Salman Rushdie & 'The Satanic Verses' : Whose Freedom? Whose Speech? (1989) - The Fifth Estate 

me

Me

Me

my government funded tv skipped over that like it didn't even happen and went on to more pertinent human rights issues of the day

an muslim fanatic stabbing a praised writer over religion no human rights issue there

@Dear dad what do you consider "genuine questions"? Can we only ask how to clean out butts? Or how to shave our armpits?? Islam doesn't have answers to genuine questions only silly questions.

@Dear dad cab we say that Mohammed(The best prophet of Islam) in fact had BLACK SLAVES....and there was a time where he traded TWO(2) of his black slaves for one non black salve. Hadith👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇😂 "A slave came and pledged to the Prophet to emigrate, and the Prophet did not realize that he was a slave. Then his master came looking for him. The Prophet said: 'Sell him to me,' and he bought him for two black slaves. Then he did not accept the pledge from anyone until he asked: 'Is he a slave? "'

@Dear dad BTW, in Islam you are only allowed to ask silly questions like how to wipe your but or is it is allow to fart during prayers.... Islam is a JOKE

True ! Religion SUCKS.

@@simpleenglish1 says the guy who doesn’t even know how to clean himself and don’t talk about Hadith it’s to much for your little brain .and Islam and Hadith have answers to all religion so again don’t talk about religions you have not studied.And basic hygiene is important and you need to be clean to pray

Exactly

He proved that he was right

OMG .this comment is even more relevant now

100%

that's what happens when you mix virgins wine and religious stupidity !!!!!!!!!!! you know all for the prophet and allah .....allah made up the blasphemy laws gave them grabriel and gabriel gave them to mohammad ???? or did allah transmit them another way ????

❤❤❤❤ ***The Messiah has come*** ❤❤ ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-NQErICgt4SM.html

May Allah guide him

​@@ajajssksk1757 ISRAELI MISSILES kILLS PALSTINE PEOPLE WHY IS ALLAH NOT SAVING THEM IS HE AFRAID OF MISSILES

@Worstje Knak 🙃

@Worstje Knak there's no god in the moon after mohammed split it, just like aisha's hymen.🙂

Bryan Stewart what is going to happen when we die? How can u be so sure nothing is going to happen. So then why are we here? Who came up with the concept of God . May be the first human on earth?? But why he thought of god? Just curious to know what you think about this

Xorodo nut No one came up with the concept of God. God is the beginning and the end. God was revealed to us. We are living now what makes you think we can not live again?

Bryan It's violent even if you don't criticize it.

Bryan Stewart, as long as you don't criticize and convert to it!

@@megabushcraft you sound like your quoting the quran. Word for word

So if a person eat pork he should be killed, even if he eats that in England 😂😂😂

For now.

😉😉😉

doesn't matter, islamic rules should apply everywhere apparently...

Wait a few minutes and probably will be...

When in rome do as the romans do

@@BilalBilal-wj3ze : Why arent Muslims living in western societies doing that?

Exactly!!! Well put!!

basically

Why

Cos islam is the truth "Allah guides whom he wills" the author was an ex Muslim and these thick ex muslims spread propaganda and a load of lies cos they are totally misguided ppl. Anyone who goes against our prophet my Allah punish them

@@saadusman6617 "islam is true" this is your stance and your opinion don't try to impose this ideology on everyone. If muslims can criticize other religions and can falsify all the religions so how is criticizing islam not a fair play hun??

Cherish when prophet Mohammad criticism to others religion.U got to learn about prophet Mohammad good luck

@tweety tweety Ive heard what you've had to say, but guess what i dont care. Goodbye

Humayun Laskar Good luck too, and it would be best for you to learn about him too and read the Quran and the Hadiths with the same critical mind as you would any other books.

It’s been refuted in full, ur just wasting money

Still gonna buy it

@@Ohnthr I don’t care if u wanna waste ur money 😂😂😂

@@boogus1670 absolutely nobody asked for your opinion

@@boogus1670 Its available for free online, do u want me to send it to you?

Think they do not have that capacity to think that far with their right brain thinking ;) :D ahaha

Point has been made

So Salman got the last laugh in a sense.

