Ranking THE WORST Superhero Movies Of All Time! 

What do you think is the WORST comic book movie?! - Follow Coy Jandreau On Tik Tok: www.tiktok.com/@coyjandreau?lang=en - Leave A *LIKE* & *SUBSCRIBE*

I was with my friends years ago during the Affleck controversy when they canceled his script and his role as batman was up in the air, and we tried fancasting an older Batman. We through around names like John Ham or Josh Brolin. I made the mistake of saying "You know, George Clooney would make an awesome older Batman" and it took a moment for me to realize what I had just said

I was a bit surprised when Coy talked about the basketball scene in Catwoman that he didn't point out it is Benjamin Bratt in the scene & then he also plays basketball in Doctor Strange.

Yes Coy, you were brave to say it! I'm rooting for ya! Also, it makes me sad that we could have gotten a Michelle Pfeiffer led Catwoman movie...

The worst is for me is probably Catwoman or Fant4stic hard to choose which is worse

Some of these movies are my childhood and it’s true nostalgia blinds my views on them, that’s why I’m scared to see them again because I know I’ll see how bad it really is 😂

I approve of this list. Mostly because you DID NOT include Roger Corman's Fantastic 4 in it. That movie is actually highly entertaining and seems to have been made with a great love for the source material, they just also happen to have been making it for less than a million bucks.

BvS is one of my favorite superhero movies ever, 5/5 film for me. But it's okay if it's not for other people. Still though, I laughed my ass off at 9:51, go on Greg lol

I was wondering Coy, if you could recommend to Greg and John if they would like to react to the DCAU which is the DC universe comprised of Batman the Animated Series, Superman the Animated Series, Batman Beyond and Justice League and is considered by comic book fans one of the greatest interpretation of the DC characters?

Well put re: Wolverine - the whole Weapon X thing isn't really an 'origin' of Logan as the person, just the claws. His trauma and relationships predate the metal.

Dark Phoenix is absolutely worse imo. Not only does it waste Oscar Issac's co-star in "Scenes from a Marriage", and future oscar winner, Jessica Chastain, as a villian, which you probably forgot what her name was (it's 'Vuk' btw, which is....something), but it's another shot at the Phoenix saga, WITH THE SAME WRITER. Wasting it once again, meaning Marvel won't touch for at least 15 years now. Can anyone tell me why she wanted it anyway? Jennifer Lawrence has completely given up, and is phoning in every scene, even more so than the previous outing, along with Nicholas Hoult. Sophie Turner is at her worst, Evan Peter's Quicksilver is an afterthought and written out of the movie, etc. It's not even trying to be serviceable, no one put any effort in. The best line is, " There's always a speech, but nobody cares anymore", which sums up the entire feeling of the film, from crew to audience.

Loving Coy's comic corner, great list of the not so great. Completely agree on your BvS & MoS take.

I like BvS, but I also like Coy, and I feel like you did a good job of explaining why you didn't like it. Really liked this video, love seeing Coy do more videos.

Most of these I saw in the theater with friends (except for Fantastic Four, Elektra and Spiderman 3 - I've never seen those) and I just remember having a good time. I don't think we really cared too much if they were good or bad. Worth a watch, then out for drinks afterward. Watching this, I realize that they weren't the best, but they were ok for the time they came out. Thanks Coy!

This is a very nice and understanding comment section. Gotta love the reject nation, that or Coy's videos just attract the understanding fans haha. Even people disagreeing with the choices are being understanding.

Coy is so enjoyable. He's the walking, talking, all informative encyclopedia of super hero comics for someone who is too lazy to go read them all. Great video. Also Batman and Robin was so unforgettable when I watched it theaters and I was probably 10 at the time. What a waste of a cast. Green Lantern is also one of those things I really want to see work as well because the idea behind it, haven't read the comics, seems so cool. Hopefully they do something cool with it going forward.

Great video Coy, you guys are doing great and appreciate the insight you provide in each video!

Coy as someone who really enjoys BvS, i agree with every word you said.

Spiderman 3 should be replaced with tasm 2 now I don't know y people calling it grate movie for me that was garbage and i recently re-watched it and still it's garbage atleast spiderman 3 had few good things about it

Thank you for acknowledging bane's intellect. He's my favorite in batman's rogues gallery. No one ever talks about his intelligence and it sucks. They think he's just a brute.

