Penny and Raj fight over who discovered a comet - The Big Bang Theory 

69th comment hehe

Penny took the picture and penny should have some credit 50/50

⁰

I love u Penny 💕💕💕❤❤

The Crimson wrath wot does it mean lol 😂

Cian Brown it means that he’s Implying because of her personality she probably can’t remember most of her teen years

@@thecrimsonwrath1337 ok thx

@@thecrimsonwrath1337 Or cuz of her drinking lmao

@@thecrimsonwrath1337 Not her personality. Her partying and drinking during that time

Don't compare Tbbt to friends... Friends suck...all they do is sleep around

Ikrrr, I was looking for this comment. It legit looks like the same roof top.

@@ajayv9039 lol and tbbt is worse.This shit was so bad towards the end that the lead actor himself has to call it off

@@ajayv9039 hello my friend do you work for tech support

@@stkrd1467 😂 savage reply

Nope. That's his camera and he positioned it for Penny to see it. Any other person in the room can do that.

@@geraldreodava9713 doesn’t change the fact that without Penny Raj wouldn’t have seen it

Nope there wasn't anything like "observation" that penny did

@@9k49 actually he would have, he did position it and it's his equipment so he would have eventually looked into it. Penny only happened to see it sooner, and that was also bc Raj told her to look into it, and Raj was also the one who recognized it being possibly a comet, Penny had no idea what it was. So it's safe to say that he discovered it.

@@MeUltimateX he was looking at it and yet he didn’t see it. She did. Idk why people hate penny so much

Caro Enba Do u know d name of this episode?

Caro Enba Excuse meeeeee?

kedar soman season 11 episode 21

Philipp Knechtle her excuse me made me laugh so hard 😂

Caro Enba Thanks..

That doesn’t answer his question 🤦🏻‍♂️

@@finlaytancred3436 it also doesn't matter

Penny deserved a lot of credit for the discovery of the comet . Raj’s telescope was set up on Penny’s rooftop and she did tell Raj about seeing something on the telescope. Penny also took the picture of the comet and told him to keep it, even though he said “ don’t worry about it, I’ll probably delete it later “ . Not to mention; that Penny helped give Raj the confidence to talk to people on his own without alcohol. So without Penny in general, Raj wouldn’t have discovered the comet or properly notify the comittiee without being drunk.

@@karleighrock593 Up to girl power 👍

@@iykeharrison9161 I also really didn’t like the fact that Raj was a complete ass during the conversation with Penny about taking credit. He basically took credit for the comet without consideration for Penny and he also insulted her intelligence by comparing her to a monkey.

REJECT HUMANITY RETURN TO MONKE

EXCUSE MEEEEEE

😂

Princess!

EMOTIONAL DAMAGE

Amy compared her intelligence to a chimp in s8 . Sheldon said to Penny in s2e17 “ It’s like talking to a chimp.”

@@demiopeseitan6965 amy and Sheldon called her slut, and whore😂

Penny acting career was an ape in a .... Nvm

She wants told Sheldon am I just a blonde monkey to you.

she reacted like a monkey on point

"I know that Mercury is a planet, but the other thing was helpful"

I've noticed a trend...everyone with and Indian name says the same thing, that Raj is right? Are all Indians thieves? Is it a cultural thing?

"Excuse me?!!"

Doesn't matter if she didn't knew what it was! She's still the one who found it! If it wasn't for her the comet would fly by and no one there would see it!

@@FRODIII No it wouldnt, raj positioned the telescope and asked her to look at it. She clearly didnt discover it

That's different. Newton didn't discover an apple falling, he came up with the theory of gravity through the apple. The comet was discovered by Penny because she's the one who found it. This is like someone who discovered an ancient pharoh's tomb and reported it to someone else, where even though the experts are the ones who know what it was, they didn't discover the tomb, the person who reported it did. That means that with this, Penny deserve the credit for finding something that otherwise would have been missed by the guys.

But sheldon probably would have known it was a comet right away

That would have been more hilarious... He could approach court sue to Rajesh Koothrapali for taking the credit. 🤣

I think , as a scientist himself Sheldon would have understand what this discovery means to Raj and his profession.... Sheldon doesn't care about discover a comet. All he cares about is Theoretical Physics.... It's Penny who's an attention seeker...

