy and sadness in their lives)🔥🔥

@FranBunnyFFXII 2 года назад

@@Dimitris_Half Nope. Incredibly detail dense, very smart and subtle planned out scenes, clever handling of characters, amazingly empathetic portrayals of abuse and discrimination, amazing ending that handles some of the most emotionally powerful portrayals in anime history, and an allegory about the incredible difficulty of dealing with a lack of closure. All wrapped around a powerful Show Don't Tell portrayal of Nature vs Nurture. Absolutely amazing TV series, with incredible depth and focus on realism in it's characters emotions and struggles. Absolutely beautiful and depressing TV series.

@FranBunnyFFXII 2 года назад

@@Dimitris_Half aaah yes, tell me more how you let the entire show go over your head and you just listen to parroted opinions by people who also didn't pay attention. Amazing show of intellect my friend. Must be great to be that dense.

@switchlaserflip9243 2 года назад

@@Dimitris_Half Edgy teens don't watch anime. Not in America at least.

@phoetharhtooo 2 года назад

I believe nature and nurture are like space-time relation. They can't just separate into two polars. This is the problem that created form dualist way of thinking.

@sbenkimmie9579 2 года назад

u mean dichotomous cuz u want to think at least dualistically considering both sides and more

@phoetharhtooo 2 года назад

@@sbenkimmie9579 No, I don't mean to.I believe it in singularity. It is just the two different quality of one thing.

@phoetharhtooo 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops There is no need to doubt about that.Let see the plant. The seed has its own potential to be a tree but that's not possible without the environment of earth . Our self centered view want to define one is essential and one is to support the main. But in reality, they work together. If we are just what our past generation teach us so, there can't be progressive.

@products3606 2 года назад

Interesting ! 🧐

@phoetharhtooo 2 года назад

@Yaz Interracial marriage is all about culture. We unconsciously choose to those who personality is more likely to us. People have their own preferences doesn't necessarily mean that they discriminate against the unchosen one.

@RohitPant04 2 года назад

For someone interested in this topic, watch documentary “Three Identical Strangers,” about identical male triplets separated at birth, there were differences in their susceptibility to mental illness, with the one who was reared by an authoritarian father more seriously affected than the two with warmer, more nurturing parents. There are a dozen research papers on monozygotic twin studies as well which present gargantuan data on the proportions of impact being ~70% environmental and the remaining ~30% as genetic. Professor Robert Sapolsky's lectures (on YT) are a great resource on the subject too. This is an exciting field of study for genetic, neuro, psychology and philosophy. I encourage anyone interested to take a dive here. It's worth it!

@DanielBro42 2 года назад

Also the book blank slate by steven pinker is a great source of knowledge about the topic

@chumark54 2 года назад

Appreciate the info. Different populations studied will have different % of genes vs. environment though, it really depends.

@movement2contact 2 года назад

Will look for it, thanks! ✌️😊

@chumark54 2 года назад

@@movement2contact I happen to know this study, you can check it out: Turkheimer, E., Haley, A., Waldron, M., d'Onofrio, B., & Gottesman, I. I. (2003). Socioeconomic status modifies heritability of IQ in young children. Psychological science, 14(6), 623-628.

@MAYK1NG 2 года назад

Thank you for your comment! I'm definitely going to explore the links you shared.

@NathanHedglin 2 года назад

Generics are a big factor. Addiction, lack of self control, low IQ are all genetic.

