ROASTING Some "Historic" Costumes // A Tour of My Costuming Closet

Подписаться 154 тыс.

Просмотров 37 тыс.

50% 1

Time for some sass? Today I'm tearing into some very questionable "historic" costumes and explaining what I would have done differently, or what I would do differently now I am older and wiser. That's right, I'm nitpicking my own attempts at historic costume, not anyone else's!
Images from (ahem) various films...and also the Metropolitan Museum of Art, MFA Boston, the V&A....Party City...
Colonial Williamsburg Swallowtail jacket : emuseum.history.org/objects/1...
Printed Cotton Bustle Dress from the V&A : collections.vam.ac.uk/item/O12...
18th century printed cotton dress from Museum of Fine Arts Boston : collections.mfa.org/objects/9...
Portrait Hat on Bess Foster : commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
Textured Cotton Blend Bustle Dress: www.metmuseum.org/art/collect...
Frilly White Bustle Gown: www.metmuseum.org/art/collect...
Dreamy Bustle Fashion Plate : commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Ca...
Any Music and Sound Effects from Epidemic Sound.
Where I get my pattern drafting paper: atlaslevy.com/Paper_c_13.html (not sponsored)
More from me?
Want to help me continue making more videos? Listen to me ramble on in a monthly podcast? Watch an additional project video each month? Peruse my Patreon here: / theclosethistorian
Blog: theclosethistorian.blogspot.com/
Instagram: / theclosethistorian
Etsy Shop: www.etsy.com/shop/TheClosetHi...
Pinterest: / bmesposito
Tumblr: / theclosethistorian
Beauty Instagram: / thehistoriansvanity
Beauty Channel: / thehistoriansvanity
But wait there's more! A PO BOX finally wahoo!
First, a disclaimer: So many of you have kindly offered to send me things, including vintage items you may have inherited, and I am so honored you would think of me and of course I do adore vintage treasures, however, unfortunately I only have so much storage space currently! So there is a chance that if something just wont work for me, or doesn't fit me etc, that I may not be able to keep all of your lovely things. Please only send things if you are okay with the possibility that I may donate items I just cannot keep. If you would prefer I put things that I can't keep into the TCH Etsy shop to help raise funds for me and the channel, please specify this in a note or letter in your parcel. Thank you so much!
Bianca Esposito
PO Box 632177
Highlands Ranch, CO 80163
Thank you for watching!

Хобби

Опубликовано:

30 сен 2020

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 541

@gabriellecress3867 3 года назад

What I've taken away from this is that I now want a Marie Antoinette themed 40th birthday party.

@zankapfel4390 3 года назад

The polyester "debate" is kind of uncomfortable... I think costumers are a bit out of touch about the cost and gatekeeping. I decided not to get into it because I do not have the funds for an all-silk art project that won't serve me in real life. I could use poly, but I do my very best to craft in sustainable ways and cannot justify using polyester for "fun" projects while avoiding them for normal clothing. It's interesting that this is never brought up - when you cringed at your muslin petticoat, I felt so bad about this - no reason to be mad at yourself! In LARP, which is a very different community ofc, there are very passionate reenactors but the principles of using thrifted pieces and materials as well as cheap cotton are very important to them - this is just a hobby, after all, and not worth compromising your values over.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

The cost is certainly a big barrier, silk is mad expensive! Sometimes you just want a break from always having to use cotton, for me that break was over 5 years ha

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Vintage lovers do not panic! Many retro projects coming up this fall as well, a film noir inspired lookbook...evening things...don't fret! A Victorian spooky season here yes, but also more 1940's and 1950's projects are on the schedule too! ❤

@ah5721 3 года назад

Yessss!! I love those eras! I love learning about what people actually wear back and the day. My belief in the movie is higher when done acutely-so continue to roast away!

@deniseheringer8972 3 года назад

😍😍😍 When you referenced Jessica Chastain in Crimson Peak, a personal FAVORITE of mine for costume design and in a horror movie no less.

@belindacoba5158 3 года назад

I loved your lookbooks !!

@garybaldwin5241 3 года назад

Very exciting news! I’m really looking forward to the journey!

@eiszapfenkobold 3 года назад

Don t roast yourself for not having enough money to afford expensive fabrics for a hobby. It looks great for beginner costumes. We costumers are much too picky/hard with ourselves. Thanks for sharing

@katieintraining 3 года назад

It is so refreshing to have a roasting video that acknowledges that there are people that made the decisions that are being roasted. I love this video. Thanks Bianca!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Katie! ❤

@jayneeojeda5677 3 года назад

"is it pretty?" this is my anthem. This is the content I'm here for.

