The Bryce Young Experiment Is Officially OVER.. 

Let me know down in the comments if you think he's a bust or not!

"should have drafted a guy who is bigger and could take more of a beating" meanwhile AR is out for the year already while BY9 has survived almost 50 sacks and 100 hits. I am not saying its a 1 to 1 comparison, but I think we can all agree he has proven to be more durable than anyone expected. Now, it shouldn't be happening and it should mean the Oline coach should be replaced. His durability won't matter next year if the line is still bad since he will eventually get hurt and hurt bad

Honestly, any QB would struggle with that team

It's way too soon to write off Young. The biggest problem was trading DJ Moore though. It's an insanely stupid idea to trade away you a bonafide alpha WR 1 when you're drafting a new QB.

Everyone who picked Bryce to go 1 in the draft should be banned from talking about draft picks ever again

Its his first year dawg its not over😂

Bruh, he’s a rookie, hasn’t even played a full year, has the worst set of weapons in the nfl and went to one of the worst teams in the nfl and people are labeling him a bust already. Give bro some time not all rookies go off right away like Stroud he’s still getting used to the nfl

Honestly been a fan for over 2 decades and as soon as they made the trade to number 1, my heart sank. I knew we were not a QB away. No matter who came in was going to struggle but to give up so much is crazy. This owner has put this team back by almost a decade. F Tepper.

i said this before but i really do feel for the dude. i’ve followed cj stroud ever since ohio state but man i want bryce to succeed too, dude seems so humble and i hate seeing his talent get wasted. hope he ends up like trevor lawrence and has a bounce back season.

This aged well

owner messing up the team, that must really suck -washington fan

Last Heisman winning QB to win a Superbowl? Go ahead, I'll wait

When the Panthers drafted Bryce Young I almost cried with tears. Imagine having success with a 5'9 QB in the NFL LMAO. He needs to play another position because QB isn't it for Young in the NFL. This team went from 6'6 250 lb Cam Newton, to " Bryce Young " the Panthers are and have always been a dumpster fire LMAO.

That dude ain't 5'10, he looks 5'5 next to every other player.

Calling someone a bust and they haven't even played their first year is crazy 😂😂 Bet you woulda been hella wrong abt manning huh

Damn, Bryce isnt even out of his first year lol. Fans are some of the stupidest analysts. People get paid millions to make these decisions and some y'all think you are so much smarter...go work for an NFL team then 🤡 . The fact is that the Panthers are talent deficient at basically every postion group on offense and defense. No player is having success on that team. Tepper is wasting careers right now. It sucks that Bryce went to the Panthers, if it was CJ Stroud he would be having a terrible first season as well. People think the Texans were not good, they actually were pretty decent last year, they had good players at key positions, a servicable OL and a decent defense. Sometimes these teams want that QB but if all you have is a QB but nothing around them they are not gonna be good. QB is the most reliant on other positions of any position on the field. QBs need guys who can block, reliable WRs that can run routes, catch, hell GET OPEN. RBs that can actually grind out yards. The Panthers have a bunch of mix matched ingredients and they are asking coaches to make 5 star meals. No coach or player is going to have success on the Panthers till Tepper is gone. There are some real facts for some of the deluded commentors on this thread.

Bears had this problem for decades with the McCaskys. They finally hired Ryan Poles and gave him a free hand. He engineered that trade, got a boatload of great talent, and is poised to do it all again this year. In about 2 years the Bears will be an NFL power house. BTW this Tepper guy looks 10x stupider than George McCasky.

Best way to tell if it's BY or not is put in Dalton for the rest of the season and if he puts up good numbers and actually wins then yeah, BY will be a big problem going forward

As a Texans fan I was irate when we lost that #1 pick on the final game. But that changed draft night when we got stroud and Anderson. On my way to Baltimore this weekend for the Divisional. Thanks Lovie

Tepper needs to stop trying to be like Jerry Jones…. Like bro… you’re not him 😂

Everyone: why you take 5’10 guy? Owner: “Bryce had a firm hand shake. ”

The irony of that trade was them not only giving up their top reviver but losing the opportunity to get this years number 1 with their own draft pick. They really could have had Moore and Williams but now the bears will have that possibility. As a Texans fan I was extremely worried we’d end up with Bryce during the talks of Carolina liking CJ as their pick. Not saying Bryce isn’t good (He definitely has the skill set to play at this level) but being short as a QB with no noticeable athletic intangible to set you apart usually looks bad. Still hoping he gets better next year, but i won’t lie the Texans fan in me is glad Carolinas owner took over that pick. 😅

I thought the Panthers were fine with Sam Darnold and Baker Mayfield competing for the QB job. QB wasn't the problem with the Panthers. Steve Wilks did a fine job as interim HC and should have been kept. And RB Christian McCaffrey and WR D.J. Moore should never have been traded. Note that Darnold Wilks and McCaffrey are with the 49ers now, which shows they weren't the problem.

