Тёмный

Jesse Reacts to The Jailer's 5000 IQ Plan 

Jesse Cox
Подписаться 1 млн
Просмотров 188 тыс.
50% 1

The delightful Taliesin and Evitel released a new video, that upon immediately seeing I knew I had to react to. I cannot stress how much I dislike the Jailer so any new takes on him as a character - well I had to see for myself!
World of Warcraft Shadowlands patch 9.2 ptr Spoilers!
Their description:
"It has been revealed that the world soul of Argus is what disabled the arbiter and set the events of the expansion in motion. It kind of also mean... that the Jailer Zovaal sort of maybe planned literally everything that has happened in WoW lore since Warcraft 3 - from Sargeras creating the Burning Legion to the creation of the Lich King to to us being awesome at raiding in Legion. People don't like it, and fair enough really. But Taliesin explains why tho think of the Jailer as an IQ5000 evil genius playing 7D chess with the fate of Azeroth and the cosmos is to fundamentally misunderstand the character and the story."
New Merch at the store! store.jessecox.com/
Become a subscriber ►► goo.gl/HPFQis
• Interested in helping me create content? Support the Patreon: / jessecox
• Watch Cox n' Crendor on / coxncrendor
• Listen to Cox n' Crendor in the Morning! The best PODCAST! On iTunes!:
/ coxncrendor
feeds.feedburner.com/soundclou...
• Stay connected!
Twitter - / jessecox
Facebook - / thejessecox
• Cox Omnimedia:
Founder/Executive Producer: Jesse Cox
Production Manager: Julia Rendell
Editors: Mari Locsin
Animation: Daniel Tan
• Send your fan mail to:
Jesse Cox
PO Box 11089
Marina del Rey, CA 90295
#WorldofWarcraft #WoW #Reaction

Игры

Опубликовано:

 

5 янв 2022

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 1,5 тыс.   
@dazaran714
@dazaran714 2 года назад
He's trying to say that the jailer threw 30,000 darts out of an airplane and one hit a target on the ground, but really it's blizzard that threw one dart, painted a target around where it landed, and took previously thrown darts and stuck a sticky note on them with "jailer" written in crayon.
@marajango
@marajango 2 года назад
Perfect description of how Blizz wanted it to look like and how it really looks like.
@ForTheHordeCro
@ForTheHordeCro 2 года назад
Ooh! Good old plot armor!
@Traumglanz
@Traumglanz 2 года назад
And that's the whole problem. Blizzard fucked up. They had a cool concept for someone who should be singing ♫ Time is on my side ♫, instead we get … this mess. The team just was not able to build, present or write a interesting story for years. Game is shit.
@MrCeratix
@MrCeratix 2 года назад
Hall of fame comment
@subaquatictoaster
@subaquatictoaster 2 года назад
He's saying that's likely how blizzard intended us to take the Jailers story. He also did specifically say that Blizzard missed the target by a long shot.
@fran13r
@fran13r 2 года назад
Jesse: "I don't know how I'm going to make it trough 20 minutes of the jailer" Bruh, I don't know how I'm going to make it trough 50 but I love you Jesse and I'm watching this whole thing!
@jessecox
@jessecox 2 года назад
My hero
@shadith2380
@shadith2380 2 года назад
Same, I watched 2 minutes of the T&E video, but the entirety of this.
@Dragons56
@Dragons56 2 года назад
agreed I always watch jesse videos especially with theories and lore and reactions :)
@fran13r
@fran13r 2 года назад
@@Dragons56 TRUE, like the ffxiv video I watched completely even tho I don't play mmos anymore.
@DarthEevees
@DarthEevees 2 года назад
I feel like "The Jailer is the reason for everything" plotline undercuts every other character's motives and even their free will. Like what's the point of Arthas's motivation if everything was decided by the Jailer?
@Rogue2316
@Rogue2316 2 года назад
To build further on what you say, it also undercuts whatever is going to happen to let him get stabbed to death by a bunch of loot-hungry maniacs. Like, how do you conceivably fight against THAT level of planning? Unless they pull a "my death is only the beginning!" bullshit (which I give them 50/50 odds of doing), there's very little logical reason for him to fall to the player characters or the major NPCS unless they pull an even bigger bag of bullshit out to let them win.
@MisterDragon
@MisterDragon 2 года назад
I mean Arthas having motions after picking up frostmourne was a mistake in the first place as Frostmourne should've eaten his soul and we "killed" Arthas' good half in wrath and it was killed before that in the arthas book. So even after destroying arthas' soul 3 times, he still had that little moment with his dad at the end of wrath and then later in legion we still found a part of his soul a fourth time inside the shards of Frostmourne. Honestly it should've just been Ner'zuhl after TFT ended. Arthas was a brilliant tragedy that just got slapped with retcons until he became a very inconsistent and badly written villain.
@suicidalzebra7896
@suicidalzebra7896 2 года назад
It's a question of agency. The best characters have agency. Sylvanas, for all her machinations (particularly in BfA), has agency ever since she broken from Arthas. By introducing the Jailer Blizzard totally undermines her arc and removes all agency from her actions, up until she 'betrays' him in the 9.1 raid ending cinematic. Same goes for Arthas. He made terrible choices even before taking up Frostmourne, was corrupted, and then later once he became the Lich King his actions were his own. Or at least he wasn't kow-towing to another 'bigger bad'. It's easy to post-hoc justify all sorts of shit once you introduce a new character, but nigh on impossible to do it without undermining what has gone before to make your new character seem more important. Blizzard were unable to buck the trend.
@glgina6
@glgina6 2 года назад
Arthas had a motivation? I thought he just liked cold weather and black towers
@LameMule
@LameMule 2 года назад
Right? It's such shitty, lazy storytelling. I get that telling a story is hard but "bad guy is reason for every decision and bad thing ever end of story" is the worst way anything can go. Nothing like throwing decades of story with potential out the window and into the dumpster below, eh
@Ironysandwich
@Ironysandwich 2 года назад
Yeah, the thing about "master plans" is that they often end up so convoluted that they just make no sense. Practically speaking, any plan that needs more than two things to go exactly right is a shit plan. A genuine master plan is one that requires zero things to go exactly right.
@Zalinth
@Zalinth 2 года назад
This comment needs more upvotes, so have one.
@jessecox
@jessecox 2 года назад
I can agree to this
@dragant2407
@dragant2407 2 года назад
Usually the reason for why plan A, B and C exists as well. always prepare for a plan to fail.
@JackgarPrime
@JackgarPrime 2 года назад
True. There is a "master plan" in Endwalker, but the plan is mostly "Here is a goal I have to cause a Bad Thing. There are a bunch of ways I can achieve the goal, but I'm not relying on any specific one of these ways to come to pass. I had a different original intent, but a better opportunity presented itself, so I took it." Which is much more of an actual plan, when you have options and can be flexible as events occur.
@PandaBearWithMic
@PandaBearWithMic 2 года назад
And the plan need to exist! Since according to the video he had no plan at all... He was just doing things cause they seemed as good to have, but If you want to learn how to ride a bike and do everything except riding a bike for infinite amount of time... you never learn how to ride a bike!
@radersrus
@radersrus 2 года назад
The plan goes well beyond flipping a coin for 9 hours and finally getting 10 heads in a row. It's flipping a coin for 9 hours, getting 10 heads in a row, and realizing that ALL your coin flips represented the exact order of 0s and 1s required to program Tetris.
@Doomroar
@Doomroar 2 года назад
"And now he has Tetris, he doesn't know what to do with Tetris, but it is better than not having Tetris right?"
@JeroenDoes
@JeroenDoes 2 года назад
And given that the universe is only so big. There are only so many titans. This entire legion part of the plan could not have been repeated. That had to go right the first attempt.
@MaMastoast
@MaMastoast 2 года назад
@@JeroenDoes exactly, unlike coin tosses, the jailers possible solutions are not repeatable an infinite amout of times
@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes
@CraftsmanOfAwsomenes 2 года назад
@@MaMastoast Right you don’t just get infinite chances to do all of this shit even if you live for many millennia.
@hqueso
@hqueso 2 года назад
A better analogy would be rolling a six-sided die until you get 10 6's in a row, but if you roll a 1 on any roll, the game ends. Coin flips don't have a result where everything stops; eons-spanning efforts to do things and see what happens and maybe it helps.
@TekharthaMondatta
@TekharthaMondatta 2 года назад
Taliesin's whole "better to have it than not" paints a picture of the Jailer frantically looking around the universe/Azeroth going "fuck I need this for la-- shit hold on Sylvanas's on the other li-- no, Gul'dan, you can't blow up the pla-- WAIT DON'T THROW OUT MY STAMP COLLECTION IT'LL BE WORTH SO MUCH IN THE FUTURE!"
@BartvG88
@BartvG88 2 года назад
That at least gives him more character. Can’t wait for his episode on “hoarders”
@4F0xSake
@4F0xSake 2 года назад
@@BartvG88 Honestly if his character had just been him giddly chatting to anyone who'd listen about how he cant believe all his thousands of successes out of millions of attempts finally lined up into a win... well it would be have different at least! Gently ribbing Denathrius "SEE, I told you pumping a bunch of death magic into that titan was gonna pay off"
@Dandelion_Stitches
@Dandelion_Stitches 2 года назад
To be fair this is 100% how I play WoW. My bank alts are full of junk I'm terrified to throw out because I might need it some day, even if they're easy to replace either directly or on auction. Stuff like... spider webs and unopened clams. I guess we all have a little Jailer in us.
@Brooke-rw8rc
@Brooke-rw8rc 2 года назад
Isn't this how every game is played? You have goals you're working towards but have to be ready at any second to respond to your opponents' moves?
@kikiohearts
@kikiohearts 2 года назад
@@Dandelion_Stitches Do we really need a stack of motes of water? No. Will we ever need then again? Probably not.. do I need them in my bank? Yes.
@permeus2nd
@permeus2nd 2 года назад
the Jailer isnt a character he is a caricature, he is a walking plot twist with no story to explain how, he is a textbook example on how to wright a bad villain he hits all the checkmarks in the what not to do.
@checkit188
@checkit188 2 года назад
what if hes not the villian and a really good cover up for a shitty and easy to poke fun at one. someone else is doing something and we are ignoring it. its not the jailers master plan
@Engravingsful
@Engravingsful 2 года назад
@@checkit188 yes some master tactician maybe Jailer himself is under domination magic
@jessecox
@jessecox 2 года назад
Thanks for tuning in! I probably could have been more concise(50 minutes?!?!), but it's been so long since I've made WoW content - and I think this video probably explains why.
@Korja88
@Korja88 2 года назад
Always cathartic to hear you talk about the state of WoW Jesse
@CloudHiro
@CloudHiro 2 года назад
thing though about the FFXIV "not being planned out just expertly connected to seem that way"? the team actually posted proof one time that they did plan it out...the major points anyway. the minor points were changed along the way. They didnt plan for everything. like the first version of the game bombing so hard they had to start over for one. but the key points like hydaelyn and her true involvement in the story and the truth of zodiark revealed in endwalker that was planned from the beginning. but the 'small' things along the way were changed as things went on.
@asparagusmelontoast
@asparagusmelontoast 2 года назад
But it's good content regardless
@shindalah1794
@shindalah1794 2 года назад
So nostalgic to see you making WoW content. If only TB were here to go absolutely full meltdown on Blizzard. But to be completely fair, Endwalker's story is pretty lukewarm at best.
@zzzMrgamerzzz
@zzzMrgamerzzz 2 года назад
Love this kinda content from you Cox. I don't really watch twitch much so it's nice to hear you ramble again.
