Тёмный

The BEST Tires for Snow & Ice Tested! Nokian vs Michelin vs Continental vs Yokohama vs Cooper + more 

Tyre Reviews
Подписаться 240 тыс.
Просмотров 357 тыс.
50% 1

This is a test of the best winter tires in snow and ice, please share and subscribe!
These tires are called different things in different parts of the world. In North America / USA, they're generally just called winter tires, but in Europe they're called nordic winter tyres, soft compound winter tyres, extreme winter tyres, studless winter tyres.
Whatever you call them, they have the same design goal, to be as good as possible in the snow and ice, without using studs.
Here's the link to adjust the winter tyre test results: www.tire-reviews.com/Tyre-Tes...
So, which is best? To find out I have taken ten of the most popular winter tyres on the market, and will be testing them in the snow, dry and wet, noise, comfort and rolling resistance!
The tyre size I'm testing is massively popular 205/55 R16, and to highlight the differences between this category of winter tire, I have included a central european winter tire and a studded winter tire!
In this winter tire test we have:
Continental ContiVikingContact 7
Cooper Weathermaster S100
Federal Himalaya ICEO
Michelin X-Ice Snow
Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5
Pirelli Ice Zero FR
Yokohama Iceguard IG53
Continental WinterContact TS870 (Central European winter tire)
Nokian Hakkapeliitta 10 (Studded winter tire)
The full article with all the data can be found on the Tire Reviews website here:
www.tire-reviews.com/Article/...
=======
Please review your tires at www.tyrereviews.com !
=======
Follow me on instagram for all the latest tyre related updates: / tyre_reviews
=======
00:00 Introduction
00:35 The Winter Tires on Test
01:35 Ice Handling
04:45 Ice Traction / Braking
05:07 Snow Handling
07:13 Snow Traction / Braking
07:38 Wet Grip
09:14 Aquaplaning / Hydroplaning
11:06 Dry Grip
11:51 Noise and Comfort
12:13 Fuel Use
12:30 Final Results

Авто/Мото

Опубликовано:

 

15 июн 2024

Поделиться:

Ссылка:

Скачать:

Готовим ссылку...

Добавить в:

Мой плейлист
Посмотреть позже
Комментарии : 898   
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Thanks for watching, go review your tires over at www.tire-reviews.com ❤ Just FYI the Bridgestone Blizzak WS90 should be in this test, but I couldn't get them over to Europe in time (the rest of the tires are sold in both Europe and North America)
@raphaelmabo5014
@raphaelmabo5014 Год назад
For the north European market (Scandinavia) Bridgestone sells the Blizzak Ice (VRX2) instead of the WS90. The Blizzak Ice has better grip on ice, but are not as good in deeper snow and slush as the WS90.
@tire_reviews
@tire_reviews Год назад
@@raphaelmabo5014 Good info, thanks
@francescovalente582
@francescovalente582 Год назад
In Europe there is also the Blizzak DM-V3. Any info on that one?
@raphaelmabo5014
@raphaelmabo5014 Год назад
@@francescovalente582 The DM-V3 is for larger dimensions and SUV’s. It has been tested in scandinavian magazines and rated as medium grade or mediocre. It doesn’t beat the class leaders (Continental, Nokian, Michelin, GoodYear, Pirelli) in any area, but it’s also not as bad as chinese budget tyres. It’s comparable to Kumho, Hankook and Falken studless for snow and ice.
@poplaurentiu4148
@poplaurentiu4148 Год назад
@@francescovalente582 Good Year is missing as well..
@anthonyc8499
@anthonyc8499 Год назад
This guy is the benchmark of tire testing on two sides of the Atlantic.
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Thanks, it's been a rough year of travel so that's particularly appreciated.
@dmalikovski
@dmalikovski Год назад
@@tyrereviews absolutely. Please do not forget the noise tests for summer tires. You are the only one that does it right!
@TheTallRaver
@TheTallRaver Год назад
Yes, he is unmatched!
@jimbeaug22
@jimbeaug22 Год назад
False !
@bennylloyd-willner9667
@bennylloyd-willner9667 Год назад
@@jimbeaug22 I'm curious why you show negative criticism but won't tell us why. It's hard to improve just by "False!"
@roccosperanza
@roccosperanza Год назад
I love how much data you put in your tests! It might not be obvious, but I'm certain your tests will save lives. It only takes one person purchasing a better set of tires to prevent an accident. Thanks for the thorough testing!
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
I've had some comments from people who have narrowly avoided crashes on good tires, as long as it's helping people I'm happy
@jabberwockytdi8901
@jabberwockytdi8901 Год назад
+1 , People buying rubbish tyres to save 40-80 £/$ on a set is a pet peeve of mine.
@poplaurentiu4148
@poplaurentiu4148 Год назад
@@tyrereviews Tank you sir for providing with such detailed info (is not easy job you did work a lot obviously to gather all this precious info ) and keep doing this great work helping out most people to understand better to get what they suit better they 'r needs ..
@EssPhour
@EssPhour Год назад
I've always believed auto insurance companies should give discounts to people who run snow tires in places that have to drive on snow and ice, if they collected the data I am confident it would show car accidents are lower among those driving with snow tires.
@shitsandwich1983
@shitsandwich1983 Год назад
i had an emergency braking scenario in the summer and my michelin ps4s stopped me within feet of a crossing car. this channel was the main reason i had opted for those tires. thankyou!
@Alanvictoryoung
@Alanvictoryoung Год назад
I’m in BC, Canada and I went with Michelin X-ice Snow as we have cold wet conditions most of the time but I live high enough on the mountain to get a snow. Plus trips to the ski mountains and tournaments around the province, the tire was a great choice. I watch you videos before every tire purchase and I appreciate the safety and confidence I get reviewing your data and experience for my family driving needs. Thank you.