Hands-down, even WORSE (somehow) than X-Men Origins: Wolverine -- was Superman IV: The Quest for Peace. There are NO WORDS for how bad this film was. There was nothing fun, or interesting, or redeeming about this movie. It was flaming garbage from beginning to end. And just having to remember it has somehow HURT my very soul.

It would be awesome if you just talk about what comics you are reading recently and some recommendation at the end of every coy's comic corner video because I and most of people first got interested in this series because your insight and recommendation of great comicbooks.

Love Coy's breakdown of comic book movies. He is so knowledgeable and makes such good points.

Everytime I see Green Lantern I always see the potential it could have gotten. But because it’s Ryan, Taika, and Blake I let it slide 😄 Great video as always Coy ❤️ 🤜🏼

Solid list! And yes I agree, I’ve always been a defender of that early era of comic book movies bc IT WAS seeing these amazing characters and comics we’ve read as kids coming to life, but some of these flicks are just indefensible lol

Ayee Coyd Comic Corner, its good to see you man. Wondering if you managed to catch that "Bar Fight" Easter Egg on first watch?

Mark 10:50. I don't want to risk the technical problems that I had sharing the previous list! But I needed to point out that he said, "neuter" instead of "spay" in reference to "Batgirl"! Traditionally, people say "spay" in reference to females. However, I read an article somewhere about how technically "neuter" should be used for both genders. So, does he not know the word "spay" or does he know that it should be "neuter"? 🤔

My first impression of Elektra was that the writers stole the plotline of Elektra facing off against the gauntlet of supervillain ninjas from the 1993 anime film "Ninja Scroll". Coy, if you haven't seen that movie, you should check it out. It's a classic.

The only thing I remember about X-Men Origins was Taylor Kitsch as Gambit and I will always be sad that we never got a Gambit movie.

I don't care about what was said in this video or what anyone else says, BVS does not belong anywhere near this "list".

X men Origins wolverine is just one of those “turn your brain in order to ignore the headache storyline but is nonsensical fun” kinda movies.

I agree with everything u said about BvS Except the lex Luther thing. Because Jessie Eisenberg was not play Lex.... he played Alexander Luther. His son, which is stated in the movie when jessie Eisenberg mentions his father twice in the movie

I completely agree with your take on BvS. It's those same reasons that I completely dislike MoS. The complete mischaracterization of Superman. He usually doesn't kill.

Unpopular opinion: I found Simon Kingerg's direction in DARK PHOENIX pretty solid He was able to give the movie an identity of its own, rather than trying to replicate Bryan Singer's direction Unlike Brett Ratner tried to do in THE LAST STAND

Andrew Garfield is my Spider-Man. I liked the TM trilogy, but when AG started quipping in TASM I was hooked. He gave me the weirdo kid I always thought SM is. His suit is also the main one I use in the 2018 Spider-Man game.

I absolutely LOVE Batman and Robin for the absurd chaos that is happening. Its so bad its good 😂😂😂😂

bro your comments about synder/and the angry fans ( cuz of course there are plenty of level headed ones) 10000% accurately describes how i feel

I agree with 9 of the 11. I love BVS, and I like X men Apocalypse. Green Lantern wasn't bad, but I won't die on a hill for it. Lol

9:20 this is how I feel when people get mad at me for liking Thor Love and Thunder

Lmaoo Greg with the sneak diss “jerry o Connell” 😂😂😂

Bvs is hella underrated and I will stick with that till I die, sue me

Honestly, thinking about it, we could have kept the symbiote suit in Spiderman 3, just make it less... cringe, and towards the end have him take it off before the final face-off after screwing with Eddie and everything, realizing what it was doing to him. Then make a venom focused Spider-man 4 where Eddie ends up with the symbiote.

I feel like Spiderman 3 and BvS (especially the UE) shouldn't be on this list. While they may have flaws that bring down the movie for some people, they are not near the worst CBMs. Like in BvS I love the political tensions that build between Lex, the senator, and the media; superman trying to cope with the guilt he felt for not being able to save everyone, yet still sacrificing himself for a world that hates him; and the beautiful redemption arc for Batman. I feel like "Most Disappointing CBMS" would be a more appropriate title for some on this list. At the end of the day, I respect your opinion and thanks for being so respectful about your takes.

