I'd buy the Altima because it drives pretty well, all the new safety features and has got AWD for the first time in years. The Altima does pretty well, but it's a bit noisy at high speeds and don't get me started on its reliability nor its CVT.
Three years back I booked a Nissan Altima SL. Then randomly went to showroom next day and the sales guy offered me to test drive Nissan Maxima. After test drive I cancelled Altima and booked Maxima. The speed, acceleration and thrill of Maxima is something that made me prefer it over Altima.
@@UnenthusedEnthusiast that's right the VC-TURBO edition Altima is not your average regular Altima and will give a Maxima a hard time without any doubt!!!!
@@UnenthusedEnthusiast that's right the VC-TURBO edition Altima is not your average regular Altima and will give a Maxima a hard time without any doubt!!!!
The Nissan Altima is no comparison to the Nissan Maxima I just bought the 2020 Nissan Maxima Sr it's a beast even with the CVT transmission it doesn't play around when you need the speed.
I have a 2020 Maxima SL with all the options available, sun roof with glass top, which I love, have leather seats and all the options that you can get with this model. I find that it has more power than I thought and can really go when I step on the gas. I have squealed the wheels without really trying. Love this car, handles great and is a really smooth ride. II am not sure I like a spoiler on the Altima, why have one, I am not wanting a race car. It is so much fun to drive and I can pass anyone I want, in fact recently passed an Acura going up hill and really made the guy mad as much as he tried he never caught up with me. So I guess it comes down to what you want and what you like.
I have the Altima and been wanting the maxima. Let me just say after finally drooling over it for 10 plus years I finally got it. It’s super fun to drive. I loveeee it! It’s a true sports sedan!
Sorry but between the two, the Maxima is way more premium than the Altima. There’s a reason why it costs more. Besides, the CVT sounds way better in the Max than the 4-banger Altima.
The Maxima has a faux engine noise that comes through your speakers when you accelerate . Yes it is more premium but I chose the Altima based on value. Thanks for you comment
@@carsunlocked The engine is a premium, if you want to pay for that lol . I just bought an Altima SR fairly loaded. Wish 'd gotten the SV for a few things however love the Altima Sr too. Was going to look at the Maxima's but as soon as I heard 6 cyl I said never mind. Glad I didn't get it. i'm guessing in a couple of years they'll rebuild the Maxima too. To catch up and overtake the Altima's new features. We came in at a good time. The Sr has a "manual transmission" option (shift paddles) and with that IF you know how, can be quite powerful on the low end. I used to beat the sht out of people with a Toyota Corona in the 1970's.... those v8's couldn't cut my little 4. lol It's the driver more than people think.
@@collinsfriend1 That v6 you dont like had won many awards and the VQ series engines Nissan makes is unbeatable by Honda or Toyota. They dont make a engine even close to it! The VQs have a huge following and aftermarket!
@@collinsfriend1 The SR has a CVT transmission with fake paddle shifters. It is a 'pretend' manual. It is all fake. Just like the Maxima's 'fake' engine noise when you put it in Sport mode.
@@fredwilliams7893 and too bad Nissan put a CVT in the Maxima. Would have been far better with either a real manual 6-speed, or a real automatic transmission.
Well I certainly took a good hard look at both the 2019 Altima and the 2019 Maxima both up at the top Platinum trim. I did like the Maxima a beautiful sedan indeed but it was way more than was practical for our driving needs. I bought the 2019 Altima Platinum ,, it was the showroom model, drop dead gorgeous it was in Sunset Drift metallic paint. This Altima was loaded, outstanding built in safety that really impressed. The Altima package came with a Winter Package, four Firestone snow tire mounted on nice alloys, the winter tires were already installed. The regular tires were Hankook 19" GT on very sharp alloys. For the type of driving I did I felt that the 2.5 engine was more that sufficient ( which it certainly is ) and with having all wheel drive available only on the Altima that was what sold me. Yes the Maxima was a lovely sedan but there was a $9979.00 ( Can. ) price difference and without question the Altima gave us a much bigger bang for the buck.
I have the 2019 Altima Platinum. I really like the all-LED exterior lights of the Maxima but it was thousands more and does not have: ProPilot Assist, AWD, rear automatic braking, good fuel economy, or the modern tablet style screen of the Altima. It's pretty obvious in many ways that the 2019 Maxima is the mid cycle refresh whereas the 2019 Altima is the full redesign as it has better features for less money.
I for one dislike the recent trend of that top mounted tablet. It's seems super in the way and out of place up there. I'd much prefer the inbuilt screen. But besides that I think the Altima kills it in everything but speed and power.
