“If the people knew how to take the good and leave the bad they wouldn’t need to listen to you, they would be giving the lecture” this alone was enough JazaakAllaahu khayran.
Mufti menk was my main men to listen years ago, i loved it when he would recite the verses he wanted to quote. His recitation and smile was very captivating mashaAllah. I still have his recordings of those ayat. I memorized many of them and did dawah in that manner. But ever since his chocolate man comment, the way he answered that question disappointed me a lot. Thats when i realized that he is too worried about making friends with everyone and everyone liking his statements. I just dont feel comfortable listening to shuyookh that are also trying to be careful not offend anyone. The deen of ALLAH doesnt need to sugar coated for anyone, the truth is the truth, we are proud of it. I dont hate Mufti menk at all, i still love him for the sake of Allah but i dont listen to him anymore simply because i know im only getting a sugar coated version. The bluntness of Abu Mussab, being able to speak against ahlul bid’ah this is what draws me. I like when du’at say it like it is. Be honest, of course do it with respect but that doesnt mean that you sugar coat the truth. And if something is haram, dont be afraid to say it is. Who cares what people say?
You said it best akhi, Alhamdulilah I was never drawn to the sugarcoated daa’ees and Americanized du’aat - I try to be very stingy on who and what I give my attention to akhi.. from the time where an ad on food can make you go get some food, it shows me words have a big impact on you. Chose what you consume wisely and let it be the correct version of the deen - no sugarcoating or rainbows and happy ever after.. there’s a reason why the Hadith says hellfire is surrounded by all the things the nafs desires and Jannah is surrounded by all the things that is difficult on the nafs. So how is every day a good day and every lecture an uplifting inspiring lecture, that’s just an unrealistic world view!
I am from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳. I love Mufti Menk for the sake of Allah. During my darkest days I listen to Mufti and started learning Islam. I didn't have any book. But Alhamdulillah now I am making my own library Alhamdulillah. By following his advice I passed two times Central Teacher's Eligibility Test and one time Assam TET. Inshallah I will be a permanent teacher in a government school. He encouraged me with the following words that I will never forget "If we move towards positivity by one inch inshAllah we will enter Jannah one day without realizing" (like this) Now coming to the topic of the video we are humans and not flawless backed many Hadith ( I think don't need to be quoted)...my request to the reactioners please remember Allah tests differently...and this is a test for the reactioners also...so do react in a way that pleases Allah and more so you can make Dua for them before exposing them...we are brothers man!... May Allah guide us to the truth and help us to follow the truth Aameen
All is well, except that when you hear sheikhs like them saying to the people "take the good & leave the bad from everyone" & "we are all brothers regardless of what we believe", while among us are those who curse the companions and ahlul bayt (may Allaah be pleased with them all), make tawaf around graves, call upon their saints, reject the hadiths, reject the finality of the Prophethood of Muhammad (peace be upon him).... Then that's where the problem starts. But heyyy ... we are all "brothers", right?? And not addressing other's deviations and fabrications is going to make everyone happy, and Allaah will give us victory while his deen is being manipulated, twisted and distorted to the very foundations?? Yeah, that's a HUGE NO. It's about time we realize that the matter is much more serious that we perceive it to be.
And say, "Truth has come, and falsehood has departed. Indeed is falsehood, [by nature], ever bound to depart."[17:81].. Dear Akhi I am not defending Mufti Menk but I am defender of Islam....I just love him for the sake of Allah. Falsehood must be opposed..I am very sad for some people who when oppose to something they adopt some ways which is completely disgusting. I myself from a grave worshippers village. Holding on to Eeman is very hard. Make Dua for us Akhi.
Why do so many Indians feel the urge to keep posting the Indian flag, keep emphasizing they are from india? Do u Indians think u are special? Your country is special? Are you aware that only Indian muslims ‘marry’ Hindus. I’d be ashamed of India or at least embarrassed instead of harping on about india, india, …..come on man! Wake up
Mufti menk NEEDS to set his priorities straight! I mean, being nice and kind is not gonna take anyone to jannah if that person indulges in shirk and bid'ah.
So what way do you propose ? If that person indulges in shirk and bid' ah I am a Muslim, my mother is a Christain and my father a Hindu, I reverted 20 years ago Alhamdulillah only child and live with my parents so you tell me should I not be nice and kind in my speech to them regarding Islam?
@@flapjax3590 Buddy relax... I'll never know what its like to have youre burden, may Allah keep us all steadfast on the path and grant us ease. Im sure @Nida Eshaque original comment was just about Mufti Menk, not to poke anything to anybody else, so... please calm down. Im just a mere layman, i followed Mufti Menk for a longtime be honest felt off after the chocolate man comment and the radio thing. Mufti menk is a public figure, so Alhamdulillah many people have a say if anything he convey is off. Im sure Mufti Menk is very aware of the risks of social media. I pray to Allah everybody in our family will recieve hidayah, may Allah open all our hearts. Aamiin
I see that i commented. And i take it back. May Allah forgive us. ♡ Back when i didnt practise islaam that well, he motivated me with his speeches. May Allah guide us all. Back then he was a step for me to loving islaam. May Allah forgive us and guide us 🌻
Mufti Menk was my favourite Daaee 10 years ago but always my mind questioned one thing? Why doesn't he talk much about Deviant groups or practices? This always lingered around me and I doubted his words? Then only I found the RU-vid video by his own Father admitting that Mufti Menk is teaching the Deobandi Book in Zimbabwe. Also please note, Wikipedia says Mufti Menk studied in Madeena then went back to Deoband in Delhi for another 2 years and obtained his Mufti position. For me this is like one goes to Harvard to get his Master's then going to get his Ph.D in a Low Rated unrecognised University. May Allah guide him to teach the right thing to the mass.