3.7K Thumbs Up + Mine! 👍 You're welcome! Thanks! ☺️ Notes: I was expecting your choice of "Fantastic Four" to be the one made by Roger Corman. (I have yet to see it.) Hmm. I think that I see your points! But for me, the sex appeal of the females is my higher priority, so I'm more forgiving about the stuff that you mentioned. 😁 Although I find "Jonah Hex" as a character concept to be quite annoying! If they want us to forgive his sins as a CSA soldier, take him out of that damn uniform! I remember when he was more like "Mad Max".

I love how Greg yells out "good luck coy" in regards to BVS

My main gripe with X-men Apocalypse (aside from the director) is the Scott/Alex thing where Scott talks about Alex like they grew up together but Alex was preventing WW3 before Scott was born, he was in Nam when Scott was in nappies. That said I really love the final confrontation, it's the X-Men movies at their most comic-book-y and all the better for it, I'd say give it another chance Coy.

The opening sequence of X-men Origins Wolverine was a better movie than the movie itself lol

Well the plus side of Bloodshot bombing is we could maybe see Sam Heughan as Sabretooth🤷‍♂️ he's been my fancast ever since I saw him in Outlander

lmao love the set up for green lantern and totally agree with you on spider-man 3. that’s a good way to simply put it i do picture andrew when i picture peter and spider-man. even after the tobey movies i didn’t really view spider-man with a face under the mask i just didn’t connect as much to tobey as i did later to andrew. loving the video so far🔥

Damn I forgot all about Bloodshot! Also saying Morbius (or Venom) *tried* to be 90s is giving them FAR too much credit imo. They're just that inept that they feel like they're a from a bygone era of lesser quality. Also also yeah BvS is trash.

great vid as usual coy, plus ive finally become a patron woo

I like the BvS arguement. There's no denying its a boring movie with some dope scenes and cool looking visuals. Calling it a masterpiece is cringeworthy. Xmen Apocalypse was an insult. Specially to Oscar Isaac. F4 2015 just makes me wanna puke everytime I see a clip or a still or that movie.

Thanks for your continuing efforts to bring sanity to these fandoms 😎✌🏼😄

I like when Greg says to get out and Coy starts to move...the look on his face paired with, "I said it!"

I agree with you so much. Fantastic 4 has a strong first half and then that second half just kills the entire movie. I like Bloodshot, but it’s extremely basic. Eiza Gonzalez’s KT is the best part to me. BvS… Man, I’m so happy you said what you said, especially about the ultimate edition. That movie may have single-handedly ruined us getting Henry Cavill’s return as Superman. There are so many technical things I could talk about with that movie. Wonder Woman is the best part of it.

I'm glad I ain't the only one who thinks BvS a trash movie.

Can we get more videos of movies that disappointed you, Coy? It's really refreshing actually. Digging it.

And I personally do like BvS a lot but I completely agree. This movie was wayyyy too soon. And they easily could’ve given us a Ben Affleck’s Batman film instead.

you wanna talk about range Toby Kebbell in rocknrolla. not to mention the entire cast, Mark strong, Gerard Butler, Idris Elba, Tom Hardy Thandie Newton. it's so sad that we'll never get a sequel

My ratings for the movies on this list: Elektra - 1.5/5 Bloodshot - 1.5/5 Spider-Man 3 - 4.5/5 Green Lantern - 2/5 Batman v Superman: Ultimate Edition - 5/5 Batman and Robin - 2.5/5 (for the entertainment) Jonah Hex - 1/5 Catwoman - 1/5 Fant4stic - 1/5 X-Men: Apocalypse - 2/5 X-Men Origins: Wolverine - 1.5/5

I know Coy usually does superhero comics stuff but we NEED his Comics Corner Special Edition on the Netflix Sandman adaptation (Waiting for Reel Rejects to react to it too)

love the list. Coy once again...Thank you!!

If you're a type of person who would prefer liking a potentially good movie instead of not liking it, then you SHOULD watch Twin Perfect's 3 videos on BvS.

