Тёмный

Richard Dawkins and Matt Dillahunty In Conversation 

Pangburn
Подписаться 179 тыс.
Просмотров 682 тыс.
50% 1

One of the most respected scientists in the world and the biggest draw in secularism, Richard Dawkins always generates impressive crowds when visiting North America. Secularism is sweeping America as a movement, and Richard Dawkins is the catalyst who galvanizes it.
From 1995 to 2008 Richard Dawkins was the Charles Simonyi Professor of the Public Understanding of Science at Oxford University. He is an internationally best-selling author. Among his books are The Ancestor’s Tale, The Selfish Gene, The Blind Watchmaker, Climbing Mount Improbable, Unweaving the Rainbow, A Devil’s Chaplain, The God Delusion, The Greatest Show on Earth and The Magic of Reality. His most recent books are his two-part autobiography. Part 1 An Appetite for Wonder, released in 2013 and A Brief Candle in the Dark released in 2015.
He is a Fellow of the Royal Society and of the Royal Society of Literature. His around-the-world speaking tour is the focus of a recent documentary “The Unbelievers” which also features appearances by Woody Allen, Stephen Colbert, Cameron Diaz, Ian McEwan, Ricky Gervais, Stephen Hawking, Eddie Izzard, Bill Pullman, and Sarah Silverman.
Richard will be in conversation with Matt Dillahunty.
Matt Dillahunty is the current host of the webcast and cable access television show "The Atheist Experience," and from 2006 to 2013 served as the president of the Atheist Community of Austin. He is also a founder of the comprehensive counter-apologetics Wiki "Iron Chariots."
Dillahunty is an outspoken atheist and fierce advocate of the concept of separation of church and state. Having been raised as a fundamentalist Baptist and having studied with the intent of going to seminary and becoming a minister before his bout of apostasy, Dillahunty is familiar with the Christian fundamentalist mindset, and very knowledgeable about both the history and the text of the Bible. While he is not formally educated in any scientific field, it's clear from watching his shows that he has amassed enough of a working knowledge of biology, cosmology, and geology to defend these fields from creationists, including Ray Comfort. Dillahunty does not claim to have any expertise in any of these fields and will frequently admit that his knowledge is limited, even as he soundly schools creationists who declare their own willful ignorance of science.
#pangburnlive

Опубликовано:

 

19 ноя 2016

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 3,6 тыс.   
@Pangburn
@Pangburn 11 месяцев назад
Watch Sam Harris & Brian Greene on stage FOR THE FIRST TIME EVER ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-5pbHsRz8A7w.html
@Evitable
@Evitable 7 лет назад
Topics discussed: @4:18 - The Extended Phenotype. @9:10 - How does/doesn't the Extended Phenotype apply to religion? @11:00 - Does Natural Selection still apply to Humans? @16:05 - The Richard Dawkins Foundation. @23:30 - Shit going down in Texas, still. @25:02 - ...and Brexit. @26:40 - On expertise. @30:00 - On trust and sourcing material. @33:42 - We fool ourselves, so easily. @37:37 - Debates! @40:45 - Matt's excellent counter to William Lane Craig's sophistry. @42:40 - Matt may have a potential point of disagreement with Richard. @46:13 - Audience Q&A @46:45 - On Maajid Nawaz and Ayaan Hirsi Ali being put on the Southern Poverty Law Center hate speech list. @53:02 - Memes, have "we" won? @55:10 - Poverty and atheism. @59:57 - Islamophobia @1:01:56 - Religious Artificial Intelligence (AI)? @1:05:09 - How do we counter illogical religious memes? @1:08:45 - Changing minds... @1:11:41 - ...and changing lives. 10 million illegal Arabic translations (pdf) of the God Delusion have been downloaded. 3 million in Saudi Arabia. That is a GOOD thing. @1:13:05 - Are religious people fucked because it's all "hardwired"? @1:19:12 - What is the best religious argument you've heard? @1:21:40 - On the religious ostracizing atheist friends... @1:28:12 - Universities and the future of free speech. Cheers!
@Gabriel-qe4ju
@Gabriel-qe4ju 7 лет назад
Thank you very much
@kirked007
@kirked007 7 лет назад
Thankyou so much. Really helpful.
@iiwi758
@iiwi758 7 лет назад
I appreciate it.
@sandokanfirst2
@sandokanfirst2 7 лет назад
Can I just add that this tête a tête took place at Sunday November 6, 2016 at 8PM in the Chan Shun Concert Hall. See chancentre.com/events/evening-richard-dawkins-matt-dillahunty/
@RaoulRamsaran
@RaoulRamsaran 7 лет назад
you saves lives man
@storyiseverything2219
@storyiseverything2219 7 лет назад
When we criticise Nazism nobody is accused of being naziophobic. Islam is no different. It's an ideology and we are free to criticise all ideologies.
@galion1991
@galion1991 7 лет назад
StoryIsEverything or racist against Germans, for that matter.
@Oners82
@Oners82 7 лет назад
Yeah but its when people take it further to hating Muslims when the problem arises (and yes, many people do make that bigoted leap). People have a problem with BIGOTRY, not criticising the ideology of Islam.
@Oners82
@Oners82 7 лет назад
***** Calling me an an "average liberal/PC person" is not a valid argument, it's ad hominem - average conservative/uneducated person who lacks the skills to argue absent fallacies ;) ;) But seriously, saying that bigotry is wrong does NOT make me liberal or PC, it makes YOU a presumptuous fool for making that assumption. What I said was a basic moral truism, and if you disagree with it then you ARE a bigot by definition. Political stance is completely irrelevant, you are just stereotyping and committing a fallacy. And as for Islam being an "evil religion", that is the only thing that you said that is correct. But once again to extend that to bigotry against Muslims per se is still wrong and anybody with any moral character whatsoever knows that, liberal or otherwise.
@atheistmeme4663
@atheistmeme4663 7 лет назад
StoryIsEverything Including Christianity which in the name of Jesus is the cause of the millions of murders. ( Somehow Christians forget this... their religion has as much if not more blood on their hands )
@TheQeltar
@TheQeltar 7 лет назад
It's a lot easier to disengage the brain and just lump all the various kinds of Islamic philosophies together.