Ooo that's not the case brother.. Knowledge is not restricted to saudi. I completely agree that deobandi has some issue with aqeedah but they have been the centre of knowledge in the subcontinent for around 200 years and darul uloom is one of the best when it comes to hadees and fiqh. I think they teach the whole kutubussittah. Just coz you studied in madinah doesn't mean you become superior.
May Allah bless you bro, I benefitted from this talk a lot. May Allah bless Mufti Menk, I enjoy listening to his lectures, but you are absolutely right- he must speak about the broader issues as well, especially if he has the knowledge to do so, Barakallahu feek brother for your excellent work
I'd like for Mufti to clear some topics up and be straightforward with Aqeedah etc. But no doubt, I know personally and have met some Muslims who are hanging on to life by a thread, drug addicts etc and they find hope or come to deen through watching Mufti Menk's lectures. But I do understand and agree with many of your points. Jazak Allah Khair.
@@luluah1198 well the topic of aqeedah most people who the platform and his audience is wont understand so he does not need divulge into it. Might be worth listening to abu usama dhabis talk regarding the creed very benefiecial talk
I can only imagine if I were a non Muslim, I would run away from Islam based on all the attacks all the religious figures and speakers hurl at each other, absolutely no different from Christianity and their sects. Apparently everyone has got issues, there is not a single speaker who is not attacked now a days. Allahul Musta3aan.
@@teckgeekwiz9088 Akhi, not just specific to this video, but in general outside of this video. If you like the word "reprimand", then great, whichever works to drive home the point.
Mufti menk never attacks anybody. He is focused on delivering the beautiful teachings of Islam to the masses. Its only very few small beginners who want to become famous by finding faults in people that Allah has made famous.
Tbh, the first time I found out about Islamic content on youtube I found guys like YQ, NAK, Mufti Menk. And then I found guys like Assimalhakeem, Dr. Muhammad Salah, and then the whole gear shifted, in a sense.
@@YusifM411 as far as I know for now, yeah, the man's safe. What I mean by the whole gear shifted is things become straight, it becomes clear. See, I like the way he just get to the point and make sure it clear so that I understand, no sugar-coating, no going around the bushes. He just go like, "This is the answer and these are the evidence." Quick, simple, and the man is surprisingly easy to listen to.
@@rafly5443 yeah alhamdulilah like u said he’s really good and any question I search up most likely he already answered it MashAllah Assim Al Hakeem needs to be more known for the peoples benefit. And do you agree with NAK?
@@YusifM411 NAK was in dangerous territory for me. I always say to myself, "Well, now that I see a lot of videos talking about him including Brother Mussab here, it's best to avoid it." Like, when there are so many people warning me about him, I decide to well, avoid him. For matters of agreeing or not, I only agree to those who present Islam as it is, as how the Quran and Sunnah present it. Because in the end of the day, Islam is Islam, it's not Islam this or Islam that, the only Islam is Islam, the Religion of Allah.
@@rafly5443 yes that’s true may Allah Guide us all we take what’s right and leave what’s wrong like Imam Malik says you take some words and throw the rest out except this person as he was pointing to the grave of the prophet Muhammad (saw) we never know NAK might be in a way higher position than us in Day of Judgment and in Jannah
A revert or convert does not just turn on a switch and magically understands every little detail of every little facet of every little denomination of Islam. The majority do not know the most basic Arabic. Mufti Menk's sermons are carefully crafted (I'm not sure if it is intentionally or unintentionally.) so that that almost any humble human being who understands basic English can spend some time listening and walk away with something of value. When I turn on many of his videos, I can almost always gain some inspiration. Whether I am in the mood to learn or understand something profound or something simple, I walk away with a result based on my own intention and investment. I am sure that he is more than capable at wasting time and spewing a pile of details that are not relevant to his specific point, but he is respectful of his viewer's time and sticks to his point.
Alhamdullilah agree with everything you've said. As mufti menk himself said everyone has their own style of giving dawah as the people are all different in the way they want to receive the message. I personally feel mufti menks approach is a catalyst, once people engage with Islam and thereafter learn deeper into it they are then ready to listen to all these other people of dawah and their approach.
You seemed to miss what is being said, or ironically proving what's being brought up. No one is saying you have to present every nitty gritty Ijtihadi issues that encompasses Islam. The main contention is to not dilute the core message and teachings to the point it is looked upon as an emotional placebo to pick oneself up and that only, this was never the prophetic message, and he being in the position that he is has responsibility of not lowering the discourse. This approach is already leading to a lot of issues in our ummah. His interview on the Danish radio station just further drives the nail in the coffin by itself even deeper.
