Rare interview of Jyoti Basu in 1970 regarding maoist revolutionaries, known as Naxalites, was causing increasing concern in several Indian states. Footage: Collected #JyotiBasu #Interview #Rare #Old #1970
The last Bengali statesman . Indira Gandhi , then PM did not give permission to WB Govt. to set up electronic complex in Saltlake in 1982 showing reason that WB is a border state . Permission was given to Karnataka govt . After license Act of central govt. was withdrawn in 1992 , Saltlake electronic complex was set up . This is the painful history of Bengal . Mr. Basu led Bengal to a food surplus state , non-loadsheding state . In 1970's , in our boyhood we did not get rice , wheat . Wu had to take milo , bhutta . We used to read near a kerosin haricane lamp !! This was WB when Mr. Basu took charge as CM of Bengal . We cannot forget these .
And that's the reason for their individual downfall. Ideology strengthens and unites a political party. . These two parties gave up their ideologies and ruined themselves as also the people on the fringes who believed in.them.
I request everyone to think for a moment before commenting anything about him. Many of you don't know about the post independence Bengal, a state that was butchered so that Nehru and Jinnah could be Prime Ministers. Many of you will only know him the way concubine Bengali media brainwashed you into. Most have three things to say, he stopped computers, lifted English, and ruined factories. But then how come Saltlake IT hub was made, how come poor people studying from free Bengali medium public schools of those time cracked IIT and AIIMS? Does any other state had such a cheap cost of living or transportation system? If all factories were closed, then why half of the labour population of UP, Bihar and Orissa used to migrate to Bengal? It's easy easy to post a hate comment here which doesn't verify the credentials? I can understand that you hated him because you were taught to, and you voted against him. He's dead now. Please don't spit on him. It's because of people like you, people like me are leaving Bengal. You now have the government you always wanted, so be happy about it. If you're truly happy you won't feel the urge to libel someone who might be a messiah for some.
@@pratippaul6583 I don't expect civilized debate from Bijemul, who prefer to vandalize Bidhan Sabha. You are right, I'm wrong. And there's a saying in Bengali, Dhormer kol batashe nore. The working class of labourers, farmers, and lower middle class are now realising what mistake they have done. Go and talk with a 80 year old farmer in rural Bengal, ask them who brought schools, colleges, electricity, land laws, you'll not feel the urge to debate with a terrorist like me. I mean aren't we commies terrorists to you? Sotti kotha bolbo Bhai, Ami nije daktar, general quota te MD obdhi esechi, kintu aj tomader moton manuser jnno aj Bangla chere amae Bihar e ese MD korte hocche, ar Bihar sorkar momtar double Maine dei, kintu maer theke dur. Tau bolchi, amae galagali dao, ja icche bolo, oi iswar tullo manus take kichu bolo na, uni na thakle, amar babara na kheye peye mara jeten, Tai tomar pae porchi, onake gal dio na. Amra iswar e biswas korina, kintu Jodi oi sthan e kauke bosai, take opoman Koro na, tomar pae pori.