@@Kshitij.Chandel Sheldon once wanted to name a planet after him that he figured out with the data Raj collected Both of them argued and finally Sheldon settled the debate with their girlfriends names, Am from Amy, y from Emily so that he could name it Amy. If Sheldon found the comet in this case, Raj wouldn't even have time to register it to his name, Sheldon would've done it way before him.

Then I would have agreed that sheldon should get the credit because he'd have immediately noticed that it was a comet but for penny it could easily have been a blot on the telescope lens. So i don't think she should get the credit for discovering it, however it was a dick move on Raj's part for not even giving her a mention.🤣

Ran Sherman yeah xD

Yeah we should be pissed at Sheldon for being more out of line than Raj was because he kept going ON AND ON over a random comic book chick in front of his fiancee! Unacceptable. That was a bigger issue than the comet argument.

I've been laughing at the idiots arguing on here for 15 minutes. I can't decide which one is my favorite: the crap about which fictional character did something that didn't happen or which said fictional character is a bigger ass. Bless their hearts.

Not an idiot if you have an opinion. God bless those who cannot think for themselves and agrees one person discovered the comet ONLY because everyone else thinks so.

Zoe Fang God bless anyone who spends time and energy arguing about people who don't exist doing something that didn't happen.

@Pers Unn 💯💯💯

@Pers Unn she wouldn't even recognise that it is a comet had it not been raj. Besides everyone might have seen an apple falling down but Newton is the one who found out laws of gravity so others who don't have any knowledge about the stuff can't blame that they too have seen the apple falling down so they too should be given credit life doesn't work that way

@@druvahegde2009 Raj didn't even notice it was a comet before penny started talking about it, SHE discovered it. He took the credit but she was still the one who noticed the comet in the first place.

@@billybob5553 1) Raj is an Astrophysicist and has studied that his whole life and put the effort for this. 2) It was Raj's Telescope. 3) Raj was the one who told Penny to have a look through the telescope, right at the start. 4) Raj positioned the Telescope at the right angle. 5) All Penny did was just look through it and didn't even know what it was. 6) Raj was the one who told Penny to take the picture. *All credit goes to Raj*

@@pahgm6222 1) The only credit Raj gets, is making the discovery possible, and discover the name. Penny was the one looking at it, and therefore being the one to discover it. How do you discover a comet without looking at it?

The point is that they should both SHARE credit. All that time that Raj was looking through his telescope, and he didn't see shit. However, the moment that Penny hopped on, she saw it. Discovery means being the first to see or find something. It doesn't matter if Raj is the scientist, or that it was his equipment. All that is irrelevant to the definition of discovery. However, Raj did identify that it was a comet, and thus, they both should be sharing credit. It amazes me how people in the comment are doing the most mental gymnastics to even elude any sort of logic all because it's Penny.

I didn't say that they shouldn't both share credit. By all means, they can do that. But if you want to know who made the discovery. I just decided that I'd ease everyone's minds by letting them know. (If anyone else on the planet saw it, they didn't discover it legally. Raj did.) This is kinda like the case of when Ash and Misty both wanted Totodile, but in the end you just have to suck it up Misty. lol

Just a bunch of racists who can't see a person of color getting any credit whatsoever.

@@julianbanks1885 is that what you think this is?

And you are bargaining for a fictional topic .

No ....penny didnt even know what a comet was. If it was only Raj, he would've had a high chance of seeing the comet. But if it was only Penny, nothing would've happened

@Drak but she mentioned that she saw something and insisted it is something. Without her, he wouldn't have seen it.

@@claddagh8nuts yeah so what. All the guys were waiting to take a look.Penny just got lucky by taking the first look and accidentally came across the comet( which she didnt even knew the slightest bit about). You've got an astrophysicist standing there to whom the telescope belongs ,who positioned it and everything...and just cus of the only irrational reason she took a peep at it first means she deserves the credit?? She don't deserve nothing

@Drak I disagree. I think they both deserved the credit. The best inventions or discoveries often happened by accident. It's still important.