@@MechkanysT I have watched less than 10% of Mufti Menk's videos. However, from his videos, I get one message crystal clear. There is only one God, and Muhammed is his prophet.
@@ninagarman216 dear sister there are also other deviant sects in islam like the khawarij and rafida who also give the same message. They also say there is no god but allah and muhamed pbuh is his messenger . And that is the whole point that this brother is trying to make. Is that mufti menk should show people like you the right aqida and worn agains people like the khawarj and rafida or igwaan al muslimeen and other deviant sects so that muslims who have a little knowledge know how to recognize these sects and dont fal in there traps. It is the duty of sheikh like mufti menk to do that and bed time story’s alone are not enough.
You will not understand the whole thing if you just watch less than 10%. Then criticize the brother? What were you thinking sister?? Are doing what you are claiming that's his doing then?
Imagine if Prophet Muhammad, Salallahu alayhi wa sallam, kind as he was held back anything of the deen from the sahaabas for fear that they will be angered or dislike him, where would we be by now Deenwise if he sugarcoated everything!? And yet The Prophet, Salallahu 'alayhi wa sallam dealt with the most hostile people of that time preaching to them something they were totally new to. Asking them to ditch their old ways and follow his teaching (islam)! I say, whoever takes himself out to teach the masses, should tell it as it is. Hidaaya is from ALLAH.
We as Muslims have a habit of living vicariously through other Muslims, and putting sole responsibility of bring everything on them. If mufti was wrong, then may Allah forgive him if he corrects and repents. He's but a man.. not free of flaw or sin.. I won't support wrong. But i also won't expect him to cater to my every feeling and apologize when he's slighted me. Grow up people. Focus on bigger and more fundamental things in life.. like reading Arabic, memorizing the quran, praying 5 times a day, eliminating harm from your life.. surround yiur self with goodness.. most of the people who are offended are teens and women in their youth who have an unclear understanding of life and their obligations in it.. Mufti Menk will offend everyone and anyone on a daily based on the moods of people. If he's wrong about an Islamic fetwah, then someone with knowledge should find a way to approach him and discuss it. Otherwise stop being emotionally unstable and invested in these imams, scholars, mufti, alarm. It is what it is.
I used to love watching your videos more than ten years ago when I was a youth learning the deen for the first time. May allah grant you jannah.. you have always been firm haven't changed and had the quality of not trying to please people and give blunt meaning.. may allah keep you steadfast dear brother
More sugar coating in islam than mufti lectures...islam allow many things just to attract many of the Arab pagans of the time...Religion is full of sugar coating man...
Jazakum Allahu khairan akhi. I know that mufti Menk did teach a few lectures on aqeedah and also seerah in the past. I used to watch many of his videos in the past, now I still watch it but only once in a blue moon. I agree with you that he should teach more subjects specially because of his way of teaching. Many Muslims would benefit
The problem here is the ummah is dealing with *a lot* of issues that people don't speak about. There's a lot of people teaching aqeedah and so on so forth.... Who's addressing contemporary issues? We have people dealing with anxiety, depression, anorexia, bulemia, pornography addiction (it's quite predominant in the Arab world last I checked), suicide, spousal abuse, sexual identity issues. These are real problems as well. Not to take away from the importance of aqeedah, akhlaq and so on... but we have 2 billion plus personalities in this ummah dealing with varied issues and we want all those to fit one mould? I mean Allah knows best.
@@12345678956824 Nobody's telling them to stop talking about the contemporary issues. You're missing the point. What part of brother mussab's "Islam is a complete package" didn't you understand? Bed-time stories have a time, and serious matters must also deserve some time. In fact, the latter should be given more time. Brother Muss'ab clearly mentioned that if one is preaching Islam, he needs to clarify the truth from the falsehood, and that involves warning against misguidance, because Islam is not just sweet talks and heart-softeners. This is the problem with the tablighis. They focus all their attention on manners & characters, and literally try to run away from the serious matters by fearing "disunity". That's not the methodology of the Prophets.
@@syedsaad1594 isn't he part of Eeman Academy? They teach aqeedah and fiqh and hadeeth et al. Or is the point that we have to see him on RU-vid using the Qur'an and Sunnah as a stick to beat people with to know he's delivering the complete package? Like his schedule should be Sunday : Refute atheists Monday : Haraam and halal Tuesday : Refute other duat Etc? Anyway Allah surely knows best. I'll move on with my life now.
Again, missing the point. A stick has more intelligence than you it seems. But what else can be expected from such people? Deobandi sympathizers can never be truthful to the religion. Instead, they are content with hearing bed-time stories. And seeking knowledge means nothing to them, as their scholars have convinced them of this. Bottom line: Let everyone figure out halal & haram by themselves, and who to take knowledge from. And refutation of misguidance is of no use and should be prioritized according to the time & place of your choosing, and not according to the abundance of it everywhere, because "unity" is more important. Wow, such precious advice. Maybe Islam is a joke to you. And you want the amount of refutation videos to be catered to your mood, your royal highness?? Shame on you, and all those who have this mentality.
