Mark Redwine Case Analysis | Shame Motivated Homicide 

It is clear the family court system needs an overhaul. When a boy is literally afraid for his life and the court orders he spend time with the man he fears will murder him, there is a serious defect in the system. My heart goes out to the mom and brother. They were completely powerless and now have to carry this horrific burden of Dylan's tragic death. A great cautionary tale. Thank you Dr Grande 🌵🌵🌵🌵

I agree, Dr Grande. Mark is guilty. Excellent analysis, but this case breaks my heart. The legal system failed Dylan by forcing him to visit an unfit parent. When children speak we need to listen.

“Embarrassing photos” has to be the understatement of the century - outrageous.

Now the whole world knows about those pictures.

"Apparel choices & dining preferences." Oh Doc, touché. LOL

Mark knew that every year Dylan got closer to 18, he was losing his last hold over Dylan and Elaine. He had already lost Cory. Killing Dylan punishes Elaine, Cory, and Dylan forever. That’s why he’s not even bothered enough to act upset about going to prison for murdering his child. He got 72 years and sweet revenge. He gave them a life sentence. What a monster.

Assassin bears carrying bleach. Makes perfect sense.

Finding images like that on a parents computer should be immediate grounds for removal of custody privileges

I was washing dishes listening from afar, and suddenly "consuming feces from a diaper".

I was gonna describe his look in the mug shot as a “shit-eating grin” but then I thought you know, too soon.

He's got that drunk uncle in your room at 4 in the morning look.

My attorney told me, “Never take a photo/video that your mother can’t see!”

As awful as the details are of any murder, I appreciate the humor and sarcasm you inserted in the story telling. It makes hearing this a bit more tolerable. I’m glad they caught the killer. It’s so heartbreaking that it was the victim’s own father. There are some things I will never be able to understand and that’s one of them.

Since I have a little time while I’m eating my lunch, I think I’ll watch a Dr. Grande video. Five minutes later… Maybe I’ll just never eat lunch again.

"There was some doubt in this case but it didn't rise to the level of reasonable." If only the Casey Anthony jurors had understood that.

You forgot that Mark was a raging alcoholic on top of all the weird shit. He might have done this regardless of the photos, it seems like he was waiting for any chance to prove he was the boss, like his son was his property. I really wish kids weren’t treated as such when it comes to divorce :(

I also think that killing Dylan could have been an act of revenge. This case reminds me of the Ancient Greek tragedy Medea, who also killed her children in order to seek revenge against her husband. Even though she was the mother and not the father, the elements of shame, hatred and revenge are the same. It’s an incomprehensible act, however I believe that many couples who are in acrimonious divorce often use their own children to hurt each other, obviously not rising to the level of murder, yet still cruel. 😕 Thank you as always Dr. Grande.❤️

Always a "like" before a listen for Dr. Grande. 😎👍

So it's fair to say that Dylan was killed by a wild animal...."HIS FATHER".

So so so incredibly sad. My heart breaks for Dylan's mom and brother. I actually lived around the corner from this a$$ scum at Vallecito Lake, CO when this all happened. We all hoped and prayed that Dylan ran off but of course new deep down that his father was guilty. I will never forget this case. Glad he was found guilty after all this time. Have been following this case since 2012-2013. Hope his family finds peace.

Log assisted attack. Phhhft! The details and how everything is delivered so deadpan despite it being ridiculous makes this channel worth while.

Those photos sound absolutely insane.

Dr Grande I'm "BEYOND" happy that your covering this case !!.......you really are the best speculator on RU-vid.

This case haunts me. Truly. Once again, looking forward to your analysis and thoughts on this case and this terrible father. Also, I want to just say "thank you" for all of your recent content! You and a couple of other of my favorite youtubers have helped me get through the past several days since being diagnosed with Covid19. I have been able to watch a lot of great videos to help keep my mind busy, (when I'm not sleeping!) Covid has been really rough for me. Keep staying as safe as you can, everyone! It's worth it.

I love Dr Grandes sense of humor so much. "You can differentiate these types of bears because they're holding bleach". Lol

This is REALLY one of the saddest cases you have covered - and you have covered some sad cases. You did an exemplary breakdown as always but I just wish Dylan was listened to when he was alive😔

This one made me cry a little. Such a young person, likely killed by a parent due to uncontrolled rage and spite. Really sad to think of his mother wanting to protect him from his father, but ultimately being unable to keep him out of harm's way. Her anguish must have been intense.

@8:44 “embarrassing images” is the understatement of the century 😳

LMAO Dr. Grande "so i guess his attorney was considering experiencing both sides of the criminal justice system - probably just as research to be a better attorney"

This is one of the saddest cases I’ve ever followed. Dylan’s poor mother. I don’t know how she manages to go on.

