Тёмный
No video :(

Romulan-Vulcan Unification 

Certifiably Ingame
Подписаться 161 тыс.
Просмотров 70 тыс.
50% 1

With the episode of Discovery "Unification" on the horizon and the completion of my Romulan War series, let's take a look at the future of the Romulan Star Empire and Ambassador Spock's efforts to unite Romulus with the Vulcan people once again.
Related Videos:
Romulan War Tactics: • Romulan Tactics of 215...
Battle of Cheron: • The Battle of Cheron (...
Picard Romulans: • Review and Romulan Rel...
Romulan Cultural Index: • ROMULAN: Cultural Index
Romulan Republic: • Formation of the ROMUL...
Music from bensound.com, purple-planet.com and freesfx.co.uk
Star Trek Online developed by Cryptic Studios and Perfect World.
Star Trek, Star Trek Enterprise/Voyager/Deep Space Nine/Discovery/Lower Decks/Picard and The Next Generation are all owned and distributed by CBS.
Star Trek Films are owned and distributed by Paramount Pictures
This Video is for critical purposes with commentary.

Опубликовано:

 

5 сен 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 290   
@TheZapan99
@TheZapan99 3 года назад
-"Captain, the Romulan and the Vulcan are now unified under he same banner!" -"What is the name of their coalition, ensign?" -"The... Vululans, captain." -"Stunning and brave."
@scottmillsap2376
@scottmillsap2376 3 года назад
Wait until the 33rd century when they split between two factions: Vululans and Romcans.
@xheralt
@xheralt 3 года назад
Couldn't they have gone with "Vulcanians"?
@general_prodigy
@general_prodigy 3 года назад
omfg this cracked me up good... XD "the Vululans"
@jamesjameson4284
@jamesjameson4284 3 года назад
Romucan not Romucant
@Delosian
@Delosian 2 года назад
Discovery says they became the Romulo-Vulcans. I personally like Ni'Varians.
@DjRenect
@DjRenect 3 года назад
The fact that the Romulans are so secluded and (generally) closed off to the rest of the galaxy is what makes them so... intriguing.
@shingshongshamalama
@shingshongshamalama 3 года назад
I believe the term you're looking for is "future history."
@cormacmacsuibhne2867
@cormacmacsuibhne2867 3 года назад
Imagine Discoverys shock when they find out Romulans descended from Vulcan.
@amazedsatsuma
@amazedsatsuma 3 года назад
Why imagine we are less than 12 hours from seeing their reaction:P
@gimzod76
@gimzod76 3 года назад
Anyone want to take bets that they'll forget that fact?
@AdmiralJT
@AdmiralJT 3 года назад
@@gimzod76 Do the writters of Disco even know that fact, seem to have slept through most of the canon
@tiggergolah
@tiggergolah 3 года назад
@@gimzod76 Forget what? (Mind wipe.) Maybe Michael goes around flashing everybody and their brains wipe out all associated memories to recover from the trauma.
@smartgoku9048
@smartgoku9048 3 года назад
@@tiggergolah i don't know why but when you said she went around flashing everybody i imagined her flashing her chest gave me a good laugh too imagining their reactions of shock
@antcow1239
@antcow1239 3 года назад
Romulans: Your not allowed to research cloaking tech and you signed this treaty sealing the deal. Federation: (Laughs in Section 31!)
@nicoloferrari1486
@nicoloferrari1486 3 года назад
you're the best ahahaha
@antcow1239
@antcow1239 3 года назад
@@nicoloferrari1486 Thanks :)
@J-CBertrand-tp6bg
@J-CBertrand-tp6bg 3 года назад
‘You’re (as in “you are”) not allowed...’
@fenrisvermundr2516
@fenrisvermundr2516 3 года назад
Me: It only says research. It doesn't say we can't "borrow" it and modify it for our own ships.
@omarqasirov8754
@omarqasirov8754 3 года назад
The Defiant had Romulan provided cloaking tech didn't it?
@dashfatbastard
@dashfatbastard 3 года назад
Aw! Seeing Spock having made it to a ripe old age somewhere between the human and Vulcan norm makes me so happy. I wonder if the Romulans of Ni'var ever recognized that Kirk, by hijacking and scuttling the Enterprise and resurrecting Spock shared responsibily for the Reunification.
@veggiet2009
@veggiet2009 2 года назад
Well they seem pretty receptive of Michael being a citizen of Ni'var and Spock's adoptive sister, so probably yes?
@DocWolph
@DocWolph 3 года назад
The Borg regularly passed through Romulan space to get to the Federation? Helps explain the Romulan's love of Superships. They were pursuing the "big hammer" solution, while Starfleet pursued the "many spears" solution, to the Borg. Many smaller more nimble Starfleet vessels pry open a Borg Cube and a Romulan superheavy battleship dumps hard (I know what I said) into the hole they made to destroy the cube.
@AGTheOSHAViolationsCounter
@AGTheOSHAViolationsCounter 3 года назад
Well it was wonderfully put Doc, curious though what would the Klingon solution be you think? Personally I imagine it'd be a good ole' "Today IS a good day to die" Followed by squadrons of cloaked Birds of Prey kamikazing the cube at maximum warp lol
@AdmiralJT
@AdmiralJT 3 года назад
I laughed harder at "dumps hard" than I should have because you pointed it out.... lol Feel like something along the lines of the Scimitar would fair okay against a cube. Also surprised the Borg didnt assimilate and take use of cloaking tech, maybe just not thought of in writing
@merryc.5466
@merryc.5466 3 года назад
@@AdmiralJT Speculatively, it would go against their intimidation tactics by not creating a tidal wave of fear & hopelessness b4 them.
@AGTheOSHAViolationsCounter
@AGTheOSHAViolationsCounter 3 года назад
@@AdmiralJT Huh actually I never thought of the cloaking device thing before. But yeah holy shit there's a big ass plot hole damn. I mean I'm pretty sure the Borg wouldn't be concerned with something like the Treaty of Algiron once they came across the Romulans lol. But I guess the writers probably thought "Ehhhh nah let's NOT make the borg anymore terrifying than they already are". Although I could also see it explained in the lore as the Romulans(and klingons as well perhaps) have some kind of fail safe system to prevent their cloaking devices from falling into the wrong hands.