@@syedsaad1594 _a stick has more intelligence than you it seems_ 👌 good job on your implementation of Surah Hujurat on insulting people. _Shame on you..._ BarakAllahu feek. The amount of jumping into conclusions in your comment...What a wow. Assuming you're right and I'm wrong...your approach...work on it kind Sir. That's my two cents and very humble opinion. Anyway thanks for taking the time to respond. Asalam alaikum warahmatullah wabarakatuh
Respect my brother. May Allah reward you for Your efforts, and I’m not scholar, but in my opinion I agree with your take. By speaking nothing but nice it gives people the idea that they can do what ever they want, and Allah will forgive, but that’s not how you build imaan, or tawheed. Subhanallah, I’m happy allah guided me to your videos brother. Keep Doing your thing . Jazakallahu khier my brother
@@OneWayToParadise what kind of imam are you? Calling other people idiots , innovators etc, like your are God. It’s good thing to objectively factually correct an individual based on arguments, but you make ad hominem attacks. You can say about mufit menk what you want but a fact is that his akhlaaq is waaay better than you
Public mistake requires public correction. You don’t wanna mislead none in life. And b4 that good intention & internal repentance. May Allah Ta’ala guide us !
Asalamualaikum brother... while i agree the point you’re making i do feel that it is best to do it privately with the person concerned... aren’t we supposed to hide our brother’s flaws ? this is like shaming bcoz it’s here on RU-vid for public views..
@@hamidahahmad574 Wa Alaykum Assalaam, apologies sister. We at times reply in voice to Salaams (which is valid) when using the phone as it is easier. Please pardon us.
Masya Allah, Qadarullah akhi 7 minutes before I watched this video's I was watching Mufti Menk video. LOL. There is no coincidence, Allah has planned for me and all of us.
Thanks for your message May Allah reward you inshallah. I really liked your lecture call the hole of the lizard. It's very on the point. May Allah accept from us all.
I really respect your take on why you took that video down. I personally thought it was for the public because lots of daaees were spreading it. It's absolutely rare nowadays to find someone who respects the privacy of others and adheres to this Islamic ruling. Barak Allahu feekom
After reading some comments I realised many did not understand that choosing the correct ustaz or Sheikh or dai is very important. No doubt I once admire Mufti Nenk but when I listen more must agreed with Brother Musaab he is problematic in certain way. He has syubhat. So far only Brother Musaab has the courage to bring this to the table bcos he cares about islam. May Allah grant you jannatu firdaus Brother.
Mufti Menk is a hard working man. He doesn't rest as much as he should. Akhi you made some valid points, but it would be better if you adressed the issue with more respect for our teacher. May Allah bless us all. Ameen.
@@neoanderson7697 he has good character and that is what brings people to like him alot ,even non Muslims love him I think his strategy is different to just being direct,sometimes people do not even know how much goodness islam has to offer of we always fighting one another and I love the fact that he shows that beautiful side in terms of the Deen, to be honest I think we all use use different strategies like when we at work we don't just Go to the people and tell them you all associating Partners with God or you all worship idols and that's wrong! They would think you Crazy if you just attack them at work but no u got to get close to them and then show them the goodness then tell them and this is something bee all try to do as daees,and sometimes when we in the street we are direct when it's needed so I don't know why people are attacking him for his style
@@yusuf_837 mashaAllah.. i totally agree with you brother.. mufti menk has his own way to approach people,to bring da'wah.. by his soft presentation people already forget to do bad things,this is good.. but that doesn't mean mufti menk never warn people about the consequences of bad deed.. he did warn but through his way of da'wah.. i agree with you brother.. this guy is too much of a mouthfull.. non stop complaining i don't know why..
Okay so I was so into these type of videos for the past couple of days where someone is always refuting, criticizing other sheikhs,scholars for something they said or done. At first, I was so angry at those sheikhs for saying this or that then I realised how much some of their lectures helped me in my deen....even if it was just one lecture where I felt closer to Allah, closer to my Islam.....The rest is up to Allah to guide us and follow our religion properly....but if a person gets benefited from at least 1 of those sheikh's videos, May Allah be pleased with them...
MashAllah brother Abu musab i totally agree with you Jhazak Al khair I kindly request brothers and sisters in faith pls read Quran with meanings and authentic hadees of Mohammed sallallahu alaihi wa sallam may Allah subhana taala guide us and those who strive for guidance ameen Ya rabbul allameen
I still like mufti menk. May Allah guide him and grant him paradise but what I learn from this brother Abu Musaab is that never blindly follow anyone. So Jazakallahu khair brother.
You are biggest innovator on the internet. Alhamdillah very few people follow you. Allah will never allow misguidance to prevail. This is why you will never prevail.
Subhanallah may Allah reward our brother for this explanation. And may Allah guide mufti menk and the like of him to the path of the Quran and Sunnah. I have a problem and need help with it. Every family member of mine listens to mufti menk. And even though he has benefited them in some ways with his lectures and reminders. They are now idolizing him to the point that when I point out that mufti menk is a human that makes mistakes like all of us, that they then start to attack me. And saying “who do you think you are to criticize a great scholar of Islam. You are not on his level and he is much more knowledgeable than you.” Even when I show them clear cut ahadith and ayat from the Quran that shows that he is contradicting the deen of Allah. May Allah help us all. Barakah Allahoe Fiekoem
Alhamdulillah. You've spoken the truth akhi. I used to listen to Mufti so much. I love his lectures. I'm very disappointed when I heard him say "Take the good from all parties & leave the bad". I have a feeling that he just makes innovations look like it's all difference of opinion.. We don't need to sugercoat Islam. Mufti has such a wider audience. If he can speak those important topics, It'll have a great impact insha Allah. May Allah (SWT) give all of us a good understanding!