😂😂😂😂

Mercenary Knight Maybe, but getting the last word in isnt what im concerned with

why would a Muslim want to leave a Muslim country run by Allah for the evil west that just dosent make any sense

The durka durkas are ruining western civilization

😂😂😂😂

👌

True

And Quran exposed internet 1400 years ago, try reading it once so you'll understand better

@@kill54boys How?

@@sunnyearthling192 in the quran its mentioned about how the people of the end times will be surrounded with diseases with no cures and here you are

@P N chill bruh u look like u mad asf

😂

you’re very ignorant my friend

😂😂😂😂

.

.

Yes,because they are living in non Muslim lands.And in our land,you follow our rules.Simple.

Muslims believe that the Quran is the recicitation of gods word to al humanity, and that all under god must adhere to its authority though. It’s part of the mindset.

Neil Vanderveen and they believe someone should be killed for criticizing

Simon Peter they believe the whole world was made for their prophet this whole purpose for us here today how crazy it that !?

Muslim fundamentalism in Canada is just as bad as Christian fundamentalism is in the states but for some reason being an Islamic fundamentalist isn't as frowned upon in society. It's funny because both types of fundamentalists refuse to adapt to modern society, both want to ban blasphemy, and both want to impose theocracy with religious law.

Matt Sherv tell me about it 🤣🤣🤣

Because the USA and UK didn't invade Afghanistan Iraq and dismantled the entire Middle East. Because prior to the meddling of Western Powers the Middle East was doing absolutely fine.

Yuh!! Tell me what will u do if someone trash-talked about your mom?

love country

blasphemy laws did that

Is he the young Naheed nenshi- mayor of calagry

The other men were dragging their knuckles to burn the books they bought 😂

@@abumaliha7266 very well could be

He brings up an interesting topic. You have to choose between freedom of expression and respecting the dignity of ethnic groups. That is the sentiment of living in a multicultural society. You can not have both when the ethnic groups don’t value freedom of speech as much as we do in the West. So you have to either choose, or change their mentality. These are not simple tasks. But not difficult enough for you to be ignorant about them. If you prefer freedom of speech, then you will see ethnic groups flooding the streets. But please, don’t act surprised when they do.

​@@_phildogwell thats ridiculuos, cause the freedom of speech doesn't necessaraly have to do with the dignity of these ethnic groups. For example if i critisize a book/god/religious leaders because its followers threat woman as second. Then i come up for the dignity of these woman. (at least from my own perspective) If i for example say that white people are racist, then if you are a white person you will be more affected, by that statement, then a non white person, are someone who also thinks white people are racist. I think that its human behaviour that we get offended, the real problem here is that one group has such a strong identity that they think they can control the whole public sphere by forming new rules, without critisizing their own standpoint about it. So in the interview there also critical things about the christian religion. but they dont know that or choose to ignore it. Thats the real problem here, double standards by a strong groupsidentity. So how does this point out, if you feel offended by a thing, but your group says, it just a person or get over it. Then it wil have a different effect as lets say, that infidel, or the west is always mocking is, we deserve respect. I think they just need time and alternatives from their own groups to change this groupsbehaviour.

That's what I think too.

That is what he wanted.

EXACTLLYY!!!

We muslims can afford to buy and burn don't be naive like you don't know Muslim countries supply your oil, Qatar owns 40% of London, your football teams are owned by Muslim s,so grow up

@@omarhussain9013 that doesn’t change the fact that you fed the troll you tried to stand against

What do you mean???

He doesn't know half of what he's talking about. He just took a controversial Islamic story and decided to make a profit off Islamophobes. Y'all follow each other blindly like a blind man guiding a deaf man without any knowledge of hadith or tafsir. And may I ask if Islam is not the true religion, then what religion should I follow? Because I am almost entirely sure each and every one of you will give me a different answer. And no matter which religion I follow, people will still be angry. People like you are the reason we will never get world peace. So stop whining and crying and give people a rest.

Yeah Islam is virus that destroys the thinking capabilities.... You can't have negative criticism about islam , when you have then you die in gutter... Intolerant as fck....

He was right about fabricated hadiths 🤣

100%

Yes but the west is picking up the medical bill for all the ills of that practice. And when a atrocity is committed by them they cite a mental imbalance. Go figure.. an inbred society with mental ilness that is endemic... really? Surely thats not medical fact but a critique of a sick society... or as they would put it blasphemous hate speech. Cant win can you

@Umer Tracker you cannot even u try ur 100%

It is acceptable islamically and god knows his creation more than the creations knows himself

a multi-generational incested mental case goes crazy when offended especially over religion. religion really reeks havoc on a crazy man

generational incestral inbreeding for centuries what could go wrong with that ???

