Tata Punch vs Renault Kiger | Comparo | OVERDRIVE

Подписаться 451 тыс.

Просмотров 71 тыс.

50% 1

When is a hatchback actually an SUV? We try and answer that, to see which of these SUV-styled crossovers, the Tata Punch, or the Renault Kiger, give you the best alternative to the mid-entry hatchback. Watch our comprehensive comparison review with real-world fuel efficiency and performance figures to see what each is like.
0:00 Introduction
0:24 Styling & dimensions
2:03 Cabin, features & ambience
4:29 Rear-seat space
6:16 Boot space
6:34 Safety features
6:54 Driving impressions
11:06 Performance & efficiency
12:01 Ride & handling
13:40 Verdict
SUBSCRIBE to OVERDRIVE for India's best automotive content! www.overdrive.in/subscribe/
OVERDRIVE is India's biggest auto media with India's most awarded television show, this RU-vid channel, a magazine that's been the best of the best for over 20 years and more. OVERDRIVE offers a wonderful spread of automotive content including tests, reviews, comparisons, reports from motor shows, travel stories and more.
Shortcuts to OVERDRIVE's stories:
Latest reviews
www.overdrive.in/reviews/
Comparison tests of new cars and new motorcycles
www.overdrive.in/reviews/comp...
The very latest motorcycle and scooter reviews
www.overdrive.in/reviews/bikes/
OVERDRIVE's feature stories
www.overdrive.in/news-cars-au...
Head to www.overdrive.in for breaking news, news analysis and all the events as they happen in the automobile market globally and especially in India.
Or follow us
Facebook / odmag
Twitter / odmag
Instagram / odmag

Авто/Мото

Опубликовано:

10 июл 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 129

@motherearth6393 2 года назад

Kiger Design + Punch Build + Maruti Petrol engine= complete Car

@Beast0930 2 года назад

There will never be one like that below 8 to 10 lakh range

@STgauss3268 2 года назад

But kiger design copied from tata harrier, not just the drls, but look at the fender-bonnet borderlines too..

@Beast0930 2 года назад

@@STgauss3268 I think Harrier is at par better than any of these. These are all kids in front of it.Even I bought baby of Harrier Punch 😂

@super_sonic2756 2 года назад

@@STgauss3268 harrier its self copied drl design of hyundai santafe

@STgauss3268 2 года назад

@@super_sonic2756 look at the shape of drl of santa fe and harrier and the placement are not exact same where as kiger drls and fender-bonnet borderlines are exact shape from harrier...

@shubhdestination 2 года назад

Kiger turbo manual sports mode and looks are 🔥 🔥 🔥

@SuperAkashrana 2 года назад

While at the lower end Punch makes more sense, but as you climb to the top two variants, forking out some extra cash to move over to turbo petrol on Kiger will be the logical choice. In case of automatics, it makes the case even stronger with a better gearbox. Though the true value is delivered by Magnite, where a little more money buys so much more kit which is the most sensible vehicle in the price range.

@STgauss3268 2 года назад

At 10.5 lakhs onroad, nexon xz+ petrol manual is much better...

@jaykolhe6150 2 года назад

@@STgauss3268 bhai kidhar milri tumko 10.5 may nexon xz + on road

@pareshsawant8036 2 года назад

Newton xmeter😂😂😂

@STgauss3268 2 года назад

@@jaykolhe6150 thats the price we got but now i guessed the price have increased.

@fanbhagatsinghda6200 2 года назад

Xl turbo variant of magnite is the one to go for

@souravdutta7844 2 года назад

Punch. Killing looks in Red color. Real Mini Harrier. Great build quality.

@AravindKumar-fs6mw 2 года назад

Kiger has better fuel economy than this numbers. The mileage of punch shown is equal to kiger as it's a 1 lit engine.

@lals8438 2 года назад

Kiger looks superb 👌👌

@radioactiveelement1799 2 года назад

Improper judgement. How can Kiger and punch both get 7 in design? Kiger looks way more better than Punch. It's bold, muscular, sporty and it has a dominant road presence. If Kiger gets 7 then Punch should be awarded with 5 or less.