@AGTheOSHAViolationsCounter
@AGTheOSHAViolationsCounter 3 года назад
@@merryc.5466 Yeah but what would be MORE terrifying and intimidating than a Borg cube(or fleet of them) suddenly decloaking in orbit of Earth or any other planet without warning. Think about it it would have created an entirely terrifying strategic situation. It would have likely crippled the UFP and every other power as they would have no choice but to abandon exploration and focus almost purely on planetary defense. As various member worlds would scream for the UFP and Starfleet to defend them. Eventually the UFP and Starfleet would have no choice but to triage worlds and I don't see that sitting well for many members. Eventually I would see many worlds leaving the UFP and becoming paranoid, militant to the extreme and isolationist. The borg would just have to send a cloaked cube every once in a while to keep the fear real and the result would be many small isolated powers with minimal co-operation until the main Borg expansion reaches them and then it'd be game over.
@xXKirkSoloXx
@xXKirkSoloXx 3 года назад
It wasn't the Romulan star that went supernova, it was the "Hobus System"
@DeaconBlues117
@DeaconBlues117 3 года назад
@@liamloxley1222 That's headcanon. It all is, really; there are references in PIC to "the Romulan star", but not "the Romulan sun", and there's nothing in even beta canon claiming that Eisn is a binary star system (although it would appear that Romulus and Remus, or ch'Rihan and ch'Havran, are a binary-planet pair). It doesn't make any sense that deploying a portable black hole generator would protect Romulus if its own sun were going nova, however, and making a G-class star or smaller go supernova is almost as weird as a planet being destroyed by another system's sun doing the same thing.
@xheralt
@xheralt 3 года назад
@@DeaconBlues117 Too bad "Rihannsu" is beta canon that is now incompatible with current canon. O Earth and Air, those were the Romulans we should have had! What little development they could have gotten in TNG got swiped for the Cardassians, right down to the Latinate rank structure! So all we are left with as racial traits for them is "xenophobia".
@chrissonofpear1384
@chrissonofpear1384 3 года назад
Eh, broad strokes still allows a lot of Rihannsu lore to work - and I would have thought Una McCormick and others would have used it further.
@DrewLSsix
@DrewLSsix 3 года назад
@@DeaconBlues117 its important to note that despite having a similar plot element they chose not to specifically make the Hobbs incident from the films the same incident that happened in the shows. This is almost certainly because the status of Paramount and its IP concerning the franchise was not quite locked down during production and pre production of Picard. Despite what non expert fans will say CBS did NOT own everything Paramount created in making the 09 and later films. Everything from the physical sets and props to the designs artwork and stories them selves were created by a company and that company owns that IP, it wasn't until the re-merger of the two companies that CBS would have potentially had unfettered access to that IP but even then it boils down to the specifics of the merger as well as the decisions of corporate heads. Is it better to leave the continuities split? Each has a distinct Fandom after all. So its seems that Picard was either in production during talks and they made the show so that this plot point could be modified or scaled appropriately depending on the outcome of the merger, possibly it was to e removed entirely if the merger failed to avoid any possible suits. It's also likely that they decided to keep the connection tenuous as a business decision to preserve their distinct products for future development. Similar to how I imagine Lower Decks fits in, its certainly an offshoot of established canon but I doubt the cartoonist antics and absolute shit ton of plot defying easter eggs are meant to be considered hard canon along side the likes of Picard.
@cmoser22
@cmoser22 3 года назад
i love these kinds of videos. even as someone who knows his Star Trek lore, I enjoy having a little watch party to remember all the relevant content before something [hopefully] big happens like in Discovery.
@jeanphillippes2196
@jeanphillippes2196 3 года назад
After Vulcanization the Romulans could laugh in the face of a flat tire.
@hamzadeen3119
@hamzadeen3119 3 года назад
Has anyone noticed that the nu romulan/vulcan insignia looks like the romulan rapture holding the vulcan emplem as if it was prey
@DeaconBlues117
@DeaconBlues117 3 года назад
The Raptor embracing IDIC.
@nategraham6946
@nategraham6946 3 года назад
One of the most fascinating facets of the unification is what will it be? The Vulcans wanted the Romulans to be like them. On the flip side, the Romulans want the Vulcan to be like them. So, how will it all work out? Will one side yield and sacrifice themselves to become the other, or will they truly live side by side?
@jacobsheehan9715
@jacobsheehan9715 2 года назад
When In doubt find a middle ground
@zerwif
@zerwif 2 года назад
Lots of logical scheming.
@ganados0
@ganados0 2 года назад
and who are the Romulans really descended from? conquerors leaving to conquer or refugees of an oppressive religion sweeping across their planet. I'd say the latter.
@TheBigExclusive
@TheBigExclusive 3 года назад
I still don't understand why the Romulan Star Empire needed the Federations help to evacuate a couple planets. They are the Romulan "Star EMPIRE". They control many numerous planets and solar systems. They have a vast military and economy that rivals the Federation and Klingons. They should be able to evacuate a few planets, and relocate a population with little difficultly. Especially if they knew about the super nova years in advance.
@fedupN
@fedupN 3 года назад
Because Star Trek. It eternally suffers from "FEDERATION WINS!" even when logic and good narrative sense would say otherwise, even when the Federation shouldn't be involved WHATSOEVER.
@jesusmora9379
@jesusmora9379 3 года назад
i guess most if not all are war vessels, with the stupid eagle painted under it. (source: balance of terror)
@L0gical-warri0rs007
@L0gical-warri0rs007 3 года назад
I guess because of politics of the romulan senate.
@litchtheshinigami8936
@litchtheshinigami8936 3 года назад
well it has to do with the way their government handled it just like some governments are handling corona.. they handled it wrong and as the video also mentioned were to busy with other stuff to think about the people.. if you are just another citizen chances are you won't have your own ship..
@carlosalbertoalonso418
@carlosalbertoalonso418 2 года назад
UFP ALSO HELP KLINGONS EVACUATE Q´NOS!!!
@RogueTwo
@RogueTwo 3 года назад
I wouldn't say that it's necessarily "a shame" that it took so long. Looking back at Unification part 2 on TNG (as Discovery itself does) Spock fully acknowledges that it could take years or even centuries to bring the Vulcan and Romulan people together, but is certain that it WILL happen. Spock's dream has been realized, but there was and is still so much to do, even before The Burn. But I'll leave that to your actual review of the episode.
