Paul Atreides "Silence" Dune (1984) - Dune: Part Two (2024) SPOILER WARNING! 

Reverend Mother in 2024: *Visibly Shocked* Reverend Mother in 1984: *Cat noises*

the 2024 one shook the entire cinema with its bass. i truly felt the power behind paul’s ‘silence’

Honestly I feel bad for the people who won't see this movie on the cinema. The amount of bass produced was out of this world, the TVs simply can't compare lol.

It's been two weeks since I saw Dune Part 2 in cinema and I still have that SILENCE in my head.

I LOVE how Jessica's eyebrow moves like a fraction of a millimeter but it conveys so much

Even Feyd was shocked at that.

The 1984 version sounded like a command that demostrated his superiority and the 2024 sounded with rage showing he will not tolerate anything else from the ones that pretend to control him. Both were great.

2024 is really good but the line "I remember your Gom Jobber. Now you will remember mine." Is such a great line.

Every hair on my body stood up when he said “SILENCE!”, chiiils

That “silence” scene on IMAX was worth the price of admission. It was an experience that I’d pay again and again to see

Saw Dune 2 in theaters 3 times (Twice in IMAX and once in Dolby) and this scene just gives me goosebumps all over!

1984: *Dad* 2024: *that one friend who had enough*

Nothing like the cinema, that scene still gives me chills

The original version of this part is iconic, but the 2024 version is impactful. I do like the echo effect from the original, however. Without being in an auditorium with LOUD bass, I can tell how loud this must be because of the effect. With the new version, unless you have some nice surround sound with a lot of bass, it doesn't have the same effect watching it on another device different from the theater.

kinda wierd how she was able to speak after having the voice used on her to remain silent....

The 1984 version was better, because he’s mentioning the Gom Jabbar, which basically equates to instant death. Also, his line about looking into that place you dare not look, you’ll find me staring back at you. That is massively important because it ties into him being the Kwisatz Haddarack (hopefully I spelled that correctly lol), not just the Lisan Al Gaieb. The 2024 version just has him as all business, telling them to be silent without really explaining why, beyond just the Reverend Mother stumbling backwards.

feyd seems turned on.

I think everyone cracking jokes about the "lul cat noises" in the original misses something that makes that version more effective: it works in the 1984 version. In the 2024 version, he shouts and she recoils, then says "Abomination". In the 1984 version, those "cat noises"? Are frustrations of an angry Reverend Mother who can't make a verbal rebuttal, even when resisting. As much as I loved both movies, and as much as I enjoyed getting the chance to see both in cinemas, the original still stands out to me. In the 2024 version, the "SILENCE" BOOMS in the theater, but still sounds like an angry child. And that effect is only worsened on a home rewatch. In the 1984 version, it feels ethereal and authoritative, still booms through the speakers, and features that reverb, but that same feeling is felt in a home rewatch even without the bass the cinema would provide. So for me, the 1984 version still wins out. Not only for it's iconicness and its transition to home media, but due to the fact it actually *works* against the Reverend Mother.

I was waiting for that "I remember your Gom Jabbar" line in the theatre, but the scene was well made regardless.

If you didn't see this in iMax or theaters, you have no idea how heavy that "SILENCE" was.

1984 - Lightning 2024 - Thunder

2024 had a better silence. But that “try looking” line goes hard.

The 1984 one had some golden lines, they should have used more of them.

Dune (1984) Kyle MacLachlan 0:06 Dune: Part Two (2024) Timothée Chalamet 0:22

man I don't remember that scene of Twin Peaks!

I love both versions for multiple reasons. With the 1984 version I wish you had included the five seconds or so before what is shown. Where the Bene Gesserit tries to intimidate Paul with this menacing gaze or stare and Paul responds with "Don't try your powers on me." You can see that line captioned in this video at the very beginning.

Showing vs telling

That gom jabbar line was kinda hard. They shiuldve added that to the new one

You really felt it in the cinema

Different era, different effects, different directors, different actors. 84 walked so 24 could run.

I remember people gasping in the theatre at the Dune Part 2 scene, I think both do a great job of showing how powerful Paul has become, or how power is taking over him

Damn, both go hard

Even Feyd Rautha was like "Wow he made a Reverend Mother to STFU"

The 1984 scene is better as just a scene than the actual 1984 movie

This scene made me jump in my seat at the theater because I wasn’t expecting the impact to come from behind me 😭

That was killer scene. 😊

It’s hilarious how both versions have a loud silence! over the calm “silence.” in the book.

Tbh, I do like Dune 2’s “silence” better, but the rest of the dialogue in Lynch’s version is superior to what we get in Villeneuve’s.

Both amazing 🤩

Watched it on IMAX, the amount of bass boost made the chair rattle a bit just to add that omph to his words

Movie was great to see in theatres

I was in a Dolby theatre and 2024's silence vibrated all the seats hard af lol

The entire cinema shook with that base

The issues with many movies is that theyll put on tv the same version meant for Cinema. Hence the annoying whsipering then loud action scenes. Or the Silence part which has a stronger effect when taking into acount cinema audio set up. On tv its a slightly audible effect.