@@drak3661 ".Penny just got lucky by taking the first look and accidentally came across the comet" Do you know how many discoveries were made accidentally and by getting lucky? Getting lucky doesn't make it any less of a discovery

Is everything rude to you Americans? He even said 'thanks for playing'. *But* the tone can be argued about 🙈

@@angeloliver7613 Americans? What are you talking about, LOL? Is it a poor attempt at trolling? 🤣 I'm italian, he was rude, and that was actually the joke. Did you even see that episode? The joke was that Neil Gaiman kept talking to them and they kept dismissing him as someone who didn't know what the hell he was talking about.

@@angeloliver7613 It is rude to talk to someone without even looking at them. ESPECIALLY as an owner/operator of a store to a customer lol

Shut up we are discussing who discovered the comet

He didn't know he was the owner

This MUST become or be used for a new meme - EXCUSEEEE ME?!?

That expression was the comet. Never seen before 😂

"her face says it all!" Yeah, it says that Kaley is thinking "Oh, dear God, I'm doing one more year of this garbage?! SOMEONE SAVE ME!"

She gets almost a million an episode, could be worse

I had a lot of free time earlier to make comments while I was uploading videos at an Apple Store. Yes, I was in New Mexico.

Raj knowing its a comet is a secondary point here...Raj positioned it and zoomed it ...all penny did was look into it... it's not like Penny randomly positioned it and saw the comet...if he asked any person in the world to see through the telescope everyone would have said the same penny has said (that's there's something)

Fair enough

But the appearance of the comet was not in the knowledge of Raj. It was random.

@@karunm4603 He did hand her the remote and say she could move it around. It doesn't show if she did or not. And also, he did look through it first and not see it.

@@bihongkollogov Well he did all the research into what it was. Penny would have seen it and never able to know what it was without Raj researching it

Ahmed T Ever heard of research assistants? They don't get credit regardless of "effort."

yeah only if she did click on her own..and not because raj said to do so.

Vikas Kyatannawar He didn’t tell her to. She said “I think this is something” and he said “well if you think it’s worth it, take a picture” and so she did. Raj who’s supposed to be an “astrophysicist” was looking in the exact same spot as penny and completely overlooked the comet as nothing. Also, penny as the photographer has the legal right to the photo and therefore Raj isn’t even allowed to use the photo without her permission

Terra messorem “Even legally” 😂 god you’re a moron.

Terra messorem Also, “even legally” those laws are still in place dipshit. Just because your small mind doesn’t understand that doesn’t mean you’d win in court of law. By they way, learn how to use an apostrophe dumbass. It’s not hard.

Raj gets ALL the credit. Astrophysics has always been his realm. He set the telescope directly at the comet's location. ALL Penny did was look into the telescope. It was already there before she saw it. If that was her telescope and SHE set it at the comet's location and saw it, YES that's her discovery. But that's clearly not the case.

FINE lets say if an astronomer positioned his telescope directly at Jupiter and Venus in the sky and I looked into it and I saw Jupiter and Venus does it mean I discovered them? Of course not.

CREDITS FOR RAJ for setting the telescope at the exact location of the comet, for identifying as a comet. CASE CLOSED.

NOPE. I didn't do a thing. All I did was look into them. I didn't do the math, I didn't position the telescope, I didn't do a thing but look. Discovery goes to the astronomer. RAJ set it up and identified it. CASE CLOSED.

Amy and Howard made better science partners than Penny & Raj.

He didn’t even know what it was until he went to the uni

@@benjamen7118 and guess what in university thanks to his work and his knowledge they confirmed that it was a discovery of a comet That's when the thing is documented that's where he got the credit That's how science works

@@benjamen7118 well he knew what it was the moment he saw it , he just wasn't sure & wanted to confirm it.

@@dimitrz2000 What is it? "I don't know. Maybe it's a comet." That is NOT equivalent to "I think it's a comet; I just have to confirm."

@@youmustcreateachanne point is Raj discovered it.

Hello Mr. Srank, good to know you are a tbbt fan. How is Mr. Mayeenkutty, your student?

@@Reslov doing well🤪

The show became feminist in the end.

Reslov How is Putin. Student of America.

@@manikkrsingh8359 He's good. Busy clearing stuff for some trump guy

I think Penny was interested in their scientific pursuits back in the day. She seemed more into those than all the science fiction movies etc.

