🎯 Key Takeaways for quick navigation: 00:03 🎙️ Introduction to Professor Ali Ataie and his expertise - Dr. Ali Ataie's background and expertise in biblical hermeneutics and comparative theology. - The subjects he teaches at Zaytuna College and his educational qualifications. 01:28 📜 Theological underpinnings of Israel's military engagement - Discussion of the theological underpinnings of Israel's military engagement with Palestine. - Reading of a passage from the Torah related to Israel's actions. - The presentation's focus on the religious justification for the conflict. 03:40 💡 An important reminder and introduction to Judaism - Discussion about the nuanced portrayal of "people of the book" in the Quran. - Mention of anti-Zionist Jews who oppose Zionism on religious and moral grounds. - An overview of Judaism as a monotheistic tradition with similarities to Islam. 06:57 🌍 Jewish history and its theological significance - Explanation of how Jewish history significantly influences Jewish theology. - The concept of chosenness and the responsibility of bringing monotheism to the world. - The idea of collective responsibility and collective punishment in Jewish theology. 13:08 🤔 Anatomical and ontological distinctions in Jewish theology - Discussion of the belief in essential differences between Jews and Gentiles. - Mention of the concept of Jews having two souls. - The influence of historical interactions and propaganda on these beliefs. 16:08 🌐 Demographics and denominational divisions among American Jews - Demographics of American Jews, including their religious identification. - The three major denominational divisions among Ashkenazi Jews. - Historical factors influencing these divisions. 21:26 📜 Differences in Torah and mitzvot interpretations - Distinctions in the authority and interpretation of the Torah and mitzvot among Orthodox, Conservative, and Reform Jews. - The Orthodox belief in the literal word of God in the Torah. - Variances in how the Torah is perceived within different denominations. 46:21 🔍 Core Beliefs of Judaism - The immutability of the Torah in Judaism, which means that there is no concept of a new testament like in Christianity. - The belief in 613 mitzvot that are considered valid and binding upon Jews as long as the world exists. - The concept of God's omniscience and His knowledge of all human actions and thoughts. 50:08 🤴 Belief in the Coming of the Messiah - Discussion of the belief in the coming of the Messiah in Jewish tradition. - The idea that this Messiah is not a divine being but a human redeemer. - The historical development of messianic beliefs and the role of King Hezekiah. 01:00:02 🌍 Significance of Jerusalem in Islam and Christianity - The importance of Jerusalem as a sacred place in Islam due to its association with various prophets. - The role of Jerusalem in Islamic history, including the Prophet Muhammad's Night Journey and Ascension. - The contradiction of Christian Zionism in supporting the construction of the Third Temple in Jerusalem, which is seen as blasphemous in the New Testament. 01:08:01 📜 The Day of Passover and Crucifixion in the Gospels - Different Gospel accounts of the day of Jesus's crucifixion, with a focus on the Gospel of John. - Explanation of why the day of crucifixion differs in the Gospels. 01:08:57 ⛪ New Testament's View on Chosen People - The New Testament's perspective on the chosen people and replacement theology. - How the New Testament emphasizes faith in Jesus as the defining factor for being chosen. 01:10:22 🏛️ Supersessionism in Christianity - Discussion on supersessionism and how it is a prevalent concept in the New Testament. - Reference to key passages and early church fathers who promoted supersessionism. 01:12:49 🕊️ Christian Zionism and Its Conflicts with the New Testament - Exposing the conflict between Christian Zionism and the New Testament's teachings. - Highlighting the paradox of supporting the Third Temple and sin sacrifices from a New Testament perspective. 01:14:12 🇵🇸 Understanding the Present Situation in Palestine - Exploring the present situation in Palestine and the need for a comprehensive theological understanding. - Drawing comparisons with historical religious conflicts and responses to them. 01:24:29 📜 The Quran's Stance on the Bible - Clarifying the Quran's perspective on the Bible as an overseer and standard of judgment. - Acknowledging the historical corruption of the biblical text and the Quran's role. 01:25:57 📚 Modern Jewish Interpretations of Biblical Genocide - Discussing modern Jewish interpretations of biblical passages related to genocide, emphasizing historical context. - Mentioning how traditional Judaism views these passages and the limited application. 