I'm not emotionally prepared to watch this....

He's not a bust. Its the panthers offensive scheme thats the problem. If you put young in a different offensive scheme i bet you he'll be good. They have to find the right coach

"Bigger stronger qb that can take more of a beating?" Wtf? If Bryce takes much more of a beating he should sue the Panthers for assault. Dude took so many hits and still standing. He is crazy accurate. I read somewhere that he only missed something like 1 out of 12 open receivers over like 12 games. The real problem is Panthers has a 1.2 second avg pocket which is why they wanted a QB like Bryce to scramble out of it. I swear Panthers and my Bears should merge into one shit org lol. all QB need a good WR and o line thats not an argument , that's what drafts are for. People want instant magic, not work lol

Sacked 44 Times?!?!?! I didnt realize it was that bad.

Bryce young genuinely has one of the worst supporting casts ever. Idk a single current QB who would succeed on the panthers...

The real question is what if the panthers drafted CJ Stroud instead how their season would of played out

I disagree strongly, how can you judge Young with this situation

Carolina hasn't surrounded him with help, but Bryce has yet to throw for 250 yards in a game. That's worse than rookie Zach Wilson or current Zach Wilson for that matter. Andy Dalton came in 1 game and threw for about 400 yards and 3 td with those same garbage weapons. At some point, we can't keep finger pointing at everyone but Bryce and have to face the elephant in the room that bryce may just not be an NFL quality QB.

Terry Bradshaw was the worst QB in the league his first two seasons, and then went on to win four super bowls.

I use to think Young just didn't hav the receivers around him. But recently watching Bryce miss guys that are open,& seems to always be at 3rd n long. Man i just dont know if the kid can make it.

Tepper just needs to be an owner and not a Coach / Player staff decision maker. He's not informed at all.

Bryce is not a bust, the Panther's owner is.

I'm a SEC fan. I know that CJ Stroud and Marvin Harrison Jr. played superbly against Georgia's vaunted defense. I hate to say this, but I agree with the people that say OSU would have won if Harrison Jr didn't get hurt. The scouts say how great Stroud was but David Tepper knew better. He's the NFC South's version of Dan Snyder. What pains me is that our old (I'm a Bucs fan) OC was named head coach. He deserves better.

The Panthers tried for year to solve their problems with a new QB.. problem is they needed to focus on improving the Oline.. AND playing to the strengths of the Oline.. ie RUnnINg the ball, down hill blocking scheme and playaction.. theyve got a great D.. complimentery football says you jsut need a DECENT Offense to contorl the clock and move the ball.

this was a really well done and edited video

Fantasy sports league and modern day sports commentary has ruined the way we analyze NFL players. Always a hater so quick to label someone as a ‘bust’ or ‘trash’.

Alabama and USC quarterbacks never = Super bowl champions.

I think that every team before drafting a player need to look into their mentality

As a Bears fan, I thank all of Carolina for the opportunity

You talk about Bryce being too small yada yada blah blah. But out of the top 3 QB's of his draft year Anthony Richardson, CJ Stroud and my man Bryce he is the one that has successfully withstood the most hits this season, because the Panther's O- Line can't protect him for isht. Most hits withstood isn't a statistic that you want associated with your QB but it's relevance in the story you're trying to sell is unmistakable. He is the only one of the three that has not been concust and not started games by virtue of the concussion protocol. He has proven his toughness by being the last man standing whilst Stroud and Richardson are rushed to the nearest emergency room for a CT Scan on their brain. Those other two are good no doubt but Bryce has escapability and when can't escape he knows how to take a hit in a measured way, in a way that won't leave his brain frazzled. In other words his intangibles are off the charts.....Youzzzeeard...

Just a horrible situation Bryce is in. Any other QB would struggle on that team. That team is God awful

Can’t take anybody seriously that is willing to call a rookie a bust. That goes for any sport

I don’t feel like you can really say he a bust unless he literally throws bad balls or takes unnecessary sacks , but if the team is not a good team an has a (bad line) an no good receiver, THEN EVEN Brady would be called a bust , he has to have atleast 1 weapon an atleast 3-4sec to throw the ball then throw bad balls to call him a bust

this is what i hate bout the nfl qbs who actually have potential but get ruined because they got drafted by a team who sucks.

“He doesn’t have any weapons” why are people acting like all of CJ’s weapons weren’t no names last year that no one cared abt. CJ made them good.