"Mark of course was free to do what ever he wanted as far as apparel AND DINING PREFERENCES" Blahhhhhhhhh! No, No, No, Nooooo! Why'd you have to go there Dr. G?.... Why!!!!???? 😂😂😂😂

"I guess it could've been one of those notorious bears who break into houses without causing damage, kill people with blunt objects, attempt to clean up the crime scene, then dispose of the bodies." Of course they carry around bleach duhhhhh

thank you for pointing out how to tell the difference between regular and assassin bears.

‘That Chapter’ is a great sister channel to this channel.

Just a reminder, I'm not diagnosing anybody in this video; only speculating on what could be happening with a cross-dressing craphound like this.

My broken heart goes out to the mother, my best friend lost her young son to leukemia 2 years ago, watching and being alongside her grief has changed me forever. I can’t imagine losing a child, let alone in such a brutal way.

"Dining preferences" 🤣 lol thank you Dr Grande for always being there to making me laugh

I like the jab about the "Assassin Bears", very nice.😆😁🤪

But now everyone knows about him/his story.

When he sent his older brother the text message saying " Hey send me those poop pics of papa, he said yall were a bad influence, I want to show him what he really is". I lost in in laughter. I know this isnt funny but that part alone had me rolling on the floor

"I don't know if there is really an upside to memorializing that particular diaper related incident" 😂😂

Pic at left is 20 miles south of Durango. Dr. Grande has innovated yet another way to analyze true crime questions and I’m ❤️ing how deftly Dr. G’s new narrative form for the Redwine content puts mental health down to another possible factor rather than the main factor in violent behavior. Thank you for being so smart and fair in your work, Dr. G.

Forcing a child to stay with a debased disgusting man is appaling. If the mother knew about the photographs couldn't she have got a court order to protect her son?

Elaine Redwine wisely chose to divorce this miserable human and tried to protect her children by keeping her sons away from their father . It always seems that few people believe women when they speak about the violence and degradation that goes on at home . Much of the murderer's behaviour is consistent with narcissism and other issues . Many divorced men use the kids to punish the ex partner and what works better than disposing of him ? This is certainly a case where one person's 'rights' should not have held sway over the courts .

I just can't get over Mark Redwine eating... you know what. I can't fathom anyone doing that. Cringe!

My heart breaks for Dylan.

I'm very thankful you covered this case; again, it is so sad that these types of disagreements lead to what is so tragic. It is good to have your insight, so that it may be prevented in the future. Thanks, Dr. Grande.

Dude even looks like a super bad person…he’s one of those people that looks like he has meanness just oozing out of him.

So sad that this young man was robbed of his life. Haunting case.

So unbeliveble and sad....and disgusting. What a shame He blamed it on the poor bears.😡

Omg you humor is off the charts! Dwl@ differentiating between the bears!!!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣. I wish you worked in psych department at my hospital!

Your voice makes me happy❤️Good day, Dr. G😊

Also its almost comforting hearing what you think happened in an event or situation...as we all are trying to figure these things out...especially when it's the murder of a child. Cant understand how a human being can kill their own child. Again...I hope Dylan's father rots away. Thanks again.

That horrible that he killed his son for that liking him and to get revenge on Elaine. Great video Dr Grande!!! Hope you are having a great day!!!

Thank you - for your delivery of the subject matter you cover on your stream (and I thoroughly appreciate the dark humor)

This guy's humor and his approach to his humor with these cases give me a good laugh he's actually deep down low key hilarious LOL and informative and smart so keep it up bro

"We are all suspects in this case" is my new goto response to all criticism.

I thought those assassin bears only lived near the Urals?! Oh no....

Very good video. I did laugh at the "dining preference" and the bear analogy, that was great and lifted a small bit of this grim story off me. I think your analysis is correct. Heat of the moment striking out and then double shame on him for the fetish AND the murder of his own son. Sadly I don't think he is capable of fully owning his actions. Mental health is a very bizarre universe unto itself. Rest in peace Dylan, you didn't deserve this.

Thanks for the update, I know a bit of this case from another channel (True Crime recaps) was really disgusted by his dad 's poop fetish, it haunted me for days

He killed Dylan out of embarassment and wanting his secret to die with him . Or to prevent further spread of the photo. Maybe he was unaware of how many people had it.

"... probably just trying to understand both sides of the justice system". That's classic dry humor. Gotta love him.😂

It should be cheap to feed him in prison.

