Тёмный

JW Elder's Meeting - I Refuse to Disassociate Myself- You Must DF Me! 

JWStruggle
Подписаться 10 тыс.
Просмотров 28 тыс.
50% 1

Yet another secretly recorded Judicial Committee hearing...The hero of this story is Rachel... This brave and funny Kiwi lady stands up to the local elders and goes through this scary situation with grace and logic and so much class!
Bravo to her husband who comes along to support her and her goal is to awaken and perhaps reach the hearts of these men that are poised to spiritually execute her. This goes right against the false label applied to so-called apostates by the WT Society that they are insincere, slanderous people out to hurt the faith of others.
Listen to the story unfold as Rachel boldly shares her research and her conscience with these men.
BTW RU-vid people we need help captioning this vid as time goes on so leave commnts or message me if you want to add text so this can get better and better as peeps listen to it and sort out the important dialogue.
When you find a snip you like type up:
52:28 We certainly don't JUDGE you for that (ie. for following my convictions).....
54:03 You've got to do what you've got to do
54:52 We ACCEPT and have NO TROUBLE with you doing things your way
55:01 You can HARM me
1.00:04 LOVING LESS a different matter than the strength of HATRED
1.00:39 Not a nutter.....make so much SENSE
1.15 thankyou for HONESTY and STRAIGHTFORWARDNESS
Also, here are the WT references for some of the stuff read out about what it means to be announced as no longer being one of JWs:
W 81 9/15 pp.20-26
W 93 10/1 pp.15-20
W 81 8/15 pp 25-30
W 94 7/1 pp 8-13
-------------------------
Follow me on Twitter at @JWStruggle for more breaking news in the twisted world of Watchtower!

Опубликовано:

 

4 окт 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 197   
@IamNemoN01
@IamNemoN01 5 лет назад
I love how the elders quote from their own publications to support disfellowshipping; rather than quoting from the Bible. So they’re quoting themselves as the authority.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 10 лет назад
Just had another listen to my recording and found myself in tears. I really miss these brothers.They are not the enemy. They don't realise they are taking their orders from "the evil slave". My expereince confirmed that to me beyond any doubt.
@janjikins
@janjikins 9 лет назад
I hear you. I know your pain. Remember, they can't pray for you, which if you think about it, is a good thing! However, you can keep praying for them. It's the most powerful thing you can do. Hang in there. I felt the pain of losing 200+ of my "friends and family" all in one evening. And it hurt for over 30+ years. I still miss them, but now, I mostly pity them. And I continue to pray for them all, as I wish enlightenment for all souls.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 9 лет назад
***** Thanks for your kind words. I am sorry for your loss. It seems absurd that the special talk following this years memorial commemoration is entitled "A Promise of Perfect Family Happiness". How can an organisation that goes to efforts to literally destroy families be so insensitive as to give such a talk. I really think the majority of JWs just do not think. Their senses have been dulled. Thanks for the reminder about prayer.
@janjikins
@janjikins 9 лет назад
You are so welcome. The important thing is to come to peace with it. I have, and it appears you have also. Peace be with you, always, janjikins.
@stevebenoit6649
@stevebenoit6649 6 лет назад
Rupunzelsawake I have not listen yet , but am about to. The one common denominator in these videos is after leaving, can we still uplift Jehovah's sovereignty and glory and acceptance of just how much Jehovah and Jesus Christ did for us. Occasionally Jehovah let me know he is still with me. And didn't Jesus say that the only way to the Almighty Father was Jesus. so we don't need any man or pope or governing body. I wish to ask everyone who has had a nasty experience with the Jehovah's witnesses to not turn our back on the Almighty Father and the only begotten son. It hurts to be set apart from family and friends! So why hurt Jehovah and Jesus. We are set apart and born in this day for a reason.. All is needed is trust in the Almighty Father not any man made system. Also as an ex jw, I really suggest looking into the scriptures on the cosmoslogy of the earth. and comparison of different translations is necessary because I have found that the new world translation is whittling away from the truth. The governing body has not received holy Spirit to discern the global earth lie. I found five scriptures that says that the earth doesn't move. So that totally blows the heliocintric universe theory. And yes I believe from my extensive research that we live on a flat Earth. Did you know that there is around two hundred scriptures on the cosmoslogy of the earth. One of my favorite is Job 38:14. I believe that Jehovah knew about the global earth lie and put many scriptures in his written word. Yet this is unimportant to the Jehovah's witnesses, members and the governing body. Best wishes to you and be blessed.