This is why the Middle east and the Indian subcontinent region are the most religious

That happens when cousins procreate

only someone who has the emotional maturity of a child cannot examine their feelings from the outside, just because people feel something strongly, does not make that feeling justified.

You people are intelligent abuse your Jesus in your lame Jokes hahaha you people have no common sense your God had no value

I like the way you put it, i just call them brainwashed

Every religion has its own black sheep. Don't single out islam.

@@TheFarouk73 thing is though you cannot deny islam is causing most of the problems in the world. Not all muslims. Islam

@@optimusprime4090 i dont hear "chrstian terrorists" when catholics commits crime. But when a muslim-sounding name did, Islam is the headline. #foreheadslap

You forget your own people the last 100 year and more who killed more than millions of people. Don't talk rubbish.

@@TheFarouk73 lol okay your religion has absolutely nothing to do with violence. Thats what you want to hear about your religion. Abrahamic religions are violent. You may not be a violent person but thats in spite of your religion. Not because of it. You have every right to believe islam is a religion of peace. Thing is if we got rid of religion thrre would be no more black sheep as you put it. They would just be regular murderers then.

There is a difference between mocking a religion and asking questions

@@jahedul.H Islam is trash mohamed is a pedophile who was visited by demons

@@maychiu1419 why are you trying to provoke people? They're sharing their opinions in good faith, and you say this

@@jahedul.H Islam deserves to be mocked it's absolutely pathetic and pitiful and a stain on humanity.

questioning is different ,criticizing is different.who is preventing you to question,you clarify ,you will get answer.it is like H2o is water,if any one says why cant be H3o,there is no answer for that it is something else cannot be water,I hope you will agree with me.

Bullshit. It's one of the greatest novels of the 1980s.

Ive read it and it is amazing

Justice for Salman Rushdie when...

Oh and I’d be willing to bet the masses didn’t even read the book. That’s just my opinion

I insult paul Stanford’s wife and you keep quiet cos then your deep love is gonna be shown

Islamic thought process is just like virus

a weak ego is a defensive ego

Yeah Islam can't really stand on it's own feet.

learn a little grammar first 😂

@@abdullahmohammed2582 I hear Mo was didn't know how to read and write? Did he?

Never possible

Go and learn grammar before you talk, you are speaking poor English

try english study first a hero

If you haven’t read the book or study on the matter keep your mouth shut. keep quiet about what you don’t know

@Brother Asked a good Question. ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-vtxDK8NlX9M.html

🙂

@Salahuddin Ayubi who cares!

@Salahuddin Ayubi good for the idiots

Artificial Avocado Islam isn't a religion, its apolitical movement of conquest.

Bruh theyre knuckleheads these muslim they were brainwashed from their childhood ya cant do anything to change their mind theyre stupid.

shut up at least respect it

@Alfred E Respect to other faiths then what are you doing i just simply said to respect our religion ....smh

who is asking you to accept ,it is your wish,if you dont want to accept truth,but you have no right to criticize others beliefs.

The only way to save Salman Rushdie, Patty Samuel , Nupur Sharma and Kanihya Lal is to promote free speech critical of Mohammed and Quran. Offense is the only defense.

Call it whatever you want to call it… we respect the religion of Islam very much & we won’t anyone to disrespect it. You must pay for disrespecting Islam and its prophet

Few words from the brides mom 👆🏼👇🏼

@@saadabdi8196 then move to another country. You don't get to impose your Islamofascism on us. We have freedom of speech here. Bye

@@saadabdi8196 In that case crawl back into the cave you climbed out of.

Ur ignorant bubba may god guide u bro

I was gonna say muslims, but it's pretty much a synonym.

@@truthserumbackup4151 😂 you need guidance bubba. We all do

@@ajajssksk1757 Guidance to what?

@@truthserumbackup4151 to the truth.

Shut up he

in reading that book of truth and not taqqiya for once.

Its not a religion peace. Its a religion of war.