@ghackotpony
@ghackotpony 2 года назад
"I've been playing a lot of Final Fantasy XIV lately." Understatement of the year.
@justinadams7824
@justinadams7824 2 года назад
is this jesse or li Jc speaking to us through his body?
@jase_allen
@jase_allen 2 года назад
Seems to be the game to play these days. My WoW guild leader just stepped down after 14 years because she pretty much stopped playing WoW to focus more on FF14.
@jessecox
@jessecox 2 года назад
If anything, it sheds some light into how I got addicted to WoW for 15 years
@Longlius
@Longlius 2 года назад
"The jailer is interesting because he's immortal and can try again forever." You mean Emet-Selch's least interesting trait?!
@Sheat101
@Sheat101 2 года назад
Least interesting, sure, but the saddest trait he has. Emet was so lonely, his reproduction of Amaurot on the first even has the reconstituted souls of the dead just to fill in the empty space with familiar faces. I guess it all depends on how writers use that immortality.
@SilverPrince_
@SilverPrince_ 2 года назад
The other thing is that Emet-Selch was also a vehicle to contextualize an entire faction we'd been conditioned to hate because "dey bad dudus" and make their total actions more sympathetic, if not still unacceptably extreme.
@christopherclayton5500
@christopherclayton5500 2 года назад
I think you kind of caught onto this, but there's an important distinction between the two magic tricks (the coins and the horses) and the Jailer's plan: an ability to control information to prevent us from seeing the thousands of failed attempts. Given infinite attempts, I will eventually rob a bank. But I don't have infinite attempts, I only have attempts until someone catches me and does something about it.
@Mprokess
@Mprokess 2 года назад
Yes, you dont have infinite attempts... but Jailer besicaly did. Who would catch him and what would "they" do? He was already locked, there was nothing more that could happen to him. Yes, I see the problem that the game does not show us any of his previous failed attempts... thats sad, Blizzard is failing to tell the story :( but please remeber "absence of evidence does not mean evidence of absence" - just because we dont see any evidence of his previous attempts, it does not prove that there was no attepts at all.
@christopherclayton5500
@christopherclayton5500 2 года назад
@@Mprokess The Primus and what the player base is going to do in 9.2.
@ioritenshi
@ioritenshi 2 года назад
@@Mprokess if they dont even hint about it, it didnt happen. this is just excuses for bad writing (or no writing at all in this case).
@Mprokess
@Mprokess 2 года назад
@@ioritenshi Yes, it is shity writing. That is not the point here. The point is, that this obviously isnt some amazing perfect plan creaded by Jailers from the scratch... its just "going with the flow".
@Null_Experis
@Null_Experis 2 года назад
@@Mprokess well, for one, remove his access to his spy network. If I saw a near miss at an escape attempt, I'd investigate how my prisoner even knew where to dig in the walls, who supplied the rock hammer, and how long he's been digging.
@IsilmeTuruphant
@IsilmeTuruphant 2 года назад
The problem with the analogy of "This is the Jailer tossing a coin for thousands of years until he got 10 heads" is that there is no point along the way where he got 9 heads, or 8 heads. No ALMOST successes that would have tipped off those around him that he was up to something. It basically assumes he's been getting 1 or 2 heads all along, and then suddenly all at once got all 10, with nothing in between. There's no way the Jailer could be trying random things and taking any and all opportunities and STILL blindside everyone and come out of nowhere.
@ValensBellator
@ValensBellator 2 года назад
I think the point is we wouldn’t hear about those failures. For all we know he’s had tons of setbacks.
@prototype0277
@prototype0277 2 года назад
I think what T&E is getting at is that every 'head' was spreading his influence and enough influence allowed him to achieve his goal. I agree though, at some point shouldn't his hat have been tipped? Still terrible story telling no matter who spins it though.
@FratinandMadrik
@FratinandMadrik 2 года назад
They could've made him an oppotunist who had patiently been waiting until the time was right and the stars aligned, but instead they made him into this "All these pawns put into play for this specific moment" kind of guy. If they had explored his backstory and shown stuff in the game, like how the Pantheon of Death banished him for wanting knowledge, he could've been a more sympathetic villain as well. Instead, we get this generic "I had planned for this all along, I am chaotic evil and nothing will stand in my way" trope.
@TheLewisScott
@TheLewisScott 2 года назад
@@FratinandMadrik yes the patient immortal story could have worked.
@FancyTophatDude
@FancyTophatDude 2 года назад
yeah exactly! If they had this all figured out back by the end of legion it could've been real fun to have side quests that address that something is wrong with the scourge. You could have had spirit healers gone missing. You could have had glimpses and whispers from the shadowlands, but nope. They wanted to keep this stuff fully under wraps so no one can guess what the next expansion would be on reddit.
@gearhead417
@gearhead417 2 года назад
One of the most unforgiveable sins WoW has ever done was wasting our Time Travel expansion on fucking Draenor instead of going to the past and fighting Galakrond.
@masonshucart7055
@masonshucart7055 2 года назад
I think it's more that they scrapped half of WoD that made it bad. I actually really liked WoD and was looking forward to the cool stuff that ultimately never existed.
@Shiirow
@Shiirow 2 года назад
@@masonshucart7055 it wasnt bad, its potential and legacy was squandered.
@gearhead417
@gearhead417 2 года назад
@@masonshucart7055 I get orcs are cool and all but the fact they wasted the time travel expansion on them instead of the idea of going back to start of mortality and fighting Galakrond which to our knowledge is shrouded in some mystery is crazy. Going back and meeting the aspects at the start of their power and uncovering the true nature of what happened to one of the most powerful beings on the planet makes for a way more interesting story than going back and seeing how the Orcs got tricked into drinking demon blood.
@jessecox
@jessecox 2 года назад
So many comic plotlines and subplots dropped
@JLOGIAC
@JLOGIAC 2 года назад
Yeah Im getting chills knowing how big Galakrond was on dragon blight 😮
@infrequentlyseldom
@infrequentlyseldom 2 года назад
One of the things that winds up being good about the Star Wars Clone Wars cartoon is that it does a lot of work to show that Palpatine is just a great improviser, that he's not making plans that rely on someone like Anakin Skywalker showing up but rather that he's good at incorporating those things into his many irons in the fire. The important thing, though, is that it *shows* that. I love improviser villains, I would love if Mr Jailer was an improvisor. But they didn't SHOW that.
@jordanread5829
@jordanread5829 2 года назад
Palpatine did have a master plan though. Order 66 was it. However he knew how to play the game of politics. He knew what to say and when to say it. Even though things don't go his way, he still wins in the end. You don't have to win every battle to win a war. Hell the Jedi find out towards the end of the war that the Clones were made by Dooku and his master. But by that point it was too late to bring it to the public. Faith in the Jedi, the senate and the army was declining. The only person who grew in the publics eye was Palpatine.
@noelward
@noelward 2 года назад
I strongly feel that Blizzard themselves are the ones responsible for portraying this story having taken place. It's not players' responsibility to write the solution to the Jailer's conundrum here. If everything T&E claims is true, or even any other alternate explanation, it's still Blizzard's responsibility to write and tell the narrative in a way that actually ties it all together. It is solely on them to communicate what is actually happening in the universe and if no one is actually understanding what they want us to understand, then their strategy of communicating it failed and they should hit the drawing board to do it better. Also TBH, even if T&E is right, I don't think it's an interesting narrative at all...the guy can wait for an eternity and live through possibly multiple iterations of the universe, until the random sequence of events he needed could fall into place and now he wins? Why is that interesting? And the way Blizzard has portrayed it to us, whatever it really turns out to be, has been absolutely abysmal. The fact that they just expect to be able to tell us what is a fact and we just have to "get it" without them writing and conveying ANY storylines, arcs, explanations, intentions, history, etc. and not walking through a single facet of it is so poorly misguided and immensely frustrating. Also they really need to start incorporating the vast majority of these things within the game itself and using extra mediums (like their novels) for just adding extra flavour on top of an already understandable and coherent storyline rather than what they're doing now with making a complex mess of confusing bits and pieces that jump all over the place then expecting us to either buy and read all of the other novels or watch RU-vidrs attempt explain it all for us just so we can get a sense of what the hell is going on in this game's universe narratively, or we just don't understand and have to play the game in ignorance and complete cluelessness. Even with the novels and the large number of content creators speculating and attempting to piece everything together, the current state of it all still feels like a confusing mess.
@MrElionor
@MrElionor 2 года назад
Blizzard is shit no argument there but you have to understand a subject to be able to properly critique it it's a proven pattern that the more popular and mainstream criticism becomes the less interest there is in actual understanding I don't see Blizzard would any different
@Peldinx
@Peldinx 2 года назад
When you were talking about how factions and their pettiness makes no sense anymore after being to "SPAAACE!" and whatnot it just reminded me of one of the sort of sideplots in FFXIV, with the beast tribes and how they used to be our enemies. We didn't really concern ourselves with killing them as they looked kinda iffy and they kept summoning primals. However as our own perspective developed throughout our experiences during our adventure, we eventually come to regard them as more than boogeymen, trying to reconcile our differences and work to move past such needless violence when there are better things toward which to focus our efforts. Makes you feel that the story actually progresses and tries to say something, instead of just spinning it's wheels for years on end.
@JackgarPrime
@JackgarPrime 2 года назад
I absolutely loved the way they paid off the beast tribes in Endwalker. It felt like such a great payoff for the messages of the game.
@Oppurtunafish
@Oppurtunafish 2 года назад
Yes. To the point they're not even regarded as "Beastmen" anymore and simple as "tribes". And in Shadowbringers they are just regarded as people, essentially, no different from anyone else. *chefs kiss*
@ownyounext
@ownyounext 2 года назад
Couldn't agree more. Can't wait to experience the FFXIV story!
@JackgarPrime
@JackgarPrime 2 года назад
@@Oppurtunafish I did love a certain line in Endwalker referring to them as "Those with more religious inclinations", making the categorization between them and the player races more one of ideology than species.
@spiritofthewolf1880
@spiritofthewolf1880 2 года назад
A lot of Blizzard Andys hate when people compare WoW to FFXIV. They hate it because it exposes WoW’s bad storytelling. 🤣
@TheDerek14
@TheDerek14 2 года назад
The Jailer's character, or lack there of, is what hurts Shadowlands the most, and potentially makes it the worse expansion. Introducing a new character, and making them be responsible for most of the issues plaguing the universe could work, but only if it given proper attention and detail. The writers have successfully failed at doing this. This has caused Shadowlands to be the worse expansion, for me, due to this extreme drop in narrative quality.
@crazyjak56
@crazyjak56 2 года назад
Hasn't blizzard been doing that exact same plot since at least starcraft 2?
@wtff
@wtff 2 года назад
Extreme drop? The story was never amazing. Even in Wrath people complained.
@valeclaw1697
@valeclaw1697 2 года назад
Honestly even beyond that: this entire xpac is about shitting on what we had before and saying "here's the old stuff you liked, but the Danuser version" which has no understanding of what was there previously, and provides less meaningful shit than the original.
@kiofea
@kiofea 2 года назад
Compare that with a similar situation with Final Fantasy XIV: Endwalker where the story takes a paralleled turn to World of Warcraft: Shadowlands. Yet the former works because of the care and effort Square Enix puts into it as opposed to Blizzard's complete indifferent apathy.
@therat1117
@therat1117 2 года назад
@@crazyjak56 Jailer is basically Amon, yeah. Almost the same motivations too.