@@Musicienne-DAB1995 exactly I hate how the writers changed her character towards the end she became the selfish center women she feared she would be

Everyone has their own opinion about who should get the credit and sadly unlike you no matter what anyone else says they won't change their mind. My issue with this clip, I haven't seen the episode yet so it could be resolved later I don't know, is how Raj handles it. They've been friends for 11 years, not only did he not even consider adding her name and I'm assuming by what Leonard said they could have had both but he had no remorse not even thinking about sharing the credit with her. If he would have just shown any sign he was sorry he disregarded not only someone he's been friends with that long but one of his closest friends who's been there for him when he's needed it in the past then I would be happy.

Logan Hufstetler Raj didnt know what it was either. He behaved like a douchebag hogging all the credit. No wonder he is single.

Newton didn't discover gravity and called to the Newton force.

Nobody's SEEN gravity. (Sorry, I couldn't help it, LOL!)

Logan Hufstetler your name appears like Leonard Hofstadter 👍🏼

Her problem was more with how he went about it. He basically said that only he deserved the credit because she was stupid and could never do anything important. She didn't try to use this to get famous and get back into acting. Yes she still wants to be an actress but she has a real career and in a previous episode Leonard talks with her about her going back to acting and she said no, she would like to but she knows staying at her job is the better thing to do, she has grown up at least a little. Raj however is the one trying to use this to get famous.

@@tonyblake7569 Raj actually discovered it. All Penny did was playing with a toy and clicking thr button. She didn't even knew what does that telescope do. 😂😂 She just wanted the credit share though.

@@HarshJ_ohn I don't think she cared as much about the credit as the respect. If he asked her before if he could do that because it would greatly help his career while being cool it wouldn't have any real impact on her she probably wouldn't have minded. The fact he obviously didn't respect her was why she was pissed. Imagine if you were on a team doing something and this one person was the best and got all the credit but you didn't really care about what you were doing anyways but they actually showed you respect, you probably won't care they got the credit. Now imagine they told you you were useless and they deserve all the credit because you suck and they're awesome. You probably still wouldn't care about what you did but would be pissed this person that's on your team was a complete ass for no reason.

One of my favorite

Yes 😂

Similar but better.... Did i just comment on a 3year old comment😂

@@meliodas5147 yes you did😂

Actually it does. First thing that came to my mind was FRIENDS roof top

Loved Amy's line on Hermes and the phalluses.

I did too!

0:11 here comes the only person taller than Raj. It's Sheldon!

jade fire pppp

jade fire iiiiiiip

nah both discover this comet. this just same as when sheldon and amy argue with experimental physicist that discover asymmetric but know nothing about it untill sheldon and amy explain that theoretically.

@@danielkim6736 how ...u can say that when penny positioned it randomly and discovered the comet...but she didn't raj positioned it...

In science nowdays to prove that you were the first to discover something you must have proof. Raj had the telescope focused in one place, looked at it saw nothing new and then invited penny to look. She insisted that she was seeing something when everyone else dismissed her and SHE TOOK A PICTURE. thats how you establish proof. She could have gone to any astrophysicist and ask for opinion of what she insisted was something and they would say congratulations madam you discovered a comment, Raj just happen to be that astrophysicist because he's her friend. That doesn't make it his Discovery. I don't deny his contribution, thats why i think they should share this Discovery from the very first moment but his initial response was unacceptable. If I had to choose only one discoverer however, for the sake of the argument, for the reasons listed above I would choose penny.

@@cicatrixnictophilii well that would work aside from the fact that Raj positioned it, knew what it was, and another scientist, Leonard agrees that Raj discovered it. All Penny did was saw a fuzzy streak and took a picture that Raj told her to do. Christoper Columbus FOUND that there was a way to sail west and find land, but he thought that it was the East Indies, but Amerigo Vespucci discovered that it wasn’t Asia, but in fact a whole new landmass. Who, from Europe, do we give credit for discovering America? Amerigo Vespucci.

@@danielkim6736 it’s not the same as that though

Phuong Le her picture, his comet

She wont know about this comet have no name and she wont see the comet if it isnt because rajh.

And Rajs wouldn't understand it unless someone told HIM.

Carsten Hansen idiot. Nobody told him he fucking saw it and made the discovery himself.

She would be the copyright owner if she owned the camera. Since she didn’t she isn’t, but precedence says she would have a slight possibility of at least a partial win in court.

If Penny didn't press the button by Raj's command, nobody would discover it.

