TESTED: Can You Beat Minecraft With Only Nether Items?

Подписаться 1,9 млн

Просмотров 162 тыс.

50% 1

ONLY Items available in the nether is such a small subsect (less than 25%) of Minecraft's total items. Can we beat the entirety of the game using them?
Minecraft Bedrock is the same as Minecraft Windows 10, Minecraft Pocket Edition; or Minecraft Xbox One, PS4 & Switch
- The Previous Video($6 Emotes...):
• Minecraft Secretly Add...
- Think you've missed something? You might have, and you can check my most recent uploads here: / ibxtoycat
Update Adventures (My Let's Play):
• Update Adventures Let’...
- My Twitter: / ibxtoycat
- Follow for video updates and Early News!
This Video Was Edited By:
Benjamin
You can become a channel member by clicking here:
/ @toycat

Опубликовано:

25 сен 2024

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист

Посмотреть позже

Комментарии : 949

@gybody4653 4 года назад

I like how he casually has some ancient Debri under his crafting table

@nackle_k 4 года назад

lmao that annoyed me to no end

@jacobb.9369 4 года назад

debris*

@lex9659 4 года назад

debris*

@GrayMajik 4 года назад

It’s not like he could get it. Did you want him to mine and destroy it?

@hannahjoys9065 4 года назад

AHHHHH

@dzarthedemon4855 4 года назад

"Being in lava isn't good for anyone's health" Striders: Are we a joke to you?

@nebularspace 4 года назад

I feel ashamed I made the likes go from 69 to 70. 69 is better

@nygelterns4683 4 года назад

Yes

@sealer101gaming6 4 года назад

Nice user pic

@danish2.012 4 года назад

Well you can un-like it

@nygelterns4683 4 года назад

@@danish2.012 what do you mean that i can un like it???

@trentonrandall9733 4 года назад

7:32 He could have killed that chicken since chickens do in fact spawn in the nether, albeit rarely

@mega_gamer93 4 года назад

Not in bedrock edition

@ella614 4 года назад

Zombified Piglins on chickens spawn and the pigman despawns

@mega_gamer93 4 года назад

@@ella614 not in bedrock edition

@goku_jerome1732 4 года назад

he doesn't play java and I'm almost certain that's a java exclusive

@imakebadvideos 4 года назад

Mega Gamer93 not on *bugrock edition

@starbot9828 4 года назад

I love how he just smacks the pigs with their deceased relatives. 7:54

@jayarnold28 3 года назад

I did that once

@haru-chan8762 8 месяцев назад

@@jayarnold28non descript mischief

@stonkspvp4631 4 года назад

Toycat: ignores the ancient debris under his crafting table

@elnkr2603 4 года назад

Well, he wouldn't be able to get it anyway

@toycat 4 года назад

The editor decided to cut the sequence where I was wildly frustrated with not being able to get it (no diamond pickaxe, no iron for a smithing table) haha

@maxcampbell-reide4131 4 года назад

@@toycat why did you not craft a flint and steel at the beginning and burn your pigs before eating them? You do not need a crafting table for that.

@lanty2092 4 года назад

NM Trindle - Randomness and more bruh he had iron from the mineshaft

@tinkersdinkers 4 года назад

@@maxcampbell-reide4131 he did bro

@BeaSDT 4 года назад

18:00 In the Nether, with a bucket and near lava, hmm... I feel like we've been over this before... Nah, I must be wrong, sticks are the way to go.

@JimJamYT 4 года назад

Lol

@toastr1255 3 года назад

And not to mention the coal he got from the wither skeleton

@nestfourthreetwoone 4 года назад

13:22 actually they aren’t 3 blocks tall, just more than two. I learned this when I accidentally shoved a wither skeleton into a 2.5 block gap and it didn’t take suffocation damage

@eisaranderee610 4 года назад

Noah Spencer-Thompson If it isn't a full block you don't take suffocation damage If it is transparent you don't take suffocation damage

@nestfourthreetwoone 4 года назад

Eisa Randeree oh cool. But from personal experience I can say that a wither skeleton can snuggly fit in a 2.5 block space with a bit of “encouragement”

@timbtw3656 4 года назад

2,2 i believe

@4wdsquirrel48 4 года назад

I think they’re 2.4

@20oxide36 4 года назад

You would have to experiment with some snow for the exact height (or just Google it).

