The Most Underrated Pirates Movie?... | On Stranger Tides Commentary & Reactions 

You guys missed a golden opportunity to shout Elizabeth right after the priest yells that the mermaid has a name

Honestly, you look way better with a shaved head. The comb forward was not a great look, and at least now you are embracing the baldness rather than fighting it. Plus, the beard draws attentuon away from the top. 😉

Remember the English guy that got shot by the main Spanish guy? He’s a recurring character. He’s the one that said “That might be the greatest pirate I’ve ever seen.” And “You think he plans it out or just makes it up as he goes.”

Jack's fake kiss will remain to be the funniest scene from the franchise

I like that this movie came out early enough to still have that same “actually shot outdoors” visual style that Curse of the Black Pearl had, unlike Dead Men Tell No Tales

Fun fact: The guy who plays Scrum (Steven Graham) is also in Venom: Let There Be Carnage as the detective (beans guy). 9:19 So that's maybe where you recognize him from subconsciously?

Biggest weaknesses are the Preacher/Siren relationship since its so one sided and Blackbeard isn't much of an antagonist especially since Jack is just chilling with him most of the time. Pintel and Ragetti could have really boosted this too, honestly Ragetti could have had the arc that the preacher had. Its fun though, I grew to like this one

The Spanish were really awesome on this. A powerful enemy with a singular goal that doesn't care for anything else.

We can all agree that the Spanish and Barbossa are the best things about the movie

“Jacks back” Me: “you’re hairs gone” *speaks in barbosa’s voice*

Barbosa really just keeps getting stronger each movie.

The Spaniard is one of my favorite characters, he’s so badass. He pays no attention to Royal Navy as they prepare to fire upon them, they get to the island first, get the chalices, nearly have both Barbossa & Jack Sparrow (some of the most famous pirates) captured, they arrive at the fountain while Pirates & The British are in a battle and surround both parties, kills the Royal commanding officer while noting his bravery, breaks the chalices, claims the fountain is sacrilege and has it destroyed, and finally before leaving, draws his sword and prepares to face down Blackbeard, one of the most feared pirates

You look amazing bald! I think it suits your facial shape and your beard stands out more! Also loved this movie. Loved the first three most, but I still had fun with this one. Jack was still mad and brilliant, the pirate lore of Blackbeard excited me, and the allure of the mermaids was phenomenal. Can’t wait to see your reaction for the fifth one! IM READY FOR A GOOD ROAST ON THAT ONE

The love for Barbossa is everything

Damn, I really am finding myself enjoying these commentaries almost as much as the actual movies lmao

That barbossa impression is spot on

Like most people in these comments are saying, only the 5th one is truly bad. While this one is not amazing, its still a very good movie and a faithful continuation of the Pirates franchise. Btw. If you're having any reservations on you hair, don't, it suits you magnificently.

"Look, Tomar, it's you!"

Random trivia, the guy who held the British flag and got shot was the guy who said “that's got to be the best pirate I’ve ever seen” in the first movie and the one who screamed “abandon ship” in three when The Black Pearl and the Flying Dutchman wrecked the ship and killed Beckett.

I'm living for all the Barbossa love 😂

16:41 I recently rewatched your first 3 pirates reactions, and that Norrington ''No'' is best thing ever

JACK YOU LOOK SO GOOD BALD! Love the new look and your guys content!! These are always the highlight of my week!

The Barbossa impressions are very convincing! I had to look up from my work a few times to check who was talking.

I think we can all agree that this is it. Best to Worst - At World’s End - Dead Man’s Chest - Curse of the Black Pearl - On Stranger Tides - Dead Men Tell No Tales

Barbossa is again the best character with the most interesting arc . #Barbossastan

I’m sure you guys knew but the guy holding the British flag who got shot was the same guy who said “ that’s got to be the best pirate I have ever seen”. I was devastated when he died

Black Beard: "I can't wait for the sun. HANZ, GET THE FLAMMENWERFER!"

If this was a real event, then I could guarantee that there would be a Sabaton song about the Spanish.

"SHE HAS A NAME!" My version: Will screams "ELIZABETH!!!!"

One of my favorite pirates of the Caribbean movies.

Nothing better than more Pirates content from NOC! Also, I like your new look! Looks good!

14:30 Barbossa singing the H2O theme song 💀

If im being honest, the only bad pirate's movie was the 5th one... I loved stranger tides It might not be the best movie but it had the best jack sparrow out of all 5 movies...he was funnier, smarter and tbh I feel johnny depp's acting was a step better than the first 3 in this one

"They're bald now... They're bald now... He's bald now."

