Karen Read Innocent Of Murder? Reviewing Jackson's Latest Motion (Also, Monday!) 

This makes me mistrusted the judge even more. Seems like she wanted to cause jury confusion.

The simple bottom line is if Bev did her job and ASKED them if they were hung on ALL the charges or just some of them, this would have been avoided. She didn’t do her job. She was blinded by biased and her “I was tired” 😂

I love the idea of pro bono work for people unable to qualify for gov aid but still unable to afford private lawyers. I grew up really poor and many things were harder as we began to earn more money as we no longer qualified for help despite still needing it.

The people saying that the defense team should've asked to poll the jury on the charges, as far as I'm aware, the judge should've done that as part of her job before declaring the mistrial.

The jury was so confused. They couldn’t even tell Brian Albert from Brian Higgins it seems. Between Lally’s endless word salad and bev’s lengthy and confusing instructions, not to mention no transcripts were provided, is it any wonder they were confused?

I just want to say. Emily and Runkle are my law parents and I will always watch both of them.

Runkle, for the pro-bono fund. Thanks for being a wonderful human and spending time with us.

Now that the other jurors saw this filing today, more will come out now to confirm what happened. .

The judge instructed the jury NOT to complete the verdict form until they were in agreement on ALL the charges.

I support you doing pro bono for people in the gap!!! Then again, I support all of your endeavors, you’re a good human.

Replay crew! Working an overnight, in a lab by myself, and you’re keeping me company!

With Proctor now suspended without pay based on his actions during the investigation of this case, I really can't imagine what the cross examination in a retrial would look like.

It is possible the jury believe she didn't hit him with her SUV, but they would like to convict her on driving intoxicated, a reckless behaviour that can be a danger to anyone.

Hey Runkle 👋 I can't sleep so I am listening to replay thanks for keeping me company

Replay crew! I am so touched by your passion for pro bono law work. I will be watching the Rust trial with you! ☺️

Love Getting Runkle 🎉🎉Full time RU-vid ❤❤Let's Support Him Well so he gets A Good Idea That We Will & Can Support Mrs. Runkle, Pupps & Runkle himself Love for Runkle Family 🎉🎉

Reply crew! Just got done watching Emily. Really hope that Trooper Bukenik and Trooper Tully face some action too. Proctor is not the only corrupt cop. They saw what he was doing and saying and said NOTHING.

Bless you Runkle, for your goal of probono work.❤

I so agree with you about the Monarchy. We really don't need it.

The way this case was handled should worry every American.

Here on replay crew. Couldn’t miss your opinions on this crazy trial.

Hey Runkle, Australian Solicitor living in Australia here who passed the NY bar exam in Feb, reach out if you need any learnings on how to make it work from a foreigner taking the bar

I really hope the anti-Karen Read people who were spreading fake news about the verdict take a long look in the mirror and have a come to Jesus moment. You have to be a really shitty person to be that wrong, but also talk crap to everyone who disagrees with you. It's insane. They should have their heads evaluated

Who saw the jury slip? Did they mark nothing on it? How do we know? Isn't it the responsibility of the hand-picked jury foreman to fill it out?

You explaining your goals for this channel (ie being able to defend clients pro bono) has definitely cemented my decision to prioritize watching you for trial coverage going forwards

John's shirt had blood running ALL down the front of it - you know, like when you get a bloody nose from being punched? If he was "knocked down" by the SUV, how did blood run down the front of his entire shirt???

58:12 "world's most expensive trailer park" BAHAHAHAHA OMG 🤣 I just alarmed my office lizard!!!

What's the point of a jury in Canada if the prosecution can keep so easily and repeatedly try again after an acquittal?

As of now, we don't know whether the "NG" was checked off on any forms or not. Jackson asked for there to be both "G" & "Ng" boxes next to each charge & each lesser included - which Bev denied. Ultimately, the forms weren't clear, and neither was the jury note. Otherwise, this wouldn't be happening now. Bev should've asked which counts they were hung on, for clarity, rather than assuming it was all of them. Everyone watching expected her to ask. The defense also expected her to, and before they could ask, Bev had hurriedly concluded the proceedings. Because of her failure to ask, all 12 jurors should now have to confirm their votes on the record. Personally, I would've indicated that we were hung on 1 charge if I'd written the jury note, but Karen still deserves any acquittals the negligent foreperson failed to mention in the final note.

Let's get Runkle to 300k, folks!❤

You’re the best Runkle!!!

One exception to double jeopardy in the US is civilian and military courts (for military personnel) - see Eastburn murders - ft Bragg as 1 example

Judge: we need to take measures to protect the identity of the jurors lest they be harassed Jurors' friends: 📣📣📣 Which honestly tracks for this case

I honestly dont think they wanted to charge on the 2nd count - but felt like they had to 'get her' on something because they felt intimidated by the McO'Alberts. Just my opinion

Just when we thought this case couldn’t get messier it does. With Read, Walsh and Birchmore this area is going through a lot.