Take the good from all parties & leave the bad" Leave the bad)what you think is bad like innovations etc. What's wrong with this? It's like obeying your parents but soon as they tell you to do something that's against Islamic teaching you don't obey them.
@@flapjax3590 Haha. That doesn't work that way bro. First our deen is not sth like buying perfumes. Let me give you a real example, People are more selective when it comes to choosing a doctor to treat their diseases but how come can we be lenient when it comes to the deen? What will happen if you choose a bad doctor? Every innovations is going astray & misguidance. It's not sth to be taken lightly. Tell me whether will you/any other Average Muslim be able to know what good & bad is? It's not even logically correct. There's no need to look up to the sheikhs if one knows what's good & bad. How does he know about those? Btw, where did you get this principle from? Why not take the good & leave the bad from Christians & Jews too? We don't mix the truth with falsehood.
💠Said it amazingly, speaking the reality, In’Sha’Allah Continue to pinch such speakers to wake up and use their platform to give a bigger impact by hitting all doors of knowledge to his listeners!
Honestly I am bothered by him a bit. In all of his social media platforms on his post he does say the name of Allah. Rather He calls Him almighty. Not that there is nothing wrong but mufti menk refused to say Allah on his posts. You don't believe me check him Twitter page and others
Cute bedtime stories 🤣 wallahi haqq I pray that Allah عزوجل increase you in knowledge and rizq and protect you from all evil Your hard work us truly appreciated ustadh Alhumdulillah for having people like you around at this time of fitnah Jazakallahu khayran
Praise be to Allah. Firstly: It is permissible for a woman to take part in public chat rooms, if she adheres to the following guidelines: She should only participate as much as is necessary, so she should pose a question or state the topic, then leave, and not comment unless there is a need for that, because the basic principle is that she should avoid speaking to men or mixing with them. There should be nothing in her words that could provoke fitnah (temptation), such as joking, speaking softly, or laughing, such as writing “hahahahahaha”, as mentioned in the question, or using smiley emojis, because that could lead to coveting on the part of those in whose hearts is disease, as Allah, may He be glorified, says (interpretation of the meaning): “O wives of the Prophet, you are not like anyone among women. If you fear Allah, then do not be soft in speech [to men], lest he in whose heart is disease should covet, but speak with appropriate speech” [al-Ahzaab 33:32]. She should avoid giving out her email address or corresponding via private messages with any man, even if that is for the purpose of seeking help, because of what such correspondence often leads to of attachment and temptation. See the answers to question no. 34841 . It is preferable and better for a woman to participate only in all-female chat rooms. This is safer for her. There are many such chat rooms, and that is better and sufficient. But if she needs to participate in public chat rooms, then it is better for her to choose a screen name that does not indicate that she is female. And Allah knows best. Source: islamqa
Whoever is prominent and influential in dawah, they are finding faults and viciously attacking them, while they themselves have very little, if not at all, achievements. And their comment section is so imbalanced that it is filled with “awakened” individuals who praised them for the attack and rarely do you see disagreements. It seems they have invested quite a bit in orchestrating confusions and disunity among the Muslim in order to monopolize the dawah scene. Allah is the Most Wise and the Best Planner. May He guide us through this fitnah.
@@OneWayToParadise ameen,ameen,ameen.When this toxicity of people standing on a pedestal of "yeah,we are on the haqq!We are on salafiyah and y'all lost it and yeah,we can be sarcastic!"audhubillah!
As-salamu alaykum. Menk was my gateway when I knew nothing, among other smooth speakers. Although I would have probably connected to the message anyways because I'm not afraid of being labeled anti-liberal. Nowadays, I follow mostly Assim Al Hakeem. I think of this like giving a knife to a person who has never handled one before, you give the handle to him safely, not pointing the edge or throw it at him, but you have to teach him how to hunt at some point, or he has to teach himself. The level of spirituality is plain dead these days in the liberal world, so it seems you have to be gentle or else you'll just get a bunch of travel bans or social media ban if you have a big audience (that's how governments and big tech calculate impending ban on dissidents: Controversy * Followers). May Allah always increase our authencity in our dawah.
Mufti Menk is the type to speak something that is unclear and when people call him out for it, he goes to twitter to write: "There are always negative people who want to attack you and put you down and so on..."
You're right Mufti Menk: - Indirectly invites non-muslim tourists to come to Medina - Doesnt speak about the muslim countries 'recognizing' the zionist colony - Doesnt talk about organisations attacking islam - Goes to UAE ater they recognized the zionist colony and after they have caused many bloodshedding acts in the muslim world etc. Instead he indeed mainly acting like "all happy & everybody is good"
I love mufti menk so much and May Allah bless and I love Bro Abu Musab May Allah bless you too brother. I think you 100% correct, May Allah guide us all , we all make mistakes.
