JOSH ALLEN OVERRATED? 🤔 NFL's top-10 QB list reaction & takeaways | Get Up 

why is no one questioning Burrow at #2? Man is always injured.

The Burrow hype is sickening

Burrow is riding beating Mahomes in a playoff game from.... THREE SEASONS AGO. Guess let's just ignore the constant injury risk and availability 🙄

How long is Burrow gonna keep living off that fluke win against the chiefs years ago?

Burrows QBR check that mfer out that's average with a loaded receiver core. I was surprised to see that. ESPN treats him like God

This list terrible

“Josh Allen turnovers could be the reason they cant breakthrough “ is the dumbest thing ive heard …. He rarely turns it over in the playoffs 😂 He has 2723 yards 21 TDs 4 Ints with a PR of 100

No Purdy or Hurts? This list is ridiculous.. Herbert has done nothing in this league along with Dak and I'm sorry Aaron Rodgers being on here without even completing a series last year is a joke. This list has zero credibility. Take off Herbert, Rodgers, and Dak. Replace with Purdy, Love, and Hurts.

Hurts not being on this list but Herbert is? Is crazy to me. The Herbert glaze is insane 😂

How is Dak on list at 10 not Purdy Hurts or Love

The list SHOULD have been “After Patrick Mahomes, Who Are The Top 10 QBs in The NFL?”

1 Mahomes 2 Lamar 3 Allen 4 Burrow 5 Stroud 6 Herbert 7 Purdy 8 Stafford 9 Goff 10 Hurts/Dak/Trevor/Caleb

Mahomes #1 then its a conversation for 2-10 tbh lol lets be real

Y’all stay riding Herbert when he hasn’t proven anything 😂

**Through his first six NFL seasons Allen has 71 interceptions. By comparison, Peyton Manning had 110, Dan Marino 103, John Elway 96, Brett Favre 93, Drew Brees 82, and Tom Brady 78. Those five are all in, or will be in, the Pro Football Hall of Fame.**

Brock Purdy not being on this list? Completely trash list

How is Rodgers on the list when was hurt last year? 🤨

2023 PFF Grades (the actual raw analytics, not to be conflated with the opinions and rankings of their podcasters) 10) Goff 85.7 9)Cousins 86.1 8)Hurts 86.7 7)Tua 86.9 6)Purdy 87.4 5)Stafford 88.2 4)Dak 90.0 3)Lamar 90.4 2)Mahomes 90.5 1)Allen 92.1 I'm not 100% defending their formula, but this should be the baseline for debate since it quantifies most everyone's opinions and hot takes.

Remember this list was put up by GM's, Coaches and SCOUTS! There is a clear reason to why Purdy isn't on this list.

Irrational Josh Allen hate primarily comes from folks who don’t watch the Bills. That’s a perennial 6-11, 7-10 team without him.

Aaron Rodgers and Dak? Here's the deal 1. Mahomes 2. Lamar Jackson 3. CJ Stroud 4. Josh Allen 5. Brock Purdy 6. Jared Goff 7. Jordan Love 8. Jalen Hurts 9. Joe Burrow 10. Justin Herbert

Anyone who thinks or says Allen is overrated, does not watch the Bills every week. He makes mistakes. RARELY in the Red Zone or in the playoffs. He is a Baller. He has an aggressive style. His upside FAR outweighs his mistakes. If you removed Allen from the Bills how re!event would they be? He's a better run threat than 70% of RBs. He has the most TDs in 4 years than anyone. Mahomes is 20 something behind him . Last playoffs almost beat Chiefs with practice squad defense. Some people never played football or don't understand it. It's n egregious error to say he is overrated. He is Underrated

Yo Bart really a hater on Josh like bro what are you even talking about lmaoo

BURROW is OVERRATED!!!!! He is the reason his team was last place in division last year. He can’t keep healthy ever. “Best ability is availability!”

And Purdy not being on this list is crazy

Lamar is too low

The dumbest thing about this list was that Patrick Mahomes wasn't unanimous number 1, you can make arguments for having one guy that is ranked too low to be higher or vice versa but what argument do you have to not have Mahomes number 1? I'd like to find out the person(s) who did that and their reasons.

Disrespectful to Hurts. Aaron Rodgers should be off until he proves fitness and Goff is questionable. Purdy and Tua should be on here as well.

We all agree that Mahomes is number 1 but here's the question, would you take Mahomes production on your team if it cost you a turnover a game? That's literally what Josh Allen is. No one else matches Mahomes peaks as often, no one can throw the angles, throw the same deep ball in crazy wind, has the rushing ability, can make average guys look all pro (john brown, beasley), put up 40+ TD's a season, win their division every single season, break playoff records, not get hurt, and give you a chance no matter where you play. The only difference is allen turns it over a little more than Mahomes which causes there to be a little lower floor. If you knew you had a chance at getting mahomes on your roster at 90% of what mahomes is they would take it, which is what Josh Allen is. That's why people hate on him for his turnovers cause everyone wants an MVP from him and for him to be the best but he's the only one who has a standard that is comparative to Mahomes which is why their duels are so entertaining.