@sugarfrosted2005
@sugarfrosted2005 3 года назад
2:30 I feel like the more reasonable interpretation is that the founding members of the Federation suppressed the information about the Vulcans and Romulans.
@paulmichaelfreedman8334
@paulmichaelfreedman8334 3 года назад
In TNG Spock revealed they had common ancestors, and that the seperatist faction left Vulcan to find a new home planet, which they found in the Romulus system, hence the name. So it has been known for a long time, although it wasn't known until after Discovery jumped to the future.
@DeaconBlues117
@DeaconBlues117 3 года назад
​@@paulmichaelfreedman8334 It was "known for a long time" only by the 32nd Century; Spock learned what Romulans looked like in "Balance of Terror", and hypothesized at the time that they were descendants of those who refused the Reformation (and made certain tactical recommendations based on this hypothesis). Since that had happened thousands of years before, they didn't know whether those who left were real, or a metaphor for certain segments of society that were overcome by the followers of Surak over the centuries. This was not confirmed, however, until "The Enterprise Incident", when the unnamed female Commander mentioned it.
@carlosalbertoalonso418
@carlosalbertoalonso418 2 года назад
VULCANS ARE ASHAMED FOR THEIR "COUSINS"
@gabelogan5877
@gabelogan5877 3 года назад
Why haven’t viewers seen the alien species subjected under the Klingon and Romulan empires in greater detail.
@tichtran664
@tichtran664 3 года назад
For several reasons. Including making the klingons(now these days a FAN FAVORITE) LOOKING "BAD". No offence but honor and dishonor is NOT THE SAME AS GOOD/BENEVOLENCE AND EVIL. Like if a klingon get captured he is dishonored(even if he HAD A KIND HEART). Remember the LIGONIANS?! In that episode of TNG Code of Honor(a episode WHERE WORF WAS NOT ON IT) IT SHOWS THAT HONOR IS NOT THE SAME THING AS GOOD AND EVIL. The antagonist Lutan demanded to know what happened to his ex wife he was jerk but STILL HAVE HIS HONOR. That what that episode was trying to do:SHOW HONOR IS NOT THE SAME AS GOOD AND EVIL. Yet these days that episode is only known for it "RACISM". LOL. YEAH RIGHT.
@tichtran664
@tichtran664 3 года назад
The klingons , to me , WERE NEVER THE GOOD GUYS. Even if they were allies of the federation. They would definitely treat their subject races as JUST BARELY ABOVE SLAVES. And definitely LESS THAN CITIZENS. Look at how the soviet union was once our allies but STILL THE BAD GUYS(IE COMMUNISM, DICTATORSHIP, ETC).
@chrissonofpear1384
@chrissonofpear1384 3 года назад
Kriosians and the Xarantine, most prominently - along with a host of beta canon ones.
@gamervox1707
@gamervox1707 3 года назад
@@tichtran664 what like U.S has not been the mirror of soviet union? Instead of having one dictatorship, we have many.
@Bitchslapper316
@Bitchslapper316 3 года назад
@@gamervox1707 No it's not the same at all. Next time you sit down to eat a bag a cheetos and shit talk a president or government leader on the internet remember you would would have gotten executed or sent to a gulag if you did that in the soviet union.
@MDMetal
@MDMetal 3 года назад
STD edited Spock's dialogue with Picard. I suggest going back and watching Unification Pt. 2 to get the unabridged version. They really dumbed it down for STD.
@cormacmacsuibhne2867
@cormacmacsuibhne2867 3 года назад
Have you been watching Major Grin?
@MDMetal
@MDMetal 3 года назад
@@cormacmacsuibhne2867 Yes, yes I did. I also remember the original dialogue, since I have all 7 seasons on Blu-Ray. EDIT: Let's face it. This is a last ditch effort by Kurtzman to try and get OG Star Trek fans interested in catching a virulent STD.
@cormacmacsuibhne2867
@cormacmacsuibhne2867 3 года назад
@@MDMetal good for you.
@MDMetal
@MDMetal 3 года назад
@@cormacmacsuibhne2867 I'm guessing you actually like NuTrek.
@cormacmacsuibhne2867
@cormacmacsuibhne2867 3 года назад
@@MDMetal it has its moments.
@Bitchslapper316
@Bitchslapper316 3 года назад
Great video friend. I really liked that they did a lot of world building with the Romulans in STP and now in discovery. It was long overdue.
@stevengalloway8052
@stevengalloway8052 3 года назад
Excellent overview of Vulcan-Romulan history concerning the Federation also. Thank you... 👍
@VCYT
@VCYT 3 года назад
'' live long an prosper '' I say.
@conor8492
@conor8492 3 года назад
There's so much I want to learn about "Ni'Var". Like is following the way of Surak optional? Do some Romulans choose to do so? Do they speak both Romulan and Vulcan on the planet or just one of them.
@randyallison3757
@randyallison3757 3 года назад
About fifteen years ago, I saw a video online that purposed an interesting idea about a common history between Vulcans and Romulans. Both races evolved on the same planet, whether that planet was Vulcan, Romulus, or a third planet. In the ancient past, the being that the TOS crew encountered in "Who Mourns for Adonis," along with others of his race, visited the world where the Vulcans and Romulans lived. It is unsure whether this visitation was before or after their visit to Earth. In this theory, Vulcans were the physically strong and telepathic beings that we know. The Romulans were more human like in that they were physically weaker that Vulcans and not telepathic. These Greek gods, for lack of a better name saw that the Vulcans were cruel to the weaker Romulans, this occurring before the Age of Logic . These Greek gods possibly took the Vulcans to the harsh world that became known as Vulcan as a punishment. They, likewise, took the Romulans to a better world that became know as Romulus. Presumably, these beings left the Romulans with the same beliefs that they left on Earth, these beliefs being the legends of the Greek gods that we read of in history.
@carlosalbertoalonso418
@carlosalbertoalonso418 2 года назад
link, Please
@gups4963
@gups4963 3 года назад
Until the events in "a pale moonlight" come out. You really trust Garak to not have that as a card up his sleeve at somepoint.
@navblue20
@navblue20 Год назад
He was involved with those events as much as anyone so what exactly card does he have to pull.
@gups4963
@gups4963 Год назад
@@navblue20 It really depends on what he would think the Cardassians might need. At the very least the info will not die with him
@dashfatbastard
@dashfatbastard 3 года назад
I love that you used a certain film's main theme in this video. I think a summer in equatorial Arrakis or Vulcan would be pretty damned similar ;)
@thomashill6347
@thomashill6347 3 года назад
I enjoy your insightful look at thing, places and Star Trek Canon THANKS FOR SHARING.