@TheDapperDragon
@TheDapperDragon 2 года назад
It really feels like WoW heard Yoshi say "Endwalker will be a culmination of the past decade", and said "WELL THIS IS THE CULMINATION OF THE PADT TWO DECADES!" Blizzard has always been theives, but at least it used to be entertaining, pre Activision
@NightClubSamurai
@NightClubSamurai 2 года назад
i only heard wow say that a week after the endwalker trailers
@FiendMatadorSlayerOfNoobs
@FiendMatadorSlayerOfNoobs 2 года назад
@@NightClubSamurai That's because Blizzard pulled that out of their ass.
@luketfer
@luketfer 2 года назад
@@FiendMatadorSlayerOfNoobs Pretty much, this is them TRYING to do what Endwalker does but them rushing it incredibly to try to make Shadowlands into an Endwalker style expansion...which doesn't work because you can't rush and suddenly pivot because then you get the whole '7D chess' meme.
@TheDapperDragon
@TheDapperDragon 2 года назад
@@NightClubSamurai But the Endwalker trailers weren't the first time Yoshi-P said they were wrapping up the Zodiark plotline.
@axelwolf2115
@axelwolf2115 2 года назад
I'm curious, this is not the first time I hear that Blizzard stole or got "inspired" by other content, could any share other examples? I've been an outsider from wow since wotlk, so I'm really at a lost of what's been happening all these years
@TheDarkChaplain
@TheDarkChaplain 2 года назад
He flipped three coins, while rolling 6 dice, while spinning the wheel of fortune, drawing a "you win" card from a deck of 278 pokemon cards, while pulling the crucial jenga piece out of the tower, watching the tower fall in the exact way onto the chess board that it'd only hit his opponent's black pieces off the board, all while actually playing Triple Triad all along.
@TheUbberman
@TheUbberman 2 года назад
And perfectly landing that PLUS COMBO 8 card flip.
@erikferal
@erikferal 2 года назад
And he still had his Tims on!!! XD
@BartvG88
@BartvG88 2 года назад
With infinite tries, anything is possible.
@RazanaArcclaw
@RazanaArcclaw 2 года назад
Yes, and if you had an INFINITE AMOUNT OF TIME you could do the exact same.
@BritishTeaFGC
@BritishTeaFGC 2 года назад
The Jailor out here top decking all five pieces of EXODIA, THE FORBIDDEN ONE
@thebrannoncannon6565
@thebrannoncannon6565 2 года назад
7 minutes in and Jesse’s trauma from the Eternals ending is resurfacing. We all have PTSD from that plot point, but no one more than Jesse.
@jessecox
@jessecox 2 года назад
It was just SO ballsy! Like I appreciate that they did it, but I can't understand how nothing in the MCU has addressed it since.
@ArmageddonEvil
@ArmageddonEvil 2 года назад
@@jessecox Oh yeah, the Ending of the Eternals was supposed to be much worse... Aka the Director wanted to END the MCU.
@drakhoon
@drakhoon 2 года назад
37:00 - 38:00 its the inherent problem they have with the story they want to tell. they have always said that there will always be alliance vs horde, the problem is to defeat the "big bad/big evils" we have to team up to beat them. so we have to learn to get together, but according to blizzard we always have to hate each other as well. the 2 ideas cancel each other out and make for reallly bad story telling
@BartvG88
@BartvG88 2 года назад
How would you make it better?
@luketfer
@luketfer 2 года назад
This is the major point. Legion represented a chance for WoW to finally move away from Horde vs Alliance and instead into Mortal races vs the World. However die hard fans are like "It's world of WARcraft" and "muh faction pride!" to ever allow crossplay. I think with Shadowlands having bombed and classic/TBC servers emptying out there's a slim chance that MAYBE the devs will let go of their pride and rework things...who knows...probably not. After all if there's no factions you can't sell faction transfers!
@drakhoon
@drakhoon 2 года назад
@@BartvG88 well that is a question that requires its own reddit thread. but keeping in mind 1) better is subjective and 2) i am not a professional writer but i am a voracious reader i would say either they pick a lane and go full on azeroth vs the universe (guild wars 2 and ff14 have done quite well with this) or they go full on factoin vs factoin (similar to warhammer or warhammer 40k) there might be a way to do both at once but i think it would require allowing time to move forward on a generational scale and i dont think they are willing to do that
@Wylf
@Wylf 2 года назад
@@BartvG88 Relatively simple - pick a theme and stick with it. Do you want a game where two faction hate one another, but slowly learn to work together and overcome their differences? Make that and follow through with it. Do you want a game focused on never ending warfare between two factions? Make that and follow through with it. Mixing and matching those themes ends up very confusing. You can do it for a bit, but there comes a point where you have to pick one or the other, you can't have both without cheapening the impact of your storytelling. If you keep telling your players "fighting the horde/alliance is bad, actually", but then just revert back to doing exactly that with the new expansion, only to push the *exact same* moral of "fighting is bad mkay" *again* it just becomes ridiculous. And that's exactly what happened, most of WoWs expansions kept retreading the exact same path of storytelling over and over again, just to completely forget the lessons learned come the next expansion.
@karrotlord
@karrotlord 2 года назад
@@Wylf A visualization, if you will. A good, if typical, story will progress forward breaking new ground and expanding as it goes. WoW's story is a pendulum swinging back and forth in the same spot forever.
@Lewd_Fox
@Lewd_Fox 2 года назад
Imagine the main villain in your game being the villain because he "got lucky from billions of random bets". Jailer was literally opening lootboxes for legendary ultra rare sylvanis for years.
@knuckles543
@knuckles543 2 года назад
spent multiple planet's entire economies on lootboxes to try and get his wish, shoved all the crappy rewards onto his stooges but finally, after that billion lootbox he gets that worldsoul deathwave....yet a trillion other things happen in the background so magically when he gets it something happens...
@BartvG88
@BartvG88 2 года назад
He could do the same with the lich king, or with the dreadlords. He didn’t need sylvanas, but it was nice to have. That he would eventually find a way to disable the arbiter, the job he had before he was the jailer, is plausible to me. As soon as the arbiter was disabled, all he had to do was order his agents to cause mass death, so all the souls would enter the maw, expanding his influence.
@Keira_Blackstone
@Keira_Blackstone 2 года назад
it's literally the same thing with the ascians. they've spent thousands of years trying to manipulate world events to lead to rejoinings, some of which fail, like the 13th- or whatever the hell Lahabrea was trying to do with the Ultima Weapon. they're immortal so they can try forever, and they can fail as many times as they need since once they succeed 13 times they win.
@ElSpartin
@ElSpartin 2 года назад
@@Keira_Blackstone The Ascians at least have an understanding of what they are trying to achieve, and a viable means of doing so. RNG into victory is a weak excuse for what Blizzard claims to be doing and the 5D chess theory is absurd.
@PerkulatorBenny
@PerkulatorBenny 2 года назад
@@ElSpartin This. The Ascians have a goal, a plan of how to reach it, the tools needed for executing that plan, etc. They are the ones flipping a coin until they get enough heads in a row enough times. Because they have a coin, and they have identified that flipping enough heads means they win. Okay, some have decided that the coin plan isn't quite what they need and have switched to a dice game, but it's the same general plan for the same end result. Meanwhile, in this explanation, The Jailer is flipping a coin, then rolling a die, then drawing a card, then betting on a horse... Because eventually he'll win one of those games, right? And eventually one of those game wins will totally be the one he needs, right? So maybe something will someday, somehow, solve his problem, right? Instead of picking a game that seems to be the most important one and trying to win it, it's better to just haphazardly play every game you find, with no focus, no commitment, and no clear route to your goal, in case one of the others turns out to the one you actually needed to win... Right?
@SSDexter99
@SSDexter99 2 года назад
I love how all of this comes down to presentation. The Ascians did the throw a bunch of plans out and even failed a bunch of times, the void being a great example. Can you just imagine Lahabrea coming back to the convocation to explain that his God eating robot with a nuke in its chest plan failed and had to ask what other plans were available. "I am gonna steal a broken stick" "I like floods can we try that again but make it of light this time?" "Super pope!" And of course the sound of Emet Selch facepalming echoing through the room till someone suggests chemical weapons.
@P0rk_Sinigang
@P0rk_Sinigang 2 года назад
Emet-Selch: Guys. I built a global superpower over here. Someone else can use it too, I'm not stingy. FFS.
@joddelrealingo7737
@joddelrealingo7737 2 года назад
"Think, Lahabrea, THINK!!"
@MisterCrim
@MisterCrim 2 года назад
So, Big 'Ol spoiler warning for Endwalker: Thanks to Endwalker we now know that whatever the Ascians had planned was, ultimately, irrelevant simply because they were operating to achieve a goal based entirely on misinformation. Whether the rejoinings were a success or not they would have ended in the same result, back to square one facing the Final Days because they lacked critical information, also they had a big 'ol traitor in their midst. However, this doesn't come off as hackneyed retconning because the story writers had an end goal and used past events to inform the narrative. Blizzard, on the other hand, started with an end point and used that ending to inform past events to fit an entirely new narrative. That would be like someone (through copyright shenanigans) writing a new story set in Middle Earth with their awesome OCs and a BBEG who was the one originally behind Morgoth's actions and essentially rewriting all of Tolkien's work through this narrative lens even though it makes zero sense.
@auriaska99
@auriaska99 2 года назад
@@MisterCrim wdym if they succseeded in rejoining Zodiark would be alive and hence shield them from final days
@KiraNightV
@KiraNightV 2 года назад
@@MisterCrim If the Ascians managed to Rejoin every other shard and then resurrect Zodiark... Zodiark would be alive and well to keep the Final Days from happening. Now, whether or not Fandaniel would have had the chance to take over Zodiark is another question. We don't technically know if the Unsundered had any power over the Sundered to stop Fandaniel in his tracks, or to unmake him before he could fuse with Zodiark or push his soul out even after he took over, we just simply don't know what would have happened. If the Unsundered defeat the WoL and they win, Rejoin Zodiark and then can't stop Fandaniel, then the Final Days happen again and there's no one to stop it from rotting Etheirys. Everyone who can, relocates to the Moon, and then - possibly in tow with the Ascians since they would have no more purpose - leave to find another star. If the Unsundered win and they can stop Fandaniel from fusing with Zodiark, which is more likely since Elidibus was Zodiark's core so it's possible Fandaniel can't even attempt to fuse with him. Then they'd sacrifice close to all life on Etheirys to bring back as many Amaurotines as possible. Hydaelyn would possibly be killed, but she would pose no threat to Zodiark either way with how weak she's gotten.
@Nobrandminda
@Nobrandminda 2 года назад
Yeah, I think Taliesin's take somehow makes the Jailer even worse than before for two reasons. 1. At least in the story as presented, Zovaal is ostensibly clever for pulling off this gambit. If he was was literally just throwing spaghetti at the wall and seeing what stuck, that just makes him a lucky idiot, not a dangerous mastermind. 2. Watching Tal's video gave me this awful premonition of the next 10 years of WoW being, "Oh no! One of Zovaal's Secret Lieutenants is trying to avenge his master! We have to find out what he's planning!" If Zovaal had ten thousand schemes that didn't go anywhere, then that's ten thousand plot hooks for future expansions, which just sounds awful.
@Shek1nah
@Shek1nah Год назад
zovaal tried to imply he planned that in millions of years in the future an evil orc warchiefs, who had to be held trial in pandaria, timetravel to another dimension, for a random orc warlock that died in his original timeline, to bring him back to the other timeline, that he can try to open an interdimensional portal to an army that is strong enough to conquer a planet, so that forces on this planet would join together and using another keystone to open a portal to the homebase of the demon army so they could beat a literal titan of death. perfectly reasonable plan to conduct.