@phildouglas9086
@phildouglas9086 6 лет назад
steve benoit I hear you. FE and the bible. Everything is being revealed.
@kimsilvio
@kimsilvio 5 лет назад
I have never listened to a more reasonable, knowledgeable and balanced reasoning !!! You didn’t miss a single point and I’m sure if any of those elders had doubts then you fed their doubt - thank you for sharing xx
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
I know what you mean evie! The laughing elder said I made so much sense and that I had to do what I had to do. He said from their point of view they had to follow 1 Cor 1:10.."we have this IDEA and you have other IDEAS". So, we can be put out of the "club" because of our IDEAS. This elder on a previous visit compared the organisation to a club, with club "rules". Exactly!
@RiaCottingham
@RiaCottingham 6 лет назад
Wow, this was so moving. You held your own so, so well. It made me cry when u mentioned all the people who have left and are being shunned by family members. I can relate completely, being shunned by my father and sister, who also have nothing to do with my two children. It’s heartbreaking!!! It’s so wrong and it’s, as u said, NOT SCRIPTURAL at all!! Well done, hugs 🤗
@meleepinata
@meleepinata 11 лет назад
They are intrepid in how they mold your thinking. Love is the antithesis of their reasoning. It is anything but unconditional. They are unapologetic how they hand down judgement. They are unreasonable yet consider themselves infallible.
@ravenrisby
@ravenrisby 4 года назад
Leaving one cult to jump into another without looking inside yourself and look at the stars as above so below 🤟🏻
@observerlink4124
@observerlink4124 10 лет назад
Excellent! These Judicial Committee examples of sham justice need to be recorded and published so that everyone can get the true story of what really happens!
@Sittingstraight12
@Sittingstraight12 11 лет назад
The caption on this vid, since she hid her recorder in her boot...remember the song " these boots were made for walking " She walked right on out with pride!!!!!
@vera747
@vera747 10 лет назад
A thinking and critical mind destroys all watchtower lies,,,gr8 points
@akeemx9207
@akeemx9207 9 лет назад
So true.
@janjikins
@janjikins 9 лет назад
A truly loving heart can do the same thing. No one who really knows love, could ever display such hatefulness.
@akeemx9207
@akeemx9207 9 лет назад
***** not true.
@gataheart
@gataheart 5 лет назад
There are apostates and THERE ARE APOSTATES! Get my drift Vera? Go to Hollywood and ACT! You should be ashamed of yourself. That antiGod, antiBible book you're hawking IS straight from the Devil. SOMETIMES the elders do Get it Right.
@shannonwrighttreesandbutte390
@shannonwrighttreesandbutte390 6 лет назад
I cant get over how loving your elders are in your congregation...but your hard person not too love!!!! Thanks again Rachel!!
@andreabergin3959
@andreabergin3959 5 лет назад
Rachel, I just love your spirit. I don't think your committee members could possibly have been blind to your Christian heart. And I know from personal experience, what joy it is not to just sneak out of the org. with head down. I was disfellowshipped for having come to follow Christ in 1974, and from the time I was born again until then was some 6 months. During that time, I continued to pioneer in NY, most of my elders being Bethelites. I gladly went door-to-door with the true gospel of Jesus, shared with the householder AND whoever my partner for the day was. I gladly continued to give talks in the Ministry School, this time having Jesus as the central feature of the message. IT WAS GRAND! I would be so interested to hear a bit of an update from you. Do you have other posts online? Thank you so much for sharing.
@zeldagoblin
@zeldagoblin 4 года назад
This was very eye opening to say the least. I've never seen kindness from elders like this. Our elders in my area wouldn't have let you speak frankly, and the meeting would be over in 15 minutes.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 4 года назад
It certainly was very weird. The kindly soft spoken elder died in November 2013. I think he was in denial about the harsh cruelty of the organisation and made a ton of excuses for it. That bugged me. The other two I just saw in the bank the other day. I'm invisible to them and I am quite sure there is no love lost on me. They probably have a great deal of contempt for me due to my speaking out publicly about WT abuses. Of course I could be wrong.