@imgay4889 4 года назад

19:22 Andrew: being in lava isn't good for anyone's health, in real life or in minecraft Striders: 👁👄👁

@indidacoolkid4111 4 года назад

I see what happening yeah, you’re face to face with greatness and it’s strange, open your eyes let’s begin. Yes it’s really me, maui breath it in,

@redboot8 4 года назад

31:20 toycat: everything we have picked up and used can be found in the nether. *has 17 end stone in inventory

@terrylap6132 4 года назад

That’s really unavoidable because of The Ender Dragon (flies and breaks end stone) unless he threw them all out of the inventory halfway through the battle and risked dying

@samhain4287 3 года назад

The dragon doesn't break end stone.

@EwanMcG67 3 года назад

@@samhain4287 yes it does

@jordanferta8212 3 года назад

@@EwanMcG67 the dragon cant break any block that naturally spawns on the first end island. which obviously includes end stone.

@BSJINTHEHOUSE420 4 года назад

“Can You Beat Minecraft With Only Nether Items?” Speedrunners: You guys are using items?

@eisaranderee610 4 года назад

BSJ IN YO HOUSE He is a speedrunner

@bl.edxardo 4 года назад

@@eisaranderee610 hes not lol

@goviknowsball 4 года назад

⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ he is lol

@TheStealthyOne6 4 года назад

Ye he is

@apexa903 4 года назад

⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ he is lol

@creeperizing4184 4 года назад

26:59 I love the way he went straight into the lava pit and blame on the creeper

@meg2831 4 года назад

I was thinking the same thing lol

@Juhnaaa 4 года назад

If you look on the roof he actually got flinged back by a creeper

@HarrisonGray 4 года назад

Normal people: Gold Armour Toycat: Gold Outfit

@rubydupyII 4 года назад

Hey

@10503. 4 года назад

Normal people: Mlg water bucket Toycat : MLG TWISTING VINES

@InfamousJRP 4 года назад

Haha

@melodysketchdraws 4 года назад

I appreciate the editor in this one, especially the "fun fact" bit near the beginning. "Mlg block placement"

@iam3gion204 4 года назад

15:54 toycat starts playing relaxing happy music Me: Things are about to go wrong

@LeoGuidi 4 года назад

Toycat: *Jumps into Lava* Also Toycat: DiD a CrEePeR eXpLoDe

@pegasz 4 года назад

Pause at 27:01. You can see exploding particles before he gets knocked into the lava

@CrimsonJay_ 4 года назад

Pegasz oh but why?

@josephmariun9680 4 года назад

Toycat: Nether items only Me: Struggles to beat normal bedrock with all items

@Scrambledggman 4 года назад

True

@bl.edxardo 4 года назад

how can you be so bad

@op-fb2cm 4 года назад

Forgot new line lol

@burningclaw8643 4 года назад

I struggle to beat it on easy.

@TAMusic 4 года назад

28:18 "if you want good armour, it has to come from the overworld" _* netherite armour cries in corner *_

@cakecatastrophe5624 4 года назад

Yes, but you need diamonds and it is rare in the nether.

@iamnabha9468 4 года назад

You need diamonds which come from the overworld but are in chests in the nether

@braydensmith2456 4 года назад

Irons in chests too

@braydensmith2456 4 года назад

It would just take a hell of a lot of nether fortresses

@damien2209 4 года назад

@@cakecatastrophe5624 it is in bastions tho

@melissayork227 4 года назад

Toycat: LETS DO A MINECRAFT CHALLENGE ON HARD DIFFICULTY AND BEAT THE GAME Me: I usually break a tree and then give up

@geckogeico2212 4 года назад

So play creative instead

@theparrot6516 4 года назад

@@geckogeico2212 dude he breaks the tree in creative? Smh lol

@razer1158 4 года назад

It's okay, Toycat, I'll do the math for you 16:45 4% of 13 damage(6.5 hearts) is 0.52 damage reduction, which means you take about half a heart of less damage with your golden helmet on. Ouch.