@jenscoconuts
@jenscoconuts 5 лет назад
Never saw Matt so relaxed...must be very delightful to have a conversation with somebody who's intelligent... the freaks that he normally confronts😄😄😄😄
@sksk-pt8zz
@sksk-pt8zz 7 лет назад
Leaving religion behind IS our next stage of evolution
@viermidebutura
@viermidebutura 5 лет назад
It has been replaced with a general distrust in science
@caramel7050
@caramel7050 5 лет назад
@saganist It has been already in secular countries, no? I mean we don't have theocratic rules over here lol.
@yourlordandsaviouryeesusbe2998
@@viermidebutura yes. Flat Earthers are the best examples😥😥😥😥
@optimusprime5199
@optimusprime5199 5 лет назад
@@yourlordandsaviouryeesusbe2998 It will take time but we won't survive to see that day.
@Jadinandrews
@Jadinandrews 4 года назад
I think it's a deeper question than simply leaving behind religious ways of thinking. We evolved this ability to create agents in our minds precisely to survive. I mean, a rustle in the bushes could be the wind or a predator, we evolved to prefer the latter as it improves our chances of survival. When we became self aware it was only a malfunction of this circuitry that drove us to believe there were agents behind everything, including behind the wind, fire, animals and even other humans. We thought there was an agent acting on a body giving it life, a spirit and so on. To really evolve past this, we will have to become purely rational beings, and I don't think there really is an evolutionary benefit to this, so we would have to do it through engineering our own DNA. Even in the most secular nations in the world, there are still SOME people that find religion, so clearly we can not leave religion behind by simply trying very hard.
@Yorker1998
@Yorker1998 7 лет назад
It's amazing that Matt went from a single call on the AE over a decade ago to now being on the same stage as Dawkins.
@notatheist
@notatheist 6 лет назад
Two of the half-dozen people who broke me free of the delusion. I thank you, my real saviors.
@nicosteffen364
@nicosteffen364 4 года назад
There is more than breaking free, more important is to have the right tools! The moral rules are important, you dont need godto set them up, you nèd a logic thinking or a good education! I guess the education is much better in northern countries than in gemany or america!
@picitnew
@picitnew 4 года назад
@@candeffect *_"So, you are now living to ensure your trashed eternity with other nonbelievers including child molesters, rapists, sex slavery supporters, home invaders, carjackers, violent gang/cartel members, etc.?"_* The fact you find more religious people than non-belivers in prison doesn't really add up with your logic. But nice try though :)
@Sanddollar1
@Sanddollar1 4 года назад
@@picitnew Do you think those people went into prison after attending church regularly? Anyone can claim to be religious. The West has been built on Christianity... it would follow that most believe themselves to be Christians when they are really not.
@unifiedcodetheory8406
@unifiedcodetheory8406 4 года назад
@@candeffect "Child molesters" LOL. More priests have molested children than there are atheists. You believe in something that ensures you can't possibly be wrong which naturally raises your ego to stupid heights. If God existed he would be ashamed of you.
@picitnew
@picitnew 4 года назад
@@Sanddollar1 So you want to try the "not a real Christian" and "not as religious as me" approach? Are you really more religious if you attend a church? And I guess it also has to be the "correct" church? And is "the West" values really based on Christian values? Do you have slaves? Do you let your women teach men? Do you kill persons having sex with the same gender? Would you slaughter an entire city because a voice in your head said so? The West has of course inherented something from Christianity, like the school system, but that does NOT mean we are Christian countries. The best countries to live in according to almost all statistics are NOT where the people are the most religious. USA is one of the most religious countries in the "West" and about 3 % of the population is in prison or on probation.
@realjuancho
@realjuancho 7 лет назад
Richard Dawkins has affected my life in a way no other person has, I'm glad we still have him around, I hope that's the way it stays for such a long time. Much Love RD
@candeffect
@candeffect 4 года назад
Child molesters define God down to justify their lifestyles. Why do you define God down?
@nickben2321
@nickben2321 3 года назад
If you were influenced by Richard Dawkins then you might enjoy reading about Joseph Campbell and watch his program series before he died The Power of Myth. Changed my life.
@LanguageImaginations
@LanguageImaginations 4 года назад
I can listen to Richard for hours. I feel so lucky to live in the time when I can witness this amazing human being teaching us so much valuable knowledge.
@sunmustbedestroyed
@sunmustbedestroyed 7 лет назад
Two utter legends! Would love to see Dawkins as a guest on The Atheist Experience.
@armadyl1212
@armadyl1212 7 лет назад
Apparently Dawkins would like to, it's just that he's not in town lol.
@sunmustbedestroyed
@sunmustbedestroyed 7 лет назад
They should have him call in! Darryl Ray did it last week.
@cartmanrlsusall
@cartmanrlsusall 7 лет назад
Joseph I would rather see him talking with Aron ra.
@sunmustbedestroyed
@sunmustbedestroyed 7 лет назад
Aron Ra is a good friend of Matt's and has been on the show at least twice IIRC. Edit: sorry if you already know this and were saying you'd like more Aron Ra! I agree. More Aron Ra! But *also* Dawkins! :)
@armadyl1212
@armadyl1212 7 лет назад
***** Majic sorcery sounds pretty awesome, I hope they sign me up!
@aviramvijh
@aviramvijh 7 лет назад
Richard is ageing to quickly for my liking. Hard to imagine the day when he joins Hitchens.
@MultiCanaris
@MultiCanaris 7 лет назад
Aviram Vijh been thinking that as well ... I was quite horrified Imagine a time without hitchens AND Dawkins What a treat this video is ... Brilliant
@rhondah1587
@rhondah1587 7 лет назад
I assume you meant treat and not threat right? If so, yes.
@AlexOjideagu2
@AlexOjideagu2 7 лет назад
He had a stroke too it has clearly aged him too
@OneTrueScotsman
@OneTrueScotsman 7 лет назад
If he's anything like his parents, he'll be with us for many years yet. His dad died when he was 95 and his mother's still alive and kicking.
@MultiCanaris
@MultiCanaris 7 лет назад
RhondaH obviously Did so from my iPhone and autocorrect jumbed in without me checking Thx
@himmura
@himmura 7 лет назад
Read Dawkins and solidified my atheism. Found Matt (the average Joe) online and was blown away by his arguments. So proud to see them up on stage together.