01:28:42 ⚖️ Contemporary Apologetics on Genocidal Passages - Overview of contemporary Christian apologetics that attempt to address or downplay genocidal biblical passages. - Examples of arguments used to rationalize or explain these challenging texts. 01:29:24 🕊️ Opinions on the justification of violence in the Holy Land - Two main opinions: one favors a peaceful approach, while the other suggests the violence can only occur when the Messiah comes. - Religious Zionism is a third perspective that justifies violence and considers Palestinians as modern-day Canaanites. 01:30:37 🇮🇱 Religious Zionism and its role in justifying violence - Religious Zionism sees no contradiction between Zionism and traditional Judaism. - They believe that the government of Israel has a religious duty to wage a war of extermination against the Palestinian people to prepare the land for the Messiah's arrival. - The political party halud, led by Benjamin Netanyahu, promotes these beliefs. 01:36:40 ☠️ AMC (Amalek) and its role in promoting violence - AMC refers to an enemy of the Jews, and its designation changes from one generation to the next. - Anyone who argues for the dissolution of the modern state of Israel is labeled as AMC, and this label is used to justify violence. - There's a disturbing trend in Western public discourse where defending Palestinians is branded as supporting terrorism and anti-Semitism, blocking any discussion of their plight. 01:50:49 📜 The problematic depiction of Patriarchs in Judaism - The depiction of Patriarchs in the Bible, particularly Genesis. - Anachronistic labeling of Abraham as a Jew or Israelite. - Contrasting this with the Quran's view of Abraham as a monotheist. 01:51:18 📚 Anachronism and historical interpretations - The historical-critical method used by trained historians and scriptural scholars. - The problematic anachronistic labeling of Abraham as a Jew in academic editions. - Contrasting historical facts with later interpretations. 01:52:12 🕊️ Misconceptions and justifications in current discussions - The misuse of the "accidental civilian casualties" argument. - Challenging the logic that unintentional civilian deaths make actions acceptable. - Advocating for a stronger stance against violence in current conflicts. 01:53:07 💔 Condemning the violence in Palestine - Calling out apologists for their reluctance to condemn Israel's actions. - Questioning how much violence is necessary before condemnation occurs. - Drawing parallels to deception in media representation. 01:54:06 🤲 The power of prayer and seeking guidance - The significance of prayer as a tool for believers. - Citing the importance of seeking the truth and shunning falsehood. - Encouraging viewers to ask God for guidance and clarity in their understanding. 01:55:33 🚫 Seeking protection from tribulations - Reflecting on the prophetic guidance to seek protection from the Antichrist and tribulations. - Emphasizing the importance of holding fast to the Quran and Sunnah. - Stressing the significance of regular prayer and Dua (supplication). 01:56:25 🤲 Using Dua as a weapon - Offering a short Dua for protection against the punishment of Hell, the grave, and tribulations. - Highlighting the power of Dua as a spiritual weapon. Made with HARPA AI
I'm one hour into the recording, yet haven't had enough of the treasure-trove Ali Ataie sir. What an academician! Subhan'Allah waking up to the notification and getting straight to the discussion! Blissful, wa'Allah! We're off to a rocky start, Alhumdul'Allah! I'm all love for y'all all the way from India-occupied Kashmir!
Paul Williams. DIVINE NEWS 86 YEAR OLD captainsays your reward is with ALLAH INSHALLAH. YOUR discussion with ALI ATAIE IS THE BEST I HAVE EVER HEARD. YOUR REWARD IS WITH ALLAH. HE HAS ALREADY REWARDED YOU FOR IT IS HE WHO SELECTED YOU TO BECOME MUSLIM EVERY CHRISTIAN IN THE WORLD MUST ACCEPT ISLAM THE RELIGION OF STRICT MONOTHEISM PURITY CLEANLINESS WISDOM AND TRUTH
Dear Dr Ataie, You clearly enjoy languages, and especially the gutteral ones. I'd like you to take up the challenge of writing an uncorrupted version of the Bible. Muslims everywhere complain of biblical errors and corruption, leading many honest, truth-loving Jews and Christians to think that their Bible is not a trustworthy source! Please set about the task at once, ensuring that every passage of the Bible that those liars and cheats have altered is made good. I really look forward to seeing the Bible as it was meant to be. (And, just ignore those threats that Moses made; you know, the ones about not adding or diminishing the word!) Thank you in advance. I can't wait!
@@paulbennett9574 wow, that is a big ask. how is he to know what is 'corruption' and what is not? should he include the book of enoch? gospel according to peter?
