Mmh, I don´t know, to be honest. There is a reason Floor didn´t change this song, just exenteded it a little bit: it is an iconic Tarja Nightwish song. Not sure if vocal freestyle helps this song much.
I agree with you. I actually didn't liked this freestyle and her voice sounds weird, not clean. I really love this song being played by Tarja but this version isn't the best.
Floor did change the song. And she is in Nightwish, I'm pretty sure she can't do whatever she wants with the songs on stage, lol. Tarja *can* do whatever she wants, because this is her own concert, and she performs the songs however the hell she wants.
@@eddiehesselman3904 This will always be Tarja's song. She might not be singing it like in the record nowadays, but the relation between sweetness, power and theatricality she is capable of is unparalelled. Floor is AMAZING but she can't sing this song like this for the very simple fact this song was built around Tarja, in the same way Tarja would never sound good singing "7 days to the wolves" just to name an example, or any of Floor's songs for that matter.
What the heck happened to the gothic angel I fell in love around 17 years ago? I'm so so so sorry but this is not her best performance of Nemo, her intonation, her diction, sounds strange
@@eddiehesselman3904 i do not remember on my comment here. sorry. but this was wrong, what i mentioned, i prefer Floor on each NW-song (i am biased). nevertheless i see Tarjas talent. I was in Stockholm to see her and NW.
But there’s plenty of room to state that this is your opinion, not a fact. I appreciate them both, in their own unique way, for what they did or do with Nightwish.
@@pathfindercl The point is that Floor is the singer from Nightwish now for 11 years and dhe never has copy the songs of Tarja and through the years she made many songs her own like Nemo but you can here that Tarja try's to sing the song as Floor does now and that doesn't work for her.
I love Tarja but from this video I think the freestyle doesn't suit this song. But I like when she sang Nemo in Nightwish. I'm fine with the other songs. I even like Planet Hell better as she sings it now.
can't she hear herself that her voice has become terrible? (why did she start singing in a modern style, she can’t do it at all there is nothing left of her former academic singing. modern Tarja sounds just awful, but Nemo in this version is just shame and disgrace