@saraswatrahul73 10 месяцев назад

Kiger ✨ is really a tiger✨ no doubt the turbo engine of kiger perform more then sufficient power👍 have best in segment boot space even more then ecosports, nexon, breeza etc best in segment ground clearance 205 mm , have very decent cabin space even more then its competitors like nexon, venue, breeza, xuv300 etc & if i talk about the looks of kiger🫡 hats of to reno.... Its amazing & kiger provide maximum features like keyless entry, 8 inches touch screen, tyre pressure monitoring, cooled glove box, rear ac winds & rear hand rest which is countable in luxurious accessories 🫡 & if we talk about safety provide by reno which is also very impressive because kiger get 4⭐ rating in global ncap crash test ✨ so... We can say its a safe car also.... & Reno provide 4 airbags in kiger so... We can say kiger is really value for money & very decent product of Renault ✨ so... Everyone should go for this beast also.... In this segment this is the only compact suv which provide alot of things according to its price segment 🫡 definitely everyone should consider this beautiful beast✨

@qaz123orama1 2 года назад

I was confused between Punch and Kiger so I moved to Nexon and bought on 15th Jan'22

@rahulmenith96 2 года назад

🤣

@prajwal9486 2 года назад

Gajab 😂

@riteshnets 2 года назад

Adding the Nissan Magnite to this comparison was more sensible given its selling more than the kiger as well.

@doggasandeep 2 года назад

Punch scoring 2 points above Kiger in Styling font is a joke.. Rest all good.

@BlameHari13 2 года назад

the kiger's sports mode makes a huge difference in how it drives cause i know, i have taken a test drive of both the punch and the kiger!!

@pramodh17 2 года назад

Kigers presence and styling outclasses punch quite handsomely..other parameters are subjective 😊

@kd6788 2 года назад

Kigers styling destroys punch really 😂😂😂.

@STgauss3268 2 года назад

Lol, renault kiger copied designs from harrier, look at the fender-bonnet borderlines too, exact rip off from harrier...

@AniketYadav-eu2gx Год назад

@@STgauss3268 Dude it's more like KWID 🤣 which is their own car

@NiteshRS Год назад

Which is a better choice- punch adventure amt or kiger rxt amt?

@prakashbinnal7884 Год назад

hi sir, whether kiger engine is reliable....which is better on this

@veerendranayak846 2 года назад

Why 1080p video quality looks bad ? Full noise and 0 stabilization and the overall video quality is bad but not the review its good .

@motherearth6393 2 года назад

Best design Is Kiger . Stunning car design

@jebybenzy 2 года назад

Waiting for the review and so confused between punch and kiger . Drove both i loved the half clutch concept of punch and for bangalore drive punch is best ..I would suggest if ur a person who don't want to spend on top variants go for for punch ....and the other pro is there is no diff in engine from base to top end of punch unlike kiger which offers turbo variant and it's cllose to 9llks.

@bhargavparmar2503 2 года назад

i ownrd punch.. creative... its fun to drive car .. at highway too... i got 19 km/l at 1st day

@jebybenzy 2 года назад

@@bhargavparmar2503 that's cool. Overall how did u llike the vehicle...?? Is it worth spending or go for kiger?

@Mohit_Yadav168 Год назад

@@jebybenzy Which one did u buy bro, I'm also confused btwn the two, would love some inputs from ur end.

@jebybenzy Год назад

@@Mohit_Yadav168 not both finally ended up with a second hand Nissan kicks. But buddy go for punch it's good... No doubt.

@aniketagrawal9963 Год назад

@jeby which model of punch to buy? I am also from bnglr

@vermasau 2 года назад

Well as far as thigh support is concerned specially rear seat i think punch is much better.

@pranavkelkar1710 2 года назад

Excellent review

@nithishjvj8736 2 года назад

Kiger or Magnite turbo with Tech pack even against its own rivals 🔥🔥

@apoorvgauravsingh982 2 года назад

Bhai sahab jitne alag alag youtubers ki videos dekho, vo sab apna hi alag alag batate hain. Koi kehta hai punch mein seats comfortable hain, koi kehta hai ki kiger mein hain. 🤣. Koi kehta hai ki Kiger dekhne me badi lagti hai, toh koi kehta hai ki punch. 🤣. Hadd hai.

@neelj5155 2 года назад

Saw a user review in dds, there uncle ji was very frustrated with ac of kiger !! He was very annoyed with AC , so yeah kiger is a no no for me... My father would give taane every day for choosing a car ,that is kiger ,as it's missing fundamental thing such as AC !!

@1502abhijit 2 года назад

Frankly, I would choose the Kiger due to the space on offer between the two. However, after owning a sub 4m SUV, I would rather go for a full size SUV, ie a Safari or something like it!