Islam is now kinda joke

@@joshuamuanlal6936 your religion is joke now not Islam

Can we buy this book from Amazon?

Me too i wanna read it!

Yabba dabba doo

I literally bought it with an extra gold case and it has all-black cover. It looks marvellous, not to mention the book itself is masterful.

Great book 📕

He must have been a smart man huh some idiots

less stab his corpse

Do you really share this colonialist bullshit quote as something good? lmao

I agree. I'd love to hear from that kid

Decades after, the kid might have been either an atheist or a middle aged man far away from religious practices.

Thank you for telling us 😂

@@ajajssksk1757 😂

No he’s been taught the truth

@@ajajssksk1757 Oh great! I had hopes someone would teach him the truth and he would become atheist!

he only repeats what he's heard bright or not he's already a religious mental case

Hello dear friend... A proud atheist iranian..

❤

@@shinchannohara5621 🤝

How do u guys stay alive. I mean because In Hindu households, our parents don't care about being religious.

@@xxxxxxxxxxx-ps8pn we stay alive because not every Muslim is an extremist and follows islam as it is.

But here we are lol

2 billion muslims on this planet now. Scary.

The religion seems to promote such emotional immaturity

Christ is the only way , light and truth . Read the Bible and meditate on his word. Away from these pagan gods that promote violence polygamy and repetitive prayers like parrots …

A muslim just stabbed Salman

We don’t care who’s is hurt as long one sick man can practice his freedom of speech👍🏾

Gypsy Soul Of course not Woman to them to serve and make babies only that’s the reason for her to be around Trust me woman’s. Before Islam came to the world woman had more respect and positions all around the arab area and some of them they were Queens who their voice was heard and some of them were leading countries and some of them as a knights too and after the Islam came to the existence changed everything and as I said they are to serve and making babies that’s all

Anon[712] who said lol

Gypsy Soul yeah women hate that old geezer too. Lol

Well.... there would have to be a ratio of 2:1, women to men, in order to even be allowed to speak. A womans testimony is worth half that of a man's in islam, as they teach women are deficient in intellect and religion.

@@mamamarianovits9029 not at all. Read the verse where it says that. May allah guide u

Probably an ex moose now

The only one with a sensible voice

They just take, take, take as did their 'prophet'.

He lied mocked Islam too

How educated is he? The boy is suggesting to you the application of sharia law and you're praising him? Do you know was sharia is?

@@FoJ-REAPP Did you hear even a word I said? I said I hope he leaves such religion alone. What don't you understand?

I'm about 100% sure that your a Christian? And if you are, Then how educated can you be? Especially if you believe in an out dated book called the bible.... lol

@@ivstova47 u sound silly please shush.

@@FoJ-REAPP a Christian should not be speaking. The guy is strong in his religion I believe and I hope

He is still alive

@@syeddastageerullah2417 many have not been so lucky.

@@syeddastageerullah2417 alive but unable to write and speak. Ironic how that’s his fate after he spread lies about god. What’s happened to him had it coming one way or another. Even if it wasn’t about Islam and merely something else. For every action a reaction.

Don’t forget how the US handled foreign policy for the past 30+ years. It used to pay attention to people like this man. Their drive was hate and speculation.

He's a great writer. He's not a scholar

How about this week?

"ek din marr jayega kutte ki maut, jag me kehlayega marr gaya madharch*d" .... The song proved just to be accurate !

All you can do is terrorize people that’s what your religion teaches, it teaches force and violence.

Would you believe they actually came out within a few weeks of each other in August/September 1988. I just looked it up. I definitely agree banning something only gives it more power. Movie theaters choosing not to show a movie is a little different than an entire country banning a book in terms of censorship but I get what you're saying

@Ahmad Mujtaba the truth that the violent and hatred in islam come from the source, the teaching of the founder prophet of islam, Muhammad.

@@dasael11 u do know that Islam is the fastest growing religion like the banner in this video showed right? Do u think majority or many people who convert into Islam likes violent? In general most of us like peace thats y they convert into Islam, not some religion like Christian who doesnt even know their own bible

@@dasael11 if Jesus is truly god, how come hes dead instead of saving these "lost" people?

@@babyboynaughty1741 the facts I know is islam spread through violent and hatred, Muhammad , the founder of islam killed, killed and killed, raped,raped and raped, what is the true loving God they to teach his follower from the violent and lustful of His prophet, Muhammad?

