Christian here: I think Shabir is the most honest and sincere apologist out there, amongst the Moslims AND Christians. He just honestly gives his opinion on matters and his arguments are of the highest quality.
Fact! I’m a Christian and he’s the only genuine Muslim apologist out there. He doesn’t intentionally lie in his debates but just gives his unbiased opinion. I’m surprised that such an honest man is a Muslim. There’s a reason why the other Muslim teachers dislike him.
@Edward I think it's extremely ignorant to say you're surprised he's such an honest man to be a Muslim, Just like Christians, there are good people and bad people in all religions
@@pebystroll It seems you don’t get me. There are honest people from all religions. Even some atheist are honest. However, when it comes to Muslim apologists, it’s difficult to find an honest one. They will intentionally lie about verses in the Bible just to convince ignorant Christians to convert to Islam, however, this man doesn’t do that. Even when he’s misinterpreting the Bible, he isn’t doing it intentionally but rather it’s because he doesn’t understand it.
Although I am not Muslim I most assuredly enjoy your videos and the humble, level headed way in which you speak of your faith as well as Christianity without guile. Your videos are a blessing in learning about the Quran and Muslim faith. May God bless.
May Allah guide you to the Truth Ameen. Muslims Love Jesus Jesus is a figure who is loved and revered by billions of people the world over, yet there is much confusion surrounding the status of this colossal personality. Muslims and Christians both hold Jesus in high regard but view him in very different ways. This pamphlet aims to clarify the issues surrounding Jesus: Was Jesus God, or was he sent by God? Who was the real historical Jesus? "Jesus as God" Some Christians claim that "Jesus is God" or part of a trinity - that he is the incarnation of God on earth, and that God took on a human form. However, according to the Bible, Jesus was born, ate, slept, prayed and had limited knowledge - all attributes not befitting God. God has attributes of perfection whereas Man is the opposite. How can anything be two complete opposites simultaneously? Islam teaches that God is always perfect. To believe that God became a man is to claim that God is or was (at some point in time), imperfect. A Christian must ask him/herself, does the idea of a god who was once a weak helpless child, one who could not survive without food, drink or sleep, be the same Almighty God described in the Old Testament? Surely not. One may ask, "If God can do anything, why can't he become a man?" By definition, God does not do ungodly acts. God does not do anything that would make Him, something other than God. If God became man and took on human attributes, he would, necessarily, no longer be God. Some ambiguous verses of the Bible can be applied erroneously to show that Jesus is in some way divine. But if we look at the clear direct verses of the Bible, we see again and again that Jesus is being referred to as an extraordinary human being and nothing more. The Bible contains many verses in which Jesus speaks and behaves as if God is a separate being to himself. For example: Jesus "fell on his face and prayed." (Matthew 26:39) If Jesus was God, then would a God fall on his face and pray? And who would he be praying to? The Bible calls Jesus a Prophet (Matthew 21:10-11), so how could Jesus be God and be God's Prophet at the same time? Jesus said, "I am going to the Father, because the Father is greater than me." (John 14:28) Jesus said "I ascend unto my Father, and your Father, and to my God, and your God." (John 20:17) If Jesus was God, then why would he say, "to my God, and your God," and who was he ascending to? If Jesus was God, he would have clearly told people to worship him, and there would be clear verses in the Bible stating this; yet he did the opposite and disapproved anyone worshipping him: "And in vain they worship me." (Matthew 15:9) "Son of God" Some Christians claim that Jesus is the Son of God. What does this actually mean? Surely God is far removed from having a physical and literal son. Humans have human children. Cats have kittens. What does it mean for God to have a child? Rather than being taken literally, we find the term "Son of God" is symbolically used in the earliest biblical languages for a "righteous person", and has been used for David, Solomon and Israel - not exclusively for Jesus: "...Israel is my firstborn son," (Exodus 4:22). In fact, anyone who is righteous is referred to as God's 'son' : "All who are led by God's Spirit are God's sons and daughters." (Romans 8:14) Qur'an 19:35 It is not [befitting] for Allah to take a son; exalted is He!1 When He decrees an affair, He only says to it, "Be," and it is. - Saheeh International. " "Father and Lord" In the same way, when the word 'Father' is used to refer to God it shouldn't be taken literally. Instead, it's a way of saying God is the creator, sustainer and supreme master of all. There are many verses for us to understand this symbolic meaning of the word 'Father', for example: "One God and Father of all." (Ephesians 4:6) Also, Jesus was sometimes called 'Lord' by the disciples. This term is used in the original languages of the Bible, for God as well as for people who are held in high esteem. For example, in the Greek New Testament, the term kyrios is used for both 'Lord' as well as to name the owner of the vineyard (Matthew 20:8), and the master who beat the disobedient servant (Luke 20.42-47). In other parts of the Bible, Jesus is even called a 'servant' of God by the disciples: "The God of our fathers, has glorified his servant Jesus." (Acts 3:13) This clearly shows that when 'Lord' is used to refer to Jesus, it is a title of respect, not of divinity. Attempts are made to explain the complexity of the above issues of the nature of God and the nature of Jesus, which can be quite confusing or unsatisfying. However, the key point to ponder is: Why would God make it so hard to understand? How do these complicated teachings compare with the simple, clear and pure teachings of the concept of God in Islam? Jesus: The Prophet In Judaism, Jesus (peace be upon him) is denied as the Messiah. This is in stark contrast to Christianity where he is worshipped as a deity, or the son of God. Islam takes the middle ground and acknowledges Jesus as an honourable Prophet and Messenger of God, as well as the Messiah, but Muslims do not worship him - as worship is for God alone who created Jesus and everything that exists. "(Jesus) said, 'Indeed, I am the slave of Allah (God). He has given me the Scripture and made me a Prophet.'"Quran 19:30.
Miraculous Birth According to the Quran, the Angel Gabriel was sent to Mary, the noble virgin, in the form of a man, informing her of a child who was to be born miraculously without a father. "He (Angel Gabriel) said, 'I am only a messenger of your Lord to announce to you the gift of a righteous son.' She said, 'How shall I have a son, seeing that no man has touched me, and I am not unchaste?' He said, 'Thus (it will be). Your Lord says, "It is easy for Me, and We will make him a sign to the people and a mercy from Us. And it is a matter already decreed." "Quran 19:19-21 Some claim that his miraculous birth is evidence of Jesus' divinity. However, Jesus was not the first to come into existence without a father, as Prophet Adam (peace be upon him) before him had neither a father nor mother. God says: "The likeness of Jesus before God is as that of Adam; He created him (Adam) from dust, then said to him: 'Be', and he was. This is the truth from your Lord, so be not of the disputers."Quran 3:59-60 If Jesus is worshipped due to having no father, then surely Adam is more deserving of worship since he was created without either parent. Miracles of Jesus Jesus was miraculously conceived with no father and also performed great miracles by the will and permission of God. He spoke as a baby in the cradle to defend his mother against the people who accused her of fornication. The Quran also states that Jesus gave life to the dead, cured the leper and the blind - all by the will of God. The fact that Jesus (peace be upon him) performed miracles does not mean that he was anything more than a humble servant of God. In fact, many Messengers performed miracles, including Noah, Moses and Muhammad (may peace be upon them all) and these miracles only took place by the permission of God, so as to demonstrate the authenticity of the Messenger. Message of Jesus The Prophets of the Old Testament such as Abraham, Noah and Jonah never preached that God is part of a Trinity, and did not believe in Jesus as their saviour. Their message was simple: there is one God and He alone deserves your worship. It is not logical for God to send Prophets for thousands of years with the same essential message, only to suddenly change it, claim that He is now a part of a trinity, and to stipulate the belief in the divinity of Jesus to be saved. The truth is, Jesus preached the same message as all the Prophets in the Old Testament. There is a passage in the Bible that really emphasises this core message. A man came to Jesus and asked, "Which is the first commandment of all?" Jesus answered, "The first of all the commandments is, 'Hear, O Israel, the Lord our God, the Lord is one.' "(Mark 12:28-29) So, the greatest commandment, the most important belief according to Jesus, is that God is one. If Jesus was God he would have said, 'I am God, worship me.' Instead, he merely repeated a verse from the Old Testament confirming that God is One. This aligns with the mission of Jesus, as taught in Islam, where Jesus was sent to the Children of Israel to confirm the message of the past Prophets - to believe in the One True God. "And when Jesus brought clear proofs, he said, '… Indeed, God - He is my Lord and your Lord. So worship Him alone. This is the only Straight Path.' "Quran 43:63-64 As an honourable obedient Messenger of God, Jesus submitted willingly to God's commands. As such, he was a "Muslim" - which refers to anyone that submits to the will and commandments of God. Jesus in Islam Jesus was as an honourable Prophet sent by God to call to the worship of God alone. This is evident in the Bible and confirmed by the Quran. The Islamic belief about Jesus explains who the real Jesus was, whilst maintaining the pure belief about God and His complete Greatness, Uniqueness and Perfection. We invite you to look further and investigate Islam. It is not just another religion. It is the same message preached by Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad - may peace be upon all of them. Islam means 'submission to God' and is a natural and complete way of life that encourages one to give due attention to their relationship with God and His creation. Islam teaches that God is the All-Just and All-Merciful and does not need to sacrifice himself to forgive sins nor is anyone "born into sin". God judges everyone based on their own deeds and everyone is accountable for their own actions. Islam teaches us to love and respect all the Prophets of God, but loving and respecting them does not mean worshipping them because worship is due only to God. Acknowledging Jesus as a Prophet of God and becoming a Muslim does not mean changing or losing your Christian identity. It is about going back to the original and pure teachings of Jesus.