@loveoffthedamned 3 года назад

I am pleasantly surprised to finally have someone in the costube voice such a chill and well-informed opinion on the so beloved by everyone in the community topic of historical accuracy in film and on tv. I feel like all of us, fashion history enthusiasts should remember that movies and tv shows are a visual medium and thus the way the characters look should first and foremost tell their story through visuals. Even tho sometimes it means some authenticity will be lost along the way. Would Jo March be arrested for running around New York with her skirts up and wearing tight pants underneath? Possibly. Does this 5 sec introduction tells us everything we need to know about her as a character in a very concise and clear way? Yes.

@cenedra20 3 года назад

Another example that I like is the back laced dress in Poldark. It's inaccurate and the show knew that, but it was crucial for the story - Demelza uses it as an innocent excuse to seduce Poldark, (asking him to help her undress) a front laced dress would have ruined the whole bit, because then she could just undress by herself

@mandycollins8795 3 года назад

hear! hear! I would also like to add that we don't know what kind of constraints or instructions the costume designers were under. When working for others, artists aren't always allowed to make historically accurate decisions.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

I love film, and stories, so the writing and cinematography as a whole always come first in my mind, costumes are there to serve the whole after all indeed ❤

@bytheriverbank1885 3 года назад

In regards to historical accuracy in movies and TV, you are correct, the general audience does not care, nor are they analyzing every detail frame by frame. Why? Because they are simply enjoying the show.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

I almost feel like if I have time upon first viewing to be deeply investigating the costumes that the story/characters/acting must be floundering worst of all! At that point the costumes may be good or bad, but the script or something else must be missing the mark furthest of all. The writing and cinematography always come first for me ❤

@zankapfel4390 3 года назад

I think there's been a weird trend on YT with those "historical correct" roasts. They feel...mean and negative now. The first few felt much more light-hearted. Your points have been made, please stop

@violetteplague3043 3 года назад

I think there is a place to discuss historic costuming and whether or not a show or movie got it right. There is also a place for those of us that prefer more historically inspired clothes who don’t necessarily want to take months making an outfit and just want something, well pretty.

@marelicainavokado 3 года назад

I'd say it depends on how much the producers bend the rules. You can't make a warrior princess show with armor over her boobs and shoulders, but she's showing off her bellybutton and thighs.

@0threnody070 3 года назад

Ah man. The part where you were talking about not being able to get a job in the field you wanted without a master’s/Ph.D really hit me hard. I’m an engineering student and this is a problem that is currently destroying my will to carry on. I empathize with you so much, especially because fabric is so expensive and I can’t make what I want because I can’t spare the funds. It’s a hard hobby

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

❤ It's not cheap to be "accurate" for sure

@xequth 3 года назад

Petition for "one hundo accurato" to become an academic term right now please! Really looking forward to seeing you get a chance to dive into a dream. I hope it is as extravagant, pretty and luxurious as it possibly can be! (And if it isn't quite, it will at least be a joy to watch.)

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you! Lots of luxurious taffeta incoming!

@l.m.2404 3 года назад

I hesitated from exploring my love of historic garments due to funds for authentic fabric but no more. I suddenly realized that I only had to please myself and decided to make it my objective to upcycle, repurpose and recycle. My garments represent different grandmother's in my family tree and since they aren't here to comment, I'm just going to have fun. I stick to true patterning for each outfit and sew an entire ensemble from underclothes to outer and accessories. I use both hand sewing and machine without remorse. So far, I have one 1150 Norman French, the Suzanne, with lots of real seed pearls , one 1706 gown, the Dorothy, with Rococo influences and am working on a 1824 wedding dress, the Joanna. All, would never survive Meme Mom or Bernadette but * shrug * ...... I'll keep on making them and watching you. Cheers. :)

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

You gotta make your art your way, and that is good indeed ❤

@e.urbach7780 3 года назад

Rather than throwing out the purple silk pet en l'air, since it is actual silk, I'd recommend that you take it apart and use it for a bustle-era bodice! Several elements of 1770s and 1780s style came back into fashion in the 1870s and 1880s, so the shape of the pattern pieces should be usable, or relatively easy to recut. It's been useful for me to remember that people used piecing to eke out gowns from real silk in historical times, too, and to remember that some well-placed trim can cover up a lot! Flat-lining also helps, especially with too-thin fabrics; I finally bought and used silk taffeta for the first time last year, and it was way too thin on its own, but when I flatlined the whole thing (even the skirt), it looked a whole lot better. Good luck getting back into historical costuming!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@johannageisel5390 3 года назад