Excellent review. I prefer the maxima though. For me, horsepower and interior styling wins. For one extra L/100 km I'd still go with maxima. I not a fan of pro pilot assist. I always turn it off on my rogue. I like to feel like I'm the one driving or else I'd fall asleep behind the wheel. Intelligent cruise control sucks when you are in traffic. It gives too much gap btw cars and everybody cuts you off
Chrysantus Awagu I juss don’t think it’s fair to compare a 2.5 to a 3.5 I have a 2006 Nissan Altima 3.5 SER and mine is pushing around 300 horse power too
" Altima too weak " ,,,, whatever that means ?? ,,, personally I have found the 2.5 engine in my Altima to be more than sufficient. I chose the new Altima based on my driving habits, mostly city driving then three times a week on a short stretch of highway on the way to my club. On close examination there was no way whatsoever that the Maxima I looked at was worth 10 k. more than the Altima Platinum.
Keep your 2017 Altima! I had the 19 Altima Platinum for 3 months and dumped it. I used to have a 2015 Altima and loved that car. The problems with the new designed Altima are many. The seats are about 2 inches narrower than the prior generation, so they are not as comfortable as it always feels like you are sitting on the edges of the seat. The engine/transmission noise is louder in the new Altima, and not in a good way. The new Altima had so many creaks and rattles and it drove me nuts. My older Altima was so quiet on the road. The CVT in the new Altima seems to 'shift' through every simulated gear before you even hit 30 MPH. Also, when easing back on the accelerator to try and coast on the highway for the best fuel economy was impossible. The car would slow down immediately so I had to keep pressure on the pedal to maintain speed which affected MPG. I easily obtained over 40 MPG on the highway with my 15 Altima, but impossible with the new Altima. It was a big disappointment because I really tried to like the vehicle. I traded it for a 19 Rogue SL and so much happier.
@@judahbiblehistoryisourhist5841 the Maxima is a noisy car with lots of squeaks and rattles, and it also 'requires' 92 octane. If he is in CA, then he will be paying a lot in gas. It is also about $10K+ more than an Altima. Maybe he doesn't need that much in a car. I drove a '16 Maxima for 2 1/2 years on a lease and I was glad to get rid of it.
I had the 19 Altima Platinum for 3 months and dumped it. I used to have a 2015 Altima and loved that car. The problems with the new designed Altima are many. The seats are about 2 inches narrower than the prior generation, so they are not as comfortable as it always feels like you are sitting on the edges of the seat. The engine/transmission noise is louder in the new Altima, and not in a good way. The new Altima had so many creaks and rattles and it drove me nuts. My older Altima was so quiet on the road. The CVT in the new Altima seems to 'shift' through every simulated gear before you even hit 30 MPH. Also, when easing back on the accelerator to try and coast on the highway for the best fuel economy was impossible. The car would slow down immediately so I had to keep pressure on the pedal to maintain speed which affected MPG. I easily obtained over 40 MPG on the highway with my 15 Altima, but impossible with the new Altima. It was a big disappointment because I really tried to like the vehicle. I traded it for a 19 Rogue SL and so much happier. I also drove a '16 Maxima for 2 1/2 years and although I had zero issues with the CVT, the CVT was the worst part of the experience. The Maxima would be so much better with a 6-speed manual, or even a real automatic transmission. Same goes for the Altima.
@@carsunlocked I don't know if mine was a lemon, but the new Altima is noisier than the prior generation, and the door panel rattles and creaks were aggravating. Nissan claimed there was nothing wrong with the CVT, even though it drove completely different than the Murano, Maxima, Rogue, and prior generation Altima...and I had driven all of them. I am much happier with the new Rogue SL.
Went with the Altima Platinum for the reasons you stated, the pro pilot, all wheel drive, and just more value for the money. I'm sure the Maxima will be back on top with updated tech after the next generation is released.
Nissan is barely moving Maximas off the lots. Furthermore, Nissan is trimming ten percent of the lineup over the next few years, Maxima is likely not in Nissan's future investment or development plans, so will probably be cancelled.
@@TheShootersBay Despite ever decreasing market share of large sedans, I hope not. There's talk of the next generation being an EV, but I believe in its current sedan form, it's difficult to go anywhere else with it.
I think I prefer the interior of the Altima, to be honest. People equate "business" of the dash with style, but I think the interior of the Altima is both practical *and* minimalist, gives it a very modern look. It doesn't look like a damn spaceship control center with a million buttons. The climate control is distinctly separate from the entertainment, and everything else is up above. But I guess the real deciding factor would be - What *can't* the Altima do with its minimalist design that the Maxima can with all its controls? If the answer is none, then why bother with 100 buttons.
