The Most Powerful Commanders of Phyrexia: All Will Be One | Power Tier List | EDH | MTG 

So what you're saying is slobad is slow and bad

Feels kind of strange to hear in D Tier "Because you are a mobo colored commander" and see the S Tier Commander and a bunch auf A Tier Commanders are also mono colored 😅

I think the idea of Rhuk is to run him with For Mirrodin and Living Weapon cards that come with something to attach to, but have expensive equip costs.

Skrelv is S tier for the art alone, we will not let Eddie get away with this slander

I don't agree that Mono colored commanders are "limited" in their card selection, sure the cardpool is less but you can play a lot of interesting cards that don't make the cut in decks with more colors, that's why i prefer to stick to around two colors in most of my commander decks.

It's nice to see all 5 of the Dominus' in A tier!

Once you accumulate 3+ equipped creatures, rhuk is literally a loaded gun in the command zone. The deck is creature+equipment focused. You just equip creatures over 1 or 2 turns, then full swing when you summon rhuk. Your not hoping for anything to die.

Always so interesting to see how different people judge the cards. I do find putting Ria above Glissa quite strange.

I don't think Glissa's final ability is supposed to be used offensively. It shines when combined with Sagas. For example, you can retrigger Binding the Old Gods over and over again as long as you keep getting hits in. Eldest One Reborn can similarly turn into a value engine. Phyrexian Scriptures turns into an infinite boardwipe until your opponents can do something about it.

dont forget that for Neyali, you can run phyrexian mites to load up a bunch of poison counters- doesnt really bump her up much imo but it is notable in this context

Ovika is a beast, and the high cost is easily managed through mana rocks.

I definitely disagree about Urtet being C tier. There are about 40 myr card with a good chunk of them that are basically 2 cost mana rocks. Plus there are 3-4 infect myrs with an inbuilt way to buff them in Urtet's +3/+3 and cards like Eldrazi monuement, darksteel forge, etc to give them indestructible and plenty of ways to reduce the cost of the myrs to 0 (leaving room to cast spells from any color). PLUS you can always win by just going wide with tokens (another Urtet effect) then giving them the +3/+3 and swinging out..

You're heavily underestimating the impact of having an instant speed "destroy target artifact or enchantment" on your commander as one of the options, the other ones being gaining evasion and a stat buff. With Liquimetal Coating or Liquimetal Torque, this becomes a Vindicate on a stick in a deck without W or B in it. Also Venser can't give himself flying or lifelink because he isn't an artifact creature.

I had no idea Unctus was so powerful and fortunately I pulled his extended art foil. Guess I’ll have to build him.

But the Myr-mmander?! The Myr-mageddon? The Myr-verwhelming possibilities?

I’m just excited for Atraxa. Maybe it’s not the most creative commander but damn it’s cool

Vrann Executioner Thane, Oh look, a nice addition to my Elas Il Kor and Lurrus deck!

unctus with a card of "if cant draw more card you win" and 2 cards of "tap to untap other card" in the table is a win, legit got that in like 3 turns with a perfect start hand

For Rhuk, any equipment which comes with it’s own token body would work well

Otharri should be at least A tier imo. For mirrodin helps to make rebel tokens to bring otharri back.

Thrun and Glissa not in atleast C tier, Venser not in D tier...interesting. The phoenix too feel it could be B tier, also weird to see myr urza not higher.

I feel like Ezuri should be A tier. Sure it's kind of basic and effectively is just giving extra draws but there are quite a few ways to achieve infinite proliferate and draw with it which with the new cards that give each opponent a poison counter or a few other options just is game over.

The only commander I'm interested in from this set is Vishgraz tbh. Chiss also interested me, but not as much. Plus I already have a mono red deck and I don't wanna be as reliant on artifacts

I dunno, I think people are sleeping on my boy Ezuri. If you can make infinite mana with a sacrifice outlet, you just win right? He draws you your deck and then you cast your win con if choice. You can do this pretty early in game too.

I am drinking a beer for each "that beeing said"......i am totally drunk

having all 5 mono colored phyrexian horrors in A tier, pretty nice balancing

Been playing with a Norn MoM deck with a proxy for Norn. Love how it plays so far. Its a lifegain ETB where the lifegain triggers other effects like card draw. Doesnt have a "I win now" type card in it (although i did one-shot someone with a 55/55 Serra Avatar + Wedding Invitation). It just grinds down other players and I've sent in an equipped, enchanted Norn herself to punch faces since she has Vigilance. Also got the OG Norn in there. Hopefully the real card wont be 50$ a copy like the promos so I can snag the real one. Mondrak is on my list too!

I think Otharri at least B and new venser is just D

Vraan has some potential with something like ashnod's altar and some other cards. I really wanna build it since I pulled him in my first pack

Karumonix is totally going in my Ashcoat deck

Karumonix the rat king is an amazing rat commander if you have a rat tribal

So i Build urtet mir tribal and ist definetly very powerful but i dont really understand the Ranking is it how powerful is the Effect of the commander or how good can you play around it? Die example i think urtet is ez A or S tier cause it is 5 color ez to Build he has an absolutely incredible overloaded kit on effects and you can Combo very ez. For example drivnod is for me D Power cause its only black you loose many oppurtunities for example an aristocrats Deck. The only good thing is his indestructible ability

Glissa I think should be at least c tier the last ability us amazing for a saga deck

As an avid OG Slobad commander player, new slobad is a combo piece waiting to happen.