@@TheClosetHistorian The color would also fit the late 19th century more. Btw. while watching your video I took apart the first "medieval dress" (lol) that I ever made. It's from around the year 2000 when I was a teenager. It's a horror show. Back then it was not easy to get info on all that. So the dress is made from a wool-poly blend and some weird poly stretch fabric that I used to make a kind of insert on the front. Because I had no idea what I was doing and basically just made a fantasy dress, it has this weird cut of costume dresses that emulate 17th century dresses without knowing what a stomacher is. Or that they were layered. And THEN I ruined it by washing it too hotly because I had no idea how to treat wool. Anyway, I now removed the front insert and will wash the wool blend part even more, so that it becomes boiled wool, and then make medieval hose out of it. Reuse, recycle, profit. :)

@margaretkaraba8161 3 года назад

Yes to all - if it's not specifically a uniform or everyday dress, it's a costume. If it's meant to propel the wearer into a different/better headspace, it's a costume. I'm not denigrating those who spend hours, days, weeks or months on a perfectly crafted garment they're going to wear once or twice a year - or a parent/guardian/nice person who throws together a costume out of a towel (or two) and some safety pins in 10 minutes. It's about the person wearing it who either feels "more like themselves" or "develops that necessary persona". It's great if that costume is outstandingly beautiful (to the eyes of the beholder), but the most basic vest/cape/spats combo can do the job and feel great to that person wearing it.

@margaretkaraba8161 3 года назад

YAY!!! For your funds and desire to pursue your dream dress. That one won't be a costume. It'll be an art project (yes, I do believe that when someone who *wants* a "costume" so bad they spend years looking for resources and knowledge it turns a potential costume into wearable art). Take your time and relish in the construction of your babies (I'm assuming you'll be making some undergarments for it as well). Make every cut and stitch count and we'll be here waiting patiently for those lovely videos. Have a ball.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Margaret! It will be a grand art project indeed! ❤

@lynnekingham8754 3 года назад

The struggle is real. Can't wait for the adventure of the bustle dress. So glad Patreon is letting you achieve your hearts desire.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Lynne! ❤

@johannageisel5390 3 года назад

"The Adventure of the Bustle Dress" sounds like the title of a Sherlock Holmes story. Many of these had this title structure.

@scottydogism 3 года назад

You crack me up. Your humor is just awesome. You are funnnny.

@bobbie9066 3 года назад

Normally, I'm really against people dissing their own work: you've put a ton of effort in, don't let perfect be the enemy of good, etc. And this still absolutely applies to your gorgeous projects!... But I also really love your intro and touching on the idea of being willing to roast ourselves if we're willing to roast unknown costume crews working with unknown limitations

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Bobbie! All my earlier costuming efforts were a good learning experience even if everything didn't always work out as I had hoped!

@Samanthasnow 3 года назад

This is very much why I don’t do more historic costuming. Money is so limiting. PS: your hair is amazing in this video!

@PoisonTheOgres 3 года назад

I am a very poor college student and I've made historical clothing from thrifted fabric as well as just $2 per yard pure 100% polyester fabric. Does it still look period even if it's not real silk? Is it still fun to make? Hell yes! It takes a bit longer to find fabrics, and often I just have to come up with projects based on fabric instead of the other way around. But it's still so much fun to do. Don't let money hold you back!

@Samanthasnow 3 года назад

I sew constantly. In lockdown I made over 30 garments mostly out of different kinds of cotton because it’s a relatively inexpensive fabric. I even made several Edwardian pieces. I just would love to make gorgeous Victorian pieces but if I was going to put all that work in I would want it to be something I am super proud of and so I would want it to be as accurate as possible which would require a large purchase of wool or silk which I cannot afford so I stick to my sewing of Edwardian-1940s pieces. Also because it’s easier to dress in a vintage style than a Victorian style everyday so it’s more practical to sew vintage.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Samantha!

@Side-Quest-Workshop 3 года назад

I’m new to sewing and to historical costuming in general. The stuff I am making is absolute trash, I frequently prick my fingers HARD with my needle (cotton poplin? More like cotton plasma), and my technique would give a tailor heart palpitations. But you know what? I’m having the time of my damn life. I love being a beginner: everything is shiny and new and when I finally - FINALLY - get the hang of a technique, magic happens. I’m excited for you and your upcoming gown project; for you to finally be able to realize this longterm wish is thrilling.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Sarah! It sounds like you are having fun which is indeed the most important dang part!!

@gav668 3 года назад

Regarding the pricking of your fingers: two thimbles on your pulling hand (I do middle and ring) as well as your sewing one (I do middle). I recommend older ones, either leather (lil caps for ur fingies basically) or the open metal ones that let your nails flow freely.