@@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi The 66 books of the KJV will do nicely! Don't worry, l'm not expecting this revision to happen in a hurry. It suits Muslims to be able to say, 'Oh, that's because the Bible was corrupted'. Why would a Muslim want to be cornered by the truth?
I always wonder about Christians. They believe almost the exact opposite of what is written in their Bible. I always ask them if they really read anything.
Only Paul can hold an amazing interview and conversation with the highly erudite and eloquent Dr. Ali Ataie because they both know and understand what they're talking about. Paul knows when to interrupt the flow, when to add a comment, when to raise a question, when to clarify a point, when to elaborate. Neither the interviewer nor the interviewee are ordinary people. Kudos to Br. Paul for inviting Dr. Ali Ataie on BT. He's my favorite of all the guests on the channel. Dr. Ataie captures my attention and imagination more than any other guest on the channel because of his sheer knowledge and understanding of the subject-matter and the magnetic way of his delivery. Masha Allah. And all praise is due to God.
@@BloggingTheology paul, you seem like a wise and well studied muslim. can you tell me if jinn can have sex with humans? without possessing a human? i read the book: the world of jinn and devils' and it says they can. i was wondering if this author is wrong? page 22: Marriage between the jinn and humans One still hears about some man marrying a jinn or some woman marrying one of the jinn or a woman being proposed to by one of the jinn. Al-Suyooti mentioned many such reports from the early generations and scholars pointing to the existence of marriages between humans and jinn. Ibn Taimiya said, Humans and jinn have gotten married and have had children, this has happened often and is well-known. Assuming it is possible, many of the scholars showed a dislike for such a marriage. Scholars such as Ishaaq were known to have shown a di al-Hasan Qataada, al-Hukum slike for it. Imam Malik could and not find any text that would prohibit it but he himself did not like for it to occur and he gave his reason for saying so, I hate that it would be the case that we would find a woman who is pregnant and we ask her, Who is your husband? and she replies, One of the jinn. Much evil would be the result of that.
@@BloggingTheologyLook at Psalm 83, especially verse 5? A coincidence? Ali who knows Hebrew very well. Curiously, he does not mention that Hamas is mentioned in several places in the Tanakh by name. 83:2 Do not keep silent, O God; do not hold your peace and be still, O God. 83:3 For, behold, your enemies make a tumult; and those who hate you have lifted up the head. 83:4 They have taken crafty counsel against your people, and consulted against your hidden ones. 83:5 . 83:6 For they conspire together with one accord; they make an alliance against you: 83:7 The tents of Edom, and the Ishmaelites; of Moab, and the Hagarites; 83:8 Gebal, and Ammon, and Amalek; the Philistines with the inhabitants of Tyre;
we could try and arrange one for you and you will either confirm or deny you seem like someone who seeks the truth . also how much are u paid per comment ? @@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi
The amount of times I am playing this whole talk... mindblown. I have to replay it for letting al this knowledge sink in. Allahoma barek. I knew the zionists were evil but now I understand why. Amazing knowledge!!!! I am in awe of Prof. Atale Thank you both may Allah Almighty protect and bless you❤
Wow! I am Christian and I am really happy to listen to this lecture. It’s almost unbelievable that a Muslim understands more than many Christians about their own faith! Good job!! #FreePalestine
Please read all Sister that’s because we read the Quran and now understand it because it’s translated. Arabic was not my mother’s tongue. It was bangla ( Bangladesh). To tell you the truth after reading/ listening to lectures found every religious scriptures brought the same message ( submit our will to god). VEDAS might have been our scripture (Hindus valley tribe) but now corrupted but basic message is still there. I live in uk but born in Bangladesh, came at childhood age and now 45. What I am saying is my ancestors followed the scripture but the Hindus ancestors didn’t. I will explain a few things later. Same with bible,Torah, budhist scripture got corrupted. But all say same message One god (imageless) and they talk about the coming of Mohammed pbuh. In the VEDAS he is called narasansa also known as the KALKI AVATAR (gives clear details). The Hindus are waiting for KALKI AVATAR. Same with the JEWS in the Torah there is a sentence “ hikku muttakim be kulli Muhammadim…??…oh …..??