I kinda prefer the 1984 version over the 2024 with the way "silence " is enunciated. I do love the added effects for Chamelet's, but the first one felt like a sharp cut of the knife which feels more appropriate than having it drawn out and let effects handle the rest.

First movie i saw twice in the cinema. Totally worth it

Heard 2024 on 5.1 headset, shit hits hard

This is why you go to theaters

“SILENCE!” Paul calmly spoke

Absolute cinema

I can't take anything with Christopher Walken in it seriously, all I see and hear is "More Cowbells"

This alone made me realize why i paid 5grand for a subwoofer

"Abomination." No, that's his sister. Her role got massively cut for some reason.

Alright, 2024 version was absolutely great in cinema, BUT 1984 version had me at "Try looking into that place, where you dare not look... You'll find me staring back at YOU." It would be so terrifing to hear this line w/ 2024 sound technology.

the original is beter in everything ( exept special efect ) ofc :)

What bothered me was the fact that she called Paul an "abomination" - Lia is the "abomination", there's nothing that would earn Paul that adjective, it doesn't make sense

I got serious PS1 vibes from the 1984 version

In the TV series, Mohiam didn't even have the guts to try to talk to Paul. She only whined and begged Paul's mother to do it: Mohiam: "Jessica! What have you done to us? Jessica, silence him!" Jessica: "Silence him yourself." It's a pretty creative take. But now I'm curious. How exactly Paul planned to stop the flow of Spice? It varied from sources to sources: in the 1984 movie, he didn't mention anything about it. In the TV series: Paul threatened to kill the entire population of Sandworm by water - killing the maker, stopping the spice (i like this one the most) In the New movie: nuclear option. How exactly he threatened to do it in the books?

i'm so mad and sad i didn't see dune in theaters......

1984 Paul: SILENCE! Reverend Mother: 🐆

You never got it right guys. His Thu’um improved. Fus roh dah!!!

imma be honest the dialogue for the older movies in this scene was way better than the new version but in theaters i must say the silence went hard af when i rewatched it at home the silence part didnt go as hard you need the bass

00:09 00:12 Bloody hell. Did Sian Phillips step on Lego. Or stub her toe. Just to achieve that noise??? 😄

Honestly, though the newer one is better produced, the Lynch one works better because of the context it adds to why Paul is so pissed at her. In the new movie I could barely remember who she was.

Just watched it...yea you really gotta watch this in theaters to feel TC's Voice

This scene in theatre 🔥🔥🔥

"Say it with yo' chest."

Poor Chalamet probably practice his yell for months to get his voice that deep.

1984 classic 2024 eerie

I fuckin love Dune, any shape way or form I love it

Watching this on phone. It's probably not gonna be great watching dune on TV without subwoofers

"Silence he said calmly"

My boy said, "SANDWICH!"

Ah, 2010+ movies, where 2/3 of the screen is just darkness

Wasnt supposed the end of the bene geserit to produce "the one" at the begging of the story Paul was just a candidate, but now is clear that he is the one, why the reverend mother keep oposing paul after witness his power?

1984: nightmare fuel 2024: extreme emotion

1984 was better. It sounded more commanding, less petulant.

Loudest silence ever

2024 was carried by the bass and added effects. The original was actually more intimidating... Timothy C is about as intimidating as a jack Russel 😂🤣

Dune Pt. 2 "SILENCE" in the theatre ..had like: ........damn, I ain't even say nothing.

I wonder how well they're gonna adapt Leto. And if they'll do justice considering the fkery they did at the end of the movie.

Context plz

Relying on the power of "Cinema speakers" in 2024 to measure the strength of a scene Vs the power of the 84's voice that you can easily feel even in your "Normal Home TV", well, hope u get that same cinema speakers effect at home then..

I love how much 2024 Dune conveys with fewer words. It's so well translated to the medium of cinema.

I feel sorry to those whom not watching this scene in cinema. I'm truly² sorry. U miss a lottery.

Reverend Mother: 🐈

I wasn’t a Chalamet fan until these films. Timothy absolutely crushed his role here.

Dune 2 Silence should of had more tremble and the building should of shook with debris falling.

In this one scene, I prefer the earlier version.

Maybe I'm weird but I like the 1984 scene better. Modern Dune is a better, more cohesive movie but there are several things I think 1984 did better and this scene is definitely one of them.

Y pensar que Paul le gritó a su propia abuela

two takeaways: - The difference is script quality is stark - Austin Butler’s reaction to the voice stole the show

The first one is said with authority. The second one is like.. a brat lol

1984 had so many more memorable lines.

Ah man I only wish he hadn't shouted.

It's hilarious to me that people still keep defending a movie that the director says sucks and that it's one of the worst embarrassments of his life... He's on record... several times, saying himself that he "sold out" less than half way into it because the producers kept butting in and doing what they wanted to he's like eh, paycheck I guess... He will literally tell you to your face that he made a crappy movie and to go please watch the superior new one...

I like the part where she says aherlehererur

0:06 Original 0:22 New yw

This movie really didn't live up to the expectation. Just massive mainstream media advertising, pushing a certain narrative. Truly disappointed

0:22