@kaytiej8311 3 года назад

"Hot glue is not the answer" Sage advice for us all. Had a good snicker over your scathing self appraisals. So refreshing to have someone show their less serious side. Always encouraging and uplifting to those of us just sorting out Looking forward to the upcoming videos so much!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Kaytie! ❤

@tikimama1139 3 года назад

You are so hard on yourself! Costuming is such a vast skillset. You learn something new with every thing you make, and continue to improve. I love that you keep making things and trying things. I've wanted to make a 1885 bustle gown for probably 30 years but I never even started one.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

1885 is my favorite bustle sweet spot too, just so good ❤

@blktauna 3 года назад

That lipstick is fire on you. If. you are making a 'costume' then poly is fine. Its for effect, not accuracy. If you are making clothes... well then that's a bit different. I do like that Edwardian on you. It suits you. That purple shot taffeta also suits you, you should do something in that again. if you want to reuse that Indian cotton, do a regency. I feel you on the not affording. We've all been there and some never leave it. It's fine. Also nothing wrong in making stuff for your own enjoyment! How much silk do you need for your bustle gown? I don't do victorian (I do medieval ) so I don't have a guess.

@musicandbooklover-p2o 3 года назад

At last, someone else who does mediaeval clothing. I admit to a yen for later Norman styles, loose and comfortable to wear wins points every time (used to wear Roman in my younger days). Seems everyone today prefers Victorian or Edwardian. Oh, and I practice 'history bounding', wearing my early mediaeval dresses on a daily basis. My concession being the under dress (chemise) is made to a more modern design, meaning armscyes and shaped sleeves.

@blktauna 3 года назад

@@musicandbooklover-p2o Early Period represent! I'm referring my SCA wardrobe as a lot of my clothes are @30 years old >.< I do 11th cent Byzantine and viking as well as late antiquity as I do love Roman as well :)

@musicandbooklover-p2o 3 года назад

@@blktauna started off in my late teens wearing mums unmade outfits from the fifties, when you could buy dresses or skirts as ready cut fabric with sewing instructions and other notions. Loved the maxi dresses of the late 70s, wore them all the time. Wore the salwar kameez (still do in bad weather) after an Indian friend introduced me to the style well into the 90s as standard dress, very practical with a young child while running a small holding and then later attending college. Met the local SCA in 2002 at a country event and two weeks later had made garb for an event in northern Ireland, wool or cotton, corduroy is great for kids as wears and washes well, outfit got passed on to younger kids after she outgrew it. I was mainly Roman with the odd 14thC appearance depending on the event we were attending and for years wore Roman, 1st C, clothing as ordinary daywear. Comfortable and practical especially as I aged. Not so practical when disabled so moved to early mediaeval, and watching priorattire realised I really liked the late Norman gowns, though without the impractical draped sleeves. Then watched Morgan Donner describe her daywear and her own name for it, history bounding. In a way I have been doing just that for nearly fifty years now. However my present anachronism is, or soon will be, regency stays as I hate modern bras (but brutalised versions of mediaeval breastbags have proved surprisingly comfortable once you adapt to the different shape it gives you) and some support is essential. No SCA where we live currently so no longer involved but still wearing the garb as everyday wear. Much more comfortable than modern wear though the salwar kameez is good in wet weather. And suits my inate modesty, not religiously derived. Like Victorian garb, and my daughters niece is into steampunk, but a lot of it is just too fancy and frilly for me. Prefer wearing lightweight wools to fancy silks and taffetas

@blktauna 3 года назад

Karen Blackburn awesome! I started in the sca as a teen in the late 70s. Ive always done early no matter how many people tried to get me into Tudor 😆 clothes were way more comfortable in the past. Im so happy to hear you do early as well

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you! A bustle gown with long sleeved day bodice, under skirt and over-skirt can be around 8-10 yards of silk eek!

@ZacharyDBrooks 3 года назад

"So I think this is the best costume for the day.” - Little Edie

@Cassayowary 3 года назад

"Because i don't like women without stays the best thing is to wear the swan-tail jacket over the stays." Historical RU-vidr Little Edie.

@stephaniew2545 3 года назад

I discovered your channel one morning at 3 am whilst tearing my hair out trying to pleat a skirt l. Not only was the video extremely helpful, but I was delighted to discover your amazing sense of style (and humor!). I’m binge watching my way through your videos and can’t wait to see the projects you make in the historical costuming arena! I look forward to watching your channel grow and I’m thrilled that your Patreon support has allowed you to realize this dream. Thanks for all the AMAZING content ❤️❤️❤️

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you so much! ❤

@francesallshouse7060 3 года назад

Oh man, this struck such a chord. I worked at a small museum for years, loved historic costume, but couldn't progress in museums because I only had a Bachelor's in preservation. Even though I had master's level experience, no one cared unless I had the degree. And, like you, I did some costuming just for fun, but stopped because it's hard to justify the expense when there's no event or reason for it except 'it brings me joy.' Happiness should be enough, right? But my bank account traitorously claimed otherwise.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

It's hard out there in museum land! ❤ Indeed joy should be reason enough! I just think of how much some folks spend on ski trips or sport ball game tickets and figure my hobby should be just as valid right? eek

@tempesttormented 3 года назад

You had me in the first half of the intro, not gonna lie. 😂 I love your sense of humor throughout and I agree that we too often forget that the costume designer doesn't always have the last say in choices. I'm excited for Victorian spooky times! As much as I love vintage I do love me a good Victorian gown. Sew on, friend!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@violetteplague3043 3 года назад

I can’t wait to see you make your dream dress. I’m sure it will come out fantastic.