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Glad you made a good pick, get a review on the site if you have some free time 😁
@pliedtka
@pliedtka Год назад
I usually stay with Nokia as they literally saved my life almost there decades ago. My friend swears by WS-80, Toyo GS-i 5, now replaced by newer model, and a few others typical Nordic tires.
@mercedesbenzs600bash
@mercedesbenzs600bash Год назад
On a scale of 1-10 how good are they??
@igorcvetkovic2112
@igorcvetkovic2112 Год назад
I am in Alberta, Canada, still using Nokian studded Haka 7 on SUV from 2012, and 10 years later and more than 50k winter milage, still stopping and handling great in snow and ice.
@miketeeveedub5779
@miketeeveedub5779 Год назад
I've got Michelin's as well here in southern Manitoba, where it goes to -30c regularly. They're mounted on my Ford sedan with AWD. They are incredible on glare ice and snow. Absolute mountain goat! I couldn't imagine driving in a Canadian winter without them.
@marlinnotfish
@marlinnotfish Год назад
I just endured my first snow storm after installing continental vikingcontact 7’s and I am blown away. I’ve never had snow tires before and I moved to a region that is more or less freezing for 4 months out of the year wirh roads that don’t get plowed much. I don’t know how I ever lived without snow tires.
@TheTallRaver
@TheTallRaver Год назад
Yet another fantastic test! Thank you for your methodological approach! Educating people about tyres is what you really do best! I think we all appreciate the hard work you put into it Jonathan! Keep it up!💪💪💪
@Someoneonthisplanet1979
@Someoneonthisplanet1979 Год назад
I am living in Alberta Canada in the rockies and just had the Nokians R5 mounted under my SUV. They are absolutely amazing to drive with. The car feels like a tank in the snow, so much grip.
@alexeirotari3761
@alexeirotari3761 Час назад
Посмотришь на Nokian через 2️⃣ или 3️⃣ сезона. Дальше -хуже. Nokian supper резина в первый год эксплуатации, потом она дубеет( твердеет -сохнет) и трескается. В отличии от Michelin. Я на Nokian and Nordman ездил в северной части России в Мурманске и всей области, на шипах. Супер! Но потом она высохла и потрескалась. В Германии я катаюсь на Michelin alpin 5. А на задней оси Continental wintercontakt ts860 ( которые тоже начинает трескаться) в отличии от michelin.
@marcvalme7732
@marcvalme7732 Год назад
Thank you for including tires available in North America! You keep saying that people don't want long videos! Who are these people! Release the 45 minute directors cut!
@TheDiggs1012
@TheDiggs1012 Год назад
Fantastic job with this review. I really love the practical approach you took. You also understand how things like temperature variants from start to finish of a test can skew the results. I appreciate the depth of understanding. Keep up the great work!
@TMM6900
@TMM6900 Год назад
This is the video I'm waiting for! From Canada!
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Hope you enjoyed it!
@AlexStyvon
@AlexStyvon Год назад
WOW!! Finally an unbiased sponsored review did for Extreme winter tire!!! Especially usefull for north american market! It only miss the Brigestone WS-90 to have THE perfect test!! It's a real delight to see somebody else say; "Your best winter tires depend on your location!". Your CE winter tires REALLY give the comparaison!!
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Glad it was helpful!
@AlexStyvon
@AlexStyvon Год назад
@@tyrereviews You confirm my choice on my next set of Michelin over my 2 yrs old cracked Hakka 9. Your the only one to really take seriously rolling resistance in the test. So thanks for my Tesla! P.s; You have got an e-mail!
@adamfrost9048
@adamfrost9048 Год назад
Amazing video as always, the effort that goes into collecting accurate data is so much appreciated!
@Boxster17b
@Boxster17b Год назад
I just purchased a set of X-Ice Snow on sale over Labor Day, so this makes me extremely happy with that choice. I'm out in Eastern Canada and it sounds like this will be a huge upgrade over the old Uniroyal winter tires I'm replacing. Wasn't happy with those last winter and with a second kid on the way, I'm trying to do my best to keep the family safe out there on the roads. Appreciate you taking the time to be so thorough in your testing!
@firstandlastname2390
@firstandlastname2390 Год назад
I am sure you will like it.
@ArshMellow
@ArshMellow Год назад
Your reviews alone makes me decide on my tires every 2 ish years. Keep them coming!
@danielsloan
@danielsloan Год назад
Amazing review. Thanks for your attention to detail and dedication to carefully explaining the differences between tires.
@trevorshields7347
@trevorshields7347 Год назад
The best tyre comparison channel bar none. Appreciate your time, effort and information in all your uploads
@nate7906
@nate7906 Год назад
I have been waiting for this video all year! Thanks.
@garyg3617
@garyg3617 Год назад
Great review, thank you. I am glad I have a set of Nokian as our winter tyres and will be using them again when I have to replace ours.
@davetravels9273
@davetravels9273 Год назад
Colorado here, I have the Michelin X-ice snows and the Continental Viking Contact 7s on our two cars. I have had them for one year and had them installed 2 weeks ago for the winter. Some thoughts after putting them on: The Michelins drive so nice no matter the conditions, they have almost no effect on fuel economy, but they are much noisier. I immediately noticed how loud they are after putting them on this year. The Continentals are much quieter and grippier, but when they go, they go. 😂 I decided not to get the Nokians because we have lots of dry days in Colorado and they spray lots of chemicals on the roads making them wet when it snows, but not enough to cause hydro planning. Ultimately, I have the Michelins on my wife’s small hatchback that mostly stays in the city and they have enabled her to get home when trucks with A/T tires were sliding off the road. I have the Continentals on my Subaru Outback and we take it to the family cabin all winter, which includes 7 miles of unpaved, snow packed roads. The Continentals have been an absolute life-safer, getting us out of the cabin with up to 10 inches on the road, while other trucks and Subarus were getting stuck or sliding off the road, the Continentals just kept gripping. What’s more is that they are so good in the other weather we have in Colorado the rest of the winter. Like you said, all three are excellent and it really depends on your use case. For the Rockies, the Continentals are king, the Michelins are good, but not quite up to the mountain weather here and the Nokians are too focused on extreme winter weather to be good the other 80% of the time here.