@merryc.5466
@merryc.5466 3 года назад
I await w/ baited breath ur dive into the parting of ways betw Vulcans, Romulans, & Remans! (Like #183)
@michaelmacleod6517
@michaelmacleod6517 3 года назад
Hoping STO gets a chance to actually tell the story of how the Vulcans and Romulans reunify. Maybe next year when the failed Year of Klingon happily ends.
@metatron7428
@metatron7428 3 года назад
I don't know the whole Star Trek universe, but I wonder if the United Federation of Planets was not the first galactic power at its peak, before the Burn : Season 3 of Star Trek Discovery reveals that the Federation was made up of about 350 member planets before its fall, not counting the thousands of colonies. In addition, the two great powers of the Beta Quadrant, the Klingon Empire and the Romulan Star Empire, seem to have joined this one : Star Trek Enterprise claimed that the Klingon Empire had joined the Federation before the Battle of Procyon V, and the latest episode of Star Trek Discovery claims the Romulans wanted to stay with the Federation. Also, I think that other powers of the Alpha Quadrant, such as the Ferengi Alliance, could have joined the Federation : the relations of these with the Federation seem, for many, to be similar to those of the powers of the Beta Quadrant before their integration. It makes me think that the Federation was the dominant power in the Alpha and Beta Quadrants and that its immediate neighbors remained negligible by its side. Except the Borg Collective in the Delta Quadrant and the Dominion in the Gamma Quadrant, no power seems to have been able to compete with it, at the time of its peak ... But I would like to know what you think about it.
@taeah6672
@taeah6672 3 года назад
I love getting more lore on them too! I can't wait to see them more in DISCO
@exastrisscientia0
@exastrisscientia0 3 года назад
So thankful for this channel!
@is77gal
@is77gal 3 года назад
Just found a plot hole regarding The Burn....don't the romulan ships use micro singularities to create warp fields? so if they don't use dilithyum doesn't this still make them warp capable? shouldn't they have been the new supreme power?
@samk522
@samk522 3 года назад
Not necessarily. We still don't know exactly what role dilithium plays in the power generation process for warp drives, and we know that romulans have historically had extensive dilithium mining operations. The singularity core in a romulan ship is directly equivalent, not to the dilithium in a Federation warp drive, but to the deuterium/anti-deuterium reaction. It's the power source itself. Dilithium mediates and regulates that power in some fashion, and that's a role that it may also be needed for with romulan singularity drives.
@gimzod76
@gimzod76 3 года назад
Don't forget the breen who ships used some organic process to achieve warp,
@exilestudios9546
@exilestudios9546 3 года назад
@samson pessah ironically we get some information on how romulans create singularities in the kelvin films of all places. apparently they use a substance called redmatter now we have no idea what the fuck this stuff is (thanks a lot jar jar) but that seems to be the source of their singularity tech
@merryc.5466
@merryc.5466 3 года назад
@@exilestudios9546 How *dare* you bring up S.W. in a S.T. thread! Tt the ✋, blasphemer. _huffs off in disgust_ XD
@hamzadeen3119
@hamzadeen3119 3 года назад
Its been intimated that not all romulan ships r powered by singularities The valdore/mogai was supposed to have a regular warp core
@GeneralBulldog54
@GeneralBulldog54 3 года назад
See, I didn't know the events of Trek '09/XI were indeed canon in more recent shows. I was under the idea that it was its own thing closed off to canon despite the inclusion of Spock Prime. This definitely sheds light on the recent Discovery.
@DeaconBlues117
@DeaconBlues117 3 года назад
The '09 and its movies are explicitly in an alternate timeline; only the actions of Prime Spock are part of the main timeline. All of the TOS and TNG movies, on the other hand, are in the main timeline. Even ST5, may the God at the galactic core save us.
@Delosian
@Delosian 3 года назад
I never understood how one Roluman sun going supernova would affect more than one solar system.
@Tempusverum
@Tempusverum 3 года назад
Bcuz Jar Jar Abrams says so
@AdmiralJT
@AdmiralJT 3 года назад
SO if the Romulans dealt with the Borg as well, I would assume that they would have assimilated Romulan tech and information at some point... guess the Borg had no interest in cloaking, would have made getting to Earth alot easier
@merryc.5466
@merryc.5466 3 года назад
Pls see my reply under DocWolph's comment a few min after yours, ty. :)
@MandalorV7
@MandalorV7 3 года назад
I remember a Klingon Borg in Voyager. So the Borg could have gotten the tech from them too. Though the thing is I don’t think the Borg view cloaking tech all that useful. They announce themselves and think their tech is above everyone. Cloaks are useful for ambushes and hit and run attacks. The Borg simply move around the Galaxy stomping anyone that fights back. That is until the Federation.
@merryc.5466
@merryc.5466 3 года назад
@@MandalorV7 EXACTLY!! :D Pls see the entertaining dialogue I had w/ this comment's author on the thread I mention above, ty.
@litchtheshinigami8936
@litchtheshinigami8936 3 года назад
certainly.. in one of the episodes (i believe in voyager) the crew actually meet some freed borg.. one of them is actually Romulan if i remember correctly
@paulmichaelfreedman8334
@paulmichaelfreedman8334 3 года назад
6:00 "ITS A FAAAAAAAKE"
@cormacmacsuibhne2867
@cormacmacsuibhne2867 3 года назад
Trump on news.
@Jayjay-qe6um
@Jayjay-qe6um 3 года назад
Maybe in season 2 of Star trek Picard will know more about the unification.
@DeaconBlues117
@DeaconBlues117 3 года назад
Unlikely, as it hadn't happened yet. Vulcans aren't quick to do much of anything.
@HansWurst-vr3pr
@HansWurst-vr3pr 3 года назад
@@DeaconBlues117 and the Admiral mentioned something about after several centurys since spocks work there
@THEGRUMPTRUCK
@THEGRUMPTRUCK 2 года назад
Nine centuries, and Spock is still relevant in the timeline. Heck, it is what Jean Luc Picard recorded of his time meeting Spock, so without Jean Luc, Spock might've had no mention in discovery at all.
