jamie + brianna | "she's just like you" 

Yes Jamie feels so deeply even in real life could see that in real life in Men in Kilts especially in episode 8😪

And she doesn't reciprocate those same feelings back to him!

SERIOUSLY. Roger is great for like five minutes and then he just becomes the worst.

Also she didn't ask about Ian

I agree, i just hate Roger, he's so selfish and rude.

That's so true I really don't like Roger at all

@@samantahernandez7928 come on, Roger is just human. Jaime is the king of men, we all knew, but why every character must be like that as well? Try to imagine a boy raised in the 1900's just going back in time, it's normal I think that he reacts how he did, every "normal man" would do that, let's be serious. I like him especially for that, because he's normal but also caring, loyal and special at the same time.

I agree. The books are huge. Ive read them over 10 times through the years. Was so excited about the series and have loved it. I do wish they had the.opportunity to do a longer season so that the series could reflect the books more deeply.

I believe a couple of more episodes in the season would be perfect, like season one. That way we could become more invested in the characters and situations. Why can't they add two more episodes????!!

I think that Sophie is incapable to give a deep emotion.

Because he is a stranger to her, he hasn't known him or of him for a very long-time.

@@rene3759 Brianna doesn't talk to Jamie in the entire final episode. Although she does not see him as a father, she lived with him for weeks and knows that he spent months looking for Roger. Not Even a single gesture of cortesy. The most absurd thing is that she tells Murtaugh that she forgave Jamie, but she never tells him. The big problem is that the television adaptation simply decided to do things differently. In the book, Brianna and Jamie spend more time together. Even he teaches her Gaelic. They fight the same, but in the end he is present at the birth of his grandson and they spend a nice time together. In the show they decided to give importance to other situations, such as the history of the French priest. Be honest. What contributes most to the plot? The terrible experience of the priest, the psychology game at Yocasta's table or the connection between father and daughter? Unfortunately, time cannot be returned and Brianna's delivery, attended by Claire and supported by Jamie, is something that will never be seen on screen. And hopefully the relationship between father and daughter will become more harmonious and affectionate, because Brianna will look very bad if she continues to treat Jamie like a stranger, while he financially supports the Mackenzies.

I think there are glimpses where she looks at him with affection but it really IS heartbreaking. He really loves her so much. He longed to meet her....and truthfully she...him, and yet....the Roger mistaken identity thing just ripped it to hell.

Thank you so much. ❤️

Arleen Rutten so true and what I love about the book ! If you look at the dedication in the front page it’s dedicated to tony gabaldon she says it’s a tale of fathers and fatherhood I’m inclined to agree . Like Brianna I call my father da trust me it’s a Celtic thing as both Scottish and Irish children do this to this day I’m of Irish descent and my Irish cousins call their fathers this !

В книге интереснее

Wow thank you so much!!

LJO 1977 I missed that also. They have time restraints with 13 episodes...also obviously are going to slip over the angst between Bri and Roger as they reacquaint themselves.

I too wanted to see Claire and Jamie to be by Their daughter as she gave birth. I did not like the slap because yes Jamie said harsh words but he hitting and slapped are not the answer

I found this disturbing too! At least in the book he coached her and held her after the birt h and even got to kiss the back of her neck by the ear (like in his dream) hopefully the writers will correct fix this somehow next season. In the book Jamie and Brianna became very close and he and Claire adored their grandchild. He was a damn good grandpa. It does bother me though that they put other situations of less importance before this very special family. Claire and Jamie are the heart of this series and need to be brought back front and center again.

You are right in your comment

P

Merci puce!!! Oui j'aime beaucoup aussi😎😘❤️

do not rush it, enjoy season 2 and 3 because 4 is terrible :(

Thank you❤️

Thank you😊

Thank you!!

@@CeciliaPixels YOU WELCOME

@@CeciliaPixels I ACTUALLY LIKE AND UNDERSTAND BRIANNA AND I LIKE SOPHIE. THERE ARE PEOPLE ON THE INTERNET TEARING HER ACTING APART BUT I AM ENJOYING HER EVOLUTION INTO THIS CHARACTER

Sunny Day No Problem. THE APPLE DOESNT FALL FAR FROM THE TREE THOUGH. CLAIRE HAS DONE A FEW SLAPS HERSELF. LIKE JAMIE NEEDED MORE VIOLENCE DONE TO HIS PERSON AFTER ALL HE HAS BEEN THROUGH, AND CLAIRE LET IT ALL HAPPEN. REALLY PISSED.

Thank you💓💓

Thank you!! 😊😊😊

Emocional. Con C.

Me diz uma coisa a versão 4 não está disponível no Netflix né .

A mí cae súper mal Brianna, esta bien que se enoje pero no al punto de decir cosas tan hirientes y hasta incluso pegarle... Si yo fuera Jamie le quitó los apellidos.

@@kendallsoto4018 Jajajajaja!!! No creo que a ella le importe mucho. Es medio insoportable, la verdad. No me cae muy bien.

Especially since Frank resembled Black Jack!