@@rathindraislam5809 I still can't understand why you have judged me as someone who will say that you are a terrorist won't have a civilised debate? For starters, I am an advocate and i am very much aware of the consequences if I say or indulge in this mudslinging. Now tell me how many industries the left front govt destroyed in those 34 years of reign? dada thik bolechen dhormoee kol batase nore noyto "amra 230 ora 35" theke 0(a big and a significant number i must say) te ase na. Ebar bolun to land reforms act, 1984 keno abolished kore deoa holo? Thanks to your beloved left front govt r বিজেমূল তত্ত্ব diye koto din nije der vul gulo ke justified korben? keno bolun to manus eto din mane 2011 saal theke eto durniti dekhar poreo apnader ke phiriye niye asche na ba bikolpo bhabche na? eai apnara rai bolten na"Congress er kalo haat bhenge dao guriye dao" ta sei songothon er eto kharap obostha je sesh obdhi sei congress er sathei jot ta toiri korte holo? r ekta kothar uttor din to kobe Communist Party Of India bolte gorbo bodh korben jara kina China ba USSR(now Russia) eder ke anusoron na kore nije der bhanbna chinta gulo proyog korbe? Uttar thakle din noyto 2011 theke ja cholche 2026 e eso sei eak i ghotona desh ebong rajjoy er manus dekhbe ekta kotha janben amra ekta gonotontra deshe bas kori jekhane sorkar ke prosno kora er jonno ekta soktisali birodhi pokkho er khub proyojon seta na amader deshe ache na amader rajjo te ache
R apni j "iswar tullo" manus er kotha bolchen tini morichjhapi, bijon setu ebong aro na na ghotona er sathe sorasori ba porokkho bhabe jukto seta ki janen naki bhakto bole ondho hoye giye setao matha theke ber hoye gache? sei sob loke der poribar er kache jan dada jara nije der swami ba baba ba chele ba vai ke hariyeche apnar eai "iswar tullo" manus ti er jonno
@@pratippaul6583 Ami apnar sob prosner uttor dite pari, debo na karon ami uttor dileo, ar jodi bamfront sonar lonkao toiri korten, bamfront kharap hoto, keno bamponthi manei kharap, terrorist, anti social. Tai Apnader sathe torko kora ar sewage tank e pora ek. Ekhono mareechjapi bolenni, obak hocchi. Amader kotha vabte hobe na, amra sunno hote pari, kintu amra daktar, engineer, ukil, bhugche rajyer manus. Jokhon Dalhousie te bostam, tokhono nijer jama nije kachtam, ajo Tai Kori. Kintu banglar khete khawa mazdur o krishok shreni bolche, "Age ki sundor din kataitam." ar ekhon rastae sue ache. Apni thik, bijemul thik, sudhu ekta prosno korbo, female reservation in parliament, right to information, 300 diner kaj ( jeta 100 tei theke gelo) ei gulo Russian na Chinese? Ar dhorun apni cigarette Khan, apnar lungse ekta adenocarcinoma holo, daktar bollo ekta lungs bad porbe, apni ki korben? Cancer ta rekhe deben toh? Congress is a slower version of BJP, and unfortunately that's best option now, Ami personally Congress jot support korina. Ar election keno jitchena, ota corporate media ar jara kal ballot box vanglo, tader ke jiges korun. Ar vote e jeta jodi sob kichur khotiyan hoe, tahole bolbo, amra 34 bochor jitechi, tar mane amra vogoban er moton kaj korechi. Ainar samne gie daran, rajpothe jara onoshon korche, jei bridge gulo bhenge manus moreche, jei mojdur ra 100 diner kajer taka pache na, mone rakhben setar jnno dayi ainate Jake dekhte pachen. Jodi kal Pakistan o bamfront er biruddhe darae, apni take vote die deben, bamponthi manei urban naxalite, jihadi, terrorist, eta keno bolchi, nijer bijemul bondhuder jiges korun. Ar mithe kotha bola apnader kach theke sekha uchit, 1984 land reforms ke abolish Kora hoeni, 47th amendment kore 1978 er land reform model ta puro deshe implement Kora hoeche, ektu India.gov.in e gie dekhun. Kintu ei mithachar die proman kore dilen je apnar main osubidha bamponthi noe, apni chan feudal system firie ante, goriber chele school e gele apnar hingsha hoe. Sorkarer kaj holo apnader bhora pet bhora, Tai na? Ar China/ Russia? British er karagare lekha ache amader nam, ar jodi konodin China r sathe juddho lage, army draft teo amaderi nam paben. Jodi boli IT sector bamfront koreche, tokhon apni reply deben, oekhane kono industry nei. TCS, cognizant, Wipro sob chop silpo. Ami gorber sathi boli amra bharoter communist party, keno amader malik holo jei bharotiyo Amar plate e khabar Ane, jei bharotiyo Amar mathar upor Chad toiri koreche. Ar bamfront kharap bolei bhagat singh fasir monche othe, ar Sarvarkar des bhag kore. Ami psychiatrist, chaile apnader moton subidha badir moton US, UK te jete pari, kintu jokhon corona hoechilo, Ami red volunteer chilam, apni ki korchilen? ar party ar matribhumir jnno pran dite pari, British jamanae diechi, Indira jamanae diechi, Modi jamanae dicchi, sob jomanae debo. Apnader ke dekhe Mone hoe kader jnno lorchi, biman da ke dekhe sob rag mite jae. Valo thakben, sudhu etai bolbo, churir taka ekdin ses hobe.