Muslims are being oppressed all over the world but still we are on battlefield between us who is on right path.we are doing dawa but still we didn’t learned how Prophet peace be upon him was doing dawa and criticising others but all of is we claim only i am the truth and others false. We cant tolerate others if we find one mistake from someone then his 99 good things are by by. May Allah give us guidance
The reason why Muslims are being oppressed is because of many things but among them are: 1. People of knowledge failing in doing their part in communicating the sound message of Islaam (therefore my video with the sincere advice to Menk). 2. Laymen like yourself (with all due respect) who are allowed to share their erroneous opinions as though they are revealed by Allaah and then judge us accordingly. Allaah and His messenger crticized every time of Kufr, innovation and misguidance out there. It is not our fault that you do not know your own religion. May Allaah guide you to follow the Islaam Allaah revealed, not the Islaam the people made.
@@OneWayToParadise May Allah Bless you. You are enough knowledgeable but you didn’t understood a layman text. The way most of you critics others this is not a way of our beloved prophet peace be upon him. May Allah give you guidance
2 years later and he hasn't changed. Just recently, he mentioned if you're a 5 time Salaah then his lectures are not for you. It's a passive aggressive stance of saying don't correct him even if he is wrong.
Abu Easa namatullah of almaghribe institute said the same thing to his students and followers that they should learn from every one including deviants and he uses the hadith of abu huraira learning from shaytan. He is another problematic and confusing individual
The problem misquoting this hadith is that he went and asked Rasulullah sallahualaihiwasallam about that and Rasulullahi sallahualaihiwasallam confirmed this. So the methodology here is take from anyone and go to those who are the heirs of Rasulullah sallahualaihiwasallam to confirm of that knowledge and we muslims are supposed to do that . And that's why there are ulama sitting to answer our doubts.
@@ayanyonis2002 The problem is that how can a layman Muslim differentiate between an authentic hadith from a weak fabricated hadith? I truly don't know what he is trying to do to his students and followers.
@Asim Ayyubi of course I read and own books of hadith. I am not talking about me per say. I am talking about the layman Muslims who don't read the authentic books rather they prefer just listening to speakers
@@OneWayToParadise i am sorry shaykh in shaa Allah i read and learn more about our beloved prophet peace and blessings be upon him. That was i thought of our beloved according to his personality. Allahu A'lam. Thanks a lot for the reminder shaykh Jazza kAllahu khayran
No problem my beloved brother. The general manner of the prophet, may Allaah exalt his mention, was to be kind and soft but there are other times when he was stern and tough. It all depends on the occasion.
Anyway I left sufism and started following salafiyya manhaj from him ❤️! I prefer to learn from him any day than you for example, no disrespect. Because his aqeedah is clear for those who actually listen to him and search, he graduated from Madinah university, he is not jaleous of any other alim, he has one of the best manners and so much knowledge. A gem machaallah
He isn't jealous nor is anyone else. The mere thought that we are jealous of him is sad and pathetic to be honest. I just don't get how certain Muslims think...smh.
@@OneWayToParadise Nobody said you are jealous, she just said he himself is not jealous. why put more words into that even if that is what she is insinuating?
Upon You Is Knowledge And Beware Of Innovating Ibn Mas'ood (d. 32H) radiallaahu 'anhu said: "(Incumbent) upon you is knowledge before it is taken away, and its taking away is by the passing away of its people (i.e. the scholars). So upon you is knowledge; for indeed none of you truly knows when he will be in need of it, or that (others) may need of that which he possesses (from knowledge). [And indeed] you will find many people claiming that they are calling you to the Book of Allaah whilst they cast it behind their backs. Therefore, upon you is knowledge and beware of innovating, at-Tanattu' (being excessive in speech) and at-Ta'ammuq (delving deeply into matters). And upon you is to cling to the ancient affair." Explanation: Here his (Ibn Masoo'd s) statement "innovating" means contriving any [act of] worship that has not been legislated by the Messenger of Allaah ( ). His statement "at-Tanattu' (being excessive in speech) and at-Ta'ammuq (delving deeply into matters)" means exceeding the proper bounds in matters and going excessively beyond the manner legislated. "And upon you is to cling to the ancient affair" refers to adhering to the path of the Messenger of Allaah ( ) and his companions. Translated by: Aboo 'Abdillaah Bilal Hussain al-Kashmiree Explanation taken from the footnotes of Ibn Waddaah (p.32), checking by Dahmaan Reference: Ad-Daarimee (no.143), al-Ibaanah (1/324), al-Laalikaa ee (1/87), Ad-Daylamee (no.2236), Dhamm at-Ta'weel (no.60), al-I'tisaam (1/107).