@fenostalgicmanrooster4898
@fenostalgicmanrooster4898 Год назад
@@Rupunzelsawake
@Sittingstraight12
@Sittingstraight12 11 лет назад
What an awesome video! Rachel you did a great job! Don't beat yourself up! It took courage and knowledge on what to say, you made good points! ESP. For young ones who get bap. And then DF'ed. And then they get shunned ! Where are these young ones to go? Can't associate with wit. Kids, and can't have "worldly" friends.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 10 лет назад
It's nearly seven months since this recorded meeting. Sadly, the nice quiet spoken elder passed away almost two weeks ago, which shocked everybody. I attended the funeral at the KH. In a way it is a blessing he won't see the demise of the organisation he was so dedicated to. It was his life. I guess when ones such as him, have given their whole life to serve the organisation, making many sacrifices, they have to believe it is right. To think otherwise would be too painful. Anyway, this dear man will be sorely missed.
@irrationalgeographic9953
@irrationalgeographic9953 10 лет назад
I congratulate you Rachel, with what you have done and to take a stand then to share with others I'm sure is greatly appreciated by those who are JWs, Ex JWs, and non JWs. I would be interested in discussing your experiences with the organization further for a upcoming thesis and book which I am writing. If you are interested please contact me and I will give you my email address. Once again well done you, fantastic work.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 10 лет назад
CSCI Trust Thankyou. I messaged you via youtube!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Thanks ohnjay72! Your appreciation is appreciated!
@observerlink4124
@observerlink4124 11 лет назад
I was very impressed with the way you presented your case to the judicial committee. It was well thought out and articulated. And your request to be deliberately D.F.'d in order to be able to empathize with those who've been through this cruel process was I thought one of the bravest things I have heard. You are a very special person. You are a very brave person. You've stood up to this highly flawed, inhumane policy. You've given a dignity to D.F.'d status! That's GREAT! You're a hero!!
@ohnjay72
@ohnjay72 11 лет назад
Awesome job!!! Thank you for doing this.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Thankyou again! I told my husband he is a "class act"! I agree! Although not considering himself Christian, he has been wonderfully supportive of me...and always has been. It's his birthday today....so your comment was a welcome gift!
@LaJeanaD
@LaJeanaD 10 лет назад
They sounded friendlier towards the end! They must know TTATT, but are captives to the concept!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
I was completely flabbergasted by their flippancy! I should have taken chips and dip, and cup-cakes. Mind you, they are not used to this particular situation.....It may have been their first.
@kathleenholland6988
@kathleenholland6988 7 лет назад
Deserting the Worship of God but they are the ones who go against the scriptural command of love and mercy? Wow!!!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Thanks runnerboy. I do genuinely love these brothers and enjoy their company. I had two meetings with two of them prior to the JH, and they were relaxed and enjoyable occasions. Which completely bamboozled me! I really don't think they believed things would end this way...but the rule book won in the end.
@GG-kv8vv
@GG-kv8vv 5 лет назад
No words, lol, TONS OF WORDS
@Mx25618
@Mx25618 11 лет назад
I think this video could benefit from captions. It's very difficult to understand.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 10 лет назад
Thankyou c rhynehardt, and steve rose!
@mega4s1000
@mega4s1000 11 лет назад
Rachel, if you're ever in Wellington and want to have a coffee with a fellow apostate, or make contact via facebook, my name is Meg Larken.