@@babyboynaughty1741 As the true God, Jesus can do anything include to die and live again, as a loving God He allowed Himself to be sacrificed ,in order whosoever believes in Him will has eternal life. No one can kill Jesus unless He let it happen.

What if we applied that logic to someone mocking or making a parody or insulting characters from the religion of Judaism or doubt the occurrence of the holocaust. No publisher would dare publish such a book out of fear of consequences. Why mess with Islam when one cannot even think of messing with another religion?

@@szehrar you don't mock reality tragedy and victims its common sense . But You criticise politician, state head, religious figures , religion .see the difference . Why we criticise a religion because it tries to sell something . If guy says he is the son of God or messenger of God and split moon or sea then we laugh .its because we know it's not reality . But disasters are real its victims are real

@@7_years_and_ Good point. Israel expanding into Palestine is a reality. Try criticising that.

@@szehrar You are doing that now . people are doing that every where with out getting stabbed. what else do you want

@@7_years_and_ i tried it, and was called anti-semitic. The act of one lone wolf stabbing Rushdie does not mean that the entire Muslim world supports the act. He may have been a mentally ill person.

he was wrong. 1.Blasphemy in Islam is death.2.They are living in non-muslim land and salman rushdie is not a muslim so why should he be killed? 3.A multicultural society should be allowed to criticise,killing someone just because they offended youor insulted you just proves that you are an uncultured swine.

@@truthhurts1936 agreed, if they want to kill someone, then they are free to kill each other as much they want, on their arabic lands.

@@danieldd1804 : You have a point,from 1981 to 1989,the nation of Ir an and Iraq,both Muslim country,killed each oth er at a tune of 4.million casualty, that span for 8years....The occutic glo balist Illuminati will cre ate 1.religion only for th e whole world,for the re ason that religion is one reason for world bloody war.The only god to be worshipped is satan/lu cifer,all other god is puni shable by death,a repeti tion of the incident in the book of Daniel.Prophet D aniel was punished with death sentence,food for 7.days fasting lions!!..gui lty of praying to other Go d within the prescribed limit of 30days.Daniel pr ayed to God not approv ed by the king of Baby lon..... Such theory and reasoning to create 1.w orld religion is tragedy waiting to happen: Iran and Iraq are both muslim nation yet they engaged in bloody war for 8.years as the world watch....The Catholic Holy Inquisition from 10th-18th century had murdered 200.milli on plus peoples,mostly protestant/born again christian....Wrong start, wrong ending... Garbage in,garbage out....This say ing was tested for the pa st thousand of years.....O nly the genuine peace of God can create genuine and perfect peace...Only Lord Jesus can give true PEACE...(John 16:33)....

🌙🧕🧕👳🏾‍♂️🧕🧕🌙

Quraish tribe main god was Moon god

No one cares what u think silly rojej

Really is , these guy gotta Open their eyes

@Rupesh Sahu I love my prophet more than my family. Muslims do. And so it makes sense that nothing should be said like this or consequences will occur out of emotion.

​@ajajssksk1757 He is a paedophile though 😂. Sahih Al Bukhari 5133

Lovely news

And that’s why so much Christians become muslim right.

you clearly have not read the verse you quoted

@@irfankayani4566 That's the only verse, I've ever posted with out checking my Quran first. You're right. It's not in there. Though many satanic verses I have read. But you are right about this one. Apologies

@@coltmagnus6572 Very well responded, thoh sarcastically.

Rushie''s book didn't insult anyone.

Yea, i don't understand why this god is so great yet it needs its followers to help n protect it.

You should watch godlogic apologetics and christian prince and cira international and Lloyd de jongh and reasoned answers on RU-vid and watch all the channels on RU-vid i'm back doe 😀😀😀

The debate is wide open and the critics of him walk the streets freely and safely

Books have been written not about Jesus as a fraud, but Jesus as having always been a myth or scam. "The Profit" on the other hand we know existed, and was a huge fraud.

me too!

Dont bother , its poo. Rushdie is an overated author who is so rubbish with the pen

It's easy to target Muslims. write gibberish = $$$$.

His four greatest novels are The Satanic Verses, Shalimar the Clown, Midnight's Children and The Enchantress of Florence.

Wilson no one cares