@leftifornian2066
@leftifornian2066 2 года назад
Picard is a robot naw
@Gangerworld
@Gangerworld 3 года назад
I am so glad I found your channel, man. You are so damn entertaining. XD
@USER-jz9mh
@USER-jz9mh 3 года назад
How were the vulcans not aware of the romulans? This make no sense as in season 1 ENT mine field they encountered the romulans; identified the species through the database (it's been 10 years since I watched the eposide my memory isn't the best as it once was). Mabye I'll re watch ENT better then what they are doing too trek these days.
@jesusmora9379
@jesusmora9379 3 года назад
they never met the romulans, they encountered a minefield and then an autonomous cloaked ship. in balance of terror they mention that federation went to war with the romulans but never knew what they looked like.
@simondaniel4028
@simondaniel4028 3 года назад
@@jesusmora9379 TOS is real loose with canon, as it had no idea what it would turn into. It wouldn't surprise me if, through several generations of leadership and power, the Vulcans were able to wipe that connection from most of its people's minds, save for a few number of 'secret-society' scholars. What's more difficult to believe is that Romulans could develop into such a formidable empire between 400AD and Nemesis-era from nothing but a few ships and a few thousand people. But then again, they were already a spacefaring civilization so hey. Maybe they had a bunch of kids to help work those first-gen farms.
@jesusmora9379
@jesusmora9379 3 года назад
@@simondaniel4028 that's not how canon works.
@simondaniel4028
@simondaniel4028 3 года назад
@@jesusmora9379 right, okay. The video says that vulcans and romulans diverged around 400 eithe ad or bc. In either case, from then to now isnt a long time to build an interstellar empire. Even if they did, it still isnt a long time to develop major genetic differences. Even if it was, I'm postulating how did the vulcans not spill the secret to the federation during the earth romulan war or any time thereafter. Theres no way. Also canon no longer matters in Trek, given JJ / Kurtz era treatment. If you gonna a get upset about canon then you better ditch Star Trek for Babylon 5.
@USER-jz9mh
@USER-jz9mh 3 года назад
@@jesusmora9379 who was Hoshi speaking romulan too then?
@systemus
@systemus 3 года назад
Can somebody tell me if the new Romulan/Vulcan star trek discovery future are Romulan/Vulcans using singularity warp cores to travel across galaxy ? Because now in new Discovery series is federation broken without dilithium but the romulans were not using dilithium .
@magodeluna
@magodeluna 3 года назад
who knows? the problem is after the supernova and the civil war, maybe their knowledge about this kind of travel could be lost.
@anonymoose9315
@anonymoose9315 3 года назад
Remember that Discovery writers know very little of Star Trek canon. This probably won't come up.
@systemus
@systemus 3 года назад
@@magodeluna well star trek picard is also after supernova and romulans are still same. i dont think this is the problem
@systemus
@systemus 3 года назад
@@anonymoose9315 Oh..... how can somebody create another cannon without of knowledge of previous canon series.....
@Netseer2000
@Netseer2000 3 года назад
@@systemus Lazy writers who do not want to do their homework and don't respect the source materials. It is a problem with many franchises that has increase over time. I've seen fan-made ST videos better written than actual current series.
@roy1701d
@roy1701d 3 года назад
The Klingons sued for peace. The Borg were neutralized. The Dominion was stopped. The Romulans reunified with Vulcan. The Orions are too fractious to be much of a threat. So...who are the bad guys now? 🖖
@navarog378
@navarog378 3 года назад
The Federation of Planets always had something of the borg at their core.
@pphyjynx8217
@pphyjynx8217 3 года назад
@@navarog378 that's why the borg were created, they're the dark side of the federation
@bradknightable
@bradknightable 3 года назад
The temporal cold war.
@jesusmora9379
@jesusmora9379 3 года назад
section 31 of course. it is logical. i'm pretty sure the starfleet dude is a good guy, but there are agents keeping secrets and manipulating everything and are the ones responsible for the burn.
@mitchellpeterson7943
@mitchellpeterson7943 3 года назад
There is something that has always confused me about the Vulcan/Romulan backstory: Vulcans are always depicted as being so overcome with emotions that, without suppressing them, they are overcome by aggression and violence, nigh uncontrollable. Now the romulans rejected these teachings, so why aren't they showing the same characteristics? They're warlike, sure, but they are not giving the Klingons a run for their money or anything. Did their species diverge enough genetically to breed out the aggression?
@CertifiablyIngame
@CertifiablyIngame 3 года назад
I did a theory video on just this! I think the Vulcan suppression exacerbated their aggression as they have no idea how to handle it. Left to play out normally, you just get the Romulan style paranoia.
@ladythalia227
@ladythalia227 2 года назад
Considering the head ridges and the fact that we learn that Vulcans and Romulans aren’t always genetically similar (references in a season 6-7 episode on DS9 I think) one could speculate that Vulcans were originally made up of different hominid species. Think an earth where Neanderthals, Denisovans and Homo Sapiens live side by side. They would share many traits but one subspecies could potentially struggle more with their anger while the other subspecies is able to route that anger into more cool headed paranoia instead.
@carlosalbertoalonso418
@carlosalbertoalonso418 2 года назад
THIS SIDE OF PARADISE
@Lukos0036
@Lukos0036 3 года назад
No idea why Romulans would be affected by the burn. They don't need dilithium for their warp cores.
@thewanderer9741
@thewanderer9741 3 года назад
true Singularity Cores use a contained Quantum Singularity i.e. Black Hole as a means of power generation and wouldn't be affected by this "Burn" however not all ships use this most older vessels & some shuttle craft still use Dilithium so it would be debilitating but not outright crippling to the Romulan's
@goktimusprime
@goktimusprime 3 года назад
[SPOILER AHEAD] Affected? The Romulans and Vulcans CAUSED the burn.
@GeneralBulldog54
@GeneralBulldog54 3 года назад
@@goktimusprime Not necessarily, I don't think. They were assumed guilty of the burn by the DSP but ultimately with proof showing they weren't they're covertly mending the frayed fence through Discovery.