@observerlink4124
@observerlink4124 9 лет назад
I appreciate this lady's courage. I think if it were me, I would have told the 'elders', at that moment where they said that they were going to announce the disfellowshipping the following week, that I was going to call up and tell the most busy-body sisters in the congregation as soon as I left the judicial committee meeting that I was going to be disfellowshipped, and I'd tell them to tell everybody they knew to spread the word as soon as possible. I will say this, this recording sounded like one of the most jovial judicial committee meetings I've ever heard. Most Jehovah's Witness elders are good guys, but when it comes to the Watchtower Society, they're little puppets.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 9 лет назад
Observer Link Thanks for commenting again!! All my visits with the elders were friendly. I really fit the description of an angry, bitter, proud apostate don't I? You could tell they were terrified of me. Two even hugged me at the end of my JC meeting. They warmly greeted me at the start of the meeting where my "announcement" was made. Then the "love switch" was turned to "off"! Just like that. I genuinely like those brothers. On the morning of the meeting I left letters with members of the congregation, at least with those whose addresses I knew. This is what I wrote: Dear Brothers and sisters I am writing this to give advance notice that at tonight’s meeting it will be announced that I have been disfellowshipped. I have no ill feeling towards any of you. In fact I care about you all and will miss you. I speak for (my daughter) also. I cannot remain in the congregation because my conscience will not permit me to accept and teach things I do not believe. Like many of you here I do not believe that only Jehovah’s Witnesses will be saved at Armageddon, and I cannot pre-judge all the individual members of Christendom. I love people and believe in justice for all of them. I also believe in Christian freedom, the right to follow one’s Bible trained conscience without fear of punishment. This is not possible in our organisation, though it should be. Our publications state that as dedicated servants of Jehovah, we do have freedom to exercise our conscience, but in reality we must follow the dictates of the Governing body. See WT98 3/15 article “Living Up to Christian Dedication in Freedom” Par 4,5. For many of you this poses no problem, but for me it does. Please understand that. I know this will come as a shock to you who know me. As you know, I am not a “wrong-doer”, nor am I an apostate. I have a very strong faith in Jehovah and in his Son Jesus. This will not change. Please be assured of that. The elders dealing with me have been very kind, patient, and respectful. They are only following the policies of our organisation. I realise this means I will be shunned, which I believe to be both unjust and unscriptural, and I will be very hurt by it. However, I hold no resentment, and you all will be in my prayers. Much warm, Christian love,
@observerlink4124
@observerlink4124 9 лет назад
Rupunzelsawake Beautiful job, Rupunzelawake! Your parting letter does you credit. It's honest, not at all bitter or vindictive, it's a message of love and caring, and It sets your record straight, so that there's an accurate account, YOUR own account, to refer to in the event false stories get circulated as to why you were DF'd! Again, I applaud you and your beautiful spirit. You are a lady of class!
@forevermoor8902
@forevermoor8902 6 лет назад
Rupunzelsawake Your love and restraint are insurmountable whilst being face to face with 'nice' puppets.
@esthermarygold-lowe4403
@esthermarygold-lowe4403 8 лет назад
wow. what a courageous woman.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Yes, CRAZY isn't it. I wonder if the GB still applies the 2/3 majority rule when deciding on changes to teachings and policies. If they don't all agree, then which ones are actually "apostate"? Yet we, the rank and filel cannot voice disagreement!! Two sets of scales!
@Jwhelpisontheway
@Jwhelpisontheway 11 лет назад
Fabulous job sister Rachel. They couldn't rebuke your reasonings and objections. It's sad that the governing body can change doctrines constantly , yet if we disagree with those changes we are kicked out. If we say a teaching is wrong we are kicked out, yet when the governing body changes that teaching after we are kicked out we are not automatically reinstated. It's a cult and I feel sorry for the lost souls that are lost to the watchtower publishing cult.
@observerlink4124
@observerlink4124 11 лет назад
You are both wonderful & beautiful people! Keep up your love dear ones!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
@47:26 One elder says there are people in the world who are very, very moral, who follow the ten commandments, but they don't worship Jehovah, who have no want to worship Jehovah, and are "quite happy with what they are". It seems this brother has psychic abilities. What an example of Pharisaical judgment.
@meleepinata
@meleepinata 11 лет назад
I could disassociate myself but I care too much about my family still being eaten by the machine. If I commit hari-kari by WT standards, its going to make it more difficult for me to reach them and pull them from the backward programming. Why would I give a company the upper hand?
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 10 лет назад
Today it is exactly one year since this meeting. I feel a little sad, but no regrets at all. Of course, I am reminded of the elder that died earlier this year and that saddens my heart too. To "mark the occasion" I wrote a letter to him.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Thankyou so much Observer Link for your kind comments! At the time I felt it was the bravest thing I've done thus far in my life. I have no regrets. I wear my df'd status like a "badge of honour"! I wrote to a member of the JC later saying how appalled my husband was by the elders comment about wanting to get home to watch the rugby. What business did they have laughing with, and hugging, someone they've just judged as an apostate? Very surreal!
@observerlink4124
@observerlink4124 11 лет назад
It does amaze me how the elders seem to laugh in many of these proceedings. I think that maybe they're nervous & stressed & this is maybe their release to some degree? Still, this just seems so odd when you consider that from their standpoint, the person they're D.F.'ing is as good as dead until they repent and perform all the 'penance' measures they dictate in order to return. So, it's quite odd to imagine a judge laughing as he pronounces a death sentence. True Christians here? Not at all.