I feel like the worst part of Origins: Wolverine is just not understanding the characters at all. Gambit's jumping off of rooftops and making cards float, Deadpool gets all the powers, I mean...why? Why do this? And Apocalypse...yeah. He was always such a terrifying villain when he turned up in the Animated Series. I was so hyped to see him in a movie and then that happened. Such a letdown. Still rank it higher than Dark Phoenix, though, as I couldn't even finish that one out of boredom.

Very interesting vid, thx! 🔝🔥👍🏻😀

The Amazing Spider-Man 2 should've been on the list over Spider-Man 3 because Spider-Man 3 has more elements that work. I want The Raimi And Webb Cuts Of Spider Man-3 And The Amazing Spider Man Films.

The Amazing Spider-man 2 is Arguably worst then spiderman 3

Arnold’s Mr Freeze just loves some good PUNishment…..

You forgot to mention Blade: Trinity, The Hellboy reboot movie, The Spirit, Bulletproof Monk, Michael Bay's Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, Judge Dredd with Stalone, The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, Steel, Son of The Mask and Superman 4: The Quest for Peace.

In BVS Bruce’s story begins as a boy who falls into a pit, believing the lie that the bats allowed him to ascend back into the light, when in reality, they plunged him further into the darkness. In ZS Justice League, Bruce’s story ends with Batman dangling over a pit by one hand, holding his grappling gun in the other, While Superman holds out his hand to help him up. There’s a long moment where Batman is just hanging there, And It isn’t until Bruce drops the gun into that pit, that he’s able to take Clark’s hand, and finally be pulled into the light. In between those points, we’re seeing a Bruce Wayne, older than we’ve ever met him before, watching as the threats become stronger and faster as he becomes slower and weaker. He’s spent the years where he was supposed to be retired, fighting harder, because his apprentice, Robin, was killed before he could take his place. And now there’s invincible aliens coming down and destroying cities. Bruce believes the only way to stay on top, is to remove these threats entirely, even if Alfred, and the public views him as a monster, who’s far from the hero they once knew. It takes being at Superman’s throat, about to kill him, and seeing a god, reduced to a boy begging for his mother’s life, that makes Batman realize he himself is no longer that boy, but instead the man holding the gun, about to destroy a family. Bruce realizes what he’s done, and that he owes it to the world to make sure no one falls into the same darkness he did. ’

I think X-men origins of Wolverine and Batman Vs Superman the theatrical cut are the worst superhero movies of all time

I'd like to see a Worlds Finest movie with Robert Pattinson and Brandon Routh. I said it.

9:18 well I think it kinda goes both ways. There will be toxic Snyder fans who insult people based on there opinions and crap on the mcu and stuff like that. But then there are mcu fans who will insult people based on there opinions and blindly crap on Snyder’s trilogy. So from my point of view (being a Snyder fanboy), I have disliked the mcu alot more over the years because of the mcu fans. Just like you might dislike bvs more because of the fans.

I personally enjoy X-Men Origins: Wolverine and Spider-Man 3 WAY more than the other movies on this list. I never saw Bloodshot, though. I completely forgot about that movie.

Coy do a Top 10 underrated superhero movies

Spider-Man 3? Are you serious man? It was the perfect conclusion to the trilogy.

........... It's even worse when Coy says he isn't mad he is disappointed haha.

Simon Kinberg might not be a good writer But you can bet he is a great producer It was because of him that we got FIRST CLASS, DEADPOOL and LOGAN And THE MARTIAN too

I liked X-men Apocalypse quite a bit, but just seeing James McAvoy and Michael Fassbender playing Professor X and Magneto is making me liking the movie immediately. Especially the death scene of Magneto's wife really made it move it to the positive side. I have the same with X-men Origins Wolverine. That movie almost worked for me just because of the pure charismatic power of Hugh Jackmann as Wolverine. It didn't even matter in what kind of movie he was in. Hugh as Wolverine just makes a movie almost good automatically.

I agree with you on all of those movies But!!!! Spiderman 3 X men oreigns wolverine Batman vs Superman Dawn of Justice Was a great movies man The most underrated movies I ever seen

Coy woke up and chose war today lol.