@search4omniscience Год назад

wrong

@rodneythuman9082 Год назад

Some Logical holes within the idea of a strong consistent correlation between eye que, genetics ,income and success . Lel this should be fun😆!!! Native Americans and South East Asians are much more genetically closer to East Asians and yet they exhibit more average disparities in eye que scres with E. Asians than E.Asians do with Yts. Yts and East Asians have more genetic deviations than this two mentioned populations Qtar ,Saudi Arabia are one of highest income countries in the world per the average person yet Qatar has an average of 78 which is among the lower average clusters in the world. Same applies to Saudi. How does this make any sense?? Eye que and income have to consistently correlate right??? Egypt has an average of 80 yet it was among the earliest advanced civilizations to arise and springing up such a civilization would require above average que. If eye que had any influence and always dictated results then they should be a superpower in the mordern world. So what happened? You want to tell me that their collective eye que decreased?? Que is highly genetic and people don't just decrease in innate abikities in such a drastic magnitude ...this shouldn't be possible if the bearing of eye que is majorly genetic . Europe was estimated to have an average of 70 at the start of the 20th century while at this time they were basically revolutionizing advancements left right and centre and were shaping how the Mordern world was going to be. So why all this fluff from genetic priests about how societies with a collective average of low 80s and 70s wouldn't manage to develop or prosper. Lastly define "success". Is it the western definition of being fullfilled in income and wealth or acheiving materialistic things or having some strong recognition in society. Success is a broad term and just doesn't narrow down to this things

@rajamohammed8683 2 года назад

Though we like to think we are indeed doing the nurture, reality is that we just do what we can do. Our efforts are just a very minute association we strive to make with the nature.

@KR4Qep 2 года назад

Haven't watched the video, just saw the headline. And yeah, it can be. Traits like being driven and confident definitely aid towards success. There are other variables too like socioeconomic and social surroundings/influence. Being born to a successful family that guides you towards success based on their experience. There are so many variables that contribute to a persons outcome. Genetics plays a roll in all of them. Sometimes a little, sometimes a lot.

@burgut781 2 года назад

🙏

@ZYX84 2 года назад

I love your features their direct to the point concise and easy to relate to, the people doing the explanations always seem to be very kind as well somehow.

@franz3659 2 года назад

Thank you❤️

@TooLateToBe 2 года назад

The only thing that's missiing is that both genetics and enviorment were not under our control when we were born and raised so what difference makes which is more important ?

@diandradeeke 2 года назад

1.success is determined by your heritage especially your LATE heritage 2.success is determined by your social status - which is linked to your heritage 3.success is determined by your ability to adapt - which is again easier if you have a high social status 4.success is determined by your beauty standards, your style and daily routines - if you know how to behave in a high society than you are probably more likely to be successfull in life . . . . . . . . . . 5.success is determined by your genetics. That means your physical condition, vulnerability, endurance, look, IQ.,EQ, MQ their are books which have been forgotten for houndreds of years because nobody was interested in seeing how smart you are. there are children of parents in power positions who cry when they get a B-Grade in school there was this one man who was a criminal and a murderer. When he got arrested and the police uploaded >>>one picture

@rodneythuman9082 Год назад

@L.I.T.H.I.U.M 2 года назад

Both genetic and environment are out of your control. Here's what predicts success: 1. IQ, genetic, environmental 2. Conscientiousness, genetic but improvable 3. Openness (creativity, curiosity), genetic So is success genetic, most likely. Will all genetically gifted people be successful, no.

@grimsobad8545 2 года назад

You literally made a statement and called it bullshit lmao first of all “IQ tests” are inaccurate and not all successful people came from great environments they struggled even in their childhood

@L.I.T.H.I.U.M 2 года назад

@@grimsobad8545 What statement and how did I call it bullshit? Plus IQ is inaccurate compared to what? It's the closest to the most accurate way of finding the general cognitive ability of a person and has been shown over and over again to be corelated to academic success, job performance, income and crime. That's why all university entrance exams are IQ tests as they require abstraction more than knowledge to solve, and hence only favor the gifted.

@grimsobad8545 2 года назад

@@L.I.T.H.I.U.M intelligence is vast and cannot be measured or determined by merit or number, also IQ tests were invented to find folks with disability and yes cognitive ability isn’t set in stone look up Neuroplasticity

@L.I.T.H.I.U.M 2 года назад

@@grimsobad8545 Intelligence is vast but don't dismiss psychometrics without prior knowledge. There's a lot of research done on IQ and the different forms of intelligence have shown to be corelated. So if you're higher in one you're very highly likely to be higher in all of them (doesn't matter how many you different types you find). And that's the reason income, job performance, school performance & crime is predicted by IQ accurately. So no, intelligence can be measured and the results are always saddening.