@cbickel2009
@cbickel2009 Год назад
super useful too me on the Vikings, thanks
@ImranShamsul
@ImranShamsul Год назад
How bad are we talking when the Contis "go"...😅😅😅
@davetravels9273
@davetravels9273 Год назад
@@ImranShamsul They go without warning. You go from grip to a slide in a second, but it has only happened to me on roads where the snow has turned to ice and there is no warning. Other tires will also struggle on ice, but they might communicate that to you better. That being said, I just steer into it and on my Subaru I have learned that if you hit the brakes a little it immediately regains traction and straightens out, but that’s on an AWD vehicle, which only Audi, Porsche and Subaru offer. Other systems that are FWD or RWD based will behave differently. That being said, the Vikings have so much more grip than the other winter tires I have driven that it usually isn’t an issue. The Vikings have caught me off guard twice on ice in two winter seasons and each time I was able to quickly regain control.
@giorgio.
@giorgio. 8 месяцев назад
Thanks for your detailed comparison. I’ve been hesitating between the Continental Viking Contact 7 and Michelin X-Ice Snow since last year. I live in Montreal, Canada where we get a lot of snow, but roads are usually quickly plowed and salted, so it’s mostly either very cold and dry or warmer and slushy wet before it gets colder and icy. My driving is a mix of city streets and highways. I’m leaning towards the Contis, I have the ExtremeContact DWS06 Plus as summer tires on my FWD Saab 9-5, so why not stay with Continental. My current winters are old X-Ice (not snow), the tread is still good, but they’re too old and need to be replaced. They’ve been fine, but I want something better, comfy and quiet enough for a winter tire. Also my car is a manual, I feel it’s easier to correct when it’s breaking traction than an automatic thanks to instant engine brake when you let go of the gas pedal.
@l3v4rt
@l3v4rt Год назад
Awesome content as always Jonathan! With the CE tires I have been happy with both Conti TS line as well as Nokian WRD4 that lacked a bit of aceleration grip but made up with braking and lateral grip and saved a couple of sketchy situations. Thanks for another great video - looking forward to a new one!
@EV-olution
@EV-olution Год назад
This video and detailed review is fantastic and by far one of the best winter tire reviews I have seen or read. I am currently working on a winter wheel and tire video for my EV6, so the information in this video is incredibly beneficial since I was unable to get anyone from Goodyear, Michelin, or Nokian to return my messages. I was only able to get some basic information from a Continental Tire product manager. So once again, thank you very much. I just subscribed.
@igorcvetkovic2112
@igorcvetkovic2112 Год назад
thank you for all the tests you do, it certainly helps when planning a tire purchase
@DavidTheScientist
@DavidTheScientist 3 месяца назад
Went to northern Finland in February, with temps ranging from -5c to -29c. Our rental car (Merc A-class FWD) had a new set of Hakkapellitta 10s fitted. It was only my 2nd time driving in snow, but the Nokkians quickly helped me feel confident. In northern Finland roads are only plowed, not treated, it was so nice being able to drive 8 hours without having to wipe the windscreen once due to salty muck like you get in other places. It also made me realise how incredibly varied winter conditions can be, with seemingly an endless amount of variation in traction conditions. Generally, the road was covered in a thin packed snow layer, with tyre tracks exposing the asphalt on the driving line; these tracks seemed to have a thin layer of icy frost. The Nokkians were very impressive; I'm not sure if the studs helped with traction much, but braking action was generally excellent. Same in hardpack snow, I was shocked that I could drive at (almost) normal speeds down a country lane with little kick-in of the ABS/TCS/ESC. When a couple cm of fresh powder fell over the hardpack, it did become much slippier, presumably as the treads no longer penetrated the hardpack. I almost put the car into a snowbank on a tight corner before I'd got used to the different traction levels. All the same, very impressive, and the car still felt safe and predictable providing speed was dropped and you slowed enough for the corners. In fact, I even did what is generally advised against: driving down an unplowed country road after 3-5cm of powder had fallen over the hardpack. I couldn't resist trying, as the road cut 30+ mins off the journey. After the first km, I kept going, as I was confident with the traction levels, and it did indeed give us a good time saving over the main highway. Seeing the snow cloud behind me in the rear-view was quite satisfying... Only thing that surprised me was that sometimes on the main road, where the asphalt was visible but frosty, the tyres would really spin up easily when accelerating away from a junction... I kind of expected them to grip better in this scenario, but I guess it was icier than it looked. Again, thankfully braking on the same surfaces was more assured. Overall, a really interesting experience, and fun to see what the best winter tyres out there can and can't do in the harshest winter conditions... As a fun aside, I also cycled 40km on the snowy (but plowed) cycle paths of Oulu in -25c. Even the bike tyres are studded, and they were also really impressive, giving much better grip than walking, even vs wearing snow boots.
@mikidof
@mikidof Месяц назад
Hey, I happen to be from Oulu, glad you were able to visit Finland during winter! I have an AWD car with the VikingContact 7 tires as my winter option. It’s a very good tire and I don’t feel like ever going back to studded tires.
@DavidTheScientist
@DavidTheScientist Месяц назад
@@mikidof Thanks! Yeah, I saw quite a few cars with the Viking Contacts also, they look like great tyres. Do they grip better than studded on bare asphalt/frosty asphalt?
@tadasstrikauskas1205
@tadasstrikauskas1205 Год назад
I really love your tests, that includes tyres from different categories.
@MrNicholg
@MrNicholg Год назад
I really appreciate the added context of specific temps and conditions here.