I just watched the Panthers draft and now that I’m seeing this I almost screamed

Panthers as a bears fan give your young QB time to develop people think every QB will come out the gate being the next Tom Brady or Pat mahomes some things take time

Any QB would struggle at Carolina.

Owners should stay the hell out of the draft process. All they bring to the table is the money...Thats it!!! That they think they can evaluate a player better than the coaches and scouts is ludicris.

Young is a bust but Tepper is a meddling moron. I don't think any respectable coach will ever go to that franchise now that the secret is out about Stroud. He got rid of his two weapons, drafted the wrong QB, and hired a terrible coach in Reich. I watched him flounder in Indy. The man has no instinct as a head coach. After watching him fail in Indy to the point Irsay had to fire him mid season when he had never done that before, why would you give him a big contract?

I cant wait to come back to this video when bryce figures it out lmfao

Tepper is a bust as an owner. His ineptitude has poured all over this franchise, and poor Bryce paid the price.

Literally his first season with the worst weapons, one of the worst olines, nonexistent offensive coaching and you’re saying it’s an “experiment” that is over. Just say you don’t know wtf you’re talking about bro

bryce young still like that way better than kyler murray

Bro you gotta trademark that “complete bust” lol

Nice detailed content! Great video

When you look at other rookie QBs CJ stroud, Anthony Richardson, and will levis play they look like NFL QBs but either bryce young i just dont see it

The Chiefs gave up their 2017 2nd-round pick, 2018 1st-round pick, to move up 18 spots to pick Mahomes in 2017. The Panthers gave away A LOT more to move up just 8 spots to get Young. What a disaster. The Bears FLEECED the Panthers.

No player should be considered a bust nor a future hall of fame player after just one year in the NFL. I personally believe in the sit a year or even 2 and develop the QB. Look at Greenbay Packers who now on there 3rd straight franchise QB as love looks to be the real deal and his numbers are currently MVP level and likely will keep getting better and better as he keeps growing together with his young wide receivers and tight ends who are all talented. Feel bad for Bryce young as he got drafted to a team with no offense line that lets him get hit a endless amount of times which can eventually destroy a quarter back mechanics and his confidence and mess with the clock in his head and make him start hearing footsteps in his mind even if no one is near him. His best thing on his offense there to help him is a 33 year out wide out from Minnesota who is still pretty good I must say, but really is a top level #2 wide out and that been proven and sadly he wasting his final years in the league in Carolina. Regardless of any of that personally I don't believe it a good idea to draft a QB who is so short really anything under 6 foot is too small for nfl QB and young weight is like under 200 pounds yikes so light for a pro QB.

In Carolina, Young is the WRONG QB, on the wrong team. He has a mediocre O line, and no real quality skill players around him. What could go wrong? Give him the offense he had at Bama, and you'll see the Bryce Young that made him the No.1 pick. You can give the best race car driver a Volkswagen, and he'll still lose to a mediocre driver in a Ferrari. Young is not a bad football player. But this was a bad pick by Carolina based on what they needed. For those Bears fans who said they should've dumped Fields and drafted Young, just STFU. You don't know football. He would've taken the SAME beating, or worse in Chicago. They got a franchise receiver in Moore, the next No.1 pick, and a LOT of options for their GM Poles. Stroud in Houston is the example of the RIGHT QB on the right team. Having said that, Young is not a "bust" IMO. He is in a position where he will continue to struggle and take punishment for the foreseeable future if Carolina's front office doesn't make some bold, decisive, and smart moves in the offseason. As well as spend some cash.

Sick of the excuses he’s a GIANT bust, want proof… put Dalton in

He needs weapons and an o line, we can’t officially call him a bust yet

Should’ve never picked him !!!!! I said on draft night that we just made a 5 year mistake !!!! Bust

Him being short has absolutely nothing to do with performance. People are weird. Being tall doesnt make you a better QB at any level.

Young needed a red shirt year also he just a rookie. Young is a rookie who has a owner who is failing the team

This is not only stupid but full of misinformation, or lies if you want to be honest.

this aged well

Great video

who made the thumbnail

I’m gonna come back to this vid a year from now and Bryce young will lead the panthers to 1st in the nfc south

The front office is the problem!!

When is a RU-vid Channel gonna talk about the Mike McDaniel being a fraud

Give BY a chance. The team is a mess and Young should be fine in the long run.

A lot of truth and some bs.. I’m glad you mentioned the part about Marvin Harrison Jr. and the future head coaching job. I’ve always explained it the same way you did. You were absolutely right. We could’ve had harbaugh but I’m sure that’s not going to happen.

Panthers looking like a expansion team 😂😂 they tanking

lets simmer down its year 1 on a really bad team. i remember all the trevor lawrence clickbaity hes a bust videos at the end of his first year.