…of Jerusalem” But they are waiting for the MESSIAH and that is Jesus pbuh. In the bible you have to follow the teachings of Jesus pbuh (red writing). A statement i will mention is something like this “ think that i shall go away now or HE the spirit of truth shall not come, all that HE hears shall HE speak, HE shall GLORIFY ME” The Christians say it’s the Holy Spirit BUT the word HE represents a person, also a person can hear and speak. A Holy Spirit can’t . There’s a lot more statements. Also it mentions “think that I have not to destroy the law of the prophets but to fulfill “ so 1) pork is prohibited 2) Jesus pbuh was circumcised 3)give charity 4)fasting 5) women’s should dress modestly like NUNS 6) Jesus pbuh fell on his knees and put his hands and face on the ground and prayed to god” Think we Muslims follow these teachings. But Christian’s don’t because they believe Jesus pbuh died for their sins. Proven from the Bible he was not crucified, also check what an ancient bible found,in the museum of turkey says. He is still alive Also has scientific errors. So it’s corrupted. Quran cannot get corrupted it’s memorised by Muslims, also written in it that it will be guarded from corruption. Over 1400yrs old And has facts 100% accurate so far that we found in this modern era. Take just these 2 mentally (check others later) 1)” oh mankind I have created you from a single pair of male and female and divided you into nations and tribes so you may recognise each other “ - DNA - 2)” think that we can not just reconstruct your bones but can also cover it with flesh right to the tips of your fingers “ - THUMBPRINT - PROVES Except Jesus pbuh 1) everyone is created from a pair (parents) as you go up the family tree it goes smaller to first pair ADAM & EVE pbu them. We are related somewhere, migration, slave trade, refugees, mixed coloured marriages & SAYTAN got us into this modern era. 2) proves every SOUL has a IDENTITY. So please STUDY if you believe in HEAVEN & HELL. We don’t want brothers and sisters going to HELL. Please don’t take it the wrong way. Just giving an advice.
@user-mc8bb6zo3q yes the chosen ones I agree Lets see if have idea of the Jews do you know the past history of the Jews and all the prophets ? Where they are from? And do they follow their religious scripture TORAH properly?
@user-mc8bb6zo3q that first word shows already what you are like. Why are a lot of Jews against the Jews who are in Israel. Do you know the prophets Do you know which land where Jews were from?
It's crazy to think that there are Christians who support Israel, the Jews who believe disgusting things about their Jesus, things that I can't even utter, to attack Muslims who love and respect Jesus.
Christanity is a branch of Judaism created by romans to include those that belive in jesus in to the circle. So they csn somewhat control them and it worked lol
their belief in 'end times' trumps all that. the christians believe the jews must be in control of the 'holy land' for the second coming of christ. it is like muslims believing gog and magog will wipe out everyone except 1200 muslims before the day of judgement. or that you have to kill all the jews before the hour: Abu Huraira reported Allah's Messenger (may peace be upon him) as saying: The last hour would not come unless the Muslims will fight against the jews and the Muslims would kill them until the jews would hide themselves behind a stone or a tree and a stone or a tree would say: Muslim, or the servant of Allah, there is a jew behind me; come and kill him; but the tree Gharqad would not say, for it is the tree of the jews. (Book #041, Hadith #6985) crazy, i know, but that is what you get from the religious.
Absolute necessary & masterclass of a seminar. I learned so much from this channel, and Dr Ali is without a doubt one of my favorite guests. May Allah preserve you both ❤🤲🏾
Certainly not all. There seems to be susceptibility among those who are historically ignorant. Among those with a consciousness of history, e.g. copts, orthodox, some catholics, there is a lot more understanding. After all, many of our brothers and sisters live in Gaza, Lebanon, the West Bank, and throughout the so-called Middle-east.
Thank you both for all I've learned today. As a greek christian, I have felt the need to pray tonight for all the people whose religion, any religion, is a means of worshiping love, respect, truth, logic and solidarity to suffering human beings like the brave people in Gaza and the West Bank.
DEAR PAUL CONGRATULATIONS FROM DIVINE NEWS 86 YEAR OLD AMERICAN B57 BOMBER COMMANDER SYED AHMED SHAMSUDDIN PAK 3969 28 GDP PAKISTAN ALHAMDULLAH. FROM TOP CHRISTIAN PRIEST ALLAH SELECTED YOU TO BE AS TOP MUSLIM ISLAMIC PREACHER . YOUR WONDERFUL INTERVIEW WILL BE RECORDED IN THE RECORDS WITH ALLAH INSHALLAH.