@grimsobad8545 2 года назад

@@L.I.T.H.I.U.M it sounds more like making excuses for not achieving, these so called “psychometrics” are nothing but modern day Phrenology which are prone to be manipulated to portray one race superior to other well that’s what they were created for I’ve known many “high iq” individuals in real life most of them are average not to mention the super geniuses I’ve met on the internet they’re iq ranges to about 3000, so no intelligence **CANNOT** be measured by a mere number and isn’t set in stone NEUROPLASTICITY is a thing

@designinquest 2 года назад

Beautifully Designed Set

@octoberhenry9875 2 года назад

Sounds a smidge like eugenics for horticulture.

@liltoaster7308 Год назад

Although both genetics as a while and IQ aren't fully defined ir understood, its clear that IQ is positively correlated with success for a myriad if reasons. We've found IQ to be mostly influenced by genetics and only malleable by 2-5 points. There will always be outliers to the trend, but although not all genetically gifted individuals will succeed, all genetically gifted individuals have a much, much higher likelihood of succeeding than your average person. Success is mostly genetic, but environmental factors play somewhat of a role.

@chumark54 2 года назад

The age-old question of nature vs. nurture; the answer, we believe, is that they INTERACT.

@vmmd8229 2 года назад

Funny my teachers have been talking about this one and was in a conference all day about this one 🤣

@shahrukh877 2 года назад

How did it go?

@dasfahrer8187 2 года назад

The plant analogy is just terrible. The only equatable comparison there would be to say that the person's nutritional intake differs. It has nothing to do with a social environment. This person is trying to conflate several different disciplines to come to a social conclusion. Social environment doesn't affect genetics. Never has and likely never will. To suggest otherwise just shows that the person doing it is eschewing science for ideology. Sneaky manipulation of concepts going on here.

@TheAtheist22 2 года назад

I totally agree with you. This is not Science. It is ideology.

@dasfahrer8187 2 года назад

@@Dimitris_Half Thanks for missing the point.

@joeysung311 2 года назад

You’re saying social environment doesn’t affect your genetics, but neither does nutritional intake so I don’t see the point you’re trying to make at all.

@dasfahrer8187 2 года назад

@@Dimitris_Half Thanks for continuing to be clueless.

@gotemlearning 2 года назад

@@joeysung311 thank you for putting my thoughts into words

@sethr.c1065 2 года назад

Some people claim that everything is connected, or nothing is real or autonomous. All are equally true, and butt against each other. This video points intentionally to the vast complexity of the universe. A particle dozens of lightyears away from any lifeform affects us via a cascade of interactions, traveling at the speed of sound and some at c. Then zoom in so far that the incomprehensible is scaled down to earth and you can see the resolution that compression leads to. Everything affects everything. The question of nature and nurture is pointless without focusing back in on that particular view. If you push the panel of a white picket fence ten light years long ten light years toward an observer twenty LY away, they would see a fence panel in ten years and it would arrive in the distant future

@normavoyton3208 2 года назад

I suggest for anyone interested in this video, check out Dr. Bruce Lipton. He has a RU-vid channel and countless talks he has given. He ties biology and epigenetics (which he pioneered) with spirituality 🕊️💕🙏

@CareerDropout. 2 года назад

In my opinion as per usual, success has nothing to do with genetics, I’d like to argue that success has more to do with influence from an external source. . . It’s a lot like love and the triangular theory, in some things you’re great at it, others a little more mediocre and for some completely ineffective. . . The influence on the task is what determines the amount of success.

@coccinelle23 2 года назад

Agree. And success is a conditional notion, it has no specific measure and size, it is all about relativity.

@nigelmack8238 2 года назад

No its persistence and preparation

@grimsobad8545 2 года назад

Finally a sensible comment

@nicholaswalker3200 2 года назад

i don't know if it was the way this was edited or what but i found this video hard to follow

@maxd3028 2 года назад

So briefly environment have the upper hand when it comes to personality formation yup reality confirm that 💯%

@CassiniProjekt Год назад

I had every opportunity but remain a failure. Success or lack thereof in my case is genetic as my IQ is low and has limited me my entire life.

