Pearl Jam - Comes Then Goes REACTION & REVIEW! FIRST TIME HEARING!

Подписаться 51 тыс.

Просмотров 6 тыс.

50% 1

Pearl Jam.....FEELIN' YOU!!! Tonight we're coming back to Pearl Jam, with a song entitled "Comes Then Goes". How's this one gonna go? Only one way to find out...
Come on in, enjoy the show...I'll see you inside.
Scoring System Guide
10 = Perfection (Unobtainable)
9.0 - 9.9 = Awesome, Amazing
8.0 - 8.9 = Great
7.0 - 7.9 = Really Good
6.0 - 6.9 = Pretty Good
5.0 - 5.9 = O.k.
4.0 - 4.9 = Not So Good
3.0 - 3.9 = Pretty Bad
2.0 - 2.9 = Really Bad
1.0 - 1.9 = Horrible, Awful
0.0 - 0.9 = A Travesty, An Affront To Nature
Link to Original Video Here:
• Pearl Jam - Comes Then...
My Twitter: / bassist4aw
My Instagram (I've just started learning how to use it): / davidheretic666
My Patreon Page, where you can view ALL the videos I try to post that RU-vid is forced to block, can be found here:
www.patreon.com/user?u=44053979
Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favor of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. I have no intent on claiming this music for my own, I'm simply reacting to the video and giving my constructive criticism and feedback. ALL RIGHTS BELONG TO THEIR RESPECTIVE OWNERS

Развлечения

Опубликовано:

18 мар 2021

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 108

@mikeclare1625 3 года назад

Don’t think anyone in Pearl Jam has come out and said it but the overall feeling among fans is that this song is about the bands friend Chris Cornell. It’s a beautiful song.

@smobeepj 3 года назад

Whether or not this was written for or about Chris Cornell, it’s impossible for me to listen to this song and not think of him.

@jamjar5525 3 года назад

Love this reaction!! This is my fave song off Gigaton and that it’s widely believed to be about Chris Cornell just makes my heart ache more with every listen. The line that hits me deeply is “the queen of Collections took your time, sadness comes ‘cause some of it was mine” it’s the most profoundly heartbreaking lyric about loss I’ve ever heard.

@lukelarsson 3 года назад

The Gigaton Produce Josh Evans(who started with PJ in the mid 2000’s assisting and getting sandwiches for the band) talking about Comes Then Goes. “Comes Then Goes” This song is just Ed’s guitar and vocal, which is either the first or second take. We recorded it on a day a couple years ago when we were about to get snowed in at the studio. We didn’t necessarily think it would go on the record that way. His performances are so perfect and so intense and so emotional that I don’t think there was ever a question afterwards that this was the song. Different people tried different things, but anytime we added something, it didn’t actually add something. The rest of the band realized their part for this song was to not play. Why mess with it? There’s a great Thelonious Monk quote: don’t put all the music in the song. Let some of it happen in the audience’s mind. In the flow of the record up to this point, you’ve had all these tempos and sounds. This gives you a break. Sonically, it’s simple, but emotionally, it is very complex.

@pvr918712 3 года назад

That's Ed on guitar. He wrote the music and lyrics, too...

@FeelItRising 3 года назад

An all Ed song. RIP Chris Cornell

@MrBings714 3 года назад

He ain't lyin'. We need to get our shit together.

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

Amen to that

@gmon78 3 года назад

Gigaton is fecking awesome. I love it! It's been a constant companion over this last year. Great wee album.

@gemevieya 3 года назад

This is all Eddie Vedder. Fricking great.

@flipjupiter1 Год назад

I love this song and I love the Gigaton album. Its so, so good. Enjoyed this reaction vid David. Good stuff. Pearl Jam always make me tear up. Theyre an emotional rollercoaster.

@CarlosSierralta 3 года назад

Ladies and gentlemen, Mr. Eddie Vedder on guitar and vocals (and lyrics) talking to Chris, releasing a couple of years of loss denial. Don’t try to comment the lyrics. They mean something different for each listener, but you can definitely be aware of the beauty of a phrase or paragraph. And poetry is math too, pal!

@sixen1 3 года назад

Yeah this is pretty much an Eddie solo song on a pj album .. to my knowledge both music and lyrics fully written and performed by ed

@scottvanschelven5359 3 года назад

You knocked this out of the park, brother. Well done. This song is genius.