বেশ কিছুদিন হল, বিশেষ করে নিজের youtube ই premium এ upgrade করানোর পর, আপনার channel এর দুর্লভ কিছু সাক্ষাৎকারের film clips আমার wall এ ভেসে উঠছে। সত্যজিৎ রায়ের কিছু মূল্যবান সাক্ষাৎকার শোনার পর এইটে পেলাম, একটু আগে। অসাধারণ সংগ্রহ আপনার। ধন্যবাদ জানাই, যাঁরা এ জিনিসের কদর করার চেষ্টায় থাকি।
@T_S accha idiot moshai bolun tahole mamata ar modir period e ki changes aseche? Konodin gdp growth ta dekhechen,2004 obdhi bengali 3-4th e thakto gdp list e,Singur nandigram massacre ar mamatar mamdobaji kore bengal ke 7th position e niye aseche,apnar bhat er golpo onno kauke sonaben,apni Benglar lok hoye americar pa chaten, America khub bhalo mone hoi tai na? Middle East er bacchara aj o kande oder tel er sokh er jonno,ar haldia petrochemicals to apnar baba niye asechilo bodhai
@T_S accha Bangladesh liberation 1971 e ke pashe darie chilo ,usa,ar amar facts gulo ke khub ojhogtik kotha diye ketechen,otei apnar dogla rajniti bojha jai
@T_S ha seta bhul koreche manchi kintu gdp obostha to bhaloi chilo,3rd e,American tax acche na,tora boka,kelane bole dekhte pash na, America te anaj na jonmale puro biswo ke kandte hoi(great world depression),middle East massacre e ora,giye Google dekh kelane koto mohila ke americar police rape koreche,mere diyeche oder nijeder lobh bachanor jonno,America naki bhalo,kon somay e pore thaken,apnader moton lokerai British der pa chatto tarpor akhon america r pa chate,John f Kennedy ar Abraham Lincoln ke amio respect kori kintu baki gulo haramzadar dol Google e dekhe nish,ar prosno nayoktontro , gonotontrer,apnar America,boro gonotontro red indian der khub respect dito na? Jim crow laws mone acche,America Nazi der choto rup,oder rastro sudhu onno desh er tax amdani te chole,ar seta jodi apnar pochondo,tahole apnar o choreder manoshikota
He did not make any reforms.Whatever was made in the name of land reform was basically creating a tool to caderisation of CPM.In 2006 when Karunanidhi an ally of CPM became CM of Tamilnadu they sent a team to WB to understand the land reform.Later TN rejected it wholly sighting the same as useless one.
@@PrabalPakrasi-uy1ki Every capitalist in this world will find that land reform as useless. Every capitalist in this world will not tolerate the rise of Labour Unions. They will not like the empowerment of the poor and working class. The people whom you are referring as Cadres, they run the political parties,they are working class people. They make the whole world running. And what does a capitalist do? They always try to demean them. They always try to demean their achievements. So, never mind.🙏
Even though I do not support communism and marksim and kind of dislike the modern day far left communist people, I have high respect for mr Jyoti Bosu. Even though our views of the world and policy may differ highly, I will not have any problem having a decent conversation with this man in a civilized manner.. even though we may disagree on many things but putting things on the table respectfully without any issue is something that can be achieved with such a man..
They did not allow computers in 1977 or 1978....did lots of nonsense activities...those days media was not strong nowadays. do u know this...both sides of coins are same...
He didn't let Darjeeling get separated from BENGAL. He didn't appease any relegion. He was an honest and a strong Communist. Indian Communist party completely got destroyed after him.
He appeased the upper caste Hindu society. Bunch of Chatterjees , Bannerjees , Basus climbed the laddder quickly in society and in the party. The condition of low caste and Muslims worsened. In India appeasement means showing same standards of treatment to Muslims that politicians show to Hindus. Its not appeasement. anyway politicians should ALWAYS appease its voter base and thats how democracy works. If people voted someone they voted so that the leader will do something good for them. Naturally its appeasement.