@wthinwthout2786 3 года назад

I hit play on this so hard that my phone glitched.

@RobinT346 3 года назад

I started costuming for LARP but liked the opportunity to make historic costume since a lot of what I played was in historic settings or heavily inspired by real historic fashion. But even then, when LARP allows you a lot of leeway in the "authenticity" of your costume Iran into some of the same issues you had. I couldn't afford the quality of fabrics needed to make the quality of item I wanted. I also managed to get Lyme Disease and then "post treatment Lyme disease syndrome" which meant I was simply too exhausted and in too much pain to put all that time into "proper" techniques needed to achieve the correct look - not for something that would be worn 4 days a year at most. I tend to play 20th Century and sci-fi games now. much easier on costuming. But I long to make another robe a la anglaise.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

I'm glad other communities are more flexible! I'd love to do some sci-fi costuming in the future!

@LizVChadwick 3 года назад

This is so great. I always feel weird about the costume roasting videos. This was insightful but also totally down to earth. Also my favourite line was “it looks like it’s been taken through a potato” 😂

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Elizabeth!

@Courior6 3 года назад

30:38 as someone that got a bachelors in art I can empathize, especially that bit about trying to get a footing in that field without a masters haha

@infamoussphere7228 3 года назад

*waves sadly* I have a bachelors in visual art and a cert IV in clothing production/fashion design. I work in customer service in a furniture store.

@deniseheringer8972 3 года назад

Bachelors of fine art in painting here, I understand it completely. I’ll never regret the decision to study what I wanted instead of what was practical and in a very roundabout way eventually ended up working in healthcare. The thing that bothers me is how hard it is for many young people now to get in the door anywhere without multiple degrees and debilitating loan debt. I’m just happy that I came from a family full of artists and musicians where it wasn’t discouraged to be a creative person.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

I figure I have enough student loan debt already...I don't want anymore ahhh!

@Ashley-gw7jb 3 года назад

I want to read that email! Ahah! As having worked in film, there are many factors in style decisions, pressure from directors, designers, budget, etc. There is definitely things that I didn’t like going up on camera but you get overruled.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

It was to an old Yahoo address so I unfortunately don't have it anymore so I cant go back and read it either! It was perfectly cordial, but still a large surprise to little blogger me ;)

@serena7261 3 года назад

Honestly even with you pointing out the mistakes, I still think your costumes look amazing. I definitely don't look at the fine details 😅

@janeunion8748 3 года назад

I personally thought the “snow fairy” costume was beyond charming! I admit finding a place to wear it might be a little challenging. Still I love it. Accurate/schmaccute, polyester doesn’t spoil it; it’s just beautiful.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Serena!

@theflapperbassist1361 3 года назад

Looking forward to historical costuming goodness!

@janajune 3 года назад

it’s great to see you address the crew behind decisions made in media. i’m a designer and there’s definitely a place for critique, but so many things can be out of your control as a costumer. historical accuracy is amazing and i dream of working on something with that kind of budget and attention to detail, but sometimes it isn’t the most important way to tell the story. i take most issue with things that perpetuate inaccurate stereotypes (negative corset lacing scenes, etc). it can be confusing to have things from all over a century in a film, but if it’s not set in a specific moment then i give it much more slack.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

I always think of things like how most background costumes are rented, and if another Victorian production already rented most of the stock...and you have to fudge it and use Edwardian...like that does happen! The budget for perfection is just not always there ❤

@sunshinecakes7962 3 года назад

This video is so great! I love the way you speak and explain things and your sense of humor

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you! ❤

@katherinemorelle7115 3 года назад

Firstly, you are way, way too hard on yourself. That last pic with the Victorian underpinnings I was look “I want that! I want that so badly!” And your Swallow-tail jacket was adorable. I think you need to stop beating yourself up for not being able to afford the best fabrics. Also, I’m super excited to go on your back to costuming journey!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@charischannah 3 года назад

So, I watched this while I was hand-sewing eyelets into a polyester shower curtain because the grommets ripped out, and I need to practice my eyelets because I have a stays project slated for this fall. I loved your discussion of the process of learning and trying and figuring out what you wanted to do and how you wanted to do it. And I really loved the orange cotton gown with black petticoat--perfect Halloween.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you! I actually do quite like stay making, will have to try again in the future!