Thanks Runkle!! Caught the VoD. It's great to hear your perspective. And, to compare it to Emily, Peter & Dad, and Lee. I think on Day 31 when the Judge read the jury instructions, the impression is given that thenjury form is only filled out after a unanimous decision on all charges . This lead to an option where guilty/not guilty verdicts on some charges and mistrial on others was not an option.

The CW probably upgraded the charge to try to pressure KR into a plea deal

Dear Runkle of the Bailey, hearing about your plan to work pro bono makes me so incredibly happy! Wonderful. Unfortunately, there will always be a screaming need for pro bono attorneys so I salute your choice. The day I climb out of my abyss of debt and hopefully one day have a divorce agreement honored, I will happily kick in for that. Thanks for leading us through the mess that Karen Read lives in every second of the day. Its such a strange and suspicious mess...

"The Scots have some feelings about the monarchy" - truest words I ever did hear 😂

Just looked up the Captain Kori book and came across the “other” one… all of the reviews mention “endorsed by Pixie/Kori’s mom” in some way or another and that POS has apparently gotten all the negative reviews taken down by Amazon somehow. If Pixie is against this book, those reviews and the blurb describing the book as having the “advanced knowledge and permission” of Kori and Pixie needs to be removed too. Imagine taking advantage of a child who passed… I could never.

I like the word "hereinafter". I like compound prepositions, but usually they only have two prepositions.

The jury completely ignored the FBI expert on if he got hit by a car or not. Why does everyone keep calling them smart? They can’t even remember which one is Higgins.

Mistakes were made in the rush to move past this Jury.

Awesome goal Runkle!!!! Ian we support you

18:35 Ok. I made the same mistake Ian. We don't have merely Juror B and Informant B AKA intermediary B. Just as with the C's, the informant and the intermediary are different people. Informant B received screenshots from Intermediary B. 😵‍💫🔄🔄🔄🥴

Did they rehouse the verdict sheets, or did Chloe eat them? What if anything did Bev do to mess up this verdict being entered into the record? Its sus to say the least.

I still come over to hear what you think regardless 😂😂😂 cant miss out on the Runkle opinion

Dude the product description on the other book is wild! F that guy

Who can actually see the verdict slips that are turned in after the verdict?

Replay crew, thanks Runkle. 🎉🎉🎉🎉

If Bev gets removed, the prosecution will not go forward with a retrial.

Lmfao 100, million 98 days we've been here

Someone please take the uss Constitution and move it out of Boston harbor. No form of the Constitution belongs in Mass

I’m working right now, love it 😍 my Elvin Targaryen law dude 😊

To be fair the queen was a bit of a bad ass in her day

Post-EDB viewing ❤

The judge hasn't even tried to hide her bias in favor of the prosecution. It's like she can see where the evidence leads and is determined to protect the police from future prosecution so she tried to steer the verdict.

Thanks for the nice evening and keeping me company

Intended to make this live but had an unexpected IRL guest show up at my home who forbade me RU-vid whilst in her presence. It was a tough ask! Here for the replay. Missed Chat, but still enjoying myself. 🙂💜

I just got to the part where someone commented that they are going to cancel their membership because Runkle has too extreme views on anti monarchy. And lol, Runkle had the least extreme take on monarchy I have heard. Spend 1 day in Ireland, you'll hear some unsavory shit about the king and the monarchy in general.

Chumbawamba were English from Lancashire. The song in question was done as a B-side to the "Tubthumping" 7" single in the UK and Europe and was released by EMI - Universal - Republic. It was not release here in Canada or the US.

My god! Remind me never to visit Canada! I don't want to be wrongly accused of something and bled dry by the government gouvernement just to end up in jail.

Replay crew! Great stream Runkle.

Ian, You are a Real Super Hero!!! I love the way you are ready to fight for right... Help Pixie to get rid of the AH's fake Kori book... and hopefully make him pay!!!

Good luck on your endeavors Runkle. You're a good man Charlie Brown!

Thanks Runkle! Please take care of yourself thru this trial! ❤ Love your Runkleisms haha Love From New Brunswick Canada 🇨🇦

i think Minnesota would be a great place to try to practice law Proctor is done, but it can't happen in a day. realize he's a member of the state employees union, so he's entitled to due process. the fact that they moved him to "without pay" says everything

💯 GUILTY.

And I still maintain my opinion on jury verdict forms and instructions. They should be written as simple as possible, with simple language and short sentences. Not because juries are dumb but because no one can misinterpret anything if it is clearly written. No one has to be confused because the instructions and forms are such a spaghetti language there's no up or down on them, if it's written simply.