DEAR PAUL WILLIAMS. THIS IS DIVINE NEWS. AFTER LISTENING TO THE LECTURES OF AN EXCELLENT TOP PRIEST BLESSED BY ALMIVHTY GOD ALLAH TO BECOME MUSLIM EVERY CHRISTIAN IN THE WORLD MUST ACCEPT ISLAM THE RELIGION OF STRICT MONOTHEISM PURITY CLEANLINESS WISDOM AND TRUTH. I DREAMT THE NEXT PRESIDENT TRUMP ACCEPTED ISLAM AND THE WHOLE OF AMERICA AND CANADA BECAME MUSLIMS. PRAISE BE TO ALLAH ALMIGHTY GOD.
The symbolism of Hebrew letters 12:46 The duty of Jews and the restoration of righteousness 13:28 Equality and degrees of belief 13:59 Differences between Jews and Gentiles 14:44 Historical context of Jewish beliefs 16:12 Origins of the term "Jew" 16:35 Significance of the name "Yehuda" 17:09 Abraham and Moses were not called Jews 17:41 Name of the religion during the time of Moses 18:04 Three major divisions in the global Jewish community 18:17 Confessional division among Ashkenazi Jews 19:24 Devotional spectrum among Jews 20:25 Demographics of American Jews 20:30The Perpetual Virginity of Mary 22:06 Different Views on the Authority of Torah 22:41 Authority of Talmud and Mishna 25:24Comparison between Torah and Talmud 27:10 Differences in the Concept of the Messiah 27:59 Introduction to Rabbi Moses Maimonides 29:04 Maimonides' Interpretation of Scripture 30:52Aristotle's Theory of the Mean 32:34 Controversy Surrounding Maimonides 31:56 Introduction to the Ethical Theory of Virtue 32:28 Aristotle's Four Causes 32:49 The 13 Principles of Faith in Judaism 35:22 Introduction to Radical Judaism 38:15 The Special Relationship between Moses and God 44:42 Reincarnation and Kabbalah 49:35 The Theology of Restoration and Messianism 51:50 In 2 Samuel 7:16, God made a promise to David that his kingdom and throne would be established forever. Dissonance and Reinterpretation 53:45 The rabbis say that we are in the final hours of the sixth day, and the Messiah's deadline is September 2240. Critique of Future Davidic Messiah 59:22 The Importance of Jerusalem in Islam 01:01:23 Understanding Zionism and Christian Zionism 01:03:58 The Connection Between Zionism and Christianity 01:05:39 The Tabernacle and the Temple 01:05:57 The Gospel of John mentions a Roman centurion piercing Jesus' side, resulting in blood and water flowing out. This event is significant because it coincided with the time when the lambs were being sacrificed in the temple during the Passover. Jesus is seen as the new temple, and the piercing of his side symbolizes the opening of the temple, with blood and water flowing out. Christian Zionism as a Betrayal of the New Testament 01:07:44 Christian Zionists often reference Genesis 12:3, where God promises to bless those who bless Abraham and curse those who curse him. Supersessionism in Christianity 01:10:35 The New Chosen People 01:11:25 Radical Christianity's View on Sacrifices 01:13:14 Radical Judaism and the Attack on Gaza 01:31:05 The speaker encourages people to research Gush Emunim, a coalition of faithful Jews, and the rabbis Abraham Cook and Yehuda Cook who are associated with radical Zionism. The Israeli government is accused of having a religious duty to completely destroy the Palestinians, as they believe it will pave the way for the arrival of their Messiah. The speaker mentions the Likud political party, which consists of extremely dedicated religious Zionists, and its leader Benjamin Netanyahu, who has been the Prime Minister of Israel since 2009. The speaker argues that the Israeli government's clear and evident policy, as seen in their treatment of Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank, is aimed at preparing the land for the arrival of their Messiah.
I was born a Christian but I've since been non religious because I found a lot of fabrications in christianity as I was growing up so now I'm slowly trying to refine my faith in the most high and hoping that he forgives me and show me the truth. This is the best theological message I've ever heard that aligns with my beliefs and what led me to leave Christianity. Bless you Dr. Ali and peace be unto everyone who seeks the truth and speaks against violence being done to innocents around the world.
Amazing! N yet u do not feel inclined to embrace the true religion? Do u not see we r not your enemy rather the Creator is our God n one n the same who revealed the previous scriptures but they got corrupted! So now the truth has dawned on u then by default your only saving grace is to embrace Islam! N follow the final prophet so that when Jesus returns as the true awaited Messiah u can follow him n not be sidelined to be killed because he is returning with a vengeance on all those that tried to kill him n made him godly n divine!