While I enjoyed Elektra, I agree that it could have been better. The biggest mistake with Spider-man 3 was retconning the murder of Uncle Ben and having Sandman be the one who was actually responsible while the guy that shot him just be a lacky. Sony should have capitalized on their set up for Lizard but they didn't. GL wasn't that bad, it was just a bad story and the stupid choice to combine two villains into one which made no sense. BvS wasn't bad at all. Batman didn't murder people, he caused chain reactions that may or may not have resulted in fatalities. Batman has always carried a grappel gun and the "gun" he had in BvS was just a bigger version of that. I never got why the "Martha" thing was such an issue. Jerry O' Connell was never Robin, it was CHRIS O' DONNEL. Why did the bat nips bother people so much? Yes, there were a lot of bad choices made with B&R but it's still a pretty decent movie overall that could have been much better. It also was going to set up a Nightwing origin or movie if it hadn't failed. Catwoman was god awful and it had nothing to do with Batman whatsoever. Fantastic Four(2015) wasn't that bad either, minus the design of Dr Doom. X-men Apocalypse was pretty good I thought? Oscar looked badass and the story was pretty good. What was so bad about X-men Origins? It was fantastic and we don't know that Reynolds' character was ACTUALLY the same Wade Wilson that was supposed to become Deadpool. He was Weapon 11 as Stryker called him.

Greg's note 😂😂😂 10:29

I am flabbergasted you think Elektra is better than BvS. That’s insane to me. Also wheres Morbius, really thought that would be on here.

Good list, but they're all recent movies... There are many many stinkers in the past worse than just about anything on this list. For example, Captain America (1990) - Latex ears on the mask? Italian Red Skull? Plus there have been plenty of terrible made-for-TV stinkers that make Catwoman look like Citizen Kane - the Justice League pilot movie with the "Friends" dynamic for example, or the Dr. Strange TV movie where Dr. Strange rocks a wafro....

Great stuff. Keep it up Coy!

Disagree about Batman & Robin. I think it is a wonderful sequel to the Adam West Batman series. And everyone points to Uma Thurman knowing what movie she is in, but not Arnold for some reason. He is doing exactly what he should be, ice puns and all.

I honestly have a love and nostalgia for all of these movies bad or not. Grew up watching most of these older films, and we are incredibly blessed to have so much in the medium to consume. Without Modern Marvel I'd probably still be watching Daredevil or Fantastic Four. I remember how jarring it was when I saw the trailer for the Avengers. Now that marvel has made that the standard, these older films age worse and worse. Some more I think are up there. Justice League Daredevil X-men Punisher Suicide Squad Ghost Rider Superman Returns Hulk 2003 Fantastic 4 Silver surfer X-men the last stand

1984 Supergirl is THEE worst comic book movie of all-time. Those X-Men movies are Oscar level movies compared to it

Wait wait wait... Oscar Isaac was Apocalypse?! I didn't even realize that. At least he got a Marvel/Egyptian redo with Moon Knight lol

Remember the final trailer of BVS promoted the Batman warehouse scene and then it’s at the end of the movie! Like wow, you think it’s earlier and it’s not with not that many Batman action scenes honestly.