The jury can't meet up for beers in public to avoid being identified as jurors. Zoom meetings are preferable for some as there might be in the group: introverts, non drinkers, those of limited means, those who can't get babysitters.

@Ian do you have the amended juror forms? If so, would you PLEASE send them to Kurt at Uncivil? He's arguing with EVERYONE that we're all wrong. The new atty is to rep them in the event they have to testify, too. Unreal, too, she never let the attys see the notes!!

25:22 Feels like the jury thinks they were the ‘drunk’ police? Karen, did have huge remorse on Sunday, imo, Jen convinced many that KR had hurt JO. Fact though, KR was on JO wifi at 12:34 and she had a drive to get there. JO lost pints, or liters of blood. The leaf blower exposed a few tablespoons that leaked as he lay, as a prop for Lucky’s plow victim. Imo, had KR not broke her light, Lucky would have been the Patsy? Imo….

Replay crew.

Did you see where Officer Albert was put on leave because of Trooper Proctor? Albert was put on leave before he even testified. If they insist on trying her again, they need a change of venue.

If/when my abuser takes me back to court, you’re all more than welcome to follow it. Maybe that would put a stop to the corruption 🤔😂😭

The defense argued against speaking objections, not objections followed by the legal reason for the objection. This is the only court I’ve ever seen where they have to approach after an objection to state the legal reasoning. It’s ridiculous. What is surprising is that the defense for Baldwin were surprised by this. One would think they watched the other trial and already knew about this and wouldn’t be surprised by this nonsense.

Excellent information Ty. God bless 🙏

Hi Runkle!

If they overturn count 3 they will have a hard time proving count 2. It’s hard to prove manslaughter if a jury has found she didn’t leave him dead or injured.

Just so you know, Chumbawumba are, in fact, English - not that it matters much to me, but not everyone , contrary to popular belief , is a royalist in England. Watching on replay, I didn't see chat, no offence intended- just a comment.

I love your commentary 😊😊

Replay crew 🦄

we need to lose the “Karen’s” and embrace the “Rita’s”

Why is it always anyone's fault but the defense? They have mouths, they know how to talk? If they wanted the jury polled, ASK!! Now the taxpayers will pay for all this nonsense that could have been avoided by the defense opening their mouth. This whole free karen read thing is too much, kind of like Murdaugh & look where he is! Proctor being suspended is because of his distasteful text. Not because she didnt do it.

Didn't the judge tell them not to fill put the forms until they were unanimous?

Auntie Bev will blame it all on the changes that Jackson asked for.

Ian, I get that judges makes mistakes and can’t be punished for every little thing. But KR’s freedom hangs in the balance. Bev may not be reprimanded, but she certainly needs to investigate the messages the defense received and then act accordingly and clean up her mess. How in the world did a judge NOT have the jury write SOMETHING on the verdict forms stating that they were a hung jury or which charges they’d been able to come to a collective guilty or not guilty. Her “We’ve always done it this way” is out of touch and reeks of her ego getting in the way. I’m appalled!

Massachusetts Rule of Criminal Procedure Rule 27 - Verdict (b) Several Offenses or Defendants. If there are two or more offenses or defendants tried together, the jury may with the consent of the judge at any time during its deliberations return or be required by the judge to return a verdict or verdicts with respect to the defendants or charges as to which a verdict has been reached; and thereafter the jury may in the discretion of the judge resume deliberation. The judge may declare a mistrial as to any charges upon which the jury cannot agree upon a verdict; *provided, however, that the judge may first require the jury to return verdicts on those charges upon which the jury can agree and direct that such verdicts be received and recorded.*

I get mall phobia in any mall lol 😅😅😅

I hope you can tube full time 😊 I prefer your commentary and then doing free law is awesome.

Missed this last night but here we are at 3am.. up again due to Puppy named AlPacino who has a broken leg and wants to lay on my face with his cast

EDB and Runkle starting at the same time is fine for me xD I have to replay crew both of you anyway, because both of you started at around 2:30 am my time and I'm asleep by then. So I can just watch both streams after one another xD

Replay crew over dinner 🫶🫶🫶

Replay crew tonight. Want to hear your take as defense as opposed to EDB! BTW, EDB said in this case, the juror lockdown is forever.

Good Luck with ProBono

Thanks Runkle. You’re the best. 🥰

Ian talking about people not being able to afford an attorney is one of the scariest things about this trial. KR could be any one of us. Luckily KR and her family were/are able to pay for some of the best attorneys. A lot of us wouldn’t be able to hire attorneys of their caliber.

Auntie bev has screwed this us so bad that the state should just drop it and try to save face.

I believe the judge was looking for the court reporter.

52:29 As an dual Aussie and UK citizen who doesn't give a toss about the monarchy, I reckon you'd enjoy listening to The Smiths song The Queen Is Dead. Lyrically.. well.. it's Morrissey, so.. you just gotta.