How is it OVER? Guy played 1 season with a bunch of practice squad guys. I feel that with a good OLine and a couple weapons he could be a pretty good QB.

I don’t feel that Bryce Young is solely the issue at Carolina. As mentioned throughout your video, Young has been setup for failure on a number of levels. I don’t fret over his size; he is capable. When you look at the number of sacks this young man has experienced, the lack of offensive weapons he has, it’s difficult to judge his potential. You’re correct that there is a need for an overhaul, but lambasting, and making potential coaches afraid to join the franchise is more harmful. I feel that Tepper needs a coaching staff that he’ll respect and listen to. The turmoil that Carolina is experiencing will be fixed. Don’t discount Young. It isn’t fair given the level of talent that he has been given.

I don't think it's fair to say he's bad. Sure you can say elite players should elevate those around but I think even mahomes would struggle in Carolina. We will know in time if he is good bad or average. I think Carolina is more at fault. Drafting a 5'9" qb number one overall was a bad move. If they wanted young, they probably would've been able to get him with that no 9 pick.

All he has is Adam Theiland, I think even Mahomes would struggle in there

Terrible finish, 8 quarters without even a field goal. But still too late to call him a bust. Aikman and Manning had bad first years, he's not going to be as good as them but here's what he needs to do. Be more aggressive, he's standing too much waiting for guys to get open...quicker feet, step up in the pocket, put a bit more speed on his throws. Run for a few and slide instead of taking -15 sacks. We'll see next year

I honestly think he can be a pretty good QB the team just sucks. I do agree he needs major development because he throws some bad balls and his desicsion making is not so great.

This video was good at the beginning but then it contradicted itself on the second half of the video! Bryce has no O-line and his playmaker receiver is a 33 year old wash out…! What do you mean he holds the ball to long? He doesn’t have anyone to throw it too! Just for clarity, I’m not a Panther fan.

Dam yall can't get a First round pick for 2024 yall screwed I lived in Charlotte for 10 years I can just say I never was a fan of Bryce he is a career backup but also look at the Brock Purdy situation maybe yall can find a hidden gem

Frank Reich has always maintained that Young was his pick. He picked wrong, or he is lying. Either one is not a good look. Also Frank has a 4 year guaranteed contract. So hes getting paid to sit at home. Maybe coaching at Carolina isn't that bad. I'll do one year of work for a 4 year contract. (And i think hes still getting paid by the colts too.)

Drew breez 6feet that’s taller in real life but not in the nfl lol

Listen i am a bama fan and i want to let the panther fans to give bryce young some time this is still his rookie year . Now if this spills to his sophomore season then we might need to call bryce young a bust and a mistake of picking him

Let me get this straight. Instead of letting your watchers turn on CC if they want it, you made the CC in the video which takes away from the video. Not only that, the captions are wrong way too many times. Besides that. Young will be a bust, but its not all on him. Smaller frame QBs wont have a place in the NFL soon. Previously, their only advantage was to be nimble and extend the play with their feet. Now we have linemen and LB's that are just as quick and nimble that can take away that advantage.

Trade him, rebuild the whole team starting with core positions. Honestly, if we drafted Stroud, we'd be having a different conversation

Keep Pounding...that broken drum

Only badly managed teams give a king's ransom to move up in the draft and select the smallest QB since 1999 in 2023. The NFL has changed a lot since 1999. Tepper Tantrum is to blame for a blunder likely to set this team back another 3 years or more. Six years of Tepper's ownership, six years of consecutive losing seasons. Coincidence? I think not.

Bryce Young is still a good pick. He can’t produce behind the godawful offensive line and with no weapons. It is him Thielen and a bunch of nobodies

LETS GO HOUSTON!!!!

Who ever could’ve guessed that an undersized, small arm quarterback from Alabama would flame out in the league. What a surprise. I don’t know how many years is gonna take for football fans to understand this do not draft QBs from Alabama.

This already aged TERRIBLY

Texans fan here, thank you so much!

The Panthers organization has failed him and the team around him. We are easily the worst managed team in the league right now and the most talent & asset poor. He will be able to succeed in the NFL, and to say everyone said he wouldn't is just bad revisionist history as he was the #1 or #2 pick on almost every draft board. Unfortunately, unless Tepper learns how to be a good team owner, the franchise will be in poverty for awhile. Next year we have a normal draft, so as long as we make smart FA moves and hit in the draft we will be *maybe* competitive next year, but more likely competitive in 2025. Unfortunately, it is impossible to fairly judge BY9 this season, good or bad, because of how bad everything has been on the team around him player and management wise. If he looks the same next season, thats when talk about if he is/isn't a bust can really be considered.