@rc31802 3 года назад

Really love you hair in this video. I know that's not the subject at hand. :) I love how the "ironwork dress turned out. Polyester is your ideal. But it looks amazing

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Rose!

@quixxovel 3 года назад

You deserve so much more recognition, Bianca. You're so hard on yourself but you've created things a lot of us only dream of making. I'm so glad you're able to do things you geniunely love and that bring you joy and that you've chosen to share them with us. 😊

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Jennifer!

@SkySaintdragon 3 года назад

I'm super excited to see your Bustle gown adventures! I have actually made a late 1880s day dress out of cotton and polyester satin/brocade (shh) that I absolutely love. Is it accurate? no. Do I still love it in all of it's eye watering orange glory? yes. I am super excited to see what you can create in silk :) You're work is always so gorgeous so i'm sure this gown will be stunning.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you! I do love orange so that sounds fun to me!

@thebookwyrmslair6757 Год назад

I'm sure the Victorians, at least, would be howling in jealousy if your orange is that bright! Have you SEEN some of their truly technicolor monstrosities?? 😂

@rileyriley8123 3 года назад

The sigh of relief I let out when you said you liked the new Little Women. Since it came out it's felt like historical dress interest and love of that movie had to be hidden away from each other. Like if you said you publicly said you liked one, you must never say you liked the other because "how dare you" and "don't you realize" and "let me explain why this is so bad that the movie is unwatchable".

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

I relate to the story a ton, I too want to be a writer (well, I am one, but I too want to be a published one!) so there is just no way I wouldn't like it really. Plus that shot when Jo is writing with all the candles? Is it realistic? No, is it beautiful? yesss mate. I go to the movies hoping for a great film, if the costumes are spectacular as well that is just a bonus for me ;)

@rileyriley8123 3 года назад

@@TheClosetHistorian Yes! Costumes are a bonus and just add to the list of things to love in a movie rather than a "do not pass go" aspect for me.

@coreygilles847 3 года назад

You give me so much joy! Thank you for making this video

@adrianamancuso4917 3 года назад

I can't wait to see your next projects!! ♥

@odettemichel3563 3 года назад

You've been uploading so frequently lately, you're spoiling us, ty. 😊

@HappyFreakingBitch Год назад

This is really encouraging for someone like me who's starting to question all my previous decisions for costumes that's half done.... And so many of your costumes are gorgeous in their own right for what you could do at the time! I really love this video! Thanks!! 🥰

@chareseshinabery 3 года назад

Omgggg that’s so amazing that you are getting back into costuming! Can’t wait to go on this journey with you!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Charese!

@Mamado88 3 месяца назад

Almost a decade ago now I started a degree in fashion design in my mid 20s, here it’s full time for four years. I did three months of it before I dropped out, it was not what I was expecting at all and not worth ruining my already dodgy back. Here they were training us to be factory workers basically wrapped up in the allusion of fashion designers to make the smallest sizes in modern styles only, they weren’t even going to ever go over plus sizes, grading or “alternative” styling (myself being a 1940s and 50s lover). I found out later on I should’ve headed to a capital city where they offered more artistic courses but now in hindsight it’s best for me that I kept my love of sewing separate from making money, I don’t have the confidence to make things to sell and I feel like I give up a little of me in every project so I only gift things.

@gillianstapleton7741 3 года назад

Thank you for this. It's lovely and human to make mistakes and very endearing to be honest about them. A tiny budget is no crime either (for many years I was a costuming pauper), and I'm often fascinated to see what others do with a thrifty amount of fabric or cash.

@mopsahackett8041 3 года назад

Love these 😊 wish I was a teeny bit as good at making clothes etc as you x

@angelaross1 3 года назад

Although I’m 62 and just started costuming, I too dream of spending copious amounts of money on silk. But, the reality is I’m learning, so combining some hand sewing and machine sewing along with primarily thrifted fabrics is how I have to roll. Although not “accurate” it gives me the feel and as I will probably never attend a function that requires a high level of authenticity, i will just have to be ok with that. Happy sewing and I look forward to your dream bustle dress experience! I know it will be fabulous 💗

@brendabijak7171 3 года назад

I love you just the way you are. Quite possibly you are the chosen one that says absolutely EVERYTHING we are thinking! Thank you for taking one for the team, you are a rockstar in my book! P.S that bow is ....well,,, fugly.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Brenda! ;)

@Jollymadhatter 3 года назад

So excited for you and I’m really looking forward to your historical costuming adventures 😆

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@BluegrassJess 3 года назад

“So thanks mom for the cloak!” 😂🥰 Your hair looks amazing here!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Jessica!