@@kundansarkar6465 Cmon , can you show me any lower caste leader in CPM top leadership ? All Brahmins and upper caste. if CPM did their job BJP will not be able to enter Bengal today. They failed to educate the masses. Go to Kerala , BJP can't enter Kerala even when the communists are not ruling. CPM was basically a party of middle class that used the bottom classes to stay in power.
@@Valkyri3Z communist don't believe in cast system,do u know Anil biswas ex state security,harkishan surjit, harekrishna kongar?there r many more ,but have not little bit Idea about communism,so spreading your propaganda,we r proudly say we r mass party in India society 40 ,,% marginal class 40% middle class 20%elite class,we r socialist,we r don't support elite it's opposite our ideology,Kerala ppl r smart,they don't support brahmin,manuvadi system,brahman r out sider of India,in west Bengal communist government gives quality education not quantity education,in now days day by day your favorite fakuji destroying government education system,why r u so ful?
One of the most prudent politicians India has ever seen, he was the icon of non communal politics, the savior of Bengal in a tough time and the Chanyaka of politics in his time. Red salute to the Great leader.
Absolutely, families like ours which hardly had any food to eat, who had difficulties to carry out higher education and more he came as a saviour, only those from rich families whose forefathers acted as puppets of the Britishers and enjoyed the oppression of people who had nothing dislikes him, a study of WB's history will help anyone understand how the IT development of Bangalore started in the 70s and hence no other state caught up with them yet it was WB state run JU that had ranked third in CS research in India by 95 after IISc Bangalore forned in 1907/08 and IIT Kgp and is still the only state government run university that ranks among the top 10-15 in India and 1000 worldwide, only people who knows history of WB and not brainwashed by Bihari-UPite culture that has taken over WB knows that post RSS-ML supported partition all the industrial belts of WB baring Hooghly Industrial Belt be it Dhanbad, Dhaka, Sylet, Silchar and many more were gone from WB and industrial belts like Asansol-Durgapur, Haldia, BidhanNagar Electronic City and New Town and rabid urbanization of Kharagpur, Siliguri etc were pursued under him, no Bengal was nothing with agricultural growth at. 6% and no quality healthcare, education centres, industries, outside pockets of Kolkata, this man spread the state established Panchayat Raj that became a model and is followed across India today, no wonder half his haters fancy an individual who failed to industrialize even a single district (Ahmedabad ) in proper sense in 12 years in a industrially developed state 🤣😂 and still failed to attract any of the top industrialists, all Gujaratis or Marwaris to leave Mumbai and their respective states and settle in Gujarat🤣😂 let alone the poor education and healthcare system that the state still suffers from, where money is the parameter to judge ones education wheter he is a Nirav Modi or Mehul Choksi 🤣😂
@@sayanroy4781 Idiot. Doesn't know anything. GDP per capita as share of India's per captia income consistently dropped under Jyoti Basu. He left state With 46% debt and fiscal deficit of 7.3%. That alone proves how damaging he was.
@Shuvam Ghosh You care about falling GDP? Under communist's Bengal GDP per capita growths rate was flat at minimum levels and much less than average. Basu left state with public debt of 46% and fiscal deficit of 7.3% and that alone shows hoe bad governance was. He even resisted technology ie computers
Generally most of the haters are the descendants of the rioters of the riots which could have occurred in Bengal if he wouldn't be in power. Like 1984, 1990, 1992 and 2002.
This is completely false. Poverty levels spiked during the communist misrule. Factories were shut down artisans and workers were un-employed. The only segment of people who profited from the communist misrule was the government servants, politiciand and the left leaning "intellectuals".
When Basuji took the rein of Bengal Govt , the percentage of people below proverty line was 54 % , when he relinquished after 23 years the percentage came down to 26% .Such performance was achieved mainly through Land Reform he pursued with Zeal and Vigor .
Jyoti Basu the carpenter ,who made the Coffin for West Bengal. Removed English from primary school,but sent his own son to foreign for good education. Destroyed Industry in Bengal with CITU union. Opposing Computer in Bank & offices.. People of West Bengal asked for job,good health care, education & Mr.Basu & his party replied Americans bombing on Iraq.