Actually I thought you invited mufti menk. And I also commented by thinking it. haha.. Anyway if you can contact him then we would love to see your discussion. inshaa Allah
Totally agree brother. And what you said there on 15:13 that is what happened... that's why someone had to correct their fellow brother... Mufti Ismail Menk is a good person beyond words you can see that on his face and everything, SubhanAllah, but he should be beware of the evil of the soul, and the tricks of the chaitan, especially because of his authoritative and responsible position. Sheik, imams muft's "all persons" who do dawha must be constantly aware that he has the right intention, his purpose, and must not withhold anything from the laws of worship! And of course he should only do this for Allah (SWT) and secondly for his Muslim brothers, so that they are guided "Inscha'Allah" on the right path. (!!He must not lose sight of the fact that he is a teacher who transmits faith in Allah with His permission! So do that as best you can, what Allah (SWT) has blessed you with that, so don't let anything lead you astray while you know it ...!!) In short, I think these are the most important things that must be present. If that is good, he will benefit from Allah (SWT) because he does this only for Allah and to guide the people by teaching them Islam. See; Both parties have an advantage Insha'Allah, and the teacher on both sides Inscha'Allah! May Allah Most Forgiving guide and protect us, and grant us patience against all the evil that He has created, and permits us into His Paradise AMIN! Peace be with you
Brother Abu Mussab Jazakallah for telling us the truth and not sugar coating the pure message off islam.I remembered the talk Mufti menk saying take good from everyone and leave the bad.This isn't possible like the sufis such as bralvees /tablighi Jammat/naqshbandi and sufi as general call to shirk such as grave worship and beliefs of walatul wajood becoming one with Allah hindu beliefs most of the blind followers not even aware of All the shirk kufr and innovation bidahin their books.Keep making these videos very beneficial may Allah reward you abu mussab.
Not you brother, YOU should never be quiet, that what be a Tremendous loss to the community at large. Thank You for your time. AS Salaam Alaikum. Ahmed
This is one opinion only. Many scholars around the world do not speak of countless matters intentionally. Many even avoid becoming popular intentionally
Nah Mufti is fine. He studied in Madinah, and he is not ashamed to call Mawlid out for what it is. He does say Mawlid is Bid'ah. Only Allah knows how many many Muslims are ok with it. No sugar-coating there.
Completely agreeing with you. I myself used to watch his lectures. From now on i probably wont. Just one advice brother. Be respectful. Try to sweeten your tongue. I dont think lot of hardcore fans of MM will leave his lectures after watching this.
we can learn aqeedah from every scholar who us upon the Quran wa sunnah with the understanding of the salaf raialahu henhuma. Aqeedah is the basic and if a scholar does not have that aqeedah of the ahlussunnah then we do not take knowledge from the begin. Allahu a3lem
@@sajidmahmood4238 People bringing there tribal cultures/traditions or there own understanding of Islam with lack of Knowledge or Knowledge that could be fabricated. Some people practice things and make it out as if its part of Deen.
Quran and Sunnah are enough for me and I am trying to gain more knowledge of Islam so I can create a sound understanding. There are many teachers out there I will learn from regardless of Sect but the knowledge I will take should follow some of my confluences which leads to the Quran and Sunnah. Please make Dua for me JZK
@@flapjax3590 So how would a layman know what is good and what is bad? If you not going speak bad about the bad from your logic carry on doing it Islam is not based on that You have to forbid the evil, otherwise like you say these traditions never change anyone’s mind Muft menk May Allah subhanawatallah bless him, has no weight on his shoulders, everytime some asks him a question that goes against his belief of teaching he shuts it down, you can never learn that way Sufi: mufti take the good from them leave the bad, what is worse than asking the dead for help, yet mufti won’t openly clarify that, because he doesn’t want feelings to get hurt, but shirk and ending up in hellfire is ok
As much as I agree with you my brother, unfortunately there are far too many people who are very soft, misled and in jahiliayyah that anything too ‘controversial’ or ‘hardline’ may drive them away from Islam when their connection to it is laying by the thread. I’ve seen this with my own family members. I am personally not assuaged by sugarcoated narratives and though I like Mufti Menk, people like Muhammad Hoblos, Daniel Haqiqatjou, Karim Abu Zaid and so on are much more authentic, firm and to my preference as they speak the HAQ regardless of potential backlashes and ultimately, these people help preserve the deen from within. However, without the Mufti Menks of the world, the Muslims with weak Iman won’t be encouraged to strengthen their return to the faith and speakers like that have their uses. Unfortunately, that’s reality today for you.
This actually doesn't make sense. How can you expect someone to have time to do all the extra things you're expecting on top of everything they already produce? And why do you get to dictate what another person should produce? You're literally promoting hatred amongst the muslim ummah. Embarrassing.
Are you even serious?? What doesn't make sense?? He's advising Mufti Menk to change his approach of doing da'wah, and start preaching the remaining 90% of Islam that he deliberately chooses to neglect. What part of this doesn't make sense?? The methodology of the Prophets in calling people towards strict monotheism was very clear, and very straight-forward. And anyone who claims to be a scholar should follow in their footsteps. He gets to "dictate" because that is what Islam dictates. Clarifying the truth from the falsehood, and warning against misguidance. Maybe that's not a big deal to you, but it is in reality a very big deal. Picking & choosing what version of Islam to sell to the people in order to keep them happy is extremely dangerous, and if done intentionally to please the people & avoiding controversy rather than stating the haqq with clarity, this becomes a form of deception. If anything, this is what's embarrassing.
