Kiss and Tell | 4-Sided Dive | Episode 16: Discussing Up To C3E70 

All those great shipper names but no one has thought of the obvious.... NightMare

"Ride or Die" is literally right there

7:42 I'm screaming over the fact that Laura went into the campaign fully intending for Imogen and Laudna to be platonic only to end up getting super jealous and falling for Laudna anyway. No one is immune to Laura Bailey romance, not even Laura Bailey herself.

The way Laura talks about the confession makes it sound like the horse girl in her head simply demanded for it to happen and Laura was just a vessel.

okay, but "fucking the wrong raven" conversation had me in stitches

Horseghoul is insane as a shipname. I need this to be a thing.

“We are NOT gonna be romantic. We really wanna show a solid platonic female friendship.” Fate: “And I took that personally.”

Everytime Vax comes back, Chetney gains another year

Very good on Matt for preemptively starting the Imaudna conversation with “Don’t do this in your home games without establishing that comfort”. Very responsible since so many people will do things that may not work at home since they saw it in CR.

I would like to thank Erika Ishii for stirring the Imogen/Laudna "friendship" and making Laura realize some things about her character

the difference between sam reading so poorly off the prompter and then laura and matthew doing it like normal people afterwards has me in stitches. skill issue my man.

Regarding the Omar cam: it's the weight. Dogs are calmed by the snugness of harnesses, especially when they put pressure on the back. This is how Thunderjackets work.

Can't wait for Liam to inevitably make the tower fall for the third time during the next episode

Sam's complete refusal to acknowledge that not one single episode of Critical Role has ever been aired on national television is always a delight.

When Laura went into mom mode, it was so adorable!! ❤️❤️

Who would dare take Laura's dice? The stories of Laura leaving a frigging awards show that she was nominated in because she thought Sam touched her dice are the stuff of legend.

I can't believe no one said Nott's line about Caleb. "He is my boy, I keep him safe."

I love that they muted what you could hear from Laura and Travis’ convo when Ronin was speaking

Let's all collectively thank Erika Ishii for confusing Laura and literally getting them together

Sam actually is a really good host. He brings the topic back when needed, he asks everyone for opinions and he makes sure that the conversation don't stale

22:07 Dani: You don't have to introduce partners to parents who don't give a fuck about you. Therapy lesson for the week. Thank you, Dani!

Matt realizing he was going to have to call chetney a weird wooden shaft in his spear reference and trying to dance out of it

My favorite quote is from Ashley/Fearne "Time is a weird soup"

After hearing about the classism in the Age of Arcannum and how people 'on the ground' barely had access to magic, I think it would be interesting to have a campaign set in that time, where everyone are magic-less classes, like fighters, rogues and barbarians.

Missed opportunity for Hearse Girl

Poor Omar on the tower of inquiry. The look on his face says "My humans have gone insane." lol

I melted when Laura stopped the show to talk to Ronin.

I very much agree with Matt. Worst moment was Eshteros dying offscreen.

absolutely wild how Laura at 7:42 describes the most accurate 'in love with your best friend'/'lesbian realization experience' ever. if that isn't relatable af