@stesrad 3 года назад

If line struck a nerve the lyrics are having the desired effect.... Loved the rant .... TRUTH !.... Don't think you can deny much longer... You are a Pearl jam fan 🤫✌️🇬🇧

@chrisdriver7776 3 года назад

David, thanks for breaking down the vocal notation choices there. I didn't have the musical theory to articulate it, so it's great to hear you do the analysis. So cool that you loved this song and that you were so struck by the lyrics. I completely agree that it's a beautiful and special song... It might be the best song on their new album. Lyrically outstanding, among other things. Shows that Eddie can still pull magic out of his hat. I'm told the song is about Chris Cornell, which takes it all to another level. "High or low, where'd you go? Are you stuck in the middle, a spectral invisible ghost, I'm here juxtaposed." A+++

@skywipe1949 3 года назад

Really loving this video. What you were saying about some of the lyrics is so true and extremely relatable to things I also think.

@jasonkart1651 3 года назад

Great reaction. Most people feel the song is about Chris Cornell which makes it even more powerful in my opinion.

@anabiscan5120 2 года назад

Great review! Your knowledge about music is superb.This song is incredible.Ed on guitar, his voice, that unparalleled voice and those lyrics.I am so happy you check the lyrics because with Pearl Jam(a bit more than with other bands i think) music and lyrics are almost symbiotic.They benefit each other and you experience one through another. Always check lyrics with Pearl Jam songs, not to menton that Ed has been known to be one of the greatest lyricist.

@laurawatters914 3 года назад

David you make alot sense, you are a very passionate man, lately it's been soo crazy!! We need more humanity in this country and world, help each other. Eddie Vedder and everyone in the band are wonderful human beings, David your amazing!! Great reaction, wow a 9.3 score wow!! 🤘✌️❤️

@dijionrose5296 3 года назад

Go on a tandem your channel..an now what what...another um fantastic out of you... ok so come on dave admit it its time...your a fan... 😊.. great review

@jerseyshawn4283 3 года назад

Great reaction Dave and I am happy to finally see you in the lyrics. Music IS poetry on top of math. This is a great song and this record came out during Covid and I will always remember this record and song getting me through the loneliness.

@dbstrozier 3 года назад

This is fun..I love seeing you love this 💕

@christianeflentie1228 3 года назад

This song is stunning. I thought I had requested this a long time ago but perhaps not. I cried the first time I heard it because of the obvious parallels that could be drawn with Chris. And you are so right, it is truly beautiful. Nice review as always! I really enjoyed it. 💖

@loganandliam 2 года назад

This is my favorite reaction of yours The excitement is so genuine!

@advantagevarnsen7436 3 года назад

Great track from a great album. Gigaton is amazing. Someone already mentioned this is potentially about Cornell. But if you look deeper it seems to be a few direct jabs at Cornell’s 2nd wife “the queen of collections took your time” the more you look into the lyrics the more I see directed at her. There is ongoing tensions between her and the band. Nice review David.

@CarlosSierralta 3 года назад

The tensions with Cornell’s wife are a Soundgarden’s survivors. Not PJ or Ed problem. For me, the Queen of Collections is The Death, the Reaper, the shinigami, la Parca. And most of the song is about neglecting feelings, all of us knows that Ed was struglling (and still) with denial. He didn’t go to funeral nor called cornell’s family. It was a huge scandal back in the day

@advantagevarnsen7436 3 года назад

@@CarlosSierralta everyone has there own interpretation of lyrics. So respect your angle with the lyrics it’s another possible interpretation. But there is a clear beef with Ed and her(and her mother) they personally attacked him and Jill. Which I think probably influenced him not going to the funeral. So it is with Ed, Matt ...Pearl jam Lilly and yes sound garden also.

@CarlosSierralta 3 года назад

@@advantagevarnsen7436 but it is not Ed’s style to argue with his friend’s widow. Not his style, not his way to fix things or to rake up the past

@advantagevarnsen7436 3 года назад

@@CarlosSierralta no it’s not his style and I don’t this he’s arguing with her directly . But I see this as Ed verbalising about Chris’s situation and where it left the relationship between him and Ed and his feelings about both. I think he uses lyrics like this a lot through the years. could be wrong. But that’s how I read it. 👍

@FeelItRising 3 года назад

She is a pretty awful woman. Easy to google it

@kaistaley5259 3 года назад

This song , Eddie Vedder 🙌 ... Just 👏👏🌟🙌🌟👍👍🙏 and for what you said👍🙏 feel the same ...