@NW-zg5qt 4 года назад

I love the new way of editing and all, but no offense, I don't enjoy all the jump cuts. The continuous and natural feeling is what makes this channel special and enjoyable

@connorcmusician 4 года назад

there's jump cuts in all of his 'beat the game without blank' challenges, it's inevitable

@toycat 4 года назад

@@connorcmusician yeah, the sad reality of a 3 hour run is it wouldn't be so exciting to watch by itself. Unless...

@TheDarklingWolf 4 года назад

@@toycat I personally love watching unedited full runs of stuff like this. Super comfy to have on in the background. Love the editing on this one, though.

@crush9955 4 года назад

27:20 He has 10 ender eyes, plus the one that was already there, it makes 11, which isn’t enough. Then 27:23, he has suddenly has 11 in his hot bar, plus the the one already there is all 12. Where did it come from?

@virscelestus 4 года назад

thank you. you seem to be the only other person who noticed

@dragostorm259 4 года назад

Also, the bow he got wasn't enchanted but it was when he entered The End

@KidPrarchord95 4 года назад

It looks like the editor cut out a lot of key stuff

@sarahdahlia94 4 года назад

He had ender pearls and blaze rods

@greenshrex7532 4 года назад

He had 14 pearls and 7 blaze rods

@arkesh110 4 года назад

25:29 lol the editor just used the transition from the nether clip

@OBLOblivion 3 года назад

also 24:46

@killer66z34 4 года назад

Toycat: Gravel is useless. Also Toycat: uses gravel for the entirety of the beginning of the challenge.

@LeapyLad 4 года назад

What else could he use

@gybody4653 4 года назад

Toycat: uploads everyone: straight to the comments me: realises im doing it too

@goose_9119 4 года назад

true

@kylefielder9664 4 года назад

true

@ebsck911 4 года назад

Can we PLEASE stop this template

@kylefielder9664 4 года назад

Why it’s a good comment

@tskjesusfreak 4 года назад

😁

@Serichuwu 4 года назад

I love the editing, Benjamin if you’re seeing this, keep up the great editing.

@NW-zg5qt 4 года назад

A few too many jump cuts though

@toastytoast9800 4 года назад

@@NW-zg5qt in my opinion, it makes yhe video more dynamic

@wiggletonthewise2141 4 года назад

He sucks at “maths” but he’s great!

@benjaminrogers2965 4 года назад

@greenshrex7532 4 года назад

Hopefully its like this but only in challenges

@iamMildlyUpsetWithMostOfYouTub 4 года назад

Technically he could’ve just killed the zombies and taken their flesh as a food source since zombie pigmen also drop rotten flesh.

@eisaranderee610 4 года назад

I despise a majority of human creations Zombies can spawn in the nether on java But that might be a bug

@iamMildlyUpsetWithMostOfYouTub 4 года назад

Eisa Randeree it’s a bug and I believe it’s because of the Reinforcement feature that the zombie and zombie pigman have where instead of a regular zombie pigman being summoned it’s glitched as a zombie since both have identical coding.

@byakuyatogami2905 4 года назад

@Leffe Monette zombified piglins used to be called zombie pig men, before regular piglins existed

@braydensmith2456 4 года назад

When I first heard this challenge idea (in one of your live streams) I was like “oh that’s just a starting in the nether challenge but easier”. I was definitely wrong though, seeing how hard it was to get to the nether. I’m definitely going to try it myself. Also, great editing by Ben

@alexbarton8692 4 года назад

17:52 can we just acknowledge that he has his crafting table on ancient debris

@alexcat6 4 года назад

i know right

@ExplosivePine 4 года назад

Yeah and It was at y 36

@pirayv3397 4 года назад

He replied to another comment and said that he was really frustrated but the editor cut that part out.