@ademalemdar 2 года назад

More genetic topics are needed to understand emerging technologies in this field and their effects on individuals. By the way, I appreciate the whole content, but genetics and its usage have become an important topic nowadays.

@better_dead_than_red 2 года назад

More genetic topics are needed to make America great again

@FoodfortheSubconscious 2 года назад

So basically we don't know... Great as usual, why don't people get paid when they actually know what's going on

@Adhil_parammel 2 года назад

80gene: 20environment

@amorosogombe9650 2 года назад

Just being born in America increases your chances of being a billionaire. Saying it's genetic allows us to run away from legislated injustices. If I was free to come to America my life chances would improve immensely. But a law saying no you are from a poor third world country you cannot access the opportunity that comes from being in America prevents me from doing so. That's not genetic.

@divinegon4671 Год назад

Why not stay in your home country to lift up your fellow citizens? Why flood into America? Why not get your community together in your original country and improve it so that America isn’t your first choice? What excuses do u have?

@amorosogombe9650 Год назад

@@divinegon4671 Why didn't your ancestors do that in Europe instead of running off to America?

@search4omniscience Год назад

@@divinegon4671 lack of economic opportunity doesn’t allow people to help their communities 🤯🤯🤯 retard moment

@divinegon4671 Год назад

@@search4omniscience hmmm I wonder why there are no economic opportunities within the home countries 🙃

@BUSeixas11 Год назад

Yeah, but if you compare Americans with one another than that’s not going to be a very good explanation. So your point is not very good. Both your genetic makeup and the country you live in matter.

@better_dead_than_red 2 года назад

Yes

@gooberpeas7926 2 года назад

It helps me to think about this as a triangle of influences: nature, nurture, choice.

@117Industries 2 года назад

Love this simplification. Awesome. Same here :).

@117Industries 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops Yeah but having a triad with choice as a third distinct category would presuppose that choices could be independent of the other two categories- I.e. we’re back to free will.

@117Industries 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops You have no grounds upon which to claim it’s ridiculous anymore than I have grounds to claim the opposite. And I am surely making a presupposition to lead to a desirable conclusion. I desire to construct a worldview in which we are free to negotiate with others, the world, and in which we have a loose control over our destiny and the path we take to it. I believe this belief is for the best of us, and brings out the best in us all. My life experience corroborates this belief. You would seem to want to believe the opposite. You need to take up philosophy buddy because your repeating of variations of belief having no connection to truth is bullshit. Ultimately everything we can claim to justifiably believe requires an epistemic leap of faith, and there are no, and can be no, dogmatic certainties. The only certainties we can claim are existence itself (in the Cartesian sense, and even *that* can be disputed), and mathematical or logical truths of a purely analytic ‘a priori’ nature. But since reality is not constructed from mathematical abstractions, but matter and wave and energy, and since we can only make inferences about it from unreliable observations and form inductions from those inferences, then our best known laws are only as good as the accuracy of those initial inferences. But these inferences and laws are quite often later falsified or amended, as the nature of reality is further expounded and we learn more about its mystery and complexity, realising in the process how wrong our initial suppositions were regardless of how well they stood up to repeated trial at the time. There are no deductions in reality. No dogmas or certainties. Just best guesses. If you don’t believe me- sit undergrad Philosophy. If you have and you still don’t get it- you’re a shite Philosopher and a retard. You’re trying to sound smarter than you are and it’s irritating.

@117Industries 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops Nobody mentioned anything to do with destiny. I explained to you that all truth boils down to belief. There is no sharp distinction between belief and knowledge. And you are now bringing destiny and fatalism into it. We’re done.

@117Industries 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops Nobody here is in any keyboard hammering rage. And it’s usually the obese Physics nerds who can’t control their emotions one iota. That’s why they never leave mom’s basement- because they can’t find a woman to trust them given their poor emotional self-regulation.

@johnraviella6561 Год назад

Probably could have explained this in about 30 seconds lol

@izzymosley1970 2 года назад

Personally I think this whole nature versus nurture debate is missing something very important and that is individual choice sure when you're examining entire populations you need to look at things that affects every member of that population like their genetics and environment but when it comes to an individual person yes nature and nurture play a big role in influencing what someone does but it doesn't force you to do something you always have the choice between right and wrong no matter your genetics or your environment.