@observerlink4124
@observerlink4124 11 лет назад
Your demeanor was exemplary, respectful, most reasonable AND inspiring! The courage and love which you displayed was quite evident and very much in contrast to 'the Judicial Committee'! I hope you'll continue to wear your 'Scarlet Letter' with the upmost pride lady! You and your husband are 'class acts'! Never doubt it! You GO girl! Best to you both!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
A very good point Barbara! Thankyou.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Thanks LightFly for your positive comments. The whole experience was surreal, what with all the laughing. Two elders hugged me before departing,,,,but hang on, I'm a disgusting poisonous apostate!! They are supposed to loathe me. What internal conflict must go on in their minds. I feel sorry for them. I am free, they are not!
@mega4s1000
@mega4s1000 11 лет назад
Kia ora Rachel and Mellee. I'm also a kiwi, out of the borg for over 10 years now but follow the latest developments. I became 'inactive' deliberately, although now known as an apostate, the elders haven't followed up. I wouldn't disassociate because that would be playing their silly game! If called to a judicial, I would attend, like Rachel, to hopefully plant seeds of doubt in the minds of the elders. Congratulations on getting out!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Hi Mr37257. Thanks. I'm out about six weeks now. No regrets. What you say about friendship being conditional is so true. If you become inactive for any reason, your friends seem to evaporate. I think it's due to self-righteousness and fear. I was missing from meetings about 12 weeks before anyone phoned, and that was despite a health condition. So much for love being the identifying mark of "true Christians"!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
It was funny that when I asked why they needed it, the three of them in unison said "Because it identifies you as one of JWs" As if I would flash it out and about town....to get free coffees perhaps? Um.
@tsi4service
@tsi4service 11 лет назад
They wanted her blood card back? That must be a new procedure? It's not in the elders book so maybe their own little idea perhaps.
@MrsBarbaraSinclair
@MrsBarbaraSinclair 11 лет назад
@ 0:53:00, the JWElders read = nw 1Cor.1:10 "Now I exhort ​YOU, brothers, through the name of our Lord Jesus Christ that ​YOU​ should all speak in agreement, and that there should not be divisions among ​YOU, but that ​YOU​ may be fitly united in the same mind and in the same line of thought." With the eternal hierarchy of a divided house consisting of upper and lower two class system of things: it is UTTERLY IMPOSSIBLE for any JW in WTS religious organization to obey that biblical commandment.
@brandybeckydoc
@brandybeckydoc 8 лет назад
I know this is an old video, but very very telling of how JW's really are..
@shannonwrighttreesandbutte390
@shannonwrighttreesandbutte390 6 лет назад
GREAT JOB SIS!!! I LOVE ALL YOUR WONDERFUL POINTS!!!!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 6 лет назад
Sam Adams Thanks so much! Have you checked out my videos?
@shannonwrighttreesandbutte390
@shannonwrighttreesandbutte390 6 лет назад
Rupunzelsawake I have I think you do a great job of exposing this terrible cult! I am disfellowshipped ...but you are truly undeserving!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Thanks Rhamsody Phage! It's so weird how friendly they were with me toward the end, even though I am now officially "Satan's helper in his evil kitchen" (ie. an apostate according to WT ) They evidently do not believe this but they are perfectly happy for other congregation members to view me this way! It is so unjust and makes me sick!
@sjbobkins3820
@sjbobkins3820 10 лет назад
I don't mean to hurt anyone's feelings but isn't the strict observance of rocky tack rules Pharisee stiff? Not getting an education not being allowed to go as far as you can in a sport you love, not being able to socialize with non JW friends. Too much. Rupun...., you had control of this letting, you know what you're talking about
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 10 лет назад
SJ Bobkins Sorry, I don't quite understand all your comment, but thanks anyway! JWs are discouraged (not forbidden) from sports, hobbies and higher education, anything that can encroach on their time for attending JW meetings, and going out preaching. Each month they are required to turn in a report of their preaching activity and placements of Watchtower literature. Many JWs will hide their hobbies or downplay how much time they spend at them to avoid criticism. JWs tend to be highly judgmental because of the Pharisaic nature of the religion. Many JWs get depressed because of not being able to do things they enjoy, and to talk about them freely. Close association with non-JWs is a no-no! Some are very strict about it, others do it anyway, but away from prying eyes of fellow JWs. (Yet more judgment and critism) Thankyou so much for your interest!!