Here is a question I have to pose to Dr. Grande. I am what you may call a "recovering narcissist." Some life issues caused me to become self aware of my lifetime of narcissism, and I've been seeing myself and the world in a different light. I've treated my spouse and others badly, being deep in the narcissistic frame of mind. I'm looking for ways to heal and understand things, but...I see dozens of videos on youtube about how to leave the narcissist, beat the narcissist, defeat the narcissist, survive the narcissist, disarm the narcissist, shut down the narcissist, have revenge on the narcissist, crush the narcissist, destroy the narcissist, make the narcissist suffer forever (lots of videos on that one), and yes, kill the narcissist. It is very hard to find anything to help the narcissist change their ways. Can you please offer some insight into helping the narcissist to recover? I have read that it is rare for a narcissist to be self aware enough to change their ways, but can you offer anything on the spiritual battle of leaving your own narcissistic ways behind?

"Bear Assassin!" Menu Preferences! Top of your game, Dr. G! 🐾🐻

Ohhhh I've been waiting for you to cover this case!!!!! And of course you didn't disappoint!

Hehe love how you call it the “Phil McGraw show.” That man isn’t helping anyone!

Confronting Mark with the photos sealed Dylan's fate.

I find it very ironic that in most interviews he clearly has "PINK EYE". How nasty can one be??🤢🤮

Good afternoon Dr. Grande! Counting the hours until I can sit back and enjoy the video:)🙂

You are what you eat.

What a horribly tragic case! Dillon's wishes should have been respected and then granted! So many unimaginable things in this case! Really enjoyed your thoughts on this, and your great wit is always appreciated! ♡

This video is so well done and straightforwardly clear. Good stuff doc.

Great. Now I’m afraid of Assassin Bears..

I love it when Dr.Grande and That Chapter cover the same case.

Dr. Grande mentions red wine and I immediately like 🍷

"The Phil McGraw Show" ooo shots fired

“Differentiated from normal bears, by carrying around bleach” 🤣👍🏻

Love Dr Grande's specifications without breaking out in raged laughters about the unusual assasination bears who are skilled to break into houses without leaving traces and also carry bottles of bleach. It sort of remind me of the businessowners who have this breed of dogs that can get into safe places and munch up years of result- and balancesheets.

He should have argued that the blood was actually red wine

I went to Fort Lewis College in Durango, Colorado. Ellan Redwine was my financial advisor at the college. She was so nice. It breaks my heart this happened to her. They found the son and arrested the dad...

Always enjoy your analysis of these cases so much !!!

Eating feces from a diaper. Dr. G. Please give us your analogy of this😆

Thanks Dr. Todd, love your story telling.

Good morning Dr Grande. Great analysis. I believe that Mark is guilty, l feel he did it for the photos,but I believe the main reason was for revenge against his ex wife. That was a sad and informative case. Thank you Dr Grande.

So I used to know Mark Redwine, Corey and Dylan when I was younger. I was in the class as Corey in 4th and 5th grade, and he lived across the street from me. His dad has ALWAYS been abusive. They didn't always live in Durango, they lived in another area for a short time before all this went down. I even got interviewed by the FBI because of a previous engagement Mark and I had when I was 11

As usual, your analysis was spot on. Thank you Dr Grande.

Wasn’t easy but you once again addressed this case with your usual tact and grace. Still not dinner conversation. 🙊

Excellent analysis Dr Grande!! I agree with you all accounts. My heart goes out to the mother and brother. What a weirdo! She should have left him sooner and not had two boys.

I know a family where mom has fully custody but dad gets to see the sons every once in a while. Doesn’t matter if it’s right before drop off, if one of the sons says he doesn’t want to go they don’t have to. From how I see it it helps a lot with anxiety and keeps the kids knowing they have a choice and say in it. At first one kid didn’t go very often but with time he enjoys going more with his brothers!

I just came from seeing the pictures, I can't unsee them now 🤢

I don't understand how you would do that to your own son? I also don't understand how people like him get to be parents/father. Smh

Looks like Mark has chronic issues concerning how he interacts with logs.

Dr. Grande just cracks me up. I don't see how he keeps a straight face when saying this stuff. I wanna see him at least smile once to prove he's not an AI . " THESE ASSASIN BEARS YADA YADA".

Beware of bleach holding Bears✌️💙love you Dr G

I laughed at “dining preferences”…and honestly Embarrassment is a part of parenting. This is so sad, I remember this story but didn’t know this was the ending

Please cover the Otto Warmbier case?

“Mark was free to do what he wanted as far as apparel choices and dinning preferences” 🤢

"Dining preferences" 😆😆 Oh Dr.Grande , I love your humor!!!

I was about to eat lunch, but no thanks.