I’ll continue to defend Spider-Man 3 till rest of eternity

Firstly, if Greg and John commit to watching Elektra on the channel, I will not only be there to watch the video (since few others will, lol), but during the next live chat I’m at, I will scavenge through my pocket lint to contribute… something. Am I above bribery? Apparently, I am not. :p Ahem… anywhos, Coy, I really appreciate your characterization of these films as disappointing. On the surface, it sounds like you’re being nice. But I see it more as a clever way to try and apply a more objective measure. Otherwise how can you compare something like Endgame, with the budget and technological advances it benefits from vs. Corman’s FF? Frankly, I think if it weren’t Corman, that film could have been exponentially worse. So, since you asked, I thought I’d share why I don’t think Elektra is as disappointing as you, or others. One thing I appreciated immensely is its take on OCD: it wasn’t played for laughs, or imbued her with supernatural ability (Monk did both, for example), nor was it a sign of her being villainous. It was a natural outgrowth of her previous life seeming so out of control, she lost it… brutally. Not only that, but it showed both how the disorder benefitted her (covering her tracks, discovering Abby’s presence), but also the slow toll it was taking on her. A realistic portrayal of OCD is not something I expect in a superhero film, and while others were put-off by it, I enjoyed it. Before I get to the other reason I liked it so much, I want to say I probably agree with a lot of the critiques. Just sitting through one of the trailers, to refresh my memory, was cringe-inducing. The effects at times are janky, some of the choices, while understandable, didn’t land for me, and the action, in general, is so neutered I joked it was the best period piece I saw. I was being facetious, of course, but while I knew they would shy away from an R, its action almost felt, dare I say, disneyesque, at times. But having spied some actual scenes on youtube, I can still say it reminds me of period cinema- but the comparison now is a compliment. For me, the film shines in the quieter moments. The film is at its best when Jennifer is engaging with Goran, Stamp, and Cunningham. For instance, I can feel the slow creeping pathos of McCabe, knowing he’s going to die because of her choice, even as he tries to play it off, and joke about it, with the gun to his chin. Or, when Millar joked that Elektra’s parents had a sense of humour naming her, and she says no. I remembered it as her being straight-faced. She wasn’t: she initially smiles, and it quickly fades before she leaves the room- as if even the most glancing aspects of cordiality are now unbearable to her (in a way they weren’t in DD). I like that better. I also like the moments where she says nothing at all. I could, say, feel her sadness and rebelling indifference when she stared through the window at Millar and Abby hugging, before Abby climbed into bed. I mean, is it the best superhero movie? Absolutely not. But the irony, to me, is that while it seemed to close the door on a female-led movie, it’s frankly, one of the best. What’s better?* For all the whining about the m-she-u, the only depiction they seem to do effectively is “the girlfriend”: brain gf (Betty, Jane); boss gf (Pepper, Peggy); fighter/colleague gf (Gamora, Nakia, Hope); would-be gf (Natasha, Christine); um, girlfriend girlfriend (MJ)? You get the point. Wanda was an interesting exception… sort of, who was wonderfully fleshed out in Wandavision, and subsequently stripped of said portrayal in MOM. And yes, there’s Cap. Marvel, but considering they share some of the same (or similar) ideas, I think Elektra is the better watch, despite the superior production value of the MCU. Elektra, in combination with DD, is a grounded, subtle depiction of what happens when pain, loss, and death becomes so prevalent that it splits you off from your very soul. And how do you reconcile living without one? Is it even living? And I so, and I mean SO appreciate a female protagonist who is cold- without the sarcasm, and without noticeable aggression. Also, she is not a supporting character, but gets to live within her own story. Widow was overshadowed, albeit in different ways, by her pseudo sister and father. I dunno, I really liked it- and the themes they tried to explore were engaging enough for me to overlook the questionable effects and plot points… so much so that if Jennifer showed up to do a cameo in secret wars, I’d love it… and I’m probably the only one, lol. But, as always, thank you for an engaging and interesting take. :) * The only film I would objectively say is better is WW. However, she is a better done depiction of an archetype that is almost standard in the action genre. Elektra is an archetype rarely done, regardless of genre; it’s probably why it stands out to me. And for whatever reason, Elektra- in places- reminds me less of other heroes, and more of the young vampire from “Let The Right One In”.

Spiderman 3 is my guilty pleasure movie 😂😂, iconic moments in it

My number one is X-Men Origins: Wolverine (much like you). X-Men: Apocalypse isn’t as bad to me as you said….and that could be because I’m not overly familiar with the comic book character. But I do really enjoy it better than most despite understanding other people’s disappointments and understanding my lack of knowledge. I still think it’s an investing and fun film despite some waists and not enough build up to the title villain. BvS: I’ve grown to appreciate this over time….however what you said is true. There are a lot of problems that I can’t get past and I wish this was a different film.

Yeah Batman v Superman sucked. You summed it up so well.

This is the beginning of the "Morbus was as Masterpiece Actually" subplot that we will all be forced to live through in the coming decade

Has everyone forgotten about "Steel" with Shaq as a scientist and armor wearing hero years before Tony Stark?

Coy, great list. You know your shit. Like your reasons and what you have to say. Keep it coming sir.

I totally agree about BVS. 100%. I also remember how hard it was to sit through that Fantastic 4. It was completely two different movies stitched together but to be honest I hated both of them.