A Muslim's Outlook on Life Balance of hope in God's Mercy and fear of His punishment I have a noble purpose If good happens, be grateful. If bad happens, have patience This life is a test and God sees everything I do Put my trust in God - nothing happens except by His permission Everything I have is from God Genuine hope & concern for non-Muslims to be guided Focus on what is in my control & try my best I will return to God and be accountable
The Word of God The Qur’an is the literal word of God, The Almighty (Allah in Arabic), revealed to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) through the Angel Gabriel. “The revelation of The Book is from Allah, the Mighty, the Wise.”Qur’an 39:1 Guidance for Mankind The Qur’an is “a guidance for mankind… and the distinction (between right and wrong).” Qur’an 2:185 It provides direction to help mankind judge between right and wrong, without which, man would surely be in loss. The Final Revelation The Qur’an is the last scripture revealed by Almighty Allah (God), confirming what little truth remains in parts of previous scriptures and refuting and correcting fabrications and additions which have crept into current day versions of such scriptures. “O you who have been given the Scripture! Believe in what We have revealed confirming what is (already) with you...”Qur’an 4:47 How was the Qur’an Revealed? The Qur’an was revealed to Muhammad (peace be upon him) and exists only in the language in which it was revealed - Arabic. However, the translation of the meaning of the Qur’an is available in many languages. The Qur’an was not sent down as a complete book in one revelation; rather, the revelation spanned over a period of 23 years. For this reason, it is essential to know in what circumstances the verses were revealed, in order to have a proper understanding of the Qur’an; otherwise, its teachings could be misunderstood. How do I know that it is from God? Preservation The Qur’an is the only religious sacred text that has been in circulation for a lengthy period, and yet remains as pure as the day it was revealed. Nothing has been added, removed or modified from it, since its revelation over 1400 years ago. “We have, without doubt, sent down the Message; and We will certainly guard it (from corruption).”Qur’an 15:09 Not only has the Qur’an been preserved in written form, but also in the hearts of men, children and women. Today, millions of people have memorised the Qur’an from cover to cover. Scientific Miracles The Qur’an does not contradict modern science but rather, supports it. One of the most remarkable aspects about the Qur’an is that it contains many verses which accurately describe natural phenomenon in various fields such as embryology, meteorology, astronomy, geology and oceanography. Scientists have found its descriptions incredibly accurate for a book dating back to the 7th century. “We shall show them Our Signs in the Universe and within their own selves, until it becomes clear to them that this is the Truth.”Qur’an 41:53 In fact, many of the scientific miracles mentioned in the Qur’an have been discovered only recently, through the modern advancement of technological equipment. Consider the following: The Qur’an gives a detailed description of the development of the human embryo. These details were unknown to the scientific community until recent times. The Qur’an states that the astronomical objects (stars, planets, moons etc...) were all formed from clouds of dust. Previously unknown, this fact has now become an undisputed principle of modern cosmology. Modern science has discovered the existence of barriers that allow two seas to meet yet maintain their own temperature, density and salinity. These signs of God were clearly stated in the Qur’an more than 1400 years ago. Uniqueness Ever since its revelation, no person has been able to produce a single chapter like that of the Qur’an in its beauty, eloquence, splendour, wisdom, prophecies, and other perfect attributes. “And if you are in doubt as to that which We have revealed to Our servant, then produce a chapter like it and call on your witnesses besides Allah if you are truthful.”Qur’an 2:23 The people that rejected Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) failed this challenge, eventhough they were extremely eloquent in the language of the Qur’an. This challenge remains unanswered to this very day. No Contradictions When people write, they are bound to make mistakes such as spelling and grammar, contradictory statements, incorrect facts, omission of information, and other various errors. “Had it been from other than Allah, they would surely, have found in it (the Qur’an) many contradictions.”Qur’an 4:82 The Qur’an has no contradictions whatsoever - be it in scientific explanations of the water cycle, embryology, geology and cosmology; historical facts and events; or prophecies. Couldn’t Muhammad have authored it? The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) was known in history to be illiterate; he could not read nor write. He was not educated in any field that could account for neither the scientific and historical accuracy, nor the literary beauty of this magnificent Book. The precision of historical recounts of previous peoples and civilisations mentioned in the Qur’an is also too great to be authored by any man. “And this Qur’an is not such as could ever be produced by other than Allah.”Qur’an 10:37 Purpose of Revelation To Believe in One True God “And your god is One God. There is no god but He, the Most Gracious, the Most Merciful.”Qur’an 2:163 The most important topic mentioned throughout the Qur’an is the belief in the One, True God. God informs us that He has no partner, no son, no equal, and that none has the right to be worshipped except Him alone. Nothing is comparable to God and none of His creation resembles Him. The Qur’an also rejects the notion of attributing human qualities and limitations to God. To Reject All False Gods “And worship Allah and associate none with Him.”Qur’an 4:36 Since Allah alone is the only One worthy of worship, false deities and false gods must be rejected. The Qur’an also rejects the notion of attributing divine qualities to anyone or anything other than Allah. To Narrate the Stories from the Past The Qur’an contains many narratives with beneficial lessons, including the true stories of previous Prophets such as, Adam, Noah, Abraham, Jesus and Moses. Of these stories, Allah says, “Indeed in their stories, there is a lesson for men of understanding.”Qur’an 12:111 To Remind us of the Day of Judgement This Noble Book reminds us that everyone will taste death and will be held accountable for all their actions and sayings: “We shall set up scales of justice for the Day of Judgment, so that not a soul will be dealt with unjustly in the least…”Qur’an 21:47 To Fulfil the Intended Way of Life Importantly, the Qur’an teaches that the purpose of life is to worship God alone, and live one’s life according to the way of life prescribed by Him. In Islam, worship is a comprehensive term that includes all actions and sayings (whether private or public) that Allah loves and is pleased with. Therefore, by doing what Allah commands, a Muslim is worshipping God and fulfilling his purpose in life. The following are examples of worship from the Qur’an: To pray: “O you who believe! Bow down and prostrate yourselves and worship your Lord, that you may succeed.”Qur’an 22:77 To give charity: “…And spend, it is better for your souls; and whoever is saved from the greediness of his soul, these it is that are the successful.”Qur’an 64:16 To be honest: “Cover not Truth with falsehood, nor conceal the Truth when you know (what it is).”Qur’an 2:42 To be modest: “Say to the believing men that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty. And say to the believing women that they should lower their gaze and guard their modesty.”Qur’an 24:30-31 To be thankful: “And Allah has brought you forth from the wombs of your mothers-- you did not know anything-- and He gave you hearing and sight and hearts that you may give thanks.”Qur’an 16:78 To be just: “O you who believe! Stand firmly for justice, as witnesses to God, even as against yourselves, or your parents, or your kin, and whether it be (against) rich or poor…”Qur’an 4:135 To be patient: “And be patient, for indeed, Allah does not allow to be lost the reward of those who do good.”Qur’an 11:115 To do good: “Allah has promised to those who believe and do good deeds (that) they shall have forgiveness and a mighty reward.”Qur’an 5:9 Conclusion In summary, the Qur’an teaches mankind how to worship the One True God, hence fulfilling their true purpose in life, and attaining success in both this world and the next. “Verily, We have sent down to you (O Muhammad) the Book for mankind in truth. So whosoever accepts the guidance, it is only for his own self; and whosoever goes astray, he goes astray only for his own loss.”Qur’an 39:41 Don’t you owe it to yourself to at least read this Noble Book?