@cufiish 3 года назад

Yeah, It's all Eddie, singing about Chris Cornell. And music sounds like something that Chris could have written. It's beautiful in so many ways. Great reaction man, love it.

@onepunchflan3071 Год назад

I was thinking the same it reminds me instantly of something Chris would make.

@fgrillo29 3 года назад

Without reading into the lyrics, this song is an emotional gut punch. Poignant and cuts you right to the bone. I'm glad you liked this one. It's beautiful.

@dms300 3 года назад

Another great reaction! I also got emotional the first time I heard this song. All Ed Ved on this song.

@youravgjoe42 3 года назад

No need to apologize for sharing your views. We tune in because we want them. As for your feelings on humanity, there is a lot to be critical of. That said, there are fewer people living in conditions of war than at virtually any point in human history, higher literacy than at any point in history, lower infant mortality rate and higher life expectancy than ever recorded. The negative things we do are also real, and man you aren’t exaggerating about how much we suck sometimes. I just think it’s worth also remembering what we are getting right. This song is actually all Eddie. He is on the acoustic. It’s that right hand of his you keep on complimenting. I’m glad you liked this track. It’s one of my two favorites on Gigaton. Seven O’clock is the other one. Similar powerful message about humanity there, but more explicitly political too. For a song with a similarly interesting acoustic arrangement, I recommend checking out Parting Ways (one of the great PJ break up songs).

@cobrakaiX 3 года назад

Best song on the album IMO.

@fgrillo29 3 года назад

Thanks for doing this one, Dave. It's one of my favorites from Gigaton. Beautiful song. Hard not to think this is in some way about Chris Cornell. Great, great song. Thanks again!!

@dustinpatton576 6 месяцев назад

Had a buddy that passed at 37 in an accident (caused by substance abuse) that shared my love of Pearl Jam and Cornell. This one, Off He Goes, and Brother The Cloud, will always get me now.

@theodeklerk3886 2 года назад

a Lyrical masterpiece

@christinecanty5409 2 года назад

Ed also wrote and sings Brother the Cloud which is about his own brother he lost and Chris. The lyrics are so obvious. There is no reason for me to believe this song is not about Chris. Eddie is so genuine like Chris was. Emotions are real and raw. Thank you. Loved your reaction. I agree with your analysis of the human race. The Kids Are Alright is a song by The Who. Check out that video.

@HutTwoHike 3 года назад

love your reactions. So earnest. I get emotional with a lot of their other songs, but not this one. Glad to see how much it impacts people.

@u2tipsy 2 года назад

Your best sensational reaction yet. It's such a slow creeping surprise of a song that explains the blood rushing to your face with emotion and excitement. They are not perfect, but, sometimes they come close. Lyrically, not your cup of tea, but the magic of PJ is that they always create music for the content and depth of the lyrics or visaversa. About humanity.....let's just say that we've become or evolved into a virus with a pulse capable of creating other viruses and so much more in less than 150 years. Regression is progression and progression is regression.✌

@duncanpearce7499 3 года назад

My absolute favourite reaction! Love your work mate

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

FEELIN' YOU Duncan!!!

@mickya3011 3 года назад

Solid review 🤙yeah this and quick escape are my favs from this album. Good stuff, never apologize for rants. Yeah, like the rest said - all Ed. Good stuff man, keep it up

@jasonsartain8168 2 года назад

I love your passion dude. Feeling YOU David!

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

FEELIN' YOU Jason, C'mon Now!!!

@abrahamesparza01 3 года назад

This album got snubbed for a Grammy nomination. I know fans point to Eddie saying he doesn't care. But as a fan I would have liked for them to have gotten at least one nomination.

@heathkeim3394 3 года назад

Best review I’ve watched from you in a while. In the early days, you went on a lot of bird walks. Lately, you’ve gotten into a groove...presumably to keep your reviews a bit more manageable in regards to time. That’s understandable. However, a bird walk from time to time is refreshing.

@ryankoepke6987 3 года назад

Genuine and meaningful.

@dr.mofongo9001 2 года назад

Huge Pearl Jam fan, and just stumbled across this vid. Absolutely love your reaction, and the technical breakdown. You shed light on elements I never would have noted on my own. Eddie Vedder is a poet, and this song, like so many others, is a masterpiece. Not sure how much of their catalog you’ve covered, but may I suggest “Present Tense” if you haven’t covered it yet. P.S. Seeing PJ at the Garden in September with my daughter. Held on to tickets for 2 years. Super psyched. *Update: took a look and noticed you covered MANY of their songs! I’ll be checking out every one of them. Didn’t see “Present Tense” though, so I still highly recommend it! 😉

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

I think Present Tense was on the full album reaction I did exclusively for the Patreon page. Unfortunately, since I did it as part of the full album reaction and review, it will not be able to get it's own individual reaction. You are more than welcome to come check out the full album reaction on the Patreon page. You can join on the Basic Tier for $1.00 and get access to that entire video along with all of the other videos that have been blocked by RU-vid.