@thomasmeyers1286
@thomasmeyers1286 Год назад
Great review. The work you do and how you do it is much appreciated. Thank you.
@tl9819
@tl9819 Год назад
Watched your reviews a year ago, selected the Michelin Xice snow, great results. Ram promaster city work van, FWD. I was able to navigate steep hills up and down, stop predictably, and get going up hill from a stop. They build confidence in exteme conditions and helped us stay working during inclement weather. Worth the price, hoping to get 4+ seasons out of them. Thank you, Tyler from Seattle,WA USA
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Glad you're enjoying htem, get a review on the site sometime :)
@SPACEMIKEB
@SPACEMIKEB Год назад
I live in Florida and I was excited to see this video pop up in my feed! LOL! Thanks for the great videos!
@Painting_Inspiration
@Painting_Inspiration Год назад
Thank you Mr. Benson for this test and review. Your hard work is much appreciated. Its amazing how the competition have caught up to Nokian over the years. Your information is invaluable. Cheers.
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Thank you very much!
@haileybenson9714
@haileybenson9714 Год назад
Wow what beautiful places you’ve tested! You must have very good eyesight because seeing the track in the snow was hard! 😍😍😍 Tire technology is getting so impressive!
@basswars7060
@basswars7060 Год назад
Thanks for the great video. It inspired my to buy a set of Michelin X-Ice for my mother's Corolla as a Christmas gift.
@lindsaydempsey5683
@lindsaydempsey5683 Год назад
Another great video thank you, I recently damaged one of my very well worn Hak R2's and had to make a quick decision on the replacing the entire set. I watched the snow handling section of the video without watching the end, chose the R5. Today, three days later I had enough time to watch the full video was delighted to see you final recommendations, making me feel very comfortable with my choice of the R5. Location: Calgary, in Canada, these are dedicated winter only tyres. Snow and ice performance are my most important selection criteria. It rains very little here, but it snows pretty good, and if the snow hangs around, it evolves into polished packed snow, very much like ice. The Hak R2's were brilliant for these conditions, looking forward to seeing how good the R5's are 🙂
@caloyvicente500
@caloyvicente500 Год назад
Thanks for the effort and review and telling me to wait and watch this review based on my comment on your other winter tire video. I’ve had both the Michelin and the Nokian and I like them both with the Nokian edging out the Michelin by a narrow margin based on where I live
@rhinosteveo
@rhinosteveo Год назад
I really appreciate the comparison to a performance winter tire, and this helped solidify my decision to get Michelin Pilot Alpin 5 winter tires for my M3 while living in the Seattle area.
@blacksaxcam
@blacksaxcam Год назад
One of your best tests yet, well done! Great to see the wet and dry tests under 7C. I find the category comparisons highly valuable. Why no Goodyear? Wintercommand Ultras (I bought a set last year)?
@aaronsmithanik4961
@aaronsmithanik4961 Год назад
Nice video! I personally use Nokian on both vehicles and love them. Studded Nokian Haks are incredible. I love in northern BC Canada and commute 150 km's round trip to work and feel comfortable with the Nokians.
@Line-vw5io
@Line-vw5io Год назад
Always look at your channel when someone asks me which tire to choose 😉 I have now the Continental WinterContact TS830P as a all winter tire on my M2. Love this one. Perfect on dry, wet, snow and feels sporty (life in Belgium and go skiing 3x a year in the dolomites, always without chains) The biggest problem on the M2 (LCI) is the lack of weight on the back. For the rest... Fun fun fun. When I have to change the tires, I will go for the ts870. Thank for all the info always.
@stephensmith2260
@stephensmith2260 Год назад
i just bought a bmw M3 x drive competiton & i live in boston / Rhode island. I only watch to see where the Michelin winter tires Rank in or your tests. they seem to come in on the top 3 or in 1st place in every internet test ive seen. Great channel! You are my go to for tire reviews from now on! very informative. Great job man keep it up.
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl Год назад
You bought a M3 competition and you think Michelin x-ice extreme ("nordic") winter tires are the right ones for your car? I've never heard of any Europeans including Fins ever putting those on M3's or any performance car. We here use "CE winter tires" like Continental TS 870, Michelin Pilot Alpin 5, Bridgestone LM 005,Pirelli Sottozero... Those are significantly (dramaticaly) better in wet or dry but still pretty good on snow. Watch the test again and pay attention to the "reference tire" ( Continental TS 870) results and comments. If you're not driving in snow and ice for 4 months straight like Inuits or penguins x-ice are not for you.
@danbraun5807
@danbraun5807 Год назад
Nice catch on the poor aquaplaning resistance of Nokians. I've been driving R3's for the past three years and twice I almost went off the road or into the oncoming lane going through deep water. Never experienced anything like it. Otherwise they were great and I just bought a new set of R5's this afternoon. Thanks to your test I know I'll still have to slow down during sudden torrential rain.
@j.alexanderbakeriii8655
@j.alexanderbakeriii8655 Год назад
Thank you! Very Helpful and comprehensive testing. I live in the Green Mountains in Vermont in very snowy conditions on a dirt road and have the Conti VikingContact 7s and they are exceptional. I put them on my Subaru Outback in November and take them off sometime in April.
@mikehup2383
@mikehup2383 6 месяцев назад
Excellent review and thank you! On my wife’s Subaru Crosstrek, our last snow tire was the studless Nokian , which we LOVED! After 5 winters on the Nokians, we just installed Michelin Ice-X Snow tires. I’m sure we’ll love these as well. They were about $250 cheaper for 4 tires.
@Spirited282
@Spirited282 Год назад
Your test and reviews are always the best. I just ordered a set of Nokian Hakkapeliitta R5 for my SUV, hope they do well
@firstandlastname2390
@firstandlastname2390 Год назад
The best winter tire review! I am so happy to see an independent testing, especially for the Nokian R5 as it was not tested yet. I wanted to buy this tire but my concern was how good it would be in snow. I am glad to know the good result. I have a feeling that this tire will not be the best in slush, deep snow and aquaplaning so it is good to be aware of that when driving.