Where is Brock Purdy?

Josh allen is not overrated that goes to herbert qb Jesus

Joe burrow over Lamar and Allen is crazy talk

The turnover argument holds ZERO water. Here's a quick list of turnovers for some "pretty ok" QBs of the past thru their first 6 seasons: 146 - Marino 143 - P. Manning 140 - Elway 138 - Favre 130 - JOSH ALLEN 125 - Brady

Purdy is better than 9 on the list, this list is full of want-a-be's... and only one who has proven he's elite and led all QB's in the NFL in all metrics and was not on the list... Purdy was the #1 QB in the NFL. ESPN has lost its' integrity by allowing this list to exist as is and putting it out to the media.

Lamar Jackson at 4? He’s a two time mvp lmao

Mahomes is no doubt the best. Playoffs clutch.

All the ppl that should not be there is....joe burrow Aaron Rodgers Justin Herbert etc and Jared Goff my QB SHOULD BE HIGHER 💯❤

People are blaming ESPN for this list when the analyst clearer stated that it was voted on by execs, coaches, and scouts! 🤣🤣🤣

Brock purdy not being on the list after having a hella start to his career is crazy.

Regardless of order these are the 10 QBs I’m rolling with Mahomes Burrow Lamar Allen Stroud Stafford Dak Herbert Purdy Hurts Goff/Love/Tua/Lawrence are right there Also Rodgers is Top 10 but can’t be ranked rn.

j don’t understand how you could have 2 mvps in your sport and not even be considered top 2 over people who have done less with more. would never happen in the nba

WHERE TF IS JALEN HURTS?!?! 🦅

RG3 is an excellent analyst. One of the only talking heads who isn’t full of it

This list shows why the Joe Montana's (3rd Rd.), Johnny Unitas' (11th Rd.), Tom Brady's (6th Rd.), Russell Wilson's (3rd Rd.), Dak Prescott (4th Rd.), Kurt Warner's (undrafted), Brock Purdy's (7th Rd), Tony Romo's (undrafted) and so on, happen. Because most NFL excecutives are total morons.

No Purdy after 2 NFCCGs and no Hurts after back to back 12+ win seaaon. But they can add Herbert with no success and CJ after 1 year.

I'd love to know who person is that actually picked Allen as the top QB and not Mahomes. Talk about nutty, especially if it wasn't someone from the Bills organization. I hope Purdy has another great year so these people that disrespect him can look even worse. It makes sense though for people in the league to not want to give respect to a guy that was the last player drafted since it makes them look foolish. They'd have probably done the same thing for Brady had he not won a bunch of superbowls early on.

Good grief. Joe Burrow at 2? Really? SMH. They are drunk for sure or something else.

I mean if the past 4 years mean anything. Statistically the two best QBs in the league have been Mahomes and Allen and it's not close. Whether it be regular season or playoffs. It's them two at the top.

Josh Allen and Lamar will be fighting for the number 2 spot this season if anybody can challenged Pat it’s those two

How a 2XMVP number 4 😂😂 horrible list

Three players on this list were injured for more than half the season. Another is a rookie (who played extremely well, to be fair). Another plays for the Rams, who got bounced in the Wild Card. And the other is a perennial playoff choke artist. Can I sign up to be an NFL exec because you have to have zero brain cells?

The purdy hate is outrageous

Taking Josh Allen over Patrick Mahomes is the literal definition of overrated.

Where is Jordan Love!! If CJ us going to be that high Jordan Love should be 6. Why is Herbert in the list? What big game has Herbert won? Aaron Rodgers is way too high. The last season matters. Tua should replace Aaron. These lists are not based on current situations

Keep haiting on Purdy, nothing new.

Someone who’s job it is to evaluate NFL talent would take Allen before Mahomes? No wonder there are so many bad teams out there.

Bart scott has always been a josh hater. Dudes so clueless that he cant even say james cook right

Burrow got to the Superbowl on a defensive second half shutout and they still act like it was him playing defense

The best list you will see Patrick Mahomes Joe Burrow Lamar Jackson Josh Allen Matthew Stafford Cj Stroud Justin Herbert Jalen Hurts Dak Prescott Jared Goff

I don’t get how Love, Purdy, Hurts or Tua didn’t end up on this list

I’m tired of the Lamar Jackson hate as if he’s not a 2 TIME MVP, meanwhile Josh Allen loses every playoff game

Allen led the league in total TD's and he's overrated? First two years everybody called him a bust...the hate is real

Actually compare the amount of int's Allen has say against Marino, Farve, Manning Allen has less pic's in his first 5 years than those three who are pretty well regarded and are in the HOF.