It's a shame that "Radical Judaism" was not talked about 20 years ago - it most certainly would have gone a long way to preventing the "industrial genocide" taking place in Gaza, today!!!
Paul, could you interview Norman Finklestein as well please? He seems to know a lot as well behind what is currently happening in the Israel-Palestinian conflict.
Dr Ali is my favourite guest on your show. He’s a genius Islamic studies. Allah has given him a brain with all these languages, and all that he shares with us. He’s very calm and you can understand what he’s talking about without yelling thank you Dr. Alie for your knowledge and sharing this with us. Peace be upon a Palestine ❤❤
Just want to say…. After 9/11 millions reverted to isalm; Netanyahu said the this was their 9/11, expect millions to revert to Islam in coming months. ❤ Palestinians have given their Dawah to Islam ❤
Fascinating insights - jazaakumallahu khayran. 🤲 And Dr Ataie is spot on: we've been bashed over the head with the "jihad" argument for what feels like forever. Time to shine a spotlight on "herem"!
In the Islamic world, there is a tremendous feeling of anger towards Israel that has never been seen before. Even the most moderate Muslims are calling for jihad
And I always thought modern day Israel was secular/atheist. They are extremists and fascists. It seems they cherry pick verses from the Scriptures to justify committing war crimes and genocide. Most of the Jews today are Khazars (European Ashkenazi Jews), converts to Talmudic Judaism in 740 AD. Modern day Israel is of the Synagogue of Satan (fake Jews). prophecied in Revelation 2, 9 & 3,9. A truly satanic and evil state.
Paul, as a fellow human, a fellow Muslim, as a fellow revert, as a fellow westerner, I just like to thank you. You've been one of the people I've recommended to those who showed me their curiosity about Islam and modern day public figures. A very balanced, patient, educated man. Dr Ataie seems to fit perfectly into your platform. Just a great upload. Keep up the beautiful work. May Allah swt reward you ❤️
Dr. Ali Ataie has become one of my favorite scholar along with Shaykh Hamza Yusuf and Shaykh Abdul Hakim Murad. His sheer erudition is admirable especially for layman like me.
I initially planned other things for my Saturday evening but couldn't help myself seeing the guest and the topic. I don't regret it! What a blessed brain Dr. Ataie. This was also a good complement to brother Paul's (aka BT) video on Jenkins' book. Great content! Cheers from Belgium
I'm very grateful to have been audience to this talk. Almost all of this was new to me. I can only pray more people hear this, too and start to understand the nuance.
This is the first interview and time hearing these men speak...absolutely astounding interview have subbed and will be watching much more....thank you both..x
@@michaelmalzahn-tx2zibro you keep spamming in the comments. Ngl it's annoying. Get a life or a job since you seem to have nothing to do right now. The video is out since an hour or so and you already are spamming the same question under many comments.
@@mohammedaleissa8666 go in through jordon, lebenon, syria. hell they managed to make it to syria in the middle of a civil war. 15 year old girls form the UK managed to make it to raqqa. certainly they can get to israel, the west bank. it doesn't have to be gaza. the army of god already has an army and they are cowering in front of the jews. did you see that guys speech?
This video had been lingering in my recommendations for quite a while, and only yesterday did I decide to watch it. This was probably the most enlightening discussion I have listened to regarding the current situation. Thank you.
Islam is the closest of the Abrahamic religions to truth- the most evolved - the Muslims -faithful ones -especially those under oppression-are the best of Allahs people - I trust Islam more than “Christians” and definitely “Jews” but alas I am a Christ -Ian - evolution happens and this new chapter is terribly uncertain and rough - but blessings to my Muslim brothers and sisters - you fill my heart with joy - free Palestine 🇵🇸
Ma sha Allāh. Dr Ataie always uplifts, opens up a whole new perspective on a given topic/issue. Thank you Paul for hosting Dr Ali Ataie, and providing the best platform. May Allāh continue to preserve & bless you both with increase in all that is good.
I feel so blessed that Paul exists on youtube. Every single of his videos is filled with precise kknowledge and wisdom. SubhaanAllah. Stay blessed, Salutations and salam to you and the remarkable Dr Sahib.
Dr Ataie is so fascinating to listen to. He has made me interested in Jewish theology like I didn’t expect. Also made me realize I know quite a bit more about Christianity. Not much discussion or debate about Judaism.
Thank you for that historical perspective of Judaism. Dr. Ali Ataie is a human specimen of Intellectual Genius. He has connected all the Divine Messages: to the Last Message: delivered as a Redemption through Muhammad PBUH: as a Universal Message Jazakh Allah Khair.