@robertdouglas8895 2 года назад

Right. But the "big role" is only giving you the environment in which you are making the choices. The environment doesn't determine the choices, you do.

@robertdouglas8895 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops I'm becoming aware of my thought processes that give up responsibility for my choices to other things and people so I can switch from being a victim to realizing I have been choosing all along. I deal with the guilt of my mistakes instead of by projecting it onto others to forgiving them and being responsible. That process is called metanoia.

@counterpoint9260 2 года назад

how do you even define success?

@bjrnn.2689 2 года назад

"Human beings are born with different capacities. If they are free, they are not equal. And if they are equal, they are not free." - Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn - Culture is just the fenotype of a population. Iq is genetic like everything else. There will always be deviants and outliers. Haplogroup is a better term than race. Plato described this 2500 years ago in the myth of the metals Crime is not a result of poverty, its a result of RELATIV poverty. Mixing groups with large diffrence in iq creates RELATIV poverty and political polarisation. Denying thees facts creates enormous psychological problems in our society.

@quchi7232 Год назад

Guess that successful gene in my family ends with me then.

@celestialsatheist1535 2 года назад

If you nurture someone in a certain way for long enough time it will eventually become their nature

@mostafaashraf5619 Год назад

I didn't understand that ; she didn't answer the question

@AK-jt7ug 2 года назад

Good job avoiding the question lmao

@marksousa8595 2 года назад

If you live in a nice neighborhood the better education.

@thechangingtimes 2 года назад

I’m having flashbacks of the pseudo-sciences like Phrenology, social-Darwanism, and socio-biology…

@valentinopereira58 2 года назад

The speaker looks like an actress I can't remember

@cassandrapeterson898 2 года назад

👆👆he's got mushrooms, LSD, bars,psilocybin, Dmt, Ayahuasca,nomes, he's got all psychedelic products. They sell the best shrooms and Microdosing products eeee 🍄🍄🍄

@dianataylor991 2 года назад

When it comes to investing, diversification is key, that’s why I engage in sectors based on projected growth. There’s no shortcut to getting rich, but there are smart ways to go about it

@jacobpetterson3873 2 года назад

Interesting, could you possibly share more hints or ideas on this approach. What are the sectors you engage in?

@dianataylor991 2 года назад

I engage in different kinds of prolific investments such as launchpad IDOs, Crpto, Stock, NFTs, and vice versa through proper planning and management of a widely known Investment Professional, and so far acquired over 500K $ as a return.

@dianataylor991 2 года назад

As to get more details on suitable investment plans you could indulge in. You can easily find the Investment Professional *(Diana Alexandra Hunts)* on the internet where you can easily reach out to her and as well write her.

@jacobpetterson3873 2 года назад

Great! Got it

@jacobpetterson3873 2 года назад

I’m delighted to engage in this opportunity, I just found the professional’s web page already written her.

@importantname 2 года назад

lets say you are born a serf in Russia under the Czar, if you show the ability to out smart your over lord, you life ended quickly. Now lets imagine you are born the first son of a king, or President - and you show great intellectual abilites, now what happens

@artvsmachine3703 2 года назад

Presentation was a bit confusing because trying to talk about science while also making it into a social justice teaching moment.

@gotemlearning 2 года назад

Then you lack the context within which this work exists. This scientist is motivated to study this because white supremacists have produced a lot of pseudoscience in this area. It is important to address their claims specifically, should the science suggest them to be wrong.

@Epicurean999 Год назад

So in a nutshell NO!

@Kyba_LLC Год назад

First Q: yes

@LungaMasilela 2 года назад

First one here😎

@Yohansanto81 2 года назад

23rd comment

@musicmangm7572 2 года назад

Can trauma be recorded in genes?