@mariarala5452 4 года назад

You cant obtain a diamond pick in the nether

@miko6161 4 года назад

Boredom: **exists** Toycat: *we don’t do that here*

@DarthPickleCT 4 года назад

I like this one

@darkfiire1647 4 года назад

Nobody likes these accounts that just beg for subs without putting any effort at all into there chanell

@Airy101skibidibopmmnndada 4 года назад

Nobody: This comment: *gives me brain damage*

@miko6161 4 года назад

Darkfiire 1 1 I don’t bet 2 I do put effort by commenting

@Airy101skibidibopmmnndada 4 года назад

Chicky Animations Nobody: You: disgusting bot

@jakefarmer 4 года назад

17:51 casually has an ancient debris underneath the crafting table

@geoffzheng5061 4 года назад

Wait... toycat technically can pick up the iron pic because both iron and sticks can be found in the nether...

@indidacoolkid4111 4 года назад

No u have to make it

@andrewrivera8651 4 года назад

Short answer: No Long answer: Maybe

@tickercruse3177 4 года назад

“Being in Lava isn’t good for anyone’s health” Magma Cubes being made of Lava: *excuse me?*

@kirane 4 года назад

I was just watching the no mining or crafting video when I got the notification lol

@tman4802 4 года назад

“If you want good armour it must come from the over world” Netherite: Am I a joke to you?

@xe5433 4 года назад

0:32 you can find chicken jockeys in the nether...

@ItsUtopia_ 4 года назад

NuruddinPlays they do, they come with baby zombie pigmen

@orangecitron4367 4 года назад

It's bedrock idk bedrock spawn chicken jockey but java y

@Laantin 4 года назад

Y'all talk about the netherite under his crafting table but y'all realize he doesn't have a diamond pick so he can't even mine it so it's just a random block

@mookydoodle3535 4 года назад

Red Dawva ancient debris

@PlaguedRat4469 4 года назад

I think I saw some emeralds in that ravine... also have you gotten a new editor?

@greenshrex7532 4 года назад

I think its the old one

@logical_harm 4 года назад

i paused the video to go find someone else who saw the emerald ore. thank you

@Wogsmawp 4 года назад

3:58 toy cat says that he’s in a dark place on hard mode Me laughs in gamma

@professionalb0at 4 года назад

This has to be one of the most entertaining Toycat videos I've watched in a while, the editing was great

@Ahmed-gu1vx 4 года назад

"Hello, I'm a next week hat"

@kevinlu1339 4 года назад

I ain't first, I ain't last. But when Toycat cat uploads, i click real fast.

@luislebronaponte2737 4 года назад

2:30 That "Oooh." with the shake tho. XD

@oofknight8199 4 года назад

Mojang: You want purple wood? Everyone: N- Mojang: WE GOT EM! Everyone: Actually, we want a lav- Mojang: Oh, Striders? EASY!

@clarencelol4921 4 года назад

Striders and the new nether wood r fine

@JediMediator 4 года назад

That save with the twisting vines might have been the best part of the video :)

@chaseallen7499 4 года назад

You can actually find diamond swords in the nether, I found one when in a Bastian place.

@aprettycoolname4839 4 года назад

You can get iron swords from Wither sleletons

@pirayv3397 4 года назад

@@aprettycoolname4839 *Stone

@katelynsakurasystem1811 4 года назад

@@pirayv3397 no you can get iron from them it's really rare though

@theminerboy5694 4 года назад

The editing was a bit glitchy in some places, but this was epic. Also, at the end of the run, Toycat had end stone in his inventory. I know he didn't use it, but still...

@indidacoolkid4111 4 года назад

It on axident

@CloudEdits 4 года назад

17:50 my guy found ancient debris and said nothing

@bl.edxardo 4 года назад

he cant use them so he didnt care

@Jevmin 4 года назад

He replied in another comment and said that he was really annoyed but the editor cut that part out.

@CloudEdits 4 года назад

@@Jevmin oh lol

@Hexatunes 4 года назад

5:48 I think there was a zombie with gold armour, you could've turned it into a drowned and gotten the armour because I'm pretty sure you can find gold armour in the nether.

@BigLettuce07 4 года назад

Hi Toycat, since I’m kinda early, I hope you see this and just want to say you’re so awesome! Keep up the great content!

@ohmumbo4483 4 года назад

never seen that comment before...

@diamond_chaos 4 года назад

Your earlyer than me

@jack16.29 4 года назад

This video was actually so entertaining. You're so genuine and the content and humour is amazing. Can't wait for similar vids!

