@@Fist3ee Shane was still a bad ass imagine if shane respected rick what a duo they would have been they could have beaten negan Rick Shane and Daryl dixon
@@lil_applejuice3456 I know that Shane is a badass but him loving Lori ruined him completely..I called him a simp since in his final moments he tried to kill his BEST FRIEND because they both loved the same woman that ain't badass that's crazy and crue,but Merle in his final moments went out like a badass he tried to kill Governor once and for all and his men so the people in prison wouldn't have to suffer anymore
Combat, battle IQ, and skill goes to merle. Combat- Merle was a marine. Marines are taught Kali, Muay Thai, karate, and tons of other CQC techniques. Battle IQ- again, merle was a marine. Skill- merle parried Michonne's sword with his knife hand (as someone who trains HEMA, that's some serious skill) and merle has shown to be a good shooter and is excellent at hand to hand.
@@Siah_SpendMarines are for first invasions. They have to enlist for 2 years of hard, intense, and gruesome training. Every ex military will never forget their training.( Seriously, ask any who served and they have tons of stories about their service) Even if merle didn't use those techniques, he still knows them.
Shane didn't even spend a year in the apocalypse. Merle showed great durability when he cut off his own arm. Merle was beaten by 7 guys, and after that he fought back against the Governor. Merle survived much more than Shane, was the Governor's right hand, made plans with the Governor, was a commander and in the past Merle taught Daryl how to survive in the forest and hunt. Merle has military experience and was a US Marine.
1-Shane was an ex sheriff 2-Was a shooting master,never missed a shot 3-Almost killed Ed with punches and threw him quite far with one hand 4-Cut his own hand with a knife but still was keeping bus door close and killing walkers 5-Easily bodied Daryl and Jim 6-Beat Rick without even using his 100% of power and concetration,stunned Rick with one headbutt 7-After fight with Rick he managed to threw tha wrench at him like it was nothing 8-Shane opened Ed eye with 1-2 punches which shows how powerful his punches are 9-Speed.We all remember his legendary run 10-IQ.Was an ex sheriff and was a good strategist 11-Physical strenght.Was trained and masculine
@@Martirosyan22 Police training takes six months. Merle is a military man. Shane hasn't really fought strong opponents. In the battle, Rick had a weaker version of himself. Ed didn't even defend himself or resist, he was afraid of Shane.
@@kiduk-yt1tu Not really the actor John Bernthal(Shane) is 180cm, and the actor Michael Rooker(Merle) is 178cm, I'm not an expert but in my opinion 2cm difference is not visible at all. Afterwards yes it is possible that sometimes in the series they make the actors appear taller but in reality it is quite different..
I think they have met each other but never saw it on screen because Merle was obviously in that same camp with Daryl and Shane but we never saw them interact but I think they never liked each other I’m assuming
@@Mystic_Editz616Shane didn’t lifted Otis was not on Shane’s back Shane shot him then got the supplies or stuff off Otis while Merle punch Rick and Rick was down for minutes while Shane punch like 10 times and Rick wasn’t after some punches rick was down Merle has better feats
@@Watermelon8 I thought he had a decent IQ compared to Merle. I think Daryl has a better IQ than Shane for sure because he figured out quickly before anyone that Shane was responsible for Otis’ death
Personally I gotta disagree with this, merle was in the military (marine corps) I’m pretty sure and is much more experienced and skilled and possibly stronger than Shane and is more skilled with weapons possibly as well, and has much better feats, but it could go either way, sick edit tho 🔥
Shane didn't even spend a year in the apocalypse. Merle showed great durability when he cut off his own arm. Merle was beaten by 7 guys, and after that he fought back against the Governor. Merle survived much more than Shane, was the Governor's right hand, made plans with the Governor, was a commander and in the past Merle taught Daryl how to survive in the forest and hunt. Merle has military experience and was a US Marine.
Looks smoth, well edited but pretty cap to be honest Merle takes far more points though and wins mid or mid high diff overall Strength/AP - Merle with 1 arm grappled daryl to the ground in the Arena fight (3x6 or 3 x7, With 1 Arm restrained glenn, michonne and maggie couldnt get him off of glenn (3x13), Knocked rick down with 1 punch on the rooftop (1x2) Combat Speed/Reaction speed - Merle dodged michonnes sneak attack in the woods and then disarmed her with his knife hand, dodged Skill/Combat - Merle Shows better Melee and 1v1 no weapon combat, he effortlesly beat Glenn twice (when the Group broke Glenn and maggie out of woodburry and in 3x13 in the prison when he wanted to go shoot the Governer but glenn Was against it), he uses kicks,grappling and punches alike Agility - He fights more agile with dodges (Arena fight against Martinez for example) (3x5 i think) BIQ - Merle imo but this could be a tie Stamina - similar to endurance because he cleared the building after cutting of his hand and killed several Zombies Gun Fight- debatable depends on the range but its fine if you say shane wins a gun fight Conclusion: Gun fight = debatable, 1v1 no weapon and melee = merle easily Merle is one of the if not the most underrated characters and fighters in twd, Shane is overrated by a lot of people
true he is overrated, but also this is just my opinion i'm not trying to make him more overrated, merle can for sure win in a fist fight but shane slams if it comes to a gun fight imo
fist fight, i was gonna say shane. because when rick fought with shane. in the fight you can see shane holding back and relax taking all punched by rick. if shane would've not holding back in that fight, rick would lose so badly
@@ArrowEditssshane is a aggressive fighter, his punched literally deadly, he almost killing ed and he almost make otis passed out in the field just using punch
@@ArrowEditssif shane and merle met, shane would not holding back in that fight, shane just use his defence,kicks,punches,headbutt and super elbow to the head
agility goes merle. This dude has done flying kicks and spinning kicks in this tv show more than once. All we have seen from shane is heavy brawling no real agility.