@sjbobkins3820
@sjbobkins3820 10 лет назад
SJ Bobkins I hate when they mess up my words
@shadegat3996
@shadegat3996 10 лет назад
Rupunzelsawake I thought they frowned upon dedication to secular interests due to the connection with the system which is controlled by Satan? I mean, you can not serve two masters, right? That the more you give to "Him" the more he wants? When you say "Criticism" do you mean reproof ? The theme i am seeing throughout watching these is: "I no longer believe that, but i do believe that" and "Well I THINK that particular scripture means this" and "I accept you are right about that but you're not right about Jesus' words in such and such verse " "I think this scripture is saying this" Seems to me they just established their own religion! These people are even organised in doing this. Sounds like they become the very embodiment of that which they have rejected. And so history tells the same story over again. The Church "Remove" those within it for the same reasons and once used to sentence them to death in some cases. The did not just burn Witches :)
@Justice4vr
@Justice4vr 10 лет назад
"Yet more judgment and criticism" while you criticize and judge them huh Rachel? you think youre free, but you're in bondage. I mean what do you think bondage to Satan feels like, heavy and difficult? Of course not. You feel freedom from the tough life of a true Christian. Id love to hear about your new found "truth"... shoot.
@MelissaBrownapt215
@MelissaBrownapt215 6 лет назад
I wished she had more examples of the wrongs that the society has wronged others, like those jailed for miliitary reasons, the suicides, but toward the end she really nailed it with the children and harshness of the organization and indifference.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 6 лет назад
Apt215 Melissa Brown HI! I don't think I knew about the military stuff ....although I do remember speaking with one of the elders prior to my JC meeting about Malawi and Mexico. He had never heard of it....even though he was 70 and spent his whole life as a JW. I did mention suicides in the meeting. Prior to this meeting I had sent letters to all the elders in my congregation outlining some of my concerns, but we didn't talk much about them at this meeting.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Hi Mellee. Thanks for your comments. You must absolutely do what is the right thing for you. Your family are important...You are out mentally...no need to commit hare-kari! Hopefully you won't have to wait too long before this organisation gets exposed to the world for it's abuses. When it does you can be there for your family to pick up the pieces. As we say in NZ, "Kia kaha" (Be strong!)
@MelissaBrownapt215
@MelissaBrownapt215 6 лет назад
Wow. That ended on an upnote. I cannot believe it. I wonder if she continued going for real. This was so unique. Those brothers didnt seem hostile as others have heard.
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 6 лет назад
Apt215 Melissa Brown HI! I did go for a few weeks. The brothers were not at all hostile. One was quite jovial. ..like the laughing policeman. Another was a bit defensive. Two hugged me...THE EVIL APOSTATE. ...when I left the JC meeting.
@alamo11
@alamo11 10 лет назад
two things that come to my mind 1. the holy spirit is not and can not be bound or restricted to any earthly organisation or association 2. the jw quotation on "Christian fruit". Normally we talk about "the fruit of the Spirit" Does this highlight the understanding that they do not have the Holy Spirit ?
@TheKatmckenzie
@TheKatmckenzie 10 лет назад
There is no religion in heaven! There is one God and spirituality. On judgement day you stand alone before God. There is no need for a congregation, God is fully capable.
@TheFunkytrapper
@TheFunkytrapper 10 лет назад
And that's why they shun so they can have a hold on people that would loose there family and friends it is cruel practice It is a screwed up organisation
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Good one!! I should have thought of that. I could have had that song playing as I exited! Or I could have sung it.
@connormusic9274
@connormusic9274 Год назад
What I could make out was good sister! But I don’t speak Australian and couldn’t make out what the elders were saying most of the time! Not your fault! Thanks
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Thanks BELTED007. Don't know why your comment came up "flagged as spam". That's why I missed it earlier! The outside certainly is a happier place. The "laughing elder" called it "no mans land" on an earlier visit. Sounds good to me...very liberating!!
@meleepinata
@meleepinata 11 лет назад
I had left for personal reasons and a general feeling of uneasiness and knowing my questions would end with dire results. I was approached by the PO of my hall 3 years later at Walmart. He asked what was going on. He gave me a biz card, not his number casually. It was for a financial institution. Yeah that's not weird. That furthered my research. I don't think ill be going back after the wealth of info I've found along with all my damage and suffering in this insidious organization.