So when you say Altima isn't a high accelerator. Would it still be pretty good at by passing slower road drivers? I do want something that has that bit of OOF in the speed from time to time. In terms of realiability which one requires less maintenance?
There is a video where the narrator tackles the dicey issue why the Nissan brand has come upon hard times in the automotive world for a number of reasons, but dwelling mostly (no Ghosn discussion which frankly is huge) the large drop in yearly sales for all nameplates under the brand. I own a '13 Maxima SV...an okay car for the era back then. The styling is actually cleaner and less offensive or radical than either of these units, and I like it better. As one advances thru their senior years, the things that turned them on car-wise are out the window. Exhaust noise, acceleration, sharp looks out and in, sound system quality, etc. are all mostly irrelevant, in fact even annoying. It's the little things about the car, the engine noise, artificial exhaust note, cabin road noise at speed, the lack of grip handles in the headliner panel at all 4 points, bad reflection points on the front windshield from the dash design, the idiosyncrasies of the CVT, the high compression V6 with premium unleaded mandate, etc. etc. that are wearing and "driving" me into looking at other brands and nameplates for an upgrade/replacement.....Cadillac, Jaguar, Mercedes, Lincoln. We're after smooth, quiet performance with maximum interior comfort...could care less about Bluetooth, Apple Car Play, the size and intuitability of the data interface screen, etc. Yes, interior materials and feel make a difference. Yes, the new Altima seats are supposed to be great, and that is a big plus to me.....but a 4 cylinder powerplant as the only option. Toyota kept the V6. Mazda, Honda and Nissan are giving up on it; that's unfortunate.....4-bangers are harsh, have higher maintenance needs, run hotter, and make more noise especially when stressed with A/C other accessory usage in warm weather. Whether this guy cares to admit or not, the big picture here is that Nissan has taken a mostly big step backward by going along with its automotive peers...for a big segment of its customer base. Maybe they just ought to make trucks, jeeps and station wagons like the other companies for the new, younger car buyer....LOL
Thanks so much for your comments i do appreciate it very much. I agree with you the Nissan brand is going down Hill. Focus has been lost from making a high quality and reliable vehicle and shifted to other aspects
@@carsunlocked I would upgrade to a new sedan but the product for older, more discriminating buyers is Infiniti and their styling sucks....over priced and also heavily relies on old technology.. like the dual screen stack in the Q60T. Just very disappointing.....
I have a 16 maxima. At the time, the Altima had no winning over the Altima. I think, this year, if they gave the maxima pro pilot assist, and the Shield 360, it would have taken it. Pro pilot is a really nifty safety feature.
Yeah right! Real men care less about extra room and more tech! Ima stick with my 2016 Maxima!!! I chose horsepower and looks over the other crap. The Maxima is the car Altima driver's wish they had but could not afford.
@@carsunlocked I do all three. Thanks for the compliment! Dont get huffy Bro. If you can't accept other folks comments then you are in the wrong place.
If your in it just for looks, then the Altima is very sexy and much cheaper with more safety features. But if you care about performance at all, its not even close.
They're both great cars, but the Maxima is next level awesome. I've never owned a car that gives me the feels like my 2018 Nissan Maxima Midnight SR. It's gorgeous inside and out, it's fast, it's loaded with amenities and the sound system is phenomenal.
@@carsunlocked You're welcome. And yes, I enjoy everything about the Maxima. On the outside it has such a sleek, stylish and aggressive form. I respect that a base model Maxima S is every bit as fast as a loaded Maxima Platinum Reserve. And the Maxima's interior, particularly at the Midnight RS trim level and up are some of the most gorgeous, ergonomic, feature packed, comfortable and well laid out interiors you'll find on any sedan at any price. The driving experience is just incredible.
@@gbma3241 The ride quality is fantastic with the one button ability to change the suspension tuning from normal to 'sport'. Incredibly tight and precise steering too. And the seats and interior overall just feel perfect to me. 9.7 out of 10, the front wheel drive can make the front end a tiny bit squirrely when flooring it from a dead stop, but this a very minor gripe, it's an awesome car in every way.
this is essentially the exact same car. These are not different cars except in name only. Same chassis, Same parts. The only difference is the 2.5 Liter 4 cylinder versus the 3.5 liter 6 cylinder. However, an Altima with the V6 engine would essentially be the same car as the Maxima
If you are a car enthusiast person u should not buy neither of them! If you are type of person that all wants is to get from point A to B and have comfortable highway cruiser than yes you should buy one of them.