Raj is too sensitive & emotional and egotistic I take it? and if Penny is a bitch to Leonard at times, Raj should be relieved for once to be single.

shes not to leonard n how

y do u think she is ir10031981

y do u say

Raj is a million times smarter than Penny.

For me it was both, something like 80/20 Also: 1) He did put the telescope at the right angle but didn’t notice the comet 2) That’s true 3) That’s true 4) That’s true 5) Neither did Raj 6) He did do the work but without telling Penny and the rest. It is like if I’m in a team, we all do the work, and I’m the one who turns the work in with just my name 7) That’s not completely true, we don’t know if he would have done this 8) If Raj considers Penny a friend, he would have told her about it first so they could come to an agreement. But you are right, Raj was not been humble. I don’t agree it was 100% Raj’s discovery, it was more like 80-90%

@@robertovieyra7020 Fair enough

Yeah, some astrophysicist he is, attempting to watch mercury at night at a higher than 45° vertical angle. You will never find mercury at that height and he should know. That's astronomy basics. And witout Penny there would not have been a discovery at all since he just stood around doing jack shit.

I don't even need that long of a list. Raj is the project lead, the equipment is his. He funded the project. He is the lead author. If there is only one name slot, it's his. It's not even debatable. It's entirely up to him to mention Penny in a thank you note in his paper. If Penny even want co-authorship (secondary author) to the paper that will be published on this, she at least have to put in some work.

1) the telescope was located on the rooftop of Penny’s apartment. 2) Penny notified Raj that she saw something on the telescope 3) she took the damn picture!!! If it was really Rajs comet then he should’ve taken the picture himself. 4) Penny helped give Raj the confidence to talk on his own without using alcohol. So without Penny in general, Raj wouldn’t have been aware of the comet or be able to notify the committee about it without being drunk. 5 ) when taking credit for the comet , Raj was a complete ASS who insulted Penny’s intelligence by comparing her to a monkey.

Yes, but she’s grown a lot between then and now, so to be compared to a monkey after she helped make an actual discovery makes her furious because it’s further cementing the unfair stereotype that Penny is just some bleach blonde bimbo getting by on her looks instead of her skills. And for that to be coming from Raj, a guy who is supposed to be one of her closest friends, makes it doubly hurtful.

I agree..Raj has invested years in this field and as a friend penny should have stepped back. She had nothing to do with. Raj called them all, seted the telescope and made them look into it. Why should penny get the credit? 'A monkey could have looked into it'

@@yashi1410 A monkey would not have pointed the "fuzzy thing" out to Raj, though. This discovery would not have happened at all if not for Penny.

yea and when raj DID look through teh telescope, he didnt see it penny was the one who saw something out of the ordinary not raj despite him looking in the exact same place merely seconds before raj didnt discover anything

@@arcnova yeah Christopher Columbus didn't discover America because he thought it was India but Penny discovered something she can't explain and she's the discoverer of a comet Concept she can't even articulate

Shame you weren't writing scripts for the show.

He told her to look through it aswell

I bet you are the person in a group project who does 1% of the work but still want 50% of the credit

@@perkz3290 you are right, it is the same situation bro

Would you call Einstein the "discoverer" or Relativity? Coz that was neither unexpected, nor was there a search for it. Would you call Newton the "discoverer" of gravity? Coz that one was also neither unexpected, nor came to light during a search.

Bazinga also

I don’t think a person of that kind would been considerate enough to reciprocate the favor

yo y was she she pissed with himshe doesnt reall care bout science n wat up with ppl calling penny a bitch she aint wat up that

emmauel pinno what do u mean all she care s about is the principle n i thought penny n sheldon r friends y penny geting pissed over something she dont care about ??

One of my classic pranks

And Joey doesn’t share....(food)

How you doin?

Please leave an intelligent commentary.

How

Shared with Princess Consuella Banana Hammock

Navdeep Gupta never even thought of that 😂

You saw his weenie, where?