@nevelledavid386 Год назад

Such a good review

@TEchYBlogger. Год назад

Hello Good video and information about Both This Cras ok 🇮🇳

@guneetsingh9750 Год назад

Nexon is TC and Punch is NA, ofcorse the fuel efficiency would be diff as its the same capacity engine, same engine actually

@sameerv6201 Год назад

Proud owner of rxt 2022 MT non turbo variant. Previously drove Tata Bolt which had 1.2 litre 4 cylinder engine with turbocharger for almost 80000 km. Honestly, can't feel much difference in terms of power delivery in kiger. It does a perfect job for city driving, no problem on highways till 100 km/h speed ( i personally don't go above 90 kmph even on highways though) . No complaints from kiger whatsoever. Even I was a bit skeptical about going for kiger due to some reviews on RU-vid which said non turbo is underpowered. I would say, non turbo kiger is sufficiently powered. Main problem is people want the features and performance of pajero or range rover by paying 9 lakhs . This is wrong expectation. I observed, there is a lot of negative propaganda against kiger . At the end, it's your money, spend wisely, there are a lot of brands and cars to chose from. So choose your poison as per your whims and fancies 😁😁😁

@RupenSheth1 Год назад

Same confused here , which one to buy Tata punch accomplished / camo edition or kiger rxz amt non turbo ??

@sameerv6201 Год назад

@@RupenSheth1 having owned a tata before for 7 years, their After Sales Service is just pathetic, their cars are wonderful though. After 4-5 years small issues crop up like music system stops working,check engine light comes up on its own. I honestly feel, the service centres aren't up to the mark. If you have budget till 15 lakhs , i would recommend venue or new brezza. My budget was strictly under 10 lakhs, hence i went for kiger.

@sameerv6201 Год назад

@@RupenSheth1 also ,i found Renault service to be good and responsive

@Mohit_Yadav168 Год назад

@@sameerv6201 What's the city mileage bro and I heard some complaints abt a lot of engine noise in cabin in Kiger, what's ur feedback on that..? Thanks in advance.

@sreeharsha4203 10 месяцев назад

Hi bro My budget is strictly under 10lacs In this price which is better kiger NA RXT Optional bs6 phase 2 or punch accomplished sunroof both are coming under 10lacs So can you please suggest

@AksshayMalaviya 2 года назад

Will Tata, Mahindra, Hyundai and Kia launch a petrol or electric 7 seater with 6 airbags and strong ncap crash test rating to compete with Maruti Ertiga and Toyota Rumion in 7 lakh to 10 lakh budget?

@kirannair3966 2 года назад

Which is better Punch or Kiger in all aspects??

@srivishvanathgovind8881 2 года назад

Good review

@sagar13985 2 года назад

At this price bracket considering Top end models of both Punch as well as kiger , one can upgrade himself to actual SUV model viz Hyundai Creta Petrol Base Model or Brezza mid spec both Manual with much larger n smoother engines

@rahulkrish9840 2 года назад

So you think creta is an actual suv? Pity your knowledge

@pareshsawant8036 2 года назад

Rahul Krish 😂😂😂😂

@shubhendujitthongam6857 2 года назад

Please do comparison between tata punch and suzuki ignis

@vishalmishra2852 4 месяца назад

Ignis compare layak nhi hai usse accha auto rikshaw hai

@MrAyushguptaful 2 года назад

Driver armrest is the only thing stopping me to buy this car. I20 is only a good option left with rich interiors.

@vivekmishra6400 2 года назад

It's a shame that OD calls these hatchbacks as SUVs. They're not sporty or utilitarian

@pareshsawant8036 2 года назад

😂😂😂😂😂

@pareshsawant8036 2 года назад

Hatchback on steroids 😅

@dks3220 2 года назад

Kiger ❤️

@PrabhatXLR8 2 года назад

I checked Punch and Kiger and bought Kiger (turbo) and trust me I made good decision. Kiger got not just the feel of space but actual space. Also, turbo engine is so much fun with equal fuel efficiency as Punch. And driving dynamics are also better. No body roll in Kiger when turning car.

@Beast0930 2 года назад

Turbo engine will be better than NA engines. But power of NA engine is better in Punch than in Kiger.