4SD Timestamps 0:47 - Roll for Tavern Keep 1:06 - Sam is Tavern Keep 1:30 - Prompter read 4:44 - Episode Intro 5:05 - What is up with that? 5:13 - Imodna 5:50 - Other ship names 6:16 - How did it happen? Who knew first? 6:30 - When did you know as characters and as yourselves? (Platonic Female Friendship) 7:42 - Imogen was jealous 8:23 - Expecting Laudna to say no 8:37 - Matt talks about the importance of knowing player boundaries and consent 9:10 - Jealous Laudna (Imogen being friends with Orym & FRIDA) 9:52 - Pep talks 10:25 - Dani’s reaction to the tether convo 11:06 - Don’t know if it’s okay anymore 12:14 - Hearing all of Laudna’s thoughts 12:38 - The Circlet 13:00 - Early stages of their relationship 13:50 - Not a secret, but not flaunting their relationship 14:02 - Chetney knows about Imodna (Too weird to judge them) 15:48 - Party Center 16:20 - Sam’s other ship name ideas 16:34 - When did Laudna know? 17:28 - Laudna invested in Imogen’s wellbeing since the beginning 18:06 - Whitestone Andy vs. Imogen 18:38 - The Snake Ring 19:36 - Dani sees herself in Imodna 20:38 - Matt’s ship name suggestion 21:05 - Will the relationship affect battle moves in the future? 21:47 - Imogen’s Parents 23:37 - Protective of Imogen 23:57 - Delilah’s back 25:02 - Spells in bed 26:30 - Keyleth & Zephrah 26:42 - The Blue Flowers 27:15 - Call from Travis 28:35 - Visiting Keyleth 29:05 - Keyleth’s anger 29:58 - Keyleth hasn’t moved on (Her Raven) 31:51 - She also can’t move on 32:21 - Vax saving Keyleth (twice) 32:40 - Vax breaking divine rules 33:23 - Random civilian dying 33:50 - C1 Nothic Reference 34:15 - The Raven isn’t visiting Keyleth 34:37 - Teven, Champion of Asmodeus 36:09 - Zerxus 37:39 - Small bit of goodness in him still 38:20 - Sleepy Omar 38:40 - Bassuras 38:44 - D Debate 39:42 - Was there a path to see D? 40:52 - Ludinus seen in Rexxentrum, but also on the Moon? 41:30 - FCG didn’t get resolution 42:16 - Devexian 42:50 - Who saw Devexian? 43:38 - Dani really should get a Lore Keeper Sting 44:00 - Tower of Inquiry 44:25 - Omar Cam 44:38 - Laura pulls a block 46:04 - What do you think your character would do if they were suddenly dropped into the Age of Arcanum? 46:55 - FCG starting a cult 50:07 - Ruidus in Age of Arcanum 50:54 - Matt pulls from the tower 51:00 - Pepe 51:34 - What’s your favorite one-liner from any campaign? 53:33 - Marisha pulls from the tower (and Omar) 55:02 - What item in your inventory currently means the most to you and why? 55:22 - Pâté 56:22 - Coin Boys 58:22 - Sam bullying Marisha’s coffee order 59:33 - The Deep Dive 1:00:15 - Sam, how is FCG doing having reunited with Dancer and meeting her new automatons? 1:01:56 - Kimothee (Sam pulls from the tower 1:03:27 - How do you think the party’s recent split and reunion have strengthened, weakened or rearranged the relationships or travelling groups which were created pre-stream? How do you think the newer relationships will be affected? 1:04:25 - Orym and Fearne 1:04:56 - Dynamics depend on seating arrangements 1:05:52 - Guest Seating 1:07:30 - Sam pulls another block (Laura’s promise) 1:08:22 - If your character taught a class, what would it be and why? 1:10:50 - Marisha, how does Laudna feel about the Eidolons? Why do they speak to her, rather than the gods? 1:12:13 - Omar takes a nap 1:12:28 - What was it like for Imogen to confront her mother above Ruidus? How is she feeling towards Liliana now? (Losing hope in her) 1:14:27 - Foiling a lie detector 1:15:31 - Matt, what are you excited for in the Shattered Teeth? 1:18:14 - Mermaid oneshot 1:19:28 - Sam, where did Shithead come from? Was it your idea or Matt’s idea? 1:21:57 - Marisha, what was it like for you to see Keyleth so wounded and go through a quest specifically to save her? 1:23:17 - Laura, how does Imogen feel about agreeing to plant the brood pit from the All Minds Burn? What was that interaction like for her? (Seeing the Importance of the Gods) 1:25:28 - Matt, how do you feel about losing Ratanish in that battle? Did you have more plans for Otohan’s second-in-command? (Possibility that Bells Hells would have been hunted more) 1:28:25 - More Ship Names 1:29:25 - Matt pulls from the tower 1:30:31 - What has been the most heartbreaking thing that happened to your character this campaign? And what has been the most heartwarming thing that happened to your character this campaign? 1:33:24 - BREAK STARTS 1:43:56 - BREAK ENDS 1:44:29 - Everyone’s characters 1:45:12 - Matt, what was inspiration behind All-Minds-Burn and its alien mind? 1:45:37 - Round 1 1:46:40 - Delilah is confirmed to be back! How is Laudna feeling now that she has that voice back in her head? To know that she didn’t get rid of her? 1:47:05 - Sharks! 1:47:29 - Laura wins! 1:47:47 - Round 2 1:48:13 - Draw 1:48:29 - Sam, how did it feel for FCG to kill Shithead- a symbol for their guilt? 1:48:40 - Round 3 1:49:13 - Draw 1:49:35 - Imogen and the Reilora. Is she turning into one? (Round 4) 1:50:00 - Marisha wins! 1:50:23 - Round 5 1:50:31 - Laura wins! 1:50:53 - Round 6 1:50:54 - Sam, do you hope to run into D in the future? Does FCG have any interest in speaking to him? 1:51:06 - Matt wins! 1:51:23 - Round 7 1:51:40 - Marisha wins! 1:52:06 - Round 8 1:52:16 - Matt, why did you decide to put Graz’tchar in the game? What came first the desire to explore the Grey Valley, or the desire for Travis to get another cursed sword? 1:54:35 - Laura, Imogen mentioned she could give into Ruidus. Does she want to give in and see what happens or is that a last resort? 1:55:52 - Marisha, This is some of the longest time we’ve spent in Zephrah on stream. How is it going to Zephrah with Laudna in your head and Keyleth in your heart? 1:57:08 - Draw 1:57:23 - Sam, how did FCG feel accompanying Orym to Will and Derrig’s graves? 1:57:32 - Round 9 1:58:11 - Matt wins! 1:58:27 - Animated Dog Fighting 1:58:33 - Round 10 1:58:54 - Marisha, how did you feel about your dog fight? 1:59:22 - Sam wins! 1:59:40 - Matt, what was the deal with Shithead and was he a revenant? 1:59:47 - Round 11 2:01:05 - Imogen and Laudna, how excited are you both about telling Zhudonna you are now dating? 2:01:27 - Draw 2:01:44 - Laura, Imogen’s opinion of the gods has changed… (already read) 2:01:47 - Round 12 2:02:20 - Matt, what’s up with the Dawnfather? 2:02:50 - Marisha wins! 2:03:09 - Round 13 (FCG hasn’t learned anything about the Changebringer) 2:03:31 - Sam wins! 2:04:00 - Round 14 2:04:40 - Marisha, Laudna hasn’t commented on Imogen’s growing lighting marks. What are her thoughts about it? 2:06:16 - Sam wins! 2:06:36 - Round 15 2:07:03 - Matt wins! 2:07:26 - Round 16 2:07:58 - Marisha is the first to 4 stars! 2:08:51 - Picking Costumes for Halloween Special! 2:10:15 - Costumes! 2:11:44 - Last Years’ Costumes 2:12:09 - Clean up! 2:12:32 - Karaoke 2:13:33 - Moppo & Santa I’m very excited for the Halloween episode and 4 Frighted Dive. Let me know if I missed any moments!