@jesusmora9379
@jesusmora9379 3 года назад
@@GeneralBulldog54 federation is kinda sus
@litchtheshinigami8936
@litchtheshinigami8936 3 года назад
@@goktimusprime i don't think so... they said they were almost positive they caused it.. however as micheal said in the episode the evidence she has found means there is one singular origin point.. where as the vulcans stated that it came from their tests with a new way of travel wich was a net that spanned a ton of space.. however if you think about it it's not logical that if it's a single point of origin that the burn was caused by their net as that would have had the burn come from all kinds of places.. no i have a feeling it's something else that happened there.. maybe even a federation test gone wrong.. maybe they had a new type of ship that due to the way it handled it's dilithium ended up destabilizing it exploding and causing a shockwave effect that swept trough the galaxy and also destabilized countless other ships.. or perhaps one ship encountered something during exploration that caused it.. some ancient tech on a planet that let out a shockwave that caused the burn.. on top of that with the way the new way of traveling the vulcans were designing you did not need dilithium to go to warp as from what i got from them was that they were similar to a stabilized wormhole that simply brings the ship from one to the other.. kind of like how the borg also were shown to travel at the end of voyager. it wouldn't need to affect the dilithium in any way thus it makes no sense for that tech to have caused the burn
@jarodforbes1207
@jarodforbes1207 3 года назад
Its more likely that the Romulans become part of the Federation and after the burn they decide (or some of them) to keep this Unification working after the "end" of the Federation. But we will see what the writers are thinking ;)
@nagash303
@nagash303 3 года назад
So when the Romulans join the Federtion, the next villain is right there: The Hitogen.
@cmdrtianyilin8107
@cmdrtianyilin8107 3 года назад
Great video. Also, can you give us your build spec of your Odyssey Class of Admiral Mark Hale character from your story series? I'm very interested how did you build your awesome Odyssey Class.
@jannegrey593
@jannegrey593 3 года назад
I second that
@DissociatedWomenIncorporated
@DissociatedWomenIncorporated 3 года назад
I have a feeling you're going to love Unification, Part III. I give it 9 🖖s out of 10. A fitting expansion of Unification into a trilogy that only the most hardened New Trek hating extremists (who, let's be honest, are mostly just Obsidian Order paid bot accounts) would dislike. Though it may wind them up that Michael Burnham being Spock's sister is such a big plot element. I'm deducting a 🖖, however, because I find it illogical that in the future everyone's transporter effect looks the same despite the technological diversity of differing, semi isolated civilisations, I mean they could have at least coloured it green. Then again I'm not a huge fan of these rapid transporter effects since Picard... the transporter effect is cool, see _Star Trek IV: The Wrath of Greenpeace_ for proof... it needs to be savoured, appreciated, like a fine Château Picard Merlot. And fine, it becoming somewhat quicker in the future makes sense but even if it's quick it needs some more flair and style, Picard's effect looked like stepping through a boring grey/white waterfall and Discovery's effect looks and sounds like... a decent spawning effect for a hypothetical Quake 5, but it's a poor substitute for the greatness of older transporters. You know what the problem is? Most of those great old transporter effects used an effects layer of glitter being dropped into water. I'm pretty sure the TOS effect was nothing but. The classic movies, I'm not sure if they used glitter but they had prominent, slow fading sparkles, and they started adding cool vertical lines (let's pretend that childhood trauma inducing transporter scene of the first movie didn't happen). By the time of _Star Trek IV: The Search for George and Gracie_ and _Star Trek VI: ⚡Flash Gorkon⚡_ it was an art form that TNG expanded on gracefully. These new effects are all digital and that's fine, but they need an Adobe plugin that simulates someone dropping glitter into water! Come on CBS, make it happen! And while I'm demanding things from CBS, bring back Babylon 5!
@Delosian
@Delosian 3 года назад
Were the Romulans exiled, or did they leave willingly?
@litchtheshinigami8936
@litchtheshinigami8936 3 года назад
they left willingly.. when the vulcans converted to logic the ones to become the romulans didn't want anything to do with their ways so they left..
@EdiaStanfordBruce
@EdiaStanfordBruce 2 года назад
I think some were maybe forced off and left to avoid persecution. We've got to look at how after the Surak movement was dominant how the minority clinging to the old order were regarded and treated in society. Episodes in TNG hinted at that in "The Artifact".
@Timberwolf69
@Timberwolf69 3 года назад
All I know about the time of the sundering are some tidbits that were issued by the STO staff in the forefront of the introduction of the Romulans in STO, quite some years ago.
@DeaconBlues117
@DeaconBlues117 3 года назад
I recommend the novels of Diane Duane, particularly "Spock's World" and the Rihannsu series. They're not strictly "canon", but the writers don't seem to mind, er, borrowing from them from time to time.
@Timberwolf69
@Timberwolf69 3 года назад
@@DeaconBlues117 Well, there are still quite a few out there that don't consider STO being "canon", either... It is quite common that writers of a tv show take some inspiration from other media and vice versa.
@DeaconBlues117
@DeaconBlues117 3 года назад
@@Timberwolf69 Yes, STO is also beta canon. Its history gets adjusted from time to time, which can be justified by the way the Temporal Wars are raging through the 25th century.
@JMaxwellE
@JMaxwellE 3 года назад
Please please please do a Lower Decks review!
@jeffa7292
@jeffa7292 3 года назад
Rick,please do a video about the transporters & holograms in star trek,please do a video about jabba the jury's slaves & the slaves costumes in star wars,please do a video about how people in star trek & star wars universe get married &divorce
@Knightfall182
@Knightfall182 3 года назад
Don't get too attached to this 'Canon' after STD's upcoming Guardian of Forever 2parter.
@xheralt
@xheralt 3 года назад
Nobody watching Disco is attached to canon; the showrunners sure aren't...
@Brando501st
@Brando501st 3 года назад
Loved this video!
@DocWolph
@DocWolph 3 года назад
One would cry for the Romulans, if we knew more about them and felt better for them. Alas, rarely a more belligerently secretive species has ever been known. The Breen are worse but the Romulans had the ability to make it actually hurt.
@mrbojangles8133
@mrbojangles8133 3 года назад
the Romulan intention unification or corruption, perhaps both
@BNuts
@BNuts 3 года назад
I still don't know what the Romulan Free State does. For the moment, I prefer the story that Cryptic wrote for the rise of the Romulan Republic -- the only political power from that species to seek a new homeworld. Involving legacy characters like Sela was also a smart move.
@CertifiablyIngame
@CertifiablyIngame 3 года назад
I think the Free State wants to remove itself from UFP territory to go at it alone, but can't because they lack the resources. This is speculation though based on Picard.