Damn I have to read the books sometime

Merci beaucoup ❤️❤️❤️

Think of this from her perspective. You’ve been heart broken and violated. You find out you’re pregnant not knowing who the father could be. When you find out your boyfriend was beaten up and sold off to an unknown fate because of mistaken identity. Then your father insulted you by saying you weren’t violated and doubting your trauma. You’re going to say a lot of things out of anger. I love Jamie too but don’t disregard what Brianna was going through.

@@amywilson9591 first of all I didn't disregard her trauma but she had no right to treat Jamie that way. He was doing his best to protect her but he never had the chance to bring her up from childhood so he was out of practice. and he more than made up for it. second of all she lashed out at Jaime first then he said things out of anger. and i can see both side but you clearly can't put yourself in Jaime's shoes. it's 100 times harder on the parents when their child says awful things to them but they always forgive and forget quickly.

thegirlnooneknows5 Well, bad adaptation.

@@liol3409 you guys are too negative

thegirlnooneknows5 If you need to read the books to love the television character, it's a bad adaptation. I'm sorry, it's what comes out of what you say and I didn't say I hated the character.

Book /show last time I checked there weren’t synonyms even if it is an adaptation just let people enjoy it stop calling it bad whether it is a book or a shows it is still a good story ok.

@@liol3409 you can't look into peoples minds. That's only in the books. You can't adopt her feelings inside her head except with monologue but I don't want to have monologue the whole episode long. I haven't read a single book but I still sympathize with her. Every empathic person sympathizes with her. Just analyse her from the dialogue and her expression. In my opinion the actress brings it well across

Jocelyn Munkirs May I know what the book version?

thank you! and that's true, it would have been an interesting parallel to make! sometimes it's hard to think of everything of course. but no, I don't take it as criticism 😉

@@CeciliaPixels You're a wonderful video maker and I'm glad you didn't take my comment as a negative. I wish I had your talent. Truely.

@@diannebdee thank you so much :)

Sério? Tem disponível na internet...

@@noelitavita como faz pra assistir eu não consigo

@@josneibf4962 Vá no site da Superflix 😊

Mel -Well stated 👏🏽 I agree with everything.

I agree whole heartedly.

Ojalá pronto

It was difficult to watch. Brianna should have told Lizzy what happened. Claire should have told Jamie about Bonnet. Poor Roger could have been spared a lot of grief.

I totally agree. Secrets/Truth always comes sooner or later. Have a wonderfully awesome day 😀

Hm some people don’t hold their anger as well, it wasn’t okay, but that doesn’t make me dislike Brianna.

Yes, it is his ancestor, Black Jack Randall, and he is played by the same actor because it's sort of a point that he looks exactly like Frank Randall

@@tychogoedhart286 thank you

Hm I get why this makes people dislike Brianna, but I've said horrible things to people when I was angry and I don’t think that I'm a bad person. Yes, it wasn’t right of her, but I wouldn’t start disliking a person or character because they once behaved awfully and then never again. From what I can tell she’s a good person, for God’s sake she was raped and is probably still traumatized from that, traumatized people behave differently and more intense in heated situations. I think it’s weird, in shows or movies we judge characters more easily, in real life you behave badly and then you move on with no bad blood. I hate violence and I definitely think she could have behaved differently, but you don’t behave perfectly when you’re angry, I think we all know that.

I agree,,I'm one of those people.

Rosalie is it just the character or the actress just curious I like both but you’re free to disagree with me !

I don´t like Brianna

@@michelleflood8220 just character

Rosalie and that’s fair enough I didn’t warm to her at first either took me until she accepted Jamie as her father that I began to warm to her and that wasn’t till the end of the third book !! But after she started calling him Da I liked her because I do the same it’s a Celtic thing common in both Ireland and Scotland to refer to your dad that way ( I’m of Irish descent ) that said once their relationship is healed I thought she’s truly Jamie’s daughter has both his and Claire’s best and worst traits has Jamie’s selfless love for Claire her impulsiveness and intelligence but also has Jamie’s temper and courage but even Diana admits Brianna for her is one of her toughest characters to write so that says a lot !!

You just expressed what I think really well.

I couldn’t agree less to be honest, Brianna and Roger's relationship seems realer to me and right now I'm more interested in their story.

@@windshieldlaugh7411 Good for you. I've moved on entirely from this show.

SHE ACTS JUST LIKE JAMIE AND CLAIRE AND DOUGAL AND JENNY AND COLLUM IT IS IN HER BLOOD...AND LET US NOT FORGET AUNT JOCASTA'S MOUTH .....LOL

@@virgoqueen8950 whatever agree to disagree

@Genie Blue well Jamie didn't abandon Brianna he had no choice and here's a idea stop going on and on about messiah daddy Frank walks on water 🗡 and bond with Jamie

@Genie Blue The lusting over Jamie is hilarious to the point that people can not look outside the box. All over social media some of the comments about how Bree treats Jamie is crazy .....This child is angry and she needs time to process this, she comes from a high strung family and they all have said and done things that seemed unforgivable especially that damn Dougal and we see how he went out

@Zoey Brown don't think DG would care

Good god no, it’s just a video about their father daughter relationship

@@windshieldlaugh7411 OH- sorry, I had a misunderstanding ;w;

You will learn love Brianna when next season come. In the books she is a powerfull woman, an amazing chraracter.

Sunny Days 🤣🤣🤣🤣