Where did I come from? Why am I here? Where am I going? One of the first questions that comes to mind when considering our purpose of life is, "where did we come from?" Are we here based on random natural coincidences or is there a higher intelligent being, a creator? Acknowledging the existence of a creator is the first step in understanding our true purpose in life. There are many logical and rational reasons for believing in a creator. Three reasons are briefly mentioned below. 1. Beginning of the Universe The first evidence that points to the existence of God relates to understanding the origin of the universe. Imagine walking in a desert and finding a watch. We know a watch consists of glass, plastic and metal. Glass comes from sand, plastic from oil, and metal extracted from the ground - all these components are found in the desert. Would you believe that the watch formed itself? That the Sun shone, the wind blew, lightning struck, the oil bubbled to the surface and mixed with the sand and metal, and over millions of years the watch came together by random or natural coincidences? Some may ask, "Who created God"? God, the Creator, is different to His creation. God is eternal, has always existed and has no beginning; therefore the question of who created God is irrational. Human experience and simple logic tells us that something that has a beginning does not simply come from nothing, nor can something create itself. Therefore, the most rational explanation is that a higher "being" created the universe. This "being" must be powerful and intelligent as it brought the whole universe into existence and created the ‘laws of science' which govern it. We can also reason that this "being" is timeless and spaceless, because time, space and matter began at the creation of the universe. All of these attributes make up the basic concept of God, the creator of the universe. This is in perfect agreement with modern science which concludes that the universe is finite and has a beginning 2. Perfection of the Universe The second evidence that points to the existence of an intelligent creator is the order and perfect balance of our complex universe. Many features in the universe clearly indicate it to be specially designed to support life, such as the earth's distance from the sun, the thickness of the earth's crust, the speed at which the earth revolves, the percentage of oxygen in the atmosphere, and even the earth's tilt. If these measurements were slightly different to what they currently are, life could not exist. In the same way that a watch has an intelligent maker to keep accurate time, so too must the earth have an intelligent maker to keep accurate time around the sun. Could this occur by itself? When we see the order, precise laws and systems within ourselves and throughout the universe, is it not rational they have an organiser? This ‘organiser' is best explained by the existence of God - the one who brought about this order. 3. Revelation from God The third evidence that points to the existence of God is the actual revelation that God has sent to humankind as a sign of His existence. There are clear signs that the book of Islam, the Quran, is the word of God. Below is a brief summary of reasons that support this claim. The Quran: Is over 1400 years old and contains many scientific facts that were unknown to people of that time and which have only been discovered recently by science. Examples include: water being the origin of all living things (Quran 21:30); the expanding universe (Quran 51:47); and the individual orbits of the sun and moon (Quran 21:33). Contains many historical facts that were unknown to the people of that time as well as numerous predictions which have proven to be correct. Is free from any errors or contradictions despite gradual revelation over 23 years and covering a wide variety of topics. Has been preserved, word-for-word, since its revelation in its original Arabic language, unlike other scriptures which no longer exist in their original form. Has a simple, pure and universal message which appeals to Man's intellect and inherent beliefs about Almighty God. Has a deep and moving effect on people. Was revealed to Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) who was known to be illiterate, yet contains a unique style of language that is universally known as the pinnacle of Arabic eloquence and linguistic beauty. The most rational explanation for the many unique and miraculous aspects of the Quran is that it is from God. God Sends Guidance Upon acknowledging that we have been created by the All-Wise Creator, we would expect to be informed of our purpose. How can we know what God expects from us? Do we live in trial and error, or make our own purpose? Do we "go with the flow" by following others? No. God sent Prophets and revelation to inform us of our purpose. God sent thousands of Prophets, at least one to every nation, with the same message: to worship God alone and to follow His guidance. They included Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, Jesus and Muhammad (peace be upon them all). Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him), the last in the chain of Prophets, was the perfect example of an honest, just, compassionate and brave human being. He was sent with the final revelation from God, the Quran, to demonstrate how its teachings should be applied. The Quran is a book of guidance and explains many concepts such as the purpose of our existence; who God is; the actions liked and disliked by God; the stories of the Prophets and their lessons; accounts of Heaven, Hell, and the Day of Judgement. It aims to clarify misunderstandings about the nature of God, such as clarifying the nature and role of Jesus compared to the nature of God. Jesus, like all the other Prophets, performed miracles and called to the worship of The One true God (Quran 19:36). The Nature of Jesus When trying to understand the concept of God in Islam, it is important to discuss the status of Jesus, given the widespread confusion and claims about his nature. Some Christians claim that "Jesus is God" or part of a trinity - that is, he is the incarnation of God on earth and that God took on a human form. However, according to the Bible, Jesus was born, ate, slept, prayed and had limited knowledge - all attributes not befitting God. God has attributes of perfection whereas Man is the opposite. So how can anything be two complete opposites both at the same time? This is not rational. However, some may ask, "If God can do anything, why can't he become a man?" By definition, God does not do ungodly acts, so if God became man and took on human attributes, he would, necessarily, no longer be God. Furthermore, the Bible contains many verses in which Jesus speaks and behaves as if God is a separate being to himself. For example, Jesus "fell on his face and prayed" [Matthew 26:39]. If Jesus was God, then would a God fall on his face and pray? And, who would he be praying to? Some Christians claim that "Jesus is the Son of God." We should ask ourselves, what does this actually mean? Surely God is far removed from having a physical and literal son. Rather, we find that the term "Son of God" is symbolically used in the earliest biblical languages for a "righteous person". It is used throughout the Old Testament for many righteous people such as David, Solomon and Israel - not exclusively for Jesus, "...Israel is my firstborn son," (Exodus 4:22) is one such example. "It is not befitting for Allah to take a son; He is perfect and flawless!"Quran 19:35 The Islamic belief about Jesus explains who the real Jesus was, whilst maintaining the pure belief about God and His complete Greatness, Uniqueness and Perfection. Jesus was as an honourable Prophet sent by God to call to the worship of God alone. So... why am I here? Everyone would acknowledge that our body parts, such as our eyes, ears, brains and hearts, have a purpose. Wouldn't it then make sense that the individual, as a whole, also has a purpose? God, the All Wise, did not create us to simply wander aimlessly or to only fulfil our basic instincts and desires. Rather, we have a higher purpose - to acknowledge and worship God alone, so that we live upon the guidance of our Creator. This guidance enables us to live a successful and blessed life in all aspects. This includes personal acts of virtue like prayer, as well as beneficial acts to society, like being good to one's neighbours, supporting one's family, honesty, and caring for animals. God forbids us from worshiping anything else (e.g. statues, the sun, moon, saints, priests or even Prophets). He does not need any partners or intermediaries. Everyone can always worship God directly. God describes this life as a test, and people are tested in different ways. We cannot control what happens to us, but we can control how we react. Patience during adversities, and gratitude for blessings, are a means of getting closer to God and attaining eternal Paradise. We are also warned of a terrible punishment in Hell if we choose to disbelieve and ignore His commands. So... what do I do now? The test of one's faith is in using one's intellect to contemplate and recognise God's signs and live according to His guidance. This is done by submitting to God's commands, which in Arabic means to become a "Muslim". God, the One and only Creator - 'Allah' in Arabic - has made Islam accessible to everyone, regardless of their history, background or present situation. Therefore, anyone can become a Muslim by simply believing in, and uttering the following testimony of faith: "I testify that there is no god worthy of worship except Allah, and I testify that Muhammad is Allah's Messenger." Isn't it time for you to fulfil your purpose of life, submit to the truth and acknowledge your Creator?
I Always think about this. Jesus raised the dead with the Holy Spirit (obviously with the permission of Allah) I wish there was more info on this instead of weak hadeeths and correlations between versus.
@@ashsharp1985 yes you are doeaking from little knowledge. In the Law Psalms Ketuviim Prophets Nt The Spirit or Holy Spirit is abundantly in bible and even quran has information on that matter 1.comes from Allah 2.not created 3.omnipresent 4.sent by Allah 5.inspires
M Rome monogenes means onlybegotten, so your saying allah is only begotten now? And thus applying your tawhid to Jesus (a mere creature in your view)? LOL
According to your speech sam is a champion debater.. Shabbir debate ( Dr. David wood, Dr. Mike licona, Dr. Jonathan Miclachi, samuel green, Tony costa, Dr. White, Dr. Doglus jacoby, Dr. William leing crig, Dr. Qureshi, jay Smith) multiple times.. Comparing to sam with them.. Sam is just like a pest...
Surah 58:22 refers to the Ruh from Allah (Himself) that strengthens those that have faith and the same Spirit strengthend Jesus...which Ruh is being referred to here because it certainly cannot be wind, an Angel or Jibreel as referred to by some scholars?
Dear Muslims u were told if u dont understand stuff go to People of The Book. Ask Christian's about Holy Spirit. Ask Him into your lives and u will start to do miracles by operating in The Gifts of The Spirit... U will also bear The Fruits of The Spirit.
@@zarabees2123 The word "Injeel" is a transliteration (not translation) of the greek word "eu-angelion" which means "good news". 1. Why does the Quran use a original greek word to refer to the book of Jesus, if it doesnt mean the in the 7th century well known greek book called "eu-angelion"? 2. What is the "good news" if not the news about the life, death (for the forgivness of sins), resurrection and inthronisation of the messiah?