@seriouslyinsanediva 3 года назад

Loved this video. Thanks for letting us into your world and creativity. Yes, it's expensive to follow your passions sometimes but necessary for the survival of the creative muse within.

@Ddouglas0302 3 года назад

This video made my day!!! Your sense of humor is on point today! 🤣🤣🤣

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Denise!

@maggies9271 3 года назад

I love this video! Always love some good roasting content! Also my heart was so happy when you mentioned foundations revealed, they do great work over their!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Maggie!

@TheZombieMe 3 года назад

I'm so excited to see your historical costuming!!!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Cassie!

@monstercockie 3 года назад

"Is it... something that little (what was the name of those things again) children... wear on... Halloween?" Omg, I'm only at the intro, not even 1 min in, and I am loving this video XD

@jojonewuk 3 года назад

EEEEK!!! So excited! I love your tutorials and have also recently purchased the goodies needed to create a bustle gown so will be following your journey closely. And so nice to see your spin on the Roast x

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Jo!

@georgebricker2224 2 года назад

I honestly believe that inside we all have sewing projects that just aren't what we had planned them to be. To have someone verbalize it just makes all of us realize that we are not the only ones is really refreshing. I feel your pain and would like you to know that you are not the only one. Money is not everything but if you have it boy does it make some things easier. To say nothing about being able to get wear out of the things that we make. I am an 1812 reenactor and at least get the opportunity to wear some of my historical clothing. If you can find a venue it is such a rush. Go for it.

@sarahlongshore2605 3 года назад

I love your videos. They are informative and just plain fun to watch. Btw your hair and make up are so pretty today!!! If I were younger I would so love to try to make any Marie Antoinett inspired dress!!! Thank you for all you do to entertain and teach us. And I love your sense of humor!!! Its right up my alley!! Lol.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Sarah! ❤

@RetroMinnie87 3 года назад

I am so excited for this project. This was a fun video. Also, I LOVE your hair and your blouse!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@pierceyourheart4006 3 года назад

This is such a refreshing video! I am so glad to see some acknowledge creative choices and the fact there are actual people behind them. I see so much snobbery from some costumers and historical reenactors if something isn't "accurate" whereas a lot don't seem to realise that it is impossible to make anything truly historically accurate. I have history degrees, I am very much someone who enjoys historical details but does someone taking creative liberties always really matters? no, probably not.

@onesma1729 3 года назад

I'm so excited for this adventure you will be taking us on with you! Cannot wait to see the beautiful gown you will make!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@silvertrees 3 года назад

I enjoyed this so much. You are inspiring and I could listen to you talk for hours. I got a good shiver when you said you will be making the gown!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you! ❤

@simplystandout5878 3 года назад

The beginning of your video is the HOT TAKE I've been been waiting for regarding historical movies and costuming. Love this whole video!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@squareroutevintage7590 3 года назад

Super excited! I love a good costume make/ construction/ historical breakdown vid. Can't wait to see what you come up with!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@hazelgeno 3 года назад

Your humor is wonderful! I loved this video, great job!👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Tamra!

@selkiemorien9006 3 года назад

That video was a great idea and also really, really eyeopening to hear about the reason you stopped doing historic costume in the first place. I've been toeing the line about starting exactly because of cost (and ability let's be real). I feel like retro clothes still want me to learn sewing/get better at it and I can wear it. I won't bat an eye about wearing 40s or 50s style out, I will shy away from doing that in 18th or 19th century clothing for sure. I might even be able to work my courage up to 20s or 10s someday xDDD

@BeverleyButterfly 3 года назад

I loved this so interesting to hear your own mistakes and why you would do different xx

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Beverley!

@sharpduds 3 года назад

The excitement on this end of the RU-vids that you are able to make your dream frock was unfortunately not loud enough to shatter the victorian plate glass I can't afford to replace

@rosikoenig7375 3 года назад

Why does this make me weepy.. lol I am sooo happy for you. Can't wait to follow you on this adventure. :)

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Rosi! ❤

@suewrather6154 3 года назад

Beautiful inside and out! Totally enjoyed seeing your work and listening to you talk

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Sue!

@mrsbellegrave 3 года назад

So excited to see what you create. We love you and your many talents Bianca!!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Alta!

@niccyknickers 3 года назад

This was so good to hear the amazing news at the end!!!! I loved looking back at your own history of costume making. Its not roasting, but great self constructive criticism.

@raquelseydewitz203 3 года назад

So exciting ! I can't wait to see your costuming gown.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Raquel!

@susiecarson 3 года назад

I can’t wait to see your dream gown! I love your channel. By the way, your hair looks gorgeous!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Susie!

@jenniferhof9448 3 года назад

I have to say that I absolutely love your hair in this video! I wish that I could get my hair to take those curls so well. Absolutely stunning!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Jennifer!