@LooseCo
@LooseCo 2 года назад
The Jailer to me the ultimate example of Blizzard having the potential to do something interesting with something and just totally waste it. All of Shadowlands has that problem, but the wasted potential with the Jailer is almost... sad?? I can't even be mad at this point I'm honestly just sad at how the jailer has been wasted as a character
@preds43
@preds43 2 года назад
Hard to not waste him when you’re out here harassing most of your co workers and not doing anything while your story department lead shoves Sylvanas into Zovaal’s much needed yet kicked out of spotlight cause “hurr redemption arc lul”. The Jailer is supposed to be evil, yes. And he IS supposed to be this powerful, I just wish we actually slowly saw more and more of him and his presence throughout the game, but he’s not cause in the old lore, Sargeras was the chaos evil dude, and the LK was the death god made to serve the legion, now it’s not the case, and that’s not really a bad thing, but I just seriously want Sylvanas to not take up most of the Jailers screentime in this admittedly too short of an expac.
@valeclaw1697
@valeclaw1697 2 года назад
Idk if it's wasted potential. From the get go he was just Sargeras 2.0, honestly.
@Rhazan91
@Rhazan91 2 года назад
I knew that Blizzard is trash the moment they destroyed their best character they made since warcraft 3 (Garosh).
@ultravioletcatastrophe
@ultravioletcatastrophe 2 года назад
@@Rhazan91 omegalul
@LooseCo
@LooseCo 2 года назад
@@preds43 I agree, it's my biggest issue with how the jailer is handled. Sylvanas drags it down so much. Everything about going into the Shadowlands should be focused on the Shadowlands itself. We should be learning about the Jailer, instead of how Sylvanas ties into it. Frankly at this point I want him to win, hit the reset button, and ARR the game and just start over completely from scratch. Delete all the current characters, make new ones from scratch. Pandaria worked so well for me becasue so much of the expansion was new characters and new races and locations and new lore and it obvious how much fun the writers had coming up with all new stuff that was only sortof tied to past WoW things. And the stuff that were, like the faction war or Garrosh, were worked into the story of Pandaria, it wasn't Pandaria being worked into the story of Garrosh/The Faction War. I want to see them that again but for the over arching story. Start over, make all new characters for us to meet and learn about. It is just so frustrating how the Jailer could've been... something.
@hermit9909
@hermit9909 2 года назад
Crendor's going to need to react to this.... Oh, wait.
@Shiirow
@Shiirow 2 года назад
Metzen "Do not squander it, this legacy I leave you." Danuser "Der what? Make my waifu fanfiction a reality?"
@shirouamakusa1826
@shirouamakusa1826 2 года назад
Taliesin's argument that The Jailor has an infinite number of tries over an eternity to win "just once" is also very flawed. If he indeed has failed many times before, there's no saying that one of those failures won't be spectacular enough to raise suspicion amongst the leaders of the afterlives that "Hey, you know that guy we tossed into super hell many years ago? He might be up to something sneaky." For instance, I'm sure souls from the many worlds the Legion burned made it to the Shadowlands. And amongst many of those souls, I'm sure some would have mentioned dying at the hands of the Nathrezim or some brush with death-aspected or domination magic (kind of like how Devos saw the runes when viewing Uther's past.) Actually, come to think of it, with how Kyrians ferry souls to the afterlife, how did none of them ever once see domination runes on their trips to mortal worlds? We know that the souls of individuals who died to the Scourge did make it to the Shadowlands, so the Kyrian must have been on Azeroth and seen some of those runes on Scourge architecture. Yeah...Taliesin's argument makes little sense. Failing many times over an eternity and only needing to succeed once only holds water as a plausible argument for what's happening with the Jailor if there is a guarantee that there is no consequence for failing.
@Dimensionmaster05
@Dimensionmaster05 2 года назад
The Kyrians clearly didn't care about the Scourge. They show that in the Afterlives animation.
@BartvG88
@BartvG88 2 года назад
Apathy and arrogance is a big thing among shadowlands leaders. Also, the jailor is already in super hell. What are they gonna do, kill him? Imprison him more? Watch him more carefully? Sure, but you can’t keep watching someone carefully for millennia.
@Thesuperhedge
@Thesuperhedge 2 года назад
This comment changed my mind about the theory. For pretty much this whole video I felt like Taliesin was making sense and Jesse was missing the point with his criticism, because the jailer has infinite time, so infinite tries, so it's zero problem if some dont work right (i.e. never getting to control azeroth)? But the game is pretty clear that basically nobody saw the jailer's escape coming until the last second, which is just not compatible with the idea that he had been making constant widespread attempts to influence reality.
@ArmageddonEvil
@ArmageddonEvil 2 года назад
@@BartvG88 Even though the Jailor *is* the bloody leader they betrayed. Because he had an idea of 'I can't do this anymore I need to change the UNIVERSES RULES! MUHAHAHAHA.'
@Dimensionmaster05
@Dimensionmaster05 2 года назад
@@ArmageddonEvil well....yeah. Did you not see how they acted when shit was out of place? Which leader went missing who actually tried to do something?
@Thromash
@Thromash 2 года назад
Only issue with Sylvanas & Arthas is, she wasn't there when he died. She decided to go see his corpse then saw Bolvar had replaced him, realizing there must always be a Lich King she realized it would never end, it meant nothing, all of what she did was pointless, so she jumped. Numerous things could have happened to stop her from deciding to go see Arthas' corpse which would have stopped that turn point. Like as an example, how literally no one was meant to know about Bolvar. But apparently no one bothered to guard the door lol
@Snowmanse
@Snowmanse 2 года назад
What I don't understand is that she really, really hates the lich king. Like still. Yet for some reason, she has been serving the puppeteer of the lich king and hadn't realized it despite it being incredibly obvious.
@MrSparten177
@MrSparten177 2 года назад
@@Snowmanse dosnt the same goes for uther? -hates arthas -joins the jailer who made arthas and apperently controlling him LUL i must say all of it is peak story KEKW
@Snowmanse
@Snowmanse 2 года назад
@@MrSparten177 It's a bit worse for Sylvanas though, because the jailer literally gave her a lich king cosplay to give to Anduin.
@MrSparten177
@MrSparten177 2 года назад
@@Snowmanse jailers whole existens is a sorry excuse of not knowing where to go with the story. i would also say the only reason they use the jailer is so make sylvanas a "good" character
@hristopavlov298
@hristopavlov298 2 года назад
Taliesin's point is he didnt count on her going up there to suicide, he capitalised on the chance. Same for the other event.
@Ramiell777
@Ramiell777 2 года назад
This is the only expansion I didn't even attempt to play and I have a wow tattoo that should tell you something
@Revvenge
@Revvenge 2 года назад
I feel the way Taliesin tries to explain it is that the Jailer is basically like Littlefinger from The Song of Ice and Fire. He also didn't have an exact plan on how to get the Iron Throne, but just saw opportunities and took them. He even took opportunities he didn't see the outcome of yet.
@Brooke-rw8rc
@Brooke-rw8rc 2 года назад
Which, ironically, is how you play chess. So essentially 10-d chess but most edgelords on the internet don't know how tf chess is played.
@Turamwdd
@Turamwdd 2 года назад
He also had to rely on several of these opportunities to succeed just enough at their goal but to be stopped before actually succeeding. And he had no hand in putting a stop to the plan which means he relied on some unknown element to come in and stop the pawn's plan from working. That is where some of this goes into the absurd level.
@Brooke-rw8rc
@Brooke-rw8rc 2 года назад
@@Turamwdd or he would have adapted and kept moving forward with the advantages that weren't destroyed. Again, this is simply how games- and life- work.
@KillItAndBurnIt
@KillItAndBurnIt 2 года назад
Yeah! And honestly, I do find chaotic opportunists more interesting than supposed master planners.
@Revvenge
@Revvenge 2 года назад
@@bidu2331324 Oh, yes. This is one of the reasons it's written badly. But the premise of the video is that it's not all one giant master plan, but rather opportunistic moves until he gets into a position he can break free.
@kenny42069
@kenny42069 2 года назад
I think the biggest problem with all of Taliesin's takes is that they are, by neccessity, intradiegetic. The only way he can make the story make sense is by speculating from an in-universe perspective and working his way backwards to rationalize the events that take place. But no one really cares about that because in the end, it's a story written by writers, and it's just not enjoyable to the player. Simply put it doesn't matter if the story makes sense, or whether the plot has holes in it or not. What ultimately matters is how the story is experienced by the player, and that experience is... not good.
@magnuscarlsson9969
@magnuscarlsson9969 2 года назад
Well i sort of think the story is written by writers, for the writers more so then the audiance. I have a feeling that if you would sit down in the studio where their whole storyboard are present, with all cut content, all books and events ordered in a sensible matter, all the exposition regarding the character roosters motivations etc. It might be a great story. Simply put the writers themselves don't read/play their own storys representation in media and if they do, they sit with the complete story right next to them and thus are able to follow even in moments where others would be lost. That will result in quite a massive disconnect between the writers and the audiance, the writers see their story as the most epic thing EVER(and perhaps it really is), while the players see the story as a mish-mash of lose ends that may or may not make sense in a few months or years when the full revelation might be part of some cutscene... or book. This disconnect cause many players to "attack" the writers(me included) describing the story as garbage... then the writers look at the criticism, then look at the "garbage" and instead see a nice high quality storyboard. Just like a chef would not accept the customer calling his high quality dish a "turd sandwitch" the writers just shut out the criticism or even get angry at the customer for makin such misconceptions.
@SignalWarden
@SignalWarden 2 года назад
This has always been my take on them. I love T&E but the reality is that while the plot can make sense if you jump through a hundred hoops and contort a dozen ways, it's all irrelevant, because it was written to have those hoops and contortions unnecessarily. If you really want, you can find story reasons for the choices made by all characters in Plan 9 From Outer Space. That doesn't change anything. It's just a thought exercise and has no bearing on the fact that it was just poorly written.
@VinceValentine
@VinceValentine 2 года назад
@@magnuscarlsson9969 Good point. Another analogy: The writers are like D&D dungeon masters who know all the possible ways to solve the puzzle/defeat the villain/find the princess, but the players don't. So of course the dungeon master thinks that the solution is really obvious and everything makes sense.
@Finn-xw4vn
@Finn-xw4vn 2 года назад
That is the point that T&E is making. It's shit, but we don't need to make up criticisms. It isn't accurate to say that the Jailer needed to plan everything to happen exactly. The writing is shit without having to fall back on incorrect criticism.
@Marisathu
@Marisathu 2 года назад
The jailer is a discount Sargeras. Honestly Shadowlands should have just been about dreadlords. I don't care about the jailer.
@ArmageddonEvil
@ArmageddonEvil 2 года назад
Nah, he's a discount MCU Villain aka Thanos.
@Marisathu
@Marisathu 2 года назад
@@ArmageddonEvil either way he a bargain bin villain that you find at the stores. Cheep and not good quality .
@jet44444
@jet44444 2 года назад
@@Marisathu Lmao 🤣 true.
@User5770
@User5770 2 года назад
My concise take on The Jailer (and Shadowland's story in general) is as follows: Imagine if instead of slowly building both Thanos and the Infinity Stones up in the background of the MCU for over half a decade, it instead introduced both Thanos and the Stones in Infinity War. And then insisted that no, this is actually what the story had been building too all the time, using a bunch of hastily made and poorly thought out retcons to try to justify it. What makes this so infuriating is that Warcraft actually had a villain it had been building up in the background for years. And then they unceremoniously threw him out specifically so they could move on to Shadowlands instead. It also doesn't help that the Jailer feels like yet another Blizzard villain entry written by a "Generate A Generic Doomsday Villain" algorithm.