You are a just a child at this moment.. Your father and your family is still alive only for this man.. He was a colossus of communists.. Bengal's pride.. Red Salute Comrade Jyoti Bose
@@rathindraislam5809 Saltlake was established by Dr bidhanchandra Roy..and as you said IT hub of saltlake..yes saltlake is a IT hub but without IT companies 😂
The curse of Jyothi Basu's rule for over 3 decades still hangs large in West Bengal. He was the mastermind for the downfall of WB. Till 1965, WB was a role model for economic growth, industrial might and success for the rest of India. Today, it contributes heavily in migrant labour list. That's his legacy.
Very true, also WB was a hub of cultural growth, music, education, intelligence was at per with global level. But during his tenure everything moved towards a path of cheap thinking.
@@rajd2990 Yes....that was an extended degeneration on all fronts. Only Bengal in India underwent a great period called Bengal Renaissance movement. It happened because of British rule and administration. The great learning and cultural institutions were built between 1850 and 1910 and education and culture flourished. Calcutta was not only the national capital, but it was said in British empire, a coveted posting on East of Suez Canal was Calcutta, when Hong Kong, Beijing, Kuala Lumpur, Bangkok, Taipei, Singapore, Sydney, or Melbourne were mere villages. The last great visionary and builder of institutions of repute was Dr. Bidhan Chandra Roy. After his departure, the leadership in Bengal became pedestrian and the people got astray due to paucity of able leadership. It still remains so. The proliferation of intellectualism has vastly dwindled.
@Anonymous Thanks for the precision. The well educated and the technocrats migrated to other Indian states or around the globe. This only further pushed down the economic growth of WB.
I request the uploader to remove this video because it's really painful for those who know what he did for Bengal to see all those hate comments against him, those brainwashed by Bengali newspaper and TV media, or mere antisocial pickpocketer now seating on Netaji's chair, tolabaaz or promoters. For many of us he's a messiah, for me who doesn't believe in God, he is one. He kept an exodus of Hindu Bengalis alive. And because of those selfish haters and how they vote, we are having to leave Bengal. I can accept leaving Bengal and Bengal today is paying the price for its recent voting pattern, but it burns me to see animals shitting on my God.
A modern day Despot, whose work has served as a guidebook to all parties in power, the iron hand with which he ruled WB has pushed the state backward, changed the psyche of the people and it will take decades or more to correct the damage. Truly a one man wrecking crew
A despot rejects the seat of the prime minister. A despot kept alive an exodus of Hindu Bengalis. A despot kept the cost of living minimal among all metroes. A despot established the cheapest public transport system. A despot who made free basic education possible which enabled poor people to crack AIPMT and AIEEE without private tuitions. A despot who established panchayat system. A despot who brought land reforms. Confirming to free market capitalism wasn't a part of Bengali psyche. If you don't believe in equality, if you you don't believe that everyone should get equal opportunity, that's your pov. You don't have the right to decide for the entire Indo-Aryan race who speak Bengali. We Bengalis used to think happiness is in contentment, and still many do. For those who don't, it's their choice and I respect it unless they are tolabaaz, smugglers, drug dealers or a plain pick pocketer presently seating on the chair of Subhash Bose because of people like you.
Communism is a joke. Human beings need to be 200 yrs advanced to establish its true colours. We are too much self centred in this age.. that's why every communist country is so secretive and imposes strong laws on countrymen. I definitely believe communism is the future..but it's also true that we are still mentally not that much developed to accept it
@@uttiyobasu3749 চুদির ভাই জ্যোতি কে চুদির ভাই লম্পট বললে কোন লুকোনোর কিছু আছে? পশ্চিমবঙ্গের গাঁড় মেরে দিয়ে গেছে শুধু নিজেদার লোকদের আর ছিটে ফোটা এদেশিদের কে ভিখারির মতো দিয়ে যেন ওর বাবার ঘরের টাকা। ও তো নিজে একটা পূর্ব বঙ্গের ভিখিরি। শালা মিথ্যুক এবং হারামির বাচ্চা। একে সমর্থন করা মানে চীন কে ও পাকিস্তান কে সমর্থন করা।
So that means those generations are master in other areas like History, Geography, Philosophy and even in Bengali. Only thing they could not learn is the English ?