@TomNyon
@TomNyon Год назад
i drove it a few weeks ago under a E-tron Gt and it was good in so many ways.
@poplaurentiu4148
@poplaurentiu4148 Год назад
He missed the Bridgestone Blizzak as well one of the top winter tires..
@smallwhitefox142
@smallwhitefox142 Год назад
the nokian tires are developed in finland, where there rarely is that much water on the roads during winter tire season, thus aquaplaning is not the number one concern for them when developing the tire. And honestly no tire performs very well in slush, since it stays under your tire like snow, but behaves like water otherwise, making it really slippery no matter the tire.
@barzinimongo
@barzinimongo Год назад
I live in northen Scandinavia and I will never choose anything else then Nokian or Continental winter tires, maybe just Nokian with studs, I had the hakkapelita 8(studded) on my Saab 9-3, such amazing tires, I guess hakka10 is just as good or better.
@nappyjim
@nappyjim Год назад
Great video. I got 325k + miles on my Outback in Minnesota, USA. First set of winter tires were General Altimax Arctic 8's. Those things lasted a long time. Then got Bridgestone Blizzaks, only lasted me 2 winters before tread was right at 4mm. I just picked up some Michelin X-Ice's now. Came across your video, seems like I made a good choice!
@DM72513
@DM72513 Год назад
Just discovered your channel. Awesome stuff my dude. In the U.S. the Michelin X-Ice Snow's have a $150 off through 10/23 and I'm grabbing those for our Forester XT after you confirmed it's abilities.
@leonv1553
@leonv1553 Год назад
Hello from Used To Be The Wet Coast of western BC, Canada. Way too dry for the huge trees now. So we find the old wet road tire prioritizing gone. Now we need "damp road", dry, cold and snow grip, good ride on cheaply made highways, and quite a dollop of performance. With all those considerations in mind, we soon tossed the nasty OE tires on our family Mini Countryman JCW awd, manual, no cursed sunroof. Yes, it feels like a family rally car. This car is going on snowy ski trips and tearing up twisty roads all the time. The winner thusly was, Nokian All Weather in the stock 225/50 x 18 V rating. As long as pressures are fussed over, they are nearly perfect. Steering, braking, acceleration is ample on all surfaces. The nearly is because at over .7 Gs in mid corner, they start to slide a bit. The slip and re grip is very progressive, so the Mini JCW can happily do it's thing. The specified pressures are 36 to 41 psi on our Mini, depending on average speeds. I leave it at 40 for fast trips and 38 for a mix. I know the real winter tires are a bit better in real winters. These All Weathers claw up snowy hills I cant walk up. Will we buy them again? It is on set #2.
@mausyyy85
@mausyyy85 3 месяца назад
Amazing Test Jonathan! For the winter holidays in Norway , i am waiting for the Viking Contact 8 which will be released in Autum 2024, the Nokian R5 is also a very nice tyre!
@razered
@razered Год назад
Great content as always. Really enjoy your videos and your insights. You do great work and you no doubt help save countless lives with your recommendations regarding safety and common sense of driving. I live in a Nordic country and we get stupid winters with all sorts of conditions. Really tough to actually find a right tyre for myself since we get it all. Deep snow, deep slush, ice, wet roads due to heavy salting and dry roads since sometimes theres sun... And I happen to run CE winter tires and havent died yet. The trick here is that I mostly drive on main roads and city streets and those are fairly well maintained. I put wet performance as my top priority due to salted roads and it works fine. Also, common sense and defensive driving is the key here since even the best tire wont save you if you do stupid stuff. I thank you for your great content again and hope to see cool new tests in the future.
@gedfi
@gedfi Год назад
I must say though that CE "winter" tires in the Nordics turn absolutely lethal under some weather conditions. And as the road conditions can change quite rapidly, that can be very dangerous. You drive out in the morning, and it's ok - you return the same way in the evening and suddenly you're in trouble.
8 месяцев назад
Amazing work, thanks for doing this and sharing the results with us!
@Kaiju007
@Kaiju007 Год назад
I've had the Blizzak WS70 on my Acura, X-Ice3 on my Genesis, and now picked the VikingContact 7 for my BMW which arrives this week!
@henryharder3823
@henryharder3823 Год назад
I enjoy your videos . Good info .Over the years I've tried a number of different winter tires . Almost any of them will blow away an all season , especially in harsh winter driving conditions . I'd say any premium winter tire like the top three or four on your list , really comes down to preference ,, or price . The last set I bought are Continental Viking , now in the fourth season , somewhere between 90 & 100 thousand km behind them . And still offer impressive grip . 👏
@user-qp3hf3et1p
@user-qp3hf3et1p 9 месяцев назад
Just completed 5 years with Michelin X-ice versions this past winter here in northeastern Canada. So impressed that I have ordered a new set of 4, Michelin X-ice snow for winter 2023. This video only reinforces that I made the right choice.
@Redhawk24
@Redhawk24 Год назад
Yes!!!! Thank you for your hard work!
@danielmorin4366
@danielmorin4366 Год назад
Thank you for your extraordinarily work. I have a 2022 Prius Prime. Based on your work we had to settle on Micheline's X ICE 4 TIRES. We wanted the Hapakalita 10's but they were not going to be available any time soon. I did sport the Nokian Hapakalita 7's (studded) on our Honda CRV and they were fantastic. Sadly the CRV has moved on. Thank you again for your thorough and outstanding presentation.
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Where in the world are you?
@danielmorin4366
@danielmorin4366 Год назад
@@tyrereviews I live in northern Ontario Canada
@firstandlastname2390
@firstandlastname2390 Год назад
@@danielmorin4366 if you can find the Hakkapelliitta 10 I really recommend them.
