Licensed since 1985...Without question the best composition shingle was Celotex “Ambassador.” They we’re made from about 1997-2000 then It was reconfigured by CertainTeed, it was still good but nowhere near as good as Ambassador. I’ve been on many old Ambassador roofs & they’re showing “No” sign of wear...
Us has a lot of cheap minded people, when the contractor doesn't even know they are using mid to low grade materials, and call it top of the line, a lot of ignorance happens..people are fine with a 20 yr roof
Asphalt roofing is the waste child of the petroleum industry. It’s cheap so that many people buy the waste off petroleum conglomerates hands. By doing so they don’t have to manage it anymore, it becomes the owners responsibility and they make extra money from it. Win win win for them. As for other materials it’s often more climate viable then clay. You won’t find any clay roofs in Canada because of the heavy snow and it’s removal. According to me clay and metal are the winners. Clay is very durable in temperate to tropical weather and is inert and reusable. Metal is also very durable and is better suited for temperate to cold climates and is recyclable.
I love how the complaints here are "some American roofing materials are very affordable" and "asphalt shingles repurpose industrial waste that would otherwise just go in a tailings pond"... which to me both sound like good things but what do I know. 😂 When it comes to America, people can complain about anything I guess.
The reason fire rating is so much more important in a roof than in siding is that a lot of homes burn down from hot embers being blown onto the roof from a nearby fire.
The good thing is at the end of the day they all work! Seems like metal might be more worth it in the end anyway. They are very close in effectiveness so paying that extra for a minor difference in performance seems pointless. I agree with your choice of metal over rubber for sure, and I hope it lasts you a long time!
I will install all all systems if the money is there. I manufacture all of the Metal Systems we install, Using the highest quality Steel Coil from companies like Shedfield Meadows and Drexel Metals. These are all kind of 500 finishes. The big box stores only carry Chinese painted polyester process which tends to peel and fade. Wind on a standing seam roof is going to do differently than a 36 inch agricultural panel with exposed screws. This is because the standing seam roof is hooked everywhere the valleys, ridge it’s hooked to the drip edge. Not being ripped off in a hurricane. I think it is a 130 mph wind uplift that you get with a standing seam roof. Most Spanish tile roofs or Clay only provide about a 60% waterproof system the underlayment is what actually protects the house from leaking. slate is different it’s not much different in a asphalt shingle being nailed on a 6 inch pattern in some cases there isn’t even felt on some of these jobs.
I’m so glad to find your channel, shopping for roof full replacement and your video gives an insight what’s good or not. So many scammers in Florida and being cautious is not enough, I usually research what reputations of this different companies. Thanks again, have a nice day and God bless!
I'm watching this three years to the day after Panama City Florida was hit by Hurricane Michael. I was in Panama City at the time and my in-laws shingles did okay holding up with up to 100 mile per hour winds. There were still shingles attached to the 10 x 10 section of the roof that ripped off the house and flew 20 ft away...
Absolutely great information. I am in the market for a new roof and I live in upstate New York, and they came up with a presentation telling me all kinds of things. I’m sure to confuse me. I thought I was going to go with him but after watching this video. Still I have to do mor research but at least now I am very prepared to make a concrete decision. Thank you.
Thanks for sharing. I wouldn't put an asphalt roof on my doghouse...they are disposable throw away roofs. Their ratings and prorated guarantees are not worth the shingle wrapper that they are written on. If you want to see the reality of comp roofs just go to the local landfill where they dump it and see the mountains of senseless waste. I've heard that the rubber roofs made from new material are better than the ones made from recycled material. Many people put on rubber in neighborhoods where that sort of roof look is required. Metal roofs can be pressure washed primed and repainted after they start looking faded or chalky.
Thanks for the nice overview of different roofing types. Sadly, you decided not to cover my two favorites, copper and slate. I realize those are niche markets though and I will probably never own a home with either type. I'm not that familiar with rubber roofing, so your information was new to me and a little surprising. I know in other applications rubber is susceptible to dry rot and aging in direct sunlight. In fact prior to this video, I had only heard of rubber being used as a water barrier under living roofs where it is covered with soil and plant matter that protects it from degradation in sunlight. I am definitely curious now and will try to learn more of its use as a primary roofing material.
Thank you very much as your tutorial is very educational. I live in the Northwest, have a cedar shake roof and have been looking at roofing products and I now am leaning towards rubber then metal due to your video.
I like to see these options... i am from Czechia, most of roofs are still eternite ! some villages have it on 70% of roofs... and most of them already behind lifespent.. i didnt look roofs when i travel to work but right now i am in process buying new house so i scan all buildings to see best option and damn i love to see changes so many tipes of roofs and solutions :)) i think every type of roof have something good, otherwise no one buy them .) .. But i really like to see healthy solutions.. Becouse old time trend in eternite was worst solution, unhealthy carcinogenic material.. Roof safe life double times :) ..
that should be a big sellling point to put on a rubber roof and sell the fact they wont have to replace a roof for a long long time, hence charge more for your house.
Dmitry! Your absolutely correct about metal it's great product for roofing. However, we feel metal is more of a rural area look to your home. Atleast in our market. It stand out like a sore thumb unless you live in rural area. The rubber seems pointless in our mild market to even consider. But great insight as usual to the products. Keep the videos coming!!
Here in california it stands out because not many can agford it, the houses you do see with metal are usually custom designer homes, roof is expensive but then again so is the whole house lol
How is rubber better if most pipeboots made out of rubber they are done in under 10yrs isn't rubber more prone to sun damage? Also when you Say Rubber roofing you are talking about a product like DaVinci or Ecostar Right? and not a Rubberized SBS Shingle? How would a rubberized shingle would be better that a regular Asphalt shingle? ok this is a question within a question.