@@johnpeter3626 No scripture was revealed to Isa (Jesus), son of Mirium. He was a Prophet receiving Wahi (instructions, guidance) and send to the original Semitic Hebrew tribes of Mid-East living under pagan Roman rule to bring them back to following the laws given to Moses. No evidence exists in Gospels (auto-biographies), Jesus receiving new revealations from God via angels, hence Wahi (instructions, guidance) was being dictated thru dreams. So-called Gospels (written decades after the demise of Isa by human beings, with the last one dated to be from around 90-100 C.E) are also auto-biographies containing sayings/actions which are attributed to Isa (Jesus). What Qu’ran refers to as Injeel is NOT a Qitab(scripture) but rather the “sayings and actions” of Isa (i.e. in Islamic tradition what is called Sunnah) bits of pieces in concocted form may have been preserved in the auto-biographies called Gospels. But Injeel in its entirety does NOT exist. So NO Injeel is NOT gospel but rather gospels are auto biographies of Jesus written by human beings(all former pagans !) containing in addition to lots of corrupted/innovated saying and actions attributed to Jesus, some authentic saying’s and actions. This is what Quran calls Injeel.
Hi, Catholic here! We ourselves believe the Trinity is a mystery, but I can give a few clarifying points based off what Dr. Ally has said here in this video. We also believe the Holy Spirit is like a wind, a breath of God, he's described in that way in the Old and New Testaments. We are taught that it is by the Holy Spirit that we are alive, as God breathed His spirit into us the same way He did with Adam. We also say that Mary conceived by the Holy Spirit; our interpretation is that it is by the holy spirit that she was able to conceive Jesus. There's an instance in the New Testament where Mary along with Jesus's closest disciples were sitting in an upper room after Jesus had ascended to heaven. The account describes that there came like a roaring wind in the upper room, and this wind enabled them to speak in many different foreign languages that they didn't know before, and also fire appeared over their heads. We consider this instance the moment God sent the holy spirit to dwell within us, and this is why Christians refer to some people as being full of the holy spirit. Simply put, we believe in the Trinity because of Jesus's teachings, and these teachings shape our interpretation of the Old Testament scriptures as well as the New Testament. I don't know what Protestants believe, but Catholics believe the holy spirit proceeds from the Father and the son. We believe they are one in the way a family is one, in that there's a mom, dad, and their child. Three different people, but one entity. It's certainly more mysterious than that, and human words can never suffice, but I hope I at least didn't confuse you further, but helped you know what we believe concerning the holy spirit.
The trinity concept is complicated and confusing doctrine 1+1+1=1 God doesn't make any sense. Even though the trinity didn't mention in the bible I don't know where did Christians get this concept from?
@Bible Bus 2.0 If that's the case, then the father cannot exist without jesus and jesus cannot exist without holy spirit (whichever way). What happened when jesus died? Were all of them cease to exist?
@@criticalthinker1123 The difference is that, Christians worship God Who took on flesh at the appointed time through The Son to come down on earth. Muslims worship a pagan god called Habul (aka Allah). And oh! Christians don’t kiss a pagan stone.
@@edward1412 I asked since Hindu worship man or animal disguise in God just like Christ, who surprisingly didn't know a lot of stuff, but still for you he's co equal to God. I asked what difference did he find that appealed him because both religion are pagan and polytheist?
@@criticalthinker1123 what is the difference between Hindus and Islam and it’s black stone? How can a stone forgive your sins? Why do you worship a stone like the ancient Arabs?
In John 14 Jesus says that the father will send the Helper, the Holy Spirit to help remind the disciples of what Jesus has taught them and to help them remember and guide them.
@علي ياسر A lot. They preached that Jesus Christ is the Son of God. A claim Jesus Christ made while on earth. They also preached about His death and resurrection, and how anyone who believes in Him would be saved. The Bible was written through the power of the Holy Spirit.
So. Spirit is not Jibril - And Mohammed didn’t even say that Jibril is the spirit - teach your followers that Mohammed is limited with knowledge and is not the truth - JESUS IS THE WAY ,THE TRUTH AND THE LIFE!
"She placed a screen (to screen herself) from them; then We sent to her Our Ruh [angel Jibrael (Gabriel)], and he appeared before her in the form of a man in all respects." Surah Maryam, Verse 17 This verse Allah said we sent her our Ruh in the form of a man. It is clear that this was Gabriel from hadith narrations and is also found in the gospels of Matthew and Luke. 👍🏼
@@BO0O0M650 O people of the Book, be not excessive in your Faith, and do not say about Allah anything but the truth.The MasīH ‘Īsā, the son of Maryam, is only a Messenger of Allah, and His Word that He had delivered to Maryam, and a spirit from Him. So, believe in Allah and His Messengers. Do not say “Three”. Stop it. That is good for you. Allah is the only One God. Exalted is He above having a son. To Him belongs what is in the heavens and what is in the earth. And Allah is enough to trust in." Qur'an 4:171 Ruh-ullah (Soul/Spirit of Allah): According to the early religious scholars from among the Companions of the Prophet (ﷺ) and their students and the Mujtahidun, there is a rule to distinguish between the two nouns in the genitive construction: a) When one of the two nouns is Allah, and the other is a person or a thing, e.g. Allah's House (Bait-ullah); Allah's Messenger (Rasul-ullah); and Allah's slave ('Abdullah); Allah's spirit (Ruh-ullah), the rule for the above words is that the second noun, e.g., house, messenger, slave or spirit is created by Allah and is honourable in His Sight, and similarly, Allah's spirit may be understood as the spirit of Allah, in fact it is a soul created by Allah, i.e. 'Isa (Jesus). And it was His Word: "Be!"- and he was [i.e. 'Isa (Jesus) was created like Adam]. b) But when one of the two is Allah and the second is neither a person nor a thing, then it is not a created thing but is a Quality of Allah, e.g. Allah's Knowledge ('Ilm-ullah); Allah's Life (Hayat-ullah); Allah's Statement (Kalam-ullah); and Allah's Self (Dhat-ullah). 👍🏼
@@BO0O0M650 Yes Jesus is God Jesus said I need to live you but I will send you Conforter,Who if not God can send Holy Spirit, if not God himself.Did Prophet Muhommad sent a conforter to enyone?
You shouldn’t think like that, that’s coming from another Muslim. Allah gave us the Quran to understand his word and to abide to his words. No one should blindly follow a religion. If you’re confused, ask or look in the Quran, don’t listen to any sheikh who isn’t validated. I’m not saying the guy in the video is not valid, I’m just saying.
@@Dkeneod Allah's power is unlimited. So his creations are not limited to angels, the holy spirit, mankind, djinns and animals. From the Quran we can assume that Jibriel is the holy spirit since they share the same attributes as being creatures who can change in beautiful human beings and both have a role in the revelations of the quran, but it's also possible that the holy spirit is not Jibriel AS. Only Allah knows best.
Why are christians here so insecure about their faith? If you believe in your trinity and 3=1 go and practice your religion instead desperately spamming other religions’ videos.
It seems the Holy Spirit plays mainly a nonexistent role in the life of a Muslim as Dr Ally has difficulty defining the term. He knows about it, but he cannot use the Bible which has much more to say as its explanations conflict with the teachings of Islam. He is respectful and I respect that.
the holy spirit in islam surely doesnt play an important role : he plays the same role as an angel, except that Allah loves him more than any angel. he is the one that reveals the message of god to the prophets, but other wise, hes just an angel
@@natu5257 what in the world are you saying. never was that stated anywhere that Allah's internal spirit is creature. the holy spirit is simply djibril as or the angel gabriel. and Allah is way beyond imagination compared to your human god so you couldnt describe his spirit as a creature that you normally see but it would adress to another aspect, such as the qualities of the creature, a little bit like the interpretation of his physical caracteristics, wich are of course not similar to anything human
@@natu5257 and if you have an AUTHENTIC source for your statement I would love to see it as well as its authentic interpretation.. see, you laught at our religion with no knowledge, wich thereforth makes you an ignorant person. laught at me but not at my god.
1-I respect your opinion, Dr. Shabbir, but I do not agree with you. Many scholars have argued that the Holy Spirit is the angel Gabriel, peace be upon him, and their position is taken from the Holy Qur’an, where we have a general rule that the Qur’an is explained by the Qur’an. Then, peace and blessings be upon him, then in another verse he mentioned that he is the faithful spirit, and in another verse he mentioned that he is the Holy Spirit 2- Gabriel, peace be upon him, is the closest of the angels to God Almighty, and God assigned him to be the messenger for the prophets in order to inform them of the revelation and support them. He was always with the Prophet Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him, and he came once before the Companions In the form of a man who is not from the people of the city and who does not have the fatigue of traveling or dirt and does not have a camel or anything, he came from heaven just as he came to Mary, peace be upon her, in the form of a man. When we connect everything, it is clear
Even as written in your Quran that the Holy Spirit is angel jubril. The total believe of the Holy Spirit in Islam is all fraud. Even your scholars are not showing you any truth on anything.