@anthonyepp406
@anthonyepp406 Год назад
These reviews helped me select my preferred winter tire, I purchased the continental VikingContact 7 two years ago. I love them! I will never go back to all seasons in the winter. Thanks for the videos!
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Glad you like them!
@FermentedFish7
@FermentedFish7 Год назад
Thank you for the great review. Helped a lot!
@mickthomas5469
@mickthomas5469 Год назад
Thanks for another great informative and entertaining review 👍 2 years ago we moved to Nova Scotia Canada and got a new Subaru Crosstrek. I bought some Continental VikingContact7s on the strength of your review at the time. The area around Halifax is renowned for black ice - so that was my major concern. My wife mostly drives the car for work and with 2 winter seasons of about 20,000 km total (gentle driving) she has put practically zero wear on these tires!!!! 🤣 It was particularly fortunate as we had a sidewall damage incident requiring the tire to be replaced 😱 but with no appreciable wear on the tread we were able to get away with just replacing the damaged one instead of a full set - Praise the Lord 🙏
@rrshse6704
@rrshse6704 Год назад
Best test ever! I live in central Canada and Hakka 10 studded is my favourite tire. All others are like hockey pucks on ice.
@dakotac69wgs
@dakotac69wgs Год назад
Great work, I really appreciate the effort you and your team put into these tests. I have just purchased Toyo Observe GSI-6 HP for my 2022 Subaru WRX. I'll be sure to review them on your website after a winter in Alberta, Canada
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Thank you!
@jasonouellette6179
@jasonouellette6179 Год назад
I’ve had the GSI5’s on previous vehicles. Great tires, especially in deep snow. Can only imagine the 6’s will be a bit better.
@echozulualpha
@echozulualpha Год назад
Fantastic in-depth review!
@Dski9393
@Dski9393 8 месяцев назад
thank you! great test and review
@wesbez6226
@wesbez6226 Год назад
You are just fantastic. Great to get these videos
@mercedesbenzs600bash
@mercedesbenzs600bash Год назад
Really great review my man,very informative,maybe one day you can do a video testing snow rated all terrain tires on snow,ice and slush it'll be greatly appreciated...
@milk-it
@milk-it Год назад
Testing tyres in Nordic winter conditions is palpably problematic, due to the changing weather conditions, such varied conditions they need to be tested in, and time constraints. I think you did a very thorough job. When I lived in central Sweden, I only drove with studded tyres during winter and parts of late fall and early spring. I think driving on ice regardless of the tyre type is always a delicate affair.
@revnto7k
@revnto7k Год назад
Great video.. I run Viking Contact 7's on my car and I would buy them again. Very happy with all aspects of them thus far.
@camiloamaya6017
@camiloamaya6017 2 месяца назад
I came here because I thought I had decided to go with the viking7 but now I have three chance to get the R5s. My new Mercedes is arriving in hopefully 2 weeks and I wanted to get the winter tire shipping out of the way before Summer starts. I'm in Ontario, Canada and, with the exemption of this past winter, we get a lot of snow and sometimes some ice. My priority besides safety and handling is comfort / quietness. I've decided to go with the R5s. Thank you for such a detailed review. It's probably the best I've seen in years. In subscribing for sure
@rmoore07
@rmoore07 Год назад
Thanks for your hard work in producing another fantastic winter tire test! Will we be seeing a winter all-terrain test this year?
@alfiealfster11
@alfiealfster11 7 месяцев назад
Great content. Very thorough. I've struggled with a couple reviews when your subjective ratings don't really line up with the objective data (ie. AT review). However, having all the objective data and being able to focus on the categories important to me (ie. braking) is simply invaluable to tire selection. Between you, and TireR@ck, and some vehicle specific chat forums, the process of tire selection has gotten so much easier. I got a used Jeep GC recently and the OEM AT tires (GY Wranglers) are not up to snuff (getting really sketchy in rain/hydroplaning). I've been running dedicated winter tires for about 20 years now and was looking for a set before this winter. Previous cars were a FWD Nissan Maxima and AWD Infiniti G37x. I've previously run a Continental tire back in the mid-2000s (can't remember model - like a WinterContact 810/820/830-?). Then the Blizzak WS70 (awesome snow tires, but a bit noisy and wore very unevenly). Then Michelin X-ice Xi3 (glorified AS/AW tires - quiet, comfortable, long lasting, pretty good in rain and light to medium snow (0-4"), but hot garbage on ice/packed snow). And most recently one season with the Continental WinterViking7 on the G37x. The WV7 was all the good features of the Xi3, but with actual avg+ to great winter performance. Winter tires for the Jeep in stock sizes have been difficult to find, at least from the more reputable brands (265/60r18), and at a decent price. Mainly Blizzak DMv2 and Continental WinterViking7. I was leaning toward the Blizzaks because the Jeep is heavier but those tires/technology is getting a bit outdated (ie. dual layer compounds). After seeing this video, I've decided to stick with the WV7. I don't plan to go off-road in the winter and the WV7 performance in dry and wet braking is class leading. I already have experience with them and know they can perform outstanding in the winter. I even put a pair on my mom's little hatchback and she was amazed at how easily she can get around in the winter now. Also, the WV7 are $15-20 cheaper per tire than the Blizzaks, and $50-100 cheaper than most other brands, so why mess with a good thing. They should be going on next week...
@Joachim21100
@Joachim21100 Год назад
Very good test again, thanks!
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Thank you too!
@ronladuke7235
@ronladuke7235 Год назад
I have always found that stud less tires can be very good on frosty rough ice but when the sun shine or temperature starts melting the ice surface ( wet ice) studs are far superior as your testing showed. Good test!
@krebgurfson5732
@krebgurfson5732 6 месяцев назад
studded or non studded you're going to get better grip on colder ice... studs work better on colder ice. no they are not more effective on softer ice, you need the hard ice or the studs will drag through it easily.