Do you realise that the level of imaan amongst the muslim ummah today is not sufficient to be widely discussing these controversial topics you love promoting? Do you not realise the reason you 'full' deen guys have such a small following is because there are very few muslims who have a sufficient level of imaan to listen to what you have to say? If Mufti listened to your recommendation, it would be an incredibly un-wise move. Currently, he is able to spread a positive message to millions. On the other hand, a controversial message would only reach thousands; and to what benefit? It would only lead to more fighting between muslims.
Islam is about quality NOT quantity. Let people learn the true deen and not a watered down version of it. Can you imagine if Mufti Menk preached the deen correctly how many quality muslims this Ummah would've had!? Let the shuyookh preach the deen exactly how ALLAH Wants it and not how people want it because people have desires and they want the deen of ALLAH to suit their lifestyles rather than them ditching their desired lifestyles to fit in the deen of ALLAH. The deen is ALLAH'S and HE Wants it kept pure!
And if we adopted the approach of Mufti Menk, we would start having problems with many parts of Islam that does not fall into the comfort zone, feel good, fluffy narratives that is not Islam as a whole, but a part of it. Because of his dilution of the Islamic message, many people are being even more justified into thinking conventional Islam is "extreme". This is text book lowering of the discourse.
Tuan Abu Mussab...I m an average person...I believe what you say...how can a man of trust to the ummah intentionally say I know this part of Islam and not the other part of Islam while preaching the knowledge of Islam
Brother love you for Allah for being straight fwd opening the eyes few blind followers. Allahumma baarik. Expect more videos with shorter times than 120 min. Thanks for keeping short.
How would our beloved prophet may peace and blessings be upon him handle people? I feel so embarrassed listening to you publicly criticize a Muslim. It's a horrible thing to look at. Prophet Muhammad had wisdom in how he delt with people. Please stop making your mission to find faults in others. This whole channel is making me feel like I am listening to gossip. Address issues you have face to face don't involve the whole ummah!
Oh ultra compassionate creature, would you feel embarrassed if you witnessed the prophet, may Allaah exalt his mention, yank a golden ring out of the companion's finger and throw it on the floor?? Would you also feel equally embarrassed if you heard him call Thou-Khuwasira and his likes "the dogs of the hellfire"? Is it our fault that you have been taught a false version of Islaam which only shows you one aspect and ignores the others? This is exactly why Menk is criticized. The outcome is confused Muslims who are ignorant of the Sunnah. As for issues you have to face, then instead of being hasty, go check the videos on this channel and you will be shocked to know that there isn't an issue the Muslims face that we have not covered! Learn from Dawood, peace be upon him. He was hasty in deciding in favor of one person without hearing the other. You are judging based on a couple of videos without seeing the others. Be just as Allaah commanded you.
Nobody (no scholar) has the full package of knowledge...they do their best, you learn from them and you have you use your aqal (no blind following...in fact it is discouraged). However, the problem begins when the scholars go tangent....that is a big problem I see these days...so the common Ummah has to become wiser to handle it. Have no clue as to what's going on with Mufti in this case....🤔
What's your problem with Mufti Menk's Da'wah, It's up to him how he wants to give Da'wah, what makes you so big to say how he should give Da'wah. He has a sound message and a lot of Muslims and non-Muslim have benefited, you sound so arrogant in your talk that's what puts me off. Maintaining his beautiful image and cute stories? So many accusations you throughout there it's as if you can read his intentions lol. If you want to know more details of his aqida then message him in person. In this day of age when you have so many sects battling out with each other causing more corruption and rifts between us, I don't blame if anyone wants to stay neutral in their Da'wah in public to avoid any confrontations and get attacked lol. You attack him like this when you clearing don't know his aqida and it's bugging you so hard to find out so you can rule him out with your arrogant ways. This video left a bitter taste in my mouth you caused more harm than anything, you need to be more relaxed and humble with your approach. I am sure your scholars would say you don't represent them in your way of mannerism? approach to harsh I would say. This is just another Hate video lol
@Mohammad Yusuf Ojela this isn’t a refuting video but rather seem like a advice video saying that mufti menk should talk more about topics he frowns away from in a bid to not be controversial, but of course when giving dawah it should be given in a full package, otherwise listeners may get advice from others who do bidah and then follow the wrong path. Allah knows best
Bro.Abu Mussab doesn't get over Mufti Menk &... Bro. Daniel doesn't get over Omar Suleiman 😄😅. Masha Allah, May Allah bless you Ustadh n may Allah guide Mufti Menk..
These public refuting videos hurt the deen and the dawah more. Its best to Leave these matter to be privately discussed. It would be better for your videos to advocate the deen in your way and leave the Mufti to do it in his way but disagree in private and call the man up.
There’s so much effort to be done out there on Muslims and no Muslims but it’s easier to sit down and make a video bashing others who in the big picture are doing smthg positive...reach out to Muslims who don’t even know meaning of shahada and Salat etc...who spend hours on smart phones; perhaps a short vid of mufti crosses them and changed their lives..
@Yasmine Neverland Definitely not what he’s doing.Sahabas had deference of opinion but they never disrespected or made fun of each other. Plus who is he to call out people?