@BNuts
@BNuts 3 года назад
@@CertifiablyIngame So the Free State had fallen _into_ UFP territory previously? The Romulans were always independents before. But I guess this is what we get when the Star Empire falls early.
@cmdrtianyilin8107
@cmdrtianyilin8107 3 года назад
Take Free State as Virinat colony one. Wants to be left alone, yet when gets screwed by the Tal Shia, comes back to the Federation and Klingon again.
@BNuts
@BNuts 3 года назад
@@cmdrtianyilin8107 Well, Virinat ended up pretty much sacked, with only a few survivors thanks to the intervention of a couple Romulan Republic ships. So I don't know who's available to help the Free State in the _STP_ scenario.
@cmdrtianyilin8107
@cmdrtianyilin8107 3 года назад
@@BNuts synths. The true master species. No, in all seriousness UFP being non interventionist, I think help will come from an unlikely place. See, the Klingons take Romulan government (Star Empire) as enemy, so, I think if Klingons could help the Free State, that would mean they'll gain some Romulan technology and Star Empire loses another influence. I think, in Galactic policy wise, it's better to go fully Synthetic with genetic engineering, so that you'll never loose loyalty and synthetic means everyone will work without hassles and isolated means nobody will bother you anymore.
@Sh_rib
@Sh_rib 3 года назад
Not the first.... and not a person will care either lol 🤣🤣🤣
@HansWurst-vr3pr
@HansWurst-vr3pr 3 года назад
Didnt the crew get a training to fit into the 32nd century, you would think something about member worlds and history especially about one of the greatest enemys, would include that
@litchtheshinigami8936
@litchtheshinigami8936 3 года назад
might have been a more practical training regarding how to use the new tech than any info on other planets.. at least that's the vibe i got from this training
@jengoh3826
@jengoh3826 3 года назад
Love the geopolitical (or should I say galacpolitical) dimension of Star Trek. Star Trek as a genre should branch out into geopolitics, espionage, and commerce, and galactic affairs (meaning international affairs). Many interesting stories can be written about this.
@ranosian1135
@ranosian1135 3 года назад
What happened to the Remans when the star exploded?
@DeaconBlues117
@DeaconBlues117 3 года назад
Same thing as the Romulans, one would imagine. It was a binary planet.
@carlosalbertoalonso418
@carlosalbertoalonso418 2 года назад
@@DeaconBlues117 NOT "binary planet", LIKE: VENUS-EARTH-MARS
@raenfox
@raenfox 6 месяцев назад
So, in canon, it wasn't the Hobus star that went supernova and sent a shockwave through subspace that destroyed the Romulus system, but the star of the Romulus system itself?
@makeracistsafraidagain
@makeracistsafraidagain 3 года назад
I'm really enjoying Discovery.
@adamofgrayskull7735
@adamofgrayskull7735 3 года назад
Damn you Rick TNG just started on horror ch
@Corbomite_Meatballs
@Corbomite_Meatballs 3 года назад
It's been running non-stop on BBCA this week, between DS9 and Voy. And you can always see it most nights of the week on H&I.
@adamofgrayskull7735
@adamofgrayskull7735 3 года назад
@@Corbomite_Meatballs not in the UK
@HartWilke
@HartWilke 3 года назад
So, what about the Remans?
@BuildaMan
@BuildaMan 3 года назад
the romulan government near the hobus disaster sounds alot like the USA.
@ivanflores-ramirez8105
@ivanflores-ramirez8105 3 года назад
Wait wait wait didn't they say that reunited before the burn not after the burn
@litchtheshinigami8936
@litchtheshinigami8936 3 года назад
yep..
@gabelogan5877
@gabelogan5877 3 года назад
I have a question I need help with: How did the Romulans lose their telepathic powers and is the Remans an offshoot species or were they the indigenous population of the Romulus home world.
@avalentova
@avalentova 3 года назад
Hi, it was never stated how Remans came to be memory-alpha.fandom.com/wiki/Reman. Look for background info part on this page.
@batguy7893
@batguy7893 2 года назад
the space elves must unite
@vservo1149
@vservo1149 3 года назад
If they were cool since it's in the future it would be unification part iv. A new hope
@merryc.5466
@merryc.5466 3 года назад
The reason ur comment is being shunned is bc uv blasphemed S.T. by daring to mention S. W. ;)
@Morristown337
@Morristown337 3 года назад
I think in Discovery that the Romulans may be a super power, Their D'Deridex class ships have been using the warp 6 Singularity Core Drives that don't require dilithium for centuries TNG Timescape episode 18 minutes in for source.
@robertotamesis1783
@robertotamesis1783 3 года назад
Trying telling that to Apaches to the Navajos.
@maybetoby
@maybetoby Год назад
What's the source for that image of an older John Harriman?
@douglasdean3785
@douglasdean3785 3 года назад
Where did you get the new 32nd century reunification emblem image from?
@CertifiablyIngame
@CertifiablyIngame 3 года назад
Made it based on what I could see in the trailer.
@curtislangford3181
@curtislangford3181 3 года назад
PROTO-VULCANS!
@ThatSolidworksGuyVC
@ThatSolidworksGuyVC 3 года назад
Wait, so both Free state AND Republic co-existed?
@kevenmitchell2562
@kevenmitchell2562 Год назад
Did the Remans survive the exploding sun from Romulus
@dandixon8080
@dandixon8080 3 года назад
"Vulcan Text"
@hellspidey
@hellspidey 3 года назад
Good theroy
@demo3456
@demo3456 2 года назад
How can any race with replication Tech ever go through hard times?
@leftifornian2066
@leftifornian2066 2 года назад
Bored writers
@Slayerthegreat010
@Slayerthegreat010 2 года назад
I don't see how anyone can think that any show after DS9 can be considered cannon. I would take the lore of ST online before abominations like STD or pukehard.
@Kyrieru
@Kyrieru 3 года назад
Every time I see a screenshot of that recent cartoon my brain just does it's best to block it out.
@nicktampoy2305
@nicktampoy2305 3 года назад
What about Remans? They are descended from Vulcans as well.
@carlosalbertoalonso418
@carlosalbertoalonso418 2 года назад
¡NO!
@KarlLlewellyn-yb3ys
@KarlLlewellyn-yb3ys 6 месяцев назад
Star Fleet and the Federation has a bad tendency to make bad deals to buy peace. As far as the treaty stoping the Federation from developing clocking technology. Well let’s just say I would have told them to “Get bent”.