@john-sebastianbarrera1884 2 года назад

4 minutes to say: No hahaha

@robertclegg2609 2 года назад

Ah! But ALL HIGH SCHOOL TEACHERS can make EACH STUDENT SUCCEED no matter the genetics nor environment OR ELSE THERE WILL BE ACCOUNTABILITY by the teacher in the form of lost pay or termination! Because, reasons? /s

@prototype9904 2 года назад

3.85 MILLION Subs and 26 comments, who do you think you're fooling eh?!?!??! Ridiculous ;p

@prototype9904 2 года назад

@@Dimitris_Half If you don't see a problem with these analytics, YOU are the problem m8

@prototype9904 2 года назад

@@Dimitris_Half obviously

@jameseldridge3445 Год назад

She is a progressive geneticist, a literal walking contradiction lol

@sociolocomtsac 2 года назад

No it's cultural.

@robertdouglas8895 2 года назад

Both nature and nurture are stances of victims. With them in place, it is impossible to change what has happened before. The problem is solved by not just postulating but realizing that we have made our lives to be what they are. Mind determines what we see. Form follows thought. Ask and you receive. The asking and the thought is greater than our conscious mind but we have hidden away the fact to escape blame and guilt for the errors of our lives. In reality, we are the mind that has all power over earth and heaven. Our only purpose here is to learn this. It's the process of changing our minds, metanoia.

@robertdouglas8895 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops I'll stick with woo woo instead of being a victim of the world and its physics, medicine, and genetics. I determine those. They don't determine me.

@robertdouglas8895 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops How you use them makes all the difference. Your doctor tells you that statistically you will die in a month. You live another 50 years. You have chosen to deny the math and choose your life purpose instead of what the world tells you. The math makes no difference at all in your life. 2+2= 4 regardless of your choices, but life is about the choices we make. Someone comes along and says that the physics/ chemistry says that global warming is going to make growing corn impossible where I live in 25 years but I refuse to believe their prediction and it doesn't come true. Either they were wrong or things changed. I chose my purpose which I knew internally instead of judging by the world. And I'm the better for it

@robertdouglas8895 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops Only the Self exists but it includes all of us. Others call it God.

@robertdouglas8895 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops I don't make my choices myself. If I did, my ego would expand with everything I thought successful and shrink with mistakes. I try to catch those ego-centered emotions and thoughts to remember that I live by God's will instead of my individual one. There are no individuals. We are all one being sharing the love that we are. Shaming others is what I try not to do.

@robertdouglas8895 2 года назад

@@3eyedcyclops You are speaking as a body on earth where we divide up as individuals and groups. Some are more special than others, or so we think. We are on the earth but not of the earth. I am speaking of what we are of, our true home.We are spirit. Spirit shows up as love which cannot be perceived but known. We get a sense of that knowing; it shows up when we follow God's will which comes from love. We get God's will by asking for it. Ask and you shall receive. We get the mind of the world by asking for it. Christ mind/ carnal mind. Carnal mind operates on lack, needing to get more as it operates in fear. The mind of love/ God/ Christ or any other name you want to give it, knows we already have all we need so we can focus on giving. Giving and receiving are the same since we are all God giving to and receiving from God.

@Adhil_parammel 2 года назад

Inorder to beat talented gene with hard work, talented must sleep.

@darklyclad 2 года назад

Environmental and genetic, mostly environmental.

@y37chung 2 года назад

Behavioral genetics is just mainly bad statistical interpretation.

@mitchelljack1590 2 года назад

You have to define success or the entire conversation is a waste of time

@nasrulrosli 2 года назад

Yup, THIS

@mitchelljack1590 2 года назад

Sounds like you chose the title to this video man

@mitchelljack1590 2 года назад

When did I criticise someone?

@mitchelljack1590 2 года назад

Ohok so you just decided to give me random advice?

@BadassRaiden 2 года назад

Is success genetic? This question is extremely inappropriate. Way to give air time to the idea of eugenics. Big think, you should be utterly ashamed of yourselves.

@thyhighcomrade2180 Год назад

So like, woke-age phrenology??

@swagchomp 2 года назад

No it’s literally oppressed by the ruling class Btw unsubscribed to this channel get better content

@TooLateToBe 2 года назад

The only thing that's missiing is that both genetics and enviorment were not under our control when we were born and raised so what difference makes which is more important ?