@candeffect
@candeffect 4 года назад
So, you now define God down with child molesters to justify your lifestyle?
@georgeelmerdenbrough6906
@georgeelmerdenbrough6906 3 года назад
He isn't average Joe in terms of biblical knowledge . He is very well educated on the subject and attached culture .
@georgeelmerdenbrough6906
@georgeelmerdenbrough6906 3 года назад
@@candeffect What ?
@PazuChill
@PazuChill 7 лет назад
I'm so happy to see Matt get more recognition!
@BrendanWhelan
@BrendanWhelan 7 лет назад
Richard Dawkins. 75 years old, went through a mild stroke and still has more intellect and class than 99% of us. This man is one of my heroes and will be sorely missed when he dies, but will live on forever in these videos..
@teresazbikowska7094
@teresazbikowska7094 11 месяцев назад
Dillahunty suffered a stroke and has had a triple heart bypass surgery.
@ronaldcatullus
@ronaldcatullus 9 месяцев назад
@@teresazbikowska7094weird flex but ok
@ptt619
@ptt619 7 лет назад
I remember when I took the god delusion to school a couple years ago, and it alone sparked many arguments in the whole classroom, and it turned lots of them into atheists. Such a good book.
@alexcsouza
@alexcsouza 7 лет назад
a miracle!! good job!
@AUSSIEMADMATT
@AUSSIEMADMATT 7 лет назад
Nice work!
@ptt619
@ptt619 7 лет назад
Nicolas Broszky I dont know about the sillyness, the only explanation in the book that I don't really like is the Boeing 747 one.
@LMcAwesome
@LMcAwesome 7 лет назад
This is a bit of a weakness of Dawkins. When people try to point out a nuance thats missing from his argument he gets pissed off and starts attacking all philosophers/philosophy in general as if the entire group is just an amorphous blob of haters. I personally think the more engaged parts of philosophy as a subject can be quite useful in this kind of thing. Dillahunty for example is best characterised as a man who payed REALLY CLOSE ATTENTION during epistemology 101. And its the reason hes one of the best around right now.
@GisherJohn24
@GisherJohn24 7 лет назад
oh you poor conditioned internet trolls who spend more time discussing God than a Jesuit priest in seminary, time to open Pandora's box, your cognitive dissonance has reached an all time low. Feel free to stay stupid but move on. If you ever want to search for truth try it one day and set yourself free from your willful ignorance of reality as prophecfied by Christ before he created you. You're a conditioned fool who embraces absurdity every waking moment. No amount of study or intelligence you all claim to have matters. Nothing. Any education, home schooled or Harvard graduates, you're all blinded by Satans covers. You're scared to admit to his glorious creation that you live in every day. Every emotion, the good food you'll eat today and the beds you all sleep in, you mock that and spit in the glorified God who gave you this life. Shame on you. There's two things I know about this world, God made this world, and I'm not Him
@GoTorino
@GoTorino 7 лет назад
"Apparently you've got to be either religious or a liar to get elected..." Preferably both, knowing politicians.
@tinagvardanyan8627
@tinagvardanyan8627 6 лет назад
A brief, 5-step summary of my mental journey from attachment (indecisiveness) to indifference (decisiveness): Start: 1. I am suffering, because I'm not living up to god's expectations. He isn't happy with me. 2. I am suffering, because god is not living up to my own expectations. I am not happy with him. to 3. Perhaps god & I are passing the burden of our happiness onto each other, therefore none of us will ever be happy. 4. I don't really know what makes god happy, but I sure as heck know what makes me happy. End: 5. Therefore, it's only reasonable that the burden of my happiness should unequivocally rest with me. That's when the constant riddle solving came to an end, and so did my indecisions. Now I am more decisive and much happier, and I can only assume with a detached indifference that so is god!
@youx457
@youx457 5 лет назад
👍💪✊👋👋👋👋👋👋👋👋👋👋👋
@therealkakitron
@therealkakitron 7 лет назад
I can't help but get teary eyed knowing there are people out there so dedicated to do good through the means of reason and critical thinking. Coming from a religious family (mexican catholic) and being the only atheist member of it, I do struggle to have a connection with my family on the subjects of religion and humanism which is unfortunate. I wish I could have a solid conversation with my family members without hurting their feelings but I know that's just pie in the sky.
@karame463
@karame463 6 лет назад
It will take a very long time before religion, superstition and the supernatural will be pulled out of central and South American cultures. I have noticed that the vast majority (if not all) of “possession” videos come from countries in those regions. It must be awful to suffer from a mental illness in those cultures because they will just claim you are possessed by the devil. I feel for you in your situation. Hopefully you can get them to at least think about why they believe what they believe. That is the first step in getting people to let go of it.
@caramel7050
@caramel7050 5 лет назад
Same here. Spain. Catholic family, likely only atheist (sister might be but she hates me and we hardly talk on a day to day basis already). I wish I could talk about these things with my parents without my mother claiming I've been indoctrinated by the internet (ironic, considering I was literally raised in the church and had no saying in being baptized) or my father going full on agnostic about everything but somehow still calling himself a christian.
@juan25amarillo
@juan25amarillo 2 года назад
I’m in the same boat as you my fren. My parents are also Hispanic Catholics and I’m the only atheist in my entire family (big ass family too). I almost feel bad for them because I feel like they’re brainwashed in a way and wish I could get them to be more transparent and at least question why they believe what they believe but yeah I completely understand your situation.
@teresazbikowska7094
@teresazbikowska7094 11 месяцев назад
You mean through chit chat or discussion. Absolutely pathetic.
@capoman1
@capoman1 7 лет назад
What an honor for Matt. Matt has been *the top reasoning skeptic* IMO. His arguments are flawless, and you won't find yourself disagreeing with him often, if ever. He deserves to be mentioned alongside Harris and Dawkins for sure.
@LMcAwesome
@LMcAwesome 7 лет назад
Hitch be dead my man
7 лет назад
Agreed. Matt's very formidable. He may lack the... wordsmithing that Harris has (Dawkins lacks it too, though) but you're right - his arguments are very well thought out and, more often than not, flawless.