Dmitry, doesn't a true rubber product (like EuroShield) have different performance parameters (wind and impact resistance, durability, lifespan, etc.) from composite/thermo-plastic products like F-Wave and DaVinci? Is it really an "apples to apples" comparison having them in the same category? Do you have any thoughts on how EuroShield rubber shingles compare to F-Wave thermoplastic shingles, and how F-Wave compares to DaVinci?
The Clay roofing you refer to will most likely be imitation clay in most cases. These tiles are pigmented concrete and do not provide waterproofing. The waterproofing of these systems are relying on the underlayment. A genuine Clay roof is very rare and also is an imported product from Europe. Clay tile roofing is the best. Concrete tiles roofing is only slightly better than a good shingle system.
The amount of repairs we do on cement tile is ridiculous, constantly cleaning valleys and areas where debris piles up, having to refelt sections or whole roof, bad flahings. For the price i cant wrap my head around why someone would want tile
@@CDCK006 Its an architectural feature choice. People believe that the tile roof systems of America are the same as in Spain.... People arent educated on the fact that the American version is just a facade. While the European version is actually a really great roof. Due to the fact that they are applying kiln-dried clay tiles. Compared to the pigmented concrete non-waterproof tile that is applied in America which really relies on the underlayment qualities to provide the waterproofing.... Most people are fooled by the facade on all levels of modern building practices.
Should you replace all fascia and flashing in a 22 year old roof?? I’m considering Timberline HDZ!! Do they have Timberline shingle that’s better for heat to reflect the sun or is HDZ sufficient?? Are their better roofing shingles comparable price to HDZ!!! I have 1700 sq.ft. roof and Company gave me estimate of $6,800 but if I wanted them to replace all fascia and Flashing how much more would that escalate the price!! Great videos I’m a subscriber!! Thank You 👍
@@RoofingInsights3.0 Most of the people that kill exposed fasteners only sell standing seam. I like the look of both depending on the house but the price difference is huge. Looking forward to your video.
It matters for some markets, for most it doesnt. The way we build our homes roofing fire rating is no longer critical performance. It matters but it overrated.
Great video. Could you please tell me what brand those flexible rubber shingles are that you're holding in the video? I've seen a couple samples, and they were rigid. I'd like a flexible rubber shingle.
I am looking to replace the roof on my summer home in Serbia where I plan to move to. I am leaning toward metal roof, but am only worried about it being too loud inside during the rainy days. Any advice on that?
Hey Dmitry , thanks for the great video, what is your opinion on rubber shingles in a market that has a 70 degree variance between seasons (Edmonton Alberta Canada). Do you have any recommendations for an installer for my area?
Standing seam is the only way, it’s the most expensive metal roofing option but it allows mechanical fasteners to be installed without drilling holes through your metal roof, good luck
Asphalt roofing is the waste child of the petroleum industry. It’s cheap so that many people buy the waste off petroleum conglomerates hands. By doing so they don’t have to manage it anymore, it becomes the owners responsibility and they make extra money from it. Win win win for them. As for other materials it’s often more climate viable then clay. You won’t find any clay roofs in Canada because of the heavy snow and it’s removal. According to me clay and metal are the winners. Clay is very durable in temperate to tropical weather and is inert and reusable. Metal is also very durable and is better suited for temperate to cold climates and is recyclable.
Just had Hy Grade Roofing install a metal roof at my house. Worst decision I could have made. They promised to install the roof in 4-6 weeks, of course they were late. When they finally showed up without the proper equipment and damaged my property. They are really proud of the “Quality Audit” that they do, but of course they won’t give you a copy of the audit…lol BTW -the “Quality Audit” they did at my house consisted of 2 guys coming over to pickup the leftover junk they left at my house for a month. They never even went up on the roof! Save your money use someone else!
CAN YOU PLEASE HELP ME? I am looking for rolls of asphalt roofing material. I saw a sample of what i want. It has a design on the roll of asphalt roofing of fish scale shingles. These are not actually shingles. They are drawn on by the manufacturer.
Thx for the informative video. After watching your video, I am contemplating a steel roof. I am in need now and got a quote from Strong Roofing in Long Beach MS and have checked with the BBB as well as neighbors who have used them. My question is who shall I get quote for a steel roof from? None of my neighbors had recommendations. Long Beach, MS 39560 Thx!
Hello: Needing to replace my roof as soon as possible. Do you recommend anyone in the South Texas area south of San Antonio, TX? I am really interested in the Composite Spanish Tile - Custom Barrel Tile. Which I think is like rubber correct?
I disagree that asphalt shingles are the easiest to repair. 10+ years old (often takes dramatically less) and they are very fragile and brittle. And you must remove a bunch of shingles' fasteners to remove one damaged shingle, meaning you are likely to damage 3 shingles repairing one...then hoping you don't damage any more. Metal roofing is not that bad to repair in my opinion, in fact, I'd say the easiest since you can almost always buy new panels to match the old ones - something that is really hard to do with shingles for size and color, believe it or not. I have repaired shingle roofs that most contractors would not even walk on. However, the real problem seems to be that no companies want to repair them, only totally replace them. Finally, I'd like to point out that the only hail-proof roof is poured concrete. It's an absolute shame we continue to build wood frame homes where that's impossible, unlike a lot of the world. Constant hail has apparently become a serious issue in Colorado.