@ownyounext
@ownyounext 2 года назад
Man its even worse than that. At least Thanos was built up as a character in Infinity War. We could actually sympathize with him to some extent. I honestly didn't even watch many of the MCU movies before Infinity War and I really respected Thanos as a villian (I did see guardians of the galaxy). Edit: Its even more like if Thanos was introduced in End Game LOL
@User5770
@User5770 2 года назад
Oh absolutely. The Jailor is terrible on a macro level, in that his position in the story is poorly set up and poorly justified. But he's just as bad on the micro level, in that he has no personality (again, feels like his dialogue was written by an algorithm), the vaguest of goals (we had no meaningful grasp of what his aim was beyond a vague "its a super evil plan" until the actual final act was announced), and no coherently stated motivation (why exactly is he doing this again? What led to the Jailor going down this path? Don't worry about it. He's evil and has to be stopped.) It is actually almost impressive how bad of a character the Jailor is. He manages to derail the story as it contorts itself to justify his existence, while also being the most one-dimensional character in Warcraft to date.
@ownyounext
@ownyounext 2 года назад
@@User5770 Very nice comment!! This is probably the most well thought out and accurate comment that I have read about the Jailer so far
@Jamesgates355
@Jamesgates355 2 года назад
its not Infinity War, its Endgame Thanos without context for who Thanos actually was but is the bad guy
@BroadwayRonMexico
@BroadwayRonMexico 2 года назад
The Jailer is what you'd get if FFXIV Endwalker introduced the Endsinger as the greater scope villain who led to everything without first showing the Final Days in Shadowbringers and without the Elpis chapter
@nakenmil
@nakenmil 2 года назад
I said it before: but this reminds me of what Blizz did during vanilla WoW with the Old Gods. They wanted the Old Gods to be big deals, so they retroactively fitted the OGs into almost every storyline that had previously existed in the Warcraft games. As a wee 'un, I remember I was pretty annoyed by how blatant it was. "Oh, the Burning Legion was formed to fight the Old Gods? Sure, sure. Oh, Deathwing wasn't always evil, the Old Gods "corrupted" him? God, this is Kerrigan and Arthas all over again. Oh, the Old Gods made Illidan plant a new well of eternity? Why? Didn't he already have the motivation needed to do that himself being an arcane magic user? Oh, the Old Gods changed the exiled Kaldorei Highborne into the Quel'dorei? Wuh-why? The Old Gods created the Naga? But Azshara was already a super powerful sorceress, why couldn't she have done something like that herself? Oh also, because of the Curse of Flesh the old gods technically caused every mortal race on Azeroth to come into being? Okay, a bit blatant, I guess." People forget that all of this shit was just made up in WoW. Etc. I could go on. Then a decade passes, new storylines get written with them already in mind, and you eventually forget that at some point they were shoe-horned in HARD.
@ArmageddonEvil
@ArmageddonEvil 2 года назад
So Blizzard has been shit at telling a story ever since Vanilla... A Character-Driven Story anyway. And now they are trying to *copy* FFXIV's Character-Driven Story structure and FAILING HORRIBLY.
@filthycasual8093
@filthycasual8093 2 года назад
@@ArmageddonEvil MAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAWALKER
@jordanread5829
@jordanread5829 2 года назад
Some of the things you listed as "the old gods being behind it" are simply false. The Old Gods had nothing to do with Illidan making the second well of eternity. They had nothing to do with the exiled Highborne becoming the High elves. Also the curse of flesh only impacted Titanforged races that were on Azeroth (this was true even in Wrath, which introduced the curse of flesh). Which basically included Vrykul (and thus Humans), Dwarfs (which we knew were descended from Earthern in Vanilla thanks to Ulduman), Gnomes, Tol'vir, Troggs and Mogu. Therefore races like the Tauren and trolls were already fleshy races. Deathwing prior to Day of the Dragon & the WotA trilogy was just a generic evil dragon which was originally going to be killed off in the cancelled Lord of the Clans point and click game. Also there wasn't that much to the origins of the Naga beyond they were Night Elves and something happened when the WoE imploded. Also Deathwing wasn't so much "corrupted" as it is at first glance. The short story Charge of the Aspects has Neltharion tell Thrall that he willingly sided with the Old Gods (mainly N'zoth) because he saw his "gift" from Khaz'goroth as a curse. N'zoth promised to remove the "curse" if Neltharion did what he asked for. And we all know how N'zoth planned to fulfill his promise in the End Time dungeon. So it is more like Anakin then Kerrigan and Arthas imo. Even right down to becoming more metal than dragon. As for Sargeras creating the Legion to fight the void, that was in Chronicles Vol 1. Even in your rant you can't even get some of your "sources" correct. Personally I prefer what blizzard did with N'zoth and co. They took footnotes or bland characters and expended upon them. Having it spread out over years is much better than doing it all at once like it is in Shadowlands. As it allows the audience to grow accustomed to the new information. Making up falsehoods doesn't help your argument. I would recommend actually learning the lore first.
@lillianjones2577
@lillianjones2577 2 года назад
Tali's comment about fish boy N'zoth is referring to the fact that his voice and speaking pattern changed from what we had in warbringers, and what we got in BFA.
@Ashurman666
@Ashurman666 2 года назад
I don't play WOW and even I think this makes absolutely no sense whatsoever. And I fully understand the "plot" of Kingdom Hearts!
@jawstrock2215
@jawstrock2215 2 года назад
So the jailor just got lucky, is all this comes down to. He could have sit still, do absolutely nothing, and just randomly be freed eventually. Same thing.
@seekittycat
@seekittycat 2 года назад
I would totally buy his "Not a mastermind just got lucky eventually" if there is some indication of it but that would actually be interesting.
@Animehermit
@Animehermit 2 года назад
I wouldnt say it's all luck, it's more like he took advantage of what was happening already.
@pluna3382
@pluna3382 2 года назад
@@Animehermit That would imply that he knew in which way to win. That he knew where pieces needed to go beforehand. He didn't.
@Rhodair
@Rhodair 2 года назад
The most unbelievable part to me is that this could be going on for _that_ long and not a single pawn let slip that Zovaal was up to stuff. I think of it like a Kingpin crime boss who is issuing out orders from the shadows but no one speaks his name. I just can't be convinced that there wasn't a single agent of his for eons that'd have a brief moment of loose lips.
@kobrraful
@kobrraful 2 года назад
fun fact for those who don't know when Jesse mentioned the open threads with FF14: for Endwalker specifically, a lot of the expansion was actually already planned out from the end of ARR to Heavensward. Yoshi P had made a comment about it a while ago in one of the Live Letters, and also had mentioned they tend to plan 2 to 3 expansions ahead from the one coming out. :) hope Jesse sees this
@leonie7754
@leonie7754 2 года назад
Exactly, this, it was mostly planned out. I called us going to the moon at back when Stormblood was announced! I was at the EU fanfest when Yoshi P revealed the SB trailer with the new continent of Orthard. He said something along the lines of "the world was expanding and who knows where we'll go in the future? Maybe even the moon!" I don't remember the exact wording, other than 'maybe even the moon', but i said at that second that we would go to the moon in a future expansion and lo, we did. He called that years before so at the very least it was part of the plan. The team have explained they had the overall story planned out in advance a few times, but i'm sure the finer details were flexible enough to change as the expansions came up. Emet-Selch being a fan favourite probably wasn't planned, but the reaction most likely led him to play more of a role in Endwalker than perhaps he would have done if he had been disliked. After all, Lyse wasn't very popular, so she got sidelined to a minor role after SB. They listen to what works so they need to have a solid direction, but be flexible enough to amend the details based on the reaction of the players.
@arof7605
@arof7605 2 года назад
@@leonie7754 FF14 has a throughline of story that can only be explained by having a true plan, at some level. I was able to realize, right after 5.0 and before any of the post-MSQ, we were probably going to Sharlayan in the next xpac, because of how important the place was all the way back into HW. No predictions about how WoW has gone line up with what came before, and that just ruins both past setup and its content and cheapens the new stuff.
@denis2306
@denis2306 2 года назад
Jailer is just a sugar-free, gluten-free, vegan version of Thanos.
@Shiirow
@Shiirow 2 года назад
people say that but in reality he is a discount Aizen Sosuke, "even the hero getting their powers was my doing and part of my master plan".
@SandwichDoctorZ
@SandwichDoctorZ 2 года назад
Not Thanos. Nathanos lol
@onetrickponysona2613
@onetrickponysona2613 2 года назад
none of these things are inherently bad. unlike the jailer
@ultravioletcatastrophe
@ultravioletcatastrophe 2 года назад
Is that a bad thing? both are quite shit tho
@VegardLaur
@VegardLaur 2 года назад
Lmao
@xRymerx
@xRymerx 2 года назад
This was great! Wouldn't mind getting more of these!
@regeoberon3676
@regeoberon3676 2 года назад
If people want an example of a game series where the writing takes some 5D chess turns, they should check out the Legacy of Kain series. Those games are a true plot of convoluted but still planned and executed concepts. This Jailer nonsense, this is all just lazy writing. "You said it yourself, Kain. There are only two sides to your coin." "Apparently so. But suppose you throw a coin enough times. Suppose that one day it lands on its edge."
@TheOnlyLonelyBoy
@TheOnlyLonelyBoy 2 года назад
Solitary upvote for Legacy of Kain. Brillaintly written series.
@sarien_aurelas
@sarien_aurelas 2 года назад
The game series that made ponder about the intricacies of free will at the age of 16. "Our futures are predestined - Moebius foretold mine aeons ago. We each play out the parts fate has written for us. Free will is an illusion" I never forgot this line
@JackgarPrime
@JackgarPrime 2 года назад
Ooooh man, the Legacy of Kain plot. The plots upon plots going on there are wild.
@Lmwpitt
@Lmwpitt 2 года назад
This is the scrutiny I've wanted on T&E's shilling videos.
@amie7628
@amie7628 2 года назад
I know nothing about WoW, never played it, yet here I am watching a 50 minute video about it only cuz it's Jesse. 😅
@jessecox
@jessecox 2 года назад
😍
@meathookmassacre2438
@meathookmassacre2438 2 года назад
Same though lol
@ghoullio-jr
@ghoullio-jr 2 года назад
it seems like the defense taliesin and evitel is making here is that the jailer is actually soooooo powerful and rad that we can't even comprehend how long he's been scheming because we're insignificant compared to him... soooo what he's saying is... the events of the game we've been playing, and the story we've been following for 30 years are completely insignificant, and new writers came in and wrote a grimdark superpowerful zack snyder-ass god villain from before time existed that barely even fits thematically with the rest of the game, and that story, not the one we've been following, is the story about the people and events who had actual influence? aaaand that's this guy's DEFENSE of the story...?
@TheGerrok
@TheGerrok 2 года назад
tldr: the jailor just sits there and the universe aligns itself for him to be free. Like when everyone at the jail forgets to lock a single door.
@MikePhantom
@MikePhantom 2 года назад
the issue also with jailer "threw things at the wall to see what sticks" there are TO MANY literal declaration that this is the one and ONLY plan, chosen ones and azeroth being THE ONE titan of something. there is to much of it to explain it with a certainty trough trial and error.