@lionofthetribe1
@lionofthetribe1 7 лет назад
Good to see this is a place where debunked internet atheists gather: Enough material on this website to debunk all your internet atheist myths - www.bethinking.org/ "Atheism deserves better than the new atheists whose methodology consists in criticizing religion without understanding it, quoting texts without contexts, taking exceptions as the rule, confusing folk belief with reflective theology, abusing mocking, ridiculing, caricaturing and demonizing religious faith and holding it responsible for all the crimes against humanity." -Os Guinness, "The Global Public Square"
@capoman1
@capoman1 7 лет назад
lionofthetribe1 "Debunked internet atheists?" I didn't know atheism could be "debunked." Nor did I know that there were "internet atheists." Are there "internet Christians" as well? And considering there are still debates entitled "Does god exist," I'd say the jury is still out on theistic claims. And sadly, atheists on the whole prove to have more knowledge of the bible than Christians do. So sad.
@lionofthetribe1
@lionofthetribe1 7 лет назад
***** so what ! copy and pasting a comment that leads you to a website that debunks one atheist myth is not playing by the rules or something? You really mean what you said by your comment of "And sadly, atheists on the whole prove to have more knowledge of the bible than Christians do. So sad." How about you prove your claim big boy. How bout you truly try and impress us, instead of whinging and complaining with no substance in what you write and comment on ? How bout you read and critique a book such as Why Trust the Bible?: Answers to 10 Tough Questions by Amy Orr-Ewing (2008) I look forward to your thoughtful knowedgable comments
@randywhite6468
@randywhite6468 5 лет назад
Have always loved Richard, but I have to say, I am so impressed with Matt. Having watched his shows recently and his presentation, he is simply amazing. So, Matt, thank you for making me proud to be a Texan again. One day the torch will pass, but with Matt, its obviously in great hands. Thank you both for a great show...
@TheBuildKingR
@TheBuildKingR 5 лет назад
agreed!!!
@jonmartinson6830
@jonmartinson6830 Год назад
Matt is a smart cookie!
@Pangburn
@Pangburn 11 месяцев назад
¡Suscríbete a nuestro nuevo canal en español! Our new Spanish channel will feature professionally translated voice acting & dubbing for all Pangburn Live Discussions. Please subscribe & share with your Spanish-speaking friends! ¡Esperamos que disfrutes! ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-dwiAsHi0Nj4.html
@scatton61
@scatton61 7 лет назад
Professor Richard Dawkins "To hell with play doe and safe spaces.... Grow up" ..... legend
@davidburroughs7068
@davidburroughs7068 7 лет назад
Stephen Catton ... If university isn't to first teach in the specific, and second provide a well-rounded education in the arts and sciences, then my worry is it will become reduced to a vocational level educational in the only the current most popular ideologies.
@scatton61
@scatton61 7 лет назад
David Burroughs Absolutely agree with you
@jordanw6918
@jordanw6918 7 лет назад
Stephen Catton Superb message considering the latest ban of him by a secular group over a freaking tweet. PC culture poisons everything. I hope the legends of hitchens, Harris, shermer, Alli, and Dawkins keeps it far away from secularism.
@xoqvuz
@xoqvuz 7 лет назад
Doesn't Matt Dillahunty lean towards Feminist & SJW Rhetoric, along with Aron Ra?
@TheQeltar
@TheQeltar 7 лет назад
Dawkins supports and admires feminism too, he just says some pretty dumb stuff occasionally.
@slumberzzzz
@slumberzzzz 7 лет назад
I get emotional when I see the people I admire meeting each other.
@mrlozmoore
@mrlozmoore 7 лет назад
aw.! :) isn't knowledge empowering
@thetruthchannel349
@thetruthchannel349 6 лет назад
emotions are as valuable and fleeting as wet toilet paper caught in a wind.
@davidcraig7771
@davidcraig7771 6 лет назад
slumberzzzz it's the holy spirit
@thebloocat
@thebloocat 5 лет назад
slumberzzzz that's why the Avengers was successful
@tsfbaf303
@tsfbaf303 5 лет назад
The Truth Channel As long as the reactions are based on reality, there is no problem in having them. It’s actually the one thing that drives humanity, for better or for worse.
@Pangburn
@Pangburn 2 года назад
Be sure to make an account on the Callin app. We have exciting shows booked for every day of the week. The daily host and I will start with a brief discussion about the topic, then we start taking callers. Eventually, we will have multiple callers active at a time and turn it into more of a group discussion. One of the main reasons for moving to the Callin app is their **100% FREE SPEECH** policy. If it's legal to say, we can say it. I think it's important for us to support platforms that make freedom of speech a priority. So JOIN US ! Make sure you subscribe to **The Pangburn Hangout** and give me a follow! If you're interested in hosting your own discussion, dm me. www.callin.com/show/the-pangburn-hangout-ytIdqseMzM
@ExtremeBogom
@ExtremeBogom 7 лет назад
Always nice to see a new Dawkins video that actually *is* new and not just a falsely dated one in order to get viewers. Great conversation.
@GisherJohn24
@GisherJohn24 7 лет назад
he's a militant fool. He says your dad evolved a fish kid. Yeah, embrace his absurdity.
@thebored999
@thebored999 7 лет назад
+Jesus Saves That's a new one.
@buttholeweeb621
@buttholeweeb621 7 лет назад
thebored999 no shit, autism hit this kid like a fucking airplane hit the world trade center.
@thebored999
@thebored999 7 лет назад
+Landon McInjames Holy fuck your comment is hilarious.
@GisherJohn24
@GisherJohn24 7 лет назад
Does anyone agree to his claim your dad evolved from a fish ? Please explain
@gilesgoldsbro5816
@gilesgoldsbro5816 7 лет назад
As an old sailor, I have to mention that Richard's socks are on the wrong legs; green is starboard, while red is port!
@rojh9351
@rojh9351 7 лет назад
Matt is ex-Navy, it probably bothered him too!
@joostvanrens
@joostvanrens 7 лет назад
Giles Goldsbro not if he rows.
@gilesgoldsbro5816
@gilesgoldsbro5816 7 лет назад
Good one! Back to the bow...
@GUITARTIME2024
@GUITARTIME2024 7 лет назад
Giles Goldsbro no one cares
@jaywhoisit4863
@jaywhoisit4863 7 лет назад
Giles Goldsbro that depends what part of the world you are in!! "Red right return" can put you on a reef in many parts of the world.