@LadyTink 4 года назад

24:48 what was that nether image pan in all about XD

@saberm2006 4 года назад

I have two questions. 1. What is your favourite server on bedrock? 2. Are you ready to the new server (galaxite)?

@koasucks 4 года назад

Why at 24:48 there was a small picture that went out of frame rlly quickly and it showed a screenshot of you back in the nether fortress?!

@davidtheninja2924 4 года назад

Maybe editing bug

@crush9955 4 года назад

It happened more than once, one time he was talking about food, and it flashed a screenshot of a burning hoglin

@exieditor 4 года назад

It happened at least 5 times throughout the video (maybe even more) some were even seconds after a previous one, maybe a mistake or something even though idk how someone could make that many...

@crimson8349 4 года назад

Was probably editing key frames and added too many

@zacharylee7137 4 года назад

poor editing

@webster1211 4 года назад

No deaths?? Impressive, Toycat! Especially that MLG Twisting Vines save in the End! Great video.

@eisaranderee610 4 года назад

Toycat was so salty that after two streams of trying to beat the world record on a random seed glitchless he decided to do this

@lightcrowd42040 4 года назад

me:*sees that there is ancient beris under his crafting table* me again:*heads straight to comments*

@thepowerful7593 4 года назад

31:20 *laughs in endstone*

@mathiascroqvist4719 4 года назад

I came here from your "what happens when you spawn a piglin in the overworld on Peaceful." video. You had said that this video was something you worked hard on and was really excited for. I decided to watch it just for that reason and it shows that you really did put a lot of effort into this video. I'm happy i came here to watch it because it was really interesting to see you play the game in such a strange way. I hope more of your "passion" videos get more recognition like this one should.

@emeraldeye5664 4 года назад

Toycat: Igores Ancient Debris Me: Always take coal

@pample_mousse6429 4 года назад

Wow toycat really blew his budget making this video.

@domotron3598 4 года назад

Reading the subtitles at the start #1 "Hello I'm a next week hat"

@BlitzerXYZ 4 года назад

24:48 what an interesting little mistake from the editor

@beeswall1291 4 года назад

hey im doing this rn (before the video came out)

@dzarthedemon4855 4 года назад

30:27 I'm pretty sure that's the first Twisting Vine MLG ever done

@schad0008 4 года назад

Dzar The Demon nope, he did it in a snapshot video

@kianneedssleep9198 4 года назад

toycat you had end stone in your inventory when you won

@toycat 4 года назад

Oops! I never used it though!

@hazzamatazza 4 года назад

ibxtoycat your ok because you NEVER used it. Sorry

@vampyberry8318 4 года назад

The edit is very awesome and this is the challenge I want to attempt myself. You are one of my favorite youtuber

@PavePlayz 4 года назад

nobody: automatically generalted captions *hello i'm a next week hat*

@angryrat451 4 года назад

One my favorite things is when editors communicate through their editing on RU-vid videos.

@serbaneva4737 4 года назад

I don’t really like this style of editing... it feels like it’s going too fast and it takes away from the nice casual feel of your usual videos

@connorburbine9459 4 года назад

Do a realm experiment where there are no rules and everyone is stuck in the nether

@Clone54_ 4 года назад

10:50 Im so close to dead! Im so close to die!

@aloyperez2059 4 года назад

Me: checks the captions to see what its gonna say The captions: hello im a next week hat 😂😂😂

@oliver7496 4 года назад

I accidentally killed my pet pig today and I actually cried... and then there’s toycat, killing a hundred pigs in the first ten minutes.

@2ManosGamers 4 года назад

It's funny that he survives the Nether with no armor in hard difficulty and I die a lot with iron armor in normal difficulty

@Bry10022 4 года назад

31'20 Toycat: ＊has 17 endstone in inventory＊

@ebsck911 4 года назад

The editing made this even better, nice one Benjamin...haven’t finished yet but I already know it’ll be great

@dajam9035 4 года назад

17:51 yep just random ancient debris chilling under a crafting table 😂

@Benthehuman 4 года назад

I really liked the editing at the beginning of the video. It adds so much more to the video but it still feels like something that you would make, it still feels like I'm listening to just you and that's why I like it so much.