@ Rahul Das : ever heard of Kothari Commission? Any idea who appointed them? Request you to read and develop your own understanding rather than being just a part of mass under influence of false propaganda!
@T_S you dint get me buddy. I partially agree with you on the commissions in our country and its role so far. However, my comment above was in context of what has been mentioned by Mr. Rahul Das. I would strongly recommend you to read and understand about Kothari Commission first and then let's debate about who was in fault in lifting up English from primary education. Marichjhapi and other stuffs are also a big dent on left governance in Bengal but there are other side of those stories too.
@@sauron2000000 he with other followers sat on Kolkata streets protestinga about introducing computers in the state Company like UPS UPS went away Others went To Bangalore. THAT WAS THE BEGINNING .
He seems to be jerky and nervous - the way he sits and stares here and there shows that he is not very comfortable with the questioning. For that matter, he was rarely comfortable with interviews. But he held his guard quite well till the end, giving only terse and shortest possible replies to questions which required some degree of explanation.
IN A COMPETITIVE WORLD CPM DECIDED TO TAKE WEST Bengal out of competition Never tried to mediate inthe disputes between workers and ailing industries which isacommonpractice all overthe world
father of militant trade uniobism...his communist philo is obsolete. for him many jute n auto industry in WB was shut down. He was a bourgeoise himself. his son is a billionaire. Look at 'capitalist' China today- their GDP, their industries.Does Jyoti Babu's marxism explain that? he supported education in bengali medium. But why u taught ur grand daughter in a posh ENGMEDIUM ?..No.... I supported Buddha Babu - he was trying...but possibly the common man misunderstood his vision.
Singer is a wrong place for Industry.It was unfair to destroy such fertile land.It was selected as a low hanging fruit because of ready infrastructure.Why we could not create Industrial area in barren lands of Purulia or Bankura or West Midnapore,the way MIDC did in remote places in Maharashtra.Leaders or Officers or Ministers had to work in that case,but we Bengalees in WB are lazy that is why we could not achieve that feat.Downfall of WB started after Dr.B.C.Roys death that still continues.For WB a benevolent dictator is required.
A few of such leaders will make indian elections interesting.....otherwise everyone knows mamata ji rahulji priyanka ji and congress is no match for modiji....didi still is the doyenne in west bengal: as a national leader she still doesn't pose a threat to modij
And west bengal, and hindu bengalis, and education of west bengal, and health system/infrastructure of west bengal, and law n order of west bengal, and...... End less list.
@@saptarshi7587 he was a dishonestperson.He se nt his.son ou of.t Bengal to avoid political unrest He took no responsibility for Naxals and allowed them to be buchared by the police.He returned grant from central govt for various project He ignored the reign of terror spread by his cadres. People couldn't vote freely and because central govt was in coalition govt they didnot take any step.to stop this terror
Because of him and his party ruling West Bengal which became number one state in India in Industrialisation, Development, Education,Health and what not during Dr B.C.Roys time fell much much behind and now almost last runner in India.He made others children as CPM cadre, save as, his own one, who became a so called industrialist.Courtesy him millions of Bengalee boys and girls are to run to others states for higher education and job,leaving behind their old and ailing parents.List is endless.
Thanks for fantastic video , even in 2020 political violence and suppression didn't end. Now can understand Genesis of these negative vibes even 50 years ago
Jyoti Basu wasn't even half the man that the naxalites are. He calls himself a communist yet was responsible for sending police-men to bring down the revolt of the peasants in the naxalbari uprising and took the side of the ruling class instead of the peasants; and yet he has the guts to talk about left-wing politics
I'd go and get education in London, but I'd expel english from the state board schools. He's great as a politician, true, but he's great only as a politician.
And make way for businessmen of my own state to go to hell and make migrant businessman the monopolists...Including privatising the electric company of the capital city.
Far from Bengal. Thinking if I could manage a decent job at W Bengal ! Just randomly came to this video. Realizing that it is not the BASU but the people of W Bengal and the backward, freeloader type of mentality which led to this current situation where the next gen has to leave home state in masses, for jobs 😥
আমরা বাঙ্গালীরা একটু বেশীই রাজনৈতিক সচেতন এবং প্রতিবাদী হতে গিয়ে; এই দশাপ্রাপ্ত হলাম! কাকে আর দোষ দিতে যাবো এখন! আমরা নিজেরাই সম্পূর্ণভাবে দায়ী এই অবস্থার জন্য!