Also I love that when Laura is on the show she's like "FOLLOW THE JENGA RULES" and every other episode people are like "yeah sure whatever you want"

I'm watching C1 for the 1st time atm and my favourite one-liner so far is "You're at the bottom of my list." So fucking cold, I love it. I got chills from that moment, amazing line.

loving the imodna talk, but i also really appreciate the talk about chetney. he's such a lovely character

“Always remember your consent!!!” Henry crabgrass 😂❤

The best one liners convo, how was it not- “you can leave, when Burt Reynolds says you can leave”

The long delayed response to Sam's "before he became a lens" was glorious

Favorite Line: "I smell like a crayon."

Someone touched Laura's dice: sacrilege🤣

I love that Laura went through a whole lesbian gay panic moment through Imogen.

Never steal from a dice goblin, especially not this one. :D

I really appreciate Matt's comment about how we need to be very careful on how we change the narrative on the fly. Sometimes it can be amazing, but it could also ruin the other person's expectation and plans of their character arc. And they've been doing this for years, so they trust each other to make the right decisions that both people would agree with.

“chetney has been telling FCG to start a cult” ok but the only thing i can think of now is that one audio of “dont you wanna become a cult leader? since the death of god theres been an absence. you could fill that void”

i love how omar is in two of the portraits in the thumbnail. everybody has to remain in their own, only omar can cross the boundaries as he should

Laura getting so immediately excited about an all-mermaid one shot is honestly the cutest thing.

Not even two minutes in and Laura’s mad that her dice were stolen 😂

Another favorite line: *Huge intake of air* "Ugh, I thought he'd never leave!"

Favourite one liner “we are basically gods!” Jumps of cliff and splat -keyleth

Please, please, PLEASE have them play Gang Beasts again. I have not laughed like that in weeks. :D And SOMEONE is going to be roundly cursing Sam Riegel next month for leaving the Tower like THAT.

33:01 Vax has been protecting Keyleth in the shadows, and every time he does that he is breaking the rules and gets punished for it

Them discussing the potential of spells during sex has me thinking of caleb German accent: "Fireböl"

Holy sharts this group is DYNAMITE. I really enjoyed the gaming segment. 😂

When she said Ronin is starting kinder garden made me feel sooooo old.

“I wasn’t planning on romancing Laudna, but then I kept getting jealous” This is so real lol I fkn love her so much.

Somehow Sam objecting to the word 'Evergreen' made me go like "Woah... Sam said something that made sense in his madness" 😂😂

Gang Beasts is like the perfect 4SD game. Listening to them scream and grunt the answers was hilarious.

Hearing them talk about how the confession was just, a surprise that happened naturally? It actually reminds me of my own game I’m a player in. The druid of our group surprised everyone by asking out my character at a Gala hosted by my parents! And so far? Super cute slow burn, I love it, and I am just, AHHHH! Romance that happens naturally in games is just SO GOOD!