@TheAmazonplay
@TheAmazonplay 2 года назад
I actually used this trope in one of my villains in a dnd campaign, it was a timeless, ageless creature whose only goal was to achieve mortality, he just wanted to die. During the campaing he started as a bored soul doing evil without caring, as he had done countless times already, but as the campaing progressed and some unlikely things started to happen (some caused by the players themselves) he began to turn into a maniacal figure. With every lucky shot, and every bet gone right he got more impacient and relentless, he just couldn´t belive his luck, he had gotten so far, he wasn't going to screw it up now, he couldn´t, god knows how many millions of years would have to pass for an opportunity like this to present itself again so, when the heroes finally stood ready to stop this murderous gambler, he fought with nail and teeth. In the end he was defeated, and he felt anger for the first time in millenia, he had failed countless times before, but never as close as he was to succes. However, after a while, he was filled with optimism, his goal was achievable, he almost got it once, now it was only a matter of time, and boy does he have enough time to shoot in the dark a few more million or billion times because, he will die, eventually. I´m not saying the Jailor should have been written this way, or that Blizzard intented this to be a caracter trope for his lamest villain yet, im just saying that there´s nothing wrong with having a lucky timeless being as a villain. The concept of timelessnes and eternity wil always face itself with the concepts of chance and probability, because no matter how unlikely the event could be, if the amount of time available is infinity it wil ALWAYS happen, its fascinating really, and having an inmortal gambler with infinte time to bet finally getting a wining streak could make for a really good character trope.
@josetapia9714
@josetapia9714 2 года назад
True. I dare say, it's not soo much "lucky" but rather being smart enought to see an opportunity and just take it. That is cunning, and people love cunning characters but hate being treated like an idiot and that is what this conbvoluted failed history of Shadowlands feels like. Hell, we could use your own history Villain's motivation for the Jailer: The Jailer was the original Arbiter created by the First Ones, meant to send mortal souls tot heir respective Afterlife. But the eons and eons, Zorvaal grew envious of Mortals existances: unlike him they lived their short lives, full emotions, joy and pain, and while his own existance was dull and never ending, and grew to resent his own inmortality and specially he grew to resent his own position, thinking the First Ones evil for the denying him the pleasures of mortal life and making him serve mortals by sending them to their afterlives. Zorvaal became hatefull towards mortals but at the same time admiring them, specially mortals of great deeds, envious of them but also respeting them. They could have writed what his own obsesion for tortuing is some weird desire to feel something, like a masochism-sadistim angle, and he specially desired souls of great mortal sinces it was their lives he desired most and he broke their wills throught torture to make them in a sick twisted way "His". And like the Lich King and N'Zoth, He could have been interested in our Character seeing our deeds and more importantly the opportunities we made for him to exploit by using the Soul of the Titan we slayed, and our opposition/Help towards Sylvanas what made the war send more Souls into the Maw. So he sees our Character as His "Greatest Champion" and seeks to capture us, torture us and break our wils into his greatest "Champion" Damnit Blizzard! You literally made create a better version of own History in a Youtuve Comment with a bunch of Strangers!!
@gregorycafiero9688
@gregorycafiero9688 2 года назад
The problem with Tali's theory is it goes from "Jailer manipulated these events to his favor" to "Jailer has manipulated countless events in the timeline" which is SO MUCH WORSE. So not only is he behind things that led to now, but now has had influence over things that are seemingly unrelated :p
@joejoejoe532
@joejoejoe532 2 года назад
Not quite: it's that the Jailer TRIED to manipulate countless events in the timeline and **failed** the vast majority of them, meaning ultimately his influence is still really limited.
@liger04
@liger04 2 года назад
@@joejoejoe532 But unless blizzard decides to give the Jailer time controlling abilities as well, those failures should have consequences. There should be other followers of the Jailer that never got the strength or the chance to destroy the Helm of Domination. There should be other planets that worship the Jailer yet never became a super-spy network like the Dreadlords did. People against the Jailer should know that he has been interfering in the mortal realm for millenia. But there isn't any of those. Just the Jailer saying "I am inevitable, so I'm successful." With the exact amount of influence we know he got.
@joejoejoe532
@joejoejoe532 2 года назад
​@@liger04 That is true, which is why Taliesin specifically says, and I paraphrase: "all of the potential is there, and they do *nothing* with it." At no point in Tali's dissertation did he ever say the this concept was remotely done well, and in fact he unambiguously expresses that this is terrible execution of a potentially great concept, and which I agree. The very fact that the community is having this discussion on the confusing nature of the Jailer is testament to how terrible of a character he has been.
@permeus2nd
@permeus2nd 2 года назад
3:46 wait the blizzard devs do know that Titans DON'T go to the shadowlands when they die .....Right? they have their own afterlife that is completely separate from ours. 5:54 i wouldnt be surprised if the blizzard devs somehow try to sell us the idea that it was the jailer behind the void lords all along.
@Jaricko
@Jaricko 2 года назад
the baddie of BFA was Sylvanas. N'zoth was a tangent. That is how bad that expansion was. We don't even get a satisfying final boss. N'zoth should have had this expansion, but we 1 patched a fully powered eldritch monstrosity that had been hyped up for several expansions... instead of the bone lady who caused all the problems and that entire war.
@hqueso
@hqueso 2 года назад
There is no coin flip result that says "no more coin flips" before you get to ten. There is no horse race result on the first race that cancels the last five. The Jailor's plan of shotgun-blasting plot elements at random does have an overall fail state if he gets something too wrong. This is where the analysis breaks down. There are not just dead ends for The Jailor there are overall failure points. And those likely would outnumber the seeming few combinations that would succeed. Even more so if he's not planning this ahead. It's not coin flips or horse races- it's Russian Roulette. The more times he pulls the trigger, the more likely it all comes to a sudden and irrevocable end. So the video basically says that there isn't a master plan- there's a massive retcon by the lore writers because they have nothing going forward. But wait, he said The Jailer gets endless retries every time he fails. The idea that he can fail infinitely assumes no failures are so bad that he cannot recover. There is no reason to assume that. If we do assume that, then why bother with the lore at all? None of it matters. No resistance works. Making the core of your lore a nihilistic uselessness of all player actions isn't good lore, even if you could justify it, and I don't think you can.
@fillosof66689
@fillosof66689 2 года назад
Exactly. Even if the Jailer can never be destroyed - or if his former peers are for some reasons reluctant to ever make that choice regardless of how dangerous the Jailer gets - and so he has to stay imprisoned in the Maw, the moment the rest if them become aware of his attempts at getting free, it is game over. Because they are also timeless beings that can dedicate uncountable aeons to thwarting every single scheme the Jailer may concoct. We were never given an explanation for why every one of those being aside from the co-conspirator chose to blindly believe in the infallability of the new order they created and never actually keep a close watch on their most dangerous prisoner.
@corpsefoot758
@corpsefoot758 2 года назад
@@fillosof66689 Yikes lol Talk about a massive plot hole
@blueshoals
@blueshoals 2 года назад
25:07 We went from, "The Jailer has a plan," To "The Jailer is in jail, and has nothing but time. Literally."
@matthewrowell5973
@matthewrowell5973 2 года назад
Time to start making things out of floss and paper mache
@JacksonJinn
@JacksonJinn 2 года назад
The problem, cold and clear, is that we have not seen the Jailer's side in this or his failures. If we were introduced to Zovaal and his plans from his side, and this was a running weekly TV show or something where we watch him laze about in superhell while occassionally doing cool villain things, and then everything eventually starts tying together in the season finale, *that* could be fun. It'd be bullshit if literally everything worked, but yeah the concept would work because we'd have the context. Instead... We saw 10 heads in a row while knowing conclusively with evidence he only tossed 10 coins. Put another way, the jailer hasn't fucked up yet at all. "All according to keikaku."
@pluna3382
@pluna3382 2 года назад
This exactly. If they were trying to sell that point that the Jailer had so much infinite time he had to win at some point. Sure. But that final eventual win is meaningless if we never understood how many countless losses had to be endured to get there. Even worse, that he didn't learn from those mistakes and that he just did whatever to make it work. Except he didn't make it work. The solution just worked itself out and he's just reaping the fact he was coincidentally there. This is not a better take. It's worse than just being a galaxy brain IQ villain.
@JacksonJinn
@JacksonJinn 2 года назад
What I think could have salvaged this was if we'd heard about the Jailer... At all before this point. Imagine if something, anything, even just a damn X.1 raid in any given expansion was dedicated to stopping the Jailer from breaking out of superhell riding off the threat of the week. "The Thunder King rose from the dead? Oh shit, he's *also* trying to summon up this super scary Jailer guy in the process! We need to stop him!" or maybe "Hey, since we're in town with this alternate dimension, the Naaru told us something weird was going down with them. Apparently this super evil guy called the Jailer is trying to make a play to escape in this timeline, and we need you heroes to stop it!" Hell, if this was all cooked up during Legion, instead of beating up Helya we should have actually seen some kind of original plot of the Jailer's that we stop. Maybe make that the expanded plot of that region, instead of the half-baked Sylvanas/Genn fight that took up the back half of the plot. Point is, if the goal was "10 heads in a row but we don't see all the flips," *we should damn well have seen times he hit tails.*
@Zastier
@Zastier 2 года назад
As a Final Fantasy XIV player, watching this video just confirmed a theory I had for a while. Blizzard saw how well FFXIV has been doing, and have been trying to incorporate the story beats from it into WoW. The Jailer is literally just a much worse version of the Ascians. They both had one goal which involved somehow rewriting the rules of the world, they both had a hand in every bad things that happened in the story, they both have an eternity to achieve whatever goal it is they are planning to achieve. They both are just tossing things out there and seeing what will stick. But while the Ascians from as early as 1.0 have been in the shadows, creating chaos in the world in order to achieve their goal through the summoning of primals, the Jailer was introduced at the very end to clumsily tie the story of each expansion together.
@windack768
@windack768 2 года назад
+ we know that the Ascians failed A LOT during all this time even if they successfuly rejoined the worlds multiple times by the beginning of 2.0. Hell, Emet-Selch even straight up says that the 13th is a useless void because they screwed up that bad. Or Lahabrea planing out a plan for King Thordan who in the end straight up kills him. It sometimes backfires on the Ascians in FF, while it rarely (if ever, can't remember that well) does for the Jailer.
@mischitary
@mischitary 2 года назад
He brings up Emet-Selch in the video and I actually think that's a pretty good comparison. He also had literally all the time in the world to plan and scheme in order to fulfill his desires but like Jesse said in the video the difference is he was basically just doing the same thing over and over again before Shadowbringers, which was founding huge destructive empires. Every time he tried to do so it didn't always end with him achieving his goals but a couple of times it either worked perfectly or came very close to working. He was just constantly flipping a large, very complicated coin.
@waking00one
@waking00one 2 года назад
Yep, and as Jesse points out the difference is we *understand* that and hes given enough time and charm to develop Hell, the first time you meet him he literally goes "i could just wait some more for you to die and try again, but let's see if i can do things differently"
@JackgarPrime
@JackgarPrime 2 года назад
@@waking00one I did think that was a good moment there. Its true, he's a very powerful immortal. He could just go hang out somewhere and wait until enough time has passed where he could just start over again with another empire. But since his current plan is already not going super great, might as well see how it ends up and he may be able to salvage and learn some things by sticking close.
@SethalaTheGamer
@SethalaTheGamer 2 года назад
Didn't Emet's goals succeed, though? He successfully caused several calamaties that in turn caused rejoinings. Sure, this calamity in the making isn't going so well, and there's probably been other empires in the making that didn't pan out, but the difference is his goal isn't "I have to win once", it's "I have to win 13 times", and he's already gotten 7 of those wins resolved before the start of ARR...