@Pangburn
@Pangburn 5 лет назад
Please remember to subscribe! :)
@RPDBY
@RPDBY 5 лет назад
what for?
@peejay4606
@peejay4606 3 года назад
I am😃👍
@pickleballer1729
@pickleballer1729 7 лет назад
I love Dawkins' rocking the 'one red sock, one green sock' look. Stylin'!
@tennis5126
@tennis5126 7 лет назад
Dawkins is the definition of a narcissist and very arrogant towards people. He has no respect for people. He wears those socks because he knows that other people know that he is intelligent and can get away with it. He wears it for attention and likes to be unique because it's a status thing.
@Lou13Cyf3r
@Lou13Cyf3r 7 лет назад
Jack - don't be hating just cuz Dawkins is beyond your intelligence.
@ROOKTABULA
@ROOKTABULA 7 лет назад
Jack - Using that "logic" what should we think about the Pope and his stomping grounds, The Vatican?! Fucking idiot.
@antmallett6065
@antmallett6065 7 лет назад
+ Kevin Ruback I thought he was doing port and starboard..then I checked, and port is red, starboard green. So as we look at him, I suppose it still hold true.
@Lou13Cyf3r
@Lou13Cyf3r 7 лет назад
Ant Mallett ha ha... meet him in the middle on the poop deck!! ha, sorry, had to
@iWishMyNameWasBetter
@iWishMyNameWasBetter 7 лет назад
Brilliant union of two very different, but forward thinking men
@jordythebassist
@jordythebassist 7 лет назад
iWishMyNameWasBetter I couldn't agree more, Richard has an eloquent touch to his public speaking while Matt is a no-nonsense, to the point speaker. I love it
@TheJwwinter
@TheJwwinter 5 лет назад
Richard is truly intelligent while Matt is an arrogant fuckhead.
@caramel7050
@caramel7050 5 лет назад
@@TheJwwinter He's not. He just comes off as bold to you, probably.
@abhikchattopadhyay9080
@abhikchattopadhyay9080 4 года назад
@@TheJwwinter actually Matt is the more intelligent person with a flawless rationale....but Dawkins is just a eloquent speaker...you must be a fucking idiot..
@ukaszrybkowski2769
@ukaszrybkowski2769 2 года назад
@@TheJwwinter Matt is often too agressive and rude, he will order you to shut up, if he doesn't like what you're saying. Kinda like a bully.
@DoctorDuto
@DoctorDuto 6 лет назад
"There are great people in almost any religion I can think of, and my point is they could be BETTER if they dumped the religious baggage; and there are bad people in every religion that I could name, and they would be WAY better if they dumped the religious baggage." I will be quoting this *many* times in the future
@Pangburn
@Pangburn Год назад
Also check out Aliens, God & Evolution with Richard Dawkins & Brian Greene ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-7iQSJNI6zqI.html
@Tasrod
@Tasrod 7 лет назад
I think Atheist is an unnecessary word. I long for the day when it is replaced by NORMAL.
@Brickerbrack
@Brickerbrack 7 лет назад
I disagree. "Normal" is already too misused a term, almost invariably meaning "Whatever I am, that you're not". I do, however, agree, that it'd be nice for the term "atheist" to become unnecessary.
@hgaddy2
@hgaddy2 7 лет назад
I prefer DEFAULT
@krisbrag87
@krisbrag87 7 лет назад
Rod How or realists
@AdmiralBison
@AdmiralBison 7 лет назад
indeed and theist + what ever the Religion is dominant in the country is the normal.
@ruben307
@ruben307 7 лет назад
it being normal won't devalue the term. Just like being sane is normal but the term is still often used.
@classicalmusic1175
@classicalmusic1175 7 лет назад
Richard's socks. Hahaha, love it.
@cshubs
@cshubs 7 лет назад
Christmas colors, at that!
@allways28
@allways28 7 лет назад
hes gone insane
@slumberzzzz
@slumberzzzz 7 лет назад
That's what I noticed too. Very colorful.
@beyondgreen9772
@beyondgreen9772 7 лет назад
I thought he put them on unknowingly.
@westherm
@westherm 7 лет назад
He's got them on the wrong sides. Red should go on his port foot, green on starboard...
@scotthunt1613
@scotthunt1613 7 лет назад
Matt Dillahunty is great at these discussions. He should do one of these with Daniel Dennett next.
@duchessren
@duchessren 6 лет назад
Scott Hunt I like this idea. I hope he’ll leave out the Kenyan prostitute quip and the bit about getting a twelve year old girl though. 😲🤔😬
@martincooper8559
@martincooper8559 4 года назад
Matt dillahunty is awesome! He's a fucking God!
@ceirwan
@ceirwan 5 лет назад
You can tell just how much Matt respects Dawkins in this conversation, great to watch.
@elfootman
@elfootman 7 лет назад
Wow I have always hoped you both could talk, this is going to be amazing.
@SocksWithSandals
@SocksWithSandals 7 лет назад
Good to see you back in the fight, Richard.
@kolnman3582
@kolnman3582 3 года назад
All we needed was the great Christopher Hitchens.
@MichaelFlenderson
@MichaelFlenderson 3 года назад
He would say otherwise. These guys are legends in their own right.
@time4sanity
@time4sanity 3 года назад
Love Richard Dawkins.....so grateful for having discovered him and for all the great presentations and discussions in which he has participated. One of the best uses of RU-vid!
@anunknownentity1637
@anunknownentity1637 3 года назад
Richard Dawkins' views are laughable to say the least
@PaganTeapot
@PaganTeapot 7 лет назад
holy spagetti,...Matt AND Dawkins ?? I have died and went to,..well ,..in the ground!😉
@nefariouspablo1088
@nefariouspablo1088 5 лет назад
So much to look forward to in the ground huh?
@shirosaieko6626
@shirosaieko6626 5 лет назад
Ahahha
@robsaxepga
@robsaxepga 5 лет назад
Lol!
@archangel7052
@archangel7052 4 года назад
👏😅
@erikrohr4396
@erikrohr4396 4 года назад
How poignant.