@@BeeBumper ..in the comments section right above this one!!

why leonard's ,, i think the fuzzy one in her teens qualifies to be a comet

Brinda Patel xxx

No, Raj programmed it

It was Fuzzy on Raj's so im Pretty sure Lenords wouldnt of been able to see it even at the same position and time but if Lenord set it up on Raj's scope then it would of been Lenord Discovery but Raj positioned it and everything so he could see Mercury he was being polite and let Penny See it first cause she was curious but really it was his accidental discovery and the fight they have just highlights why I dont like this series theyre all horrible to eachother Raj is the one whose job is all about space and stars and comets and stuff so even if Penny did set the thing up and find it herself by looking around a real friend would of given him the find cause it would probably be good for his career and stuff...probably...and even if it didnt it means more to him then it does to Penny....but theyre always being rude to eachother and messing with eachother in the worst ways

@@MeelogMalterion no it would have been the discovery of whoever the following day could confirm the discovery to the university OJ Simpson isn't an assassin he is allegedly an assassin officially and outside speculations he is no murder If you don't do the paperwork and don't get recognise you are no discoverer you are just a dude with a hobby

If he could identify it as a comet, then yes

KingdomHeartsFan3211 I don’t think so.Do you think everyone in history that are known for their discoveries are the first ones to stumble upon their discoveries? The ones who understand the value behind it are the ones who get recognized otherwise you are just an observer. Open and shut case

But he didn't recognize the value before, after she took the picture, because she said it was something special. I'd say it was Penny who discovered it. And no, most people don't get the value of it, until it is explained to them, but that goes for Raj too.

Carsten Hansen so who had the means and the resources to get there first? Would penny even bother to find out what it was? Whose equipment did they use to take the picture and who was the one who pointed out that it looked like a comet?

@joe20m20 - Chuck Yeager is known as the man who broke the sound barrier in 1947. He did it in a plane made by the US airforce. Would you say it was Chuck Yeager, that broke the sound barrior or the US air force?

Carsten Hansen he is the man who broke sound barrier not discovered sound barrier. The engineers who designed it so are the ones who invented such a aerodynamic machine. Neil Armstrong didn’t discover moon if you were wondering about that too

Except he didn't do his job. He just stood around doing nothing until Penny pointed out the fuzzy object.

It is a good thing you are pretty

It’s both of them, both names should be credited. She observed it first, he identified what it was

I agree too. Penny's name can be in paper but not as discoverer. Raj should get major credit

Interesting moral dilemma. To me it's not even a debate. She saw it, so she discovered it. His claim would be like taking a photo of the whole sky and claiming you've discovered everything in the picture cause you positioned the camera, which is obviously nonsense. There is no philosophical or morally or factual way he discovered the comet.

@@mdaniels6311 looking at something doesn't make you a discoverer, identifying and knowing what it is, do. Newton discovered gravity, who should get the credit? Newton or the apple? Penny is the apple.

@@angelminaj617 the apple story is apocryphal by the way. Newton didn't discover gravity as any caveman who fell down a ravine will tell you, but he came up with a theory to describe gravity's effects. You are comparing apples to oranges, pardon the pun. So if I discover a alien spacecraft via telescope, but I don't know what it is, I'm not the discoverer?

Hmmm she said knots😂😂😂😂 to sheldon😂😂😂😂 dammm about string theory😂😂😂

I dont think you know what an achievement is. you can just happen upon an achivement by accident.

I'm pretty sure in situations like this you would use the girls maiden name

@@moizmoosajee1432 Her maiden name was never revealed though.

@@moizmoosajee1432 I dont think so. Madame Curie is not known as Madame Sklodowska.

Exactly!

Well, the positioning , and setting the scale of the telescope matters the most...all the hardwork was done by raj...penny just said she saw something and raj asked her to take a picture....raj just gave her a chance to look thru the telescope...raj deserves more credit definitely

@@ritamgoswami5586 ye i think penny shouldnt get much credit for that i mean raj would have looked in the telescopee and would have found it anyway ig. Only thing penny did was that she looked before him.

@@ritamgoswami5586 it was the way raj delivered it as of he found it all by himself. He didn't. Without penny pointing that out he could have just dismissed it as an "eyelash" and then he compared her to a monkey which added salt to the wound. If he had only thanked penny and explained it to her how important it is to her job that he alone discovered the comet, I think penny would have considered it.

So the first guy who saw an apple fall should have credit for the discovery of gravity? No it took Newton to understand it. Same way it took Raj to understand that it could of been a comet which he confirmed. I get the feeling you the person in a group project who does 1% of the work but want 50% of the credit. Welcome to the real world.