@milliev3565 3 года назад

Thanks for this video Bianca, really enjoyed seeing your historic costume attempts and fixes. Also, had no idea you worked/interned in a museum, my dream once upon a time - I am green with envy right now! Looking forward to the bustle dress, good or bad it will definitely be fun!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Millie! I was super lucky to work in a small textile museum during my final year of university and then intern with the Denver Art Museum for a summer after I graduated ❤

@mce1939 3 года назад

Enjoyed the video! I really liked seeing you go through each costume and talk about what you learned from your mistakes.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@fbxn 3 года назад

Looking forward to a looong series of really long videos, including everything from pattern drafting to sewing hooks n eyes 💕

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you! Alas I have gone for Truly Victorian patterns, but they are a dream so I'll be chatting about them lots!

@22mendonca 3 года назад

You crack me up doll! Love this 'having a go at ones self' type of video. You never fail to amuse me Bianca! Xxx

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Jo!

@22mendonca 3 года назад

@@TheClosetHistorian 💋

@soniasilva1139 3 года назад

Love the hair... exquisite! and the pumpkins and the humor :-)

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Sonia!

@angeliccow 3 года назад

I love your refreshing view on historical costume - is it pretty also my number one priority.

@gerileemakes 3 года назад

If I could like this video 10k times, I would! I'm so excited to watch your progress on this new adventure!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Geri!

@kimberlydonohoe3427 3 года назад

I'm halfway through and love this video. I like the bow on the hat ;), and your hairstyle is adorable. Looks quite nice on you! My Grandmother Beatrice wore her hair like that in the 40's and 50's.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Kimberly!

@lucasroofingllc5845 3 года назад

Yay!!!! I can't wait to see the beautiful bustle gown you are going to create!!!! I am glad that you are going to start historic costuming again. So happy for you. Thanks for sharing.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you!

@ilovemydog879 3 года назад

I hace faith in you! All the expensive you now have is gonna come in handy. I really enjoyed having an insight into your thoughts and feelings. It was a very relatable topic. I look forward to seeing your progress unfold (:

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Linda!

@celticgoddess81 3 года назад

YAY! I'm so glad you will have a chance to make your Bustle gown. I adore making costumes. And envy your lovely vintage wardrobe. Can't wait to see what you create! :D

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you! ❤

@tafsf415 3 года назад

You have just inspired me to start a birthday tradition. I will research and handsew one gown from the skin out to wear on my birthday. I make plenty of sloppy dresses with minimal research and time. Making time and effort now Thanks for the inspiration ☺️

@frugalfemmecarole6517 3 года назад

I love when people get to do something they dream about. Can’t wait to watch your journey. 🥰

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Carole!

@makeda6530 3 года назад

The ruffled train on that first dress is indeed quite stunning. Thank you for that image of something so pretty I'd fear to own it.

@josie8581 3 года назад

I'm with you on that hat bow, it took me out of the moment the first time I saw it. But. A bustle gown? I'M SO EXCITED TO SEE YOU MAKE IT!!! I can't wait 😁💙

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Josie! It's still a nope on that bow from me too ;)

@amyjanefrater1447 3 года назад

Gosh, my collection of 'learning exercises' is so plain next to yours. You're brave! And thanks for saying that your criteria is, "Is it pretty?' That's the joy of all this.

@julithewizards1358 3 года назад

I'm looking forward to your silk bustle gown, and I'm happy for you that it's now possible for you! 🤗 💝

@janetkingshott123 3 года назад

Fabulous video by far my favourite chanel. Keep the good work up xx

@rachellynncreates2703 3 года назад

My friend, I cannot wait to come along for your adventure. Your humor and skills are why I click as soon as I can every week! Hugs!!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you RachelLynn!

@robynross255 3 года назад

Wonderful video. I love honesty far more than historical accuracy. I really hope that your new adventure is everything you dream it should be, and I am looking forward to watching it unfold. Thankyou.

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Robyn!

@mimzyriepensell1423 3 года назад

Looking forward to watching you create your dream bustle gown....and would love to see you demonstrate your tambor embroidery skills, I have it on my to do list to learn how....

@MichaelColeman86 2 года назад

You are Amazing. The dress with the Purple Silk Jacket is very similar to a famous painting of a young Martha Washington. I would love to be able to make that gown when my skills get better. Thank you for all your work and videos.

@emmara8461 3 года назад

Omfg I, too, had a Marie Antoinette themed birthday party! I was 15, totally in love with the film, and had spent the whole summer frolicking through France, visiting all the places that had something to do with Marie Antoinette. Good times. Anyway, thanks for the great video!

@TheClosetHistorian 3 года назад

Thank you Emma!