@PrabhatXLR8 2 года назад

@@Beast0930 sir have you drove both? I test drove both and Punch struggled to climb a flyover where as Kiger. Check this video also : ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-rkaWgWD1u0M.html

@Beast0930 2 года назад

@@PrabhatXLR8 I am using Punch and I didn’t feel any issue with hill climbing or climbing a flyover. One test drive won’t present everything about a car. Infact I test drove Kiger as well buddy and it’s power is less compared to punch initially.

@PrabhatXLR8 2 года назад

@@Beast0930 I guess you are talking about Kiger NA engine. Yes that under perform compared to Punch but Kiger turbo competes with Nexon actually.

@Beast0930 2 года назад

@@PrabhatXLR8 tats what I said we shd never compare a NA(means non turbo) engine with Turbo.

@barbarianpuppy 2 года назад

Punch + Kiger = Puncture (New variant)

@Nik_diary Год назад

Punch❤️❤️❤️

@aroy8731 2 года назад

Kiger doesn't have passenger seat seatbelt pretensioner.

@carxproboy4301 2 года назад

U r lying go to showroom and check

@prashantgautam1567 2 года назад

Reanult Kiger & Triber don't have fog lamps😅😅😅😅

@sidh089 2 года назад

better go for tata nexon low variant

@BipinBabu2024 2 года назад

Kiger is the best.

@aswankishore1842 2 года назад

why do people call these cars SUVs.?

@ghulamali561 2 года назад

My KIGER is giving 8kmpl. Disappointed

@carxproboy4301 2 года назад

I think u always drive in sports mode

@ghulamali561 2 года назад

No sir I have base model

@razaullahkhan1693 2 года назад

All depends on hoq u drive...how u use clutch and brake during drive

@kamalruhela5404 2 года назад

Punch is far away from Kiger..no comparison....

@Beast0930 2 года назад

Look at the. Sales figures then

@kamalruhela5404 2 года назад

@@Beast0930yes .please do share sales figures of Magnite..from last 3 months..ans i will share punch as well

@Beast0930 2 года назад

@@kamalruhela5404 Punch released in October 18th last year and already garnered 20K+ sales in 3 months. Now you provide me the Kiger sales(not magnite, see your initial message).

@kamalruhela5404 2 года назад

@@Beast0930 yes that what I am saying...punch is good package. And have good sales figures.

@Beast0930 2 года назад

@@kamalruhela5404 Oh. I thot vice versa. Then we are on the same page then 👍

@chetanpanwar7872 Год назад

Punch is better 👌

@RajeshGhodke 2 года назад

You guys are funny. With all the audacity, you say, you never thought of comparing these two cars and then you go ahead and conduct a full fledge comparison. Congratulations! Also, why put three adults in the rear seat and then say the car is made for 2 in the rear. It's time to just put 2 people in the back and analyze. I seriously think you need to rethink before doing such a comparison. Well, production, lighting, scripting, locations, all as good as it always is! BUT, the basic premise is wrong, in my view! Social media is open to comment, so I expressed candidly.

@runsim_run 2 года назад

Oh boy 🤦‍♂️. Ok, the pricing makes them natural choices for someone shopping in the segment. Do you get a smaller crossover which drives better, or a larger crossover with more space? That’s the question which we illustrated our answers with. Secondly, two adults in the rear will be comfortable in most any car - have you been vastly uncomfortable in any car in recent memory sharing the rear bench with just another person?

@wayofliving365 2 года назад

Don't compare Punch with any vehicle. Iron And steel is very costly in the market. Go for a good build quality car not for a cosmetic looks in the car

@1502abhijit 2 года назад

The kiger also has a good crash test rating! So I don’t think this point is valid

@nithyaprasanth3510 2 года назад

@@1502abhijit only magnite is tested kiger isn't tested yet n 3.85m without turbo car n 4m car with turbo weights same

@1502abhijit 2 года назад

@@nithyaprasanth3510 it is the same vehicle with only the outer shell or the "top hat" being different. So the Kiger should also get the same score. That's my logic.

@thecrypticmystic28 Год назад

@@1502abhijit and your logic became true now with 4 star Kiger

@AyushNiranjan 2 года назад

Punch top end should be compared to Magnite/ Kiger Turbo as the price difference is not that much. Punch is quite expensive for what it offers, but nowadays all cars are getting expensive day by day The price between kiger Turbo and punch is just 45-50 k On the other hand the price difference of non turbo kiger and Punch is 72k ( punch is expensive) Still reviewers are comparing non turbo variants only.