So from he non-nordic European point of view, Columbus didn't discover America because he thought that he was in East Asia. Newton didn't discover gravity. He interpreted it.

@@alexh8613 Columbus didn't discover America. Bad argument

@@alexh8613 Columbus didnt discover America. Native Americans discovered America. All Columbus did was report back to royal family back in italy.

@@MikeMessiah What part of from a non-nordic European point of view did you not understand.

Not true. If I find weird metals while digging in my backyard so I call up the local news and it turns out to be Alien Artifacts that prove we are not alone in the Universe, I would be credited with the discovery, not the government scientist that identified them.

I think it was less of a fight and more of a Lawsuit against the guy who put down the camera in the intention that the monkeys can take pictures. And how the world is, he lost the lawsuit and was deeply shattered and broke.....

yeah, I remember that, it was a really famous selfie that the mankey took of itself, then it went viral.

I don't know the idea that I animal can own the rights to anything is kind of a joke just take the camera back from the monkey ownerships 9/10 of the law let's see them take the picture stop me from using it the monkey can't really argue is point so really the owner of the monkey is arguing about the picture.

Tony Blake well said! I've never really disliked Raj but now I can see why he finds it so hard to keep a girlfriend, no girl would like a whiney, selfish, spoilt child as a boyfriend!

BING! POP GOES THE WEASEL!

Tony Blake raj should have the credit

Lupe Esparza III why should he get all the credit and not share it?

Well she is stupid basically.

Simp

@@vortexfury7197 exactly my thought xD

Never liked Raj, I think the actor is fantastic but as a character I can’t stand him, he’s selfish arrogant and just a plain old douchebag!

Ummm no that analogy doesn’t work at all

@@squares4u work perfect Oh that was something I don't know what it was but something was wrong Newton passing by starts thinking and later writing Raj and Newtown the people who did the writing got the credit not dude falling and Penny who knew something happened and it was uncommon but couldn't really explain what really it was

Daniel waugh he should name it after her

but this is Raj, he became such a self centred jerk and think of himself now

oh f*ck off she didn't discover sh*t raj's point is right if a monkey comes along and snapped the picture he wouldn't be the one who discovered it either it was the person who set it up and was activly looking at the stars

Bloody Waitress getting credit, Raj is a Physicist, Penny just got lucky getting a right Neighbour otherwise, she didn't knew even 6th Grade Science. Really Dumb Girl. Nothing more than a Mouth.

It doesn’t matter if she doesn’t have an interest. She pointed out it could be something when Raj didn’t think it was anything, which convinced him to take a picture and led to the discovery. She should at least get shared credit, so the way Raj snuck around and just claimed it was pretty rotten of him. You don’t do that to friends.

@@Jeff_Pryce but if Raj was looking through the telescope he wouldnt of thought it was an eyelash he probably would of recognized it where as theres alot of jokes at the expense of Pennys Intelligence she has smart moments but is mostly pretty dumb and her confusing an eyelash was supposed to be funny cause shes that clueless or something if Raj Wasnt there she would of thought of well whatever and carried on no picture would be taken and that would of been the end of it but he set up the camera and everything to take pictures...so yeah

@@MeelogMalterion Penny didn't confuse the comet for an eyelash, lol. Raj is the one who dismissed whatever she was seeing as an eyelash, probably because he'd JUST looked through the telescope himself and didn't notice the comet. And then he told her to take a picture only because she was insistent that she was seeing something of interest. Not sure what makes you think she would've brushed it off, considering how immediately interested she was in what she was seeing.

What injustice are talking about, he was being an asshole the whole episode, if she hadn’t even said anything, Raj wouldn’t have discovered it in the first place.