Only on this freaking channel of all places can you hear Captain Barbossa, the cursed undead pirate captain from the first movie, and Pirate Lord of the Caspian Sea, sing the theme song from H2O: Just Add Water. XD

The commentaries you post are always so good! Can’t wait for more

YES! Love this movie. No idea why it's gotten so much hate since it came out. It's my second favourite Pirates movie

Scrum definitely would be #RikkiStans

I just realized recently that the Christian guy is finnick from hunger games.

It’s really awesome watching you guys having fun going back to watch movies from our childhoods, always happy when you post a video

I love how like half the people in this film are christians even though the previous film showed greek gods exist

As an English man I’d like to confirm that is exactly how we are in pubs..😂

Me forever defending Gore verbinski’s amazing trilogy! 🎥 ☠️☠️☠️ (Part 1) For anybody who is always praising the first movie to be the best. I have been studying 1-3 and I constantly re-watch them. Pirates of the Caribbean does not go downhill in writing after the first movie. That is your business to believe that opinion everyone else goes with. Dead man’s chest gave the characters more depth! Elizabeth and William barely have anything to work with in the first movie. William’s relationship with his father that was hinted in the first movie of his father‘s existence. Paid off wonderfully. William’s character had way more in depth now and you have something to truly care about him for. You get both perspectives when you understand their Reunion! Bootstrap didn’t want Will to become a pirate like him, he wanted him to have a free life from the pirate life. William had a hard time accepting he was half Pirate but when he accepted his life and his father… He has a new journey to stab the heart of Davy Jones to set his father free. And you’re implying William is better in the first movie just because he wanted to save the girl he loved? William in the second movie now has Elizabeth as a lover. And now a new journey to rescue his father someone else he cares about. And this became a difficult situation when bootstrap told Elizabeth at world‘s end. William has to make a decision. Either don’t kill Davy Jones so he can be with you. Or he does kill Davy Jones and set me free, but he won’t be able to be on land for 10 years. If I were him I wouldn’t pick me! 😕 The emotional weight on William’s character gets better and better. Elizabeth in the first movie was just a damsel in distress girl. She wasn’t useless in the first movie but you get the point. In the second movie, Elizabeth learned to wield a sword and she used it in the battle. She pulled a gun to Beckett‘s head.. went on her own journey to save will. She has grown a lot since the first movie who was just an innocent girl! Elizabeth got better as a character in 2 and 3! As for Jack sparrow. He does not become a joke at all in all 3 movies. Jack sparrow is at his best in the second movie and in the third movie. There was a moment in dead men’s chest… Where Jack didn’t know what he truly wanted so the compass couldn’t locate what he desired. So when Elizabeth went on her journey and then found Jack.. Jack used her for his advantage! He took advantage of Elizabeth’s feelings by telling her if you want to save Will you have to want to find the chest of Davy Jones! In order to get will back.. That’s why Jack gave her the compass. Jack knew if he couldn’t figure what he wanted out he was going to get it out of Elizabeth. Since Elizabeth now wants to find the chest of Davy Jones to save will. This gives Jack the huge opportunity to find the chest to stab the heart in it. But instead he wants to control DavyJones before killing him. Jack sparrow is not stupid! When will was trying to stab the heart towards the end of the second movie. Jack knows just because Davy Jones is dead, does not mean the Kraken will be stopped as well. And you’re telling me Jack is dumb after part 1?? As for Beckett. He was a well executed villain who uses dialogue and negotiation to control people. The Reason why Beckett didn’t fire his cannons at worlds end. Was because it would be totally out of his character to use weapons. Beckett uses certain words to get through people and how to control them behind the scenes. Beckett at the end of the movie had nothing left to negotiate with. Davy Jones was dead, Jack sparrow is alive and well. Will Turner is now the new captain of the Flying Dutchman. Beckett had literally nothing to use against on people. He was caught in shocked and he decided to die.. Anyways I could defend the Gore Verbinski’s Trilogy all night. His trilogy is an underrated trilogy. It had great character writing and amazing detail of its depth. Also Will vs Davy Jones!!! 😈😈😈 when Will challenging Davy Jones. Davy Jones asks him how do you know about the key? Will replies and says, that's NOT part of the game is it? 😏 You can STILL walk away!! 😏 As for pirates 4/5 they are not even Canon they are filler movies. The story ended at worlds end! ☠️ (Part 2) Dead man’s chest has a very simple plot.. Jack sparrow is the master at controlling peoples hearts to get what he wants and out of a situation. He screwed over Will so Jack can save himself… But it worked in his favor for his reunion to meet his father.. William even told Jack you screwed me over but because of you I was reunited with my father after such a long time.. Elizabeth was caught in Jack’s illusion of trusting him to get Will back that had nothing to do with him which was a lie. Will being on Davy Jones ship had everything to do with Jack lol. Jack left on good terms with Elizabeth and William in the first movie. Elizabeth had every right to believe Jack…. It was Jack who took advantage of her feelings to find the chest by telling her if you want to find will you need to find the chest of Davy Jones! But it was an illusion so Jack can get closer to find the chest of Davy Jones to control him. But to also go back and save will after Jack got what he wanted. If people don’t understand these movies that’s their problem. But I understand every movie! That’s why I rank 2>3>1 ☠️☠️☠️ (Part 3) I’m sorry to break it to you but the curse of the Black Pearl is my least favorite in the trilogy. I rewatch the trilogy every few months. And to me I just don’t find it as deep or as interesting compared to dead man’s chest or at worlds end. Curse of the Black Pearl is still a well written amazing film. It’s just I’d rather choose having William struggle on trying to save his father from Davy Jones along side using very clever strategy and dialogue during the dice liar game on Davy Jones to get key from him.. VS William in the first movie who just wants to save Elizabeth…. I love darker storytelling and when steaks are becoming higher! Dead man’s chest gave me everything.. Elizabeth was a useful damsel in stress female lead in the first movie. But I would rather choose her character development in the second movie compared to her in the first movie. Elizabeth pulled a gun on Beckett’s face. She went on her own journey to save William. Who also taught her how to defend herself with swords. And that paid off well at the end of the movie! Her development is miles better in (Dead mens chest) compared to herself in the first movie who just takes the fall for William to protect him from Barbosa. Jack sparrow’s dialog and clever intelligence grew (MORE) in (dead men’s chest) and (at worlds end) and you cannot convince me otherwise. If people think he became a joke after the first movie that sounds like a (YOU PROBLEM) Jack sparrow is pretty intelligent in the second movie on being a master at manipulation and taking advantage of people around him to get himself out of a situation in order to save his life and possibly everyone else’s. He just knows how to play the game like that….. You can’t trust Jack sparrow on making the right decisions because he’s supposed to be ahead of the game on everyone’s perspective on him. If Jack was easy to follow with answers he wouldn’t be Jack sparrow lol. Not to mention what’s with this opinion on people saying Jack sparrow was someone you should not mess with?? Jack sparrow literally wants you to mess with him so he can use that to his advantage to pull you in under his string, for you to doubt him in order to rise up above everyone else. You were caught in his illusion the entire time so he can be superior at the end of the situation and screw you over. If Jack sparrow was someone to NOT mess with, just like Davy Jones.. Then you wouldn’t be caught in Jack sparrow’s illusion on being the worst pirate in the world.. No seriously if Jack had the same fear approach as Davy Jones…. Then all you would have to do were to look at Jack sparrow for a few seconds and be so scared of him, Everyone would just run away.. literally what’s the fun in that for Jack Sparrow?! If he was someone to not mess like people claim. Then (WHY) do people keep on assisting 100% on messing with Jack Sparrow?? Please answer that man lol. That literally makes no sense… 😂