@numberonepun4126 Год назад

Love this review brother and I especially loved hearing your insight on your thoughts about humans. I can't disagree with any of what you said, which is why music is so important because it gives us something to find common ground on to build a relationship where we won't hurt each other. I appreciate the work you do as do all of your followers. Never be afraid to talk to us about your thoughts dude. !!!

@CarlosSierralta 2 года назад

I saw this reaction for 4th time. And I note that you didn’t mention the harmonies in the later two paragraphs. And you love harmonies!

@zethpadilla3159 2 года назад

You are an amazing Being. I enjoy so much your passion for music. And I love when you react to me the best musicians of all history time Pearl Jam. Thank You so much for your passion and soul.

@selaimutiara 3 года назад

DH my man, again you always amaze me with your musical breakdown of a song that I'm very familiar with. I thought that before I know all about the song very well, it turns out the song has many technical delicacy that us fans can't explain but can feel. Kudos to you man, never regret subscribing your channel and be your Patreon from Day-1...it will get you there! 😁😉

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

FEELIN' YOU Selai!!!

@death2denemy 2 года назад

We are totally the opposite man! Music to me is the greatest form of art.. its about the feel.. its the exact opposite of math.. its abtract! No rules.. but thinking about it, and based on the way i saw it, it moved you as much as well.. And then I realized, the concept of music might be mathematical to you, but in the end, you were moved by it in a profound manner as well.. Somehow the same as a lot of us who view music as shapeless and without form.. Anyway, this song is definitely a 10 to me.. I couldnt believe it the first time I heard it.. Just so beautiful!! Clearly my favorite off gigaton!! And one of the best pearl jam songs ever recorded.. period!

@u2tipsy 2 года назад

Never apologize for your reactions

@brianfrandle326 2 года назад

Love you Mr. Cornell

@lukelarsson 3 года назад

Ed doesn’t get enough credit for his guitar skills.

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

Agreed

@ryankessler9528 3 года назад

Damn, there a way to send 100 likes for that rant? 💯 agreed lol. Great tunes almost 30 years into it Pearl Jam is so awesome.

@reb569 2 года назад

I've gotten to the point where I don't want to interact with people unless I absolutely have to. People are so f'n judgemental and "ME" oriented. I'll leave it at that so I don't go on a rant myself lol. First time I've ever heard this song. Definitely can see that this would be about Chris (RIP).

@borov76 7 дней назад

Шикарная песня! Прослеживается сходство в аккордах с песней Parting Ways

@emenem6131 10 месяцев назад

Ooo do Present Tense studio or Unthought known. Just aggravating no Do It! Or just do Man of the Hour. Had to edit. First time I hear a song it’s all about feel and the ride of the music. Then I go back to add and understand the lyrics. I can’t do both on the first or second run. But there have been thousands that I’m like change the channel (old schoolers know) on the first listen to the progression. Anyway love the reactions

@brucenadeau5920 3 года назад

"That's so pretty!" .... OK David TIME to OPENLY admit to yourself you ARE SOLD on PJ!!! "I'm going to get emotional"... Yeah INTERVENTION time and get David comfortable in his PJ shoes. To David's bother... Tell David stop being in denial! lol

@brucenadeau5920 3 года назад

David, NO need to be sorry for that rant, there is nothing I could disagree with in what you said, spot on and MORE people NEED to stand up like you did and SAY it! Just another reason to add to the list for you being such a class act bro!

@brucenadeau5920 3 года назад

Dijion and Gmon.... ANOTHER 9 for Eddie/PJ within what a week... Mainly all 8+'s..... Is the day coming he breaks down and admits he is lost into PJ...? lol

@onepunchflan3071 Год назад

Instantly reminds me of Chris and the song seasons

@benjamincoleman9337 Год назад

Its all Eddie on This one .......9.5

@coryolsen2245 Год назад

Glad to hear your review. Always entertaining. Question: what is the highest rating you’ve ever given a song? I don’t think I’ve seen any ratings too high in the 9s & mostly 8s or lower. Thanks & peace!