@@MeelogMalterion actually no he wouldn't He even says in the scene he didn't know what it was he just said "probably" a comet

But if Raj didn't tell her to take a picture, penny could've just dismissed it, too. Even if penny took a picture without Raj's command, she may think, "ooh, it's nothing. Guess I'll just watch the stars" and throw the idea away that it's a comet, which she wouldn't have come up with if it weren't for Raj. What if on the other neighborhood someone discovered it first but didn't know it what it was. Would he still be considered as the first person to discover it?

well if you were ordering someone to take something they found, were you the one who discovered it or was it the person who saw it first? like what if you went to some ancient ruins then your friend found a super cool knife, your friend wasn't sure so you told your friend to go get it so we could make sure, were you the one who discovered it because of you bringing your friend, or you telling your friend to get it or your friend for finding it? another one, if you brought a friend to a nice restaurant, then he suddenly starts complaining about something uncomfortable, you said: "well if it's uncomfortable then remove what is making you uncomfortable", then he shoots a guy in the head in the opposite side of the room, your friend didn't like the way the person was looking at him, so did you kill the man because you brought your friend here, or because you gave the suggestion, or was it your friend's fault? (I wanted to use kill instead of remove in the dialogue but it sounded out of place so I had to use remove, because there is no word for "violently remove something", if I say eradicate or eliminate it sounds awkward and out of place, and doesn't really convey what I mean) I personally believe it was penny's achievement, however it is true that raj was the one who coerced penny to take a picture, so I can't really side with anyone here and just want both of them to take credit, but making use of my second example-ish, I believe it to be the friend's fault for killing someone, so yeah I gotta say penny here although if we are arguing that raj "discovered" it and penny was just the first to "see" it, then ok techinically raj did discover it, penny just saw it first, but they said that it was a comet never seen before, so I still believe it should be penny

That makes no sense. However saw it discovered it. Raj identified that it was a comet, but Penny saw it first. They both deserve to share credit. I really don't get why people find this so hard to understand.

@@MissNayNay It's you who do not understand how it works in scientific community. If there is only one name slot, it's going to be the name of the first author/ project lead.

@@tuanseattle Not necessarily. What kind of scientific community you're working on? That would cause a shit ton of legal problem. In the context of the scene, the intention was not to discover something new. So there is no project here, just casual stargazing. However Penny sees and discoveres somethings, and gets the proof as she think it's worth. Then the scientist looking at the picture identifies it. The person who has discovered it is Penny. Raj was just the scientist that's get to be asked for information.

Q I see what you did there. 😎

Lucifer S. Morningstar I don’t get it :/

You mean, Kaley's Comet?

You said it not me.

Funny, a few seasons ago, Sheldon found a comet and Raj confirmed what it is and they both got credit, Raj was clearly trying to exclude Penny so he got all the credit.

@@nathanevans1382 Sheldon discovered an asteroid and unlike Penny knew what the celestial body was so he wasn't a random observer. And they both spent the weekend in the observatory so it's most possible that they ended up making a paper together and if so deserves his name on the research

@@sonam6221 Sheldon didn't actually know what the celestial body was, he knew it was something but he didn't know what it was, he was hoping it was a whole god damn planet! Plus legally, Penny would be the only discoverer, Penny even mentions in the episode that since she took the picture it's her discovery, I'm being nice saying Raj could put down both of their names.

Well not really. If i give you a shovel and tell you where to dig, did you discover that bone, or we both did?

@@bartoszbielawski8558 you're right. You both did. But the thing is, Raj took the full credit when he could've shared it with Penny. You know it really hurts when you deserve something that you don't get, just like when I was the one who wrote the script for our class performance then the credit was given to my classmate who they thought the one worked on it. I was upset.

@Devansh Shah Penny probably would've if Raj spoke to her before taking the credit without question and then call her stupid.

Did the paleontologist tell you where and how to dig for it?? Because thats kinda what happened here, he set everything up and had her take a look at what he did..

@@bartoszbielawski8558 Digging deeply is not the same as pressing a button

Jeffry Syam agreed

Mr. Scientist over here🤦🏻‍♂️

No it doesn't ❤️

It sounds like shit

No

Why would he share credit?

So the non-european world was "discovered" only when Europeans noted it? What.

​@@EchoMirage72 From an European point of view, yes.

@@Tontoquienloleation What was the tallest mountain on the planet before Mt Everest was discovered?

@@EchoMirage72 I'm not saying America wasn't there, I'm just saying it was discovered by Europeans because before that Europeans didn't know it existed. How would you use the word "discover"?

@@Tontoquienloleation Discover is an asinine pro-European word. As if something doesnt exist unless it was found by a European / "Western Culture" ... I don't have a better turn of phrase, or word, but discover should only be used when ANY person hasn't seen it before.

Since it's a sitcom it can be excused