We're all looking forward to sexy thirst trap waluigi. It'll be Travis 😂

It's absolutely incredible how Laura and Marisha were completely oblivious to their relationship because from day one I thought they were romantic and always felt Laudna reciprocated more than Imogen.

thank you dani carr for your service asking all the imodna questions i owe you my life

watching them play Gang Beasts was genuinely riveting content. I was on the edge of my seat and had to keep rewinding when I realized I hadn't heard a single word from their question responses

In this episode of 4-Sided Dive: a big bunch of wooden bricks spit in the face of gravity!

They were indeed roommates

I just want an episode of Matt and Sam creating ship names

I'm here for the C plot: Sam vs. Kyle

what i've learned is laura bailey does not control the imogen and both laura and marisha ended up in the queer girl story of falling in love with your best friend

Shout out to Omar, Dogrector of Photography

I love that Marisha is playing the old man while Matt is playing the old lady in that game at the end 🥺💕

4 sided dive has become so fond to my heart. This is hands down their best episode to date! Just watching them, hang out and throw some answers out casually while SCREAMING about the game is top class friendship and energy.

Laura Bailey is so method that Imogen actually got jealous about Laudna. That's acting.

Probably off-topic, but I love that Dani is wearing the mermaid pendant from Stardew Valley. Whether it signifies something with her partner or it's just plain nerdery, I love to see it.

As someone who DD's often, I completely empathize with Dani attempting to ask the crew serious questions while they're playing a ridiculous melee game.

I love how the question and gameplay portion was SO chaotic! Nobody could stop laughing!

What is up with Vylia or Vilya because DID EVERYONE FORGET ABOUT HER?

Imodna ship name idea: Dread Lightning.

Corpse Bridle. I'll see myself out now.

Man, this was a great one. And one big Critter *THANK YOU!!* to Dani Carr for being our voice in the room XD

Dark and Stormy! Laudna and Imogen are Dark and Stormy.

The "Omar Pull",- the best pull from The Tower of Inquiry. WOOF 🐕

Can’t believe they didn’t think of Night-mare.

Sam: "So, I'm the tavern kee-" Dani: "HOLD UP I'M REAL HAPPY FOR YA IMMA LET YOU FINISH BUT **IMODNA IS CANON!!** "

Can't wait for Matt to do a bunch of research on deep sea creatures and use that to inspire the underwater campaign.

I'm starting to have a feeling that 4-Sided Dive's Canned Bits might be able to solve all my problems.

Bro. Seeing Laura take the call and be a mom was actually pretty fucking awesome

Everything in this episode is amazing, side note Matts voice for Pate reminds me of Jim Trott from The Vicor of Dibley and I love it

I’m SOOO HAPPY they keep the mess up version as the official! ❤😂

“Ride-and-Die” would be such a cool ship name for Imogen and Lauda!

this is hands down the best episode of 4 sided dive in its history. dani was an absolute joy and I hope she continues to become more involved with the show. also, I love that the conversations were allowed to flow into different topics instead of just answering one specific question and moving on. 10/10 no notes.

I'm not gonna spoil the Halloween outfit picks, but if the outfit Marisha picked isn't assigned to Ashley I feel like there *will* be a riot on Tumblr

41:40 Dancer's speech to FCG was so perfect on her saying she's moved on, why can't he. It was such a great moment to show people how you don't need closure to move on, you just move on. I hope FCG (and maybe Sam) learns from that

The BEST 4SD ever produced

10:20 Dani being iconic (also love how she styled the Imogen denim shirt)

Sam wearing the P4 shirt gave me so much life!! Teddy representing

Help it’s again is my favorite quote of them all

37:19 Well now I’m just sad for Xerxes all over again 😢

I wouldn't usually say this sorta thing but everyone's outfits are so on point in this episode!!

32:18 Vax's supposed to be present whenever important people pass, right? So I like to imagine that the "illegal" part is not him being there, but actually preventing Kiki's death: Attack episode- Matron: hey, your girlfriend's gonna die, go help her pass, she's the Tempest after all Vax: yeah bet **makes sure she doesn't** Matron: you're grounded Otohan episode- Matron: this time is real, please do your job. this'll be a tough one so you can be by her side when she dies Vax: thanks mom **SAVES HER and gets orbed** Matron: wtf dude?!?!?!

It's honestly kinda funny to me that they were intending for this to stay platonic at first. The married couple vibes have been strong since episode 1.

"You need me, more than I need you. Give it back!"

It's always the "we're only besties, guys" lmaoo

Matt suggesting shocking grasp as a potential sex spell.