@daron6616
@daron6616 3 года назад
“Reunification”
@briscoejr1
@briscoejr1 3 года назад
Just saw the new ep... Excellent, excellent episode.... You are not going to believe who appears to assist Michael Burnham...
@mischahosten4300
@mischahosten4300 3 года назад
What about the mintakins
@limondorn1494
@limondorn1494 3 года назад
Well you are a point point wrong the Romans and the Vulcans United in for the Federation time
@Tia-Marie
@Tia-Marie 3 года назад
Unification was never an option, the ship clans can't go back to all that silliness. The way of D'era is the only way. I have The Way of D'era ST:TNG Romulan Star Empire tabletop companion guide, the story about the ship clans is kinda fun.
@samdog8087
@samdog8087 3 года назад
Kirk was the 1st to see a Romulan
@litchtheshinigami8936
@litchtheshinigami8936 3 года назад
face to face yes.. however in enterprise the crew does encounter a romulan ship.. and technically one of the senators on vulcan is actually a romulan that acts like he's a vulcan so technically that's the crew that saw them first.. even though they might not have known at the time..
@daveyb454
@daveyb454 3 года назад
The federation didn't have anything to do with the pale moon light. That was all sisko and garak
@codyscott3673
@codyscott3673 3 года назад
Wow I'm so early
@jasonulysess3652
@jasonulysess3652 3 года назад
Hello RU-vid algorithm. Let us all worship the algorithm.
@merryc.5466
@merryc.5466 3 года назад
Too close to aspects of 1984 by George Orwell to be funny. 0_0
@jozebutinar44
@jozebutinar44 2 года назад
Well they nead 1500 years to rebuild and travel to stars humans only 10 years
@jeffd8465
@jeffd8465 2 года назад
I just can't accept disc and Picard as prime timeline.
@leftifornian2066
@leftifornian2066 2 года назад
It’s fan fiction
@airesalpha
@airesalpha 3 года назад
Hobus Is not the star of the romulus system. Hobus a star 500 light years away from Romulus. The pre movie book "the path to 2409" mentions that the supernova somehow accelerated through subspace to high warp speeds. In Star Trek Online this acceleration of shockwave and the supernova itself is shown to be retribution from the Iconians for Empress Sela's actions in the past.
@CertifiablyIngame
@CertifiablyIngame 3 года назад
Hobus system in STO, Romulan Sun in Picard.
@airesalpha
@airesalpha 3 года назад
@@CertifiablyIngame if that's true it makes the science sooooooooooo much worse
@Daron7181
@Daron7181 Год назад
Re-Unification
@user-roninwolf1981
@user-roninwolf1981 3 года назад
Is "Certifiably Ingame" the same guy as Shadiversity?
@marvinhuth4487
@marvinhuth4487 3 года назад
different person,. same guy.
@cmdrtianyilin8107
@cmdrtianyilin8107 3 года назад
MACHICOLATIONS!!!!!!
@tyreecebaker6600
@tyreecebaker6600 3 года назад
👍
@Corbomite_Meatballs
@Corbomite_Meatballs 3 года назад
Personally, I think the PIC version is a pile of nonsense, and I like the STO storyline, branching off from the '09 Trek reboot movie. (The entire "warp speed supernova" stuff makes sense in STO.)
@jannegrey593
@jannegrey593 3 года назад
Still prefer STO. This "canon" is ridiculous. When a game actually makes better story than triple A TV shows.
@samk522
@samk522 3 года назад
Well, Discovery seems to be canon to STO, but Picard isn't.
@jannegrey593
@jannegrey593 3 года назад
@@samk522 Yeah. I do realize that some people like to be edgy etc. But to me the plot of Federation just stopping existing "because dilithium" for Centuries, is the stupid way of saying - we're tired of making good Star Trek, so we're going to wreck it. I know that challenging the Status Quo is what you often do with the story if it gets stale. However in Picard we just had Hobus supernova - we don't need more tension and problems. Star Trek was always promising a better future, while also delivering a lot of action etc. - often to ridiculous degrees. But you always had the chance of stuff returning to normal - and having another show about exploration/other stuff - and yeah it would probably be boring like first 2 seasons of ENT, but it was always an option (besides I do like seasons 1&2 of ENT, despite their many flaws). And now it has been taken from us. Unless the Discovery fixes it somehow. But I've given up after watching Season 1. Would have to catch up and see if it is better and tries to have actual continuity between the series. Because STO tries as hard as possible to have that continuity. And while it suffers because of that sometimes, overall it is big positive of the game. Couldn't they just make the series in alternate timeline or something like that? Give us some hope that we will see something that can be canon, but isn't cool just because it tosses continuity out of the window?
@MrRavenBlackwing
@MrRavenBlackwing 3 года назад
@@samk522 That's because the Dev Team is working on how to incorporate that into the game and redo the back story to fit. Al made it clear that anything in Picard regarding that over rides and becomes canon in the game. They've already started with the Utopia Planitia TFO.
@avalentova
@avalentova 3 года назад
@@MrRavenBlackwing I am dreading this. STO story line and lore is great as it is. They should stop with this re-adjusting every time new TV series comes out.
@avalentova
@avalentova 3 года назад
For me STO is more canon then the new TV/streaming series. :) It was there with its story when there was no new Trek in TV. I always dream about the possibility that STO story could be made into TV series, but alas...
Далее
VULCAN: Cultural Index 2.0
16:09
Просмотров 146 тыс.
Klingon's View of the Early UFP
11:31
Просмотров 208 тыс.
Cute kitty gadget 💛💕
00:23
Просмотров 4 млн
VULCAN (Why is it called that?)
11:14
Просмотров 81 тыс.
The Mystery of the Romulan Free State
7:45
Просмотров 57 тыс.
REMAN: Cultural Index
10:53
Просмотров 143 тыс.
Vulcan's Influence on Starfleet: Early Federation
9:16
Species Who Lost their Homeworlds (Star Trek)
8:20
Просмотров 183 тыс.
First Contact... From The Vulcan Perspective
15:39
Просмотров 49 тыс.
Types of Cloaking (Star Trek)
12:33
Просмотров 157 тыс.
CAITIAN: Cultural Index
10:07
Просмотров 149 тыс.
What Are the Romulans' TRUE Origins...?
17:06
Просмотров 191 тыс.