@stranahan07
@stranahan07 7 лет назад
Finally! I swear I've been waiting so long for these two to sit down and converse about these topics of discussion. Time to clean the house and put on some headphones for the next hour and a half. 🙂
@jpats6124
@jpats6124 7 лет назад
This was so uplifting - thank you so much. I just love listening to both of these people.
@robsaxepga
@robsaxepga 5 лет назад
Thank you for posting this ❤️
@coecovideo
@coecovideo 7 лет назад
FYI: This conversation took place on November the 6th, 2016 in Vancouver
@dwight4k
@dwight4k 7 лет назад
Thx! I don't know why they never mention when the conversation was taped.
@coecovideo
@coecovideo 7 лет назад
Dwight Dunker laziness?!
@dwight4k
@dwight4k 7 лет назад
coecovideo I don't think that's it. Check out the description box. They wrote all that without mentioning when the event was taped. They never mention that. It always gets on mu nerves.
@coecovideo
@coecovideo 7 лет назад
Dwight Dunker it's called copy and paste.
@dwight4k
@dwight4k 7 лет назад
coecovideo Yes, but still. Then the original poster didn't mention it either.
@cyberswine
@cyberswine 7 лет назад
Brag Warning! I was there and it was great! The video might not show that it was packed (theater's capacity is listed as 1200) full Vancouver atheists, that's what made it extra great!
@tonyeezi7315
@tonyeezi7315 6 лет назад
I'm surprised a group of religious fundamentalists didn't bomb the theatre knowing there were so many non-believers packed in there.
@thetruthchannel349
@thetruthchannel349 6 лет назад
You sound like a church group bragging about how many showed up to see a guest minister! I guess thats why the Supreme Court ruled atheism a religion in 1962! ;)
@Jake007123
@Jake007123 6 лет назад
Saying atheism is a religion it's like saying abstinence it's a sex position.
@thetruthchannel349
@thetruthchannel349 6 лет назад
Then tell that to the Supreme Court. It ruled atheism a religion in 1962.
@thetruthchannel349
@thetruthchannel349 6 лет назад
"Chrysanthus3 minutes ago Saying atheism is a religion it's like saying abstinence it's a sex position" It isnt alike because you are mistaken. Comparing the two is ridiculous. Your analogue is irrational. Atheism is a religion because its based on the assumption of faith that 'there is no God' Whether or not you participate in sex or not you are still a sexual being. It doesnt change the factors involved in sexuality. It doesnt mean SEX DOESNT EXIST. I love how atheists love to think they are SO rational BUT every time YOU open your mouths you sound like IDIOTS.
@catherine_404
@catherine_404 6 лет назад
Love you! Thank you very much for the talk.
@funnymyth1827
@funnymyth1827 6 лет назад
fantastic talk. thank you for the upload.
@TheOicyu812
@TheOicyu812 7 лет назад
This is a presidential ticket I would have voted for.
@DS-hw8id
@DS-hw8id 3 года назад
Only one is eligible…
@ByTruthImFree
@ByTruthImFree 7 лет назад
What an absolute treat. Thanks, Matt and Richard.
@nestrada19740
@nestrada19740 7 лет назад
I really enjoyed this conversation. Both participants, brilliant.
@multiquantumwell
@multiquantumwell 3 года назад
Love these guys, one of the best conversations recorded for the history. Who in the world could dislike this? If that's your case, please read more about science. Regards
@ASM881
@ASM881 7 лет назад
I just love these two gentlemen. Having read, watched a good deal of their works, I feel a legitimate warmth toward them both.
@roder51
@roder51 7 лет назад
2 great minds in conversation. How wonderful!
@op1ekun81
@op1ekun81 7 лет назад
Simply beautiful :) Thank you!
@dk6024
@dk6024 7 лет назад
Wonderful discussion. Even the Q&A was really enjoyable.
@princepratik32
@princepratik32 7 лет назад
Dawkins has the absolute authority on what a 'meme' is as he coined the term.
@thaDjMauz
@thaDjMauz 4 года назад
I respectfully partially disagree. Words (which are in darwins defenition a vehicle for memes) go through their own evolution, and in the end the dominating use is what defines something (because of utility, the whole thing science is based on). Darwins coined defenition of a meme is legitimate, but he does not have the authority of when the dominant culture is wrong. Also, is gif pronounced jif? Because the creator of the format said it is.
@whipsmartchris
@whipsmartchris 2 года назад
@@thaDjMauz I have always said “Jif” and I always will - not because it’s right but because I’m 75% Irish.
@SalisburyKarateClub
@SalisburyKarateClub 7 лет назад
great to see these two on the same stage. Enjoyed it immensely.
@mistou26
@mistou26 7 лет назад
So good to listen to two itnelligent persons discussing together ... Thank you a lot for this video.
@staninjapan07
@staninjapan07 6 лет назад
I like to hear both of these people speak. I guess I will find this quite a worthwhile watch. Thanks for the upload.
@robsawalker
@robsawalker 7 лет назад
Matt is so important on this subject because he is so familiar with the Bible. Christians love to ask atheists to quote chapter and verse out of thin air and Matt can.
@chronicler2313
@chronicler2313 7 лет назад
robsa walker Although Matt can he is not a seasoned reader of the bible. Reading the bible does not mean someone is saved and personally knows Jesus.
@achapmaninhk
@achapmaninhk 7 лет назад
But he was saved. He IS a "seasoned" reader of the bible. He has studied it in great depth, as a Christian and as an atheist. Look him up on Iron Chariots
@chronicler2313
@chronicler2313 7 лет назад
Alex Chapman Faith is a fruit of the Holy Spirit. Since he never had faith he did not ever have the Holy Spirit since he didn't he never belonged to God. Many pastors and leaders who are actually not saved. What Dillahunty did was just a form of religion. **Galatians 5:22-23 But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, 23 gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law. **Romans 8:9 You, however, are not in the realm of the flesh but are in the realm of the Spirit, if indeed the Spirit of God lives in you. And if anyone does not have the Spirit of Christ, they do not belong to Christ.
@chronicler2313
@chronicler2313 7 лет назад
+TwoHandedSledge Well it's a bit late for that. How were you saved and what is salvation?
@theshapeexists
@theshapeexists 7 лет назад
Matt Black perhaps you can tell Matt and Richard how you were "saved", so they and all the audience can laugh at how ridiculous you sound. do you hop on atheist videos to save us, or to flirt with the idea that everything you believe is all a crock of shit?