@@carsunlocked I meant that if person is looking for performance aspects and driving dynamics in those cars it wont get it bcs of that CVT! This is not a transmission for driving engagement if person is into that type of stuff. Those cars are only pretending to be sporty but really they are not. Great highway cruisers and just regular family type of driving stuff, driving engagement, forget it but yes to each his own.
Maxima for me. I just bought a 22 Maxima SV. My wife has a 20 Altima SR 2.5L. I'll take my new Maxima any day over her Altima. Her car is nice. But mine is nicer.
With SUVs and Crossovers dominating the market why buy any sedan without AWD especially if you live in a city where it snows? The Alrima has more technology also
Hi I don't know if anyone is reading this and could offer some advice. I'm looking at buying an Altima or Maxima in Dubai United Arab Emirates. Does anyone have any recommendations? I have no idea about cars, but need something affordable reliable and safe for my 3 son's and I. (Single Aussie mum in dubai) any help would be greatly appreciated! Great video by the way, do you happen to review older models at all?
@@carsunlocked hi wow thanks for replying! My first ever you tube comment too, because I just don't know anything about cars. But I'm looking at a 2015 or 16 or 17 second hand car. After much searching thru dubizzle I've come to the conclusion a nissan Altima or Maxima is probably the best bet for my budget and family and needs (school runs/city driving). Could I just ask you I Googled it and saw some comments on some issue about a CVT I think that's the word or another engine issue? Being a car person do you know if they have a known problem under the hood? I just don't trust these second hand sellers when I walk in I feel like they'll say anything to get a sale. And none of my friends are into cars also. 😅Sorry for the rant and THANKYOU for your info
@@hassanalmehza2653 yes Nissan was the first movers of the cvt transmission back in 2008 and it did have a lot of issues. This allowed for a poor reputation. However over the years Nissan has worked out the kinks and fixed the issues
Jamel Lloyd Hampton then don’t buy a Honda, Toyota, or Nissan. If the ‘06 Nissan is clean, then it would be a great car. I think the SE was a manual transmission. And yes, the new turbo Altima beats the old Altima V6. The old Altima V6 is a toned down engine from the Maxima.
Cars Unlocked thanks for responding. Also, can you do a comparison between Honda Passport Elite and Nissan Murano Platinum? Can you do this one first? 😊
Great video! I have a 2011 Altima and I absolutely love it. I was considering getting a Maxima to try something different but now you have me thinking I should stick with the Altima .
Altima is a want to be low budget Maxima just get the Maxima because it looks better drives better don't kid yourself don't cut yourself short the Maxima is a better buy the only thing the Altima got on a Maxima is the price other than that Maxima is the way to go
@@judahbiblehistoryisourhist5841 yes we don't need to argue you fact. you feel they are the exact same??? I feel they have similarities but are two different cars.
Then why buy a Max? You should tell the Japanese automakers they got it all wrong. Or maybe you do. Have the prices reversed. Sell the Max cheaper than the Alti. That’s only reason for buying Alti. It’s cheaper than the Max. Unless you get a 3.5 Alti. You mght have someone. But as it goes now. The Max has it over the Alti. Especially on the road.
The suspension on the Max is very delicate for a car its weight and power also. The smaller Alti scoots right along on crabby roads cause its alot lighter too. The Max’s superiority only boasts the Highway. Where power is king.
Maxima all day long .. you are comparing the maxima with another Nissan the altima. Also for 35k there are other better cars than the Altima . Nissan vs Nissan sedan the winner is the maxima, buddy ..
Listen to what he said… go to 1:56 he says, “ our Nissan msrp $35,098 and our maxima msrp for $45,900.” I thought they both were Nissan? Lol :P and yea maybe should have waited to make this review when he didn’t have a stuffy nose. He is cute though haha :P
Máxima is the best yet car hands dwn , you get what you pay for , Altima is a great gas car but the maxima is the flagship and the Altima is way behind
OMFG dude ditch the Anne Rice Interview with a Vampire wardrobe. Also the aesthetic - the Maxima has much better lines and look at that sculpted hood. The altima is just a mass market attempt to copy the general look of the maxima but you're missing all the key details. i'd rather have a mazda than an altima based on looks.
Had to Google Anne Rice to understand the reference. And yes the whole Nissan lineup is beginning to look the same but this is starting to become a trend with every manufacturer.