No decency around, no decent jobs available. When was WB a decent place? Those people who cared to bring about decency were joked at, given different names and then chased out from WB. How can one expect WB to be decent without decent persons around? 🙏🙏
@@dipankarroy2320 rajnaitik.sachetan? One of the problem is envy.Whether it helps us or not we donot like other Bengalies doing well mr Basu, s communism suited us.well Chinese communism is completely no no CHINEESE ACCUMULATE and TAKE OVER MARKET I REMRMBER.NASTY RUMOUR THe LEFT.SPREAD ABOUT Dr.BC.Ray Atulya Ghosh etc and people believed them This is not being politically consciois
@@uttiyobasu3749 modi aur amit shah jaise dhongi Bharat mei doosra nahi hua...Amit shah toh ussey bhi battar... ek aur ghatiya hai west bengal mei DILIP GHOSH bloody asshole
Played very constructive role in pushing Bengal lower bottom of every chart. Those words Marxism, socialists, capitalist etc etc sounds wonderful in literature. All we need a decent life. If your ideology can’t provide that, then it’s outdated. 3 generation were destroyed due to outdated ideology and policies. He was against capitalism but his son was at helm of Bengal lights. There is no good or bad cat, if it can catch mouse it’s definitely a CAT and rest are not a CAT.
Are you sure about bottom? Like Bengal's GDP is still in top five. Poor Bengalis educated from public schools are sitting at eminent positions worldwide. But what about those schools now? Destroyed 3 generations? Yes destroyed by bringing land laws, establishing the panchayat system, education for all, cheapest public transport in whole India. People used to get good food in 5 rs, there were yearly employment, people didn't have to give donations to get into colleges. Today, Mamta is not the problem, greed of Bengalis has made way for turning Bengal into Bangladesh.
This is not possible..there's false rumors being spread in the name of jyoti Bose..he introduced land reforms & panchayeti Raj in west bengal..He established power projects in Bakreshwar, Hoogly...he established industrial towns like Haldia, Rajarhat...
@@bratiksarkar1409 hope you have not forgotten the closure of endless factories, killing of Anandamargi, killing in Marichjhhapi, sponsored killing of Deputy Commissioner Mehta followed by custodial death of the main accused in Lalbazar, political party based recruitment in University VC upto office clerk, has made students of bengal weak in national level - you will not find IAS or IIT toppers from Bengal for last few decades. CPM has spoilt generations of bengali people. In 2015 few jokers like Bikash Bhattacharya & Subodh Sarkar organized a beef party. Now don't tell me I am a bhakt or a Congressi or a TMC supporter. But I don't see any reason to support CPM.
@@kaustavdey1 Lal Salaam is not a human who is in coffin after death. It's a greeting Its a emotion It's a Slogan Of the Workers, Of the Peasants And the Proleteriats Against the Burgouise
@@kaustavdey1 তুই তো অন্য কমেন্ট গুলিতে গালাগাল দিয়ে বেড়াচ্ছিস । এখানে শুরু করলে কর নম্বর দিয়ে দিস সিধা তোর বাড়িতে এসে কথা হবে গুন্ডামি নয় তোদের মতন শুধুই যুক্তির কথা বার্তা হবে আর মন্দ বুদ্ধি এটা কে হুমকি বলে মনে করিস না😂
Look at that stubborn face. Everything was right if he thinks so. nobody was allowed to talk without his permission. He had a manager ANIL BISWAS who was there to make sure of It. If a reporter asked him of any incident which would be his discomfort he used to say " I didn't hear it" . Though his party did something good in 80 s but after that everything was colonised.
I didn't understand when he said Indira Gandhi as a capitalist representative. As far as I have heard that Jyoti Basu also came from a Zamindari family of East Bengal. To me Indira Gandhi was much more pro Moscow than them that helped India militarily and diplomatically a great deal in those days against hostile nations.