وعن عمران بن حصين أنه سمع رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم قال: «رأيت حمامة بيضاء على نخلة فقلت لأصحابي هاهنا روح القدس معنا، فقال جابر: ما هذا يا رسول الله وأنا؟» “لقد نزل الله إلينا في صورة حمامة، فامتلأ الجمع خوفاً وفرحاً عندما سمعوا ذلك. Imran ibn Husain reported that he heard from the Messenger of Allah that said ” I saw a white dove perched on a date tree and I told my companions here the Holy Spirit is with us and Jabir said, ” What is this Dear Prophet, and I said ” God has come down to us in the form of a dove and the crowd was filled with fear and joy when they heard it. -- ( Kitab alhikmat al Nabawiyya , Page 274, Volume I , By Shaykh Abu Bakr Umar ,Dar al-Kutub al-Qawmiya Islamic Publication ,1978 ,Cairo Egypt )
Bible teaches Tawhid. The Greek word is monogenēs (μονογενής). monogenēs (μονογενής) means one of a kind or one and only. It translates to Arabic Wahid. وحيد.
I was touched by the holy spirit so i now its true you cant even explain how powerful that experience was it turned my life around and wittnessed people talking in tongues it was a promise by JESUS i will sent to you the SPIRIT OF TRUTH as a witness of me. But i do like dr shabir i find him very respectful when he talks the way it should be
@@voidremoved its a feeling of something going threw you its very hard to explain so people can understand it during a healing prayer two guys prayed over me and told me everything about me i had three alarm clocks to get up my stress was very high at the time took medication for it they told me you will not need the alarms anymore or take medication also about my marriage and this feelin99 of complete peace and a feeling i cant explain and i never needed that alarm was on time for work never late stopped the medication stopped drinking and got back with my wife even though know i go threw anxiety i have that to get me threw it
Mz Beats well to me it’s not never knowing anything about it after what happened studied it’s right there i was touched by the HOLY SPIRIT the same way the BIBLE talked about
But is Mohammed not the ‘praise one’? So allah is the praise two or how can you be praising two people and blasphemy applies to both of them. Is Mohammed not your god? If you say no, then why do you kill the people who speak against him?
@@rodstars1914 oh! May The Lord open your eyes of understanding in Jesus name. There is no salvation in any other except in The Lord Jesus Christ. Every believer in anyone else is preparing for The Lake of Fire.
Shabir missed that the Holy Spirit bears witness to believers in Christ/God [Jehovah/Yahweh] of Him (Who Christ/God is - then (during biblical times) and now), guides /teaches truth through revelation - proves truth of bible - the Word of God given to his saints/apostles - divinely inspired, God-breathed Word of God. The Holy Spirit is active - convicts of truth and sin (wrongdoing, operating outside of God’s will) also imbues ordinary women and men with the power (for that moment) to heal, reveal hidden truths within the Word of God and so much more! The person of the Holy Spirit is so deep and rich. Come and feast at the table of the Most High God. You’ll never hunger or thirst again 🙏🏾
I can debate your sam shamoun just one question to him, where I could find your god yahweh of old in the new testament? Come on help sam shamoun to the question.
Miraculous birth of Jesus Matthew mentioned Holy Spirit and Luke mentioned Angel Gabriel , So who is Holy Spirit if not Angel Gabriel which also support by the Holy Qur'an? Matthew 1:18 NIV 18 This is how the birth of Jesus the Messiah came about: His mother Mary was pledged to be married to Joseph, but before they came together, she was found to be pregnant through the Holy Spirit. Luke 1:26-27 NIV The Birth of Jesus Foretold 26 In the sixth month of Elizabeth’s pregnancy, God sent the angel Gabriel to Nazareth, a town in Galilee, 27 to a virgin pledged to be married to a man named Joseph, a descendant of David. The virgin’s name was Mary. Qur'an 19 : 16:17 And mention, [O Muḥammad], in the Book [the story of] Mary, when she withdrew from her family to a place toward the east. - Saheeh International And she took, in seclusion from them, a screen. Then We sent to her Our Angel [i.e., Gabriel], and he represented himself to her as a well-proportioned man. - Saheeh International.
I’m not a scholar of Islam and this is just my humble opinion. I guess the term “Al-ruh” and “ruhul qudus” spirit & holy spirit are used in many ways and doesn’t pertain only to an angel like Gabriel (peace be upon him). I guess the terms might pertain sometimes to Gabriel or other angel or it might be pertaining to the “wahi”(revelation) to the Prophet or an inspirational force from God that uplifts the believers and empowering them both mentally & physically. Just like how it is used in the Bible. It could be pertaining to the Divine influence of God on the Creations. Again only Allah knows best..
I’ve read the Quran numerous times. I’ve haven’t once seen Gabriel being addressed as an Angel anywhere in the Quran. He’s always called by name. Most translations address him as Angel but the Arabic is always ‘Ruh’. Is Gabriel the Holy Spirit? One example: فَٱتَّخَذَتْ مِن دُونِهِمْ حِجَابًۭا فَأَرْسَلْنَآ إِلَيْهَا رُوحَنَا فَتَمَثَّلَ لَهَا بَشَرًۭا سَوِيًّۭا Transliteration (2021): fa-ittakhadhat min dūnihim ḥijāban fa-arsalnā ilayhā rūḥanā fatamathala lahā basharan sawiyya Word for Word Dr. Shehnaz Shaikh, Ms. Kauser Katri, and more: Then she took from them a screen. Then We sent to her Our Spirit then he assumed the likeness for her (of) a man well-proportioned. Sahih International: And she took, in seclusion from them, a screen. Then We sent to her Our Angel, and he represented himself to her as a well-proportioned man.
Asalam o alaikum dear brother. The verse you are referring to contains indeed the word 'Ruh'. Sahih International translates ruh to Angel with capital A to differentiate the word from malaaika (angels). Ruh is the holy spirit but there is no quote in the quran nor hadeeth that states that this spirit is Jibriel AS. We can only make assumptions based on verses from the Quran and from the hadeeth. Basically connecting the dots. The hadith of Jibreel mentions his human form when he came to visit Muhammad PBUH: "Once we were sitting in the company of Messenger of Allah when there appeared a man dressed in very white clothes and having extraordinary black hair. No signs of fatigue of journey appeared on him and he was known to none of us ... Then he departed. - - He was Jibreel". Also Quran 16:102 Say (o Muhammad), “The holy spirit has brought it down from your Lord with the truth to reassure the believers, and as a guide and good news for those who submit ˹to Allah˺.” Quran 2:97 Say, ˹O Prophet (Muhammad),˺ “Whoever is an enemy of Gabriel should know that he revealed this ˹Quran˺ to your heart by Allah’s Will, confirming what came before it-a guide and good news for the believers.” It's clear that the Ruh and Jibriel share the same attributes as being able to take on a (beautiful) human form and have a major role in the revelations of the quran. But we cant say with certainty that Jibriel AS is the same holy spirit that presented itself to Meryem. Only Allah knows. Surah 78:38 يَوْمَ يَقُومُ ٱلرُّوحُ وَٱلْمَلَـٰٓئِكَةُ صَفًّۭا ۖ لَّا يَتَكَلَّمُونَ إِلَّا مَنْ أَذِنَ لَهُ ٱلرَّحْمَـٰنُ وَقَالَ صَوَابًۭا The Day that the Spirit and the angels will stand in rows, they will not speak except for one whom the Most Merciful permits, and he will say what is correct. Surah 2:98 مَنْ كَانَ عَدُوًّا لِلَّهِ وَمَلَائِكَتِهِ وَرُسُلِهِ وَجِبْرِيلَ وَمِيكَالَ فَإِنَّ اللَّهَ عَدُوٌّ لِلْكَافِرِينَ Whoever is an enemy to Allah and His angels and His messengers and Jibriel and Mikail - then indeed, Allah is an enemy to the disbelievers. Surah 66:4 وَإِنْ تَظَاهَرَا عَلَيْهِ فَإِنَّ اللَّهَ هُوَ مَوْلَاهُ وَجِبْرِيلُ وَصَالِحُ الْمُؤْمِنِينَ it is best if you (wives) both turn to Allah in repentance, for your hearts have certainly faltered. But if you ˹continue to˺ collaborate against him, then ˹know that˺ Allah Himself is his Guardian. And Gabriel, the righteous believers, and the angels are ˹all˺ his supporters as well. Surah 97:4 تَنَزَّلُ الْمَلَائِكَةُ وَالرُّوحُ فِيهَا بِإِذْنِ رَبِّهِمْ مِنْ كُلِّ أَمْرٍ The angels and the Spirit descend therein by permission of their Lord for every matter. What we can conclude from these verses is that Jibriel and the Spirit are mentioned seperately from the malaika (angels). Is it because they have a special status or because they are from a different creation? Again, only Allah knows. As where the angels have 2,3,4 wings (Surah 35:1 All praise is for Allah, the Originator of the heavens and the earth, Who made angels as His messengers with wings-two, three, or four. He increases in creation whatever He wills. Surely Allah is Most Capable of everything) Jibriel has 600 wings ("He increases in creation" can be applied on Jibriel). We can again only assume that Jibriel is from the malaika creation but we can not be 100% sure of that. Surely Allah's power is limitless and thus his creations are not limited to humans, djinn, angels, the holy spirit and animals. Jibriel AS is also different from the malaika in other ways. He is the only creature to whom Allah always directly communicates to, no (other) angel has that privilege and he is the chief of the angels.