In old germanic folklore a kiss from a mermaid heals any injury and you'll be able to breath underwater So Philip (missionary) got to live with syrena

Bro rob’s barbossa impression is actually insane

I believe people think that Jack is more goofy in this movie, because there is not always a straight man to balance it out.

God knowing the actor that played Blackbeard was also the hotel manager in John Wick makes this so much better. It would've been cool if his first mate was Lance Reddick

Wow Robby and Scott from Nerdsync doing a movie commentary together this is amazing Nah in all seriousness looking good JAAAACK

I've been waiting for you to do this movie. One of my favorites

yesss been waiting for this video for months

I like that this movie came out early enough to still have that same “actually shot outdoors” visual style that Curse of the Black Pearl had, unlike POTC5

jaaack... JAAACK... Glad we're back on the pirates train. I do like this movie but there's a lot of missed potential there, which is something youcan't say about the other three. It just feels like there's something missing from it. Idk. Far sight better than the fifth one at least.

i think peoples judge this movie too much because they don't understand some simple things like the post credit scene where Angelina gets the voodoo doll i think its the best explanation for why he's so unlucky in the next movie also peoples think the priest drowned after going in the depths with serena but actually its told that a true love mermaid kiss gives you water breathing power i know sounds weird

17:52 can you run that by me again.😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣 I can’t stop laughing

This is the most expensive movie ever made, clocking over 400M dollars. Let that sink in. heheh, sink I have no friends

Man im still getting so use to seeing you guys react and not just hearing you lol but i love these memes we are creating xD CLEOOOOOOOO

I’m with Robby on the hype for Blackbeard and the Spanish lol If you look at this as an epilogue for the trilogy it’s great, it provides satisfying endings for Jack and Barbossa, and it gives us nostalgia for the old movies while actually giving us new content that doesn’t insult the old. Then the fifth movie happened. And it can burn. 😂 Literally the only good thing I can say about it is that David Wenham (Faramir from LOTR) was in it.