It's bigotry to think every zamindar would be a capitalist by believing in feudalism, labour exploitation, etc. Marx, Engels, Lenin, and even 6/10 members of the party core committee, was from a Zamindar family, whereas congress had 10/10 members from a Zamindar family. It is some of us zamindars who thought what our previous generation has been doing was wrong, and we brought land reforms to change it. It's not Indira was pro Moscow, USSR looked after India, because Pakistan was with US, and China was still a boy flying and falling at many steps. I have to agree Indira took few leftist step, and one of them was nationalisation of bank, which is still holding the economy or it would have collapsed in 2008. But Indira took those steps under our pressure. That was politics those days. While congress enjoyed being ministers we were busy getting policies like 300 days work( stopped at 100 days), female parliamentary reservation, right to information, essential food bill passed. That was politics those days. Politics is a spectrum with Y and X axis, they being economical and social inclination towards left/right. So, to us, they are capitalist, but to BJP, they are left. I'm glad someone acknowledged Soviet's role towards India. It's not that we support Soviet, but it was one the first implementations of our idealogy, which swore like a dragon but got shot down by US. It taught us many lesions. And I don't have any hesitation to accept, we had mistakes, but we promise we have learnt our lesion. Amader Bangla medium schoole pora manusera aj Bhabha centre of physics, CIP Ranchi, onek national ebong international institutions er HOD. Kotha dichi bangali abar sikhore uthbe. Ebar ar ager barer vul gulo hobena. Jodi hoe, abar namie deben.
@T_S ভাই তোরা কয় পার্সেন্ট?? আমরা কত পার্সেন্ট তোরা কত পার্সেন্ট সেইটা বুঝা যাবে সামনের নির্বাচনে। আশা করি তোর তারপর বোধবুদ্ধি হবে যদি যুক্তির কথা শুনতে ভালো লাগে তাহলে নির্বাচনের পর কথা বলিস আর ৬.৫ পার্সেন্ট হলে কি কথা বলা যাবে না। নিজের বাপের গোটা দেশ নাকি তোর ভাই আইটি CELL এ কাজ করে তোর রুজি রুটি চলে, বার বার সবাইকে বুঝিয়ে দিচ্ছিস আর তুই অন্য কমেন্ট এ বিবেকানন্দের কথা বলিস আবার এক নারী কে অসম্মান করিস তুই বিবেকানন্দের নাম খারাপ করছিস কাল তোর উপর সাইবার ক্রাইম এর case দিচ্ছি, মনে রাখিস
@T_S আরে ও চাড্ডি তোদের ই তো মনে হবে যে আমি বানিয়ে লিখছি পাসে দেখ বই গুলো এবং বক্তা গুলোর নাম লিখে দিয়েছি 😂 বিশ্বাস না হলে, কিছু করার নেই🥱 Cyber Crime department এ case দিচ্ছি তারপরে তুই সামলা
@@souravsaha2643 How did his son manage to anass huge wealth and properties? His son owned lots of lands in Rajarhat Newton. His son owns lots of housing complex projects in West Behala like Green field city etc. His son was just a graduate in arts but became the director of Indian Airlines due to Narshima Rao's intervention. His party cpm supported Narshima Rao's government from outside and so he got the medal for his son and not for the people. He was responsible for the killing of Bengali migrants who were basically schedule castes from erstwhile East Pakistan and they were torched and not allowed to drink water. They died without water and food and many of those who tried to escape were caught and shot dead by his goons and police who were working in tandem with the cpm goons. These were his characters.
People's liberator❤️ Father of the deprived section of Bengal, the Messiah of the poor, the only CM who facilitated an all round growth of a state in a proportionate rate across WB and across departments, only looteras and thugs whose families benefitted from British Raj, whose forefathers were Billeti Kuttas and who are brainwashed today by the anti-Bengali anti-poor mentality propagated by the British Patriot gang hate him, no true Indian Bengali who suffered from poverty, whose family members died from the lack of food and healthcare during the 60s and 70s can dislike this man
He andhis family had a middlrclass life style and there is nothing wrong.in that what is wrong is to destroy assets refuse.to build projects to provide opportunities (flower market) to create jobs his policy infact helped the established business communities His son didnot have to wait until 8th form to start english lessons.Whether we like it or. not books are in english
This man had great impact on Bengal society,for example political violence, hooliganism,decline of industries.This are some of his important contribution.