@Pangburn
@Pangburn 3 года назад
Do you enjoy having discussions on topics that "you shouldn't talk about" ?... Try joining our discord server! We have daily voice chats about life, philosophy, science and art. It's free! discord.gg/XSSGDcdB5f
@Shorey
@Shorey 7 лет назад
Atheism and religion are but two sides of the same coin. One prefers to use its head, while the other relies on tales.
@cwdor
@cwdor 5 лет назад
dont you mean science and religion.????
@alexbentley4087
@alexbentley4087 4 года назад
Who said that?
@jasonstefanovich58
@jasonstefanovich58 4 года назад
No, you are wrong.
@peterpickedapeck2894
@peterpickedapeck2894 4 года назад
Shorey Utter bollocks.
@rkernell
@rkernell 4 года назад
@Make Me Believe How many is "some"?
@Pangburn
@Pangburn 11 месяцев назад
A discussion with my hero Daryl Davis. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-NkXpljcEt9c.html
@Dazzletoad
@Dazzletoad 7 лет назад
I only wish I was privileged enough to watch and listen to the Professor live, and indeed Matt Dillahunty. Two great men, one fantastic discussion. Huge thanks for the upload.
@braveheartphysique2464
@braveheartphysique2464 7 лет назад
FINALLY! Been waiting ages to see these two people share a stage.
7 лет назад
I love both guys: smart, excellent speakers, cultivated. They belong to the "truth" era. We're in the "post-truth" era. Let's enjoy their conversation, but know that we're watching an historical anomaly
@mobydickswife9512
@mobydickswife9512 7 лет назад
'What do you mean by "post-trust" era?
@xebek
@xebek 7 лет назад
+Edward Black Please re-read the original comment.
7 лет назад
Post-truth is as culture in which debate is framed largely by appeals to emotion disconnected from observable reality, and by the repeated assertion of talking points to which factual rebuttals are ignored.
@xebek
@xebek 7 лет назад
alley boulcrest​ It appears you copy-pasted that entire assertion, but can you provide any independently verified, falsifiable and peer-reviewed evidence for any of your claims? How have you determined that this being exists? If the bible is an accurate representation of its character, then Dawkins' analysis is spot on. Lastly, does the biblical god have perfect foresight? Did it know how reality would play out at the time of creation? If so, it created satan knowing it would rebel and fall, it would create hell to house satan and his compatriots, it would create man knowing man would fall, it knew it would send man to hell, it knew it would have to flood the world as a reset, which would fail, it knew it would have to sacrifice itself TO itself, which would fail for most people and it knew it would pass on the most important message ever in languages that would die out while giving us the ability to think critically yet base salvation on not using that ability at all. Odd plan. I won't even go into detail about its desire to play favorites with "chosen people" and allowing them to slaughter any infidels (it created those other tribes knowing they would end up slaughtered - and just for that express purpose?), the endorsements for slavery and murder and the idea of infinite torture for finite crimes. Yeah, super duper nice guy, that god appears to be. Also, believe or burn is hardly free will. Besides, he knows the future preemptively, right?
7 лет назад
By the way, from the bible alone, Satan is the lesser of 2 evils. He is only responsible for 10 deaths, including the sons of Job (killed with the explicit agreement of Jahveh). By contrast, God kills or orders the killing of between 2,500,000 to 25,000,000 people (estimations vary depending on the scholar). Including women and children (e.g Medianites).
@nixodian
@nixodian 7 лет назад
Love both Matt and Richard, Most powerful, knowledgeable Horsemen holding up the pillars to our logical freethinking, scientific side
@georgeelmerdenbrough6906
@georgeelmerdenbrough6906 3 года назад
I agree but also worry about putting people on pedestals .
@bryanmcalister9780
@bryanmcalister9780 6 лет назад
Thoroughly enjoyed this conversation.
@3101010
@3101010 7 лет назад
Looking fwd to this for awhile now.
7 лет назад
GOD, im glad i live in scandinavia and are atheist.
@TomBrooklyn
@TomBrooklyn 7 лет назад
Are there more than one of you?
@Princedemars
@Princedemars 7 лет назад
Your pic is great!!!
@bluntedcorleone3628
@bluntedcorleone3628 7 лет назад
Norse mythology is so dope though...
@beauzxcvb
@beauzxcvb 6 лет назад
But can you are use grammar correctly?
@jaymiddleton1782
@jaymiddleton1782 5 лет назад
pathstogodbyfaithcom wow you’re a moron. Any evidence for someone being euthanised against their will? Aka murder?
@TerribilisScriptor
@TerribilisScriptor 7 лет назад
oh boy 1 and 1/2 hour of conversation between two of my favorite debatingpersonalitys. this can only be good!
@RealinDealer
@RealinDealer 4 года назад
I love hearing Dawkins speak. It is a great comfort. A much needed link to sanity and sense.
@junepearl7993
@junepearl7993 7 лет назад
I've been looking forward to this since Matt announced it months ago. It did not disappoint! I wish it could have gone on for hours. Great questions from the audience.
@theowlsarefun
@theowlsarefun 7 лет назад
I paid $200 for orchestra seats and then got the date wrong and missed it :( Glad I get to see it on RU-vid, at least!
@theaurafist
@theaurafist 7 лет назад
theowlsarefun I'm half way around the world, RU-vid is a savior alright. I would give up 10 years of my life to see them live. I'm sorry you couldn't. :(
@timwoodjetts5960
@timwoodjetts5960 7 лет назад
Listening to Richard’s anecdote about being represented by an empty chair at a debate, it occurred to me wouldn’t it be a good idea in debates or public conversations on this subject, if there were always an empty chair and an open invitation for God to attend and put his case in person? I fear that until we can keep religion out of the school room, there will always be someone turning up at the stage door for an autograph.
@MarttiSuomivuori
@MarttiSuomivuori 6 лет назад
BTW thanks to you, professor Dawkins, my son is doing his post doc in Stanford right now. I am forever thankful to you, sir. I have seen the influence you have had on quite a few public figures. For the better. My respect for you is of the highest kind. All your books are on my shelf.