@Paul/@Blogging Theology, Please do a session regarding Ezekiel 38, with an islamic scholar. It has become a source of issue around the world. Pls put a light on it.
Given the censorship regime of Google, do you have an alternate site? It would be a terrible blow to lose this video. I don’t see a website in the show notes. You need to preserve your message. We’re in a hybrid war. Information is a key component.
I was expecting Pr Ataie to speak as soon as I heard Bibi the butcher mention the Amalek, I didn't expect it to be on BT tho but man I so here for it! Thank you sirs may Allah reward you for this great content.
Dr. Ali possesses such a wealth of knowledge...I do so appreciate and enjoy every time you have him on. Jazak Allah khair for your wonderful and insightful videos
The coast and hinterland in antiquity was known as Canaan the land where Jesus was born. Attested by Egyptian and Assyrian records but no mention of Palestine. The people called the Country Eretz Israel, the land of Israel, using the names Israel and Judah to designate the two Kingdoms split after the death of King Solomon (Suleiman)…The Judge must be very wise and sober not to give what belongs to one to the other or vice-versa. Israel was gracious enough to offer this land to the “Palestines” as an independent state but they refused. They want everything.
It is interesting to note that Palestine is neither mentioned in the Quran, nor the Bible, or the Talmud, or the the Assyrian Prism of Records, or the Chinese Jih-li Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Emperor of Zhongguo [China], nor the Kebra Nagast Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Negusa Nagast (Emperor) of Abbysinia (Ethiopia), or any of the ancient world records. So when did it start existing? So many others are mentioned including Edom which was destroyed, Jordan, Moab (Petra), Syria, Seba (Sheba), Egypt, Persia land of the Medes, Lebanon, but no mention of Palestine. So when did it start existing?
@@ring-tone278 There's a wikipedia page dedicated to this question. Search for it and decide AFTER you read it completely. It never hurts to change your mind.
The coast and hinterland in antiquity was known as Canaan the land where Jesus was born. Attested by Egyptian and Assyrian records but no mention of Palestine. The people called the Country Eretz Israel, the land of Israel, using the names Israel and Judah to designate the two Kingdoms split after the death of King Solomon (Suleiman)…The Judge must be very wise and sober not to give what belongs to one to the other or vice-versa. Israel was gracious enough to offer this land to the “Palestines” as an independent state but they refused. They want everything.
It is interesting to note that Palestine is neither mentioned in the Quran, nor the Bible, or the Talmud, or the the Assyrian Prism of Records, or the Chinese Jih-li Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Emperor of Zhongguo [China], nor the Kebra Nagast Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Negusa Nagast (Emperor) of Abbysinia (Ethiopia), or any of the ancient world records. So when did it start existing? So many others are mentioned including Edom which was destroyed, Jordan, Moab (Petra), Syria, Seba (Sheba), Egypt, Persia land of the Medes, Lebanon, but no mention of Palestine. So when did it start existing?
@@ring-tone278when Muslims realized that nationalism was the basis of the modern nation-state and that only by pretending to be a nation would their demonization of Israel gain traction. Prior to that Muslims only legitimized the theocratic empire (i.e. caliphate) under which they lived.
The coast and hinterland in antiquity was known as Canaan the land where Jesus was born. Attested by Egyptian and Assyrian records but no mention of Palestine. The people called the Country Eretz Israel, the land of Israel, using the names Israel and Judah to designate the two Kingdoms split after the death of King Solomon (Suleiman)…The Judge must be very wise and sober not to give what belongs to one to the other or vice-versa. Israel was gracious enough to offer this land to the “Palestines” as an independent state but they refused. They want everything.
It is interesting to note that Palestine is neither mentioned in the Quran, nor the Bible, or the Talmud, or the the Assyrian Prism of Records, or the Chinese Jih-li Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Emperor of Zhongguo [China], nor the Kebra Nagast Records of the Royal Imperial Court of the Negusa Nagast (Emperor) of Abbysinia (Ethiopia), or any of the ancient world records. So when did it start existing? So many others are mentioned including Edom which was destroyed, Jordan, Moab (Petra), Syria, Seba (Sheba), Egypt, Persia land of the Medes, Lebanon, but no mention of Palestine. So when did it start existing?