You try so much lol. Stop pointing the ambiguous and skipping the clear lol. Say, “Whoever is an enemy to Gabriel - it is [none but] he who has brought the Qur’an down upon your heart, [O Muhammad], by permission of Allah , confirming that which was before it and as guidance and good tidings for the believers. (2:98) Whoever is an enemy to Allah and His angels and His messengers and Gabriel and Michael - then indeed, Allah is an enemy to the disbelievers. (66:4)
Youre funny. Ur trying to attribute partner to Allah by trying to take your interpretation of the quran. While the whole quran is emphacizing about tawhid alllllllllllll long from a to z. With you logic that also means Micheal is not angel. So attribute him to Allah. Looks likt it is what your doing. In the first one it is said that Jibreel gave the revelation to Muhammad. And Muhammad SWS assured everyone that Jibreel is the master of the angels. The quran is not open for your own interpretation
@@frap9965Dear brother, I'm not interpreting anything here and definitely not considering any of the creations as attributes of Allah. I'm only making the link between the holy ruh, Jibriel AS and the angels. Logically speaking by connecting all the verses and the hadeeth, Jibriel AS is an angel with a special status and referred to as the holy ruh. I'm just dissecting the dots i connected. It's common knowledge that Jibriel is a special angel which is widely accepted because he is mentioned in the quranic verses when Allah talks about the gathering of the angles and Jibriel/the holy spirit. Since malaik is derived from malak which means messenger, Jibriel would definitely fit the category of angel. But he is also something more than an angel since he gets treated different than the angels. When i stated that the ruh that presented itself to Meryem as a man, i didnt mean that it may have been some attribute of Allah but rather a different creature. Our knowledge about the other creations is very limited although i tend to believe that it was indeed Jibriel AS who visited Meryem.
Shabir SAM SHAMOUN CHALLENGES YOU TO A 2 DEBATES 1) "Does the Quran teach Tawhid?" and 2) "Does the Bible teach the Trinity?". Please step up to the plate and debate him.
M Rome yes I am a native Greek I know what monogenes means... monogenes does not mean tawhid, tawhid refers to allahs “oneness”. Monogenes refers to onlybegotten. The verse about monogenes is speaking of JESUS, are you saying JESUS is allah? Thank you for destroying your Quran.. Also tawhid means unification, if allah is one there is no need to unify him... your own ISLAMIC Arabic dictionary says this...
@@first_last2740 "Native Greek" or Fake Greek? No one translates "monogenes" to "Only Begotten" not even in John 3:16. Old King James made a bad mistake.
Today the same holy Spirit is Muhammad, tomorrow he is angel Gabriel, very confusing. Both books mentioned spirits but Holy Spirit is specific you cannot equate to other spirits.
@@dennismuiha629 well thank you but I don’t listen to any of your sheiks or imams teaching anything and when teaching it from your books. It’s obvious that Mohammed copied those things and fabricated them into your quran. The holy spirit in your book is not The Holy Spirit in the bible. Even the antichrist in your book is not the antichrist in the bible and likewise the jesus in your book is not the one I know. All the bible names copied into your book are not the same as those ones in my bible. You or anyone in Islam don’t know who Holy Spirit is and so, you don’t know the truth. I have never seen this man speaking any truth before and I don’t expect him.
@@FindTruthintheBible hey I gave my opinion on how he explained it he clearly stated Quran doesn't tell who is holy spirit he admitted this truth and that is a honest answer from someone of his rank, and I ain't a Muslim you can see my name I don't know why you wanna brand me
@@fidelcatsro6948 Hmm pretty much like the Holy spirt John 16:13 But when he, the Spirit of truth, comes, he will guide you into all the truth. He will not speak on his own; he will speak only what he hears, and he will tell you what is yet to come.
Hmm. Well ..the spirit within me..shines from a silohet of flowing glowing light..which waves at me.. I see him when my eyes are closed.. Then I asked..if he could send my dog...and my dog came.. And a tree..and the wind stopped and started.. And I see.. We are ..connected as one..in a combined..body.. ...... Its written in king James bible.. John 14:17. And alot of Christian scriptures.. But of course that's..gods spirit.. Within.. ...... I wonder if Elohim..El Is Allah.. .... Please feel free to comment.. May peace of god be within you.. And may you understand.. The importance.. Of that which we "as Christians" are taught.. Never is it forgiven..if we swear against..the holy spirit.. Which is the spirit of truth.. .... so can Allah be seen..or the spirit within..bring.. such a oneness.. Being then one with god. And we kinda return to the garden..of Eden. Knowing also...one" God" is within. and of course sets our day before us.. Helping ..us all the ways possible.. But also that all our ways be sharing Love peace Kindness Gentleness Goodness And Faithfullness.. Towards..all people and all faiths.. For that is.. The light of life which resides in us all.. Mind you not all Christians..know this..nor see god within.. But rather than me read the Quran.. Perhaps. Can you tell me... Your personal understanding..of that which ive written It's written as.. The body is the temple..of gods spirit..the holy spirit.
Does allah have a soul allah said in quran in surath al hijr verse no 29 And when I have proportioned him and breathed into him of My [created] soul, then fall down to him in prostration."
No, it just means that soul belongs to God like all souls In this verse Allah means that this spirit is a creation of Him, like when He tells us "My servants" it just means that it belongs to Allah, there are also other examples where He calls His creation as " My ...."but, like said, it just means that it belongs to Him Allah created Adam, Allah created the soul, and Allah Himself blew the soul into Adam (as) there is a movement believing that we all have some divinity in us, but astaghfirullah, this is not what islam teaches. There is only 1 deity, and that is Allah
Bible teaches Tawhid. The Greek word is monogenēs (μονογενής). monogenēs (μονογενής) means one of a kind or one and only. It translates to Arabic Wahid. وحيد.
Holy spirit sent by spiritual human body?died in the cross from the hands of the sinners then sinners save mankind from the blood of christ, Praying himself, very sicked christians ideology..
@Handy Man christianity only twisted the scripture of the jewish literature .Isaiah 53 does not talk of jesus.. Where did jesus says my blood is the everlasting covenant Hebrew 13:20?
@Handy Man poor knowledge of satan😅,he can do all things just to ask jesus to worship him,but the drama and deception of your so called bibles says "IF THOU BE THE SON OF GOD,COMMAND THIS STONES TO MADE BREAD"(your god does not show anything miracle to satan just to prove it he is the son of god😅 and satan did not know if jesus is god why did satan confused to ask jesus😅and satan fails to ask magically your god jesus and does not perform it then satan leave jesus and angel came after satan left,why the angel never came since jesus argued satan😆your bible full of drama and deception..
The holy spirit in the bible is still answering to the Father..there is difference in status between them..but the christians made him the 3rd person of God.
@@efdawahfan Personally I can agree with you that many Christians do that. But the Bible signifies that God is a spirit and that there is only one God. Thus, the Holy Spirit according to the scriptures is God
Don’t even learn the things of the bible from Muslims or else, you will get itchy ears and iro funfun balawu ni won maa Ko e. Be shaneli arakunrin kan ti oruko re nje woli Arabian wo Lori ikoni yii. Ti koi ba tii gbayo fidio re lori oro emi mimo ninu esin awon elesin iro yii, o maa keko nibe and don’t forget to soskribu si saneli naa fun atimo awon inkan nipa esin yii. Omo Middle East ni
Kudos to Dr. Ally for consulting biblical sources for answers to questions that clearly point to biblical source material. But the meaning of the Holy Spirit with respect to Mary is very clearly explained in Luke 1:35: "The angel answered, 'The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you. So the holy one to be born will be called the Son of God.'" The virgin birth and the indwelling of the Holy Spirit point to the coming Son of God. This passage also answers another muslim controversy - clearly the Holy Spirit is not Gabriel, since he is the one announcing the work of the Spirit.
Then jesus(as) when he is born as a holy spirit then he leave in John 14:26 he(jesus) sent another jesus holy spirit😆😆😆sicked ideology of christianity..