@Pangburn
@Pangburn Год назад
Christian Josh is back with another Atheist Nightmare episode tonight at 7pm pacific. See if your atheism stands the test of Josh! Call in! www.callin.com/room/the-atheists-nightmare-atheism-needs-god-SmleoBNuVt
@robinhood20253
@robinhood20253 Год назад
Lmfao
@gnagyusa
@gnagyusa 7 лет назад
"This shit makes no sense". Great line, Matt! Religion never made sense to me. My grandma took me to church a couple of times when I was little and I remember being bored to death, thinking that all those grown-ups were playing some kind of a *pretend game*. They couldn't *possibly* believe all that nonsense. And I still believed in Santa back then (in Europe, Santa is just an old guy with presents, no flying reindeer or other magical stuff). Some of use are born completely immune to the BS we call "religion". It took me a while to grasp that grown-ups actually believed that crap. I'm still baffled by this fact.
@kenbrunet6120
@kenbrunet6120 4 года назад
We share similar memories of our childhood. I remember thinking when i was a teen that religion was declining. Feels like there's a resurgence. I can't seem to understand how people buy into it so blindly.
@Ryattt81
@Ryattt81 4 года назад
Remonds me of watching tv as a young child and hearing the description of "god" for the 1st time. My only thought was "I dont think thats real." Not sure if it happened but its a real memory.
@lightningandodinify
@lightningandodinify 7 лет назад
the introduction gave me goosebumps.
@AmeerBadran4Life
@AmeerBadran4Life 7 лет назад
I spent the whole video trying to focus on the subject and not on the red and green socks of Dawkins :')
@Doctor_Straing_Strange
@Doctor_Straing_Strange 3 года назад
truly in the spirit of christmas
@thehotyounggrandpas8207
@thehotyounggrandpas8207 5 лет назад
Such a beautiful celebration of logic and reason gives one hope!
@gor265
@gor265 7 лет назад
Fantastic interview.
@whynottalklikeapirat
@whynottalklikeapirat 7 лет назад
Great to see Richard doing public stuff again.
@callumtinant7412
@callumtinant7412 7 лет назад
great conversation, went there live.
@kirkcreelman
@kirkcreelman 7 лет назад
I just sat down to watch this and feel like a kid at Christmas!
@fdakis
@fdakis 7 лет назад
Richard Dawkins is one of a very few people on this earth that makes Matt dillahunty appear to have normal intelligence. That's not a slight on Matt because I'm a big fan of his show.
@xebek
@xebek 7 лет назад
So epic. I don't know how people can sit through a sermon yet reject discourse and dialogue such as this. My god (phrase intended), people, it's time to embrace reality and intellectual honesty!
@swiitchy511
@swiitchy511 4 года назад
Two of my favorite people on one stage, thank you :)
@Zarih67
@Zarih67 5 лет назад
Just saw this. Excellent!
@donsnow8559
@donsnow8559 7 лет назад
I like Matt Dillahunty, he is brilliant on the atheist experience. In debates he sometimes misses opportunities presented. When Richard Dawkins suggests that it s high time a scientist got the Nobel prize for literature, Dillahunty just moved on. He should have acknowledged that Richard Dawkins should be at the front of the line for science literature. I also don;t understand why he hasn't won a Nobel prize in science for the selfish gene or the extended phenotype.
@arjitjere1559
@arjitjere1559 4 года назад
I agree he's a better writer than scientist
@ASM881
@ASM881 7 лет назад
Absolutely Brilliant.
@harbster2
@harbster2 4 года назад
Great interview !
@johndoe-ie1be
@johndoe-ie1be 7 лет назад
Thank you, Matt & Richard ! Keep doing what you do !
@paulj6662
@paulj6662 7 лет назад
90 minutes well spent. Thank you.
@TornadoCAN99
@TornadoCAN99 7 лет назад
Wish I had known this was being put on...could have attended in person!
@TheSoy1313
@TheSoy1313 3 года назад
Awesome guys,love from Michigan
@laurieharper1526
@laurieharper1526 6 лет назад
Wish I could give this more than one thumbs up. Excellent.
@lucitti8065
@lucitti8065 6 лет назад
Dawkins is serving me mad (book) dumbledore vibes with the wacky socks and the lyrical introduction lmao
@johnwestcott5612
@johnwestcott5612 7 лет назад
Dawkins looks healthy. That'a s relief.
@thetruthchannel349
@thetruthchannel349 6 лет назад
Course he does. He scared as hell to die.
@MsCosta-uz4hz
@MsCosta-uz4hz 6 лет назад
If God is in a fight with the Devil, why do we have to be part of that. Doesn't God says to love our enemies, why does God not love the devil?
@MsCosta-uz4hz
@MsCosta-uz4hz 6 лет назад
why does God make us with brains that are encrypted with the understanding and knowledge of Him? This is why I am an agnostic.
@TommyPKFire
@TommyPKFire 6 лет назад
That's one of the dumbest most delusional things I've ever heard. Bravo!
@TommyPKFire
@TommyPKFire 6 лет назад
I'm not sure... your comment seems fine. Not sure what I was on about... hmm. Maybe I replied to the wrong post LOL sorry m8!
@sharkamov
@sharkamov 5 лет назад
Two intelligent, clear thinking, eloquent giants of reason and truth! - On a personal note: I'd be _more_ than honored to call these two human beings 'my friend'!!! . . . . . .
@_s_p_a_r_k_e_s_7615
@_s_p_a_r_k_e_s_7615 7 лет назад
I could listen to this knowledge all day!
Далее
Richard Dawkins - Giving Thanks in a Vacuum
1:05:29
Просмотров 231 тыс.
James Randi & Matt Dillahunty In Conversation
1:05:25
Просмотров 245 тыс.
Dawkins re-examined: Dawkins' legacy
48:48
Просмотров 64 тыс.
Seth Andrews Interviews Richard Dawkins
1:01:59
Просмотров 118 тыс.
Outgrowing God: Richard Dawkins in Conversation
57:21
Просмотров 306 тыс.
Matt Dillahunty:  The Superiority of Secular Morality
26:55
Matt Dillahunty and AronRa - Lecture and Q&A - Perth WA
2:10:55
Richard Dawkins - Now Praise Intelligent Design
57:06
Просмотров 371 тыс.