Top 5 is very good maybe minor changes but those would be the 5 I have. My 6-10 is 6 is Stroud, 7 is Purdy, 8 is Goff, 9 is Dak and 10 is Hurts. Herbert would be my 11th guy and Rodgers would be around 13-15 just want to see how he comes back this year before I put him top ten

Dak over Purdy 😂

T-Law way better than Herbert. No cap 🧢

This is definetly a list of measurable how is Herbert number 6 but hurts and purdy who both been to a Super Bowl and been way more successful than Herbert not even on the list 😑🤣

Burrow at 2 over allen and jackson is crazy

The fact that they glaze all over Josh Allen is wild. He lead the league in total yards and TDs, and always leads the league in INTs. He is just a thrower and locks onto guys he throws to. We gotta stop making excuses for guys we like. My goodness.

Crazy thing is, Purdy probably has better cerebral ability than everyone on the list other than rodgers and Stafford. Facts!

I expect joe to win mvp this year

So the qb with highest QBR and most yards per attempt and threw for most yards EVER in franchise history, AND was super bowl runner up isn't on the list? Purdy hate is reaaal

How is Josh Allen and Joe Burrow above Lamar Jackson who just won his 2nd MVP? Sounds about white

People say a lot of dumb stuff. Josh literally played perfect in the playoffs the 2021 season and the Bills lost it for him. He knows how to play winning (read nearly perfect) football

Whoever rates QBs sucks at their job, as fans rates QBs better than the media does. Media is over rated.

Scott calling Josh Allen a “stat stuffer” is such an asinine comment. He’s #2 right now and him and Mahomes are in their own class

Out of that top 5, I'd argue Allen has had the worst supporting cast of players and coaches and yet they've been pretty successful. He's definitely underrated by the majority of fans who don't watch him all the time. He literally has to turn a busted, broken play into a positive at least once a drive to keep the chains moving.

Pats fan here, Jared Goff should have been listed in the top 4

What they ignore in comparing Brett to Josh, 3 MVPs and a superbowl win...

The only 2 QBs better than Allen is the 2 in front of him on the list

The only reason Allen hasn't won 2 Superbowl is because the defense can't step up on important games

love them coming around on purdy, lots of hate and back tracking last season especially from bart lol

if your asking me to pick today im taking Allen #2 behind Mahomes. Burrow injury concerns are a real thing. Also i think Josh gets judge harder because he has so much talent. I think he is the most talented QB in the league when you combine everything. The last piece he is missing is that Mahomes just processes the game a much higher clip. But Mahomes is an all time great whose in the Goat conversation.

Dak being on ten list over Purdy is ridiculous. Were Purdy a Hyped up 1st round draft pick he’d be a undisputed elite QB.

Where is the quarterback who put up MVP number last season? Kirk Cousins

It’s Mahomes & Allen, then everyone else

Purdy being off the list is insane

Lets be honest the only reason people are over critical of turnovers now is because of DAK. 1 SEASON. Yall have to try to maintain an unbiased approach so yall talk about Allen's turnovers but it's in a much lighter tone and that's facts!

Allen, Herbert, Rodger’s and Goff all insanely overrated. None should be there. Purdy is top 5 or 6.

Overrated how? Josh is in the 2-4 range for virtually everyone. 3 is literally right in that range. I think he's fine there

Prescott could be higher on the list. NFL is loader with exceptional young talent. Rodgers barely makes the list.

The Burrow agenda is crazy and ignores that Mahomes played his absolute worst playoff game vs the Bengals in that loss. Burrow does not play defence, he did not force those picks, Burrow himself was unremarkable, just a bad game by Mahomes. Had Mahomes thrown that many interceptions vs the Bills, Ravens or 49ers this year & played that badly, they’d all have beaten him too. Burrow just the benefactor of an anomaly, he’s not uniquely impressive among his peers and certainly not a definitive top 2 QB.

Allen may not win championships but his QBR is well above the others, and his total TDs far exceed them other players

“He’s number 10 because his playoff success amd doesn’t play big in big moments” puts Lamar at 4 when he has the same record as dak with a lot worse stats in big games 💀💀💀

Rodgers and Goff over Hurts makes this list just laughable, he literally was the best player in a Super Bowl.

Allen above Lamar is wild

Knew he would immediately hate on the Herbert pick 😂😂😂

If it was me I would probably would have to rank em 1 Maholmes 2 Jackson 3 Rodgers 4 Allen 5 Burrow 6 Goff 7 Bradford 8 Stafford 9 Herbert 10 Stroud

No way burrow is higher then allen just check the stats josh allen lapped joe B in stats last year. He can not put burrow ahead of josh allen. The hate for the bills is unreal!! Josh allen is setting records every year

Always about the turnovers on Josh Allen. Why didn't anyone ever say that about Peyton Manning, Marino, Elway, Brady, Brees, Favre, Brady? Allen has more total touchdowns, about the same amount of yards but less than or the same amount of turnovers in the first 6 years