I really dont understand why Elesh is so high up, one clone effect and you are out of the game. A commander, which ruins your entire deck if your oponnents have it out, is not good in my opinion. Copy, steal, Elesh playing casualy all these things just make the deck super unfun for you. And everybody plays blue so its pretty common to have a copy effect each game, and in addition when you design your deck around elesh and have your spot removal on permanent slot you dont even have anything you can do cause you dont have any etbs

Melira, living cure + Phyrexian unlife = you cannot lose to damage for an aditional 10+ combats after hitting 0 life.

Sorry I just want to ask how do you gain 8 with Vraan it says gain only 2 life and it doesnt say for each life opponent lose. Am i missing something?

Well I thought I had only pulled some mediocre stuff in my prerelease pack (I don't play blue)... But seems I have 'the best commander' and gotta try to make a deck with him lol 😎😂

I’m sorry, but Urtet is definitely S or A tier with it being a cheap, colorless, 3 drop, 5 color, artifact, tribal commander. I built a busted Myr artifact deck with him and have been slaughtering tables all week with it. It creates boatloads of mana and token creatures, I got 20+ artifact lands, kuldotha forgemaster to cheat in threats like darksteel forge to prevent boardwipes, bronze guardian because of its massive power boosted per artifact, mycosynth golem to make everything have affinity for artifacts and basically play everything for free in the deck. Also have tezzeret, master of the bridge to also give everything affinity for artifacts and do massive damage to each opponent with his +2 ability. And have a ton of cards for looting including unctus. Got 3 cheap boardwipes, 2 of which don’t destroy my creatures and plenty of ways to add +1 counters as well. Token doublers like doubling season and Mondrak. A couple tutors to pull anything I need for a couple infinite combos. I even threw in a mechanized production to enchant a myr token and basically win the game on the spot. Artifacts are some the most busted cards in MTG and Urtet is probably one of the best, if not the best commander to run in an artifact deck. You sir, need to reevaluate this list.

Chiss-goria should be at least A tier he is so broken and so underrated.

Dominus sweep let's goooooo!!!!

Most are expensive as hell to be commander or mono color which limit what you can do in commander

Wheres Vorinclex, Monsterous Raider?

Urtet only tier C? I think you really don't understand how powerfull is a commander deck with him... pentacolor, with all tutor. I think Urtet will defeat easly all other stupid commander on this tier list. See you in the future.

Glissa in Tier D???? Hahaha let's retalk about in a month

GIVE JUSTICE TO THE MYR!!!

Did anyone count how many "that being said" were there?

Thrun is the best card 😤

I feel like ixhel is better than you give her credit for. Probably still B tier, but definitely not the bottom of B. Her ability once it gets going is fairly strong tempo. And with as many cheap ways to infect with this set, it's really not that hard to reach 3 counters.

Just realized of all the cards I got, I also got unctus, collector edition..... Hue hue hue....

Today's release day and we still don't know what battle means. 🤔

I knew Ezuri would at least be B tier

Isn't indestructible less good because of all the -1/-1 from toxic?

I built Mondrak Stax and it wins quite often. But Im losing friends

Unctus being the only S tier commander just because you can loot your library so easily is kinda lame. I mean it makes sense since *“WOW Card draw is so good! Who knew!”* But come on it was still lame to see Especially when you made the true best commander Skrelv C tier

Hello. :)

Thrun hits C all day IMO

I honestly don’t think the Dominus belong in A tier at all they in and of themselves S tier. You might be a little bias on it imo.

juggernauts still get wrecked by arcades most defenders aren't walls xD

And now Atraxa dominated all Commander / Historic Brawl and Unctus is not used at all

Chiss-Goria !!!!!!!

Unctus S tier?????

Ixhel didn't deserve that disrespect. Sit down and play against her, you'll probably regret that ranking.

Painter's Servant will be banned in 10, 9, 8.....

Does this mean no more Golden Toilet series? Good.

Hey. At least Skrelv isn't D tier lol.

Rat Colony time

I think tier list videos are more interesting if you don't go from lowest to highest. That kind of takes out the "how will he rate this" anticipation for viewers, since we know that the earliest you mention are D and C tiers and the last ones you bring up are A and S tiers. Not as exciting.

Atraxa is Def an s tier

I don’t like your s tear at all 🤣🤣🤣

i think your tierlist was dogshit, i use elish norn mother of machines and she far out classes your s tier commander. Just because you can win the game quickly doesnt make the card godd

This review is irrelevant as the Biden administration, u clearly don't know how to play magic

Damn, theseare some pretty dogshit opinions.

malcator is my commander when i want tribal phyrexian. also run artifacts, lots of em.