Martin Scorsese on GONE WITH THE WIND 

You can also add The Wizard of Oz and Citizen Kane. Two other iconic films from golden hollywood

@@Leg0456 citizen kane the best movie of all time and the Godfather

Singin not singing

@@muhammadirvansyahsyahaziz7758 yessir

The Left have turned into the censorship pigs they used to despise. Destroying art will never be intelligent or "progressive." In fact, they've hijacked the words "progressive" and "liberal"as neither actually describes anything coming from those idiots. They have turned into the intolerant, book burning Nazis. They even have one race of people as the evil oppressors, just like Nazis. *The current day Left/globalists are SICK HYPOCRITES who deserve to be ridiculed and mocked out of intelligent society.*

Uh, I don’t think that the novel is a criticism of the South as a whole. I think that the novel is really a love letter to the South, especially the old South. But it’s also not afraid to point out the flaws of it either. But by no means does the novel indicate that the South was on the wrong side of history. The novel exudes hatred towards the North. But that’s the point. It is _the_ great Southern novel, and heck probably a contender for “the great American novel” period.

I thought it was a very feminist sort of perspective of war and life at that time the Author was a Southern woman herself it just resonated how strong the women had to be they still could not even vote after the war while black MEN could they had no say in that war but they still lost their husbands brothers etc. Many died in childbirth worked in hospitals slaved in fields themselves and look how condemned the main character was just for wanting to run the lumber business because that was unlady like Rhett treated her horribly even though he pursued her for years. I always liked to think maybe she did get a happy ending after Rhett died Ashley and she probably finally got together since Melly had died and Bonny they would have needed eachother then.

John Wayne was an enormous shitbag poser that couldn’t come near Clark Gable.

“Otherwise aged well”? It literally villainizes the North and defends those that fought to keep slavery. The whole film is built on that foundation

Hahah whats that! The movie is great and is still good. The political propaganda doesnt changr anything. 12 Years a slave is also propaganda ;)

@@ClashGamerGTA 12 years a slave is a true story and sympathises with the right side of history. Unbelievably stupid comparison

@@aaronjenkins5179 If you watch a analyse, you will see that 12 years a slave isnt that true! And the fact, that you call one side as the right side is propaganda of our community. Im glad that there is no slavery anymore, but the movie is still a great movie and shouldnt be banned because it is a propaganda movie, like all the other movies in the world, only because of the fact, that is on the side of a lost civilisation. It is also mansioned that the south, the stero types, are gone with the wind;)

@@aaronjenkins5179 if it sypathises with a side, it is propaganda ;). Unbelievable stupid "argument".

Lol 😂

Perfect. Marty's so ... uh ... profoundly ... well, mid-20th ... sort of. LOL!

I say of all time cinema

I also liked this phrase: unlocks the fantasy part of your brain...

Nothing to complain about it! Great movie

Yeah. Lol.

The movie could’ve been historically accurate and simply featured characters who are pro slavery, but the movie itself seems to be pro slavery.

I do agree with Casablanca is better than Gone With The Wind but it doesn’t crush it

I agree, in terms of Story Casablanca takes it, in terms of the spectacle, great epicness, Gone With The Wind takes it

Don't think Casablanac crushes so much as it gives Gone with the Wind a serious limp. Still, both films are fantastic works in their own right.

I preferred GWTW

If you don't say why and substantiate it your opinion is crap

No it's super racist

Scorsese saying Marvel ain't cinema meanwhile he keeps remaking goodfellas over and over again

It's garbage ,because it uses the currency of a fantasy version of history.....the reality of the genocide+ ,land theft of the native people; the deceit , mass rape ,murder,torture of slavery ,means that this authors whole outlook was smoke grenaded .....her heroine is navigating a rotten system, that benefitted a tiny minority,who enacted an invirtuous, murderous, sedition from the king of England......her world is an ideologically evil one , constructed immorally and amorally,for her classes benefit,at the constitutional,institutional, legislative ,expense of everyone else ; racially,+ socio-economically.....

Why not ?

jslasher1 facts💯 you’re asking a director who specializes in gangster movies about one of the most melodramatic romance movies ever made yes the GREATEST movie ever made period. As much as I like Scorsese’s work after awhile I feel like it’s the same stuff over and over. When you’re a great director who can do many different high levels of a diverse array of film genres then you can have the clout to comment on a fill as great as GWTW and have it hold some precedence and value but not for a director who while great in his genre of film really hasn’t produced high level film outside of his own genre.

@@46foryounger Is Taxi Driver a gangster movie? Is Raging Bull? There are gangsters in it, but it's not a gangster movie. What about Last Temptation of Christ? Shutter Island? Hugo? Is that not diverse? Of all the films Scorsese has directed, maybe 6 or 7 of them are gangster movies.

​@@46foryounger You clearly know NOTHING about Scorsese's body of work if think he only does gangster movies & has no diversity. Alice Doesn't Live Here Anymore, Taxi Driver, New York New York, Raging Bull, The King of Comedy, The Color of Money, After Hours, The Last Temptation of Christ, Cape Fear, The Age of Innocence, Kundun, Bringing Out the Dead, Gangs of New York (despite part of the word gangster in the title, it is not a Mafia film, which is what people like you refer to when you say he only does gangster movies), The Aviator, Shutter Island, Hugo, The Wolf of Wall Street & Silence are NOT gangster movies. The only movies in that genre are Mean Streets, Goodfellas, Casino, The Departed & The Irishman. The rest of his work are quite diverse. A family fantasy (Hugo), period costume romance (The Age of Innocence), religious pieces (Last Temptation, Silence), thrillers (Cape Fear, Shutter Island), & even quite bizarre dark comedies like After Hours. That is quite diverse. Besides, what does what films one makes qualifies them to talk about cinema? If you actually knew anything about Scorsese, he is a HUGE lover of cinema history & strongly advocates film preservation. He knows more about the history of the medium than just about anyone alive. But, even if your ignorant logic about having to be diverse in the medium is the only qualification to talk about cinema history, then Scorsese still can talk about Gone With the Wind because he made The Age of Innocence & Gangs of New York. Both period pieces. And again, YOU haven't made any films, so according to your logic, you can't talk about film in general.

@@zachjohnson637THANK you. The notion that Scorsese only makes gangster movies is itself a stereotype perpetuated by people too young to remember Scorsese’s reputation pre-GoodFellas.

He loves Gone With The Wind. He restored the film in the 8K digital restoration.