Ranking Every 'ARE YOU AFRAID OF THE DARK?' Season Five Episode! 

Night Shift is my favorite of Season 5 too! Dead Man's Float is probably my second favorite! Great video! #AYAOTD

5. Station 109.1 4. Tale of the chameleons 3. Tale of the vacant lot 2. Tale of the mystical mirror 1. Tale of dead man's float

My Season 5 rankings: 13. The Tale of Prisoners Past 12. The Tale of A Door Unlocked 11. The Tale of Badge 10. The Tale of Station 109.1 9. The Tale of the Chameleons 8. The Tale of C7 7. The Tale of the Mystical Mirror 6. The Tale of the Unexpected Visitor 5. The Tale of the Vacant Lot 4. The Tale of the Manaha 3. The Tale of the Jagged Sign 2. The Tale of the Night Shift 1. The Tale of the Dead Man's Float

My episode ranking: Jagged Sign Mystical Mirror Manaha C7 Prisoner's Past Unexpected Visitor Door Unlocked Badge Vacant Lot Chameleons Station 109.1 Dead Man’s Float Night Shift Story teller ranking: Stig: Station 109.1 Dead Man’s Float Betty Ann: Mystical Mirror Chameleons Tucker: Manaha Prisoner’s Past Sam: C7 Night Shift Kiki: Jagged Sign Unexpected Visitor Vacant Lot Gary; Door Unlocked Badge WORST: Tucker (Back to the bottom again, wah wah) BEST: Stig (Ew), best returning player is Sam due to Night Shift