@chronoxtreme2427
@chronoxtreme2427 2 года назад
@@SethalaTheGamer Yeah, that's the big major thing. Emet's plans are actually really, really good - he almost won in Shadowbringers. But despite him being very shrewd, even he can't stop wildcards from mucking with what he wants. Sometimes he's quick enough on the draw, like when he literally pulled out a gun to put his plans back on track. But other stuff like Zenos and Ardbert he couldn't have forseen because he's immortal, not all knowing. That's how you have a well written villain: his failures are from things he realistically could not have anticipated, and without that, he would have won again.
@Shiirow
@Shiirow 2 года назад
"Listen to my 5Head plan and bask in its 4D chess greatness" - The Jailer, probably Venat : "Hold my mana potion."
@souledgar
@souledgar 2 года назад
And she does it without shitting on every character on either side of the morality line in the last 10 years.
@lancerhades971
@lancerhades971 2 года назад
Literally dude. Venat has an 4d chese play that seems like a stretch even in FF, but this makes it seem TAME
@Tsuna_SoulSilver
@Tsuna_SoulSilver 2 года назад
tbh she could go for something stronger and she will still outdo nipple man
@Kokerret
@Kokerret 2 года назад
only reason venat's plan works for the story is because she's following the law of paradox time loops
@JackgarPrime
@JackgarPrime 2 года назад
Maaaan, Venat would probably solve all the problems in Azeroth in like a week, even without creation magic. Although that would help.
@localshaman
@localshaman 2 года назад
See the biggest hole as i see it in Tali's reasoning is this; it's becoming increasing clear for the Jailers plan to work he needs Azeroths world soul *specifically* for his overall plan to work, it serves a purpose in the big cycle machine thing we don't yet fully understand. So for one of his first big major moves to be "Go encourage that other titan to go around killing planets with world souls willy nilly (particularly ones with old god infestations like Azeroth), seems just a liiiiittle bit counter-intuitive to the goal?
@rainbowratty
@rainbowratty 2 года назад
If he failed all these times, with this many attempts, with this many fingers in this many pies... how was there zero evidence until there needed to be to introduce the character?
@Tubeviewilhm
@Tubeviewilhm 2 года назад
Why…. Why would there be evidence. The failed ones in the video we’ve already seen and most of the other plans probably happened on other planets. How would we have seen those? The more pressing problem is the cosmic deities basically stay true to their trope and don’t really pay attention to the mortal realms very carefully but then again that’s a trope in pretty much all of media.
@PerkulatorBenny
@PerkulatorBenny 2 года назад
​@@Tubeviewilhm Because having some kind of evidence and foreshadowing that something more is going on the background would mean that it feels like he was there, being involved, and actually affecting things as they unfolded. You know, proper storytelling when introducing a big villain with plans that have been ongoing for a while? Instead this is like you and your enemy playing a chess match when the Jailer shows up, flips the chess board, claims that you were actually playing poker all along and also he's got a straight flush. Read 'em and weep.
@Tubeviewilhm
@Tubeviewilhm 2 года назад
@@PerkulatorBenny you mean like even in edge of night when they Val’kyr joined Sylvanas for reasons unsaid. Or later when we see Sylvanas making plans with other figures like Helya that would eventually join the jailer. Yes, it’d be nice if the Jailer had more of a presence than he did earlier on but seeds were there. If you’re going to fault Blizzard for not explicitly planning out how all those seeds would take effect than I hope you’re ready to fault pretty much every story teller in existence that has written sequels or follow ups to their story.
@PerkulatorBenny
@PerkulatorBenny 2 года назад
@@Tubeviewilhm I can fault Blizzard for it all I want, because even when they do try to use some foreshadowing, they are not very good at it. :P "Reasons unsaid" is not foreshadowing. That's just leaving a blank space you can fill in later with whatever you want. If it had been foreshadowing, they would have mentioned someone in charge that the was responsible for the deal, done the horrible cliché of "mysterious stranger lurking around the corner", or just ANYTHING that you can come back to and see that "oh yeah, that guy. I remember that guy. So that was HIM!" But Blizzard pretty much seem to have a pile of completely disconnected (or "self-contained", if you want to be generous) plots that they just dig one out when they release a new expansion. Just bring out the blindfold and dartboard of "what is going wrong in Azeroth today?"
@Tubeviewilhm
@Tubeviewilhm 2 года назад
@@PerkulatorBenny I love all the negative buzzwords. You don't see that in literally every single complaint. Truly original stuff there. The fact of the matter is it was foreshadowed whether you like it or not. What you are wanting is them to have spelt it out for you. That's the crux of people's problems in WoW. Any time they don't directly spell out what is going on, the fans get pissy and complain and always misunderstand what they are complaining about. Like literally these whole videos were made because fans didn't pay any attention and latched on to complaints without verifying if the complaints knew what they were talking about. It's ironic that fans will also complain about Blizzard not doing subtlety in their stories and characters spelling everything out. This is why. You are more than welcome to continue complaining about things you don't understand correctly, just as I would then be welcome to call you out for it.
@PharaohofAtlantis
@PharaohofAtlantis 2 года назад
Man. I just... cannot believe the WoW story. On paper, almost everything in the last two expansions could have been good. Could have been great. It takes a few tweaks here and there, and a reversal somewhere else. But they are so close, to something compelling and good. But on almost all of the options, they take the bad one, and the story just suffers so much. There are some really great things - but small things. And all the large stuff is just so... sad.
@cartwheelsweetpickle
@cartwheelsweetpickle 2 года назад
The whole lore is just OMEGALUL for me.
@Sharksterfly
@Sharksterfly 2 года назад
Im sorry, there is one Azeroth in the universe apparently. Its super special titan. So no, he had no place for error - if burning legion destroys azeroth - he is done, Zerath Mortis is finished.
@Snagprophet
@Snagprophet 2 года назад
Yeah even if someone says "you'd say anything negative about Shadowlands" most people like Denathrius and find both his design and character fun and enjoyable and they don't really explain why he's like that. It shows how bland the Jailer is
@noelward
@noelward 2 года назад
I really enjoyed Denathrius! That was fun and entertaining and it made me feel like I could connect to him. I understood enough about who he was and what he wanted that I could empathize with his emotions and ambitions even if we didn’t always have every detail of his plan. He also had an exciting and engaging personality! Even just hearing his Voice Actor speaking in character now gives me feels. It’s sad to think that his “superior” bad guy lacks so many of those qualities
@Kirby99881234
@Kirby99881234 2 года назад
For me, WoW ended after Legion. I don't count the last 2 expansions as real.
@MrBarlien
@MrBarlien 2 года назад
I've said this before, and I say it again... so yeah, here it is: I used to think that Zovaal could be cool if given the time, and build up, that he required, like an Arthas for WoW 2.0. But I've come to the conclusion that if you have to thread a hundred needles for him to make sense, it's a bad idea and it would always feel contrived. Zovaal is the single worst thing to ever have happened to WarCraft lore. It is a total destruction and ruination of the once vast, diverse and mystical universe of WarCraft. The game has left me wanting for years, but the lore I have always loved, so fuck Steve Danuser, fuck him from the bottom of my heart.
@LovelyRising
@LovelyRising 2 года назад
I love listening to you go off on lore/story stuff! Always feels like a conversation I imagine I’d enjoy having with you, so I least I get to hear your perspective. Would love more lore/story centered videos/reacts.
@RedNZBlue
@RedNZBlue 2 года назад
If it's throwing spaghetti at the wall, then his planning completely fails to cover anything past this current point in the story. So when he inevitably gets killed in the raid it's not because we're powerful or tenacious or anything positive, it's because this whole time we were fighting a lucky idiot. And that's terrible to me.
@BartvG88
@BartvG88 2 года назад
Tali’s argument isn’t that Zovaal is a lucky idiot, just that he has plans within plans, and oceans of time. Even if he was discovered, he’s already in the most inescapable prison. He could be watched more carefully, but not forever. I dunno. I like it. It reminds me of terrorist plots. Many will fail, but humanity can’t stop them all. This inevitability of evil through constant effort is something primally dreadful.
@RedNZBlue
@RedNZBlue 2 года назад
My issue with the inevitability of evil is that his plan is infinite chances up until he passed through that portal. Because once he goes to Zereth Mortis he has one chance. And if his strategy so far has been to "try everything" then he's gonna fail when he needs to rely on a single plan.
@TheMeGuy1
@TheMeGuy1 2 года назад
I dunno I actually like their interpretation more because the retcon of "Jailer 5D Chess'd everything in WoW" takes away from the agency and circumstances the other characters had to make the choices they did. It shits all over the existing lore by tainting it as part of the Jailer's big break. But this interpretation of "The Jailer had his hands in things when he could get them, and waited for his opening" feels better because it doesn't recontextualize EVERYTHING, it adds a small detail here and there, but it doesn't take the agency from the characters who made certain decisions and shit on the lore in quite the same way.
@snatchr2451
@snatchr2451 2 года назад
This isn't how the Jailer worked like... At all. We're given zero indication hes been able to do anything like this. The denizens of the shadowlands are stunned hes done >anything< when we show up. Its clear this is his one, single plan and he calculated it to perfection because please god care about the story why is everyone unsubbing aaaaaaaaaa Hell his journal entry on the raid literally says hes "never known defeat" lmao
@kiofea
@kiofea 2 года назад
Yet his chest-orb was stolen from him by his siblings and he was locked away in the Maw to be imprisoned forevermore... But totally not a defeat, just a setback!
@gearhead417
@gearhead417 2 года назад
@@kiofea I mean yeah it kind of was just a set back because hes right back to where he was like nothing else happened.
@RazanaArcclaw
@RazanaArcclaw 2 года назад
they are stunned because the one person (the primus) who found out he was doing this was captured and imprisoned before he could tell the others. They beleive he and his workers cannot leave the maw at all, which is untrue. so they ignored the signs, its literally in the bastion afterlives video "There is a minion of the maw running rampent on a mortal world!" "thats literally impossible, stfu, get outta here.| this is entirely given indication of this literally ingame, but the people of the shadowlands have been fooled by their own false security that he has done nothing, especially since one leader who found out vanished, and another leader is on his side and snuffs out any possible hint of him being influencing.
@TheAlexkon3
@TheAlexkon3 2 года назад
I mean, much of this sounds very much like their headcanon. As far as we know the Jailer didn't try a billion times to escape already.
@keuric
@keuric 2 года назад
The problem with Tali’s point is: he is using speculation to refute a speculative perspective. He is trying to short circuit one person’s logic using equally flawed logic because none of it is canonical because WoW writers are both cowards and incompetent.
@valeclaw1697
@valeclaw1697 2 года назад
EXACTLY! Nothing he's saying is canon. Him so proudly saying in the title that we're wrong, 'heres why' feels actually really fucking gross when he's just... pushing his speculation as an objective fact?
@tickub
@tickub 2 года назад
"if you and i have been mortal enemies forever, and we went to the afterlife together, something tells me when we got back we wouldn't be mortal enemies anymore" nobody tell jesse that the cold war broke out almost immediately after WW2, his pure heart wouldn't be able to take it.
@greysonmiller9407
@greysonmiller9407 2 года назад
So basically the Jailer is Orgalorg from Adventure Time, open door philosophy.
@MaMastoast
@MaMastoast 2 года назад
The fundamental problem with comparison the coin toss example with and how the jailor supposedly did things is that with the coin tosses you have an infinite amount of shots at the goal which are all possible solutions. In an actual finite world, and at the scale the jailor operates he'd only have room for so many misguided attempts before everything permanently got away from him
@MaMastoast
@MaMastoast 2 года назад
My point is that unlike with the coin tosses, there is not a certainty of the jailors desired outcome because he will run out of option through guesswork. Let's say he needs a world soul as his solution, well . If his random guesswork ends up destroying all world souls in existence, he's lost for good
@zerocopy8407
@zerocopy8407 2 года назад
Im glad you did this video because I have not been keeping up with the story.