@MarathonAuto1980
@MarathonAuto1980 9 месяцев назад
GREAT REVIEW! As a Nokian tire dealer since 1980 and selling winter tires since 1973 I can appreciate the time and effort it took to do this review. Very educational as most people (including most tire stores) do no take regional needs in consideration when choosing or recommending tires, or reading test and reviews. Bravo! I will be recommending this to our customers.
@gomanprepper
@gomanprepper Год назад
Thanks for the reviews, I live in the Vancouver area of BC, Canada and although my experience with Nokian All Weather Tires has been good, this winter I will be going up a large un-even hill below 7C. We get about two weeks of snow a year here but it's better to be safe. Although I hate having to change over tires, I'll get a second set of rims and went with the Michelin X Ice Snow.
@minivanin
@minivanin Год назад
When I had to drive much much more for work, I typically used Continental snow tires. Now with a 20mile commute, run mid tier stuff, currently Sumitomo snow tires. They are very good for the price.
@medicus1963
@medicus1963 Год назад
The best tire tests ever, because they are independent and performed with a lot of ambition!I have the ugly feeling that some of the tests from other sources are influenced. For example some automobile clubs don’t become tired emphasising how bad all seasons are. Logical because it’s a great loss of business for tire industry. For a very long time it’s the first test of Nordic tires, which are as well in CE interesting when man live in the alps. I rely at first on your tests when I buy a tire!
@makanjia
@makanjia Год назад
This is by far the best review I have come across for winter tires. Thank you for your thorough testing, its appreciated and for sure helped me make an informed decision. I live in Alberta, Canada where the winter temps can go up to -40c. Currently I have Nokian Hakka 3 on my SUV, and they have kept our family safe over last few years, but I am thinking of going for Michelin X-Ice this time. I love the Hakka 5 but I also keep the same tires during summer months (I know its not recommended but less hassle so...) and have experienced more aquaplaning with Hakka's. Any thoughts or recommendations if one is going to drive on same tires throughout the summer and winter.
@jasonroberge6336
@jasonroberge6336 Год назад
Great review as always from you. I do wish Blizzacks were in on the test as I was narrowing my purchase down to Blizzacks, Michelin, and Nokian. My last purchase went from Hakka 9 studded to Blizzacks, and am quite happy with the compromise change. I tried Michelin studded and they were so bad on the dry, I returned them.
@carlosoruna7174
@carlosoruna7174 Год назад
Dont let those blizzacks touch asphalt. They disintegrate
@nigelcampbell8460
@nigelcampbell8460 Год назад
One of the only Winter Tire comparisons videos this year. Michelin Xice Snow is my pick based on tire wear long term
@edwarddelderfield
@edwarddelderfield Год назад
Got Conti TS860s on my E Class estate. Game changing tyre, drives almost as well as a summer in the dry and wet and still sold on snow.
@66cotter
@66cotter Год назад
I have the Michelin X ice snow now and love them. Smooth, quiet, comfortable and probably do a bit better fuel economy than my all seasons. I had a previous generation Nokian and they were very similar with quiet, comfort and fuel economy. Both great on hard pack snow, but where the Nokian falls short is in slushy conditions, which we have lots of here in Nova Scotia. Otherwise it would be a toss up which one I'd buy again.
@PhilAndersonOutside
@PhilAndersonOutside 8 месяцев назад
I live in the Pacific Northwest. Our snow is heavy and wet, much of the winter our lower elevation roads are soaked with rain, which high up is heavy snow (there's a reason our mountains have glaciers on them!), but during cold snaps we get ice at elevation and high passes, ski areas; frosty, chunky ice, not sheet ice like Minnesota. Your test showed me the Michelin X-Ice Snow is the tire for where I live.
@remiltonsilveira7314
@remiltonsilveira7314 Год назад
Again, watching reviews of tyres that I would never use in my home country just because this channel know that tyres don't have to just be round and black. Love the content!
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
@strandlie92
@strandlie92 Год назад
When somebody tells me RU-vid is just for vlogging and kids, I’ll show them this video to prove them wrong. Super interesting and extremely valuble. I should have watched this before I ordered winter tires with my new car. Luckily I chose well with the Continental VC7. Also, really interesting to see the difference between the nordic market tires and the Central European one, highlighting the importance of choosing a tyre after the conditions you live in.
@benjaminmensah5075
@benjaminmensah5075 10 месяцев назад
Wow, this is what I call an absolute review. I'm getting ready to purchase my first winter tires and after consulting severak experts, the continental viking 7s have been overly recommended. I must admit your review has re-echoed what I think must be the best in class. Thank you for your unparalleled review.
@danielbukowski
@danielbukowski Год назад
I live in south west Sweden where we get a mix of a couple of days of snow, black ice on mornings and evenings, half of the winter it’s raining or we get sunny snow free days with dry tarmac and I do travel a lot south to Germany/Poland. I got a really good price for the Pirelli Ice Zero FR and after watching this review I feel confident that it’s a fairly good tire. It’s like you said - a really good all round tire.
@Lollakuk
@Lollakuk Год назад
These videos are just so good Jonathan! I got myself an EV6 and now got Hakka R5 as its winter tyres. I live in Sweden and wanted to skip studs as I drive an EV. Excited to see how they perform!
@ipadmini220
@ipadmini220 Год назад
Same here in Canada BC. Hakka R5 on my EV6. So far so good
@HCkev
@HCkev 7 месяцев назад
3rd winter with the Vikingcontact 7, still very satisfied with them. What I have been the most impressed about is how well they performs through slush. Those bad boys goes through big puddles of slush as if they weren''t even there, where many other tires quickly lose traction. Impressive. I have found that when the tire lose grip, it tends to quickly gain it back, basically just giving you a warning to maybe slow down a little(yeah I'm kind of an heavy foot driver...). I do feel very safe with them. By the way, I had Nokian Hakkapeliitta 7 before the Continental's, so it's not like I was coming from crappy tires. The Vikingcontact 7 were significantly cheaper than the hakkapeliitta 9 (the 10 weren't out at the time).