I remembered not liking this movie after having seen it once years ago, but watching this video honestly made me like it a lot more!

This film is such a fun film 🙌 I love it 🥰 I still remember the quote “pirate’s life for me, savvy?” Oh yeah!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Let’s be pirate!!!!!!!!!!!!!

25:00 This is the guy who says “that’s got to be the best pirate I’ve ever seen” in the first movie!

You look amazing! You guys are funny af!

I was waiting for this one

THEYRE BACKKKKKKKKKK

Y’all should react to the Night at The Museum trilogy

Since youre a Blackbeard fan, there's a pretty good show that came out this year called "Our Flag Means Death" and it's very losely based on the history of Stede Bonnet and Blackbeard. It's very funny and amazing, can recommend.

The English King is the father of the King from Hamilton.

Can u do h2o season 3 when is that coming

The boys are BAAAAAAAAAACK!!!

I feel like the problem with this movie is it feels too empty. The world seems much smaller, and the cast is just... Jack, Barbossa, Gibbs, Angelique and Blackbeard. You never think how much Norrington, Elizabeth, Will, Elizabeth's dad, and Jack's crew did for the movies. On Stranger Tides seems like a barren wasteland. Also like, At World's End talked so much about how the golden age of piracy is coming to an end, and the world has become conquered and lost it's luster, and then the oppressive East India trading company was obliterated... it just feels like we're stuck in a world where everything interesting had already happened, and this is the quiet, boring world after the war.

Honestly, I feel like the biggest problem is this really doesn't feel like stranger tides. It seems like regular Pirates sea. When I hear "On Stranger Tides" I imagine the opening of At World's End, like literally entering another world.

Love the beard man

Omg after seeing your reactions to the transitions in this film I’d LOVE to see your reaction to “The Adventures Of Tintin: Secrets Of The Unicorn”, it’s made by Steven Spielberg and Peter Jackson so even if it were terrible it would still be amazing 🤣🤣 Pleeeeease react to it It’s such a good movie 🤣🤣🤣

OMG I love the bald shaved head really fits you well!

Maybe their lost "Bootyed Treasures" to begin with that time forgot!

The actor for Blackbeard is my friends grandad. He’s a nice guy

I watched the first three pirates movies for the first time at the beginning of summer and heard the last two weren’t good and didn’t plan on watching them. But one day I was craving more jack sparrow adventures so much that I watched this and was pleasantly surprised. More jack sparrow adventures is exactly what I got

My good friend are back at it again

YES! Another Pirates with these Gems!!! 😍 I would rather watch these commentaries than the actual films at this point. The Barbossa impression is too on point! Can’t wait for the next boys! Also… if Scrum died… “WHY IS THE SCRUM GONE !?” 😂😂😂

this is actually my favorite one of the franchise so im really happy this video exists

Shaggy? 😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣 I'm dying!

I may not like this movie, nor the 5th one, but I'm happy to see another Pirates video from y'all. Good to see you BAAAACK!

Ahh, this one is my favorite.

Man this was a great movie in my opinion it just sad they didn’t make another one after this. (To be fair I loved the costuming and colors of the last movie)

28:00 true to form, "I'm no simp, mate" - Jack Sparrow

Honestly new look looks great.

The Spanish themes are godly.

This one is honestly my favorite pirates film

ITS FINALLY HERREE

This one was also the first one I watched of the trilogy. It introduced me to all of the characters and I had a really great time. Not a bad film at all. Not as good as the first three but not bad.

Bald with beard I love it ^^ also my fav Pirates movie is the second XD ive see it all tho!

24:59 Here we see the British doing what the British do best

I've always liked this movie myself as it still had the feeling of the other movies. The only pirates movie I genuinely Dislike is the 5th one.

The bald look is a way better look, definitely own it mate!

i thought they would never do it but they did. didnt watch it yet lets go

“I saw it in theaters with my best friend at the time.” Wait does that mean that Robby isn’t your best friend now?

he's bald now? HES BALD NOW

6:16 It's a pastry, not a doughnut.

Did you watch Prince of Egypt? Thats a very good one!

This is honestly my favorite movie next to Black Pearl. Also that mermaid though 😍

You guys have to review the whole of Harry Potter