@THEDavidHeretic Год назад

Nightwish - The Greatest Show On Earth - 9.9

@ryankoepke6987 3 года назад

Sorry....three straight comments...send the pigs.... is the chorus not harmonies of eddie over eddie?

@ryankoepke6987 3 года назад

ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-JBYqTTgLV2E.html

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

More than likely, as we say in the industry, no one can harmonize with you better than yourself.

@sarahdaw6648 3 года назад

It sounds like Zeppelin in the beginning...like an outtake from the III album.

@adrock1011 3 года назад

This might be your best musical breakdown that ive seen yet. I really enjoyed your take on the numeric breakdown of the vocals. Sounds like a 12 string to me? Am i wrong?

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

I'm not hearing the octaves on the single note plucking so I don't believe it is, but the tone the strings are getting certainly sounds like a 12 string....very crisp and bright. then again he just might be playing a really nice acoustic, like a Takamine or a Taylor nd getting that tone. Taylors especially are renowned for that bright, crisp sound in studio.

@adrock1011 3 года назад

David Heretic im a taylor guy myself! But i think when it comes to acoustics... ed likes guild jumbo bodies. Of course i could be wrong. But thank you again. This was a really a great review from a musicians stand point. I loved it

@youravgjoe42 3 года назад

@@THEDavidHeretic I am somewhat of beginner guitar player. I started with a PRS Tremonti and a year in, once I knew I was gonna stick with it, I splurged on a custom built Taylor 814ce dlx in sunburst. Love that instrument, but way more challenging to play than the electric.

@Julieroo28 5 месяцев назад

This song is too sad for me to listen to on a regular basis. Ed has always had a knack for expressing his heartache. I find it interesting that the highest score you’ve ever given a PJ song is for their most recent release, and an all Ed Ved song to boot. They just finished a new album and I’m crossing my fingers that it’s good!

@Janman81 3 года назад

There's no shortage of human behavior to be ashamed of, but for another perspective you might benefit from reading Steven Pinker, who details how dramatically the human condition has improved in recent history.

@jeremymonsi 3 года назад

This songs always destroys me... It's so sad.

@loganandliam 2 года назад

Hey David I don't mean to sound ignorant but you have such an intelligent way that you look at the music. Did you major in music in college? This is a real question.

@THEDavidHeretic 2 года назад

I've been studying music since the age of 3 when I started playing piano, so over 40 years of studying and playing. I've been a professional musician since the age of 15. I did spend 2 years in college, and music was my major....but college just wasn't for me.

@u2tipsy 2 года назад

9.7

@derek4729 3 года назад

great vid man! coming in, i kind of expected a "this isn't my cup of tea, but..." haha. great little tune by ed ved (he's on guitar as well) and a big hat tip to josh evans the producer. this whole album sounds great. couple suggestions: superblood wolfmoon from gigaton ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-BOYdZ0GyQFQ.html, comatose from their self titled 2005 album.. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-zyv9-t01Q74.html some more punkish pj for ya. peace! (also, with you all the way on the state of things these days - particularly the media's role in dragging us down and splitting us apart)

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

Comatose is actually in the pipeline for filming and editing...should be coming out soon. Superblood Wolfmoon is already in the que, added your name to the requesters.

@derek4729 3 года назад

@@THEDavidHeretic nice, looking forward to them. thanks man

@travissmith7009 3 года назад

Please tell me you are a pearl jam fan now?

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

I'm definitely getting there....

@user-nd1to7jq1f Год назад

9.3 is my guess

@duncanpearce7499 3 года назад

sounds a bit Beatles Rain ? or that just me?

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

Now that you mentioned it, yeah I can hear a little in there.

@mastergriggey391 3 года назад

Dave , Pearl Jam is the best lyrical Band of our time, you should listen more They incorporate their music and lyrics to tell A story, listen to inside job again

@lucassegura3460 3 года назад

Totally agreed with your opinion about the human race. I have the same fucking opinion. As The Beatles said, "All you need is love, love is all you need" Keep it up my dude, thank you for being you. Cheers from Montevideo, Uruguay Ps: Please! React to the Rock Steamroller from Argentina! A.k.a Divididos! Ala Delta: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-WVX9hO44Bco.html (Song starts at 3:53) or ¿Que tal?: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-IHnVForkO64.html (with a good bass solo) or Sábado: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-cEvyfPuqc5E.html You are not gonna regret it, i assure you haha

@THEDavidHeretic 3 года назад

Added to the que