@MrsBarbaraSinclair
@MrsBarbaraSinclair 11 лет назад
@ 1:08:00, they bring up 2Tim2:15-19 of Hymenaeus and Philetus, who deviated from the truth, saying that the resurrection has already occurred; and they are subverting the faith of some. Fact is: the WTS religious organization ARE as Hymenaeus and Philetus, for they teach that the resurrection has already occurred for some of the 144,000 to a glorious place in the spirit realm, and these very ones "may be involved in the communicating of divine truths today." [Rev Climax bk p.124-125, pr16-18]
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Another excellent point! Just like how Russell helped with the writing of "The Finished Mystery" posthumously, from heaven, eh? That really was "divine truth" wasn't it!!
@runnerboy36
@runnerboy36 11 лет назад
I'm really impressed with how loving you were to them and I have no doubt you at least made them think. I'm wondering if the reason they were so non-chalant is because deep down they felt bad for what they were doing and were trying to keep it 'light', at least to an extent.
@Lisa-xp4xl
@Lisa-xp4xl 5 лет назад
Well done they are delusional
@sjbobkins3820
@sjbobkins3820 10 лет назад
Tough lady with a bubby bright voice. Not having been a JW its shocking that one would put up with this control but I do get it, the shunning is terrible and the you can only avoid death by being a JW doing all the right stuff
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
That's a good suggestion LightFly. I wonder if JJ could take it up?
@kdrazalotg-usa6345
@kdrazalotg-usa6345 10 месяцев назад
WOW!THAT WAS THE FUNNEST JUDICIAL I EVER HEARD! :) I HOPE YOUR BUMPED HEAD DIDN'T GET A LUMP THOUGH@
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 11 лет назад
Hi Meg! I saw your name at the AAWA site and thought "Do I know her?" I hope so!! Did our husbands work together? I would love to have coffee. I don't have facebook yet but will get my daughter to help me! Congratulations on getting out!
@justinthyme3396
@justinthyme3396 4 года назад
Just become TOTALLY inactive, I've known some who've been inactive for 20years or so, and are not shunned by family and friends, best way out.
@rhdtv2002
@rhdtv2002 4 года назад
Nah .I left as an inactive 30 plus and have been shunned by my family
@robertaltergott3341
@robertaltergott3341 Год назад
Me too 1989. Have 2 sisters and a brother who I have zero contact with. I feel sad for them.
@fenostalgicmanrooster4898
@fenostalgicmanrooster4898 Год назад
The problem was. you made a very affirmative things. May with a diferent words and phrase construction, you could not being DF. Of if you had DF, you could appeal in a good position. Instead say "the WT have X problens" you could say "my belive that this issue being a not heavy problem today, is weacker than i was some year ago....". This kind of structure maybe not give what they want from you. 50:00 at some point you will say "id belive that the JW are the only channel". Was in this moment, that i knew .you got DF.
@dianesicgala4310
@dianesicgala4310 7 лет назад
Still cannot understand why she did not disassociate. That what I did. The outcome is the same everyone still shuns you.
@roger767
@roger767 10 лет назад
by JW logic a man who grows up on a deserted island and never breaks the 10 commandments but never heard of Jehovah will burn in hell.
@RitaMalikfour
@RitaMalikfour 6 лет назад
Roger Schooneveld no, that’s not taught , if a person is of good heart his knowledge of Jehovah dosnt matter , his heart condition is what’s important
@SCD4
@SCD4 10 лет назад
Then leave. They are not going to change.
@Rhamsody
@Rhamsody 11 лет назад
You did WELL sister. It blows my mind how many people come forward with documented verifiable evidence of impropriety, and yet they still rationalize it away. I just don't get it. It was also bizarre how after you stated your intentions, the mood changed to an almost jovial one. As if a big part of their job had already been done for them...wow...
@BJBFOREST
@BJBFOREST 5 лет назад
Oh my , they talk about Satan, angels as if they are true......no wonder they live their life in turmoil.
@rosefern743
@rosefern743 10 лет назад
Good job Rachel! I see one of your critics, shadegat3, has uploaded questionable material to his You Tube channel un-befitting of a christian. Perhaps the elders should have word with him about pornography. Three months baptized and off to a bad start!