@jonnemonto4410
@jonnemonto4410 Год назад
I must say that this review video is far better than our local Finnish videos. Just bought Michelin and love them already in harsh Finnish winter
@nikoyochum6974
@nikoyochum6974 Год назад
Thank you so much for the video, excellent as always. I bought the X-Ice Snow last year for Colorado and they kicked ass in the snow, especially when I was caught in a blizzard on I-70 and everyone was on ice skates around me. They are quite spongy in the dry, but meh, they are a winter tire
@jakubjodlowski8416
@jakubjodlowski8416 Год назад
Thank you so much for this!
@K4g4m1
@K4g4m1 Год назад
This video was a great help for picking out a new set of winter tires for my car. I ordered Nokian R5s and I'll make sure to be mindful of its aquaplaning performance in the wet. Thanks.
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
Let me know how you find them!
@RayFanful
@RayFanful Год назад
Nokian Tyres quality control worker here! Brilliant testing glad you liked hakkapeliitta 10 :) very interesting data edit: And the R5 of course :D
@HifkHockeyPASM91
@HifkHockeyPASM91 Год назад
I have the continental viking contact 7's on my BMW i4 M50, and I could agree more with your comments about the tire. It is very very good, quiet and comfortable, and provides ton of grip in snow and ice, BUT the levels of grip is quite snappy, so i.e in snow if you want to drift, you get a false sense of grip because in one moment you have all the grip in the world and then suddenly you have no grip at all. It makes you super excited and scared at same time
@jtome84-91
@jtome84-91 Год назад
Well done review !
@CloD44
@CloD44 Год назад
Great testing .. I own a 2021 veloster n dct with Continental Viking 7 , best tire for Northen New York weather , ice ,snow and slush .
@Ficon
@Ficon Год назад
Thank you for your hard work and outstanding analysis, as always. X Ice Snow is a ridiculous tire, driving on snow feels like driving on dry roads.
@Ram14250
@Ram14250 Год назад
Love your testing! Excellent! I would pick the Michelin's as they are very good and have a very good wear rating in the USA. Funny enough, I picked Bridgestone Blizzak DM-V2's for my vehicle. Studded tires here are a big no-no here. I live in the US northern Great Lakes Region... lots of Ice, Snow and cold 5 months of the year! Thanks again for the great tests!
@scottcrawford3745
@scottcrawford3745 Год назад
You will not be disappointed the the DMV2's. I just bought a set for my GF's Mercedes GLE 400, and already run them on my Navigator, after enjoying the Original Blizzak DMV on it's predecessor vehicle, a V-8 Explorer. Just remember to get them off by the last days of cold temperatures. They will wear out Very quickly in anything above 7 *C for daily driving. I had debated the Hakka series thoroughly, but the availability is very hit-and-miss. *Canadian Central Ontario Snow-belt Region, about an hour north of Toronto.
@AttitudeAdjusterAA
@AttitudeAdjusterAA Год назад
I love these, thank you
@jimsgaragetoys
@jimsgaragetoys 4 месяца назад
I've got Michelin X-Ice tires on my wife's Prius and I've had them on other cars and loved them. I have the Blizzak on my RAV4 but I went with a high performance winter tire on my new GR Corolla. I looked at the Michelin Alpin 5 but went with the Vredestein Wintrac Pro as Tire Rack loved them both. So far I'm loving them. They've been excellent on ice and snow and much better than other winter tires on dry and wet roads.
@dc4497
@dc4497 Год назад
As a Californian who has literally driven in zero snow, we moved up to Oregon. For winter I bought Viking 7s and my son has CrossClimate2s, both on FWD Toyota Camrys. We drove in some pretty heavy snow (for us) driving through peaks and valleys for about 3hrs straight. There were many cars and SUVs stranded at the sides of the road during our trip. My son and I are novice snow drivers. We high-fived thankful we made it home in a very uneventful manner without incident. I can't say enough about investing in 3peak winter tires, they'll get you home and may even save your life.
@ms-jl6dl
@ms-jl6dl Год назад
CrossClimate is not a dedicated snow tyre,it's considered all-seasons in Europe. Conti V7 is heavy winter "nordic tyre" for very low temperatures,two classes above all-seasons for winter,and is for winters only. The fact that you could do the trip without any problems on the CrossClimates on the Camry shows you that you overshot the target by a long margin in buying the C. V7.That's a tyre for Eskimos not Oregonians,and it's dangerous on wet and dry roads compared to the "normal" winter tyre or good "all weather tyre" as you call them.
@JohnPMiller
@JohnPMiller Год назад
Thank you for adapting to the snow. We have a lot of Californians moving to Colorado, and they often have problems in the snow.
@tyrereviews
@tyrereviews Год назад
They're two great tire choices DC. John, I'm in Salt Lake and have the same problem. Also the same problem with the locals.
@dc4497
@dc4497 Год назад
@@ms-jl6dl Thanks for the info, I do have the Viking 7s on a set of steel rims and Yokohama UHP A/S on my factory set daily drivers. As an old guy from CA, I need all the help I can get when anticipating to drive in the snow or icy conditions. The CrossClimate2s are my son's daily drivers on his factory rims.
@michaelmorrow6499
@michaelmorrow6499 Год назад
Great video!
Далее
Самый надежный автомобиль
01:00
Просмотров 468 тыс.
ОБЗОР ТРЕЙЛЕРА STANDOFF 2 0.29.0 FUN&SUN
13:13
СЫГРАЕМ МИНИАТЮРУ #большоешоу
01:01
2WD Winter tyres vs AWD Summer tyres: SNOW DRAG RACE
10:02
The BEST winter tires for SUVs and CARS!
3:23
Просмотров 49 тыс.
Легкий тюнинг 🤣☝️ #goodcarkz
0:26