Gabriel himself is the messanger angel and his first answer is his answer as an individual the holy spirit itself could potentially be the deliverance of a vague spirit (which makes sense as Isa AS is the messiah for the children of Israel despite their rejection of him and in the end times he will be the messiah for all of us as he never truly died (at least in islam he never died) Another potential interpretation could be that the answer is God's answer and the act of Gabriel AS coming could be the holy spirit depending on interpretation (also son of god is a translation error its has also been used for many prophets in the old testament in reality son of god is a mistranslation of servant of God or if that isn't good enough it could potentially be wordplay of the idea that they are inheriting the message god sends.
Hollyspirit=Gabriel (Gibreel(A) Gbriel is the Revelation bearing angel even since Adam(A).and he has another things to do(what the God commanded'). If you know about the junood(military force) of Allah,you don't have to take a risk of minutes to describe about the ruh-Ul-Quds Gibreel(A). The birth of Jesus, splitting of moon,red Sea parted, farova's mout filled with mud,Abu jahl cruelly seized ,and many. Why? The hollyspirit(ruh-Ul-Quds) acted by the commandment of His(and our)Lord Allah SWT. please do not make the religion difficult to ordinary people.
Isaiah 40:12-13 Who hath measured the waters in the hollow of his hand, and meted out heaven with the span, and comprehended the dust of the earth in a measure, and weighed the mountains in scales, and the hills in a balance? Who hath directed the * Spirit of the LORD * or being his counsellor hath taught him? Pretty much Shirk, isn't it? By the way who made me final prophet?
i used to look up to people like Zakir naik, mufti menk, omer suleiman, nomam ali khan etc.. After finding Dr shabir, i don’t trust the other scholars anymore except for he
Thank you for the video. It is good to have these discussions. The Old Testament does call the Spirit of God the Holy Spirit in Psalm 51:11 , Isaiah 63:10-11. The Torah, Prophets, Psalms and Gospel speak a lot about the Spirit. In short, he perfects and enacts God's will in creation, and the promise is that the Messiah will give the Holy Spirit to God's people. Regarding the Qur'an, the Holy Spirit is God’s breath through whom he gave Adam life (Q. 15:29). God sends his Spirit with revelation (Q. 16:102), and the Spirit comes as a man as an agent of God to Mary (Q. 19:17) to announce the birth of Jesus. Therefore, in the Qur’an the Holy Spirit is the personal breath of God who is his agent into the world. It seems there is a remnant of Trinitarian theology in the Qur'an.
" do not say 3 " please dont superimpose Trinitarian theology on the Quran to justify idolotary. Shabir cleary mentions that the spirit is a created being if you were listening pastor it would do you good. Dont forget the Jews dont accept your idolotary either. in all 3 Abrahamic faiths the Father/Allah has always been the creater God the most high whom everything is subordinate too. this is even the case with the Bible " of that hour non know but the father " " The father is greater than I " " I accend to my father and your father my God and your God " Does God have a God please think your logic through next time
@@delpthepath127 it's in the hadith secondary sources but dont forget Jews dont have the conception of holy spirit the way you do. Your church fathers did not know what the holy spirit was so they added it to the God head. Thet dug a deeper hole to fill a smaller one
@@knowledge_lantern So your god couldn’t reveal it in his supposed direct revelation and now we gotta rely on man to tell us about it through oral traditions? Ok makes sense. Not sure why you’re telling me about Jews as if they are my role model. Jews don’t have the same concept of salvation or afterlife either. So let’s stop with the red herrings. My question was simple, and you answered that it’s not in your Quran. That’s enough for me. Are the hadiths the direct words of Allah too? Read Psalms 51:11, the Holy Spirit is in the Old Testament and in several places. And I’m not a trinitarian nor a unitarian. Your red herring tendencies are strong You don’t know what the Holy Spirit because your faith is not in Yahweh, the Creator and Our Father. I have no church fathers
@@delpthepath127 let me address your points one at a time I'll make it simple for you 1. God does not reveal everything in his direct revelation otherwise it would get impractically too long, Just how the Jewish people have the talmud as an oral tradition. Regardless the holy spirit is also mentioned in the Quran in quran 17:85. From this we can clearly see the holy spirit is not God. There are many details missing from all scriptures as it would be impractical to include everything the book would otherwise be too long 2. The reason I mentioned the Jewish people to you is because you I assume, hold onto the New and Old testament as the inspired words of God. I am merly explaining to you that in Jewish theology like Pslams 51.11 and genisis 1. the holy spirit is a divine entity that is not God but can be translated as the wind of God or power or someother unknown entity. 3. if you are not a unitarian or trinitarian then what are you, a binitarian ? sounds like equvication and sophisty to try and avoid polythiesm. Simply if you believe in the holy spirt father and son as co equal and co eternal you are a pagan Trinitarian. 4. "Are the hadiths the direct word of Allah" they can be if its a Qudsi hadith. perhaphs you should study a little more 5. Yahwah was a pagan desert God created by the amalgamation of Yah and Wah Jesus does not refer to God as Yahwah in the New testament. additionally you are misinformed on what Allah means. Allah means the one true creator God its not a name rather a title. Thus if you claim to worship the one true God then you worship Allah by default regardless if you like it or not :)
Shabbir ally do a comprehend video on preservation of quran... Last 2 weeks it has been tough time for Muslims when Yasir qadhi himself declared Quran is not preserved.. Instead of going around others faith,refute your religious concepts
He didn't say this, watch the full video. Yasir said that this is a complex topic, but the quran is fully preserved and so the different readings. Christians took the video out of context, so don't worry
@@BO0O0M650 do you think I'm an infidel if I don't believe in Hadith at all.. I only believe in Quran and I feel Hadith only insults our beloved prophet pbuh.. I feel Hadith are fabricated stories which propagate selfish medieval agendas by putting up our Prophet as a brand.. Like there are numerous violent Hadith that put our Prophet in negative light.. What do you think?
Holy Spirit is the God Not Jesus Jesus is Human a perfect soul that God made him inside the womb of his mother. How can be God become a human? And dead in 3 days? What well happen to the world if God dead?. Can u image on that. Holy Spirit is independent not 3 not by 4 . Jesus (as) represents the Holy Spirit by his unique born and by his self a holy men.but Not God. Whe he speak he always says Father.
@@monikatobias7061 but in the Bible God never said he's three jesus said "God is one he's one he is my lord and your Lord" if Jesus was an equal how could he pray to himself how could he not know time? Jesus is a prophet the Bible has been corrupted by man how can you not see it you guys have many different versions of the book original Jesus has one holy book but the non believer change it why else is there other version of the book made by man with proof think about it..
@@theScorpio-kz7xc Jesus to us Christian is not a prophet, understand that, but God, why? Because hee was prophecied by the, profet, that, he is the messiah, and to us Christian God is 3in1, just the same as you, you can, be a father, unncle or a granny to someone but it's you, because those people, where cannal, in fresh don't understand, the things of God, he was making it easier, for them to, understand wich is easier for them, just as you you understand that he is a prophet you are in the same way, (as long as Jesus is not dead, he is my king, my lord and personal savior).
@عَبْدُ الله SlaveOfGod YOU THINK EVRYBODY BELIEF WHAT YOU BELIEF ???? I DONT NEED YOUR SCHOLARS I HAVE MY OWN WICH IS CHRISTIAN JEWISH AND ISLAM DR SHABYR ALLY IS TO ME THE BEST AND HE TOLD IN A SESION WHAT IS THE HOLLY SPIRIT ? GO AND WATCH IT ON YOU TUBE .IT CALLS LET THE QURAN SPEAK WISH YOU THE BEST SOON IT JUDGEMINTSDAY AND HELL WAITS MOST OF US . WE ARE BORN TO SIN AND TO ETERNALY HELL FOR NOT FOLLW GOD LAWS AMIN
Very contradicting response from Dr. Shabbir. Vast majority of Muslim scholars clearly stated "Ruh-ul_Qudus" (noble spirit) refers to angel Jibreel bcz this particular angel is very different than other angels when it comes to his role. ordinary angels are referred to as Malaika. The word Ruh is also used for soul and command from God. Context is important..
@pwhak 88 Moron. Little learning could be dangerous. No where in the Quran does it state that God breathed life into men. Stop comparing GOD with creation. GOD is beyond time and space. what is stated is "Be and it becomes"..
@@tazboy1934 God is nothing like his creation. God doesn't have any spirit. Words were used make scripture easy to understand foe the audience, no different than schools teacher using analogy to explain to little children. They can't be taken them literally.