@Danke255
@Danke255 2 года назад
I feel that comparing the jailer's plan to the probability of someone winning 6 horse races in a row, or getting 10 heads in a row is highly disingenuous. Those things are probable enough that they were *done*. Sure, it took 9 hours of filming to get 10 heads in a row, and sure, it took however many thousands of people to get someone to win 6 races, but the jailer's plan to me feels more like that old "get infinite monkeys typing on typewriters and give them infinite time that you'll certainly end up with a Shakespeare's play" idea.
@Greenhooves
@Greenhooves 2 года назад
That's pretty much what Taliesin is saying.
@MonstaRastaVideos
@MonstaRastaVideos 2 года назад
Aren't the writers writing themselves into another corner? Let's say the Jailer planned this all out or finally got their big break. What's that got to say about the player and free will? What does it matter if the player does anything, if it technically is part of the jailer's plan? "I knew you'd get in my way." Without a Deus ex ___ there's nothing to do.
@fidly4
@fidly4 2 года назад
Yes, its exactly the monkeys with typewriters and infinite time will write Shakespeare thing; good example. Why is that a problem? He basically had infinite time. That's how it works. Do you just dislike the examples because of how scaled down they are? The logic scales up.
@NomNomsense
@NomNomsense 2 года назад
If you had infinite monkeys typing, you'd have a Shakespeare play in the amount of time it takes to type a Shakespeare play. That's how infinity works. That said, I think the jailer is a terrible character and a terrible big bad. I also don't think Taliesin is wrong. Blizzard is wrong, as usual.
@cathulionetharn5139
@cathulionetharn5139 2 года назад
Also extremely likely that at no point the plan backfired Say Sargeras notices dreadlords are secretly filling argus with death mana and purges the shit out of them. Boom, Jailer has ZERO ability to affect the living world The biggest failure we know of (beyond imprisonment) is a mild case of cockblock by Bolvar, ffs
@toychristopher
@toychristopher 2 года назад
Taliesin's talents really are wasted trying to make sense of WoW's writing.
@Shiirow
@Shiirow 2 года назад
clearly a more creative writer than Danuser, they should hire _him_ to write the story for the game.
@strings1586
@strings1586 2 года назад
No kidding. You can feel the corporatization through the expansion
@TheUtindi
@TheUtindi 2 года назад
I would watch you react to literally anything. Much love!
@TheGamingCabby
@TheGamingCabby 2 года назад
Throwing it out there, I know you've never been a reaction channel, but this was fun! Do please continue whenever it is you next find something that peaks your interest.
@Funkyent
@Funkyent 2 года назад
My big problem with the macro cosmos story is the sheer amount of retcons and lampshading needed to make it happen. If and only if the lead narrative writer had been the same dude for 20 years and had actually planned seeds to make this shit not ridiculous than maybe it wouldn't be silly.
@cyberdoga5728
@cyberdoga5728 2 года назад
Ok I just have one question regarding 30:45 , If the Jailer was taking as many opportunities as he could you would think someone on the outside would've noticed by now before his step by step plan actually worked.
@Orthus100
@Orthus100 2 года назад
You can notice something and pay it no mind without context to make it matter to you. Also, the entire hypothesis is that it wasn't a step by step plan, but rather enough bets taken.
@Dimensionmaster05
@Dimensionmaster05 2 года назад
You'd think that, but the only one who honestly might notice is The Primus. Mainly because that's his job, but with Denathrius also helping the Jailer, who knows if he was helping cover his tracks
@Yorah95
@Yorah95 2 года назад
@@Dimensionmaster05 and the primus did notice. that is how we got the Runesmith.
@cyberdoga5728
@cyberdoga5728 2 года назад
@@Yorah95 I will ask if the Primus did notice, how come he didn't warn everyone else about it before he did he thing and became the Runesmith.
@cyberdoga5728
@cyberdoga5728 2 года назад
@@Orthus100 Hey this guy The Jailer has repeatedly tried to escape his prison but kept failing, maybe we should keep a much closer eye on his escapades and possible communications out the outside.
@beezwax112
@beezwax112 2 года назад
Loved the vid
@GhostNappa2k10
@GhostNappa2k10 2 года назад
Within the first minute you put my back out with that AOL nostalgia. Thanks for that, I feel so old now 😅
@Randerson2409
@Randerson2409 2 года назад
One of the things I love about Jesse is that, when he is criticising someone's argument (actually criticising, not just memeing on it), he goes into teacher mode and directly focuses on the specific issue(s) in the argument, and makes note of those flaws, helping to avoid having his criticisms spill and overreach into other areas of the argument. I love it, cause I wish more people were like that, since I'm a super literal and direct-focus oriented person, so that is the best way for me to see an issue in my thinking
@NotShalune
@NotShalune 2 года назад
You can't compare the two because Derren Brown's tricks are not good ways of predicting races or to film 10 heads flipped in a row. The goal is to fool an observer about your capabilities. For this to apply to the Jailer his goal would have to be to fool someone into believing he's a genius for [whatever the fuck the plot is], not actually accomplishing [whatever the fuck the plot is]. Statistically, it's literally the least efficient way you could pursue a goal short of not trying.
@Haiyken
@Haiyken 2 года назад
The first 1 min of rambling and confusion is already worth it ! More please !
@Zakiel97
@Zakiel97 2 года назад
one tiny thing about dreadlords you struck on at 31:30 ish, we've learned in Legion that demons are just creatures that stuck around fel long enough to basically become infused by it so the writers incorporating that isn't a 9.0 thing entirely, it does touch on it. Like the eredar and felhounds and succubi, all of them were among the worlds the legion conquered and incorporated into their own, the dreadlords being creatures of the plane of death isn't more convoluted than the eredar being corrupted squid-goat-people.
@RazanaArcclaw
@RazanaArcclaw 2 года назад
This ^^^^ and actually even hinted at ealier then legion. There is no "native" demon races, as the fel was not a native power, it was one that was created, and its spreading influence corrupted worlds, converting them into demons Like the grell, the imps we see in the emerald nightmare/dream, and even the nelf starting area. they are a race on their own, that many were corrupted and turned demonic. all the demonic races were once living races that became corrupted by the power of fel into demonic beings.
@tangentkatz
@tangentkatz 2 года назад
Ngl, after watching some of Tali's livestreams it feels so weird to hear him described as positive. Enjoyed the reaction though. Also: a tik tok? When did that happen?
@toychristopher
@toychristopher 2 года назад
I agree, he isn't what I would call a positive voice either. I think Jesse meant positive in regards to Blizzard, not necessarily a positive person in general.
@Wolfstorm701
@Wolfstorm701 2 года назад
@@toychristopher That... is not what Jesse meant haha.
@yellowbeard1
@yellowbeard1 2 года назад
@@Wolfstorm701 Maybe he meant positive relative to other content creators, many of whom have already left or are making money by criticizing Blizz as harshly as possible.
@Wolfstorm701
@Wolfstorm701 2 года назад
@@yellowbeard1 That is exactly what he meant.
@ArmageddonEvil
@ArmageddonEvil 2 года назад
@@yellowbeard1 Ehh, then what about their beef with Pyromancer and calling all Content Creators TRAITORS? Ooh, yeah, Whoops. *facepalm* It's the defending Blizzard part, not the other content creators they have a beef with the part. lol
@lukewind13
@lukewind13 2 года назад
Sorry to say Jesse ive not watched your content in years, This is the first video ive seen of yours in ages and i remembered why i loved you man, Keep up the good work.
@mikkelmv3991
@mikkelmv3991 2 года назад
Happy to see more fun thoughts of yours on stuff, like wow
@Nora-rb6tr
@Nora-rb6tr 2 года назад
im so down for more Jesse Reacts
@glizzywrangler774
@glizzywrangler774 2 года назад
"The most positive beacons of positivity" Guess you're unaware of all the drama he's been in? Or him flipping at Asmongold?
@ThePhantomKingX
@ThePhantomKingX 2 года назад
Would love to see you do a reaction to the 10.0 leaks. Great vid Jesse. It's a real wake up call seeing the guy who helped get me into WoW also look at the lore and go, "This ain't it dog"
@semiramisubw4864
@semiramisubw4864 2 года назад
Jailer is such a mastermind, even Danuser dont know what hes up to!
@jakereno5891
@jakereno5891 2 года назад
Really enjoyed the reaction content from you Jesse!
@FairyTailFTW
@FairyTailFTW 2 года назад
a huge problem with the analogy used in the video is that a) magician has a clear plan with a goal and only battling probability, and b) there are way too few things that could actually destroy the arbiter and get us to the shadowlands to actually have million+ plans/attempts.
@MrElionor
@MrElionor 2 года назад
a) that would only be a problem if he has say for Blizzard planned this which it isn't Tali hates Blizzard as much as anyone but "Blizzard bad" starts to ring hollow after a while I think he was trying to give an alternative interpretation that doesn't solely rely on them being poor story tellers b) If there were of lot of things that could destroy the arbiter it wouldn't take nearly as long as it did to find it Tali hates Blizzard as much as anyone but "Blizzard bad" starts to ring hollow after a while what I think he was doing is trying to give an alternative interpretation that doesn't solely rely on them being poor story tellers
@hristopavlov298
@hristopavlov298 2 года назад
Go watch Tali's streams and see how much beacons of positivity they can be.
@Exxy6965
@Exxy6965 2 года назад
He's actually one of the most toxic content creators out there.
@hristopavlov298
@hristopavlov298 2 года назад
Bingo.
@BartvG88
@BartvG88 2 года назад
@@Exxy6965 Really? I’ve only seen his youtube videos. How is he so toxic in your opinion?
@hristopavlov298
@hristopavlov298 2 года назад
@@BartvG88 Making backhanded comments for other content creators (shared trait with his wife). Shoving political opinions (often correct imo, but at the wrong place) at his viewers and never seeing other points of view. Often assuming comments inbetween viewers and what not is directed towards him negatively. Punching down viewers (the irony) to prove his arguments, followed by banning and insulting.
@Exxy6965
@Exxy6965 2 года назад
@@BartvG88 yep you should check his Twitch sometimes. Because obviously on RU-vid he tries to be "nice". There are tons of clips of him freaking out - you should just look for it. One that comes to my mind is him openly shit talking Bellular (I'm not a fan of his clickbait video names but he's ok in general) about him being slow at going through Final Fantasy which was completely uncalled for.
@relogos
@relogos 2 года назад
At least we got a really nice visualisation of that post from this.
@theDan402
@theDan402 2 года назад
This is the kind of content I subbed for lol your reaction to this reminds me of the old podcast days
Далее
Jesse Reacts to WoW's Darkest Secret
22:58
Просмотров 145 тыс.
15 Years of WoW vs 1 Year of FFXIV
36:20
Просмотров 1,4 млн
Игровой Комп с Авито за 4500р
01:00
Thank you 3M❤️
00:14
Просмотров 899 тыс.
What If I Told You... Zovaal Is NOT The Jailer?
36:51
SimCity (SNES) - Angry Video Game Nerd (AVGN)
19:17
Просмотров 900 тыс.
The Story of The Jailer aka Zovaal [Lore]
15:28
Просмотров 184 тыс.
World of Warcraft: Was Legion as Good as I Remember?
40:33
Warcraft's STUPIDEST Dragon
29:01
Просмотров 813 тыс.