@AR15ORIGINAL 4 года назад

So, by living in the Nether for a long time, you could walk around getting diamond from chests until you had a little over diamonds (enough for full armor set and tools, plus enchantment table), plus ~36 netherite scraps (to turn everything into netherite), and theoretically make yourself a fully enchanted God Set (Protection IV on all armor pieces, Sharpness V sword, everything having Unreaking III and Mending, two netherite pickaxes so one has Silk Touch and another one Fortune... Make a Nether only survival run which aims to get yourself a full godset!

@Lord-dn7xp 4 года назад

28:20 that music makes mappers very happy

@presummit2146 4 года назад

2019: MLG Water 2020: MLG Twisted Vine

@trentthen642 4 года назад

Toycat: *beats the game on hard difficulty with only nether resources* Me: *cant even beat the game on easy mode with all resources allowed*

@miko6161 4 года назад

Toycat: posts Everyone: *goes straight to the comments*

@Renosen 4 года назад

ITS LITTERALLY JUST SOME SEC AGO

@ThatOneGamerDoodle 4 года назад

Yep

@oliverholland6512 4 года назад

Toy cat:posts You: rush to the comments to spam this annoying comment to get subscribers Me:rushes to the comments to find this comment and reply to it

@Renosen 4 года назад

@@ThatOneGamerDoodle yes

@Renosen 4 года назад

@@oliverholland6512 just want to reply to a commebt made like 10 seconds ago

@IndigoGollum 4 года назад

1) Just disable the map in world options so you don't have to throw it out for speedruns and some challenges. 2) You could have killed the cows and only kept the leather, as hoglins drop leather. 3) The priorities map could have easily been a written book or book & quil.

@sethpham729 4 года назад

Toycat: goes in lava Toycat:"I think a creeper exploded or something" 27:02

@cuff1626 4 года назад

well done toycat for an unique challenge

@PashaGamingYT 4 года назад

You've already beaten it with NO items... I don't see how you could EVER top that again.

@Zees-bw4gq 4 года назад

Things: Warped Crimson Gold Nuggets/Ingots Mushroom Pork chop Glow stone ShroomLight Diamond Gold Iron Ingots/Nuggets Lantern Soul Stuff String Basalt Magma Soul Sand Chest Gold Block Wart Block Warped Wart Block (then why isn’t there warped wart?) Leather (cows and Hoglins drop it) Ancient Debris Quartz Those were all the stuff founded in nether possible and netherite scrap even PIGSTEP Snout Soul Speed 3 It’s possible the netherite is the most hardest thing to get

@PunchPunchPunchPunch 4 года назад

Coal, blackstone, soul soil, diamonds, chicken, feathers, eggs, (If you really stretch it), string, arrows, bows, golden apples, gunpowder, ghast tears, blaze rods, nether fort stuff, horse armor, saddles, ender pearls, clocks, bells, crying obsidian, golden carrots, fire resistance potions, and on java the spectral arrow.

@GeorgeIsInactive 4 года назад

Binge watching toycat videos and previous live streams for over a week now, thanks for the background English sound. Cheers bro.

@revivedreality 4 года назад

Toycat:everything that we've used today is found in the nether! Me:I never knew end stone spawned in the nether

@d4nj0n35 4 года назад

17:33 U can make a fishing rod because string is obtainable in the nether by killing strides as they drop it so u could craft a warped fungus on a stick as sticks are obtainable in the nether now

@catzvrgaming4352 4 года назад

“ can you beet mineCraft with only nether items?” “Sadly I can’t get this dog becouse you can’t find wolfs in the nether” Dog: DID YOU JUST CALL ME AN ITEM!!??

@coledog10 4 года назад

Nice idea! Btw flint and steel does not require a table to make, so you could've had a weapon sooner

@persomalaccount1797 4 года назад

I appreciate the boost in quality, and it still feels some what like a toy at vid

@peterschimpf6620 4 года назад

12:44 background piglin goes for a swim

@officialsomaliaball6373 4 года назад

2:46 you can see if you look at the right wall there are emeralds!!!! Although those aren’t available to him as there aren’t emeralds in the Nether, I don’t think?