@Rupunzelsawake
@Rupunzelsawake 10 лет назад
Thankyou! Mmmm.I wondered if/when someone else would mention that. Judging by the frequency of talks given about pornography (at least the last few years I was a JW) it is a big problem in the organisation. That along with immorality in general. As I mentioned in my recording I would wonder who the audience was that needed to hear the same talk over and over. Now I see it as evidence of God's spirit being missing....generally speaking. (A lack of "fruitage of the spirit") They can't promote the organisation as one that "completely abides by God's moral standards" (as their literature has done....and I BELIEVED it) when they clearly don't!! Ray Franz made a good comment in one of his books. He said that it is like a prime minister (or president) of a country stating that his country has NO crime, because they lock criminals away in prison. I thought it was a good analogy.
@iamfemaleone
@iamfemaleone 8 лет назад
You should have just faded away and not have even allowed them to bring you into a judicial meeting.
@naytchh7
@naytchh7 7 лет назад
Bro. Terrence O'Brien, is that you?
@iamfemaleone
@iamfemaleone 7 лет назад
NO I am FEMALE not a Male and NOT him. Don't even know him.
@chevyjerry2507
@chevyjerry2507 8 лет назад
question? If I leave any other church that believes in Jesus am I an apostate if i become a JW? answer is yes.. If you leave a cult are you an apostate? NO... they are not a religion they are a ocult. The definition of an ocult is a belief in god or a religion which is not of normal Christianity.. a strange view of a religion...
@Thelmajeanne
@Thelmajeanne 8 лет назад
So, in reality, people who have left Jehovah's Organization are not truly apostates. They have simply decided to save themselves from being duped any longer. The true apostate is Jehovah's Organization who is misleading the entire inhabited earth to believe their pyramid scheme and contribute to their world empire of money grabbing !! !
@chevyjerry2507
@chevyjerry2507 8 лет назад
:) yes
@warriorprince4890
@warriorprince4890 9 лет назад
If people want the devil's world they are free to turn away from Jehovah. I have no idea why they cannot move on. I thought the world was such an amazing place.
@JWStruggle
@JWStruggle 9 лет назад
Warrior Prince Black and white thinking is the hallmark of a closed mind. Do you mean to imply that anyone that doesn't believe the exact same brand of Christianity as you is turning away from God? Can you read hearts? Is it your job to judge others? Or is it Christ's job? (John 5:22,23) Over one hundred thousand Jehovah's Witnesses each year are thrown away and shunned by their family and friends. Many turn to drugs or alcohol to dull the pain of this ostracism. A percentage commit suicide as the despair is so great. These human-rights violations should be stopped, and several governments and other groups are putting pressure on your slave master leaders to halt this barbaric practice. Soon I suspect the governing body will receive "new light" and the punitive practice will cease. Is this something that you feel is a good and healthy thing? The more folks that learn about the damaging practices and arrogant beliefs of Jehovah's Witnesses the better. This way people can make an informed decision before joining the cult run by the billion-dollar corporation called Watchtower Bible and Tract Society. I do agree with you on one thing- the world IS an amazing place, filled with amazing and great people. Instead of trying to segment and elevate yourselves, why not work with the rest of society to make the world a better place? How many times have you called a person that didn't want to buy your brand of religion "a goat" or "a pagan"? All of us that used to go canvasing and door knocking for the Watchtower have done this. I doubt you are an exception as your words indicate bigoted thought processes that have been indoctrinated well by your masters in New York.
@warriorprince4890
@warriorprince4890 9 лет назад
No evidence of shunning, and as I say move on. Quit telling lies about JW. JW have shown we are God's humble children, it is too late in the day to pretend otherwise. Again, move on.
@JWStruggle
@JWStruggle 9 лет назад
Warrior Prince Since this is MY RU-vid channel, coming onto it and telling me to "move on" is a bit silly woudn't you say? As for evidence of shunning, how much do you want? Jehovah's Witnesses are known globally for shunning those that that are kicked out. They even have their own special word for it called "disfellowship". Duhhh!
@warriorprince4890
@warriorprince4890 9 лет назад
JWStruggle Disfellowshipping does not mean shunning.
@BenAnder83
@BenAnder83 9 лет назад
I don't know if you are a JW. But if you are why are you using a character, the prince of persia, from a game that clearly is demonic?
Далее
A second JW Elder speaks out!  part 1
30:21
Просмотров 31 тыс.
Living life on the edge 😳 #wrc
00:17
Просмотров 5 млн
The Watchtower: Roots, Shoots, and Those in Cahoots
1:14:23
My JW Indoctrination and Waking Up
59:34
Просмотров 3,4 тыс.
Interview- "My mother had an affair with an elder!"
56:40