The Jewish people hold the belief that they have a special relationship with a powerful supernatural entity. They see themselves as the chosen people, and according to their religious tradition, this entity promised them the land. It had commanded them to exterminate the Canaanites (Joshua 6), the Amalekites (1 Samuel 15), and the Midianites (Book of Numbers 31). Their holy book recorded that failure to fully execute these commands resulted in divine punishment. Is this entity God or the Devil (Revelation 2:8-9)? People with homicidal thoughts are locked up in institutions, while people with genocidal thoughts are promoted to lead nations. What would you call people who consistently, unquestionably, and proudly followed their God's command to perform genocides? Saying 'God made me do it' does not release you from karmic debt. The Jewish people's future and identity can only be determined by their own choices and decisions, as external forces cannot enforce change upon them.
Thanks for a comprehensive review of Jewish history by Dr. Ataie and by Paul for organizing it. I think learned scholars especially in comparative religions like Dr. A. Ataie and scholars from other religious denominations should have an international interfaith dialogue to clear the massive confusion and expose the true reality in these odd times for general common man. It would certainly avoid any religious wars.
Israel should be grateful to Palestiniaams in the first place, because they've welcomed them to their place to live in when they don't have place to live. The. Palestinians allowed them in their land Why do we fight each other? Why is there war? Why can't we understand each other? I think Christ so as resolve all these misunderstandings
1 hour 3 mins in and i don't know what's more interesting, Dr A's exegesis of jewish messianism, or watching Paul trying to stay awake (must be past his bed time)
Isreal Shahak notes the use of mistranslation to hide the real meaning in English of Hebrew words ect. Mostly famously one of the most used books in Theology - Strong's Hebrew - English dictionary is condemned for redaction. Never use it. What does the word Jew actually mean? 😂 Can't repeat it without getting redacted 😂
And as for Ishmael, I have heard you: I will surely bless him; I will make him fruitful and will greatly increase his numbers. He will be the father of twelve rulers, and I will make him into a great nation. (Bible, Genesis 17:20) * Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) is a descendant of Abraham (and Ishmael); therefore, this not only makes him part of the prophetic lineage, but the final prophet in the Abrahamic lineage to guide humanity to the Straight Path * Jesus said: “Therefore I tell you that the Kingdom of God will be taken away from you and given to a people who will produce its fruit.” (Bible, Matthew 21:43)
Oh my goodness, Ismael is also the seed of Abraham along w other Nations! I am a Puerto Rican born, via an Ashkanazi Polish father and Ladino/African/Taino Indian mix (Shephardic) Mother. I love all tribes although, I may not be accepted the same way, with Love. To feel the suffering of Palestinians, is beyond expression. At times, I feel like a Nephellim!
Great talk , Jazakoum Allah Khayran Brother Paul for inviting the esteemed Dr Ali Ataie , May Allah SWT bless you both for spreading the knowledge , & give our brothers and sisters in Palestine patience & strenght & grant their deceased Janat Al Firdaws InchaAllah ..Ameen
Hebrew Israelis left black and returned white. These in Israel were never slaves in Egypt nor ever slaves period . They were never scattered to the for corners of the earth.
God bless you both for this extraordinary blog. It is very rich in information, emotional and touches the heart. It described the situation right now very precisely and relates what is going now in Palestine with the Jewish belief and the old testament.
@@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi it belongs to who was indigenous people and there is a lot of evidence that suggest that the Arabs (Palestinians) where the indigenous people
@@michaelmalzahn-tx2zi The mosque is not on top of the 2nd temple. That is your z!0nist myth that you are trying to propagate. You are already aware that they don't really know where the 2nd temple was. They are merely guessing. Your propaganda and nonsense won't work here, kiddo.
«Disbelievers will not spare you any ruin. Their only desire is to see you suffer. Hatred has already appeared from their mouths and what their hearts hide is far worse.» (Quran 3:118)
elijah, sup? those connet the dots guys are hilarious. anyway, why do you think hezboallah is largely sitting this out? and why are no muslims flocking to fight for the palestinians like they did for the Islamic State?
Such violent teaching and behaviors. I heard that they consider all of the Western countries Amalek. The US Germany especially. Now It all makes sense. God bless you both.
Br Paul, amazing discussion, there are too many ads, literally every 7 min or so I am getting an ad...it's a big distraction. Any way to reduce the ad would be much appreciated
Netanyahu's anger means that the nuking of Gaza is an idea that was floated in one of the cabinet meetings. And, that minister commits the crime to let the word out! That's a lesson learned from the master, US!