All our souls are from the breath of God. Just like how God breathed into mud to make adam. If that’s ur logic then adam and all of us are “the rooh of Allah”
Interesting upload; however, in Genesis 2:7 (The Old Testament - The Holy Bible), it actually says: "And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life, and man became a living soul." So it would appear that "the breath of life" (our living souls) is distinct from The Holy Spirit, which is Almighty God's own Spirit that hovered over the waters in the creation story also in Genesis. This same Holy Spirit indwelled the Bless Virgin Mary, at God's appointed time; a sinless woman, at the Incarnation, which led to her giving birth to the only sinless man to have ever existed - The Messiah Jesus Christ. Dr Shabir's statement regarding what The Bible (New Testament) says about the Holy Spirit, consoling the believers is correct.
There is nothing any Muslim can say about the Holy Spirit that will be correct. Don’t let whatever he as said and you believe that is true fool you. Please don’t have itchy ears to their words. He must have found it outside their books
فَٱتَّخَذَتْ مِن دُونِهِمْ حِجَابًۭا فَأَرْسَلْنَآ إِلَيْهَا رُوحَنَا فَتَمَثَّلَ لَهَا بَشَرًۭا سَوِيًّۭا -------------------- And she took, in seclusion from them, a screen. Then We sent to her Our Angel, and he represented himself to her as a well-proportioned man. *Quran (**19:17**)*
Holy spirit Gabriel 🤣🤣🤣 Dang Dang this is really a Jokeeeeee ... eaven a child know that Gabriel is Arch Angel and Messenger Angel ... Aww Aww Awww ... To Mary was Gabriel ... Adam was made from earth .. And Jesus was blesed in Virgin Mary from the Father and Holy Spirit ✝️ YAHWE ... Lion Of Judahs ✝️✝️
Unless you fully understand Arabic, you’re never gonna understand the true meaning of the Holy Quran no matter how hard anti-Islamist Christian bigots and missionaries try. Keep that in your mind and have a good day.
If you accept Jesus as LORD and savior ask for the Holy Spirit and he will show you the truth He will bear witness to Jesus and you will know the truth and the truth will set you free Seek and you will find knock and the door will be opened Everyone who seeks God with truth and honesty in humbleness will find him Some may see a vision Some may hear his voice Some will be guided to the truth by people of God (Christians) Some will have their spiritual ears/eyes opened to the truth Either way you will have no doubt anymore because you know the truth. But don't resist God by hardening your hearts because he will give you what you want your own ignorance And you will remain blind and die in your stubbornness Many Muslims, Jewish and other religions have come to Christianity thx to a vision or a spiritual encounter with Jesus Type on RU-vid "Muslim vision and dreams" This is a serious matter because one day you will face a Holy perfect God alone Not with your imam, father, son, wife or husband... You and God alone If you think a Holy perfect being will not find faults in you, you're mistaken and arrogant/prideful
Even if your rant is true, I didnt read it. But that doesnt mean we should disregard other things. For Example, i do not casually dismiss the Mormons claim that a man had an encounter from an appearance of Jesus. But its not my church. But I choose to believe that oh cool so we have another documented event. Cool. Some Jesus dude had a crazy thing appear out of nowhere and God spoke from invisibility? Now some Mohammed guy sees a crazy thing too? Then some other guy? You mention Jewish too, while there is things to be learned from their understandings. you may be the one missing the point. After all, on whose authority are you preaching? Are you a Doctor?
Qur'an 19 :17 tells spirit is Gabriel N he came in a form perfect n complete human...... Read the ch19:17 commentry She placed a screen before them; This means that she hid herself from them and concealed herself. فَأَرْسَلْنَا إِلَيْهَا رُوحَنَا then We sent to her Our Ruh, Then, Allah sent Jibril to her. فَتَمَثَّلَ لَهَا بَشَرًا سَوِيًّا and he appeared before her in the form of a man in all respects. This means that he came to her in the form of a perfect and complete man. Mujahid, Ad-Dahhak, Qatadah, Ibn Jurayj, Wahb bin Munabbih and As-Suddi all commented on Allah's statement, فَأَرْسَلْنَا إِلَيْهَا رُوحَنَا (then We sent to her Our Ruh),
This is COMPLETELY FALSE! The narrative of Jesus' conception is being misunderstood or twisted by the scholars who are trying to conflate Gabriel with the Holy Spirit. This is the ONLY unforgivable sin! Be careful.
Can any of you muslims explain to me if The Holy Spirit is Gabriel, then where does Gabriel get his power? Is Gabriel a God? No. So tell me who is more correct when we say that God is the Holy Spirit.
Muslims saying the holy spirit is a mystery 👍👍👍, now they better stop asking about TRINITY. God knows best is = I don't know. Thank you for your honesty.
It isn’t a mystery and the holy spirit isn’t God. If it was God God would say that. As ur bible says God isn’t the author of confusion. Yet the trinity is very confusing
@@hvkhbojnlinlubobilib3220You claim things you don’t know. That’s the biggest set problem either Islam. Now you’re attacking the Holy Spirit! And as usual, you don’t know anything about it.
Accept the debate Dr Shabir Ali, Sam Shamoun would decimate you! Accept it and get schooled...too many errors. Your apolgetic career is about to be ended
Funny you titled your channel "Let the quran speak", Yet no muslims can make sense of it, and this is why muslims need to go see a sheik or an imam to understnad what allah meant when he was revealing his unclear quran to Muhammad. And the imams and the sheiks today needs to go after tafsir over tafsir, from scholars who lived before them who are interpreting each and every verses. Maybe you should consider changing the channel name to "Shabir Ally explains the quran", or better "Let Shabir Ally explains what allah really meant in the quran"
Heh his not explaining Quran hes speaking for the "Holy Spirit" ,Quran is very clear unlike bible changed 5000 times and goes against its own verses in many places ,Quran got not a single mistake
@@umariqbal2321 No, islam is false. Muhammad was not a prophet. Actually, he is the most obvious fake prophet of history There is too many errors in the quran (the type of errors you would expect from a merchant of 7th century Arabia who is making stuff up), and Muhammad was a horrible person. Have a good day.
@@umariqbal2321 Here is one in a million example on why islam is an horrible religion: ru-vid.com/video/%D0%B2%D0%B8%D0%B4%D0%B5%D0%BE-7sVIRsPb6h0.html There are news like this every single day, in the name of the prophet. You guys deify a simple, sinful man, Muhammad.
I’m a Christian but Shabir Ally has a beautiful soul as you could tell that he’s unbiased and purposeful doesn’t lie. No wonder some Muslims dislike him. I pray he hears the voice of Jesus Christ one day.
I respect you, but we follow Jesus Christ more than the Christians, we only bow to The God of Jesus, Abraham, Moses, Isaak, And more and surely the last messenger from God ( Muhammed Peace be upon them all ) Jesus is not God he is God his servant and messenger
@@yargi5811 Don’t seem so respectful but that okay. And don’t you realize that you guys believe in different books. Christians don’t believe in Muhammed they believe in Jesus of the Holy Bible. so, they believe themselves to be Christians.
@@yargi5811 all historical accounts and scholars understand that modern Islam (not just Islam in 630) is the most similar to the historical (not forged biblical) accounts of the 1st century of Christians before it was tainted by the byzantines
He is both ... bashiran wa nadhira' (a giver of glad tidings & warner) he is also khatamannabiyyin (seal of the Prophets). Rasul (Messenger) to all of Mankind. These are all mentioned in the Noble Qur'an.
“And in Mary, ‘Imrān’s daughter, who preserved her chastity and into whose womb We breathed Our spirit; who put her trust in the words of her Lord and His Scriptures, and was truly devout.” This passage of the Quran is mysterious for a Muslim, but very clear for a Christian because it is borrowed from the Gospel of Luke: “The Holy Spirit will come upon you, and the power of the Most High will overshadow you; therefore the child to be born will be holy; he will be called Son of God.”
John 14:15-31 Act 1 vs 8 2 Timothy 1:6-7 Luke 24:49 Act 1:4 Act 2:2 Act 2:4 2 Corinthian 3:17 2 Corinthians 5:5 Psalm 104:30 Act 10:38 Holy Spirit is a divine spirit from/of God. It is the spirit of truth! The comforter and a spiritual/moral guide. It lives in us and within us if you believe. Islam doesn’t have this knowledge and they are struggling to find it since they took stories from the Bible that mentions the spirit of God. Holy Spirit is not Mohammed! It not a wind! It definitely not Angel Gabriel.
Brother distinguished means something that is said or explained but this guy was like oh since the Quran doesn’t say angels are spirits it must mean they are un affiliated. This is like saying since Sam never explicitly claimed to be human he is a mud crab
If Angel gabriel and holy spirit were two separate beings, bringing the quran verses to Mohammed p.b.u.h., wouldnt he not mention this once? Like this verse was from gabriel and that one from the holy spirit?
Q 58:22 The believers are to be supported by the spirit. As the scholar says, this is like the support Jesus also received through the spirit. The Christians know how the spirit supports believers. But the Muslims don't know how the spirit supports believers! It then means Muslims are not really believers supported by the spirit! So, they are not believers according to the Quran!
